Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
Micro-electro-discharge machining (micro-EDM or -EDM) has been gaining popularity as a new alternative method to fabricate
micro-structures. The main advantages of the micro-EDM method are its low set-up cost, high accuracy and large design freedom.
Compared to etching or deposition techniques, micro-EDM has the advantage of being able to fabricate complex three-dimensional
shapes with high-aspect ratio. However, there are many operating parameters that affect the micro-EDM process. The fabrication of
micro-electrodes on the machine is also an important process to remove the clamping error to maintain high accuracy in the machined
micro-structures.
In this paper, the machining of micro-structures is divided into two basic processes. One is the on-machine fabrication of the micro-
electrodes with high-aspect ratio, and the other is the EDM of the workpiece in micrometer range. An optical sensor has been developed
to measure and control the dimension of the thin electrode during the tool fabrication process. Different methods have been investigated
to fabricate a thin electrode into the desired dimension without deflection. The performance of the micro-EDM process is evaluated in
terms of the material removal rate (MRR), tool wear ratio (TWR), and the stability of the machining. Influences of the various operating
parameters of the micro-EDM process, such as the operating voltage, gap control algorithm, and resistance and capacitance values in the
RC spark control circuit, are discussed.
2003 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
0924-0136/$ see front matter 2003 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/S0924-0136(03)00760-X
H.S. Lim et al. / Journal of Materials Processing Technology 140 (2003) 318325 319
etching techniques are also comparatively more expensive This paper presents an attempt to fabricate high-aspect
than micro-machining using machine tools. ratio micro-structures on an aluminum workpiece. The ma-
Many studies have been conducted for micro-EDM pro- chining of micro-structures is divided into two basic pro-
cesses. One of the first experiments reported on micro-EDM cesses. One is the on-machine fabrication of micro-electrode
was performed by Van Ossenbruggen [5] in the Philips tools with high-aspect ratio, and the other is the EDM of
Research Laboratory at the end of 1960s. With a preci- the workpiece in the micrometer range. Different methods
sion EDM machine he was able to fabricate parts with have been investigated to fabricate a thin electrode into the
dimensional tolerances of 0.5 m and with a high-speed desired dimension without deflection. The performance of
EDM method. He was also able to obtain dimensional toler- the micro-EDM process is evaluated in terms of the mate-
ances up to 1.5 m with a machining rate of 5 mm3 min1 . rial removal rate (MRR), tool wear ratio (TWR), and the
The smallest electrode fabricated had a diameter of 30 m. stability of the machining. Influences of the various operat-
Another researcher, Sato et al. [6] was then the first to ing parameters of the micro-EDM process, such as the op-
report on EDM-drilled micro-holes for ink-jet nozzles of erating voltage, gap control algorithm, and resistance and
printers. The micro-holes have a diameter of 15300 m, capacitance values in the RC spark control circuit, are
a roundness of 0.5 m or better, and a surface roughness discussed.
of 0.1 m Rmax . Soon after, Masuzawa et al. [7] presented
a system for drilling deep micro-holes by EDM. The elec-
trodes used had a diameter of less than 50 m and have as- 2. High-aspect ratio micro-EDM
pect ratio of 10:1. From this basic technique, he then derived
a three-dimensional micro-machining technology demon- Micro-EDM is a non-traditional machining technology
strated by the machining of a rotor for a micro-turbine. The that has been found to be one of the most efficient tech-
smallest electrodes have a diameter of 4.3 m for a length nologies for fabricating micro-components. The non-contact
of 50 m. By combining EDM with electro-forming, he was process requires little force between electrode and work-
able to set-up a process for micro-nozzle fabrication [8]. piece and is capable of machining ductile, brittle or super
Micro-EDM can also be used to machine less conventional hardened-materials. With appropriate parameters, it is pos-
materials. It was reported that Toshiba manufactured the sible for micro-EDM to achieve high precision and high
magnet of an ultra-small electromagnetic motor with an out- quality machining.
