Professional Documents
Culture Documents
VS
COUNTER AFFIDAVIT
PAPER-BOOK
FILED BY:
Lucknow
4. ANNEXURE R-3 The true copy of the Transfer Case 252 - 266
(civil) 38 of 2002
5. ANNEXURE R-4 The true copy of the Army HQs letter 267 - 268
6. ANNEXURE R-5 The true copy of the AFT order in T.A. 269 - 286
7. ANNEXURE R-6 True copy of note titled Brief History 287 - 315
of Military Nursing Service prepared by the
8. ANNEXURE R-7 The true copy of the (The Indian) 316 - 324
9. ANNEXURE R-8 The true copy of the posting cum 325 - 326
10. ANNEXURE R-9 The true copy of the attachment plan 327 - 328
11. ANNEXURE R-10 The true copy of the movement 329 - 330
VS
COUNTER AFFIDAVIT OF
PETITIONER MNS CORPS ASSOCIATION
as under:
each and every averment therein except those which are matter
case.
BRIEF FACTS
short) has its origin from the Indian Military Nursing Service
3
(hereinafter called IMNS) which came into being with the Indian
the Allied Forces in the British Indian Army; the origins of the
India. These nurses in due course laid the foundation for the
and persons subject to the Indian Army Act, 1911. The said
Nursing Service).
2
(2) [***]
6. The Parliament repealed the Indian Army Act, 1911 and enacted
the Army Act, 1950; and by this repeal the Indian Military
which laid down the Terms and Conditions of Service for the
1950, Rank, Seniority and Promotions (in the MNS) will be with
continuously.
7
status granted under the Army Act, 1950 in the regular Army
commission in the regular Army are liable for service in any part
8. With the coming into force of the Army Act, 1950 and issuance
Army Act, 1950 under Section 2(1)(a) of the Act. The service
promotion.
Sister - Lieutenant,
*Matron - Major
Matrons.
10
10. Since the creation of the MNS through Army Instruction 274/50;
like other officers of the regular Army serving in other Arms and
Section 10 of the Army Act, 1950, and the Act applies to them
Form of Oath
Form of Affirmation
13
13. That officers serving in all Arms and Services of the regular Army
14. Further, the Army Rules, 1954 are Statutory Rules made by the
The Section 193 of the Army Act, 1950 speaks about Publication
15. Neither the Army Act, 1950 nor the Army Rules, 1954 mention
16. The Section 2 of the Army Act, 1950 describes the person
is under Sub- Section (1) clause (a); and cannot be under any
of 1948);
forces;
17
Army.
(2) Every person subject to this Act under Cls. (a) to 2[(g)] of
service.
17. According to the above stated Section 2(2) of the Army Act,
1950, the Persons subject to the Act under Section 2 (1) clause
The Rule 16A of the Army Rules, 1954 had laid down the
manner provided in Section 2 (2) of the Act. The said Rules have
Regular Army. The persons subject to the Army Act, 1950 under
Section 2(1)(a) of the Act can only be retired from the regular
Section 2(2) of the Act. This leaves no manner of doubt that the
officers serving in the MNS are officers of the regular Army. The
in which they
whichever is earlier.
be
Service;
rank of Colonel;
18. The Rule 2(f) of the Army Rules, 1954, reads as under:
Thus under the Rule 2(f) of the Army Rules the Officers in
reads as under:
19. Further, the Army Rules, 1954 being Statutory Rules shall
Lieut.
Captain
Major
Lt. Colonel
Colonel
above.
Services.
23
21. However, the Section 12 of the Army Act, 1950 puts restrictions
behalf.
Act, 1950.
Further, the Army Act, 1950 applies to them under Section 2(1)
(a) of the Act. The persons subject to the Army Act, 1950 under
Section 2(1)(a) of the Act can only be retired from the regular
Section 2(2) of the Act. This leaves no manner of doubt that the
officers serving in the MNS are officers of the regular Army. They
the Act.
25
in the MNS are Army Officers and will rank equally with male
officers of the same titular rank. The relevant parts of the 1962
Army, 1962; the Chief of Army Staff clarified the issue of saluting
the MNS officers through Army Order 501/63. The relevant parts
times.
25. That in the year 1973, the AO 501/63 was cancelled through
Army Order 353/73 and the Chief of the Army Staff again
with service caps will salute service officers senior to them and
27
return the salutes of junior officers and soldiers at all times. The
Medical Services and the Surety. Before this date, only the
27. That in the year 1977 the Government issued the Army
regular Army. All the present and past officers in the MNS
28. That with the creation of the MNS forming part of the Regular
the status, rank, duties etc for officers in the MNS in exercise of
the powers under the Army Act, 1950. On 15.03.1982, The Chief
of Army Staff through the Army Order 11/82; laid down the
and the earlier Army Order 120/73 on the subject was cancelled.
in honouring the women, the only all women Corps of the Army
that is the MNS was placed first among the Medical Services at
regular Army were placed first among the Medical Services. The
7. Medical Services
(a) MNS
(b) AMC
30
(c) ADC
of (i) the regular Army, (ii) the Army Reserve, and (iii) the
The persons subject to the Army Act, 1950 under Section 2(1)(a)
of the Act can only be retired from the regular Army under Rule
the MNS are officers of the regular Army. Hence the Regulation
58, 65, 66, 67, 75, 76, 77, 81, 105, 109, 255, 341, 618, 619,
of the regular Army. Both 1962 and 1987 Regulations laid down
that officers in the MNS would rank equally with male officers of
30. Further, the Para 255 of the Regulations for the Army, 1987
was further reiterated when the COAS through the Army Orders
Arms/ Services and Units of the Army. That the MNS is not
to any department.
