Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1AC
Contention 1 is Femicide
China is currently undergoing systematic eradication of
its female population- the femicide scale is massive and
embedded within their two child policy. Diplomatic
negotiation is the only way to solve
Smith 16
(Chris, U.S. Congressman for New Jerseys 4th district, U.S.
Commission on China Hearing Addresses Gendercide in China,
February 3, 2016 http://chrissmith.house.gov/news/documentsingle.aspx?
DocumentID=398695)
The global crisis of missing girls constitutes a gross human rights abuse
which is aptly described as gendercidethe extermination of the girl child in
society simply because she happens to be a girl. Gendercide is not only a
predictable tragedy of lost potential, but also a demographic time bomb,
particularly in China, with social, political, and potentially even security
implications, said Smith. China faces some of the worlds most severe gender imbalancesaccording to official
estimates, there are currently 34 million more males than females in China. As the author of the Trafficking Victims
Protection Act of 2000Americas landmark law to combat sex and labor traffickingI am deeply concerned that
China has become the human sex trafficking magnet of the world.
We have seen a marked increase of women trafficked from
neighboring Southeast Asian countries such as Vietnam, Myanmar,
and Cambodia being trafficked into China as brides and for sexual
exploitation. North Korean women who escape into China also
remain at risk for human trafficking for forced marriages and forced
labor. Chinas gender imbalances are significantly exacerbated by
government policyparticularly its draconian population control policies. Click here to read Cong. Smiths
opening remarks. The hearing, entitled Gendercide: Chinas Missing Girls, was held in the Congressional-Executive
Commission on China (CECC), which Congressman Smith chairs with Senator Marco Rubio of Florida. The hearing included
expert witnesses including Chai Ling, the Founder of All Girls Allowed and a former leader of the Tiananmen Square
student demonstrations; Mara Hvistendahl, journalist and author of the Pulitzer Prize finalist book Unnatural Selection:
Choosing Boys Over Girls, and the Consequences of a World Full of Men; and Julie Ford Brenning, the Director of Research
& China Outreach for the organization, Give Her Life. The witnesses offered both analysis of the problem and
recommendations to combat this problem as well as lessons learned from other countries which have struggled with
gender imbalances either as a result of cultural preference or government policy. In her testimony Chai Ling said,
Chinas population problem is not too many babies are being born, but too few
babies being born, especially too few baby girls are being born. There is a
severe cost for low birth rate All the facts and data point to the
clear conclusion that the brutal and unwise Two Children Policy
needs to come to an end and be replaced by an all children allowed
policy as soon as possible, for the sake of China, the people, the
Chinese government and the countryGendercide is the largest
injustice on earth today. We also urge the U.S. leaders,
Congressional leaders, President Obama, business, education,
womens rights and faith community leaders, presidential hopefuls
and all to help us end this evil. Said Hvistendahl in her testimony, We have
historical amnesia. Western institutions played a critical role in bring
sex selection to Asia. And yet, I cant tell you how many reports Ive
read that blame sex selection squarely on traditional values. As a
major international issue, afecting South Asia and Eastern Europe
as well as China, sex selection demands an international response.
Moreover, as the entity responsible for the population control policies
that contribute to the preponderance of boys being born, the Chinese
government cannot be expected to solve its sex-ratio problem without
international pressure. Said Brenning in her testimony, We all know that the consequences of the
skewed sex ratio are well documented. It is now vital to address the policy
implications and how to implement successful government initiatives
that will get to the roots of the sex ratio imbalance. It is only by
recognizing the importance of the empowerment of women, as an
end in itself and as a key to improving the quality of life for
everyone both men and women - that China will achieve a more long-lasting and effective means of
achieving balanced sex ratio.
