Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Vol.
17, No.
0038-0717/85$3.00+ 0.00
CHLOROFORM
FUMIGATION
AND THE RELEASE OF
SOIL NITROGEN: A RAPID DIRECT EXTRACTION
METHOD TO MEASURE MICROBIAL BIOMASS
NITROGEN IN SOIL
P. C. BROOKES, ANDREA LANDMAN,* G. PRUDEN* and D. S. JENKINSON
Soils and Plant Nutrition Department, Rothamsted Experimental Station, Harpenden,
Her&. AL5 214, U.K.
(Accegted 14 MqJ 1985)
Summary-A new direct extraction method for measuring soil microbial biomass nitrogen (biomass N)
is described. The new method (fumigation-extraction)
is based on CHCI, fumigation, followed by
immediate extraction with 0.5 M &SO, and measurement of total N released by CHCl, in the soil extracts.
The amounts of NH,-N and total N extracted by K,SO, immediately after fumigation increased with
fumigation time up to 5 days. Total N released by CHClr after 1 day fumigation (1 day CHCIr-N) and
after 5 days fumigation (5 day CHCl,-N) were positively correlated with the flush of mineral N (FN) in
37 soils that had been fumigated, the fumigant removed and the soils incubated for 10 days
(fumigation-incubation).
The regression equations were 1 day CHCI,-N = (0.79 & 0.022) F, and 5 day
CHCl,-N = (1.01 & 0.027) F,, both regressions accounting for 92% of the variance in the data.
In field soils previously treated with r5N-Iabelled fertilizer, the amounts of labelled N, measured after
fumigation-extraction,
were very similar to the amounts of labelled N mineralized during
fumigation-incubation; both were about 4 times as heavily labelled as the soil N as a whole. These results
suggest that fumigation~xtraction
and fumigation-incubation both measure the same fraction of the soil
organic N (probably the cytoplasmic component of the soil microbial biomass) and that measurement of
the total N released by CHCI, fumigation for 24 h provides a rapid method for measuring biomass N.
INTRODUCTION
that the increased biochemical activity in a moist soil following CHCl, furnigation, fumigant removal and aerobic incubation is
due to the decomposition of the cells killed by the
fumigant by the recolonizing microbial population.
Under most conditions, the decomposability
of other
soil organic fractions is little, if at all, affected by
CHCI, fumigation (Jenkinson and Powlson, 1976).
The Rush of N, (FN), defined as the N mineralized
by a previously fumigated soil incubated for 10 days
under standard conditions, less that mineralized by a
similarly incubated, but non-fumigated control soil,
can be used to estimate soil microbial biomass N on
the basis that 68% of the N in the original biomass
is mineralized (i.e. k, = 0.68) during this period (Shen
et al., 1984). Voroney and Paul (1984) used a comparable approach, differing however in two important aspects. Firstly, they considered that the total
It is now well established
&38
P. C.
BROOKES et
al.
AND METHODS
Soil freafmenfs
All soils were sieved (< 2 mm) and given a preliminary incubation in bulk at 40% water holding
capacity (WHC) for 7 days before use (Brookes et al.,
1985). Soil samples used for 1 day CHCl,-N and for
F, determinations were fumigated simultaneously at
40% WHC with alcohol-free CHCI, for 24 h (or for
5 days for 5 day CHCl,-N) before extraction or incubation. Extraction for 1 and 5 day CHCl,-N was
done with K,SO, immediately after fumigation and
without fumigant removal; samples used to determine
initial total and inorganic (i.e. NH, and NO,-N) N
were extracted at the time fumigation commenced.
For F, measurement, the fumigant was removed, the
soil moisture adjusted to 50% WHC and the soils
then incubated for 10 days at 25C before extraction
with 0.5 M K,SO, for measurement of extractable
NH,-N and NO,-N (Jenkinson and Powlson, 1976;
Shen et al., 1984). Methods for measuring CHCI,-N,
NH,-N, N03-N, total N and total C in soil are fully
described by Brookes et al. (1985).