3(xviii) of the Army Act, 1950 and MNS is a Corps of the Regular Army.
32. The report of the 5th Central Pay Commission 1997, accepted by
cadres.
33. Officers in the MNS have always been treated on par with the
xiii. Liability to serve in the Army, Navy and Air Force like
xxiii. Eligible for and also awarded with the same awards
34. The MNS is one of the three constituents of the AFMS, the other
two are AMC and ADC. The method of selection, training, terms
MNS, AMC and ADC are similar. However the AFMS officers are
meant for combat duties and are employed only on jobs which
the regular Army have the same status regardless of their parent
Arms/ Service.
from that of the fighting arms like Infantry, Artillery and Signals
etc. The officers of AFMS are officers of the regular Army are
Selection
professional training
Cadets
commissioning
appointments
Service
Para 81 of the
Army, 1987
armed forces to be
commissioned as
officers
Selection Board
Interview
Medical Services
hospitals etc.
42
Medical Services
Director General
Services
character, Nursing,
will correspond to
equivalent ranks in
those Services.
establishment of
Dental Officer is
originally
commissioned in the
respectively
Condition of the
Field. Geneva, 12
August 1949.
36. The officers in the MNS, AMC and ADC are officers of the regular
MNS. The following table gives the actual job performed by the
educational qualifications:
No. Educational
Qualification
helicopters Arms
making etc.
communication Arms
equipments
Mechanical etc.
Engineers,
battle
Police Service
Service
Corps Service
only) Service
personnel
only)
substantive rank held the officer. The Army in general does not
Hence in the Army the job is synonymous with the rank held by
the officer, and his or her status is according the rank held, not
status.
38. It is an accepted fact that the officers of the Army do not form a
Arms and Arms Support, no matter they may all be drawing the
same salary, holding the same rank, wearing the same uniform
and serving the same employer with similar service benefits. The
held that:
51
benefits...
rest of the officer cadres of the Army (excluding the MNS). There
are separate Army Instructions exists laying down the terms and
52
the same for AMC under Army Instruction 75/78. In the case of
Gazette of India.
Army Nursing Corps and they form an integral part of the Royal
Army. They wear the same uniforms, bear the same insignias
and ranks as officers of the regular army, salute and are saluted
42. This is the situation in the US as well. Recently, the head of the
43. As in the UK and the US so too in Nepal, the nursing officers are
like any other officer of the regular Army on par in every respect
and they wear the same uniform. This is also the situation in
55
44. That, India routinely trains the Army Officer Nurses from
Germany, UK, USA etc. Some of them like USA and UK got
separate branches for Army, Navy and Air Force. And in the
45. That the women officers of the MNS are also routinely required
staff who are placed under them. She handles combatant male
them the basic nursing skills. All these different roles, they have
commissioned ranks.
women officers serving in the MNS are the most combat exposed
47. The officers of the MNS have served on the fringes of the battle
independence. The officers in the MNS are still caring for the sick
and wounded soldiers in the terrorist torn North and North East
to the field area bunkers just a stones throw away from the
Cambodia, and Sierra Leone etc. and with IPKF in Sri Lanka, also
training for the officers of the MNS. Every officer of every branch
of the Army gets weapon and arms training. This is true of all
are required to go near the battle front. The officers of the MNS
may be ordered
50. In India the officers of the MNS have been posted at J&K where
the reach of small arms fire from across the border. The Tangdar
the militants.
51. In Assam and other parts of the North East the officers of the
the officers of the MNS are posted in these disturbed areas. Not
only are the officers of the MNS required to work in the hospitals
52. The officers in the MNS often travel with persons from other
zones and insurgency areas thus facing the same level of threat
53. The distinction between combat and non combat officers of the
them. Not only are they required to serve in such places, but
ought to be set aside by this Court. The written orders are not
under:
63
ARTICLE 22
charge.
56. That the Medical personnel have the right to bear arms and may
57. That the Army in order to discriminate the officers in the MNS
them of the right to bear arms and use them in their own
Lt. Col. (then Major) Saroja Kumari Jhuthu an officer in the MNS.
Lt. Col. Jhithus illustrious career started with her being adjudged
the Best Shot during the Initial Nursing Officers Course in 1991
bronze medals for the Indian Army and made the Nation proud.
rifle, 10 m air rifle and big bore events for the Indian Army. She
vogue for the MNS officers. However, the Indian Army trying
66
erase its own past by denying the contribution made by the MNS
officers in shooting.
58. That the grant of commission under Section 10 Army Act 1950,
the Act; and following the procedure laid down in Rule, 8 and 9
of the Army Rules, 1954; and mention in Rule 16A of the said
353/73 and 11/82; Regulations for the Army 1962, and revised
edition 1987, Paras 32, 58, 65, 66, 67, 75, 76, 77, 81, 105, 109,
the Act can only be retired from the regular Army under Rule
of the MNS and other AFMS officers of the regular Army. They
officer ranks. They are trying to change the surety bond for
68
Army titled Military Law Officer Training School AMC Centre &
even today.
point out to the MNS officers and others that they do not have
the rank and status of officers of the regular Army. In this book
Army Act, 1911 with Army Act 1950. Similar version of the
70
62. That the following comparative table gives the Section wise
statute books and the false version being circulated in the Army.
India.
