Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1 Oct 13
PART IA
GENERAL LEARNING OUTCOME: Upon completion of this lesson, students are
better prepared to operate in a Joint Environment.
SUPPORTED COMPETENCIES/DIRECTIVES:
The Joint Warfighter lesson supports the following AF Institutional Competencies:
1. Employing Military Capabilities Operational and Strategic Art
2. Employing Military Capabilities Unit, AF, Joint, and Coalition Capabilities
3. Employing Military Capabilities Non-adversarial Crisis Response
4. Enterprise Perspective Enterprise Structure and Relationships
The Joint Warfighter lesson supports the following Basic EJPME Learning Areas:
Service in a JIIM Environment (Joint Interagency, Intergovernmental, and
Multinational).
TERMINAL COGNITIVE OBJECTIVE: Comprehend Joint Warfighter concepts.
TERMINAL COGNITIVE SAMPLES OF BEHAVIOR:
1. Explain Joint Warfighter concepts.
2. Give examples of Joint Warfighter concepts.
AFFECTIVE OBJECTIVE: Value Joint Warfighter concepts.
PART IB
ORGANIZATIONAL PATTERN: Topical
LESSON OUTLINE:
CONTENT
INTRODUCTION: Attention, Motivation, and Overview
MP1. Joint Warfighter Challenge
MP2. Joint Interagency, Intergovernmental, Multinational Scenarios
CONCLUSION: Summary, Remotivation, and Closure
OA02SG - 2
PART II
STUDENT READING
As members of the Profession of Arms we are often called upon to defend this country we
are fortunate enough to call our own. We take great pride in defending the homeland and
US interests and are willing to do so by any and all means necessary. However, this does
not mean that we simply make the rules up as we go along. We are provided a playbook,
so to speak, through documents such as Air Force Doctrine and various security strategies
which guide and direct both combat and non-combat operations in which we may become
engaged. Beginning with military theory and shifting into the principles of war, it will
provide a framework of how we engage our adversaries in conflict. Second, it will
examine doctrine and how we use air, space, and cyberspace to meet our objectives.
Finally, it will address the various strategies employed by the United States and conclude
with a look at our range of military operations (ROMO) to include non-adversarial crisis
response. When all of the elements are put together, operational and strategic art is
created. Let us begin in the mind, where ideas and theory begin, specifically, military
theory.
NOTE: Joint Interagency, Intergovernmental, Multinational (JIIM) is the same term as
Joint. When you see Joint, it is also means JIIM and vice versa.
FULL-SPECTRUM OF MILITARY OPERATIONS
1. Full-spectrum of military operations is a military concept whereby a joint military
structure achieves control over all elements of the battlespace using land, air, maritime,
and space based assets. These include the physical battlespace (air, surface and subsurface) as well as the electromagnetic spectrum and information space.
2. The concepts that make up the full spectrum of military operations are Military
Theory, Principles of War, Air Force doctrine, and U.S. Strategy.
A. MILITARY THEORY
1. Military theory can be explained as the scientific, artistic, and philosophical idea or
view relating to principles, methods, rules, and operations of war. Military theory
describes the best way for men to wage war in a universe described by science, and
based on the nature of man in that universe, as described by philosophy.1 Military
theory, which is not subject to the rigors of scientific experimentation, remains invalid
until put to the test in war.