RESULTS
AND DISCUSSION
by 0.5 M K,SO,
8.2
8.0
22.5
13.2
7.5
17.5
22.8
8.4
5.8
26.6
38.0
30.5
39.3
38.3
31.6
34.2
41.3
38.5
37.3
33.3
39.8
16.7
69.0
18.1
14.9
3.7
4.2
2.6
2.8
7.8
9.7
7.9
5.7
8.8
8.5
7.3
9.3
7.6
8.0
18.1
8.4
0.5
9.6
9.1
0.9
1.1
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
14.5
32.3
4.2
13.6
3.7
4.2
2.6
2.4
6.9
8.0
7.1
4.8
5.8
7.6
6.5
7.6
N extracted at
time 0
NH,-N + NO,-N
NO,-N
Mineral
N extracted
13.6
13.5
30.0
14.9
8.9
34.9
34.2
10.1
10.9
33.3
44.0
36.9
42.0
42.1
39.1
43.6
49. I
48.5
49.1
40.2
52.5
25.5
97.7
40.6
21.2
8.5
9.4
8.2
6.5
14.5
24.1
13.6
13.4
13.7
14.7
15.6
15.1
NH,-N + NO,-N
13.1
13.1
26.4
10.4
0.3
16.6
10.5
0
0
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
23.3
76.9
6.4
19.9
8.5
9.0
6.1
6.1
14.1
21.2
12.7
12.1
13.3
14.7
15.2
14.7
48.7
46.4
166.1
175.3
100.8
154.9
150.9
28.8
31.6
79. I
93.5
81.8
91.7
93.2
86.6
89.9
96.8
97.5
95.1
91.1
100.4
82.2
131.6
108.1
65.3
20.3
20.9
16.9
14.0
34.3
45.7
37.4
35.6
32.3
37.1
41.1
42.2
NH,-N + NO,-N
Fumigated
NO,-N
soil
N extracted
Non-fumigated
Mineral
soil
6.7
5.1
11.5
0.8
0.5
2.0
1.4
0
0
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
8.4
35.8
3.4
7.1
3.6
4.6
4.0
3.1
5.9
7.8
7.1
7.9
5.0
6.5
5.7
6.1
NO,-N
by 0.5 M K,SO,
9.7
6.8
17.8
15.7
21.9
35.8
38.1
25.7
20.6
36.0
37.5
39.7
43.1
42.2
41.7
36.9
40.7
29.7
35.4
36.8
41.6
9.7
45.2
22.5
7.3
4.5
7.2
6.6
4.9
7.0
8.3
10.0
7.8
8.4
7.0
5.7
6.6
IA
1B
2
3
4
5A
5B
6A
6B
7A
7B
7c
7D
7E
IF
8A
88
SC
SD
SE
SF
9
10
II
12
13A
13B
14A
14B
l5A
15B
16A
168
17A
17B
18A
18B
Soil
sample
no.
Table 2. Mineral
initially
extracted
from fumigated
37.3
36.9
139.9
165.6
149.5
141.6
141.6
50.9
47.3
96.9
97.7
89.9
95.5
91.9
89.4
91.6
90.7
88.1
87.9
95.2
91.8
70.0
93.1
83.9
53.7
16.4
13.8
12.0
10.0
29.9
35.5
31.3
29.9
37.1
34.4
40.4
38.5
40.0
37.3
110.9
126.3
123.7
136.7
127. I
43.3
42.5
81.3
82.5
78.4
78.9
78.3
80.6
76.7
80.5
69.5
78.5
81.3
82.7
55.4
84.2
66.0
42.2
13.1
11.9
13.7
12.0
25.7
37.9
19.3
27.5
18.1
22.9
31.5
25.0
extracted
soil
(pg N g- soil)
840
P. C.
BROOKESet
fumigation-incubation.
It also gives total N extracted
by I&SO, from the same soils, again immediately
before fumigation, or after a 1 or a 5 day fumigation.
