Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DOI 10.1617/s11527-007-9260-y
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Received: 22 November 2006 / Accepted: 8 May 2007 / Published online: 6 June 2007
RILEM 2007
1 Introduction
The worldwide demand for high-performance cement-based materials has increased and predictions
are that it will be widely used in construction industry
during the early 21st century. Economical and
environmental considerations had a crucial role in
the supplementary cementing material usage as well
as better engineering and performance properties [1,
2]. From the viewpoints of the development of highperformance concrete and the reuse of industrial
waste products, the use of blast-furnace slag (BFS) as
a cementitious ingredient in either cement or concrete
composites has been increasing [3].
On the other hand, blast furnace slag is a quite
variable material due to the variation in its chemical
composition together with both content and composition of the glass fraction of the slag. The crystalline
part of the slag does not hydrate interfering only as
fine aggregate and crystallization seed. The hydration
mechanism of the slag is also different from that of
cement. When the slag is mixed with water, initial
480
2 Research significance
The purpose of this study was to assess the combined
effects of high replacement level of slag and curing
regimes on the performance characteristics of high
performance concretes. As mentioned above, these
effects have not been well documented, especially for
permeability-related durability and corrosion resistance of the embedded reinforcement in high performance concretes with higher levels of replacement
(up to 80%), and it is hoped that this investigation
will improve the knowledge on this subject and also
provide useful information to high performance
concrete users.
3 Experimental program
3.1 Materials
The materials used in this investigation were Portland
cement, blast furnace slag, fine aggregate, coarse
aggregate and superlasticizer. Portland cement (CEM
I 42.5R) conforming to the Turkish standard TS EN
197-1 (which is mainly based on the European EN
197-1) and blast furnace slag were utilized as
cementitious materials. The chemical compositions
and the physical properties of Portland cement and
blast furnace slag are given in Table 1. The slag was
obtained from Iskenderun Iron-Steel Factory in
Turkey. The slag was ground granulated in the plant
to have a Blain specific surface area of 405 m2/kg.
The XRD analysis of the slag shown in Fig. 1
displayed an amorphous hump characteristic at about
30o indicating the presence of large amounts of glass.
Moreover, as reported by the manufacturer, the
typical glass content of the slag is about 98%. The
fine aggregate was a mix of natural sand and crushed
sand whereas the coarse aggregate was crushed
limestone with a maximum particle size of 16 mm.
Both aggregates were obtained from local sources.
A commercially available sulphonated naphthalene
formaldehyde-based superplasticizer was used to give
a consistent workability.
481
Portland
cement
Slag
SiO2 (%)
19.73
37.45
Al2O3 (%)
5.09
11.80
Fe2O3 (%)
3.99
0.66
CaO (%)
62.86
34.83
MgO (%)
1.61
10.06
SO3 (%)
2.62
0.35
Na2O (%)
0.18
0.86
K2O (%)
0.80
0.38
Cl (%)
0.01
0.24
1.90
0.57
1.70
3.14
2.82
2-46/3-44
Le chatelier (mm)
327
405
Cement
(kg/m3)
Slag (%)
Slag
(kg/m3)
Water
(kg/m3)
Fine aggregate
Natural sand
(kg/m3)
0.40
Coarse aggregate
Crushed sand
(kg/m3)
No I (kg/m3)
No II (kg/m3)
SPa
(%)
400
160
739
238
567
303
1.7
200
160
50
60
200
240
160
160
725
722
234
233
556
554
298
296
1.7
1.7
120
70
280
160
719
232
551
295
1.7
80
80
320
160
716
231
549
294
1.7
482
concrete sample
Parafin wax
water
483
the current and time history, the total charge (coulombs) passed through the specimen was computed
by Simpsons integration. The results presented are
the averages from two concrete specimens. The test
was conducted at the ages of 28 and 90 days.