Egan 15
After years of explosive expansion, China is cooling off. Growth has fallen to
its lowest level since 2009, and investors believe it might be even worse
because Beijing may be fudging the official numbers. China is now the second
biggest economy in the world. The fear is that China will pull other major
economies -- including the U.S. -- down with it. That would be scary given
how slowly the global economy is currently growing and how little ammo
governments have left to jump start business. "We need all the growth we
can get. A slowdown in China wouldn't help ," said David Joy, chief market strategist
at Ameriprise Financial. Investors around the world went on high alert when China's
stock market began to crumble in late June and early July, causing prices for
oil, gold and copper to tumble. Chinese equities stabilized for a few weeks after massive
government intervention but the rout resumed Monday, with stocks slumping 8.5%. Foreign trade is
the most direct link between the U.S. and China . Over the next two years,
U.S.-China trade is projected to surpass U.S.-Canada trade as the largest in
the world, according to State Street Global Advisors. But if China slows drastically, it will
lose its appetite for foreign products, including those made in America.
Pockets of the U.S. stock market are exposed to China's troubles. That's
because 40% of the revenue generated by S&P 500 companies comes from
overseas. A faster deceleration of growth in China would disproportionately
hurt multinational companies. Just last week, United Technologies (UTX) dimmed its 2015
outlook and pinned the blame on China. The manufacturer said new equipment orders at its Otis elevator
business experienced a 10% tumble last quarter in China alone. China's economic growth has
partially been fueled by an explosion of debt. Now that its economy is
slowing, there are concerns about toxic loans could trigger a financial crisis
there that could spread around the globe -- much like what happened in 2008
with bad U.S. mortgages. "A financial panic...could potentially plunge the
world into recession, particularly if it spread throughout Asia ," said George Hoguet,
global investment strategist at State Street Global Advisors. Even if China's problems stay
mostly within its own borders, it's clear the turmoil has changed the way
investors look at the country. Chinese equities skyrocketed 150% during the
12 months before June 12. Then they crashed by 32%, spooking investors
who feared it was a signal of deeper economic trouble . The run up in Chinese stocks
was fueled by debt, heavy speculation and state-run media promoting stock buying. Regulators in China
rushed to save the stock market. They rolled out a series of heavy-handedmoves that helped stabilize
financial markets. However, those aggressive actions may have a chilling effect on
investors who had hoped Beijing was making its markets more free.
A 2010 Census found that 74 percent of women worked overall, but in more
urban areas, only 60.8 percent of women work. Women work less than men
because employers hire a disproportionate number of men , when layoffs and
occur, women tend to get pink slips first , says Leta Hong Fincher, author of "Leftover
Women," which tracks a resurgence in social and economic discrimination
against women in China.
1AR Internal Link: CEDAW K2 Economic Rights
CEDAW is k2 improving womens economic rights
International Journal of Constitutional Law 8
(Committee dedicated to advancing the study of international and comparative constitutional law, Gender
and democratic citizenship: the impact of CEDAW http://icon.oxfordjournals.org/content/10/2/512.full#fn-47)
The Committee has considered the relationship between gender and economic
development: seeking information and expressing concern about the impact on women
of economic crisis, structural adjustment programs , observing that economic growth and development may not
benefit women as much as men. It has requested states to ensure that all poverty alleviation programs
fully benefit women to enhance monitoring of the impact of economic development and
changes on women and to take proactive and corrective measures, including increasing
social spending, so that women can fully and equally benefit from growth and poverty
reduction. The Committee has also welcomed the introduction of microcredit or
microenterprise schemes that facilitate women's independence through enhancement of
their economic self-sufficiency. It has expressed concern about women's poverty and
social exclusion, which have been exacerbated by the global downturn from 2008. The
Committee has linked sustainable development with people-centered human development, based on equality and equity,
participation of government and civil society, transparency and accountability in governance.
another Rwanda looms." However, by describing the responsibility to protect in terms of U.N. action, the World Summit
failed to address a critical issue: What can and should be done by individual states if the United Nations fails to fulfill its pledge? The answer to
this question will inform the scope of permissible unilateral action, with implications for future humanitarian interventions and military actions.
