Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Page 1 of 317
339510607
Page 2 of 317
Resolution
339510607
Page 3 of 317
Resolution 2016-2017
Topic wording for 2016-2017 is
NFHS.org, 16
[1-11-16, China Selected as the 2016-17 National High School Policy Debate
Topic, https://www.nfhs.org/articles/china-selected-as-the-2016-17-nationalhigh-school-policy-debate-topic/, accessed 4-29-16]
339510607
Page 4 of 317
Resolved:
339510607
Page 5 of 317
Resolved
339510607
Page 6 of 317
Resolvable
Resolved means resolvable
Garner, Blacks Law Dictionary editor, 95
[Bryan A., A Dictionary of Modern Legal Usage, p. 764]
Resolvable; resolvible; resoluble. The first is far more common than the
other in meaning able to be resolved E.g. We held that the pilot
base dispute was a 'major' dispute subject to the court's jurisdiction
and not a 'minor' dispute resolvable by the Railway Labor Act's
adjustment mechanism. Resoluble has the liability of meaning also
capable of being dissolved again. The variant spelling resolvible is to
be avoided.
339510607
Page 7 of 317
Determined
Resolved means to make a firm decision about, to make clear
Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary
(resolve, http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/resolved, accessed 730-9)
resolved
One entry found.
Ads by Google
Conflict Resolution
Manage conflict in the workplace. Download a free guidebook here!
DaleCarnegie.com/resolution
Main Entry:
1resolve Listen to the pronunciation of 1resolve
Pronunciation:
\ri-zlv, -zolv also -zv or -zov\
Function:
verb
Inflected Form(s):
resolved; resolving
Etymology:
Middle English, from Latin resolvere to unloose, dissolve, from re- +
solvere to loosen, release more at solve
Date:
14th century
transitive verb1obsolete : dissolve, melt2 a: break up, separate <the
prism resolved the light into a play of color> ; also : to change by
disintegration b: to reduce by analysis <resolve the problem into simple
elements> c: to distinguish between or make independently visible
339510607
Page 8 of 317
339510607
Page 9 of 317
resolved
resolved [ ri zlvd ]
adjective
Definition: determined: determined in purpose
339510607
Page 10 of 317
339510607
Page 11 of 317
Firm Conclusion
Resolved means firm in purpose
Random House Dictionary, 14
[resolved, Dictionary.com, http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/resolved,
accessed 9-10-14]
resolved
[ri-zolvd] Spell Syllables
Synonyms Examples Word Origin
adjective
1. firm in purpose or intent; determined.
Verb
* S: (v) decide, settle, resolve, adjudicate (bring to an end; settle
conclusively) "The case was decided"; "The judge decided the case in
favor of the plaintiff"; "The father adjudicated when the sons were
quarreling over their inheritance"
* S: (v) conclude, resolve (reach a conclusion after a discussion
or deliberation)
* S: (v) purpose, resolve (reach a decision) "he resolved never to drink
again"
* S: (v) answer, resolve (understand the meaning of) "The question
concerning the meaning of life cannot be answered"
* S: (v) resolve (make clearly visible) "can this image be resolved?"
* S: (v) resolve, solve (find the solution) "solve an equation"; "solve for
x"
339510607
Page 12 of 317
ADJECTIVE
[PREDICATIVE, WITH INFINITIVE]
Firmly determined to do something:
Constance was resolved not to cry
339510607
Page 13 of 317
Resolve
339510607
Page 14 of 317
Decide
To resolve is to make a formal decision or determination
Cambridge University Press
(resolve, Cambridge Advanced Learners Dictionary,
http://dictionary.cambridge.org/define_b.asp?key=67258&dict=CALD,
accessed 7-30-9)
Definition
resolve (DECIDE) Show phonetics
verb [I] FORMAL
to make a decision formally or with determination:
[+ that] She resolved that she would never speak to him again.
[+ adverb or preposition] After hours of argument, they resolved against
taking legal action.
[+ to infinitive] The company resolved to take no further action against
the thieves.
See also resolute.
resolve
[ri-zolv] Spell Syllables
verb (used with object), resolved, resolving.
1.to come to a definite or earnest decision about; determine (to do
something):
I have resolved that I shall live to the full.
339510607
Page 15 of 317
339510607
Page 16 of 317
339510607
Page 17 of 317
Firm Conclusion
Resolving an issue means coming to a firm conclusion about it
Dictionary.com
(resolved. Dictionary.com. Dictionary.com Unabridged (v 1.1). Random
House, Inc. http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/resolved, accessed: July
29, 2009)
resolve
/rzlv/ Show Spelled Pronunciation [ri-zolv] Show IPA verb, -solved,
-solving, noun
verb (used with object)
1. to come to a definite or earnest decision about; determine
(to do something): I have resolved that I shall live to the full.
2. to separate into constituent or elementary parts; break up; cause or
disintegrate (usually fol. by into).
3. to reduce or convert by, or as by, breaking up or disintegration
(usually fol. by to or into).
4. to convert or transform by any process (often used reflexively).
5. to reduce by mental analysis (often fol. by into).
6. to settle, determine, or state formally in a vote or resolution,
as of a deliberative assembly.
7. to deal with (a question, a matter of uncertainty, etc.)
conclusively; settle; solve: to resolve the question before the
board.
8. to clear away or dispel (doubts, fears, etc.); answer: to
resolve any doubts we may have had.
9. Chemistry. to separate (a racemic mixture) into optically active
components.
10.
Music. to cause (a voice part or the harmony as a whole) to
progress from a dissonance to a consonance.
11.
Optics. to separate and make visible the individual parts of (an
image); distinguish between.
339510607
Page 18 of 317
12.
Medicine/Medical. to cause (swellings, inflammation, etc.) to
disappear without suppuration.
verb (used without object)
13.
to come to a determination; make up one's mind; determine
(often fol. by on or upon): to resolve on a plan of action.
14.
to break up or disintegrate.
15.
to be reduced or changed by breaking up or otherwise (usually
fol. by to or into).
16.
noun
17.
a resolution or determination made, as to follow some course
of action.
18.
Origin:
132575; ME resolven (v.) < L resolvere to unfasten, loosen, release,
equiv. to re- re- + solvere to loosen; see solve
resolve (r-zlv')
v. resolved, resolving, resolves
v. tr.
1. To make a firm decision about.
2. To cause (a person) to reach a decision. See Synonyms at decide.
3. To decide or express by formal vote.
4. To change or convert: My resentment resolved itself into resignation.
339510607
Page 19 of 317
339510607
Page 20 of 317
Problem
Resolve means ending a problem
Cambridge Online Dictionary, 10
(resolve,
http://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/british/resolve_1#resolve_1__3,
accessed 9-10-14)
339510607
Page 21 of 317
Colon
339510607
Page 22 of 317
Introduces
Colon introduces
The Guide to Grammar and Writing, no date given
["The Colon," http://grammar.ccc.commnet.edu/grammar/marks/colon.htm,
accessed 9-11-14]
339510607
Page 23 of 317
339510607
Page 24 of 317
The USFG
339510607
Page 25 of 317
The
339510607
Page 26 of 317
Specification
The implies specification
Dictionary.com
(the. Dictionary.com. Dictionary.com Unabridged (v 1.1). Random House,
Inc. http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/the, accessed: July 29, 2009)
the
1/stressed i; unstressed before a consonant ; unstressed before a
vowel i/ Show Spelled Pronunciation [stressed thee; unstressed before
a consonant thuh; unstressed before a vowel thee] Show IPA
Use the in a Sentence
definite article
1. (used, esp. before a noun, with a specifying or
particularizing effect, as opposed to the indefinite or
generalizing force of the indefinite article a or an): the book you
gave me; Come into the house.
