Philosophical Studios ‘Alterations orl for Pogo py a he Ante eon ‘Sonn Potiocs; Oop af Panphy, Univers Arie, Texan, SA rose Sere dete! he ue palo of reo ‘ee pura (ot mt scene epson pverates ag Py egunge eens The aria io tsa se a {Eaimate cy ae pesabi Sein) wa ene pcan preg ‘Sie tris ne urs re megs npmiseprswoxe epee bes ‘See eather oe ote rs 4 G72. ona Sa fencorars oie pasnsnarang COeeettnietera |AUSTIAL ASIAN JOURNAL OF ay ames Ton with be ssa of Mary Meloy Breas sue Sn MacCall Elaabe Crome nse an Was Na en aus, omen andthe Pry of Ley “Cana Fonnarbea iter Sipe Eat aS Eu Sic ome ene rer Sin rain kd Chie Swanton "Bate Nouret Seal Robert Parte and Elaaith W. Por ‘eRETICAL REVIEW fons An Oseniew sl Dice ‘i an pees ‘al Pama PRICE: 35, ropa Bi PACIFIC PHILOSOPHICAL Quarterly ‘my 6 ‘Aatons ad Everts ut Gre 1 Di Han and Contes oF Values ‘and of Deis it Atte Michael Sacer 36 His Me bem othePotemaf ‘ephen Cohen 62 "Ws Encl Explains Quin Sith 78PACIFIC PHILOSOPHICAL QUARTERLY uns The arn San Calf Cousomr HoMKD ene Adam, Use of aera Brey: i TDN ick ah Raber ha Unser feta a Sete et ero Atami eto tn, ‘ee Cnn armani Sg, Une oor Ae ‘EERE Cave rd Dray Ronchi Brn Oe tne Far ann Maun ore neta re am En ate eny Pipe ae Od i one of ao Fe tent ate ind aa Una ef Caran ere MET Stee anes Cf ce Cari Men Ue of {eine oma nme Rae ce, ern a, Se maa of clin se ke Le ‘teameatate oe Tin ck, Cart Gat Scot Rea Stony of Cats se ict eraee Main Ci Pao (Sites Sed Poy nner ef Somer Cairo Aree | scicammptinger Sree! eeu Ce Sencha cece hres Sergi ects tray spe re rat Pipl Qi (SS pa ey ‘tei aes hago Pc Pipa rt, Sn of Poke, ‘imei a Seen Cras SABO, USA ACTIONS AND EVENTS PAUL GRICE Teas pape. 1 dete apes el of teton tothe vis of Dost Dan top, Si nl-kaer ad tet ay "Tne Logi! Fs of Aton Sea ‘en ete n Eom Acton al ven (lc Pes, Ox {oun 08-14) Toph Lamia: Dison po 0 sot conne mya to dc a oon fk aa ly Tipe ompetealychugh witout cneatnca, «pie serve tounge ont acy upon tha one of perros dine nett pega fr gnc oa ‘in erunos aah ot on, ith eps oo arg is mot edge. ne, at fbn ae fn wn wee fica et bs fers, De BE Be Senin A Overview aly), wernovoLoGY sentences als win the bounces oa age abot aya ‘sa ie imu held iw that lees oe prof sis ‘tinapes 9 dtr at ago You pelt 1 ee ‘an anierfothe otion wht general tpt er, te foe ewer tae on nee anier brn ut frre of em have een wily gebros fie Richard Rabies "You vane “Sgn © ey ay et ne2 PACIFIC PINLOSOPHICAL QUARTERLY ‘ce amthing yu can meno wll win i hss of the rive gel otary sles, eal, the Ring of ro; mt hem lave fen sete tne te moet, In ea ties ee I ben tg ecm to ae enn less, ‘cline of ous, l sera etes ences, eins shoe 2 aoa ees Iie eens td pepetionn Soh a) People and cs hector aed qu have epee lant for many puso frac xan wal es they a pert tess of Dahon’, ows ich Cy, in ‘walter, ey symp, ht ile mor acts call ‘abl som rob ou er vem of au ot ag whi Frets pace met he er aos Given eat is Skea mapyscins, tor uration oes ie and Af foram we nn ati Cae fo menbeahip of he wens, (hewn la fetes which ml nl he death offs Coes in 44 1.C. al pec sabes fee wich al ‘read ais Caer ring ofthe Roi in BC Tele nymph (which shor fed ery bed to pos ih id) tat Davie’ bse ethic ut ie th Oui IS tt wha igh al "Dag Resa™ Chay pt ach postion wouldcont, Wie witht: cones of sme oto Sap an Heat, a aay ies frver bekind an genera ‘tn it eke oo modest a allow pone asp oy Hp Sota ote options