Professional Documents
Culture Documents
discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/282701581
CITATIONS READS
0 1,834
1 author:
Satish Modh
VES Institute of Management Studies and Research, Mumbai
16 PUBLICATIONS 2 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Satish Modh on 10 October 2015.
The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file. All in-text references underlined in blue are added to the original document
and are linked to publications on ResearchGate, letting you access and read them immediately.
TITLE: Leadership styles and Individual Differences: Comparing leadership styles of
1
Leadership styles and Individual Differences: Comparing leadership styles of Mr.
ABSTRACT
Mr. Narendra Modi, the Prime Minister of India, has been in news for his travels abroad and
creating an impact by his mega rallies while addressing people of Indian origin. Many
commentators have tried to compare his one year in office with that of Dr. Manmohan Singh who
was the Prime Minister of India for a decade. In 2014 India voted in favor of Mr. Narendra Modi
who offered a totally contrasting style of leadership to the people of India. This article makes an
attempt to compare the leadership styles of Mr. Narendra Modi and Dr. Man Mohan Singh using
1.0 INTRODUCTION
Leaders have followers who believe in them and in their capacity to achieve desired goals. When
people are at peace, happy and satisfied there is hardly any discussion on the styles of political
leadership. On the other hand, when the welfare of the people is at stake and the economic situation
requires someone to initiate change, the need for leadership is high (English, 1992). Leaders are
expected to have a vision of the future and formulate strategies to bring about changes needed to
achieve that vision (Carlson, 1996). Dependable and capable leadership is crucial to the success of
2
1.1 VARIOUS LEADERSHIP STYLES IN THE LITERATURE
Some researchers have focused on leader-follower relationship. In this theory researchers have
looked at their mutual obligations and their psychological contract (Ilies et al., 2007). Sometimes
follower traits and characteristics influence leader-follower relationship (Shamir, 2007). Shamir
(2007) suggested that such followers are likely to show blind loyalty, obedience, and deference.
This line of research suggests that leadership effectiveness is just as a product of good followers
as it is of good leaders. This concept developed into a leadership style called servant leadership.
Such leaders are service oriented, appreciate others service, and are good listeners and delegators
Cognitive leadership emphasizes on how the leaders think and process information (Lord and Hall,
2005). The research on cognitive aspects of leadership explains the way leaders and followers
think and process information (Lord and Hall, 2005; Mumford et al., 2007). Lord and Hall (2005)
developed a model that emphasized leaders cognitive attributes or abilities whereas Mumford et
al. (2007) focussed on interactions that occur between individuals. There are a range of cognitive
attributes in a person and which attribute remain dormant and which attributes are activated at a
Professional leaders have the ability to draw upon the experience, wisdom, understanding and
knowledge inherent in the organization and its people. Such leaders have very good problem
solving skills (Northouse, 2012). Virtuous leaders give emphasis on each of the classical human
virtues most essential to leadership e.g. magnanimity, humility, prudence, courage, self-control
Transformational leaders have the ability to understand the fine and subtle information about the
situation and capabilities and feelings of people. According to Burns, transformational leaders are
3
those who motivate their followers to perform beyond expectation by raising the followers'
confidence levels and by providing support for developing high levels of performance (Burns,
1978). An entrepreneurial leader has the ability to identify opportunities and initiate actions to
Task-oriented leaders prefer to focus on the tasks at hand in order to achieve the goal. They focus
on step by step solution to the issues and problems at hand (Griffin and Ricky, 2010).
punishment mechanism (Bass, 1985). There are various types of transactional leadership such as
charismatic, inspirational and visionary leadership (Judge and Piccolo 2004; Lowe and Gardner,
2000). Situational leaders focus on the current context of the situation and try to do what is needed
to get the job done successfully. These leaders are able to assess the maturity of the people they
are leading and the details of the task (Hersey and Blanchard, 1977).
Mentor leaders, according to Tony Dungy (2010), help others learn, grow and become more
effective in their jobs. Mentoring builds capacity of people and organizations in implementing
projects and achieving success by creating structures and process to bring out best in people. Duty-
oriented leaders are concerned with what people do, not with the results or consequences of their
An Intellectual leader is an idea broker that enables the exchange of ideas for the survival and
growth of the organization (Hampden-Turner and Trompenaars, 2000). Creative leadership is the
ability to think and act beyond the boundaries while addressing critical issues (Puccio et al., 2011).