2. (used to mark a proper noun, natural phenomenon, ship,
building, time, point of the compass, branch of endeavor, or
field of study as something well-known or unique): the sun; the
Alps; the Queen Elizabeth; the past; the West.
3. (used with or as part of a title): the Duke of Wellington; the Reverend
John Smith.
4. (used to mark a noun as indicating the best-known, most approved,
most important, most satisfying, etc.): the skiing center of the U.S.; If
you're going to work hard, now is the time.
5. (used to mark a noun as being used generically): The dog is a
quadruped.
6. (used in place of a possessive pronoun, to note a part of the body or
a personal belonging): He won't be able to play football until the leg
mends.
7. (used before adjectives that are used substantively, to note an
individual, a class or number of individuals, or an abstract idea): to visit
the sick; from the sublime to the ridiculous.
339510607
Page 27 of 317
339510607
Page 28 of 317
Unique Particular
The indicates uniqueness
American Heritage Dictionary
(the., Dictionary.com. The American Heritage Dictionary of the English
Language, Fourth Edition. Houghton Mifflin Company, 2004.
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/the, accessed: 7-29-9)
339510607
Page 29 of 317
Definitive, Particular
The indicates particular setting a functional limit
Words and Phrases, 8
[the, Vol. 41B, p. 1]
Word the is a word of limitation. It is a word used before nouns with a specifying
339510607
Page 30 of 317
2. used to point forward to a following qualifying or defining clause or phrase: the fuss that he
made of her | the top of a bus | I have done the best I could.
(chiefly with rulers and family members with the same name) used after a name to qualify it:
George the Sixth | Edward the Confessor | Jack the Ripper.
3. used to make a generalized reference to something rather than identifying a particular
instance: he taught himself to play the violin | worry about the future.
used with a singular noun to indicate that it represents a whole species or class: they placed
the African elephant on their endangered list.
used with an adjective to refer to those people who are of the type described: the unemployed.
used with an adjective to refer to something of the class or quality described: they are trying
to accomplish the impossible.
used with the name of a unit to state a rate: they can do 120 miles to the gallon.
4. enough of (a particular thing): he hoped to publish monthly, if only he could find the money.
5. (pronounced stressing the) used to indicate that someone or something is the best known or
most important of that name or type: he was the hot young piano prospect in jazz.
6. used adverbially with comparatives to indicate how one amount or degree of something
varies in relation to another: the more she thought about it, the more devastating it became.
(usu. all the ) used to emphasize the amount or degree to which something is affected:
commodities made all the more desirable by their rarity.
origin Old English (Northumbrian and North Mercian dialects) th; related to Dutch de, dat,
and German der, die, das.
usage: The article the is usually pronounced / TTH/ before a consonant sound (please pass the
potatoes; ) and /TTH/ before a vowel sound (please pass the asparagus; ). Regardless of
consonant and vowel sounds, when the desired effect following the is to emphasize exclusivity,
the pronunciation is /TTH/: she's not just any expert in vegetation management, she's the expert.
the1
[stressed th ee; unstressed before a consonant th uh; unstressed before a vowel th ee] Spell Syllables
Examples Word Origin
definite article
1. (used, especially before a noun, with a specifying or particularizing effect, as opposed to
the indefinite or generalizing force of the indefinite article a or an):
the book you gave me; Come into the house.
339510607
Page 31 of 317
The is definitive
Words and Phrases, 8
[the, Vol. 41B, p. 1]
The word the is a definitive, and is commonly used before nouns which are specific or
understood.
The is particular
Words and Phrases, 8
[the, Vol. 41B, p. 1]
The determines what particular thing is meant, i.e., what particular thing
we are to assume to be meant. * * * Yet this article is not always used to mean but one.
Take the well-worn and well-wearing quotation: The man that hath not music in his soul is fit
for treason, etc., the meaning of the article is not exhausted when one man is found with no
music in himself. The man means there, any man.
339510607
Page 32 of 317
339510607
Page 33 of 317
339510607
Page 34 of 317
to the bill of exceptions indicated an intent that there be but one bill of exceptions in a case.
Kraft v. Montgomery Ward & Co.
339510607
Page 35 of 317
To decide if you should use the word the, ask yourself these
three questions:
1. Is the noun indefinite (unspecified) or definite (specific)?
The general rule states that the first mention of a noun is indefinite and
all subsequent references to this noun are definite and take the.
A man is walking down a road. There is a dog with the man.
The second mention may be a synonym:
Combine butter, sugar and eggs. Add flour to the mixture.
First (indefinite) mention requires a or an for a singular count noun, no
article for a plural or non-count noun. Second mention makes the
correct for both count and non-count nouns:
A growing plant must have water and minerals. The plant must also
have sunlight. The minerals must include nitrates and the water must
not be saline.
Three special groups of nouns are considered definite in reference
even if they have not been mentioned in the preceding sentence or
clause.
a. The first group consists of nouns which refer to shared
knowledge of the situation or context. For example, in Canada
you can say
The Prime Minister will arrive tomorrow
because there is only one Prime Minister in Canada, and so it is
clear to whom you are referring. Similarly, if there is only one
hospital in the town, you can say
He's been working in the hospital for two years.
But you couldn't say this in Toronto, where there are many hospitals. You
would have to name the particular hospital in your first reference to it:
339510607
Page 36 of 317
He's been working at Toronto General Hospital for two years. He says
the hospital is in a financial mess.
b. The second group consists of nouns referring to unique
objects:
e.g., the sun/the earth/the Pope/the sky/the equator
c. Superlative adjectives and unique adjectives form the third
group. Because there can be only one of these (only one of a series can
be the tallest or the best or the first), they take the definite article
Mexico City is the most populous city in the world.
I enjoyed the first part, but I was disappointed at the end.
She is the principal researcher.
2. Is the noun modified?
a. Premodification: If the noun is preceded by one of the following-this/that/these/those/some/any/each/every/no/none/my/mine
do not use the definite article.
e.g., the red books/some red books/no red book/his red books/each red
book
b. Postmodification: if the noun is followed by a dependent clause
(who/which/that) or a prepositional phrase (of/in/to...), it is made definite
and takes the definite article. The man who lives next door is Chinese.
We take the regular collection of garbage for granted.
The journey to Vancouver take three days by train.
No one expected the results that were found.
EXCEPTION: collective nouns take the indefinite article:
a box of matches/a deck of cards/a bar of soap/a herd of cows.
339510607
Page 37 of 317
2. (used to mark a proper noun, natural phenomenon, ship, building, time, point of the compass,
branch of endeavor, or field of study as something well-known or unique):
the sun; the Alps; the Queen Elizabeth; the past; the West.
339510607
Page 38 of 317
Context Key
Meaning of The varies in context
Words and Phrases, 69
[Vol. 43]
339510607
Page 39 of 317
All
The can mean all of the
Words and Phrases, 8
[the, Vol. 41B, p. 1]
The definite article the has sometimes been construed to mean all of the.
339510607
Page 40 of 317
One
The refers to one
Cambridge Dictionaries Online
(the, http://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/british/the_1, accessed 911-14)
339510607
Page 41 of 317
United States
339510607
Page 42 of 317
Federal Republic
United States is a federal republic
The New Oxford American Dictionary, 13
United States
((abbr.: US or U.S.) )
a country that occupies most of the southern half of North America as well as Alaska and
the Hawaiian Islands; pop. 304,059,724 (est. 2008); capital, Washington, DC. Full name United
States of America.