2. It is only after war in which existing military theory has been proven wrong that
new theories are produced. It is fundamental to the scientific method that for a theory
to be invalid there must be the means to prove it wrong. General predictions are used in
theory development, as they are difficult to disprove. In peacetime training, and even in
limited conflicts, it is difficult to sort out the necessary elements of a theory from
fiction because doctrine, technology, and world events (cyber war, the militarytechnical revolution, chaos and warfare, and the now ever-present information war)
seldom present what could be called controlled or anticipated environments for
experimentation.2
OA02SG - 3
OA02SG - 6
ability to leverage our unique national attributes, just as global security depends upon
strong and responsible American leadership. That includes our military might,
economic competitiveness, moral leadership, global engagement, and efforts to shape
an international system that serves the mutual interests of nations and peoples. The
world has changed at an extraordinary pace, and the United States must adapt to
advance our interests and sustain our leadership. To achieve the world we seek, the
United States must apply our strategic approach in pursuit of four enduring national
interests:
a. Security: To attain and maintain the security of the United States, its citizens,
and U.S. allies and partners we must:
(1) Strengthen security and resilience at home
(2) Disrupt, dismantle, and defeat Al-Qaida and its violent extremist affiliates
in Afghanistan, Pakistan, and around the world
(3) Reverse the spread of nuclear and biological weapons and secure nuclear
materials
(4) Advance peace, security, and opportunity in the greater Middle east
(5) Invest in the capacity of strong and capable partners
(6) Secure Cyberspace
b. Prosperity: To ensure a strong, innovative, and growing U.S. economy in an
open international economic system that promotes opportunity and prosperity, we
must:
(1) Strengthen education and human capital
(2) Enhance science, technology, and innovation
(3) Achieve balanced and sustainable growth
(4) Accelerate sustainable development
(5) Spend taxpayers dollars wisely
c. Values: To ensure respect for universal values at home and abroad, we must:
(1) Strengthen the power of our example
(2) Promote democracy and human rights abroad
(3) Promote dignity by meeting basic needs
d. International Order: To ensure international order advanced by U.S. leadership
that promotes peace, security, and opportunity through stronger cooperation to meet
global challenges, we must:
(1) Ensure strong alliances
(2) Build cooperation with other 21st century centers of influence
(3) Strengthen institutions and mechanisms for cooperation
(4) Sustain broad cooperation on key global challenges
OA02SG - 8
Each of these enduring national interests is linked to the others: no single interest can
be pursued in isolation, but at the same time, positive action in one area will help
advance all four. These initiatives do not encompass all of Americas national security
concerns. However, they represent areas of particular priority and areas where progress
is critical to securing our country and renewing American leadership in the years to
come. The NSS gives guidance and direction to the other strategies we have as
Americans, the National Defense Strategy, and the National Military Strategy. Now we
will move one echelon down into the National Defense Strategy.
2. National Defense Strategy: A core responsibility of the U.S. Government is to
protect the American people in the words of the framers of our Constitution, to
provide for the common defense. For more than 230 years, the U.S. Armed Forces
have served as a bulwark of liberty, opportunity, and prosperity at home. The United
States, our allies, and our partners face a spectrum of challenges, including violent
transnational extremist networks, hostile states armed with weapons of mass destruction
(WMD), rising regional powers, emerging space and cyber threats, natural and
pandemic disasters, and a growing competition for resources. The Department of
Defense must respond to these challenges while anticipating and preparing for those of
tomorrow. To succeed, we must harness and integrate all aspects of national power and
work closely with a wide range of allies, friends, and partners.
The National Defense Strategy (NDS) serves as the Departments capstone document in
this long-term effort. It flows from the NSS and informs the National Military Strategy.
It also provides a framework for other DoD strategic guidance, specifically on
campaign and contingency planning, force development, and intelligence. It addresses
how the U.S. Armed Forces will fight and win Americas wars and how we seek to
work with and through partner nations to shape opportunities in the international
environment to enhance security and avert conflict. The NDS describes our
overarching goals and strategy. It outlines how the DoD will support the NSS,
evaluates the strategic environment, challenges, and risks we must consider and maps
the way forward.
Objectives to support the NSS and provide enduring security for the American people,
the DoD has five key objectives:
a. Defend the Homeland
b. Win the Long War
c. Promote Security
d. Deter Conflict
e. Win our Nations Wars
OA02SG - 9
We will achieve our objectives by shaping the choices of key states, preventing
adversaries from acquiring or using WMD, strengthening and expanding alliances and
partnerships, securing U.S. strategic access and retaining freedom of action, and
integrating and unifying our efforts.
3. National Military Strategy: The role of the National Military Strategy (NMS) The NMS derives objectives, missions, and capability requirements from an analysis of
the NSS, the NDS, and the security environment. The NSS and NDS provide a broad
strategic context for employing military capabilities in concert with other instruments of
national power. The NMS is the CJCSs strategic direction for the US Armed Forces
and provides focus for military activities by defining a set of interrelated military
objectives and joint operating concepts from which the Service Chiefs and combatant
commanders identify desired capabilities and against which the Chairman of the Joint
Chiefs of Staff assesses risk.
The National Military Strategy is guided by the Presidents National Security
Strategy and serves to implement the Secretary of Defenses National Defense
Strategy of the United States of America.