Preamble An Ordinance to
constitute a force to
Military Nursing
(Union). WHEREAS: an
following Ordinance:-
commencement. Commencement:-
force at once.
Nursing Services
(India).
1911.
notification in the
Official Gazette.
appointment as an appointment as an
Military Nursing
Service).
by regulations.
to Indian
commissioned officers,
inapplicable to women.
or may be prescribed.
82
63. After the year 2000 an issue arose relating to medical officers
namely:
in the statutes were not brought to the notice of the Court and
the fact that the Ordinance relied upon had been impliedly
have been correct prior to the Army Act, 1950 can no longer
changes that have taken place and have been set out in detail in
Court.
parties.
68. After the above observation by the Supreme Court, the Army
the Army made an order stripping the car flags and star plates
from the official cars used by the senior MNS officers of the
Service
69. That the order dated 30.04.04 by the Army stripping the car
flags and star plates from the official cars used by the senior
India & Ors., and the decision of the Armed Forces Tribunal
70. This case was also wrongly pleaded before the Tribunal by the
under:
under
starting with the Army Act, 1950 and various Army Instructions
officers and others that they do not have the rank and status of
(IAP) dealing with medical services issued by the Chief of the Air
erstwhile IMNS are nothing but the same organisation and the
self explanatory and explicit in all terms and removes the cloud
Sl MNS IMNS
No.
1. Officers of the MNS/ Other Subject to the IMNS
to the Army Act, 1950 and Indian Army Act, 1911 and
Army.
Army.
provided in Section 16 of
commissioning.
Rules, 1954.
1954.
combatants according to
Rules, 1954.
the MNS, like all other the Ordinance and the Rules
1950).
Services/ Arms.
army.
11. Officers of the MNS like all Liable to serve only with the
world.
the Army.
years.
male officers.
16. Only the persons subject to Rule 16A of the Army Rules,
1954 as provided in
76. In 2014 the Law Commission of India in report no. 249 relating
from time to time starting with the Army Act, 1950 and all the
from the Indian Army Act, 1911 which was repealed by the Army
Act, 1950 and by this repeal the IMNS Ordinance, 1943 is also
impliedly repealed.
Indian Army on the repeal of the Indian Army Act, 1911 and
78. That the force called IMNS under the Indian Military Nursing
Act, 1911.
79. The Section 4(1) of the Ordinance limits the service liability of
under the Army Act, 1950; the Government of India had set the
in any part of the world and in any branch of the Armed Forces
ever ordered in any of the three Armed Forces i.e. Army, Navy
and Air Force. Had the MNS officers were subject to the IMNS
reads as under:
India
103
conformity with the Section 11 of the Army Act, 1950, reads as,
84. Presently the age limit for grant of commission in the MNS is 20
85. That the Central Government did not issue any special Gazette
force.
86. That no other provision exists under the Army Act, 1950 to bring
the Officers of the IMNS were clearly not persons not otherwise
inapplicable to women.
88. That the Section 9(1) of the IMNS Ordinance modified the
89. That the corresponding provisions of the Indian Army Act, 1911
Army Act, 1950 are given in Section 39, absence without leave
107
Army Act 1950. Hence the members of the IMNS could have
90. That the officers in the MNS are subject only to the Army Act,
1950 and Rules made thereunder they can be tried for any
under Section 42 of the Army Act, 1950 like other officers of the
by all the MNS officers, the Government shall have the right to
91. Further, the persons subject to the Army Act, 1950 under
Section 2(1)(a) of the Act can only be retired from the regular
108
Section 2(2) of the Act. That the provisions of the Army Act,
fact as seen from Rule 16A of the Army Rules, 1954. This leaves
Gazette.
93. That Section 9 of the IMNS Ordinance, 1943 laid down that,
inapplicable to women.
94. Hence on 22nd July 1950 onwards (on the commencement of the
95. That the IMNS (India) Rules, 1944 also became redundant
thereafter as the rank, status and all other aspects of the officers
in the MNS came under the exclusive purview of the Army Act,
1950.
96. That the IMNS Ordinance, 1943 was amended by the Parliament
IMNS or its successors under the Army Act, 1950. Further, the
from 15th August 1947. The officers of MNS were brought under
98. That the Army is trying to rewrite the military law to down grade
the officers of the MNS from being officers of the regular Army
stating that the officers of the MNS are not officers of the
veterans of MNS who all have dedicated their lives in the service
of the Army and now retired but concerned about the rank and
about the state of affairs in the Service which has given their
PARAWISE REPLY
procedures/ facts.
315).
reads as under:
was still in force. The Army Act, 1950 came in to force only
104. Para 12-13 The averments made in this Paras are false and
Nursing Service (MNS) was raised under the Indian Military Nursing
Army; and the Ordinance governs the terms and conditions of service
persons subject to the Army Act, 1950 under Section 2(1)(a) of the Act
can only be retired from the regular Army under Rule 16A of the
Army Rules, 1954 as provided in Section 2(2) of the Act. That the
provisions of the Army Act, 1950 apply to the officers serving in the
MNS is an undeniable fact as the MNS has been included in the arms
Army Rules, 1954. This leaves no manner of doubt that the officers
serving in the MNS are officers of the regular Army. Therefore the
officers of the regular Army; under Section 2(1) (a) of the Act. It is
submitted that elaborate details of the same are given in Para 5 17,
above.