The US is a federal republic comprising 50 states and the Federal District of Columbia . It
originated in the American Revolution, the successful rebellion of the colonies on the eastern coast
against British rule in 177583. The original 13 states that formed the Union drew up a federal
constitution in 1787, and George Washington was elected the first president in 1789. In the 19th century
the territory of the US was extended across the continent through the westward spread of pioneers and
settlers and acquisitions such as that of Texas and California from Mexico in the 1840s. After a long
period of isolation in foreign affairs, the US participated on the Allied side in both world wars and
emerged from the Cold War as the world's leading military and economic power.
339510607
Page 43 of 317
339510607
Page 44 of 317
Republic
United States refers to the republic comprising 48
conterminous states, Alaska, Hawaii, and D.C.
Random House Dictionary, 14
(united states. Dictionary.com Unabridged,
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/united%20states, accessed: 9-11-14,
AFB)
United States
Use united states in a Sentence
noun
a republic in the N Western Hemisphere comprising 48
conterminous states, the District of Columbia, and Alaska in
North America, and Hawaii in the N Pacific. 267,954,767;
conterminous United States, 3,022,387 sq. mi. (7,827,982 sq. km); with
Alaska and Hawaii, 3,615,122 sq. mi. (9,363,166 sq. km). Capital:
Washington, D.C. Abbreviation: U.S., US
Also called United States of America, America.
339510607
Page 45 of 317
Republic Government
Republic is the government
Munro, Encyclopedia Britannica, 13
[Andre, 3-18-2013, Republic,
http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/498751/republic, accessed 9-1114]
republic /ripblik/
noun a state in which supreme power is held by the people and their
elected representatives, and which has an elected or nominated president
rather than a monarch.
archaic a group with a certain equality between its members.
origin late 16th cent.: from French rpublique, from Latin respublica, from
res ' entity, concern ' + publicus ' of the people, public '.
339510607
Page 46 of 317
Federal Jurisdiction
United States includes all of the jurisdiction of the federal
government
Words and Phrases, 6
[United States, Volume 43A]
339510607
Page 47 of 317
Jurisdiction
The United States includes all areas under US jurisdiction
U.S. Department of Defense, 9
(United States, The Dictionary of Military Terms, p. 574)
339510607
Page 48 of 317
Constitutional Union
United States is a Constitutional entity
Ballentines Law Dictionary, 1969
[United States, 3rd edition, edited by James A. Ballentine,
http://citizenlaw.com/pdf/u.pdf, accessed 9-11-14]
339510607
Page 49 of 317
339510607
Page 50 of 317
Country/Nation
The United States is comprised of 48 contiguous states,
Alaska, Hawaii, and various territories, with DC as the capital
American Heritage Dictionary
(United States, Dictionary.com. The American Heritage Dictionary of the
English Language, Fourth Edition. Houghton Mifflin Company, 2004.
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/united states, accessed: 7-29-9, AFB)
339510607
Page 51 of 317
Definition
The United States (abbreviation US) is the United States of
America, a nation consisting of 50 states, all but one (Hawaii) in
North America.
339510607
Page 52 of 317
USA
The United States is the United States of America
Cambridge University Press
(United States, Cambridge Dictionary of American English,
http://dictionary.cambridge.org/define_b.asp?key=unite*1+4&dict=A,
accessed 7-30-9)
Definition
The United States (abbreviation US) is the United States of
America, a nation consisting of 50 states, all but one (Hawaii) in
North America.
339510607
Page 53 of 317
339510607
Page 54 of 317
Geographic
United States refers to a geographical entity
Merriam Webster
[United States, http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/united
%20states, accessed 9-11-14]
(Concise Encyclopedia)
339510607
Page 55 of 317
[United States,
http://www.wordswarm.net/dictionary/united_states_of_america.html#mw,
accessed 9-11-14]
United States geographical name country North America bordering on Atlantic, Pacific, &
Arctic oceans; a federal republic capital Washington area 3,619,969 square miles (9,375,720 square
kilometers), population 281,421,906
United States
((abbr.: US or U.S.) )
a country that occupies most of the southern half of North America as well as Alaska and
the Hawaiian Islands; pop. 304,059,724 (est. 2008); capital, Washington, DC. Full name United
States of America.
The US is a federal republic comprising 50 states and the Federal District of Columbia . It
originated in the American Revolution, the successful rebellion of the colonies on the eastern coast
against British rule in 177583. The original 13 states that formed the Union drew up a federal
constitution in 1787, and George Washington was elected the first president in 1789. In the 19th century
the territory of the US was extended across the continent through the westward spread of pioneers and
settlers and acquisitions such as that of Texas and California from Mexico in the 1840s. After a long
period of isolation in foreign affairs, the US participated on the Allied side in both world wars and
emerged from the Cold War as the world's leading military and economic power.
339510607
Page 56 of 317
Includes Territories
The United States includes territories and areas under US
jurisdiction
U.S. Department of Defense, 9
(United States, The Dictionary of Military Terms, p. 574)
339510607
Page 57 of 317
D. Minn. 1944.
Alien Registration Act of 1940
a.
United States is used in the Alien Registration Act as including
the states, the territories of Alaska and Hawaii, the District of
Columbia, Puerto Rico and the Virgin Islands, but the term does not
include the Philippine Islands.
339510607
Page 58 of 317
CA.9 (Hawaii)
Rabang v. I.N.S.
a.
As used in the constitution, term United States does not
include all territories subject to jurisdiction of the United States
Government.
339510607
Page 59 of 317
Includes Agencies
United States includes US agencies
Words and Phrases, 6
[United States, Volume 43A]
D.D.C. 1982
a.
The term United States, as used in exception for offsetting
judgments to the priority given by Federal Tax Lien Act for attorney
liens includes the United States Postal Service and, hence,
attorneys lien on taxpayers recovery on contract claims against
the Service was subordinate to Internal Revenue Services claims
against taxpayer for unpaid employment taxes.
339510607
Page 60 of 317
Federal
339510607
Page 61 of 317
National
Federal is government of states, central government of US
The New Oxford American Dictionary, 13
[federal, 3rd edition, Oxford Reference database, accessed 9-11-14]
federal /fed()rl/
adjective having or relating to a system of government in which
several states form a unity but remain independent in internal affairs:
Russia's federation treaty shares powers among Russia's federal and local
governments.
of, relating to, or denoting the central government as
distinguished from the separate units constituting a federation: the
federal agency that provides legal services to the poor.
of, relating to, or denoting the central government of the US.
(Federal) US historical of the northern states in the Civil War: a loud
Federal cheer was heard, proving Stonewall to be hard pressed.
339510607
Page 62 of 317
339510607
Page 63 of 317
339510607
Page 64 of 317
339510607
Page 65 of 317
Government
The government of the United States is that of a federal
republic set up by the Constitution of the United States, adopted
by the Constitutional Convention of 1787. There is a division of
powers between the federal government and the state
governments. The federal government consists of three
branches: the executive, the legislative, and the judicial. The
executive power is vested in the President and, in the event of the
President's incapacity, the Vice President. (For a chronological list of all
the presidents and vice presidents of the United States, including their
terms in office and political parties, see the table entitled Presidents of
the United States.) The executive conducts the administrative business
of the nation with the aid of a cabinet composed of the Attorney General
and the Secretaries of the Departments of State; Treasury; Defense;
Interior; Agriculture; Commerce; Labor; Health and Human Services;
Education; Housing and Urban Development; Transportation; Energy;
and Veterans' Affairs.
