Professional Documents
Culture Documents
org::ViewtopicCalculatingSloshing(Convective)SeismicForceonaTank
www.sefindia.org
STRUCTURALENGINEERINGFORUMOFINDIA[SEFI]
Search
www.sefindia.orgForumIndex>SEFIGeneralDiscussion
Viewprevioustopic::Viewnexttopic
Author Message
mishijoshi Posted:TueMay21,20137:50amPostsubject:CalculatingSloshing(Convective)SeismicForceona
SEFIMember Tank
HiAll,
IamtryingtocalculatetheseismicforcesonatankduetosloshingeffectperASCE705(Chapter
15).FollowingthroughtheprocedureIneedtoknowTi(fundamentaltimeperiodofthetankand
impulsivecomponents).IcouldnotfigureoutawaytogettothisTi.Thetankunderconsiderationis
Joined:24Sep2009 notaconventionaltanksupportedoncolumnsoratowersothatIcouldjustusespring&lumped
Posts:11 massanalogytocalculateTi,neitheritisagroundsupportedtank.Itisaverticalcylindricaltank
Location:UnitedStates
withonlyacoupleoffeethighanglelegsanchoredtotheslab.
Also,IwaswonderingabouthowdoIgettotheconvectiveandimpulsivecomponentsoftheweight
?
Anyhelpwiththeaforementionedissuewillbegenuinelyappreciated.
PostedviaEmail
Backtotop
hemant324 Posted:WedMay22,20134:08amPostsubject:CalculatingSloshing(Convective)SeismicForceona
SEFIMember Tank
DearMishi,
ThereisaverygoodReportpublishedbyIITKanpurforGujratStateDisasaterManagementAuthority
titled"IITGSDMAGuidelinesforseismicdesignofliquidstoragetanks".Youcaneasilygetiton
internet.Itcontainsalltheformulationsrequiredandtheirbackground.Thebasisoftheguidelineis
Joined:14Feb2013 ACI350.3.IfyouwanttogettotheverycoreofitandseethesourceofformulationIsuggestyou
Posts:4 readACI350.3howeveryouwillgeteverythingrequired(fundamentaltimeperiodoftankand
impulsivecomponentetc.)foryouranalysisfromtheabovementionedpaperpublishedbyIIT
alongwithsamplecalculation.
Ihaveusedthispaperforseismicdesignofatank16mdiaand6mhighinoneofmyprevious
project.
Hopeithelps..
Regards
Hemant
http://www.sefindia.org/forum/viewtopic.php?p=57514 1/6
3/15/2017 www.sefindia.org::ViewtopicCalculatingSloshing(Convective)SeismicForceonaTank
Backtotop
maheshdabli Posted:WedMay22,20134:10amPostsubject:CalculatingSloshing(Convective)SeismicForceona
SEFIMember Tank
Dear,
Joined:08Feb2010
Posts:9 YouneedtorefertheACI350301Rfrdesigningthetankforhydrodynamiceffect.Inthiscode
thereisastepbystepmethodforcalculatingthehydrodynamicforcesontanksandtimeperiodalso.
Sinceyourtankdonotcomeunderanycategoryyouhavetomakesomeassumptions
forutilizingtheequationsgivenintehACI350.
OnWed,May22,2013at7:28AM,mishijoshi<forum@sefindia.org(forum@sefindia.org)>wrote:
Quote:
HiAll,
IamtryingtocalculatetheseismicforcesonatankduetosloshingeffectperASCE705
(Chapter15).FollowingthroughtheprocedureIneedtoknowTi(fundamentaltimeperiod
ofthetankandimpulsivecomponents).IcouldnotfigureoutawaytogettothisTi.The
tankunderconsiderationisnotaconventionaltanksupportedoncolumnsoratowersothatI
couldjustusespring&lumpedmassanalogytocalculateTi,neitheritisagroundsupported
tank.Itisaverticalcylindricaltankwithonlyacoupleoffeethighanglelegsanchoredtothe
slab.
Also,IwaswonderingabouthowdoIgettotheconvectiveandimpulsivecomponentsofthe
weight?
Anyhelpwiththeaforementionedissuewillbegenuinelyappreciated.
PostedviaEmail
Backtotop
mishijoshi Posted:WedMay22,20134:22amPostsubject:RE:CalculatingSloshing(Convective)SeismicForce
SEFIMember onaTank
ThanksalotHemant.