Innovative leaders bring new thinking and different actions to manage their work. They think
4
differently about their role and the challenges they face. Innovative leaders are able to solve deep-
The leadership research has also explored the concept of shared leadership in teams and in
organizations as hierarchical levels. This research focuses on the role of an individual leading the
team. This team leadership is also described as shared leadership, distributed leadership or
collective leadership. This team leadership style varies based on the inputs, processes, and
outcomes of the team (Day et al., 2004) and develops relationship between team members (Carson
et al., 2007). The research in this area covers levels of task competence in the team, complexity of
tasks, and task interdependence in terms of examining how teams function when using shared
leadership. The shared leadership produces patterns of reciprocal influence between team or group
or organization members developing and reinforcing further relationship between them (Carson et
al., 2007).
Organizational functions where repetitive actions need efficient execution and skill building is a
must, they position command and control mechanism firmly in place in those functions. Leaders
in such context develop values and belief systems which put more emphasis on results the concerns
of individuals and become authoritarian leaders. Authoritarian leaders, also known as autocratic
leaders provide clear expectations for what needs to be done, when it should be done, and how it
Democratic leadership: Democratic leaders rely upon group decision making, active member
involvement, honest praise and criticism, and a degree of comradeship (Bass and Bass, 1974;
Cooperative leadership: Distinct from the authoritarian and democratic leader, a cooperative
leader tries to build a consensus and is a facilitator of a common goal. A cooperative leader believes
5
more in self-regulation rather than external supervision. Such leaders are willing to compromise
on values and beliefs when they see that nothing can be done without a compromise and something
needs to be done. John Baldoni (2012) points to a good process that will help you on the path to
compromise: Our ego often prevents us from seeing what others see and, worse, prevents us
from seeing the merits of their case. Strong willed people often become so consumed by the power
of their ideas that it prevents them from examining and understanding another's point of view.
Spiritual leadership: In last few years there have been discussion on spirituality at work place and
a new concept of spiritual leadership has emerged. In this model the leaders and followers express
genuine care, concern, and appreciation for both self and others (Fry, 2003). In an article on
spirituality at workplace Fry (2005) defined spiritual leadership as comprising the values,
attitudes, and behaviors that are necessary to intrinsically motivate self and others to enhance a
Cross-cultural leadership: In the current globalized environment of business there has been also
research on cross-cultural leadership (Gelfand et al., 2007; House, Hanges et al., 2004). The
GLOBE study of CEO leadership behavior and effectiveness has focused on this aspect (House et
al., 2014)
STYLES
This article makes an attempt to classify published research on leadership styles into seven groups
to compare the leadership styles of Mr. Narendra Modi and Dr. Man Mohan Singh. This framework
is given in Figure 1.
6
1.2.1 Wisdom and experience: The spiritual quality (positive energy) influences us toward
goodness, truth, purity and knowledge through discriminative power of intellect. Knowledge is the
Wisdom is making use of knowledge with an enlightened perspective of the world. There are three
Wisdom
Ethical Intellectual
approach Approach
Values and
Beliefs
Capacity
Strategic building
actions
Achievement
of goals
1.2.2 Strategic actions: Implementation of strategy is very crucial for success. According to
Davenport (2007) creating a brilliant strategy is good but executing it successfully is important. It
is very important for the leader to initiate strategic actions in time to achieve the goals. When the
leadership focus is on achievement of goals, there is emphasis on vision, mission and strategic
actions. Visionary leadership, strategic leadership and managerial leadership styles are more
dominant.
7
1.2.3 Capacity building: Every nation need a skilled, well-educated and competent workforce,
excellent work environment, transparent systems and favorable institutional set up to move on the
path of progress and create opportunities for growth. This can only be achieved through a
streamline of capacity building processes of the individuals, institutional systems and processes,
and a continuous review of environmental factors and policies. When the leadership focus is on
1.2.4 Intellectual approach: Strategy formulation is an intellectual process that comprises two
phases: diagnosis and formulation. It is important for the leader to be able to conceive new ideas
and bring about meaningful change. The strategy formulation process produces a clear set of action
plans to accomplish the goals. Leadership style here can be classified as analytical, creative or
innovative.