From these data, 1 day CHCl,-N, 5 day CHCI,-N
and F,, defined as [(NHI-N f NO,-N extracted
from fumigated soil after 10 days aerobic incubation) - (NH4-N + N03-N extracted from similarly
incubated non-fumigated soil)], were calculated. If
denitrification occurred during the incubation of the
fumigated soil (and if the necessary NO3-N measurements were available) FN was corrected by adding (dzfirence between NO,-N extracted initially
and NO,-N extracted from fumigated soil after
fumigation-incubation)
to (actual amount of NH,-N
and NO,-N extracted from fumigated soil after
fumigation-incubation).
Both 1 day CHCl,-N and 5 day CHCl,-N were
closely correlated with the N mineralized from the
biomass (FN) in 37 soils during fumigationincubation (Fig. la and b). Both regressions accounted for 92% of the variance in the data and the
intercepts were not significantly different from zero.
The regression equations (calculated with the intercepts fitted through zero) were:
1 day CHCl,-N = (0.79 k 0.022) FN.
(11
(2)
al,
non-unifo~ly
iabelled. About 0.25% of total soil N
was SN-Iabelled in plot 9-b and about 0.35% in plot
14-d, irrespective of whether the labelled fertilizer had
been applied 1 or 2 yr previously.
For a given soil (with one exception, see later) the
ratio of (labelled N)-to-(unlabelled N) was similar in
F,, 1 day CHCl,-N and in 5 day CHCl,-N. However
(again with the same exception) this ratio was considerably greater in plots that had received N-1abelled
fertilizer 1 yr before than in plots that had received it
2yr before. These results again suggest that
fumigation-incubation
and fumigation-extraction
both attack the same small fraction of soil N, a
fraction much more N-enriched than the bulk soil
N. Futhermore, this labelled fraction is much more
sensitive to when the labelled fertilizer was added
than is the labelled fraction of the total soil N. These
observations are thus consistent with the hypothesis
that F,, 1 and 5 day CHCl,-N all come from the
same fraction of the soil N, probably the cytoplasmic
(McGill et al., 1981) part of the soil microbial
biomass.
The labelled N content of F, was anomalously low
in soil SD-F (0.46 1_1g
N g- soil). The reasons for this
150
la)
100
50
FNipgN
200
150
g-soil)
150
(b)
=
.03
.
/
P
0
50
100
150
200
Fn @gN g-soil)
Fig. l(b). Relationship between the flush of N (FN) following fumigation-incubation
and N released after a 5 day
fumigation. 5 day CHCl,-N = (1 .OI + 0.027) F,. For symbols see Table 1.
Measurement
Table 3. Labelled and u&belled
Soil
sample
IIO.
Years between
addition of
labelled
fertilizer and
sampling
of microbial
Fraction
biomass
841
Labelled N
(pg N g- soil)
Unlabelled N
(pegN gg soil)
Labelled N
unlabelled N
IA-C
Total N in soil
F,
I day CHCl,-N
5 day CHCl,-N
6.71
0.44
0.53
0.62
2810
46.8
37.9
50.8
0.0024
0.010
0.014
0.012
7&F
Total N in soil
F,
1 day CHCl,-N
5 day CHCl,-N
7.39
0.73
0.70
0.89
2830
48.2
37.6
50.4
0.0026
0.015
0.019
0.018
8A-C
Total N in soil
F,
1 day CHCI,-N
5 day CHCl,-N
7.27
0.62
0.48
0.53
2070
48.1
39.2
54.4
0.0035
0.013
0.012
0.010
SD-F
Total N in soil
F,
1 day CHCI,-N
5 day CHCI,-N
6.13
0.46
0.78
0.79
2000
46.7
38.9
48.1
0.0034
0.010
0.020
0.016
0.14
5.1
0.0038
LSD between
F, and CHCI,-N,
within soil. within
year (P = 6.05)
All measurements in this Table are means of single determinations on soils from each of the three replicate plots
((A-C) or (D-F)) that received a particular treatment with sN-labelled fertilizer.
between
Measurement
of
fumigation-incubation
CHCI,-N
soil biomass
N (BN) by
is based on the relationship
B, = P,ik,,
(3)
(4)
(5)
The fumigation-extraction
method has certain adover biomass
N measurements
by
vantages
fumigation-incubation.