339510607
Page 66 of 317
Not States
The United States federal government is the governing body of
the United States, distinct from the states
Columbia Electronic Encyclopedia, 4
(US, Reference.com, http://www.reference.com/browse/columbia/US,
accessed 7-30-9)
Government
The government of the United States is that of a federal
republic set up by the Constitution of the United States, adopted
by the Constitutional Convention of 1787. There is a division of
powers between the federal government and the state
governments. The federal government consists of three
branches: the executive, the legislative, and the judicial. The
executive power is vested in the President and, in the event of the
President's incapacity, the Vice President. (For a chronological list of all
the presidents and vice presidents of the United States, including their
terms in office and political parties, see the table entitled Presidents of
the United States.) The executive conducts the administrative business
of the nation with the aid of a cabinet composed of the Attorney General
and the Secretaries of the Departments of State; Treasury; Defense;
Interior; Agriculture; Commerce; Labor; Health and Human Services;
Education; Housing and Urban Development; Transportation; Energy;
and Veterans' Affairs.
339510607
Page 67 of 317
339510607
Page 68 of 317
Should
339510607
Page 69 of 317
Useful Definitions
339510607
Page 70 of 317
Must/Mandate
Should means ought to
Random House Dictionary, 14
["should." Dictionary.com Unabridged
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/should, accessed 9-11-14]
339510607
Page 71 of 317
Duty
Should expresses obligation, duty, what should happen
The New Oxford American Dictionary, 13
should /SHoood/
modal verb (3rd sing. should)
1. used to indicate obligation, duty, or correctness, typically when
criticizing someone's actions: he should have been careful | I think we
should trust our people more | you shouldn't have gone.
indicating a desirable or expected state: by now students should
be able to read with a large degree of independence.
used to give or ask advice or suggestions: you should go back to bed
| what should I wear?
(I should) used to give advice: I should hold out if I were you.
339510607
Page 72 of 317
Kan. 1951. The word should denotes duty whereas word could
denotes no more than a possibility. Mosely v. Kansas City, 228 P.2d 699,
170 Kan. 585.
339510607
Page 73 of 317
Obligation
Should implies obligation or correctness
Oxford Dictionaries
[Oxford University Press, Should,
http://www.oxforddictionaries.com/us/definition/american_english/should,
accessed: July 5, 2016 //SL]
Should is obligatory
Words and Phrases, 6
[Volume 39, p. 372]
339510607
Page 74 of 317
339510607
Page 75 of 317
Expectation
Should implies probability
Cambridge Advanced Learners Dictionary & Thesaurus
[Cambridge University Press, 2016, Should,
http://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/should, accessed: July 2,
2016 //SL]
339510607
Page 76 of 317
339510607
Page 77 of 317
Opinion
Should expresses opinion
Cambridge University Press, 14
[Should, Cambridge Academic Content Dictionary,
http://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/american-english/should, accessed
9-11-14]
339510607
Page 78 of 317
Desirability
Should implies the necessity, desirability, or importance of the
action following the verb
Cambridge Academic Content Dictionary
[Cambridge University Press, 2016, Should,
http://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/should, accessed: July 2,
2016 //SL]
339510607
Page 79 of 317
Implies Benefits
Should implies an evaluation of the benefits of an action
Cambridge Advanced Learners Dictionary & Thesaurus
[Cambridge University Press, 2016, Should,
http://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/should, accessed: July 2,
2016 //SL]
339510607
Page 80 of 317
Immediacy
Should implies immediacy
Merriam-Webster
[Merriam-Webster.com, n.d., Should, http://www.merriamwebster.com/dictionary/should, accessed: July 5, 2016 //SL]
339510607
Page 81 of 317
Condition
Should implies a conditional approach
Merriam-Webster
[Merriam-Webster.com, n.d., Should, http://www.merriamwebster.com/dictionary/should, accessed: July 5, 2016 //SL]
339510607
Page 82 of 317
339510607
Page 83 of 317
Should AT Discretion/May
Should is distinct from may it is not permissive or
discretionary
Words and Phrases, 6
[Vol. 39, p. 311]
The use of the word should instead of the word may in the part of
the charge which tells the jury that they should consider the interest
the witness has, etc., is objectionable as in some measure an invasion of
the province of the jury; the word should there meaning more than
the word may in its permissive sense. Lynch v. Bates, 38 N.E. 806,
807, 139 Ind. 206.
339510607
Page 84 of 317
339510607
Page 85 of 317
Discretion
Should allows discretion
Words and Phrases, 6
[Volume 39, p. 369]
339510607
Page 86 of 317
Request
Should implies a polite request
Merriam-Webster
[Merriam-Webster.com, n.d., Should, http://www.merriamwebster.com/dictionary/should, accessed: July 5, 2016 //SL]
339510607
Page 87 of 317
May
In the context of instructions, may and should are sufficiently
synonymous
Words and Phrases, 6
[Vol. 39, p. 311]
339510607
Page 88 of 317
AT Should = Mandate
Should is not mandatory in legal context
Words and Phrases, 6
[Volume 39, p. 372]
La.App.2Cir. 1993.
Should is not mandatory in sentencing guideline that concurrent
sentences should be imposed if two or more criminal acts constitute
parts of common scheme. --State v. Stamper
339510607
Page 89 of 317
AT Should = Obligation
Should is a recommendation, not an obligation
Words and Phrases, 6
[Volume 39, p. 369]
C.A.10 2001.
Term should in statute indicate recommended course of action,
but does not itself imply obligation associated with shall.--Qwe
Corp. v. F.C.C.
339510607
Page 90 of 317
339510607
Page 91 of 317
Futurity
Should expresses futurity
Merriam Webster 14
[Should, http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/should, accessed 911-14]
3used in auxiliary function to express futurity from a point of view in the past
<realized that she should have to do most of her farm work before sunrise Ellen
Glasgow>
339510607
Page 92 of 317
should
[shoo d] Spell Syllables
Synonyms Examples Word Origin
auxiliary verb
1. simple past tense of shall.
Definition of SHOULD
past of shall
339510607
Page 93 of 317
Would
Should is less direct would
Random House Dictionary, 14
["should." Dictionary.com Unabridged
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/should, accessed 9-11-14]
339510607
Page 94 of 317
Substantially
339510607
Page 95 of 317
Substantially Violations
339510607
Page 96 of 317
Substantially
# S: (adv) well, considerably, substantially (to a great extent or
degree) "I'm afraid the film was well over budget"; "painting the room
white made it seem considerably (or substantially) larger"; "the house
has fallen considerably in value"; "the price went up substantially".
339510607
Page 97 of 317
339510607
Page 98 of 317
Definitions
339510607
Page 99 of 317
In the Main
Substantially means in the main
Judicial and Statutory Definitions of Words and Phrases, 10
(West Publishing Company, Volume 4, p. 753, Google Books)
339510607
Essentially
Substantially means essentially
Oxford Dictionaries
[OxfordDictionaries.com, Substantially,
http://www.oxforddictionaries.com/us/definition/american_english/substantiall
y, accessed 7-3-16, ZT]
339510607
339510607
Materially
Substantial means materially
WORDS & PHRASES, 2
(Vol. 40A, 2002, p. 469.)
Substantially is essentially
Words & Phrases 64,
[p. 818.]