IwillrefertothereportyoumentionedandACI350.3.
Thanksagainforyourguidanceonthis,Ireallyappreciateit.
Joined:24Sep2009 _________________
Posts:11
Location:UnitedStates
Regards,
MishiJoshi,P.E.
StructuralEngineer
Backtotop
Jeet_mbm Posted:WedMay22,20134:23amPostsubject:CalculatingSloshing(Convective)SeismicForceona
GeneralSponsor Tank
ErMishiJoshi,
Itwouldbebetterifyouattach,roughsketchoftankelevationforbetterunderstanding.
Anywaysifyouaregenerating3Dmodelofthetank,thenfortankemptycaseyoucancalculate
timeperiodbyapplyingunitpointloadinlateraldirectionattipofthetankandmeasuringrespective
deflectionatthatpoint.Theratioofpointloadtodeflectionwillgiveyourequiredtimeperiodinempty
state.
http://www.sefindia.org/forum/viewtopic.php?p=57514 2/6
3/15/2017 www.sefindia.org::ViewtopicCalculatingSloshing(Convective)SeismicForceonaTank
Whetherweneedtousedifferenttimeperiodincaseoftank(fullstage)IthinkSeniorSEFI
memberscangivebetterexplanation.
Joined:26Jan2010 WithRegards
Posts:58
Location:DelhiNCR
JitendraSharma
Backtotop
mishijoshi Posted:WedMay22,20135:31amPostsubject:CalculatingSloshing(Convective)SeismicForceona
SEFIMember Tank
ThanksalotMahesh!!IhaveACI350handynow.
PostedviaEmail
Joined:24Sep2009
Posts:11
Location:UnitedStates
Backtotop
tukaram.patade Posted:WedMay22,20135:39amPostsubject:
SEFIMember
Hi,
Joined:25Feb2013
PleasegothroughAPI650alsowhichisusedbyMechanicalguysforDesignofweldedstoragetank.
Posts:2
Inthisonechapteristheretoworkoutthissloshingeffectduetoseismic.
Hopethiswillhelp.
Backtotop
ibarua Posted:WedMay22,201310:45amPostsubject:CalculatingSloshing(Convective)SeismicForceon
GeneralSponsor aTank
22ndMay2013
IS:18931984gaveaprocedureforcomputingsloshingeffects,butthathasnowbeensupersededby
therevisionofthatCodein2002.YoumayliketocheckthelatestIS:18932002fordetails.Dr
SudhirJainhaddonesomeworkinthisarea.Youmayreferthemattertohimforbetterguidance.
Joined:26Jan2003
Posts:1039
IndrajitBarua.
From:mishijoshi<forum@sefindia.org>
Sent:Wed,22May201307:29:50
To:general@sefindia.org
Subject:[SEFI]CalculatingSloshing(Convective)SeismicForceonaTank
HiAll,
IamtryingtocalculatetheseismicforcesonatankduetosloshingeffectperASCE705(Chapter
15).FollowingthroughtheprocedureIneedtoknowTi(fundamentaltimeperiodofthetankand
impulsivecomponents).IcouldnotfigureoutawaytogettothisTi.Thetankunderconsiderationis
notaconventionaltanksupportedoncolumnsoratowersothatIcouldjustusespring&lumped
massanalogytocalculateTi,neitheritisagroundsupportedtank.Itisaverticalcylindricaltank
withonlyacoupleoffeethighanglelegsanchoredtotheslab.
Also,IwaswonderingabouthowdoIgettotheconvectiveandimpulsivecomponentsoftheweight
?
Anyhelpwiththeaforementionedissuewillbegenuinelyappreciated.
http://www.sefindia.org/forum/viewtopic.php?p=57514 3/6
3/15/2017 www.sefindia.org::ViewtopicCalculatingSloshing(Convective)SeismicForceonaTank
PostedviaEmail
Backtotop
ibarua Posted:WedMay22,201311:03amPostsubject:CalculatingSloshing(Convective)SeismicForceon
GeneralSponsor aTank
22ndMay2013
Thedocumentis:
IITKGSDMAGuidelinesforSeismicDesignofLiquidStorageTanks.
Joined:26Jan2003
Posts:1039 Thefileisattached.