This Comment argues that the Summit agreement strengthens the legal justification for
limited forms of unilateral and regional actionincluding military actionif the
United Nations fails to act to protect populations from genocide and other atrocities. The Summit
agreement strengthens the justification for unilateral action in two main ways. First, the agreement affirms
*Note on this card: if the other team brings up that the UN was ineffective in
Rwanda, point out that this summit occurred as a response to the failures in
Rwanda so the UN learns from its mistakes
In China, women
The statistics tell an important story. Here in the United States women own about 30 percent of small businesses, which generate more than $1 trillion a year in sales.
make up some 25 percent of all entrepreneurs , numbers will continue to and these
boost GDP worldwide by up to 12 percent by 2030. Im a big believer that investing in women is good social policy because
women, on average, devote a larger share of their income to the education and health of their families. That yields important dividends today, but it also lays a solid it also lays solid groundwork for the next
and the empowerment of women and girls a priority in the new Sustainable
Development Goals and the Financing for Development Framework. We look
forward to working with China to ensure these agreements reflect the
importance of including women as key drivers of economic growth.
postmodern or postcolonial circumstances.(1) Theory that does not investigate or even notice the
omnipresence of militarism cannot represent or address the depth and
specificity of the everyday effects of militarism on women, on people living in
occupied territories, on members of military institutions, and on the
environment. These effects are relevant to feminists in a number of ways because military practices and institutions
help construct gendered and national identity, and because they justify the
problematic because they distract attention from the need for sustained
resistance to the enmeshed, omnipresent systems of domination and
oppression that so often function as givens in most people's lives. Neglecting
the omnipresence of militarism allows the false belief that the absence of
declared armed conflicts is peace, the polar opposite of war. It is particularly easy for those
whose lives are shaped by the safety of privilege, and who do not regularly encounter the realities of militarism, to maintain this false belief.
The belief that militarism is an ethical, political concern only regarding armed
conflict, creates forms of resistance to militarism that are merely exercises in
crisis control. Antiwar resistance is then mobilized when the "real" violence
finally occurs, or when the stability of privilege is directly threatened, and at
that point it is difficult not to respond in ways that make resisters drop all
other political priorities. Crisis-driven attention to declarations of war might
actually keep resisters complacent about and complicitous in the general
presence of global militarism. Seeing war as necessarily embedded in
constant military presence draws attention to the fact that horrific, state-
sponsored violence is happening nearly all over, all of the time, and that it is
perpetrated by military institutions and other militaristic agents of the state.
Moving away from crisis-driven politics and ontologies concerning war and
military violence also enables consideration of relationships among seemingly
disparate phenomena, and therefore can shape more nuanced theoretical
and practical forms of resistance. For example, investigating the ways in
which war is part of a presence allows consideration of the relationships
among the events of war and the following: how militarism is a foundational
trope in the social and political imagination; how the pervasive presence and
symbolism of soldiers/warriors/patriots shape meanings of gender; the ways
in which threats of state-sponsored violence are a sometimes
invisible/sometimes bold agent of racism, nationalism, and corporate
interests; the fact that vast numbers of communities, cities, and nations are
currently in the midst of excruciatingly violent circumstances. It also provides
a lens for considering the relationships among the various kinds of violence
that get labeled "war." Given current American obsessions with nationalism,
guns, and militias, and growing hunger for the death penalty, prisons, and a
more powerful police state, one cannot underestimate the need for philosophical and political
attention to connections among phenomena like the "war on drugs," the "war on crime," and other state-funded militaristic campaigns. I
propose that the constancy of militarism and its effects on social reality be reintroduced as a crucial locus of contemporary feminist attentions,
and that feminists emphasize how wars are eruptions and manifestations of omnipresent militarism that is a product and tool of multiply
oppressive, corporate, technocratic states.(2) Feminists should be particularly interested in making this shift because it better allows
consideration of the effects of war and militarism on women, subjugated peoples, and environments. While giving attention to the constancy
of militarism in contemporary life we need not neglect the importance of addressing the specific qualities of direct, large-scale, declared
postmodern or postcolonial circumstances.(1) Theory that does not investigate or even notice the
omnipresence of militarism cannot represent or address the depth and
specificity of the everyday effects of militarism on women, on people living in
occupied territories, on members of military institutions, and on the
environment. These effects are relevant to feminists in a number of ways because military practices and institutions
help construct gendered and national identity, and because they justify the
problematic because they distract attention from the need for sustained
resistance to the enmeshed, omnipresent systems of domination and
oppression that so often function as givens in most people's lives. Neglecting
the omnipresence of militarism allows the false belief that the absence of
declared armed conflicts is peace, the polar opposite of war. It is particularly easy for those
whose lives are shaped by the safety of privilege, and who do not regularly encounter the realities of militarism, to maintain this false belief.