339510607
Real
Substantial is real and substantive
Merriam Websters Dictionary
[Merriam Websters Learners Dictionary, Substantially,
http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/substantially, accessed 7-3-16,
ZT]
Adjective
* S: (adj) substantial, substantive (having a firm basis in reality
and being therefore important, meaningful, or considerable)
"substantial equivalents"
* S: (adj) substantial, real, material (having substance or
capable of being treated as fact; not imaginary) "the substantial
world"; "a mere dream, neither substantial nor practical"; "most
ponderous and substantial things"- Shakespeare
339510607
Amount
Substantial must be of a considerable amount, quantity, and
size
Dictionary.com
[Dictionary, substantially, http://www.dictionary.com/browse/substantially?
s=t, adj. 1, accessed 7-3-16, ZT]
Substantial
of ample or considerable amount, quantity, size, etc.:
a substantial sum of money.
substantial adj
considerable in quantity
: significantly great [would be a abuse of the provisions of this
chapter "U.S. Code "] compare de minimis
substantiality [-stan-ch-a-l-t]
339510607
Quantitative
Substantial is quantitative
Merriam-Webster 9
(http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/substantially, accessed 9-9-9)
339510607
80%
Substantially is 80%
Curtin, Judge, United States District Court for the Western District of New York, 2003
(John T., 2-23-03 (Gateway Equipment Corp. -vs- United States of America 2003 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 2942, United States District Court for the Western
District of New York, Lexis)
The government cites Webster's Ninth New College Dictionary for the
definitions of "limit" and "impairment" as suggesting "meanings equivalent
to restriction and reduction, respectively." Item 30, p. 3, n.1. It posits
that the word "substantially" suggests "an order of magnitude
equivalent to 80% or 90%." Id. It concludes that "using those
definitions, 'substantially limited' and 'substantially impaired'
means that there must be an 80%-90% restriction and/ or
reduction of use by virtue of the design of the CB-4000." Id.
339510607
Degree
Substantially means to a large degree
Cambridge Dictionary
[Cambridge Academic Content Dictionary, substantially,
http://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/substantially, accessed
7-3-16, ZT]
substantially
adverb US
/sbstnli/
to a large degree:
Serious crime is down substantially.
substantially
1 To a great or significant extent:
profits grew substantially
S: (adv) well, considerably, substantially (to a great extent or degree ) "I'm afraid
the film was well over budget"; "painting the room white made it
339510607
339510607
Important
Substantial is of considerable importance, degree, amount, or
extent
American Heritage Dictionary 11
[American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language, Fifth Edition,
Substantial, Houghton Mifflin Harcourt Publishing Company,
http://www.thefreedictionary.com/substantially, accessed 7-3-16, ZT]
substantial (sb-stnshl)
adj.
1. Considerable in importance, value, degree, amount, or extent: made a substantial
improvement ; won by a substantial margin.
substantial
worthwhile; important : a substantial reform
339510607
Requires Context
Substantial must be determined by context
Words & Phrases, 2
(Vol. 40A, 2002, p. 464)
339510607
339510607
339510607
Meaningless
Substantial doesnt mean anything
Horowitz, J.D. Candidate, 13
[Colby, Fordham Law Review, v. 81, CREATING A MORE MEANINGFUL
DETENTION STATUTE: LESSONS LEARNED FROM HEDGES V. OBAMA,
http://fordhamlawreview.org/assets/pdfs/Vol_81/Horowitz_April.pdf, p. 28802881, accessed 7-23-13]
Substantial is ambiguous
Horowitz, J.D. Candidate, 13
[Colby, Fordham Law Review, v. 81, CREATING A MORE MEANINGFUL
DETENTION STATUTE: LESSONS LEARNED FROM HEDGES V. OBAMA,
http://fordhamlawreview.org/assets/pdfs/Vol_81/Horowitz_April.pdf, p. 2887-9,
accessed 7-23-13]
339510607
339510607
339510607
Increase
339510607
Violations
339510607
339510607
339510607
Increase
339510607
Make Greater
Increase is to make greater.
Random House Dictionary, 11
[Increase http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/increase, accessed 6-611, TP]
339510607
Increased, increasing
intransitive verb
1: to become progressively greater (as in size , amount, number, or intensity)
The house increased in value.
She increased her wealth substantially.
339510607
increase
VERB
Pronunciation: /inkrs/
Become or make greater in size, amount, intensity, or degree:
[NO OBJECT]: car use is increasing at an alarming rate
[WITH OBJECT]: we are aiming to increase awareness of social issues
(as adjective increasing) the increasing numbers of students
increase
verb [I or T] UK
/nkris/ US
339510607
S: (n) addition, increase, gain (a quantity that is added) " there was an addition
to property taxes this year"; "they recorded the cattle's gain in weight over a
period of weeks"
S: (n) increase (a change resulting in an increase) "the increase is
scheduled for next month"
S: (n) increase, increment, growth (a process of becoming larger or
longer or more numerous or more important) "the increase in
unemployment"; "the growth of population"
S: (n) increase, increment (the amount by which something increases) "they
proposed an increase of 15 percent in the fare"
S: (n) increase, step-up (the act of increasing something) "he gave me
an increase in salary"
339510607
Net Increase
Increase means net increase
Words and Phrases, 5
(Cumulative Supplementary Pamphlet, v. 20a, p. 295)
339510607
339510607
Greater in Frequency
Increase can be an expansion or growth in size, degree, and
frequency
Collins English Dictionary 12
[Increase, Dictionary.com, http://www.dictionary.com/browse/increase?s=t,
accessed 7-5-16, ZT]
increase
verb (nkris)
1.
to make or become greater in size, degree, frequency, etc; grow or expand
339510607
Progressive
An increase is progressive
Merriam Webster Dictionary
[Increase, MerriamWebsterDictionary.com, http://www.merriamwebster.com/dictionary/increase, accessed 7-5-16, ZT]
339510607
Must Be Preexisting
Increase requires pre-existence
Brown, Oregon District Court US Federal Judge, 3
[Anna J., 7-17-03, CourtListener, Elena Mark and Paul Gustafson, Plaintiffs, v.
Valley Insurance Company and Valley Property and Casualty, Defendants,
Lexis]
FCRA does not define the term "increase." The plain and ordinary
meaning of the verb "to increase" is to make something greater or
larger. 4 Merriam-Webster's [**22] Collegiate Dictionary 589 (10th ed.
1998). The "something" that is increased in the statute is the "charge for any
insurance." The plain and common meaning of the noun "charge" is "the
price demanded for something." Id. at 192. Thus, the statute plainly means
an insurer takes adverse action if the insurer makes greater (i.e., larger) the
price demanded for insurance.
An insurer cannot "make greater" something that did not exist
previously. The statutory definition of adverse action, therefore,
clearly anticipates an insurer must have made an initial charge or
demand for payment before the insurer can increase that charge. In
other words, an insurer cannot increase the charge for insurance unless the
insurer previously set and demanded payment of the premium for that
insured's insurance [**23] coverage at a lower price.