felsic Skin, at fds econ ‘to erp! muti len fr hgh we cu inp Resi, ‘rea fern hypolssbt each of wh a ief ) Te mre rain ks, cos. Mts page wl be ale Sous the creat 9 wich rs, hy nou poe Backing o at eae tect a mts of ent te Ths epic ealok uae ha lik eee tapes testo mc My fore ean el! heen or ates of Com ‘ham, accor wich Realty wold ie nt wo eget, ‘vigil eeunconstaced seca, and acomerce ch or eh ‘of scents) in mb conaracted en me ldo xia ste ‘ska cus of te eset forthe extension ma; ‘etiam of Ulinred Cras, wich wad ue ale, bek hia catego fons as consecrate cape Ir the iocion ofan enone! seers woul be hoje) chlo byt supine platy of metankcal msemee ck ‘hates sich at primitive nome seme woul! by mn ACTIONS AND EVENTS. a soe. Rots forms wl nee Wo chris Logline cnr Frocoes Oy which weap exes ae made, OF tai St {t,t einem he Dagon Realtime, the Contract sls on pose taro ce orl isk frp ore ser ‘ingot Kea wince to id the ot teas postr a ‘ekg tbe one hich asses ht pncal aco of Realy ich mi tly ji and ports te delvernce of selec, BM wha eae? Panis? Abd what dlvrases? Phiogion tery? Ie estat ve [Rad ow arte tobe slated xcept tsa of etn of th, ttle het be pine nance fy as sa th ate FReaiy? sens ta fen ttl mod fr ome own tse ya te ge of sence ach are independent of se which ‘Shep wl be povided by acon a! gut coum of Rel ‘Nwtn cay poet age rston supposing Dai deon vote a fos a agoste Heute conven Wish Le Dab ih ses nee iy ears icin bee eri” (nscale Cerone pop coms) RO soil ely ai or, bt motto pie Foren cea ie tht Dares eaten etloia qostons gues sme ‘xn Wann ore an Dp Reon 2), PROBLEMS What considerations cane pit to which woul eosurage um pecs vere hs mets deecton Ua alain eves ator th ft of which mathe on ch enclynenoed Keon, to who Dio geste or te woioee,o ees a is tip (1) Te penomenon of orcad) “vale pay” Ife ik on ‘iat oo i a esa ve, fr exe “ob ed ‘hat ican be wed om ileen eco Kaaiono pre ‘tect varying suns of ply, Snes omaning eae Tecousctd uhich ene ve ce mr ors hte pes {bene uper nit pound by ema, act whe lait Aeponibe soon of hisphtowenon, vx haying mabe {nee promos ie cee” seta have clipe My doe ut the sac ei, st ho any re eo4 [PACIFIC MIL OSOPHICAL- QUARTERLY apo nv Bem he to rp ot This phenomenon 0 Iter of myatry i we pon tht here may beacon elts [ester toi sei. Te pesomenon of aria pla ipa tei fo ok pocsely pal ote sun ah te serene ed dsb ius: hr we may he at ‘She btwn deni Socrates man a a a, a fa ctr an, td 0. (2) Some ncn rors ugh te maze of pay one inves tetcc eee ihr ely npn of ne ‘het inte talon’ Yo he" wr seen,“ ered tho tom” which ccf by erm semen em wc (inci ter ttt imal he ee: at She forcuinie ht M.S. Reding te Bosak etal STEMS Rody sk” We nest sone thot! cata te ones when sah eens nat. an tte ‘esting ots nies a how ihn 0 je ‘ttn, yep ot tae (3) Aatons aon esti ned serve a bts freee Rene swore, ay Comic he semen The ma {eft nepal ova rigid Wt weck and Ann {Sheen meso tin err W107 vious ‘tthe Minerale bei ange anit sly ig gests Sn and made joe about at we. bower, om ea {inition ong a ty who bs elo tow il he gap it comfy, (4) Some a a epi alk swt mi 8, I the provision ‘tec, cnet roe the poy of rig tes ve “in difeen mays acne we deeable ees, ti may apes a ny han to them, oe tern of (aba stone ch wl lw whan and wen sat ey thf he ts ner nie pp i in the fou et sade o dngpse beyond he rz ove, Ital 6 8 ‘roo oh tw stil ble oo a es 1 be ord nce fh sae deseo coger vt ae ped ‘ocr fortress ny Gi ees tess, we ane ced {sd an w eons. hy oe st Be mer eal "aed cps thy con bo pt io wor nthe verve etn pat ‘our daa. The ger Ci ht te dat oft at of “home ras te ads soo be tly neta, [ae can eyo te ota me [ACTIONS AND EVENTS. 