The belief that militarism is an ethical, political concern only regarding armed
conflict, creates forms of resistance to militarism that are merely exercises in
crisis control. Antiwar resistance is then mobilized when the "real" violence
finally occurs, or when the stability of privilege is directly threatened, and at
that point it is difficult not to respond in ways that make resisters drop all
other political priorities. Crisis-driven attention to declarations of war might
actually keep resisters complacent about and complicitous in the general
presence of global militarism. Seeing war as necessarily embedded in
constant military presence draws attention to the fact that horrific, state-
sponsored violence is happening nearly all over, all of the time, and that it is
perpetrated by military institutions and other militaristic agents of the state.
Moving away from crisis-driven politics and ontologies concerning war and
military violence also enables consideration of relationships among seemingly
disparate phenomena, and therefore can shape more nuanced theoretical
and practical forms of resistance. For example, investigating the ways in
which war is part of a presence allows consideration of the relationships
among the events of war and the following: how militarism is a foundational
trope in the social and political imagination; how the pervasive presence and
symbolism of soldiers/warriors/patriots shape meanings of gender; the ways
in which threats of state-sponsored violence are a sometimes
invisible/sometimes bold agent of racism, nationalism, and corporate
interests; the fact that vast numbers of communities, cities, and nations are
currently in the midst of excruciatingly violent circumstances. It also provides
a lens for considering the relationships among the various kinds of violence
that get labeled "war." Given current American obsessions with nationalism,
guns, and militias, and growing hunger for the death penalty, prisons, and a
more powerful police state, one cannot underestimate the need for philosophical and political
attention to connections among phenomena like the "war on drugs," the "war on crime," and other state-funded militaristic campaigns. I
propose that the constancy of militarism and its effects on social reality be reintroduced as a crucial locus of contemporary feminist attentions,
and that feminists emphasize how wars are eruptions and manifestations of omnipresent militarism that is a product and tool of multiply
oppressive, corporate, technocratic states.(2) Feminists should be particularly interested in making this shift because it better allows
consideration of the effects of war and militarism on women, subjugated peoples, and environments. While giving attention to the constancy
of militarism in contemporary life we need not neglect the importance of addressing the specific qualities of direct, large-scale, declared
In her book, Unnatural Selection, Hvistendahl (2011) recounts how gender imbalances came about through
advocates of population control and the development of technology to determine sex before birth.
Hvistendahl identifies political individuals and organizations that actively supported using abortion for
population control, including aborting primarily female fetuses. In commentary on Hvistendahl's book,
Douthat (2011) states, "For many of these anti-population campaigners, sex selection was a feature rather
than a bug, since a society with fewer girls was guaranteed to reproduce itself at lower rates." Douthat
also noted Hvistendahl's depiction of the "unlikely alliance between Republican cold warriors worried that
population growth would fuel the spread of Communism and the left-wing scientists and activists who
believed that abortion was necessary." Foster (1989) commented on population control as military
strategy: "policymakers must ... employ all the instruments of statecraft at their disposal (development
Abortion
assistance and population planning every bit as much as new weapon systems)" (p. 24).
aimed at female fetuses may be considered by some as an acceptable and
effective weapon. An article in The Economist (2010) discussed societal consequences of gender
imbalance. In China and India, rising crime rates are correlated with the increase in
the ratio of males to females. Specifically, crimes against women such as
rape, prostitution, and sex trafficking are becoming more prevalent. Both the
United States Department of State (Lagon, 2008) and the Chinese Academy
of Social Sciences have identified gender imbalance as a contributing factor
to trafficking and forced prostitution (China Faces Growing Gender Imbalance, 2010).