The NMS establishes three military objectives that support the National Defense
Strategy:
a. Protect the United States against External Attacks and Aggression
b. Prevent Conflict and Surprise Attack
c. Prevail Against Adversaries
CRISIS RESPONSE/CONTINGENCY OPERATIONS
1. According to Joint Publication 3, Joint Operations, a crisis is an incident or situation
Forces, will participate in that may or may not have an adversary, i.e. war or natural
disaster.5 It is smaller than a campaign or major operation and typically limited in
scope and conducted to achieve a very specific objective.6 Crisis response/contingency
operations focus on deterring war, resolving conflict, promoting peace, irregular
warfare, national disasters, and supporting civil authorities in response to domestic
crisis. These operations may involve elements of both combat and non-combat
operations in peacetime, conflict and war situations.
3. Crisis response/contingency operations can be addressed from two different mindsets
using two different concepts to accomplish the mission, adversarial and nonadversarial, let us explore them now.
OA02SG - 10
Civil Support (CS): DOD support to US civil authorities for domestic emergencies and
for designated law enforcement and other activities.
Emergency Preparedness (EP): Those planning activities undertaken to ensure DOD
processes, procedures, and resources are in place to support the President and SecDef in
designated National Security Emergencies.
OA02SG - 11
A secure US Homeland is the Nations first priority and is fundamental to the successful
execution of the Nations military strategy. It is also essential to Americas ability to
project power, sustain a global military presence, and honor its global security
commitments. The military will continue to play a vital role in securing the Homeland
through the execution of HD and CS missions, as well as Emergency Preparedness (EP)
planning activities. As shown in Figures 1 and 2, HS is not synonymous with HD, nor is
HD, CS, and EP subordinate to HS. On the contrary, although HS, as defined in the
National Strategy for Homeland Security (NSHS), is concerned solely with preventing and
mitigating the effects of terrorist attacks, DODs concern cannot be limited to terrorists.
DOD must address both conventional and unconventional attacks by any adversary
(including but not strictly limited to terrorists). When DOD conducts military missions as
the lead agency to defend the Homeland, this is HD.
DOD has lead responsibility for HD, with other departments and agencies in support of
DOD efforts. Circumstances in which DOD supports the broader federal, state, and / or
local government efforts, as coordinated by and in cooperation with DHS or other
departments or agencies as LFA, are appropriately described as CS. In these cases, DHS
(or another LFA) coordinates activities and DOD is prepared to support the plans that are
developed. In the same way that some aspects of HD are unrelated to HS, some aspects of
DODs CS functions are unrelated to terrorism and do not fall under HS, yet DOD can still
provide other unique capabilities in support of civilian authorities (for example, support for
natural disaster relief).
Similarly, as depicted with the examples in some aspects of HS fall outside the purview of
DOD. These functions (such as airport security measures enacted by the Transportation
Security Administration (TSA)), fall under the lead of DHS (or another LFA).
Ballistic Missile Defense of
North America
DOD Support for natural
Disaster Relief
Airport Security (TSA)
CBRNE Consequence
Management
Mobile Redundant Command
Centers
Aviation Support to Secret
Service for COG
OA02SG - 12
cueing.
Air Interdiction consists of operations to divert, disrupt, delay, or destroy the
enemys surface military potential before it can be used effectively against friendly
forces. Air interdiction is air and space powers application of interdiction. Air
interdiction is a form of aerial maneuver that destroys, disrupts, diverts, or delays
the enemys surface military potential before it can be used effectively against
friendly forces, or otherwise achieve its objectives.
Close Air Support (CAS) provides direct support to help friendly surface forces
in contact with enemy forces carry out their assigned tasks. CAS can provide a
tremendous tactical advantage when supporting ground forces. CAS can halt
attacks, help create breakthroughs, cover retreats, and guard flanks. To be most
effective, however, CAS should be used at decisive points in a battle and should
normally be massed to apply concentrated combat power and saturate defenses.
D. Countersea is an extension of Air Force capabilities into a maritime
environment. The identified specialized collateral tasks are sea surveillance,
antiship warfare, protection of sea lines of communications through antisubmarine
and antiair warfare, aerial minelaying, and air refueling in support of naval
campaigns. As with the air and space functions, countersea operations are designed
to achieve strategic, operational, or tactical level objectives in the pursuit of joint
force objectives.
E. Agile Combat Support (ACS). This is the timely concentration, employment,
and sustainment of U.S. military power anywhere at our initiative, speed, and
tempo that our adversaries cannot match. Agility in combat support is crucial to
meeting the demands of todays rapidly changing environment. Combat support
creates, sustains, and protects all air and space capabilities to accomplish mission
objectives across the spectrum of military operations.
F. Expeditionary Combat Support (ECS) comprises the expeditionary subset of
ACS. ECS includes the essential capabilities, functions, activities, and tasks
necessary to employ and sustain all elements of aviation and ground combat
operations forces in a deployed location.