5 [B. Davidson's Criticism of Prior Theoris (1), REICHENMACH (*LOGICAL FORME AND LOGICAL EQUIALENCE”) Dai tke Recbenbach my tot fr Holling tat 138) content fact that Amante ut the Noh Ps) iene ‘Svar, bt oes wt giveth Wage fr of "Aude De ae Noth foe coring Recent eter nab se ii sc. ne coke inset of esocon semen, he sna ight Arnon the New Pele uk pe” we wou lao ‘sng sense thi dra cre, advo a senem e lgies Tonml ticcolbe given he Ht scone, tse pea) "We mew eens mol so Be lpely equal Dain proposes ‘amend Rent’ orto, otha he rtsrens tae ing the lp orm "Anes eto he Noth oe a ot ey ling nly eq ott sree cange ane ay ‘th pode ta ey or wes bos pom he iy a pat of ly hh wil stan for to ci ond i ble sud M3 Kechekuch thous thee a ta anguge pis of fgeal quale emer oof wich abo vei, st tee ft dillercnce ight jay be el hes wean fr denying at the pun adi one ase a cosine Reehetach wax 20) night sug at the earn fot ines aoc ‘ntereconarits skp ah exeaon oes piv oh) ‘wich Sos cot ten and which miter oly nseiencs wack ‘donc amen te I ae el at peo ene woah rope eee (2), REICHENBACH (IHE “HIDEOUS CONSEQUENCE”) uid’ min xian of Recheck poten om es ted ines wich we el etnies pty vad in ‘hosting nay of co lee sega tera of foally equal! senes i appropriately celled cet prime Rehetbech camo exape the ecu commence that ll ‘rent Met th one nner Dardis pune ay tvemmrvaas follows, Leta albeit Reisen oper cn han at hhh hen pein aentene pduens pee (either °C theater wi rer an [NSE ‘Septeon bane Emperor of Pane’ Ten: a) sentence (D, oC6 XCF ML OSDENTICAL QUARTERLY te utincse serene 2" 0 (G'=y 8) = =>) te, se the prs te alec wich low he oper exo min ‘tees ae lop ult (5) Sven (2) ee jt ee Senea Oh, tngiy=y & N) ~ $=)" a, se "9 =y & CT InI'gg-) 8 NY ae ogra whieh and ae ah ‘Sen itr fs) am ttre cfr mdm {© Sennee) above rie ft ee oN tu, ce "Nan Subscene follows nS exubaet So provided iba Cav hes af what ey sa ay even whieh ous fh fat it Ca coi oft hat Wa ie rs teat a, 9 prof asd cn eve ae et Tah et hn gh eli at te pps cen. iran of olen ga nol eee Iscnne a fly domed bcm hy re mle terse ‘Sta pc sal inte iin aon open is bc, ‘Revol coune enero als yo etait eet he liming ds ccnp, nh 0 Ks eee ana {Dost insti, ox encoun # comer xo a he ed 0 ‘Scape races wl peri So ay ssw be tle we gh, tee ceomic, wh reining he ae paps, pa ie se of the ‘cower yung hpel sgn price’ hs Fevr vn. Sa mee wcll nee ave som nko ee ‘the ced spent ial depen of the heal eens inp seme oe le he pst of ence wh owls operon for tubleragapteaion of he the pile Ii aa aw he ane wy stop? 9) YON WRIGHT VOCATION OF INITIAL AND TERMINAL, srares) tis Dsus view tht vm Wright wither io hurt ems as eng ss dro ps nal state a tei Stead Coda seus asta ting at of erene One of Deas Shin of prom ying San rae 1 Ne Son andy tying San rancho New York weak at Be te sed fom ester by he pas ats ited (wish woul be fhe saa andi ioe toe me of tael De og eG ‘isin ete elingw New York ying Now Yo eeenes ‘ena ohn roe os scm ome thet tires does co ese to von Wi wh lsplanty woking one tn ls tt a) he ois ge fed het hs a of ran ta charge an De eee 8 (Mevesiouof sien fnsy vow he al a