105. Para 14 The averments made in this sub Para are false and
Chief of the Army Staff and existence of MNS (I) Rule 1944
118
status and all other aspects of the officers in the MNS came
106. Para 15 The averments made in this Paras are false and
(i) Nationality
domicile.
'or'
120
India, 'or'
'or
107. Para 16 The averments made in this Paras are false and
misconceived and the same are denied to the extent that the
108. Para 17 The averments made in this Paras are false and
109. Para 18 The averments made in this Paras are false and
drawing the same salary, holding the same rank, wearing the
benefits...
110. Para 19 The averments made in this sub Para are false and
in the MNS are officers of the regular Army. Further, the persons
subject to the Army Act, 1950 under Section 2(1)(a) of the Act can
only be retired from the regular Army under Rule 16A of the Army
Rules, 1954 as provided in Section 2(2) of the Act. That the provisions
of the Army Act, 1950 apply to the officers serving in the MNS is an
undeniable fact as the MNS has been included in the arms and
Army Rules, 1954. This leaves no manner of doubt that the officers
serving in the MNS are officers of the regular Army. Therefore the
officers of the regular Army; under Section 2(1) (a) of the Act. Why
be ordered
53, above.
now they are being denied the arms training are elaborated
112. Para 21-22 The averments made in this Para are false and
officers in the MNS are officers of the Army are set out in
Para 5 40 above.
113. Para 23 (i) (iv) The averments made in this sub Paras are false
officers in the MNS are officers of the Army are set out in
Para 5 40 above.
114. Para 23 (v) The averments made in this sub Para are false and
dentists, then the same can not affect the nurses. The
(MNS, AMC and ADC) and other officers are given in Para 34
37, above.
115. Para 23 (vi) The averments made in this sub Para are false and
MNS, AMC and ADC are similar. However the AFMS officers
doctors, dentists and nurses from the Civil are selected based
the back ward notion to the world that in India the nursing is
116. Para 23 (vii) The averments made in this sub Para are false and
the Army Act, 1950 applies to them in full, being the officers of the
regular Army. Further, the persons subject to the Army Act, 1950
under Section 2(1)(a) of the Act can only be retired from the regular
Army under Rule 16A of the Army Rules, 1954 as provided in Section
2(2) of the Act. That the provisions of the Army Act, 1950 apply to the
officers serving in the MNS is an undeniable fact as the MNS has been
given in Rule 16A of the Army Rules, 1954. This leaves no manner of
doubt that the officers serving in the MNS are officers of the regular
Army. Therefore the Army Act, 1950 applies to the women officers
serving in MNS as officers of the regular Army; under Section 2(1) (a)
129
31, above.
117. Para 23 (viii) The averments made in this sub Para are false
the extent that the 6th Central Pay Commission had in fact
Despite this, the MNS officers are kept on a lower basic and
grade pay than other officers of equal rank in the army. This
therein.
case is attached.
132
118. Para 23 (ix) The averments made in this sub Para are false and
119. Para 23 (x) The averments made in this sub Para are false and
being made out that officers from the other arms and
39, above.
120. Para 23 (xi) The averments made in this sub Para are false and
under:
that para.
121. Para 23 (xii) The averments made in this sub Para are false and
under Section 2(1)(a) of the Act can only be retired from the
doubt that the officers serving in the MNS are officers of the
reduced their pay scales and grade pay, changed their travel
122. Para 24 The Petitioner submits to the Honble Court that, this
of the Act can only be retired from the regular Army under
of the Act. That the provisions of the Army Act, 1950 apply to
that the officers serving in the MNS are officers of the regular
Section 2(1) (a) of the Act. Hence, at the very minimum the
123. Para 25 Andhra Pradesh High Court Lt. R.S. Rebecamma, EX MNS
agricultural land?
139
the notice of the Court. This case was also wrongly pleaded
is, this Court holds that the petitioner who worked as Non-
men are given in Para 131 of the regulation for the Army,
statutory changes that have taken place and have been set
142
was misleading, and that the High Court was not informed:
instruments;
this Order.
Army on her own request. Her case did not meet the
that she had been released at her own request The fact
124. Para 26 The averments made in this sub Para are false and
the officers in the MNS are subject only to the Army Act,
40, above.
125. Para 27(i) The averments made in this sub Para are false and
and orders stating that the officers of the MNS are not
MNS who all have dedicated their lives in the service of the
Army and now retired but concerned about the rank and
the MNS officers equal status at par with the officers of the
their life.
126. Para 27(ii, iii & iv) The averments made in this sub Para are false
127. Para 27(v) The averments made in this sub Para are false and
the rank pay and hence the related status of the serving and
128. Para 27(vi) The averments made in this sub Para are false and
the regular Army serving in the MNS will adversely affect the
129. Para 27(vii) The averments made in this sub Para are false and
130. Para 27(viii) The averments made in this sub Para are false
under:
131. Para-1 The averments made in this Para are denied. The
Army Act, 1950 under Section 2(1)(a) of the Act can only be
retired from the regular Army under Rule 16A of the Army
Army given in Rule 16A of the Army Rules, 1954. This leaves
31, above.
155
132. Para-1A The averments made in this Para are denied. The
objections.
reiterated that the MNS is subject to the Army Act, 1950 and
forms part of the regular Army. The officers in the MNS are
134. Para-2B The averments made in this Para are false and
135. Para-2C The averments made in this Para are false and
the regular Army and officers in the MNS are officers of the
136. Para-2D The averments made in this Para are false and
subject only to the Army Act, 1950 and the Rules made
137. Para-2E The averments made in this Para are false and
Neither the Army Act, 1950 nor the Army Rules, 1954
subject only to the Army Act, 1950 and the Rules made
subject only to the Army Act, 1950 and the Rules made
74, above.
above.