IndrajitBarua
From:mishijoshi<forum@sefindia.org>
Sent:Wed,22May201307:29:50
To:general@sefindia.org
Subject:[SEFI]CalculatingSloshing(Convective)SeismicForceonaTank
HiAll,
IamtryingtocalculatetheseismicforcesonatankduetosloshingeffectperASCE705(Chapter
15).FollowingthroughtheprocedureIneedtoknowTi(fundamentaltimeperiodofthetankand
impulsivecomponents).IcouldnotfigureoutawaytogettothisTi.Thetankunderconsiderationis
notaconventionaltanksupportedoncolumnsoratowersothatIcouldjustusespring&lumped
massanalogytocalculateTi,neitheritisagroundsupportedtank.Itisaverticalcylindricaltank
withonlyacoupleoffeethighanglelegsanchoredtotheslab.
Also,IwaswonderingabouthowdoIgettotheconvectiveandimpulsivecomponentsoftheweight
?
Anyhelpwiththeaforementionedissuewillbegenuinelyappreciated.
PostedviaEmail
Warning:Makesureyouscanthedownloadedattachmentwithupdatedantivirustoolsbeforeopeningthem.
Theymaycontainviruses.
Useonlinescannershereandheretouploaddownloadedattachmenttocheckforsafety.
Elevated_Tankdesign.pdf
Description:
Filename: Elevated_Tankdesign.pdf
Filesize: 1.83MB Download
Downloaded: 939Time(s)
Backtotop
MusaibPatel Posted:WedMay22,20136:34pmPostsubject:CalculatingSloshing(Convective)SeismicForceona
SEFIMember Tank
DearIndrajitsir,
Joined:05Jan2013 BelowmentionedseismicguidlinesisforElevatedtankandtankrestingonthegroundonly.
Posts:2 Isthereanyguidelinesoranyreferenceforundergroundtankofsize100x40metre.
Regards,
MhPatel,On22May20136:16PM,"ibarua"<forum@sefindia.org(forum@sefindia.org)>wrote:
Quote:
22ndMay2013
Thedocumentis:
IITKGSDMAGuidelinesforSeismicDesignofLiquidStorageTanks.
http://www.sefindia.org/forum/viewtopic.php?p=57514 4/6
3/15/2017 www.sefindia.org::ViewtopicCalculatingSloshing(Convective)SeismicForceonaTank
IITKGSDMAGuidelinesforSeismicDesignofLiquidStorageTanks.
Thefileisattached.
IndrajitBarua
From:mishijoshi<forum@sefindia.org(forum@sefindia.org)>
Sent:Wed,22May201307:29:50
To:general@sefindia.org(general@sefindia.org)
Subject:[SEFI]CalculatingSloshing(Convective)SeismicForceonaTank
HiAll,
IamtryingtocalculatetheseismicforcesonatankduetosloshingeffectperASCE705
(Chapter15).FollowingthroughtheprocedureIneedtoknowTi(fundamentaltimeperiodof
thetankandimpulsivecomponents).IcouldnotfigureoutawaytogettothisTi.Thetank
underconsiderationisnotaconventionaltanksupportedoncolumnsoratowersothatI
couldjustusespring&lumpedmassanalogytocalculateTi,neitheritisagroundsupported
tank.Itisaverticalcylindricaltankwithonlyacoupleoffeethighanglelegsanchoredtothe
slab.
Also,IwaswonderingabouthowdoIgettotheconvectiveandimpulsivecomponentsofthe
weight?
Anyhelpwiththeaforementionedissuewillbegenuinelyappreciated.
PostedviaEmail
Backtotop
www.sefindia.orgForumIndex>SEFIGeneral AlltimesareGMT
Discussion Gotopage1,2Next
Page1of2
Jumpto: SEFIGeneralDiscussion Go
Translation: Translatetopic Go
Youcannotpostnewtopicsinthisforum
Youcannotreplytotopicsinthisforum
Youcannotedityourpostsinthisforum
Youcannotdeleteyourpostsinthisforum
Youcannotvoteinpollsinthisforum
Youcannotattachfilesinthisforum
Youcandownloadfilesinthisforum
http://www.sefindia.org/forum/viewtopic.php?p=57514 5/6
3/15/2017 www.sefindia.org::ViewtopicCalculatingSloshing(Convective)SeismicForceonaTank
2003,2008SEFINDIA,IndianDomainRegistration
http://www.sefindia.org/forum/viewtopic.php?p=57514 6/6