Thousands of Vietnamese women have been forcibly taken to China,
compelled to work in brothels or sold as wives for Chinese men (Giang, 2002; Linh,
n.d.). Women who are trafficked in India may be required to sleep with not just
one man but "with his brothers as well" (Hvistendahl, 2011, p. 190). This was confirmed by
Vinita Shaw who stated that in Haryana, India, it is a common practice for many brothers to share one
Child marriage is increasing as
woman as their wife (personal communication, July, 22, 2014).
women become increasingly scarce (Burns, 1998; Hvistendahl & Lindquist, 2008). Women
sold to be brides often find themselves in abusive marriages. Among foreign wives
living in Korea, 25% stated they felt physically threatened by their husbands (Foreign Brides Rejuvenate
Forced marriage has become so common in Asia it is
Korea's Aging Society, 2009).
now recognized as a valid reason to petition for political asylum in the United
States (Gao v. Gonzales, 2006). In countries where abortion is a form of
discriminatory violence against unborn females, it appears to have
precipitated even more violence against adult women and girls.
2AC Impact: Ableism
Sexism produces negative efects on female psych
Valenti 15
(Jessica, Staff Writer, Sexism is making women sick, The Guardian, Jan 26,
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/jan/26/sexism-is-making-
women-sick)//jdi-sc
fear and
immediate response to move to the other side of the van or to change my direction, I didnt think twice about it. Its normalized, but it has such an effect on your life women constrain their behaviors every day. This
anxiety that women experience isnt simply anecdotal: women are 70% more
likely than men to experience depression and were twice as likely to have an
anxiety disorder, something Watson, who has a degree in counseling
psychology, says is absolutely related to living with misogyny. Over time,
existing in a state of hypervigilance has a negative impact, and leads to a
higher level of psychological distress, she explained. Watson also pointed out that the impact is much greater on women of color, who live with a different
historical legacy of objectification and sexual violence. Mental health issues are still widely stigmatized, but remain incredibly serious they can be debilitating, lead to serious physical symptoms and increase the risk of self-harm. Watson would
like to see more studies done bigger studies, that pay close attention to the way that sexuality, race and other identities also impact mental health. So would I: we need to identify the link between sexism and mental health with great enough
get or drug we can take to lessen the impact that sexism has on womens
everyday lives. But perhaps recognizing just how sick it is making us and
that the damage it causes runs deep we can start to convince others to take
sexism (and the misogyny behind it) more seriously.
fear
me. I had an immediate response to move to the other side of the van or to change my direction, I didnt think twice about it. Its normalized, but it has such an effect on your life women constrain their behaviors every day. This
take to lessen the impact that sexism has on womens everyday lives.
But perhaps recognizing just how sick it is making us and that the
damage it causes runs deep we can start to convince others to take
sexism (and the misogyny behind it) more seriously.
Internal Link
2AC Public/Private Divisions >
Dehumanization
Lack of clear enforcement mechanisms allows
femininicide to occur with impunity
DoS 15
(US Department of State, China (includes Tibet, Hong Kong, and Macau),
Country Reports on Human Rights Practices for 2015,
http://www.state.gov/j/drl/rls/hrrpt/humanrightsreport/index.htm?
year=2015&dlid=252755)//jdi-tts
Although the family-planning law states that officials should not violate
citizens lawful rights in the enforcement of family-planning policy, these
rights, as well as penalties for violating them, were not clearly defined. By law
citizens may sue officials who exceed their authority in implementing birth-
planning policy, but few protections existed for whistleblowers against
retaliation from local officials. The law provides significant and detailed sanctions for officials who helped
persons evade the birth limitations. The National Health Population and Family Planning Commission reported that 13
million women annually terminated unplanned pregnancies. An official news media outlet also reported at least an
additional 10 million chemically induced abortions were performed in nongovernment facilities. Government statistics on
The countrys fertility rate was
the percentage of all abortions that were nonelective was not available.