greater een [ACTIONS AND EVENTS 7 scion be ere Ll, homever pseu me deed oni C. Purher Comideation of Davidon’s Problem List cv). vane Potaaorerry ss calng fv pica saly of acom snes The surviving tte of ths Int arte plemns of arate plod, he no era usr yet sect crn range etl lt ing ais. a the dean fore von ej freee Co ‘Senn cearonces of rons. So fa, Lave spl Ue S10 ‘Sreieatanr eileen of ich eh pating to a dict [ihcret penton of Duin, Tele eomileble prt 8 ‘ulnar lngige fr the se ta wat and thr eaten pete ‘spree ary camel win hanaer open] sapeseaboe seen degre potatoe") ewe” ft cane, Sst eqpese ern ion (ing etc) a3), whe ‘aon sniod hy “above” ka cw two-rtn eon n pei ‘ato ofthe mbt ferme sicarelatonal expesion ole ces (ote cena than eit th ef ie elton Cera Many lcm aten ta vem at yo msm et thie ‘iow cect ett is anguocly sapere earns Tee a wn Jo retin Viens, me ay get te ane “Bl, soc ent codon diy i being vated Moweoer ‘ihc conarasione lgcl anes coord, hes bo ain ‘Sacto or icy se ant rue or edie lope ‘Soyetops wit bent moc eal fr jot te sl ‘ont tit problems, ut he powson ofan acne of on ‘eae ich omy ace fort frets a faite fpljisiy and that of he stannic, Tout lene ot nce he question my ssl me oppo, oF ss, ha teu te demas shal bo tt single tne a ‘ould be wrong stn gg segura mses oe? Let won ae ‘Sey a theo an: etn wih varie poyadey. Tota eto a of vale pote woul ecap he ppropie it me ners coming the mame in whi sons crt es a ptson) hed, ate escios ayig degre f pois OP ps, eid on Ue oan varying eae lo ie ents Gometines es mito, atin at lai). BY pony of eascng ext are play ener weld have oe (=)8 CHIC PMLOSOMUCAL QuakrERLY on oceion date, octinn Hi, ex tea: an hs Tega coh resomably be ned a fon Btw en tw ings Wyn, vd to es nowingse tom, e's elen(a cist wich mightiest: irctungmipthessags ts elon oon heh ty, {Sincere rms pono, pedig et Ww ay ee net fewer Tha way of hing, wal bere sere eons ‘Sout wy te oa tm be hon ain sho! Be oto Sigh qs: tenes ch os gy en Devon et item der oe, warn ce knit gt woo {tn lysing une, ean et pes ikem Pity deci festa thsi, weve lance he (aeat Cacens thetic ey ahd ie we Stet meee sees et ands nett" estes ‘natin he psec “gush teas ost, ne gate worms may cr tee [i Ye (pete eter) wih te the sks vt wich eo icra an wit ay these ey (2) Precepts) ra fem th hy the *— bel teed" ee must he mgm way 6 hs nat rt ane a ‘cy of the pte, he mer fe cents my Ce Canal eences yor ay ee psi y aes Bv Thine th pedi H step be te buses of «erat thy ofefogung io make yan or he cence ech of the pes of tem ‘Whan ices to ateyting a) th dandy fr 2 syste scan of iby of sh none hat fe "Sh bate he ‘Sst ine Behm’ to Soh Bare he tea tems ce ‘Shenker te atte soe ond) hse which ae {ete fora cma ern «ingest my pen to Daron rte) tet ese su uote ema inbthemes, ie tae a wre tg se romincve ao dt develo Weve al st one Tretia ot teat acon an bjt ff pees oc he ‘Samet he tsa oped the aly of sch nee mh ACTIONS AND EVENTS, 9 uo pall Gn oben spi ast nea Fa that pope esting (62), PRONOMIVAL REFERENCES My dais at decease y erin to the id consterton, whch rele the pono of an objeto teem the roa ‘secs snc at "Te mange othe Mame eae eed ‘whatwas he het of An Landes ak Nether the Meas Moon "ater manaper sald pipeny he reel 0 hy he ea oun, a dict fr a mses pomoun “he oe 3 la ey the ‘ference is ply he tages sigmation Now his vet acon ‘te dente tat a anor eyins preset th tng ‘ich he