1.2.5 Achievement of goals: Achievement of goals is dependent on the use of resources and
capabilities. A leader through his/her leadership style achieves goals by focusing on tasks, projects
or people involved. These styles are very individualistic and are hard to copy by others. Based on
the methods of achievement of goals leadership styles can be described as task-oriented, project-
1.2.6 Ethical approach: The word ethical action comes from theory of Karma from the ancient
Indian text Mimamsa. This theory states that good actions produce good fruit, evil actions
produce evil fruits. Every individual seems necessary to be guided by Karma yoga which holds
that when duty is performed in a spirit of dedication it becomes the cause of emancipation.
Morality, fair play, ethics and justice are the basis of Karma yoga (Adhikary, 2007). Based on the
8
1.2.7 Values and Beliefs: A culture is made up of values and beliefs which are an integral part of
what one chooses to see and absorb (Davenport and Prusak, 2000). It includes a shared perception
of reality, regarding how things are and how things should be. Leadership of an organization is
responsible for the creation and management of its culture. Based on the flexibility in values and
This article uses the above framework to compare the leadership styles of Mr. Narendra Modi and
1.3.1 Wisdom and experience: Dr. Singh joined Indian civil service in 1971 as an economic
adviser in the commerce ministry and later became chief economic adviser in the ministry of
finance. He was the Governor of the Reserve bank of India and the Deputy Chairman of the
planning commission. Though he became a politician in 1991, he continues to rely on his wisdom
Dr. Singh is a system leader as a result of his background in bureaucracy. There are three core
capabilities that system leaders develop in order to foster collective leadership. The first is the
ability to see the larger system. The second capability involves fostering reflection and more
generative conversations. The third capability centers on shifting the collective focus from reactive
Mr. Narendra Modi promises to be a transformational leader. The 'Swachh Bharat' (clean India)
campaign launched by the Prime Minister has sent a message to make the country clean in body
and spirit. .Seth (2008) comments: And what was most impressive was the passion which Modi
exuded. The passion for development. There is however, no question in my mind, that his flaws
apart Narendra Modi today, is truly a transformational leader! And we need many more like him!
9
Even President of America Barack Obama called Mr. Modi Indias Reformer in Chief in his
introduction of Mr. Modi for TIME magazine's list of 100 most influential people.
1.3.2 Initiating strategic actions: Dr Singh was a visionary leader. He initiated lots of actions in
various fields nuclear bill, food security bill etc. It is important for an entrepreneurial leader to
have a good team which can implement his/her ideas effectively. An entrepreneurial leader has the
ability to identify opportunities and initiate actions to benefit from such opportunities (McGrath
and MacMillan, 2000). Unfortunately for him his team was unable to implement these strategic
Mr. Narendra Modi is a strategic leader. This leadership style stresses the competitive nature and
the ability to out fox and outwit the competition. Strategic leaders also have the ability to influence
others to make day-to-day decisions that lead to long-term growth and survival. Hitt et al. (2005)
define strategic leadership as the ability to anticipate, envision, maintain flexibility and empower
others to create strategic change as necessary. Mr. Modi was able to inspire the whole nation into
believing that under his leadership Achhe Din (good days) are not far off.
1.3.3 Capacity building: When we look at the leadership style of Narendra Modi, he comes across
is willing to give more money in the hands of every state to implement welfare schemes based on
their needs. This has been evident in the allocation of nearly 10% more funds to states. He has
abolished Planning Commission and established NITI Ayoga where chief ministers would
Dr Man Mohan Singhs style in capacity building was that of a Mentor/Coach. Even the Japanese
Prime Minister Shinzo Abe playing host to Dr Man Mohan Singh at his official residence in Tokyo
10
1.3.4 Intellectual approach: Narendra Modi comes across as a more innovative leader. He has
been using social media to his advantage and comes out with many innovative ideas to remain in
the national focus. The strategy to build a statue of unity is such an innovative idea. A leader,
who is being criticized as a divisive leader is creating a symbol of national unity in the state of
Gujarat (Business reporter, 2013). He has announced many innovative schemes such as Jan Dhan
Yojana, 'Pradhan Mantri Beema Suraksha Yojana' and 'Atal Pension Yojana'. He has made a
very innovative use of radio by communicating with the nation in his Man Ki Bat.