side diameter of 3 mm using EDM. In USA, Jacobson used The non-contact nature of EDM makes it possible to use a
micro-EDM to produce a micro-wobble motor [9]. very long and thin electrode for the machining. Even though
Even though many research results show successful fab- a micro-milling cutter of down to 50 m in diameter is avail-
rication examples at micrometer size, the thickness of the able in the market, the length of the tool is usually 35
machined shape is almost similar to their size. It means that times of its diameter and it is also not suitable to machine a
the aspect ratio of a micro-component in current state is usu- very tough die material, which only can be machined using
ally close to 1. However, there can be requirements to fabri- EDM. Although micro-EDM plays an important role in the
cate higher aspect ratio micro-structures using micro-EDM. field of micro-machining, it has disadvantages such as high
To increase the aspect ratio of micro-fabrication, longer and electrode wear ratio and low MRR. The wear of electrode
thinner toolelectrode is required, and high tool wear rate is must be compensated either by changing the electrode or by
to be endured. Careful tool preparation and optimal machin- preparing longer electrode from the beginning or fabricating
ing conditions are needed for a high-aspect ratio machining the electrode in situ for further machining. It is not recom-
of micro-structure. mended to change the micro-electrode during machining,
because it may reduce the accuracy due to the change in electrical machining, such as EDM and ECM, can be per-
set-up or re-clamping of the micro-electrode. formed on the machine. The motion controller can execute
Fig. 1 shows a conceptual process to fabricate a a program downloaded from the host computer indepen-
high-aspect ratio micro-structures using micro-EDM. In the dently; thus a good EDM gap control can be achieved in a
micro-EDM process, the toolelectrode is fabricated on the real time.
machine to avoid clamping error. From an electrode thicker The response of each axis is important because a fast
than the required diameter, a cylindrical electrode is fab- movement is required for the gap control during EDM. Fig. 3
ricated by EDM process using a sacrificial electrode. Dif- shows the frequency response of the Z-axis with the refer-
ferent set-up of the sacrificial electrode can be used in this ence amplitude of 0.1024 mm. The Z-axis shows a linear
process (Fig. 1(a)). When there is a dimensional change in response up to 10 Hz and a resonant frequency at 100 Hz
the sacrificial electrode, the diameter of the toolelectrode at the amplitude of 0.1024 mm, which is sufficient distance
fabricated is usually unpredictable. An on-machine mea- to control the spark gap in the micro-EDM process. From
surement of the toolelectrode diameter is required in this the characteristic of the Z-axis response, the 0.01 s aver-
case (Fig. 1(b)). An optical measurement device has been age gap voltage is used as a feedback signal to control the
specially developed for the measurement of a thin elec- micro-EDM spark gap.
trode, which consists of a laser diode, optical filter and
photo detectors. After measuring the diameter, a compen- 3.2. Experimental method
sated machining schedule for the toolelectrode fabrication
is generated and machining is carried out. These processes The machining process study is divided into two stages.
are repeated until the required toolelectrode diameter is The first concerns the on-machine toolelectrode fabrication
achieved. After finishing the toolelectrode fabrication, process, and the second is on the parameters that affect the
micro-EDM is performed to fabricate the high-aspect ratio EDM and to fabricate a micro-slot on an aluminum block.
micro-structure (Fig. 1(c)). In the study of the toolelectrode fabrication process,
three different sacrificial electrodes are tested to compare
their capability and performance. Fig. 4 shows the three
3. Experimental set-up and method different types of sacrificial electrodes. Fig. 4(a) shows a
stationary block, which is the simplest method to machine
3.1. Construction of a multi-purpose miniature
machine tool
where FZ is the Z-axis feed rate, Vgap the gap voltage be- f = k sgn[Vgap Vth ] (2)
tween the electrode and workpiece and Vth the threshold
value for the gap control. k is a control parameter that
determines the speed of the micro-EDM gap control. The
Fig. 5. Surface engraving EDM. Fig. 6. Fabrication of a triangular micro-slot using linear scanning EDM.
322 H.S. Lim et al. / Journal of Materials Processing Technology 140 (2003) 318325
Table 2
Properties of the material
Workpiece Tool
0.3
Tool Wear,
Using a thin electrode first fabricated on-the machine, 10nF
mm 0.1 4.7nF
micro-EDM experiments were conducted and the character- 1nF
istics of the micro-scanning EDM are investigated. In this -0.1 470pF Capacitance
100pF
4.7k
1k
Fig. 8. Influence of feed rate on micro-EDM. Fig. 10. Influence of EDM gap control.