Fig. 3 Schematic
representation of
accelerated corrosion cell
484
Mixture
Air cured
Wet cured
28 days
Mean
Compressive strength (MPa)
90 days
COV
Mean
28 days
COV
Mean
90 days
COV
Meana
COVb
Control
50.6
9.0
57.9
4.7
56.2
3.5
63.1
5.4
50% slag
41.9
10.7
54.6
3.2
49.0
1.6
66.2
3.3
60% slag
38.3
2.3
51.8
7.5
43.1
5.7
64.5
1.2
70% slag
30.9
5.4
43.5
5.4
37.1
5.5
57.8
4.7
80% slag
27.9
3.4
38.0
2.8
34.2
2.7
51.4
2.7
Control
4.01
6.2
4.64
5.0
4.41
12.5
5.09
2.3
50% slag
3.36
10.7
4.37
7.9
3.93
6.0
5.20
2.5
60% slag
3.18
4.4
4.27
1.0
3.69
11.5
5.17
8.8
70% slag
2.78
4.6
3.91
14.5
3.39
1.6
5.00
0.6
80% slag
2.57
3.3
3.41
14.3
3.05
1.2
4.57
2.6
Control
50% slag
0.231
0.220
5.6
3.1
0.209
0.170
9.3
9.9
0.200
0.176
4.2
7.9
0.166
0.117
1.2
4.9
60% slag
0.206
4.4
0.156
3.8
0.165
6.0
0.107
4.0
70% slag
0.201
7.7
0.145
5.4
0.158
2.4
0.090
6.2
80% slag
0.188
2.9
0.137
8.4
0.152
1.8
0.082
2.6
Control
5.16
6.1
4.58
5.4
4.50
1.2
3.90
1.1
50% slag
4.67
4.0
3.84
5.7
4.00
4.1
3.01
5.5
60% slag
4.50
3.2
3.73
8.9
3.85
2.6
2.95
2.3
70% slag
4.33
6.5
3.66
5.2
3.80
2.7
2.84
3.0
80% slag
4.39
9.4
3.61
7.2
3.75
2.2
2.79
0.8
Control
4800
2.8
4050
2.2
4250
4.1
3750
0.9
50% slag
2700
6.0
1850
6.7
2050
2.1
1410
2.3
60% slag
2330
3.6
1770
2.3
1870
3.2
1070
3.5
70% slag
2100
4.1
1650
3.3
1600
3.3
960
3.1
80% slag
2050
4.4
1500
3.0
1580
5.4
880
1.7
Control
50% slag
78.0
83.0
5.7
2.3
92.0
109.0
3.2
1.0
85.0
93.7
2.5
1.0
115.0
139.5
3.1
1.8
60% slag
88.9
0.7
116.0
4.3
101.0
0.3
149.2
0.7
70% slag
90.0
1.1
123.0
10.0
110.7
2.1
161.6
6.2
80% slag
91.2
0.2
129.0
3.1
114.0
2.8
175.1
0.9
The number of observation is 3 for compression, split, and absorption tests while that is 2 for chloride permeability and corrosion
tests
is also evident that the curing methods had considerable effect on the compressive strength development, especially for wet cured slag concretes. For the
control and slag concretes, air curing resulted in
significantly lower 28- and 90-day strengths as
compared to wet curing. It was observed that the
ratio of the compressive strength of the specimens
subjected to air curing to those cured under wet for
485
6
80
Wet cured
Dry cured
Test age: 28 days
Test age: 90 days
Wet cured
Dry cured
Test age: 28 days
Test age: 90 days
60
70
50
40
30
20
1
10
0
0
0
20
40
60
80
100
20
40
100
6000
Wet cured
Dry cured
Test age: 28 days
Test age: 90 days
Wet cured
Dry cured
Test age: 28 days
Test age: 90 days
5000
4000
3000
2000
1000
0
0
20
40
60
80
100
0,3
Wet cured
Dry cured
Test age: 28 days
Test age: 90 days
0,25
0,2
0,15
0,1
0,05
0
0
20
40
20
40
60
80
100
0.5
80
60
60
80
100
486
487
0.6
Control specimen
Specimen with 60% slag
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90 100 110 120 130 140 150 160 170 180 190 200
Time (Hours)
488
150
100
250
Wet cured
Dry cured
Test age: 28 days
Test age: 90 days
200
50
0
0
20
40
60
80
100
489
Source of variation
541.2
96.2
0.00002
yes
1153.5
205.1
0.00000
yes
1
42
3000.4
5.6
533.5
0.00000
yes
Replacement level
1.57
64.0
0.00003
yes
Curing condition
7.08
288.8
0.00001
yes
18.53
755.2
0.00000
yes
42
0.02
Replacement level
0.00214
88.4
0.00002
yes
Curing condition
0.02665
1101.4
0.00000
yes
1651.7
0.00000
yes
0.00004
yes
Error