ager eee is esipntion cul eta That Tis, wht ie ecto have ten ping fr "Row ih) ftv govt" But my sence esto he an aon eebes a Seite previo rfc wich sing php. The on ‘igi, Ponever be regal exe (ae fate tnempeat of resigtion were mete filam of wy erewplay ‘ojns. al) sue forthe spp ht covert een ome Gt design of tht wt hod be poset nthe ung, Tange tha esl comer no question when refernes seca “ol” a onto () the mode rece in sah as, Toray or icy comm sed hy the oli sanded gos ‘macs? (2) the teres wl not focal oe suey contr Ten infra? wool nt are re dsr tho eh mae of stranding acti eee lea he net (Gtbee guest nigh wel beh fors patel it come mph eleece to he mae hoe ep ee oer ve (mare sl be haute, Hovev if es demand at fo impel {gama bu fr igi, hens covert eereve st eed or dscouse ot messy on se een For cue {0 *Tspeat ost ser in Per thy ee very sale with the resent ime hey a oF cou he Ps) 2) ear em whizig Oy aad serpy Fes ut he slop [The er ofc) (6) “Tones ews o he morality of sou Aka many popes0 NCIC PHILOSOPHICAL QUAREALY Min: 95 be Onn Ue Pes whic i then ub Is (= Jones satin of his vw.) “Tie leg os cancers commen Aes” = We dicase concer) ‘night, a5 pce, roma tat the accent to wens of sch toms te above, dyed hei exsonce o aly a sme Utada sy 0 shy erase incre fn The Otley D. Outline of Davidson's Proposal ie tam nw to Bsns oun wll Atown prophage Ace questo uh she ut on dieing poste sae ‘pty hi yo ey nota ot oe eating Wee the Intiacony inte sin tepesettin ofthe rcs ‘Eros fh whic may Be oxape hy rales rai ver “son and wish mig tly bebo by quien The seem Shum ike Shain hah of nots combi of 0 ae ‘sndatworpls rite, bt aroha hs pee Kik Sd eighth om 3) (Kicked (Se, Sha 2) ate ‘oe within wich, sx Doe ois t,t eens 'Shem hick Shou mtneappers. Aes rang ie Els of Datars act Seat fered ate tly Tete xan event x ac ht 2 ating ot Sta by Shen , Prestheorticel Demavcation of Actions and Events Bele coming sr examin of Dvn ropa eu st ‘orga enn fhe mat feng eel wc oe opiate, Mate ettevew acto, cin a mre epaes on 1 Tettrtenst, at ot ell st ha soul hk to kao $e wow! "ase der net Tn, ae Geos appear it ‘etc shane Tat ot whe iT ea tl ha a0 th tation be reed ene et Had ‘Con would eave fr thin sation nth cura hese Snot but ach aecartensso he word a hee dont lp ve sch ‘unc api te werd conte us The wed oto Iss pasta ed esl ave, and he elt hr ebay sts in rhe sn, vow of iconsecan Wis a ind I pretending, The hone homely wed "pls ch ager ‘don ofc soe A tbl er A oo PPS [ACTIONS AND EVENS n nos ccumstanc wil qui as something whieh some peso ot “hg oe wy 9 ater, dso at done. Ue gueion, “Wha dd the psoas do hen” ay be que Monat) anewee na of fattonng ways Hl Wt me ofthe nse”. He aed "He bast eit nghig® “ie ja sat hee’ “Nong tae tt hen’ He et hisses mens The moun “ose ote ote a sb marion exccedingy basal, tending taney coon ‘ch dts of drag he cng of cove mens by gallant nigh The pea poms Rb ft er Li ha lt a gamba expan Weal nr wie ange of Inrrgues in Engl ne atone nt, wih expt [Bren Cucpiry, wich tem win he caopry Cond Vode ier ke covesion of an open seaice oe econ a uh ‘Avett tne, ste? a at ace, swhy™ a nha reno each expen o ch errgaies; an ote ngs ‘sch Grek sd Lat sr ees hater supe than Fah Al oF ‘nt of se snrrogatiepeonouns hae tne coup ite ‘ponding “uber” somewhere tha “sont oe, ‘om dre might ne Ben (sgh i et the fmt al of expe esrb rns tera inet) whch {hie be caring, called “poser