Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Democracy
Robert Dahl Polyarchy (1971) has the following procedural minimal
attributes:
1. Officials have to be elected;
2. Free and fair elections;
3. Universal suffrage;
4. Almost everyone had the right to run for office;
5. Freedom of expression free press;
6. Alternative information is available;
7. Freedom to form associations.
Attributes 5-7 refer to political and social freedoms that are minimally
necessary during and between elections for elections to be fair and
competitive.
ODonnell
10. The tenure of elected officials should not be arbitrarily terminated
before the end of their constitutionally mandated term;
1
11. There should be a generalized expectation that the electoral
process and its surrounding freedoms will continue into an
indefinite future.
2
According to Juan Linz and Alfred Stepan, a consolidated democracy has the
following features:
1. A vibrant civil society based on freedom of association and
communication;
2. Free and fair universal elections with universal citizen participation;
3. The rule of law or constitutionally established, broadly accepted
and obeyed legal culture;
4. A modern state apparatus with a monopoly of legitimate force
based on rational-legal norms capable of regulating society and
economy; and
5. A market economy in which the state moderates social and
economic needs.
Civil society
Alfred Stepan: Civil society is that arena where manifold social
movements...and civic organizations from all classes...attempt to constitute
themselves in an ensemble of arrangements so that they can express
themselves and advance their interests
Larry Diamond: Civil society represents the realm of social life that is open,
voluntary, self-generating, at least partially self-supporting, autonomous
from the state, and bound by a legal order or set of shared values
3
One important critique of civil society is that it has meaning only for a small
privileged section of the population many citizens, because of their socio-
economic status, ethnicity, gender etc, whether or not they form
organizations and associations, tend to be marginalized or even excluded
from the domain of what we call civil society
The debate comes down to whether democracy is more than just about
political relations the minimalists insist that democracy has to be
understood in its political context critics argue that this makes many
democracies simply electoral democracies where all that matters is
4
elections one of the main problems with the idea of substantive or
maximalist democracy is there is no consensus on precisely what kind of
socio-economic conditions must prevail for substantive democracy
Or, for that matter, if the daily lives of the majority is not improving, is it
due to the nature of democracy or other factors (international economic
conditions for example) country A depends on export of copper for its
earnings world copper prices are down and this hurts country A without
economic growth, welfare suffers
Degrees of Democracy
The term degrees of democracy refers to whether there is more democracy
or less democracy the reference is to the quality of democracy, whether
democracy is just formal or procedural or of better quality
5
Democratic Deepening: Horizontal and vertical dimensions of
democracy
The notion of broadening can be understood as the spatial spread of
democracy along three dimensions:
1) Across social groups;
2) Across national territory; and
3) Across different issues.
Broadening has a quantitative dimension in that it reflects democracy as
embodied in the constitution and in laws -- Democratic broadening may
reflect different degrees of emphasis on political, civil, and social rights, and
refers primarily to the spread of these rights and to their explicit recognition
by the state in the forms of laws -- Broadening implies the spread of
democracy from the political arena to the civil and the social domains, from
the urban to the rural areas, and to all individuals and groups
6
We can conceive of democratic deepening along the same three dimensions
as the concept of broadening - the notion of deepening refers to the
substantive meaning of democracy
1) Across different social groups;
2) Across national territory; and
3) Across different issues.
For example, the gap between democracy in theory and practice is more
defined in rural areas than in urban areas - the degree of democracy or
democraticness varies in urban and rural contexts another example:
while political rights can be seen as being consolidated in most of Latin
America, this is not the case with civil and social rights especially for the
poor, indigenous peoples, and women