Replacement level
0.03996
42
0.00002
0.15120
19.5
Curing condition
8.85800
1139.8
0.00000
yes
Testing age
6.16330
793.1
0.00002
yes
42
0.00777
Error
Replacement level
594668.7
108.1
0.00000
yes
Curing condition
3847669.0
699.6
0.00000
yes
1
42
5050519.0
5500.2
918.2
0.00000
yes
Testing age
Error
Time to failure
Significance
Testing age
Chloride permeability
P-level
Error
Water absorption
Computed F
Replacement level
Testing age
Rate of water absorption
Curing condition
Testing age
Error
Splitting tensile strength
Degree of freedom
Replacement level
1000.8
19.5
0.00022
yes
Curing condition
20398.1
397.6
0.00010
yes
8643.0
168.5
0.00080
yes
Testing age
Error
42
the compressive strength data and the water absorption data (or rate of water absorption, chloride
permeability data) suggested the presence of inverse
type of relationship between them; the higher the
compressive strength, the lower the water absorption
(or rate of water absorption, chloride permeability).
However, the compressive strength increased with
increasing the time to failure of concrete specimens
for both plain and slag concretes. It was also evident
that the correlation coefficients between the measured
properties for the slag concrete was somewhat low
since the data obtained from slag concrete mixtures
exhibited more scatter while those for the plain
concrete was close to unity, suggesting fairly good
correlation between them.
To quantify the type and nature of interdependence between the chloride permeability and the
other three measured properties (water absorption,
51.3
490
c) 80
80
Plain concrete
Slag concrete
70
60
50
y = -14.136x + 98.413
R2 = 0.5305
40
Plain concrete
Slag concrete
70
y = -9.8114x + 101.48
R2 = 0.9597
a)
30
20
y = -0.0115x + 105.61
R2 = 0.9779
60
50
40
30
y = -0.0126x + 67.214
R2 = 0.2936
20
10
10
0
0
1000
d) 80
80
Plain concrete
Slag concrete
70
60
50
40
y = -180,66x + 73,525
R2 = 0,4084
30
3000
4000
5000
6000
Plain concrete
Slag concrete
70
y = -181,59x + 93,583
R2 = 0,9038
b)
2000
20
y = 0.3053x + 28.746
R2 = 0.901
60
50
40
y = 0.265x + 14.589
R2 = 0.4056
30
20
10
10
0
0
0,05
0,1
0,15
0,2
0,25
0,3
50
100
150
200
250
Fig. 12 Correlation between compressive strength and (a) water absorption, (b) rate of water absorption, (c) chloride permeability,
and (d) time to failure for concretes with and without slag
However, the interdependence between the permeability and absorption provided relatively higher
correlation coefficient.
5 Conclusions
The following conclusions are drawn from the test
results and analysis presented in this paper:
1.
2.
a)
6000
Plain concrete
Slag concrete
y = 818.28x + 501.61
R2 = 0.9094
5000
4000
3000
2000
y = 802.63x - 1285.4
R2 = 0.9259
1000
0
0
b)
6000
Plain concrete
Slag concrete
y = 14807x + 1228,2
R2 = 0,8187
5000
4000
3000
2000
1000
y = 11894x - 124,89
R2 = 0,9584
0
0
0,05
0,1
0,15
0,2
0,25
0,3
c)
6000
Plain concrete
Slag concrete
Fig. 13 Correlation
between chloride
permeability and (a) water
absorption, (b) rate of water
absorption, and (c) time to
failure for concretes with
and without slag
491
5000
y = -24.741x + 6501.1
R2 = 0.8063
4000
3000
y = -17.017x + 3704.6
R2 = 0.9053
2000
1000
0
0
50
100
150
200
492
3.
