Professional Documents
Culture Documents
UNIT II ( Part I)
FUTURE AND FORWARD MARKET
FORWARDS FUTURES
1. Concepts
2. Mechanics
3. Differences ----------- ---------------
4. Features
5. Pricing Estimation
6. Hedging Strategies ----------- ------------
2. Speculators: -
A speculator may be defined as an investor who is willing to take a risk by taking
futures position with the expectation to earn profits. They do not aim to minimize risk but
rather to benefit from the inherently risky nature of future market. Hedgers use the
futures markets for avoiding exposure to adverse movements in the price of an asset
where as the speculators wish to take position in the market based upon such movement
in the price of that asset.
In spot market a speculator has to make an initial cash payment equal to the total
value of the asset purchased whereas no initial cash payment except the margin money, if
any to enter into forward market. Therefore speculative trading provide the investor with
a much higher level of leverage than speculating using spot market. That is why, futures
markets being highly leveraged market, minimum are set to ensure that speculator can
afford any potential losses.
Unlike the hedger, the speculator does not actually seek to own the commodity in
questions. Rather he or she will enter the market seeking profits by offset rising and
declining prices through the buying and selling of contracts.
Positions of Hedgers and Speculators
Parameter Long Position Short Position
The hedger Secure a price now to Secure a price new to
protect against future rising protect against future
prices. declining price.
The speculator Secure a price now in Secure a price now in
anticipation of rising prices anticipation of declining
prices.
3. Arbitrageurs: -
Arbitrage is the process of simultaneous purchase of securities or derivatives in one
market at a lower price and sale thereof in another market at a relatively higher price. For,
Ex: - On maturity if the pepper futures contracts is Rs. 650 per KG and the price is Rs. 642, then
the arbitragers will buyer pepper in spot and short sell futures, there by gaining riskless profit of
650 642 i.e., Rs. 8 Per KG.
Here two markets are spot and futures market. Thus riskless profit making is the prime
goal of arbitragers. Arbitrage keeps the futures and cash prices in line with one another. This
relationship is also expressed by the simple cost of carrying pricing which shows that fair future
prices, is the set of buying the cash asset now and financing the same till delivery in future
market. It is generalized that the active trading of arbitragers will leave small arbitrage
opportunities in the financial market. In brief, arbitrage trading helps to make market liquid,
ensure accurate pricing and enhance price stability. It involves profits from relative miss -
pricing.
CLASSIFICATIONS OF FORWARD CONTRACTS: -
The forward contract can be classified into different categories. Under the forward
contracts (Regulation) Act, 1952, forward contracts can be classified in the following categories.
Hedge Contracts: -
These are freely transferable contracts which do not require specification of a particular
lot size, Quality or delivery standards for the underlying assets. Most of these are necessary to be
settled through delivery of underlying assets except in a residual or optional sense.
Transferable specific delivery (TSD) contracts:-
These forward contracts are freely transferable from one party to other party. These are
concerned with a specific and predetermined consignment or variety of the commodity. There
must be delivery of the underlying asset at the expiration. It is mandatory provision of the
forward contracts (Regulation) Act, 1952, but the central government has the power to exempt
(in specified cases) such forward contracts.
Non - Transferable specific delivery (TSD) contracts:-
These contracts are normally exempted from the provision of regulation under forward contract
act, 1952 but the central government the right to bring them back under the act when it feels
necessary. These are contracts which cannot be transferred to another party. The contracts, the
consignment lot size and quality of underlying asset are required to be settled at expiration
through delivery of the assets.
Conditions: -
1. if (F) > (S I) * ert the investor can earn the profit by buying the asset and shorting a
forward contract on the asset,
2. If (F) < (S I) * ert an arbitrageur can earn the profit by shorting the asset and taking a
long position in a forward contract. Further if there is no short sale, the arbitrageur who
owns the asset will find it profitable to sell the asset and go long forward contract.
iii. Forward price where the income is a known dividend yield: -
A known dividend yield means that when income expressed as a percentage of the asset
life is known. Let us assume that the dividend yield is paid continuously as a constant annual rate
at q then the forward price of for a asset would be
F = S * e(r-q)t
Conditions: -
1. If (F) > S * e(r-q)t then an investor can buy the asset and enter into a short forward
contract to lock in a riskless profit.