ewe wel ve 1 as ‘qui out ini reece oe etgey fen rch pee ts (or epics) see to sts, law vay exactly prt tte fans ng pena. “Sacate ad n 991. igh Be sore bY “Drak he ak js a “Whe id Sorte ik he Iola” anes by "la Ae: and given tht Sorat id dine thet in 39 B.C we mut hve tee es Thee Re yt We er coe ln (ob ng ter "amd soe oe ‘mpl “Wt di Socrates dn 399 B.C" ln capac pat of (vat nic whan a which ct, s ly sping ta il Sotto sity a arowe-down fang: etn, oro “ain ver. Puscaed ints diecoos, we igh Oko wang aloes tron i ie fom he ces cor, sommes ie one ‘econ wit atte Wil ton which echo speak in Pca ‘ho ocanrely ved ha one itngisheby api comet ‘ake el tw ie at tng be eed wis ling ‘gestion th actos singed by semen with he wl ay Ge cxpeed to lal at once to th es tha ater eto te dati. uh by el coeon with acs of i and the ean at ee Se ich things aa ofl se merely eB ple Am2 PIC PILOSORUCAL QUARTERLY scot ogy me ata with seme en pong nd erage ‘ni Davis ms), woul be oak particu Vrs Yer oes wh ae we wo py ar Ssrbe Wi pbsopes s at ‘et and iene range of priclar words a phrases, sach kth tok the mead“ tat The eee ihe ow’ encour Ut wile some vets or verb pay, “np fe ed at fue nd weet wh iene wall an —anenoraene amber of veth pes esupy am mdse poston hey can, ‘ten, be wa eer my an theless pte Toler [inten cramp,“ snd one Roman ser lon 0d rs fr hi pan cal Tce the rie ic, 4 it nd, ston i egy fore eats say pepe ante gan ler et i eon tee ell is wong on ‘recone, tpn ha ned ov nd bs unable ad ttn rato serene hs ben ponder pcs then wel tose ht or ie peel ny sue 3 caratrton ‘amp if wo domo tom wha tons (or hit ae aos) uw eee se a he creo uy peopel) eed a an impity show aco actrees? Might sot te, for ame rely an ngiy abt eens emt lie pst) I pid fateaw of ere I would apd wie omar ht ae ps fi inte it ec edn eho ‘lium, ey este Coto gh fa waft Ger ne actos wien s pps Meuen of Wa ee 2), evens Tell 0 hse ton shot sins her ae queso wi ie about eve Dadsn oeng ws a aca of eve prea. of fy rods woul my mind De ara one we eb a aes in ings’ fer an intvescgntin cea a eve ‘ksh by Meningie and ieences Revers vercar ‘Spree taal dno reat temo esr coy ed ACTIONS AND EVENIS B ion, a ofthese mold be gee a geal chaceizaton, Ichi emit ask to refs he versa, a clas of ve (Evens wih whi meet be conecrod bing Understood tat {hy th ote Gatcaon night wl ne te eps for p= ‘Seal paps, yan accom wich wold Be heretical he ‘Shing ond Homing, Deion, however eee be laure ‘thao ts proces, On pages 119~T2DBe el, fo tat “art troy plore ibs nd wa soso en he vv ht Bold her ncsrmngs over Some pedis ve anew lac, re ma Seco “ou nar ak eve cates an ee, es Soni we ofthe eo Uiletet degre sabe ev wih {eae bation ha hangs of obec xe fin ange ome wih pest o wich ira poblens schol polcnty poles Mckee al ‘ewe ur ae nd yal pu yoo ior pects a he ein sect {0} Ow isthe combiaton of he en th lity to nt mabe If pce ich pests fr alan ogni oe peemse tons on evel, grt of wha eve in ering the tacig of he prea als pes) a pt of what ved it ung ts lng nwt te ote long, wih be Fre ‘des shat ele ores) mye expec obese, ned sips ta pops tpi of na ‘Sh plier events Arse to eke ho oe Moe's iw 80 ‘SSuontcooe son, erent emp ined at ‘Sow oe cernn tote cn fin sich» prover spain {ie tne dc Da to rubies ich sn oplctin of Bec’ ale capbl of ing, Croc wife’ epson vr te nogsston de aby Wo re ‘poe vet pase (an 0 een) pro ing ew he langage. igicues With