You are on page 1of 1

The difference between an -ing noun and a real noun

They thought that Tom would bring a big development for this small town.
They thought that Tom would bring a big developing for this small town.

"developing" is not a noun. It's the form of a verb called the gerund, and it has a dual nature; one of a
verb and one of a substantive.
Its verbal nature is shown by:
a) its ability to take a direct and an indirect object.
b) the fact that it can have a subject (I was proud of him being my son).
c)its ability to appear in different tenses (he boasted of his having killed her)
Its substantival nature is shown by:
a) its ability to be the object of a preposition (by doing so)
b) the fact that it can take a plural ending (such going-ons)
c) it can take an attributive adjective (his dangerous driving)
d) its ability to take a definite or an indefinite article (a hanging was once a public amusement)
The active form of a gerund is often used in a passive sense (your hair wants cutting, the garden needs
weeding)
In parallel cases a noun ending in e.g. -ment would normally imply the result of an action, the product
of an action while the corresponding gerund would refer to the action itself. Take for instance
"extension" vs. "extent" or "export" vs. "exportation.
A gerund would normally have in it the verbal nature which the corresponding noun need or does not
have. Compare "The king's arrival was met with much enthusiasm" vs. "We are quite tired of his usual
arriving very late".
In the case of "developing" one might compare "The new president aims at developing the country's
poor-relief system" vs. "The development of AIDS in Africa has proved to be one of the biggest
tragedies in the Third World"
It's not that some verbs have a corresponding noun, but rather that many verbs have many
corresponding gerunds. If they always meant the same thing, we wouldn't need different suffixes.
In other words, there's that phenomenon called blocking. When two ways of creating a word conflict,
the existence of one blocks the other. Since we already have the word development, the process to form
the word developing to mean "development" is blocked.

You might also like