160
to the MNS officers and others that they do not have the
that the case was decided on the basis of the Indian Military
as under:
force.
before the Tribunal. The fact that officers in the MNS are
discriminated.
141. Paras 3.1 to 3.4 The serving officers of the MNS neither formed
this Society, at the twilight years of their life. The reply given
143. Paras 3.6 The averments made by the respondent is false and
not under the Army Act 1950. It is humbly submitted that the
144. Para 3.7 In reply it is reiterated that the AI 4/59 was issued
145. Para 3.8 The averments of the respondent is false and denied
to the extent that Paras 754 and 755 are not applicable to
MNS are officers of the regular Army under the Army Act,
165
as under:
commissioned officers.
147. Para 3.9 The averments made by the respondent are false
Further, the Army Order 11/82 places the MNS first among
are false and denied. The officers serving in the MNS are
officers of the regular Army and hence the Army Act, 1950
under Section 2(1)(a) of the Act can only be retired from the
doubt that the officers serving in the MNS are officers of the
Pom Pong Island. The officers of the MNS have served on the
still caring for the sick and wounded soldiers in the terrorist
torn North and North East to the field area bunkers just a
169
Sierra Leone etc. and with IPKF in Sri Lanka, also in war
are within the reach of small arms fire from across the
parts of the North East the officers of the MNS have been
170
skies on the fringes of the battle field like what used to be Sri
Lanka.
officers of the regular Army. They are the ones who were the
in the year 2000. This led to certain issues which were finally
Para 102. Therefore the Para 234 of the RMSAF which states
officers.
Army Act 1950. The Section 193 of the Army Act, 1950
Neither the Army Act, 1950 nor the Army Rules, 1954
they
sub-rule 5 (f) (ii) and (g) (ii) and sub-rule (6), whichever
is earlier.
be
Service;
and not defined, but defined in the Act, shall have the
Thus under the Rule 2(f) of the Army Rules the Officers in
under:
with the Statutory Law is invalid and cannot bring the officers
from the Army Act, 1950 and Rules made thereunder. The
1950.
149. Para 3.13 The contents of this Para are false and denied. The
of the Army Act 1950. Further, the Army Act, 1950 applies to
(xviii) of the Act. The Navy Act, 1957, Section 10 (2) laid
officers in the MNS from 1950 till 1999 and cannot be called
150. Para 3.14 The contents of this Para are false and denied.
and can be tried for any offence under the Army Act, 1950.
151. Para 3.15 The contents of this Para are false and denied to the
152. Para 3.16 The contents of this Para are false and denied. It is
of.....
152. Para 3.17 The reply of the respondent is false and denied. The
154. Para 3.18 The reply is misleading and misconceived and hence
155. Para 3.19 to 3.23 The averment put forward in this Para is false
held that:
regular Army subject to the Army Act, 1950 and Rules made
from the regular Army under Rule 16A of the Army Rules,
Army given in Rule 16A of the Army Rules, 1954. This leaves
(A)
186
Services.
158. Para 3.26 to 3.27 The contents in this Para are denied
service;
called out on permanent service along with the Arms and all
the Army Act, 1950 and Rules made thereunder. The preface
PREFACE
188
salient
of these regulations.
local authorities.
prevail.
(S.K. BRATNAGAR.)
159. Para 3.28 The averments in this Para false are and are
the Army Act 1950. The Section 193 and 193A of the Army
read as under:
191
thirty days
under:
and not defined, but defined in the Act, shall have the
not defined in the Rules but is defined only in the Army Act,
1950. Hence, under the Rule 2(f) of the Army Rules, the
reads as under:
this Act;
give under:
Further, the Rule 187 Army Rules, 1954 lists the Corps
namely:
combatants.
combatants.
combatants.
195
including non-combatants.
Engineers.
160. Para 3.29 to 3-30 The contention of the respondent is false and
is denied. The said bond for the Nursing Cadets admitted for
bond is as follows:
the officers of the regular Army. They are the ones who were
contains the facts which has not been denied in detail by the
the respondent is fully aware that the officers in the MNS are
Army Act, 1950 and the Rules made there under. Further,
2(1)(a) of the Act can only be retired from the regular Army
Section 2(2) of the Act. That the provisions of the Army Act,
doubt that the officers serving in the MNS are officers of the
Army; under Section 2(1) (a) of the Act. The details are
Act, 1950 nor the Army Rules, 1954 mention the name of
Army Act, 1950 and the Rules made thereunder. The MNS
forms part of the regular Army and officers in the MNS are
161. Para 3-32 to 3.34 The contention of the respondent is false and
bear arms and may in case of need, use them in their own
enjoy the respect to which they are entitled. During the 1971
203
The respondent even ignored the facts that there are still
with her being adjudged the Best Shot during the Initial
above.
are within the reach of small arms fire from across the
205
parts of the North East the officers of the MNS are posted to
the MNS are posted in these disturbed areas. Not only are
under:
206
329 to 330).