Davidson’ Proposat 11), INTELLIGIILETY OF tHE ‘ExTRA SLOT Lan weno aes he queso wheter Dl’ pop, with pad 1 te lg fc of actor, mat ot be esprielysimle ‘The propos nt contary (perhaps t0 ot taal ns det tutions we sad gard Richa or xanple) nts worse ed {eke wine th vacancies ae il by enon of Ue cea the ‘edt tee pace iat with esa Yas for fence (Gite cantor shown wish a Klag oose Td s puaig1“ PACIFIC LOSORNAAL QUARTERLY ‘stand, ao um ints igure how te ena ple Hs i a Sesto ein or fay comparable aoa eae). The ‘ss, ot 30 lng 0, Oxf, a pees of he hisoy a pan ‘Sh Go he ai) espns wat wit ecb form of Neo Hele she mine ht ck senna an "There ale ne re ‘tthe ream or Snow white wie nsomptl oamlt be popes ‘ins onthe sate de. Suppose dane Lt 1930s, ha Bsee {erg in cob German erate seeneswith he aie same fiona prise to sai er i ae Fler yf We names is ene ction este of ce ‘ting he woe He 99 Ue eral war Ae with Gea ies ery vale, Ging!" “She wat as gentle a yume ei Tinks. Oe an eve nage te pave ete to oie fee apeaan gente (3s) (Wess depose a ap an "acs eng wih hs ics sen prima be thst sont stalls ben provide te pepe wih th ely ade es eve they ae jot aad for ipl wil alton of ha oa "oyai col cme em te plement Oa thence Dies [reer sete si cen: eds a wl he toe tiie placer, he remy ier os a Eng “pap Bat loa cuoe ds mn il he gap se le ht Dio ed the appearance f sich cx sheng the mae he “tale pay of ach pts ae Kske ans pooenon nese mtr removed eel as eves een ow i decomposes toa cls of elie peas bch cover in femal ps th infrences fr mich ceton eed. sd Fase ate! pair to Dvorak abo Yrs ad preps sors.) One we distinguish etnesn peice vets und eins, wean ‘yuh fol of te ental ar pei ye le te pre ‘openseences) to which be pet ae-ebeats ele fr rape ofthe so i ty" is spd by he the thet alee ‘rate "sk bith ston (een 3 and we eat rep he ch. ‘Settin ofthis le as pred Uy ena) decompo oes Press Hk kd © he ct he tema a {ction mo sucha conuncve peda ofaconsor eves) 6 ied Dns, amd mar done pon cyan x as dae a Tha pons nde rh pcan tea i a iat [Tecra pists P applet ar so der aredtePwih rel oP he ois oe caja ACTIONS AND EVENTS 1s FQ), SIING/DESCRIBING WHAT HAPPENS My linguist ition lise any to om tht a3, Lan sa) fel ou my age eli ou a a aig a ep Se tha srry 1 ay aw ae cole on ee Ti Sty saying Ceing yo) wht Rape, dering taling boo 0 ag someting bow what happened ying ‘rt tamed sam ote mee 0 Be dat ro ig at Src happend, ta te be, ta ese prepped By Hs 7g bat pened sco, te, obey cena sometime ‘us wodoinndria nora teat on ling on ath {als our bathe. was pra, eit ete wich {el Keichenfoc todsinssh Dette gill equiva! seers ost wtih dic, he te of wc des mt flr oe lk to ‘tet Davie ana hin, ae place for he aon ck Tam defending ow his i anything oo ys bt hat pene ik sfc) a case of in something bape which AE have Sony nse, as wold te comarca exes x ilo {ole wih Recta 703) THE PROBLEM OF GENERALIZED FORMULATION Ax pcininry me se ht nha rms seqpet secs fall eat Daido propo conning the ogi fom ‘etn ster sapling ental eeu sete which (cn arkkon sow an ction sro dete slopes frm which he at tutes tot fom sta acne Kindo event sence: nh fees as ptt ep 10 . ‘inktion eco propos in ale mae nd with id of se example. "To se a that ves a cvs ay ua omoons di’—shaldbeconsruelascotlningplaceforsnglr iris ‘rare hat hey do ot peat Preamp, bal ao ‘pon tht ‘Shr ke Sa sonst! two sen toa preieae Tsagee, drug ht we tink of Kiko