The problems associated
with the incubation stage-the
need for complete
fumigant removal and for a prolonged incubation
under carefully controlled conditions do not arise. It
also sidesteps the issue of whether or not to use a
842
P. C. BROOK3s et al.
between
biomass
nitrogen
of proposed
method
of non-fumigated
soil at start of fumigation)]. S$iI
calculated
from
microbial
biomass
N
is
(1 day CHCl,-N)/0.54. All results are expressed as
pg N gg O.D. soil.
Acknowledgements-We
thank M. L. Fearnhead for Technicon analyses, J. E. D. Brown, D. S. McCann and N. D.
Sills for technical
assistance,
D. S. Powlson and R. P.
Voroney (University of Saskatchewan)
for useful discussion
and T. J. Dixon and Lynn C. Parry for statistical analyses.
REFERENCES
Adams T. McM. and Laughlin R. J. (1981) The effects of
agronomy
on the carbon and nitrogen contained
in the
soil biomass. Journal of Agricultural Science (Cambridge)
97, 319-327.
Brookes P. C., Kragt J. F., Powlson D. S. and Jenkinson
D. S. (1985) Chloroform
fumigation
and the release of
soil nitrogen:
the effects of fumigation
time and temperature. Soil Biology & Biochemistry 17, 831-835.
Jenkinson D. S. (1971) The accumulation
of organic matter
in soil left uncultivated.
Rothamsted Experimental Station,
Report for I970 Part 2, pp. 113-137.
Jenkinson
D. S. and Powlson D. S. (1976) The effects of
biocidal treatments
on metabolism
in soil-V.
A method
for measuring soil biomass. Soil Biology & Biochemistry
8, 209-213.
Jenkinson D. S., Johnston A. E., Powlson D. S. and Pruden
G. (1983) Uptake
of fertiliser
N by old grassland.
Rothamsted Experimental Station, Reportfor 1982, Part 1,
pp. 263-264.
Johnston
A. E. (1969) The Broadbalk
Wheat Experiment.
The plant nutrients
in crops grown
on Broadbalk.
Rothamsted Experimental Station, Report for 1968, Part 2.
pp. 5&62.
Johnston A. E. (1973) The effects of ley and arable cropping
systems on the amount
of soil organic matter in the
Rothamsted
and
Woburn
Ley-Arable
experiments.
Rothamsted Experimental Station, Report for 1976. Part 2,
pp 131-159.
Marumoto
T., Anderson J. P. E. and Domsch K. H. (1982)
Mineralisation
of nutrients from soil microbial biomass.
Soil Biology & Biochemistry 14, 469-475.
McGill W. B., Hunt H. W., Woodmansee
R. G. and Reuss
J. 0. (1981) Phoenix, a model of the dynamics of carbon
and nitrogen in grassland
soils. In Terrestrial Nitrogen
Cycles (F. E. Clark and T. Rosswall. Eds). Ecological
Bulletins (Stockholm) 33, 49-l 15.
Shen S. M., Pruden G. and Jenkinson
D. S. (1984) Mineralization and immobilization
of nitrogen in fumigated soil
and the measurement
of microbial biomass nitrogen. Soil
Biology & Biochemistry 16, 437444.
Voroney R. P. and Paul E. A. (1984) Determination
of k,
of the chloroform
and k, in situ for calibration
fumigation-incubation
method. Soil Biology & Biochemistry 16, 9-14.
Warren R. G. and Johnston A. E. (1964) The Park Grass
Experiment. Rothamsfed Experimental Station, Report for
1963, pp. 240-262.