207
in the MNS are officers of the regular Army was hidden from
the same rank, wearing the same uniform and serving the
all respect to other cadre officers of the Army, during the 4th
had proposed to the 4th CPC to grant the same pay scales to
(Para 147.39 of 5th CPC report) . In 1995 to the 5th CPC, the
one increment below the other cadres. In 2008, the 6th CPC
the MNS and other Service cadre should be the same (Para
same pay band and grade pay to officers in the MNS will
Dist and at Kargil are within the reach of small arms fire from
and other parts of the North East the officers of the MNS
areas. Not only are the officers of the MNS required to work
and are saluted to and have exactly the same status, dignity,
and they wear the same uniform. This is also the situation in
164. Paras 3.40 The averment made in this Para are false and denied.
The officers in the MNS are officers of the Regular Army and
above.
165. Para 3.43 to 3.44 The averment made in Para are false
and hence the Army Act, 1950 and the Army Rules, 1954
to the Army Act, 1950 under Section 2(1)(a) of the Act can
only be retired from the regular Army under Rule 16A of the
The Para 234 of the RMSAF which states that Nursing Officer
reiterated.
167. Para 3.50 to 3.51 The averment made in Para are false and
in the MNS are officers of the regular Army and hence the
Army Act, 1950 and the Army Rules, 1954 applies to them in
216
the Indian Army Act, 1911 and enacted the Army Act, 1950,
August 1947.
MNS. The officer status granted under the Army Act, 1950 in
Army are liable for service in any part of the world along with
218
With the coming into force of the Army Act, 1950 and
officers in the MNS, due to the fact on that date the IMNS
Army, under Army Act, 1950 and the Act applied to them
hence the Army Act, 1950 and the Army Rules, 1954 applies
the Army Act, 1950 under Section 2(1)(a) of the Act can only
the MNS are officers of the regular Army. Therefore the Army
Act.
222
168. Para 3.54 The averment made in this Para are false and
Army Act 1950. Further, the Army Act, 1950 applies to them
the Act. The Navy Act, 1957, Section 10 (2) laid down that
Army Act, 1950 applies to them under Section 2(1) (a) of the
171. Para 3.57 The averment made in Para are false and
Army Act 1950. Further, the persons subject to the Army Act,
from the regular Army under Rule 16A of the Army Rules,
Army given in Rule 16A of the Army Rules, 1954. This leaves
173. Para 3.59 The averment made by respondent in this Para are
1943 flows from the Indian Army Act, 1911, which was
this repeal the Indian Military Nursing Service, 1943 was also
226
of the Army Act 1950 and Rules 8 and 9 of the Army Rules,
1954.
Army Act 1950 and Rules 8 and 9 of the Army Rules, 1954.
flows from the Indian Army Act, 1911, which was repealed
Army and hence the Army Act, 1950 and the Army Rules,
of the Act can only be retired from the regular Army under
of the Act. That the provisions of the Army Act, 1950 apply to
that the officers serving in the MNS are officers of the regular
Section 2(1) (a) of the Act. Hence, the officers in the MNS
are officers of the regular Army, they have powers like other
5 to 31, above.
from which the said Rules draws its force, namely the Indian
Army Act, 1911 and the Army Act both stood repealed on
MNS and IMNS are not the same and the later no longer
exists.
175. Para 3.61 The averment made by respondent in this Para are
IMNS was subsumed in the MNS. The Army Act, 1950 applied
this Para are false and misconceived and the same are
the Act and Rules 8 and 9 of the Army Rules, 1954. Further,
2(1)(a) of the Act can only be retired from the regular Army
Section 2(2) of the Act. That the provisions of the Army Act,
doubt that the officers serving in the MNS are officers of the
flows from the Indian Army Act, 1911, which was repealed
of the Army Act, 1950 they were serving in IMNS part of the
177. Para 3.63 The averment made by respondent in this Para are
Army Act 1950 and Rules 8 and 9 of the Army Rules, 1954.
(vi) of the Army Act, 1950 read with Rule 187(1)(y) of the
from the Indian Army Act, 1911, which was repealed on the
repealed.
179. Para 3.65 In reply it is submitted that the said "Regulations for
Army. The regular Army includes the Army Reserve and the
235
with the Arms and all Services including MNS which are
Rule 187 of the Army Rules, 1954, the relevant portion reads
as under:
namely:
Section 2(1) clause (a) of the Army Act, 1950. The petitioner
182. Para 3.69 3.71 The averments in this Para are false and
applied to the MNS. Neither the Army Act, 1950 nor the
Army Act, 1950 describes the person subject to the Act. The
Section (1) clause (a); and cannot be under any other clause
the Section 2(2) of the Army Act, 1950, the Persons subject
to the Act under Section 2 (1) clause (a) to (i) shall remains
the Army Rules, 1954 had laid down the provision for
does not apply to the persons who are subject to the Act
under Section 2.
Army Act 1950. Further, the Army Act, 1950 applies to them
false and are denied. The officers serving in the MNS are
Army Act, 1950 applies to them under Section 2(1) (a) of the
under Section 2(1)(a) of the Act can only be retired from the
doubt that the officers serving in the MNS are officers of the
applied to the MNS. Neither the Army Act, 1950 nor the
the MNS).
187. Para 3.82 3.83 The averments in this Para are false and
elaborated earlier.
188. Para 3.84 The averments in this Para are false and are denied.
above.
242
189. Para 3.85 The averments in this Para are false and
are repeated.
2(1) (a) of the Act. Further, the persons subject to the Army
retired from the regular Army under Rule 16A of the Army
Army given in Rule 16A of the Army Rules, 1954. This leaves
the regular Army; under Section 2(1) (a) of the Act. Hence,
world will look down upon India, if the rights of these hapless
Army.