ar 4 ve place ect, and ha the ete be pte i hs fo (is Shem, Shien) etry foran Empl somenc at ni ess thi fr So by Shon” about Be bes Tan do, tue we as eee “a king’ ino sng tea, Ghent Elk aking, sy penal ny snd ery ie Relea of couse hs que lees Tapes pret. The sou She Khe) Shas’ nome pes6 PACIFIC PATLOSOPINEAL QUARTERLY. ‘ode my arly ence, and hit kes ier al the three "utc ei en we nk fr goon penn! pera na lon ois prop ate vs [vem are be conse os Dias avi one ote cet yk hey” ee ardy {stshictry, tommy be rane “eo rt pine “te pomp th ir aes ots ape Ingres Apt fy ating, wh ol ait rs exten shy tp ne gating ob Jocelyn mati af we ar shoe» mlsatcy gone a ran mt we shoud pape etn tha oe wen Se ives Oxy (ane es f Cet Tz the “Ds pean Anil rahe widely hh oan ommeed mth bal of tno Ws mye also ops fee sere erage pesons icp be tan tk ear o evens hone who wih ait ‘eu nites wl eta ens he ues rao tne ean tet pei, eae pel dos spat ve Scare rhe dcp rat) wil he tr ean, aa of inames, each Wich wl ben seqxne 9 fst lamers Ie Ply Danson view that one elemet i to oun a ws "hm (0) above relrne o evet wl me cm ty aca of wat gre. But tough evens ny mt belie oe Stace leet, yay wel beeen «pt in wil ‘tholsks oro Kiel for Dako, none way aa {ie maed i or prict nsoncting te thn ht, moe etek lhe pti ian term hg tan We ee sow wiht oie grea oration of Den ett ny applet ven pede will bested by at of man, each SC wee wl st seperti seen a whch len Yayo ‘hot, heii amen ote sequence arp: Dion, has, ‘seal nein, shown nse be vies dane awa 3 Sand repeton ofthe wns “Shr ks Sha tn ‘ef follows (20) (xis aia shy Showa xt Shan Std eA Format of hr vat gh rout at Be a ‘ltzace bso be indigenes oi. een eth somo, i ess ape ons ee my he sill angered. Ae vets mete hes id ape fo ae they engin! et, or const? Ae thy oct tai ACTIONS AND EVENTS fy ‘mpesine in ton pap ters i my rye ht Dei {on meld wid arom “Ye to aco ve guns: he weld ‘spud eel ‘ein elt than onset cas ply ese he woul ot ind he cinco cry ileal pry Pease if ‘hee wo eae const eletece oan gh beens esa eat ao hat he well hin fe orc ‘rth composi since i hy wes conte WB ep a= inning nth yrcpton nan even of erin en nol eeingly ties cones of helt eT pec Ge epee wld incline oars th wet of anos ad wok cerely want 0 ak ‘ti, overt em oon the any sateen oe 3d fend ate was Boe. PUD. PREPOSITIONS AND VERB-DBPENDENCE Uatoruntly wear nt ae the esse omy mi we tee sr ih Daan tam hepa w hentai 0 aig Contin being a appease Thi hee bso een, om macro fom ns, The noes wergreton ‘ele tha eh 8 cep “ns ew ale) De "alow psi be pases James (sub) Dew fo esata Igo “Ja [bet wt (ene Je ae rain a “lames [abet] Sew [ver Yo Fre ave] Wom ‘yc bt a tl antes of ach ac of pring i wea Provide ourselves wih a nee we eo. Fhe, Hs being Sago tha i preposition is wt meet pransicly spable {rm the ve fy fost indent of thon we show es; forth pean fx preston sign eto my wel Fresopove psn of «ronal verb rte dee whe Soc Pron nando Jerse” ol to Stan” woul Pe Incl osr resol ver sgh ay every pes Tint am be seen at wi Tam ow ang w be Davin als of oem ermal oral to Beil 108 ‘Sch uawanetwatlisbis, The spies and ext srl eros of ‘sch anal (tute Daal esi) Tr the seins “Sho ‘a Sha vide onthe Ist shin the aboot mind ono owe, Thre an such ht a king, and doe by Shem, ao nde to Shan andi dne oe Shas el shy ad isda ley and xs dc in he bteoe™ Te eens we at tua mt alla the adel reposton! phe coined in his