First, the court said that the ordinary meaning of the word increase is to
make something greater, which it believed should not be limited to cases
in which a company raises the rate that an individual has previously been
charged. 435 F.3d at 1091. Yet the definition offered by the Ninth Circuit
compels the opposite conclusion. Because increase means to make
something greater, there must necessarily have been an existing
339510607
339510607
Includes Create
Increase doesnt require pre-existence
Reinhardt, Ninth Circuit United States Appeals Court Judge, 5
[Stephen R., 8-4-05, FindLaw, Jason Ray REYNOLDS; Matthew Rausch,
Plaintiffs-Appellants, v. HARTFORD FINANCIAL SERVICES GROUP, INC.;
Hartford Fire Insurance Company, Defendants-Appellees., Lexis]
339510607
339510607
Not Extend
Increase means to make greater excludes extending duration
Martinez, Justice for the Supreme Court of Colorado, 6
(SUPREME COURT OF COLORADO, 129 P.3d 988; 2006 Colo. LEXIS 395,
Plaintiff-Appellee: DOUGLAS BRUCE, v. Defendants-Appellants: CITY OF
COLORADO SPRINGS and KATHRYN YOUNG, City Clerk, in her official capacity
as election officer for the city, 2/27, lexis)
Turning, then, to the language of section (3), itself, we assess the plain
meaning of "tax increase" as it appears in that section.
[*995] In examining "tax increase" as it appears in Amendment 1, we look to
the intent of the voter as it is an initiated constitutional provision. See In re
Interrogatories Relating to the Great Outdoors Colo. Trust Fund, 913 P.2d 533,
538 (Colo. 1996) ("[A] court's duty in interpreting a constitutional
amendment is to give effect to the will of the people in adopting such
amendment."). We also consider how the typical voter would interpret "tax
increase," because our concern here is how the form of the election notice
affects a voter's understanding of a proposed measure. Accordingly, we
consider whether the practical, everyday meaning of "increase" is
synonymous with "extension." A tax "extension" suggests the
continuation of a tax, whereas a tax "increase" suggests a greater
amount will be taxed. Accordingly, a proposal to "extend" a tax implies
that neither the amount nor rate of the tax will change from its
current rate. Likewise, a tax "increase" indicates that the [**22] tax
burden borne by an individual taxpayer will be greater than its
present amount. The former indicates a continuation of the status
quo, whereas the latter suggests a change that will impose a
greater cost on the taxpayer.
339510607
CONCLUSION
Because the consideration of written communication is the cornerstone of
the judicial process, the technique involved in that consideration has
intrigued the ages. That technique, judicial interpretation, [*434]
attempts a highly delicate balance. On the one hand, it acknowledges the
legendary imprecision of language. On the other hand, it seeks to
glean from that language the elusive signals of purpose, meaning
and intent. A "science" so inexact incessantly craves a semblance of
constants -- conventions assisting to impose order upon
understanding.
Roman law, and subsequently the English common-law system, sought to
appease this insatiable desire by offering up the canons of construction. The
canons, fundamental maxims of compositional meaning , have proved both
vulnerable and venerable. Their existence has provided an irresistible
historic target for a labyrinth of denigrating commentary. Yet the courts, the
construers themselves, have claimed the canons as their own, affording
them a determinative role in judicial decisionmaking which transverses the
spectrum of litigation. Accordingly, the critics are left with little choice
but to concede the canons' existence and shaping influence, while
pleading for caution in their invocation.
From the canonical mass, the most popular and powerful maxims of meaning
are perhaps the three here selected for treatment: Noscitur a sociis, Ejusdem
generis and Expressio unius est exclusio alterius. Although different, the
three precepts are also similar -- they counsel an analysis of associating what
is present with what is to be determined. The writer, they presume, meant
something by what he expressed; that expression, or at least a portion
of it, they insist, offers the best hope for resolving the ambiguity at hand.
As they occasionally broaden, frequently constrict and sometimes exclude,
339510607
339510607
Its
339510607
Violations
339510607
its
Syllabification: its
Pronunciation: /its/
Definition of its in English:
possessive determiner
1 Belonging to or associated with a thing previously mentioned or
easily identified:
turn the camera on its side
he chose the area for its atmosphere
339510607
The definite article in English is the. The indefinite articles in English are
a and an. Both singular and plural nouns can take the definite article.
Only singular nouns can take the indefinite article. The following
italicized determiners are examples of articles:
* The baby drank a bottle of milk.
* An apron is often worn by bakers.
* The shih tzu is a popular dog breed.
Articles are sometimes referred to simply as determiners.
339510607
339510607
339510607
339510607
Its
339510607
Possessive
Its means possessive
Macmillan Dictionary
[its, Macmillan Dictionary,
http://www.macmillandictionary.com/us/dictionary/american/its, accessed 815-15]
339510607
its
Also found in: Medical, Financial, Acronyms, Idioms, Encyclopedia, Wikipedia.
its (ts)
adj. The possessive form of it.
Used as a modifier before a noun: The airline canceled its early
flight to New York.
339510607
Belonging To
Its means belonging to a thing previously identified
Oxford Dictionary
[its, Oxford Dictionary,
http://www.oxforddictionaries.com/us/definition/american_english/its,
accessed 8-15-15]
its
Syllabification: its
Pronunciation: /its/
Definition of its in English:
possessive determiner
1 Belonging to or associated with a thing previously mentioned or
easily identified:
turn the camera on its side
he chose the area for its atmosphere
its
adjective \its, ts\
: relating to or belonging to a certain thing, animal, etc. : made or
done by a certain thing, animal, etc.
Full Definition of ITS
339510607
its
pronoun US
/ts, ts/
its (ts)
determiner
1.
a. of, belonging to, or associated in some way with it: its left rear
wheel.
b. (as pronoun): each town claims its is the best.
Collins English Dictionary Complete and Unabridged HarperCollins
Publishers 1991, 1994, 1998, 2000, 2003
its (ts)
339510607
pron.
the possessive form of it (used as an attributive adjective): The book has lost
its jacket. I'm sorry about its being so late.
[15901600; earlier it's= it + 's1]
usage: See me.
it's (ts)
1. contraction of it is: It's starting to rain.
2. contraction of it has: It's been a long time.
Random House Kernerman Webster's College Dictionary, 2010 K
Dictionaries Ltd. Copyright 2005, 1997, 1991 by Random House, Inc. All
rights reserved.
TranslationsSpanish / EspaolSelect a language:
its [ts]
A. POSS ADJ (with singular noun) su; (with plural noun) sus
everything in its place cada cosa en su sitio
it has its advantages tiene sus ventajas
the dog is losing its hair el perro est perdiendo el pelo
the bird was in its cage el pjaro estaba en su jaula
B. POSS PRON (el/la)suyo/a, (los/las)suyos/as
Collins Spanish Dictionary - Complete and Unabridged 8th Edition 2005
William Collins Sons & Co. Ltd. 1971, 1988 HarperCollins Publishers 1992,
1993, 1996, 1997, 2000, 2003, 2005
its
su
Multilingual Translator HarperCollins Publishers 2009
It isn't holding its charge (US)
It's not holding its charge (UK)
No conserva la carga
Collins Multilingual Translator HarperCollins Publishers 2009
339510607
339510607
339510607
World Bank, help countries to overcome such collective action problems and
provide greater amounts of public goods for more countries generally.5
339510607
339510607
339510607
339510607
339510607
Economic Engagement
339510607
Economic Engagement
339510607
Long-Term
Economic engagement with Asia includes a breadth of
interaction
Rivkin, Assistant Secretary of State for Economic and Business
Affairs, 15
[Charles H., May 14, 2015, US Department of State, Advancing U.S.