4.
5.
6.
Slag concrete exhibited marginally lower absorption characteristics than control concrete. An
increase in slag content (from 50 to 80%)
reduced the water penetration by total immersion
and capillary action, particularly under wet
curing condition.
It was observed that the concretes containing
50% and above-replacement levels of slag
showed sharply reduced values of the charge,
irrespective of curing condition and testing age.
Results indicated that the chloride permeability
of the air cured control concrete was about 1.1
times higher than that of the wet cured control
concrete, whereas for slag blended cement concrete, the equivalent increase in the dry/wet ratio
ranged from 1.3 to 1.7 times, depending on
replacement level of slag and testing age. This
implies that concretes containing high replacement levels of slag are very sensitive to the
curing method adopted.
Based on the results of the rapid corrosion test,
slag concrete specimens had superior performance and mostly gave longer time to failure at
similar curing condition and testing age in
comparison to control specimens. Similar to
water absorption and chloride permeability
results, the corrosion resistance of the specimens
increased considerably with increasing slag content. For example, the 90 day wet cured specimen
containing high level of slag (80% slag) exhibited about 52% higher corrosion resistance than
the control sample.
The effect of wet and air curing regimes on the
durability related properties was more pronounced in the presence of slag, particularly at
higher replacement levels (5080%). It was
observed that large differences in values between
wet and air curing were obtained for the slag
mixtures. This illustrates and reinforces the
importance of proper curing for concrete containing 50% and above-replacement level.
References
1. Badogiannis E, Papadakis VG, Chaniotakis E, Tsivilis S
(2004) Exploitation of poor Greek kaolins: strength
development of metakaolin concrete and evaluation by
means of k-value. Cem Concr Res 34:10351041
2. Ramezanianpour AA, Malhotra VM (1995) Effect of curing on the compressive strength, resistance to chloride ion
penetration and porosity of concretes incorporating slag,
fly ash, or silica fume. Cem Concr Compos 17:125133
3. Babu KG, Kumar VSR (2000) Efficiency of GGBS in
concrete. Cem Concr Res 30:10311036
4. Pal SC, Mukherjee A, Pathak SR (2003) Investigation of
hydraulic activity of ground granulated blast furnace slag
in concrete. Cem Concr Res 33:14811486
5. Itoh H (2004) Rapid discrimination of the character of the
water-cooled blast furnace slag used for Portland slag
cement. J Mater Sci 39:21912193
6. Mill KC, Courtney L, Fox AB, Harris B. Idoyaga Z,
Richardson MJ (2002) The use of thermal analysis in the
determination of the crystalline fraction of slag films.
Thermochim Acta 391:175184
7. Gao JM, Qian CX, Liu HF, Wang B, Li L (2005) ITZ
microstructure of concrete containing GGBS. Cem Concr
Res 35:12991304
8. Ozyildirim C (1994) Investigation of low-permeability
concretes containing slag and silica fume. ACI Mater J
91(2):197202
9. Afrani I, Rogers C (1994) The effects of different
cementing materials and curing on concrete scaling. Cem
Concr Aggr 16(2):132139
10. Parrott LJ (1996) Some effects of cement and curing upon
carbonation and reinforcement corrosion in concrete.