2. If (F) < S * e(r-q)t then an investor can enter into a long forward contract and short the
stock to learn a riskless profit.
Further, if dividend yield varies during the life of a forward contract, the q should be set
equal to the average dividend yield during the life of the contract.
4. Value of a forward contract: -
There is a subtle difference the forward price and the value of a forward contract. The
forward price that has been determined so far is essentially the price that is equally acceptable to
the buyer and the seller and therefore is the price at which the forward contract has zero value at
its inception. If the forward contract had positive value at inception nobody would sell forward
and if a negative value had, nobody would buy forward at its inception; therefore the forward
contract has zero value.
But after some period of time the forward contract would have a non zero value. Suppose
for,
Ex: - An investor bought a three month forward contract two months ago, at a forward price of
113. Let this be the delivery price, as two month elapse, the forward contract now becomes a one
month forward contract. The delivery price specified in the contract of course remains fixed at
113. If the one month forward price is now 115 clear our investor is sitting on a profit.
If he were to enter into a forward contract, it would be at a price of 115, but his existing
contract allows him to buy at 113. The existing contract therefore reduces his cash outgo at
maturity by 2 from 115 to 113. The value of the forward contract is therefore, the present value
of this 2.
In general, the value of a forward contract can be determined as follows,
f = (F K) * e rt
Where,
F = Forward price (Current) of the asset,
K = Delivery price of the asset in the contract,
T = Time to maturity of contract,
r = risk free rate of interest.
Conditions: -
1. In the absence of any income, yield or storage costs, the forward price F = ert * S
f = (F K) * e rt
= (ert * S K) * e rt
f = S K * e rt
2. Asset with known income
f = S I K * e rt
qt
f=S*e K * e rt
Consider a six month long forward contract of a non income paying security. The risk free
rate of interest is 6% per annum. The stock price is Rs. 30 and the delivery price is Rs. 28. Compute the
value of forward contract
F = 30* e 0.06*0.5
= Rs. 30.90
Value of forward contract,
f = (F K) * e rt
Mr. B. Sudheer Kumar, MBA, M.Sc (Maths), Ph.D Page 7
Assistant Professor and Training & Placement Officer,
Dept of MBA, VITS, PDTR,
E Mail Id: - bskmba06@gmail.com, Mobile No: - 09177873363, 09491641832.
FINANCIAL DERIVATIVES
2. Standardization,
3. The clearing house,
1. Exchange: -
All the futures contracts are initiated through a particular exchange when a new
futures contract is developed, an exchange must specify in some detail the exact nature of the
contract of the agreement between the parties. Further, it must specify the underlying asset,
size of the contract, how price will be quoted, where and when delivery will be made and
how the price will be determined.
Each exchange has usually membership organization whose members can be resident
Indians, NRIs, FIIs and Mutual funds. Based on nature of roles performed, futures
derivatives market, participants are
i. Trading member,
ii. Clearing member,
iii. Self clearing member,
iv. Professional clearing member.
Trading member who trades on his own behalf and on behalf of his clients, clearing
member who undertakes to settle his own trades as well as the trades of the other non
clearing members, self clearing member who clear and settle their own trades only,
professional clearing members who perform only clear functions and they do not trade on
their own or on behalf of their clients.
2. Standardization: -
Futures contracts have standardized term set by the exchanges on which these futures
contracts are to be traded. The benefit of the standardized specification is that the trading is
concentrated in just a few contracts resulting in more liquidity of these contracts. Further
standardization also makes it easier to compare future prices. A futures contract specifies
about every aspects of the deal regarding the asset, price limits, futures period, trading hours,
delivery settled etc.,
The Asset: - The first important term of the futures contract is the Underlying Asset. On
commodity futures market, the assets are commodities like food grains, metals, oils, gas and so
on where as on financial futures markets, financial assets like equities, debts, currencies etc., are
the specified assets. Exchange must stipulate the quality and grade of commodity. The issue does
not arise with financial assets, however, features of the assets must specify.