G. Airlift. The transportation of personnel and material through the air, which can
be applied across the entire range of military operations to achieve or support
objectives and can achieve tactical through strategic effects. Airlift provides rapid
and flexible mobility options that allow military forces as well as national and
international governmental agencies to respond to and operate in a wider variety of
circumstances and time frames. It provides US military forces the global reach
capability to quickly apply strategic power to various crisis situations worldwide by
delivering necessary forces. The power projection capabilities that airlift supplies
are vital since it provides the flexibility to move rapid-reaction forces to the point
of a crisis with minimal delay.
OA02SG - 14
H. Air Refueling is the in-flight transfer of fuel between tanker and receiver
aircraft. Air refueling increases the range, payload, loiter time, and ultimately the
flexibility and versatility of combat, combat support, and mobility aircraft. Air
Force air refueling assets employ to accomplish six missions; nuclear operations
support, global strike, airbridge support, aircraft deployment, theatre support, and
special operations support.
I. Special Operations. The use of special airpower operations (denied territory
mobility, surgical firepower, and special tactics) to conduct the following special
operations functions: unconventional warfare, direct action, special reconnaissance,
counterterrorism, foreign internal defense, psychological operations, and
counterproliferation. The difference between special operations and conventional
operations lies in the degree of physical and political risk, degree of overtness,
operational techniques, mode of employment, independence from friendly support,
and dependence on detailed operational intelligence and indigenous assets. That
setting is one often dominated by high risk and political, environmental, and
operational constraints.
J. Surveillance and Reconnaissance. Surveillance is the function of
systematically observing air, space, surface, or subsurface areas, places, persons, or
things, by visual, aural, electronic, photographic, or other means.
2. SPACE
a. Space power is the capability to employ space forces to achieve national
security. Used effectively, space power enhances Americas opportunities to
succeed across the broad range of military operations. Space power is derived from
the exploitation of the space environment by a variety of space systems. A key
element of space power is the people who operate, maintain, or support these
systems. Space affords a commanding view of operations and provides an
important military advantage. At the level of basic aerospace doctrine, the
principles that govern aerospace operations are the same for air and space.
b. Space consists of three elements: space, terrestrial, and link. The space
element consists of the platforms for which astrodynamics is the primary principle
governing movement. Examples include satellites, space stations, or the space
shuttle. The terrestrial-based element consists of the land, sea, or airborne
equipment used to communicate with and control the space element.
c. The terrestrial-based element also includes the personnel required to operate
and maintain equipment. Examples of the terrestrial-based element include ground
stations, ship borne space communication systems. The link element is the
communication between the space element and the terrestrial element. Examples of
the link element include data link signals. All three elements can be key factors in
military operations.
d. As an integral element of national capabilities, space systems influence
operations throughout the conflict spectrum. Space supports Service, joint, and
multinational operations across the range of military operations, from peacetime
engagement to general war.
OA02SG - 15
OA02SG - 16
OA02SG - 17
(c) Economy. Despite the large initial investments in hardware and lift,
over time some functions are performed more economically from space.
For example, global communications are generally more economical
when operated from space.
(d) Effectiveness. Some activities such as wide area surveillance are more
effective when they are conducted from space. Additionally, the
absence of atmosphere and attenuation provides an optimum operating
medium for future directed energy weapon such as lasers and particle
beams that travel at light speed with great range.
(e) Robustness. Functions accomplished by space-based and terrestrialbased systems, using both air and space assets, provide mutual backup
and complicate hostile attempts to neutralize our overall military
capability.
With our ever-increasing reliance on information technology, it is absolutely vital that we
all take an active role in the protection of our third capability cyberspace.
3. CYBERSPACE
a. Cyberspace touches practically everything and everyone every day. The
security and prosperity of our nation is dependent on freedom of access to and
freedom of action in cyberspace. While there are many benefits that come with this
access, there are numerous inherent vulnerabilities. Threats via cyberspace pose
one of the most serious national security challenges of the 21st Century. The threat
is asymmetrical with a minimal cost of entry; events of the last several years show
that one person, with one computer, can affect an entire nation. Growing arrays of
adversaries are targeting the US military and our critical national infrastructure,
commerce, and citizens. The combined and coordinated efforts of government,
industry and academia will be required to effectively counter many of these attacks
and assure mission success in the future.
b. The significance of USAF operations in cyberspace is readily apparent. Not
only is cyberspace vital to todays fight, it is key to the continued US military
advantage over our enemies, now and in the future. Consequently, the USAF is
steadfastly intent on providing a full range of cyber capabilities to Joint Force
Commanders, whenever and wherever needed. Today, USAF cyber capabilities
range from the virtual to the very real, including critical combat communications
provided to the warfighter within hours upon the arrival of the USAF.
c. As always, USAF Airmen are the core of our mission success; and the civilians
and contract partners of the USAF also play a unique and critical role. Technical
competence alone is not sufficient to meet the challenges of the 21st century.