Economic Engagement in Asia,
http://www.state.gov/e/eb/rls/rm/2015/242411.htm, accessed: July 2,
2016 //SL]
My testimony has only hinted at the breadth and complexity of our economic
engagement with the Asia -Pacific. It is as diverse and vibrant as the
region itself. Beyond the areas Ive discussed today we are engaged
on intellectual property rights, development finance, and sanctions,
to name but a few more issues. Through this all-encompassing web
of economic initiatives we and our regional partners are building a
stronger region that is even more vibrant and dynamic.
339510607
Agriculture
Economic engagement includes investment in agriculture,
manufacturing, and service industries
Dr. Adelman, Center for Science in Public Policy Director, 5
[Carol C., Jeremiah Norris, Senior Fellow, Jean Weicher, Research Associate,
June 28, 2005, Americas Total Economic Engagement with the Developing
World: Rethinking the Uses and Nature of Foreign Aid,
http://www.issuelab.org/resources/19603/19603.pdf, accessed 7-3-16]
339510607
Incentives
Economic engagement involves tangible incentives
Haass, Brookings Foreign Policy Studies director, 2000
[Richard N., Honey and Vinegar: Incentives, Sanctions, and Foreign Policy, p.
5, Google Books]
339510607
339510607
339510607
The United States and China are furthering economic engagement with
ASEAN countries in several ways.
Trade agreements . The United States has a free trade agreement (FTA) with
one ASEAN country, Singapore, while China has an FTA with all 10 ASEAN
countries. The United States and China are each party to separate
regional trade agreement negotiationsthe United States through the
Trans- Pacific Partnership and China through the Regional
Comprehensive Economic Partnership. Chinas existing FTAs do not
address aspects of trade addressed in the U.S.-Singapore FTA, such as
intellectual property, the environment, and labor rights.
Support for firms . From 2009 through 2014, U.S. agencies provided
approximately $6 billion in financing for U.S. firms in ASEAN
countries. China reports billions of dollars more in financing than the United
States worldwide, but data on Chinas financing in Southeast Asia are
unavailable.
Support for regional integration . In fiscal years 2009 through 2013, U.S.
agencies provided $536 million in trade capacity building assistance to
ASEAN countries. China has promised tens of billions of dollars for
infrastructure development through new funds and multilateral
institutions like the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank, expected to
begin operations in 2015.
339510607
339510607
Tech
Economic engagement is tech assistance, market-based trade,
and investment
Delury, Yonsei University Graduate School of International
Studies Chinese Studies professor & Global Studies Chair, 12
[John, 4-26-12, American Foreign Policy Interests: The Journal of the National
Committee on American Foreign Policy, Volume 34, Issue 2, Triple-Pronged
Engagement: China's Approach to North Korea, p. 71-72, Taylor & Francis.]
Economic engagement includes state-backed assistance, marketbased provincial trade, and long-term strategic investment.
Assistance includes technical assistance, knowledge sharing and
human capacity building in effect, educating North Korean counterparts
on the China model of market transition and authoritarian capitalism.
339510607
Economic
339510607
Commodities
Economic means relating to commodities
Random House Dictionary
[Dictionary.com Unabridged, Random House, Inc. 04 Jul. 2016, Economic,
http://www.dictionary.com/browse/economic, accessed July 3, 2016 //SL]
adjective
1. pertaining to the production, distribution, and use of income,
wealth, and commodities.
339510607
Industry/Resources
Economic requires relation to industry or material resources
Merriam-Webster
[Merriam-Webster.com, n.d., Economic, http://www.merriamwebster.com/dictionary/economic, accessed: July 5, 2016 //SL]
339510607
Production
Economic means relating the economy, specifically production
Random House Dictionary
[Dictionary.com Unabridged, Random House, Inc. 04 Jul. 2016, Economic,
http://www.dictionary.com/browse/economic, accessed July 3, 2016 //SL]
339510607
economic
Pronunciation: /eknmik/ /knmik/
ADJECTIVE
1 Relating to economics or the economy:
the governments economic policy
pest species of great economic importance
More example sentences
Negotiations have been complicated by court rulings over economic policy.
The two political leaders conduct their argument on the margins of economic
policy.
Getting the public finances back into balance must be a key objective of
economic policy.
Get more examples
339510607
339510607
339510607
Profitability
Economic means justified in terms of profitability
Oxford Dictionaries
[Oxford University Press, Economic,
http://www.oxforddictionaries.com/us/definition/american_english/economic,
accessed: July 3, 2016 //SL]
339510607
/eknmk/
Contribute to our Open Dictionary
Related words
economic cycle NOUN
economic migrant NOUN
economic indicator NOUN
Black Economic Empowerment NOUN
leading economic indicator NOUN
economic/medical aid
economic/moral decline
339510607
financial/economic ruin
economic/industrial growth
economic/financial independence
political/financial/economic clout
peace/economic/trade/nuclear accord
economic/social/health consequences
financial/economic/political crisis
social/economic/racial/sexual inequality
an economic/political/employment situation
economic/political/moral/intellectual climate
from an economic/legal/political etc. standpoint
economically depressed/devastated/disadvantaged
a moral/political/economic imperative
more dictionary definitions
CollocatesNouns frequently used with economic
339510607
339510607
Engagement
339510607
Violations
339510607
339510607
Incentives work on a quid pro quo basis this for that. If you change
your behavior, Ill give you a reward. One could say that coercion is an
incentive program do as I say and Ill let you live. However, I define an
incentive as getting something you didnt have before in exchange for new
behavior, so that pretty much puts coercion in its own box, one separate
from incentives. But fundamental problems plague the incentive approach.
Like coercion, incentives are poor motivators in the long run, for at least two
reasons unintended consequences and perverse incentives.
339510607
actors all the time simply by interacting with them . To be a meaningful subject of
analysis , the term engagement must refer to something more specific than a
policy of non-isolation. As used in this article, engagement refers to
a foreign-policy strategy which depends to a significant degree on
positive incentives to achieve its objectives. Certainly, it does not preclude
the simultaneous use of other foreign-policy instruments such as sanctions
or military force: in practice, there is often considerable overlap of
strategies, particularly when the termination or lifting of sanctions
is used as a positive inducement. Yet the distinguishing feature of
American engagement strategies is their reliance on the extension
or provision of incentives to shape the behaviour of countries with
which the US has important disagreements.
339510607
Conditional Engagement
The conditional engagement strategy is conducted on the
government-to-government level and requires reciprocity by the
target state on essentially a contractual basis. It is typically focused
on a discrete issue but can be broadened to encompass a range of
issues in a "grand bargain" (as some have proposed in the case of Iran).