Daily price limits is to prevent large price moments from occurring because of speculative excess.
Positive limits are the maximum number of contacts that a speculator may hold. The purpose of
these limits is to prevent speculators from exercising under influence on the market.
3. The clearing houses:
Every exchange as an affiliated clearing house for the smooth functioning of the futures
trading in the future market. A clearing house is a separate body or a part of the future exchange and has a
number of members known as clearing brokers. Brokers who are not members of clearing houses have to
transact their futures through a member of the clearing house. Thus acting as an intermediary between
mediators and exchange, guarantees performance on futures and options contracts there by eliminating
counter party risk.
Obligation with a clearing House
Pay Money Pay Money
Party A Clearing House Party B
Receive Receive
Shares Shares
Goods
Buyer Seller Obligations without Clearing Houses
Funds
Clearing house does not assume any position the market; it is market in its exposure.
National securities clearing corporation limited (NSCCL) acts as clearing house for deal
globally provide clearing house, NSSCL permits meeting at the individual client level only.
Margins in future trading:
Before entering into a futures contract prospective trader (investor) must deposit some funds with his
broker which serves a good faith deposit. An investor who enters into futures contracts is required to
deposit funds with the broker called a margin.
The exchange set minimum margins but the brokers may require larger margins if they are
concerned about an investors financial situation because they are because ultimately responsible for their
client losses the amount of margins may vary from contract to contract and even broker to broker the
margin may be deposited in different forms like cash, banks better of credit, shares (50% of market
value). Some brokers may simply pay then money market interest rates on their margin account.
However, most of brokers usually do not pay interest on margin in money.
Types of margin:
(1). Initial margin:
It is the original amount that must be deposited into account to establish futures position.
To determine the initial margin, the exchange usually considers the degree of volatility of price
movements in the past of the underlying the asset. The initial margin approximately equals the maximum
daily price fluctuation permitted by the exchange for that underlying asset. For most of the futures
contracts, the initial margin may be5% or less of the underlying assets value. After proper completion of
all the obligations associated with an investors future position, the margin is returned to trader
(3) Maintenance margin:
The investor is entitled to withdraw any balance in the margin account in excess of the initial
margin. However minimum balance in the margin account must be maintained by the investor. This
minimum amount is called maintenance margin. This is normally about 75% of the initial margin.
(4). Variation margin:
It refers to that additional amount which has to be deposited by the traded with the broker to during
the balance of the margin account to the initial margin level.
on the case may be this brings the value of the contract back to zero. In the other words, a futures contract
is closed but and re written at a new price every day.
SETTLEMENT OF FUTURES POSITION:
(Closing a futures position)
There are four ways to close the future position namely physical delivery, cash settlement
offsetting and exchange of future for physicals.
(1) Physical delivery :
One way of liquidating of futures position is by making or taking physical delivery of the
goods/asset. The exchange has provided alternatives as to when, where and what will be
delivered. It is the choice of the party with a short position. When the party is ready to deliver, it
will send a notice of intension to deliver to the exchange the price is settled which is normally
most recent with a possible adjustment for the Quality of the asset and chosen delivery location
after that, the exchange selects a party with an outstanding long position to accept delivery.
(2) Cash settlement / Delivery:
Cash payment is made based an the underlying reference rate such as a short term interest
rate such as a short term interest rate index such euro dollar, time deposits ,municipal bonds
indices futures, certain treasury securities on expiry of the settlement period, the exchange sets
the final settlement price equal to the spot price of the asset an that day. For example suppose an
investor takes long position in near month NSE Nifty futures with deliver price at 3100 on
maturity if the index it at 3200 with near month short at 3225, then the investor gains Rs 100
through cash settlement
3 offsetting position:
This type of settlement is evidenced in 90% of futures settlement worldwide, affecting
an offsetting futures transaction means of the initial position.