Dr Man Mohan Singh is a well-recognized economist and provided intellectual leadership to the
who is compassionate and attentive to common people, and as a recognized technocrat (Makta,
2013).
1.3.5 Achieving goals: Mr. Narendra Modi appears to be a project-oriented leader. There has been
a plethora of projects initiated by him with fixed time lines. He has announced creation of 100
smart cities, running of high speed trains and linking of rivers. He has announced a very ambitious
Make in India campaign to generate employment for youth in the manufacturing sector.
Dr. Man Mohan Singh appeared to be a task-oriented leader. Task-oriented leaders prefer to focus
on the tasks at hand in order to achieve the goal. They focus on step by step solution to the issues
and problems at hand (Griffin and Ricky, 2010). He picked up one task after another for legislation,
e.g. the nuclear bill, the food security bill, the land acquisition bill and maneuvered to get them
1.3.6 Ethical approach: Dr. Singh belongs to the classification of virtuous leader (Ahluwalia,
2014). His image of a virtuous person has enabled him to face all the turbulences of his political
11
life. He used his humility and the aura of honesty to face all the storms. It is a miracle that in spite
Mr. Modi is a result-oriented leader. He is not going to be pinned down by the burden of being
nice and gentle. He had been chief minister of Gujarat State for nearly 13 years and there is a
general perception about him that he is a dynamic, decisive and development-oriented leader.
Indian people see a ray of hope due to his focus on development, eye for detail and efforts to bring
1.3.7 Values and beliefs: Dr. Man Mohan Singhs style was an accommodating leader. He
believed in consensus building. Though himself not corrupt he was willing to compromise on his
core values and beliefs to keep the government safe. This accommodating attitude was reflected
even in foreign affairs, defense and other bilateral negotiations which were strategically important
to the country.
Mr. Narendra Modi has an image of an authoritarian leader. Authoritarian leadership is a form of
leadership where one leader typically has complete control over a work area or project. The
authoritative leadership is most advantageous in a crisis situation. The advantages are quick
decisions, close oversight, total control and streamlined work process. In the current crisis situation
which the country is going through, this style is making him more popular among people who are
Table 1 summarizes the comparison of leadership styles of Mr. Narendra Modi (NAMO) and Dr.
Man Mohan Singh (MAMO). They are two very different leadership styles. The MAMO style has
kept Dr. Man Mohan Singh in the Prime Ministers chair for almost 10 years. Mr. Narendra Modi
(NAMO) has his unique leadership style (NAMO) which makes him the front runner for the Prime
12
Table 1: Comparing leadership styles of Mr. Narendra Modi and Dr Man Mohan Singh
1.4 SUMMARY
The purpose of this study was to study individual differences in leadership styles. This article
develops a framework to broad base the leadership styles of individuals. Leaders reveal different
leadership styles while dealing with issues that confront them. Leadership style of a person is a
unique combination of various leadership styles. In this article seven parameters were identified
which combine almost every area of leadership actions. In the process this study has also presented
various leadership styles reported by researchers in this field. This framework was then used to
compare the authentic leadership styles of Narendra Modi and Dr Man Mohan Singh.
Similar framework was developed by Modh (2014) to study the process of conflict
resolution. This framework was based on Satwic, Rajasic and Tamasic guna concept given in the
13
Gita. The characteristics of these three gunas have been explained in detail in the Gita and a couple
of research papers have been published on the subject (Kejriwal and Venkat, 2004; Narayanan and
Krishnan, 2003; Parvinder and Sinha, 1992). The knowledge of this leadership map would also
of a leaders authentic leadership style is critical to its success, at least those who are in key
REFERENCES
Adhikary, Nirmala Mani. (2007). Studying Mass Media Ethics, Kathmandu: Prashanti
Prakashan.
Ahluwalia, S. (2014). Dr. Manmohan Singh: Down but not out, The Time of India Blogs,
http://blogs.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/opinion-india/dr-manmohan-singh-down-but-not-out/
Bass, B. (1985). Leadership and performance beyond expectations. New York: Free
Press.
Bass B.M. and Bass R. (1974). The Bass Handbook of Leadership: Theory, Research, and
Business Reporter (2013). "Modi seeks iron from villages for 'Statue of Unity' | Business
standard.com/article/current-affairs/modi-seeks-iron-from-villages-for-statue-of-unity-
113061101008_1.html>.