324 H.S. Lim et al. / Journal of Materials Processing Technology 140 (2003) 318325
machined cavity and it will prevent further electro-discharge. fully. The machining depth is found to be inversely
In the conventional EDM, the toolelectrode can break proportional to the feed rate.
the insulating layer. However, this is not possible in 3. For the stable and efficient scanning micro-EDM, a gap
micro-EDM, where the stiffness of the toolelectrode is control speed of 0.010.02 mm/s, resistance of 4701 k
very low. Together with the electric polarity, it is ob- and capacitance of 110 nF have been found to be the
served that upward machining always gives better result most suitable ranges.
than downward machining. This is due to the fact that any 4. The polarity of aluminum workpiece must be set to
impurity existing in between the tool and workpiece may cathode in order to prevent the formation of an insulat-
prevent the EDM machining. Presently, the EDM equip- ing layer. Upward machining tool path is also desired to
ment does not have mean to monitor if the machining is prevent a catastrophic tool deflection.
abnormal. Consequently, the tool movement will be con-
tinued even when it buckles. In the same situation, upward
machining experience only a slight elastic deflection of the References
tool. It may have greater chance to remove the impurity
in the following machining cycles. Fig. 12 shows some [1] H. Okuyama, H. Takada, Micromachining with SR and FEL, Nucl.
Instrum. Meth. Phys. Res. B 144 (1998) 5865.
micro-slots machined using linear scanning EDM success- [2] S. Matsui, T. Kaito, J.-I. Fujita, M. Ishida, Y. Ochiai, Three-
fully. The polarity of the workpiece is cathode, with upward dimensional nanostructure fabrication by focused-ion-beam chemical
machining. vapor deposition, J. Jpn. Soc. Prec. Eng. 67 (9) (2001) 14121415
(in Japanese).
[3] Z. Lu, T. Yoneyama, Micro-cutting in the micro-lathe turning system,
J. Mach. Tools Manuf. 39 (1999) 11711183.
5. Conclusions [4] M. Rahman, A.S. Kumar, J.R.S. Prakash, Micro-milling of pure
copper, J. Mater. Process. Technol. 116 (2001) 3943.
In this study, an attempt is made to fabricate a high-aspect [5] C. Van Ossenbruggen, Micro-spark erosion, Philips Technisch Tijd-
ratio micro-structure using micro-EDM. At first, a very schrift 20 (1969) 200213.
fine electrode is made on-machine by micro-EDM and then [6] T. Sato, T. Mizutani, K. Kawata, Electro-discharge machine for
micro-hole drilling, Natl. Techn. Rep. 31 (1985) 725733.
micro-EDM is performed to fabricate a micro-structure [7] T. Masuzawa, C.L. Kuo, M. Fujino, Drilling of deep micro-holes by
using the electrode. A series of tool fabrication and EDM, Ann. CIRP 38 (1989) 195198.
micro-EDM experiments have been carried out and the [8] T. Masuzawa, C.L. Kuo, M. Fujino, A combined electrical machining
following conclusions are made: process for micronozzle fabrication, Ann. CIRP 43 (1994) 189192.
[9] S.C. Jacobsen, R.H. Price, J.E. Wood, T.H. Rytting, M. Rahaelof,
1. Three different types of sacrificial electrodes have been The wobble motor: design, fabrication and testing of an eccentric
tested to assess their performance for toolelectrode fab- motion electrostatic microactuator, in: Proceedings of the IEEE In-
rication. The rotating electrode shows the best perfor- ternational Conference on Robotics and Automation, Scottsdale, AZ,
May 1419, 1989, pp. 15361545.
mance in the high-aspect ratio toolelectrode fabrication. [10] H.S. Lim, A. Senthil Kumar, M. Rahman, Improvement of form
2. Parameters of scanning micro-EDM have been investi- accuracy in hybrid machining of micro-structure, J. Electron. Mater.
gated and a micro-structure has been fabricated success- 31 (10) (2002) 10321038.