The initial buyer (long) liquidates his position by selling (going short) a similar future
contract and initial seller (short) goes for buying (long) an identical contract offsetting is a
process of carrying for word the transaction by changing sides.
HEDGING STRATEGIES WITH FUTURES: -
Risk is not loss rather it is uncertainty about the expectation of a future event (e.g. Fore cast of
tomorrows price) the uncertainty may turn out to be favorable(profit) or loss .Risk is thus a neutral
concept, profit or loss are merely two sides of the same coin called risk. Since hedging eliminates risk, it
follows, that hedging shuts the door closed to profit as well as loss investment is locked at a particular
value and it rather gains nor loss in value from subsequent price changes.
Hedging Vs Insurance:
Hedging is one of the three principal ways to manage risk, the others being diversification and
insurance.
Diversification minimizes risk for a given amount of return (or maximizes return for a given
amount of risk). Hedging elimates both sides of risk the potential profit and potential loss, insurance
resolves risk into profit and loss and eliminates the loss while retaining profit.
Hedging is implemented by adding a negatively and perfectly correlated asset to existing asset
insurance for investment is achieved by buying a put option on the investment.
Diversification and hedging do not have cost in cash but may have opportunity cost insurance on
the other hand, has explicit cost incurred in cash.
Features of Hedging:
The main features of hedging are
1. Hedging means buying and selling futures contracts to offset the risks of changing cash market prices.
2. Firms hedging because of tax advantages the firm managers may benefit from reducing the firm risk.
3. Hedging also is a tool used to offset the market (Systematic) risk of stock profiles.
4. Hedging is extremely important for the proper functioning long term liquidity and open interest of a
futures market. Thus viable futures contract are linked to commercial hedging activity.
TYPES OF HEDGING:
HEDGING
Position Nature
Short hedge: A short hedge (or a selling hedge) is a hedge that involves short position in futures contract.
It means Being short a net sold position or a commitment to deliver etc. Thus the main objective is to
protect the value of the cash position against a decline in cash prices.
Long hedge: A long hedge (or a buying hedge) involves where a long position is taken in a futures
contract. The basic objective is to protect itself against increase in the underlying asset prior to purchasing
Mr. B. Sudheer Kumar, MBA, M.Sc (Maths), Ph.D Page 13
Assistant Professor and Training & Placement Officer,
Dept of MBA, VITS, PDTR,
E Mail Id: - bskmba06@gmail.com, Mobile No: - 09177873363, 09491641832.
FINANCIAL DERIVATIVES
it in either the spot or forward market. A long hedge is appropriate when a firm has to purchase a certain
asset in futures and wants to lock in price now.
Spot Price
Future Price
Future Price
Spot price
Expiry Date Expiry Date
Generally basis is likely to be negative since most assets face a positive net carry as time elapses and
expires date approaches, future price will converge to the spot price since cost of carry will be approach
zero. Otherwise an arbitrage opportunity exists. If the futures price stays above the spot price, we can buy
the asset now and short futures contract (agree to sell the asset later at the future price. Then we deliver
and earn profit. If future price stays below the spot price, anyone who wants the asset should go long on a
future contract and accept delivery instead of paying the spot price.)
HEDGING USING FUTURES:
Futures contracts can be used to hedge a companys exposure to a price of a commodity. A
position in the futures markets is taken to offset the effect of the price of commodity on the rest of the
company business it is important to recognize that a future hedging does not necessarily improve the
overall financial outcome.
There are a number of reasons why hedging using future contracts works less than perfectly in
price.
(i) The asset whose price is to be hedged may not be exactly the same as the asset underlying the
future contract.
(ii) The hedger may be uncertain as to the exact date when the asset will be bought or sold.
(iii) The hedge may require the futures contracts to be closed out well before its expiration date.
Hence, the basic objective of a hedging strategy is to minimize risk or to maximize hedging
effectiveness. While deciding about futures
1. GOING LONG BUY FUTURES:
When an investor goes long that is enters a contract by agreeing to buy and receive
delivery of the underlying at a pre determined price. It means that he or she is trying to get
profit from an anticipated increase in future price. The pay off profile of going long is shown
in below figure
Loss
(i) Situation: Bullish outlook for the market price of the underlying expected to increase.