far below replacement level, in part due to more than three decades of
coercive population control policies and in part due to economic and social factors. According to the
UN Population Fund (UNFPA), the average fertility rate for women nationwide was 1.6, and in the countrys most populous
and prosperous city, Shanghai, the fertility rate was 0.8. National family-planning authorities were gradually shifting
emphasis from lowering fertility rates to emphasizing quality of care in family-planning practices. UNFPA reported that 87
percent of married couples used contraception but that contraception use was significantly lower in unmarried
relationships. As a direct result, approximately half of abortions occurred among 15- to 24-year-old women. Among
married couples, 72 percent used a reversible method of contraception. Only 1.2 percent of women took oral
contraceptives. A 2013 survey published by the China World Contraception Day Organization showed that more than 68
The national population and family-
percent of women were confused about contraceptive methods.
planning law standardized the implementation of the governments birth-
limitation policies, but it left considerable discretion to provincial authorities
to determine enforcement measures, which varied significantly. The law
grants married couples the right to have one birth and allows couples to
apply for permission to have a second child if they meet conditions stipulated
in local and provincial regulations. During the year the policy allowing couples
to have two children when at least one spouse is an only child remained in
place. Implementing regulations for the amended policy were adopted on a
province-by-province basis. The birth limit was more strictly applied in urban areas. In most rural areas,
couples were permitted to have a second child in cases where their first child was a girl. Ethnic minorities were subject to
less stringent rules. In 2013, 35 percent of families nationwide fell under the one-child restrictions, and more than 60
percent of families were eligible to have a second child, either outright or if they met certain criteria. The remaining 5
percent were eligible to have more than two children.
(Heidi, Staff Writer, Chinese women are killing themselves at astronomical rates: is the
one-child policy to blame?, Life Site, April 3,
https://www.lifesitenews.com/opinion/chinese-women-are-killing-themselves-at-
astronomical-rates-is-the-one-child)
The latest Human Rights Report on China (2010) from the Department of State links the
One Child Policy with high female suicide rates in China: A high female suicide rate
continued to be a serious problem. According to the World Bank and the World Health
Organization, there were approximately 500 female suicides per day in 2009. The Beijing
Suicide Research and Prevention Center reported in 2009 that the suicide rate for females was three times
higher than for males. Many observers believed that violence against women and girls,
discrimination in education and employment, the traditional preference for male children,
birth-limitation policies, and other societal factors contributed to the high female suicide
rate. Women in rural areas, where the suicide rate for women was three to four times higher than for men, were especially
vulnerable. Stop for a minute and think about it: 500 female suicides per day in 2009. Thats
3,500 suicides per week. Fifteen thousand per month; 182,500 suicides per year. If the
rate has remained constant throughout the years, we are looking at millions of females
taking their own lives in a matter of decades.
theories that have been proposed and used to explain the origins of
In the West.
domestic violence and wife abuse are numerous. such as social learning
theory, conflict theory, resource theory. and gender role theory. to name only
a few. Because the subject matter of this article is concerned with wife abuse in socialist China, direct
borrowing or testing one or more of these theories may not be productive. Instead. I will first lay out some
theoretical mechanisms that are potentially important and relevant to understanding domestic violence in
urban Chinese society. Then, based on my theoretical reasoning several empirically testable hypotheses
will be developed. for the institutionalization of wife abuse in Chinese society. Added to the three guides .
three obediences. and four virtues is a patriarchal. patrilineal, and patrilocal
family system that together ensured a subordination of women to men. which
in turn justified a cultural and moral legitimacy for men to abuse women. For
instance, in historical China women were severely abused by the practices of foot-binding, child bride.
forced prostitution. and the husband's as well :5 mother-in-law's maltreatment and beating. Thus ,
from
a cultural perspective. it is not difficult to understand that most of these
abusive acts directed against wives were exculpated in order to enforce
compliance with cultural codes and/or to meet cultural expectations.