Mater Struct 29(187):164173
11. Wainwright PJ, Aitaider H (1995) The influence of cement
source and slag additions on the bleeding of concrete. Cem
Concr Res 25(7):14451456
12. Lumley JS, Gollop RS, Moir GK, Taylor HFW (1996)
Degrees of reaction of the slag in some blends with Portland cements. Cem Concr Res 26:139151
13. Alshamsi AM (1997) Microsilica and ground granulated
blast furnace slag effects on hydration temperature. Cem
Concr Res 27(12):18511859
14. Dehghanian C, Arjemandi M (1997) Influence of slag
blended cement concrete on chloride diffusion rate. Cem
Concr Res 27(6):937945
15. Jau WC, Tsay DS (1998) A study of the basic engineering
properties of slag cement concrete and its resistance to
seawater corrosion. Cem Concr Res 28(10):13631371
16. Erdogdu K, Tokyay M, Turker P (1999) Comparison of
intergrinding and separate grinding for the production of
natural pozzolan and GBFS-incorporated blended cements.
Cement Concr Res 29(5):743746
493
34. Detwiler RJ, Kjellsen KO, Gjorv OE (1991) Resistance to
chloride intrusion of concrete cured at different temperature. ACI Mater J 88(1):1924
35. Shaker FA, El-Dieb AS, Reda MM (1997) Durability of
styrene butadiene latex modified concrete. Cem Concr Res
27(5):711720
36. Okba SH, El-Dieb AS, Reda MM (1997) Evaluation of the
corrosion resistance of latex modified concrete (LMC).
Cem and Concr Res 27(6):861868
37. Al-Zahani MM, Al-Dulaijan SU, Ibrahim M, Saricimen H,
Sharif FM (2002) Effect of waterproofing coating on steel
reinforcement corrosion and physical properties of concrete. Cem Concr Comp 24:127137
zturan T, Gesoglu M (2005) A study on
38. Guneyisi E, O
reinforcement corrosion and related properties of plain and
blended cement concretes under different curing conditions. Cem Concr Comp 27(4):449461
39. Hogan FJ, Meusel JW (1981) Evaluation for durability and
strength development of a ground granulated blast furnace
slag. Cem Concr Aggr 3(1):4052
40. Roy DM, Idorn GM (1982) Hydration, structure, and
properties of blast furnace slag cement, mortars, and concrete. J Am Concr Inst 79:444457
zberk E, Altay B (1997)
41. Tas demir MA, Tas demir C, O
Fineness effect of GGBS on the properties and microstructure of concrete. In: Proceedingsof the 1st International Symposium on Mineral Admixtures in Cement,
Istanbul, Turkey, pp 198215
42. Khatip JM, Hibbert JJ (2005) Selected engineering properties of concrete incorporating slag and metakaolin.
Constr Build Mater 19:460472
43. Bai J, Wild S, Sabir BB (2002) Sorptivity and strength of
air-cured and water-cured PC-PFA-MK concrete and the
influence of binder composition on carbonation depth. Cem
Concr Res 32:18131821
44. Dias WPS (2000) Reduction of concrete sorptivity with
age through carbonation. Cem Concr Res 30:12551261
45. Malhotra VM, Carette GG, Bilodeau A, Sivasumdaram V
(1991) Some aspect of durability of high volume ASTM
class F fly ash concrete. In: Malhotra VM (ed) Proceedings
of the second CANMET/ACI International Conference on
Durability of Concrete, American Concrete Institute (ACI)
Special Publication SP-126, pp 6582
46. Plante P, Bilodeau A (1989) Rapid chloride ion permeability test: data on concretes incorporating supplementary
cementing materials. In: Malhotra VM (ed) Proceeding of
the third CANMET/ACI International Conference on the
Use of Fly Ash, Silica Fume, Slag, and Natural Pozzolans,
ACI Special Publication SP 114-30, pp 625644
47. Bonavetti V, Donza H, Rahhal V, Irassar E (2000) Influence of initial curing on the properties of concrete containing limestone blended cement. Cem Concr Res 30:703
708
48. Kolias S, Georgiou C (2005) The effect of paste volume
and of water content on the strength and water absorption
of concrete. Cem Concr Comp 27:211216
49. Buenfeld NR, Glass GK, Hassanein AM, Zhang JZ (1998)
Chloride transport in concrete subjected to electrical field.
J Mater Civ Eng 10(4):220228