(ii) Risk: Unlimited as the price of the underlying and hence of futures increase, falls, until it
reaches zero.
(iii) Profit: Unlimited, depends on the upward price movement.
(iv) Break Even: The price of the underlying (on maturity) equal to the futures price
contracted.
2. GOING SHORT SELL FUTURES:
A speculator who goes short that is enters into a futures contract by agreeing to sell and
deliver the underlying at a set price is looking to make a profit from declining price levels. By selling high
now, the contract can be repurchased in the futures at a lower price, thus generating a profit for the
speculator. The pay off profile of going short is shown figure.
Figure:
Profit
Future Price
Stock Price
Loss
(i) Situation: Bearish outlook for the market price of the underlying expected to fall.
(ii) Risk: Unlimited as the price of the underlying and hence of futures increase.
(iii) Profit: Unlimited depends on the downward price movement until price of the underlying
reaches zero.
(iv) Break Even: The price of the underlying (at maturity) equal to the futures price contracted.
3. Long hedging Short spot and long futures:
Hedges where long position is taken in futures contract are known as long hedges a long hedge is
appropriate when a company knows it will have to purchases a certain asset in the future and wants to
lock in a price now. A company that knows that it is known as long hedge. A Long hedge is initiated
when a futures contract is purchased in order to reduce the price variability of an anticipated future long
position. Equivalently a long hedge locks in the interest rate of price of cash
Security that will be purchased in the futures subject to small adjustment due to the basis risk. A long
hedge is also known as an anticipatory hedge because it is effectively a substitute position for a futures
cash transaction. The pay off profile of long hedging is shown in fig:
Stock Price
Loss
Short Spot
The salient features of long hedging strategy in futures.
(i) Situation: Bullish outlook: Prices expected to rise.
(ii) Risk: No upside risk strategy meant to protect against rising markets
(iii) Profit: No profit, no loss in case of price increase loss on the spot position offset by gain on
futures position. In case of price fall, gain on the spot position offset by loss on futures
position.
4. Short Hedging Long Spot and Short futures: -
A short hedge is one that involves a short position in futures contract. A short hedge is
appropriate when a hedger already own an asset and expects to sell it at some time in futures. It
can also used when a hedger does not own an asset right now, but knows that the asset will be
owned at some time in the future. A hedger who holds the commodity and is concerned about a
decrease in its price might consider hedging it with a short position in futures. If the spot price
and futures price move together, the hedge will reduce some of the risk. This is called short
hedge because the hedger has a short position. A company that knows it is due to sell an asset at
a particular time in the future can hedge by taking short futures position. This is known as a short
hedge. The pay off profile of short hedging is shown in figure,
Stock Price
S / F = Q*F / QS
This is most common formula which is used frequently in the futures trading for hedge in order
to achieve the minimum variance hedge.
HR* = Hedge ratio that minimizes the variance of the hedgers position.
In case of perfect hedging (absence of asset miss match and maturity miss match) the hedge ratio
should be one because the future profit or loss matches the spot profit or loss.
If the objective of the hedger is to minimize risk, a hedger ratio is not necessarily optional. The
hedger should choose a value for the hedge ratio that minimizes the variance of the value of the
hedged position.
Optional Hedge ratio: -
HR* = S / F = S / F
If the coefficient of correlation between in spot price during a period of time equal to life
the hedge and change in futures price during a period of time equal to life of the hedge is equal to
1 and standard deviation of change in spot price during a period of time equal to life of the hedge
and standard deviation of change in futures price during a period of time equal to life the hedge
are equal the optimal hedge ratio, HR* is 1.0. This is to be expected because in this case the
futures price mirrors the spot price perfectly.
Variation of Position
HR*
Minimum variance of hedge ratio can be calculated by regression method. This method is
specifically designed to provide the best linear relationship between two prices i.e. future price
and the price to hedge.