PRAYER
DEPONENT
VERIFICATION
knowledge derived from and are based on the available records and
DEPONENT
246
Annexure R-1
Major Saroja Kuari J who did the nation proud by winning India's first
Nursing Service (MNS) from College of Nursing. AFMC Pune. Her first
Nursing Officers Course (INOC) where she was adjudged the Best Shot
Li Gen OP Nandra jog being shown the Gold Medal won by Maj Saroja
Kumari J
-Dr KA Sagar
Annexure R-2
1943]
the Government of India Act. As set out in the Ninth Schedule to the
Services wherever they may be. It shall come into force at once.
this Ordinance.
Ordinance.
the armed forces of the Union and for service with the Military
Nursing Service.
249
service only with forces and persons subject to the Army Act.
1950.
thereunder.
250
the Army Act 1911, shall to such extent and subject to such
women.
251
Nursing Service.
or may be prescribed.
11. Power to make regulations:- The Chief of the Army Staff may
Nursing Service.
252
Annexure R-3
BENCH:
JUDGMENT
With
SRIKRISHNA, J.
titled The Indian Military Nursing Service Ordinance, 1943, which was
manner provided in the Ordinance "as part of the armed forces of the
Union and for service with the Indian Military forces" an auxiliary force
254
section 6.
Army Act, 1911 shall, to such extent and subject to such adaptations
make Rules to carry out the purposes of the ordinance and section 11
vests in The Chief of the Army Staff the power to make regulations
providing for all matters to be laid down and generally for all detail
changed from time to time taking into account the advice of special
Despite the fact that the Indian Military Nursing Service (hereinafter
this service are not subject to all the provisions of the Army Act and
have been treated separately while being part of the Indian Army.
the Dress Code for different purposes. We are not concerned with the
details of the prescribed uniforms for that in no way affects the legal
were faced in the hospital environment in the wake of the dress code
prescribing uniform for the IMNS was a matter well within the
this Court admitted the special leave petitions and also transferred all
257
"We have heard learned counsel for the parties. The writ
Court.
When these petitions came up for hearing on 6th May, 2002 it was
the nurses in the Army. This Court made the following order:
order:
Force), Dy. Judge Advocate General and ADG Military Nursing service
following:
"Terms of Reference
Services.
nurses.
dress code.
The Dress Review Committee held its deliberations on 8th and 9th July
2002 and made a report. Though Major General P.K. Sethi, Addl
the Safari Suit of soothing colour (Beige colour) in suitable fabric with
frame of three months and that the cost of the recommended dress
263
competent authority.
A copy of the Dress Review Committee report has been placed on the
learned counsel did not press the contentions based on Article 21.
part of the military services should have any uniform, and, if so, what
Chief of Army Staff by reason of Army Act, the Indian Military Nursing
Act and the Regulations made by the Chief of Army Staff by the
was paid to their objections before the Dress Code was finally decided.
Even if true, the contention has lost its force presently. When taken
review committee.
matter, the members of IMNS could not have asked for anything
our constitutional powers. The petitions have no merit and are liable to
fail.
The members of the IMNS have the glorious role model of the 'Lady
with the Lamp', Florence Nightingale, who went around on the battle
field, caring more for the patients than for her own life. We hope that
266
the shining example of the Lady with the Lamp shall continue to be
Annexure R-4
B/42127/AG/CW-1 30 April 04
OFFICERS
2. Regulations for Army para 773 only lays down the shape/colour
3. The Indian Military Nursing Officers are not covered under the
Sd/-
(Brijendra
Singh)
Brig
DDG(Cer)
DGMS-3A
Copy to:
SO to DGMS (Army): for info of DGMS (Army) w.r.t. note No. 2094/
Annexure R-5
NEW DELHI
Versus
CORAM:
restore her status and other Nursing Officers at par with all
other officers of the Indian Army as per laid down orders, rules
Armed Forces.
3. Brief facts which are relevant for the disposal of Present petition
Indian Naval Hospital Ship (in short INHS), Asvini, Mumbai. The
visit was carried out on 17th and 18th August, 2003. During visit
authority, not to display stars and fly flag on her official vehicle
Branch are that Indian Military Nursing Officers are not covered
3(xvill) Army Act, 1950 and it is also mentioned that MNS was
Service implying that officers of MNS are not part of the Armed
officers of the Indian Army and it was finally ordered that under
273
Chief of Army Staff and the Chief of Army Staff assured her that
all grievances of the MNS officers would be looked into and all
driven to file the present writ petition before the Hon'ble Delhi
High Court with aforesaid reliefs and the same was transferred
position that petitioner was not recruited under Army Act and
Rules and she has been recruited under Indian Military Nursing
5. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and bestowed our
best of consideration.
and this Ordinance still holds field till date. Section 3 lays down
reads as under:
India).
reads as under:
under:-
276
officer of the Nursing Services the Act, whether the Army Act
(44 & 45 Viet. C. 58) or the Indian Army Act, 1911 (VIII of
these Rules
officers and the provisions of the Army Act shall apply to officers
14. Rule 5 says about modification of the Army Act. It says the
15. Further procedure has been given how the punishment can be
regular forces. From this, what emerges is that they will have
the various orders issued from time to time i.e. With regard to
or Engineers.
18. Similarly with regard to the use of National Flag, this has been
given as per the ranks of the officers and same will be applicable
19. From these provisions of the Acts, Rules and the Military Orders
and she has also been equated with the same rank and as per
Armed Forces.
20. Learned counsel for the respondents has seriously contested the
position and submitted that despite all this, petitioner was not
recruited under the Army Act, 1950 and she cannot be treated to
under:
includes:-
this Act.