14
Carson J.B., Tesluk P.E., Marrone J.A. (2007). Shared leadership in teams: an investigation
Davenport, T. (2007), Strategy Execution: Avoid the Extremes, Harvard Business Review.
/strategy_execution_avoid_the_e.html.
Day, D., Gronn, P. and Salas, E. (2004) Leadership capacity in teams, Leadership
English, F.W. (1992). Educational administration: The human science. New York: Harper
Collins.
Fry L.W (2003). Toward a theory of spiritual leadership. The Leadership Quarterly 14
(2003) 693727
Fry, L.W. (2005). Introduction to the special issue: Toward a paradigm of spiritual
Gelfand, M. J., Erez, M., & Aycan, Z. (2007). Cross-cultural organizational behavior.
Griffin, Ronald J. Ebert, Ricky W. (2010). Business essentials (8th ed. ed.). Upper Saddle
15
Havard A. (2007). Virtuous Leadership: An Agenda for Personal Excellence. New
Competitiveness and Globalization (6th ed.). Cincinnati, Ohio: South-Western Publishing College.
House, R. J., Hanges, P. J., Javidan, M., Dorfman, P., & Gupta, V. (2004). Culture,
leadership, and organizations: The GLOBE study of 62 societies. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
House, R.J., Dorfman P.W., Javidan, M., Hanges, P.J., and Sully de Luque, M.F. (2014).
Howell, J. M., & Shamir, B. (2005). The role of followers in charismatic leadership:
Relationships and their consequences. Academy of Management Review, 2005, 30. 96-112 ,
Ilies, R., Nahrgang, J. D., & Morgeson, F. P. (2007). Leader-member exchange and
John Baldoni (2012). Compromising When Compromise Is Hard. HBR Blog Network -
<http://blogs.hbr.org/cs/2012/10/compromi
meta-analytic test of their relative validity. Journal of Applied Psychology, 89: 755-768.
Kejriwal Aditi and Venkat R Krishnan. (2004). Impact of Vedic Worldview and Gunas on
16
Lewin, K. (1939). Field theory and experiment in social psychology: Concepts and
Lewin, K. and Lippitt, R. (1938) An experimental approach to the study of autocracy and
Lord, R. G., & Hall, R. J. (2005). Identity, deep structure, and the development of
Lowe, K.B., and Gardner, W. (2000), Ten years of the leadership quarterly: contributions
<http://www.civilserviceindia.com/subject/Es
School Press
Modh Satish (2014). Developing a new three energy framework of personality for conflict
analysis and resolution based on triguna concept of Bhagwad Gita. Journal of Human Values, Sage
Mumford, M. D., Friedrich, T. L., Caughron, J. J., & Byrne, C. E. (2007). Leader cognition
in real-world settings: How do leaders think about crises? The Leadership Quarterly, 18, 515543.
17
Narayanan J. and Krishnan V. (2003). Impact of sattva and Rajas Guna on
Transformational Leadership and Karma Yoga. Journal of Indian Psychology, Volume 21, 2, July,
2003.
Puccio G.J., Mance M. and Murdock M.C.(2011). Creative Leadership: Skills That Drives
Russel, R.F. and Stone, A.G. (2002). A review of servant leadership attributes:
developing a practical model, Leadership & Organization Development Journal, Vol. 23 Issue:
3, pp.145 157
Senge P., Hamilton H., and John K. (2015).The Dawn of System Leadership. Stanford
of_system_ leadership)
Seth Suhel (2008). Why India needs Narendra Mody?, The Financial Express, October
needs-narendra-modi-/375103
18
Spinelli, R. (2006). The Applicability of Bass's Model of Transformational, Transactional,
and Laissez-Faire Leadership in the Hospital Administrative Environment. Hospital Topics, 84(2),
11-18.
Tony Dungy (2010). The Mentor Leader: Secrets to Building People and Teams That Win
Vijayan, Vipin. (2013). "Abe hosts dinner for 'dear friend and mentor' Dr Singh -
<http://www.rediff.com/news/report/abe-hosts-dinner-for-dear-friend-and-mentor-dr-
singh/20130529.htm>.
19