Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Karl Cassel
ENG 141B Calloway
04/03/14
Word Count: 1,323
Pied Beauty
By Gerard Manley Hopkins
Beautiful Imperfections
illuminates the idea of finding beauty in unique aspects of imperfections in life. Nature plays a
crucial role in the exploration of Hopkinss two-toned aspects within creation. From cows to
trout to landscape, quirks and uniqueness stand out and paint the picture of the value and detail
within each dimension. Hopkins uses a variety of literary devices to help the reader along in their
understanding of the aspects of nature that might not be acknowledged and then points these
things back to their creator, giving Him praise. This poem is extremely relevant in that the all-
powerful, never-changing God of Christianity finds beauty in His creations imperfections and
differentiations. This embrace of imperfection and abnormality speaks a great deal louder when
expressed by a troubled, depressed man in search of worth and meaning in his life.
2
Beginning with the title, Hopkins states the direction of the poem with the word, pied,
meaning, having two or more different colors and continues this throughout as he examines
various parts of nature. From the skies of couple-colour and brindled cow, to the finches
wings and landscape, the texture and visual chaos is given attention (line 2, 4, 5).
Secondly, being an ordained priest, Hopkins frames this poem almost as if it were a prayer,
praising God for his creation of diversity and uniqueness among creation. Due to Hopkinss
religious understanding, this poem is considered to be similar to the Psalms. The Catholic faith,
however, took its toll on Hopkins, leaving him with a tremendous sense of guilt and lack of
motivation resulting in the great delay in the publication of most of his works. These details
within the poem shed insightful light on the tone and the authors view of personal imperfections
and the beauty within. This concept of the authors personal interaction can be seen in line 8
where Hopkins expresses, (who knows how?) in intrigue as to how beauty and diversity came
Next, it should be noted that Hopkins became well known for his use of sprung rhythm in
which the first syllable is stressed and is then followed by any number of unstressed syllables.
This technique lacking true meter was used to imitate natural speech and broke the running
rhythm that was popular at this time. Looking to the rhyme scheme, it can be shown as abcabc,
dbede. This pattern is rather difficult, however, it is concluded nicely with the last line set apart
far to the right. This separation makes the reader briefly pause as they shift their eyes over to
Praise Him which concludes this prayer type of poem (line 11). This also gives a sense of
closure to the reader, as they are reassured of the beauty within imperfection of nature created by
an unchanging God.
3
Hopkins also utilizes inscape and instress within this poem, exposing various two-toned
parts of nature. The inscape examines what makes each facet of nature unique where the instress
shows how they fit together or can be compared and contrasted. For example, For skies of
couple-colour as a brinded cow sheds light on two rather different areas of nature, yet brings
them together by examining their textural colors and pied design (line 2). Metaphors play a role
in Hopkinss writing, as well, including Line 2, which also provides a simile comparing the skies
to cows and their similar textural colors and disorder. The metaphor Fresh-firecoal chestnut-
falls follows in line 4 by comparing fallen chestnuts to coals in a fire (line 4). Both of these
metaphors enhance the imagery describing the details within nature, providing more evidence to
Another influential device used by Hopkins is alliteration, particularly with the letter f.
In areas describing nature, such as Fresh-firecoal chestnut-falls; finches wings, the soft f
alliteration represents the gentleness of beauty within nature (line 4). This underlying gentleness
is unique because so often nature is portrayed as harsh and untamed, but in this case, the peace
and calmness of nature is the aspect of beauty being communicated by Hopkins. Continuing,
Hopkins uses three sets of contrasting words, swift, slow; sweet, sour; adazzle, dim to enhance
his message of embracing differences and celebrating the beauty between them (line 9). These
contrasts between the opposite aspects of nature are fairly common, however, when brought
together and strung in succession, Hopkinss two-toned approach to the complexities of nature
becomes that much more apparent and effective in demonstrating the beauty in each.
among his ever-changing creation. Line 8 explains the fickle, changing, diverse nature of
creation. Then He fathers-forth whose beauty is past change explains that this fickleness,
4
chaos, and change among creation is held fast by a never-changing God who is steadfast now,
has been since before time, and will be for eternity (line 10). Hopkins then calls the reader to
Praise Him, the creator, as a conclusion to his prayer (line 11). The beauty of language is
exposed through Hopkinss expression of literary devices in this poem and the way he laces them
In response to this poem, a question is still posed: Is there truly beauty in imperfection?
As Christians, there should be no doubt to this question whatsoever. For my best friend, Jeremy,
this question was interpreted slightly differently. Being diagnosed with Muscular Dystrophy and
confined to a wheelchair at an early age, Jeremy, learned what real life, physical imperfection
was like. His handicap was the dapple part of his life that he proved to others would not hold
him back which was beauty in itself. Not for a second did this impairment bring him to
discouragement. One of Jeremys lasting legacies was the unchanging smile he put on everyday.
This was the light of Jesus Christ, who Jeremy had accepted, and showed to everyone he came in
contact with. His health was always changing, just as the chaos in nature does, but Jeremy held
close to the steadfast God who created nature and created him.
My friends life parallels this poem because he was a little different than most of the kids
of our grade school class. His iron chariot, however, was the detail that most considered an
imperfection, but Jeremy considered a tool. This tool allowed him to grab peoples attention and
show that whether his day was good or bad, or he was sick or healthy, or tired or strong; the God
In conclusion, Pied Beauty works to provide the reader with different views of various
aspects of nature that are unique and often over-looked. Within these different aspects of nature,
Hopkins sheds light on their differences, explaining their beauty because of them. God shows his
5
power through the intricacies and details as well as the vast differentiation of nature. Hopkins
appreciates these details and even expresses his own wonder within the poem. The literary
devices displayed by Hopkins provide unique insight to the different levels of variation and
complexity in nature from the sky, to the landscape, to the rose-moles all in stipple upon trout
Too often, the details of life can be looked past or not appreciated. It takes an acute sense
of observation to determine the oddities of nature and find the beauty within them. Hopkins
brilliantly attributes these differentiations in nature that are ever changing to a God who is never
changing. There can be no shortage of praise for that fact, which Hopkins reminds the reader as
he concludes. Perhaps the question now moves from Is there truly beauty in imperfection? to
Where is true beauty in imperfection? This fallen world is filled with abnormalities and
oddities, so to praise the beauties within them, as Hopkins does, are truly a skill worth
developing.