Act.
e) (Omitted)
21. It is true that the petitioner was not recruited under the Army
recruited directly under the Army Act, 1950 and rules framed
will not distract from the fact that for all purposes she will be
treated at par with the officers of the Indian Armed Forces. The
objection that she does not fall in Section of Army Act 3 (XVIII)
Armed Forces also. Simply because she has not been recruited
under the Army Act, that will not in any way reduce her status
officer entitled under the Army Act, 1950 and rules framed
(Chairperson)
Sd/-
286
M.L. NAIDU
(Member)
New Delhi
Annexure - 6
INTRODUCTION
Early Days
The first sisters were sent from St. Thomas hospital, London
Madras.
Crimean War
the war against Russia. There were no nurses to care for the
poorly cooked and of a kind that the very ill could not eat.
appeal was sent out for help and supplies and Miss
Nov 1857.
She was the first lady in the world to receive this honour. On
this occasion, King Adward Seven said its matter of pride for
290
Chief in India and Lady Robert in 1888, Lord & Lady Roberts
even raised a fund for the nursing of Officers, until such time
as the govt of India recognized a need for it. The first batch
refused cooperation.
292
year 1896.
British army Nursing service in the UK, which was then called
War speaks volumes for the tactful and able manner in which
from france in 1915 except six who remained with the Lahore
During the War dire need of nursing care for Indian soldiers
Egypt.
295
establishments.
to the hospital.
Service.
World War II
cared for when sick, so that they could return to the front as
Thus it was during the war that this facility was introduced
denied so long.
for 6077 beds for Indian troops of British crown, 215 nurses
battle dress blouses replaced the grey & scarlet ward dress
nurses.
number was very less, with the progress of war and to meet
September 1940.
2787 joined ANS (I) for service with army. In Dec 1943 a
Japanese. During the World War many nurses lost their lives
300
took the control of the city .The names are as given bellow:
14 2.42
14.2.42
on 14.2.42
302
daughter of P. P. Sebastian
died on 14.2.42
on 14.2.42
from MNS (T) and 4 from AINSR (IT). The number of them
1949, when the final and decisive step was taken and
the British service, and this was one of the obstacle in the
305
all the sections of the Army Act and Indian Army Act,
draft as he desires.
regulated as follows:
Matron - Major
Sister - Lieutenant
309
of sister-in-charge.
Before the end of the end of 1946, the nurses from abroad
Juliet Piggott).
Post Independence
311
In the year 1950, soon after the enactment of the Army Act,
The officers in the MNS are subject to the Army Act, 1950
Maj. Gen. (Miss) G.A Ram, was the first woman to attain the
Maj Gen - 01
Brig - 12
Col - 31
Lt Col - 116
315
*****
316
Annexure R-7
[30 of 1943]
of the Government of India Act, as set out in the Ninth Schedule to the
1943.
6
(2) It applies to members of the Indian Military Nursing
Ordinance
Ordinance.
as part of the armed forces of the 7(Union) and for service with
318
8
(the Indian) Military forces an auxiliary force which shall be
9
[**]
10
4. Liability of service of members of (Indian Military Nursing
Service.
11
(2) [**]
13
6. Eligibility for appointment.(1) (Any citizen of India) if a
12
appointment as an officer in the (Indian Military Nursing
20
offering themselves for appointment in the (Indian
to be or may be prescribed.
21
11. Power to make regulationsThe (Chief of the Army Staff) may
Nursing Service).
26-1-1950).
26-1-1950).
322
10. Subs. for Military Nursing Services (India) by A.L.O. 1950 (w.e.f.
26-1-1950).
(w.e.f. 7-5-1955).
15. Subs. for Military Nursing Services (India) by A.L.O. 1950 (w.e.f.
26-1-1950).
18. The words and those members of the Army in Indian Nursing
Service Reserve who have engaged to serve with forces and person
323
subject to the Indian Army Act 1911 were omitted by A.L.O. 1950
(w.e.f. 26-1-1950).
20. Subs. for Military Nursing Services (India) by A.L.O. 1950 (w.e.f.
26-1-1950).
(w.e.f. 7-5-1955).
324
Annexure R-8
Headquarters
No
325
Fd Hosp on 27
NR-20458L GD Matron
Feb 2017
GD Matron (New Raining
Unit)
MH Bakloh
posting
NS-23167W Sr Sister
27 Feb 2017
Haokip Fd Hosp on 27
Sr Sister
Feb 2017
NS-23713X
(New Raining
Sr Sister Unit)
CH (WC) Chandimandir
326
2. The unit will fwd arrival report and DO Part-II showing date of
TORS of the MNS offr directly to Dte Gen upon arrival of the offr.
(Smita Devrani)
Col
For DGMS
(Army)
Copy to:-
188 MH 154 GH
456 Fd Hosp
Internal:-
Annexure R-9
Mukhyalaya/Headquarters
PIN-900496
BH Lucknow MH Meerut
MH Bareilly MH Roorkee
1. The pgme for the year 2016 regarding temp duty of Nursing
Offr
(RE).
(MK Samanta)
Lt Col
DADMS
for MG Med
Copy to:
C/O 56 APO
C/O 56 APO
329
Annexure R-10
RESTRICTED
MOVEMENT ORDER
Airiya of this hosp whi will return to this hosp for duty.
authority.
For commandant
Distribution:-
Offr concerned
329 Fd Hosp
Case file