Airmen must be technically astute, tactically competent, armed with warrior ethos
and equally prepared to deploy forward or operate in place to accomplish the
mission.
d. The significance of USAF operations in cyberspace is readily apparent. Not
only is cyberspace vital to todays fight, it is key to the continued US military
advantage over our enemies, now and in the future. Consequently, the USAF is
OA02SG - 18
highly unlikely that most adversaries will choose to fight the US in a traditional,
conventional manner. Thus, for relatively weaker powers (including non-state entities)
irregular warfare (IW) has become an attractive, if not more necessary, option. IW
presents different challenges to our military and to the Air Force.
1. The Air Forces ability to operate in the air, space, and cyberspace domains
provides our fighting forces with a highly asymmetric advantage over IW adversaries.
Command of the air prevents adversaries from conducting sustained operations in this
domain while allowing US and coalition forces to exploit numerous advantages.
2. While our IW adversaries have their own asymmetric capabilities such as suicide
bombers, improvised explosive devices (IEDs), and the cover of civilian populations,
they lack and cannot effectively offset unfettered access to the high ground that
superiority in air, space, and cyberspace provides. Exploiting altitude, speed, and range,
airborne platforms can create effects without the impediments to movement that terrain
imposes on ground forces.
3. The following definitions highlight some key differences between irregular and
traditional warfare, and conventional and unconventional warfare. Understanding these
differences allows Airmen to have a common frame of reference when discussing these
types of warfare.
a. Traditional warfareA confrontation between nation-states or
coalitions/alliances of nation-states (Joint Publication [JP] 1, Doctrine for the
Armed Forces of the United States). This confrontation typically involves force-onforce military operations in which adversaries employ a variety of conventional
military capabilities against each other in the air, land, maritime, space, and
cyberspace domains. The objective may be to convince or coerce key military or
political decision makers, defeat an adversarys armed forces, destroy an
adversarys war-making capacity, or seize or retain territory in order to force a
change in an adversarys government or policies.
b. Irregular warfareA violent struggle among state and non-state actors for
legitimacy and influence over the relevant populations. This is warfare in which
one or more combatants are irregular military rather than regular forces. Guerrilla
warfare is a form of irregular warfare, and so is asymmetric warfare.
Irregular warfare favors indirect and asymmetric warfare approaches, though it may
employ the full range of military and other capabilities, in order to erode an
adversarys power, influence, and will. It is inherently a protracted struggle that
will test the resolve of a state and its strategic partners. Concepts associated with
irregular warfare are older than the term itself.
Across the range of IW scenarios there is a set of overarching concepts that provide the
foundation for planning and employing Air Force capabilities.
The Air Force must be prepared to simultaneously conduct irregular and
traditional warfare operations. The nature of a single conflict can easily shift
between types of warfare. Failure to understand or anticipate these shifts often
leads to fighting the wrong type of war, or focusing on the wrong effects for a
given conflict.
OA02SG - 20
surprise you and no amount of technology will change that reality. You must also
understand that employment of military force will continue to be conditioned by
politicsthose of the United States, our allies, and our opponents. Therefore, above all,
you must have a clear understanding of the strategic and political goals for which we and
our enemies conduct military operations, how and why were organized to plan and
conduct operations, and because you will find yourself working closely with partners, its
absolutely paramount for SNCOs to have a thorough understanding of U.S. Political goals!
OA02SG - 22
NOTES
1
Pellegrini, Robert P., Thesis: The Links between Science, Philosophy, and Military Theory:
Understanding the Past, Implications for the Future (Air University Press Maxwell
Air Force Base, Alabama. August 1997), 42.
2
Ibid., 20.
Department of Defense. Homeland Defense and Civil Support Joint Operating Concept,
Version 2.0, pg, 5, 1 October 2007.
Ibid. pg, 5.
August 2005, 8.
6
Joint Publication 3. Joint Operations, 17 September 2006, Change 2, 22 March 2010, VI-1.
OA02SG - 23