"Conditional reciprocity" is a form of conditional engagement, elucidated by
George, in which meaningful changes in behavior by the target state would
be explicitly linked to each concession or benefit bestowed by the United
States.45 The engagement of an adversary under conditional
reciprocity has three key features , which clearly distinguish this strategy from
appeasement . First, the inducement must be tied to specific policy changes
in the target state's behavior, not general expectations of improved
behavior. Second, the reward should come only after the specific change
in behavior. If the reward is provided in advance of behavior
modification or is not linked to a specific behavioral change, it may be
legitimately criticized as a bribe . And, third, such an approach
depends on mutual adherence to the specific conditional reciprocal
steps in the sequence. If the target state does not fulfill its
obligations, the process can be halted and the benefit withdrawn .46
339510607
339510607
339510607
339510607
Literature of liberal school points out that economic engagement policies are
significantly effective tools for sender and target countries. The effectiveness
leans on mutual economic and political benefits for both parties.(Garzke et
al,2001). Economic engagement operates with trade mechanisms where
sender and target country establish intensified trade thus increase the
economic interaction over time. This strategy decreases the potential
hostilities and provides mutual gains. Paulson Jr (2008) states that this
mechanism is highly different from carrots (inducements ). Carrots work quid
pro quo in short terms and for narrow goals. Economic engagement
intends to develop the target country and wants her to be aware of the long
term benefits of shared economic goals. Sender does not want to contain nor
prevent the target country with different policies. Conversely; sender works
deliberately to improve the target countries Gdp, trade potential, exportimport ratios and national income. Sender acts in purpose to reach important
goals. First it establishes strong economic ties because economic integration
has the capacity to change the political choices and behaviour of target
country. Sender state believes in that economic linkages have political
transformation potential. (Kroll,1993)
339510607
339510607
339510607
http://www.defense.gov/Portals/1/Documents/pubs/2015_China_Military_Powe
r_Report.pdf, p. 16, accessed 7-8-16]
339510607
and human rights among a countrys armed forces and, more feasibly, to
establish relationships between Americans and young foreign military
officers.4 These areas of engagement are likely to involve, working with
state institutions, while cultural or civil society engagement is likely to entail
building people-to-people contacts. Funding nongovernmental
organizations, facilitating the flow of remittances, establishing
postal and telephone links between the United States and the target
country, and promoting the exchange of students, tourists, and other
nongovernmental people between the countries are some of the
incentives that might be offered under a policy of cultural engagement .
This brief overview of the various forms of engagement illuminates the
choices open to policymakers. The plethora of options signals the flexibility
of engagement as a foreign policy strategy and, in doing so, reveals
one of the real strengths of engagement. At the same time, it also suggests
the urgent need for considered analysis of this strategy. The purpose of this
book is to address this need by deriving insights and lessons from past
episodes of engagement and proposing guidelines for the future use of
engagement strategies. Throughout the book, two critical questions are
entertained. First, when should policymakers consider engagement? A
strategy of engagement may serve certain foreign policy objectives better
than others. Specific characteristics of a target country may make it more
receptive to a strategy of engagement and the incentives offered under it; in
other cases, a country's domestic politics may effectively exclude the use of
engagement strategies. Second, how should engagement strategies be
managed to maximize the chances of success? Shedding light on how
policymakers achieved, or failed, in these efforts in the past is critical in an
evaluation of engagement strategies. By focusing our analysis , these
questions and concerns help produce a framework to guide the use of
engagement strategies in the upcoming decades.
339510607
339510607
339510607
339510607
339510607
339510607
http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/10576100902888479?
journalCode=uter20, pg. 512, accessed: July 8, 2016 //SL]
339510607
339510607
Engagement Definitions
339510607
339510607
Kim and Easley prefer the United States current policy to a grand
bargain. Both recommend some modifications designed to reassure and
engage China , including joint participation in humanitarian missions,
naval cooperation on counter-piracy operations, deepening of
economic interdependence via the U.S.-China bilateral investment
treaty, and support of initiatives that would increase Chinas role in
international organizations. As I argue in my article, there is much to like
about the current U.S. policy toward China and East Asia more broadly. If the
United States adheres to this policy, then many of these recommendations
would be useful refinements.
339510607
339510607
Beginning when President Obama met President Xi for the first time
formally at Sunnylands... we agreed that we did not believe conflict
was inevitable between China and the United States, a rising power
and an established power, and we agreed that we would work to
make sure that rivalry didn't become inevitable. So that's the basic
framework for our relationship, and we think we've succeeded in
accomplishing that in recent years.4
To help make Beijing more cooperative, Washington can shape its
choices, according to Bader:
Underlying our approach was a clear understanding that our
political, security, and economic policies in Asia needed to be
grounded in traditional state-to-state relations and a commitment to shaping
the choices of emerging powers like China through our diplomacy
and deployments.5
But how to shape China's choices? To establish "a modicum of trust
between U.S. and Chinese leaders so that there could be political
incentives for cooperation," Bader recalls that Obama's Asia team built
a China strategy based on "three pillars," which can be considered the
pillars of engagement:6
(1) a welcoming approach to China's emergence, influence, and
legitimate expanded role;
(2) resolve to see that its rise is consistent with international norms
and law;
(3) endeavor to shape the Asia-Pacific environment to ensure China's
rise is stabilizing rather than disruptive.7
The goal, according to Steinberg and O'Hanlon, is to shape "China's
interpretation of U.S. strategy" and its "leaders' assessments of U.S.
intentions." They argue that: "Washington can craft its own policies in
ways that will call forth reciprocal, positive Chinese actions.8
Chinese assessments range from one extreme that the United States is
determined to maintain its hegemonic position and resist China's rise. At the
other, they accept the argument that the United States is prepared to 'share
power.'"9 The chances to avoid hostilities can be improved if "U.S.
policymakers can reinforce the domestic political forces in China that are
likely to support constructive Chinese strategies." By empowering Chinese
moderates U.S. policymakers will reduce the possibility that more hawkish
leaders will push China toward aggression. Thus, by reiterating the U.S.'
339510607
willingness to share power with China Washington can reduce the chances of
conflict with Beijing.
In practice, this engagement-based China strategy means that
scores (if not hundreds) of U.S. policymakers in numerous
government agencies correspond regularly with their Chinese
counterparts across a wide breadth of issues. In September 2014,
President Xi Jinping said there were over 90 official mechanisms for
U.S.-China exchange.10
339510607
339510607
the urgent need for considered analysis of this strategy. The purpose of this
book is to address this need by deriving insights and lessons from past
episodes of engagement and proposing guidelines for the future use of
engagement strategies. Throughout the book, two critical questions are
entertained. First, when should policymakers consider engagement? A
strategy of engagement may serve certain foreign policy objectives better
than others. Specific characteristics of a target country may make it more
receptive to a strategy of engagement and the incentives offered under it; in
other cases, a country's domestic politics may effectively exclude the use of
engagement strategies. Second, how should engagement strategies be
managed to maximize the chances of success? Shedding light on how
policymakers achieved, or failed, in these efforts in the past is critical in an
evaluation of engagement strategies. By focusing our analysis , these
questions and concerns help produce a framework to guide the use of
engagement strategies in the upcoming decades.
339510607
military engagement
(DOD) Routine contact and interaction between individuals or
elements of the Armed Forces of the United States and those of
another nation's armed forces, or foreign and domestic civilian
authorities or agencies to build trust and confidence, share
information, coordinate mutual activities, and maintain influence.
Source: JP 3-0
339510607
Presidential Level
Engagement must be sustained through bilateral or
multilateral efforts at the presidential and cabinet levels
Brown et al, George Washington University Elliott School of
International Affairs Dean, 13
[Michael E., Timothy J.A. Adamson, Mike M. Mochizuki, Deepa Ollapally,
Robert G. Sutter, Elliott School of International Affairs Master of Arts
graduate, Elliott School of International Affairs Political Science and
International Affairs Associate Professor, Elliott School of International Affairs
International Affairs Associate Research Professor, Elliott School of
International Affairs International Affairs Professor of Practice, 8-13,
Balancing Acts: The U.S. Rebalance and Asia-Pacific Stability, p. 15, NVM]
339510607
Interdependence
Engagement is limited by a three pronged test (a) status quo
involvement must be low, (b) the material need of the target
must be high, and (c) the target must perceive the engager as
the solution for that need
Resnick, Yeshiva University Political Science professor, 1
[Evan, 2001, Journal of International Affairs, Spring, 54(2), Defining
Engagement,, https://www.jstor.org/stable/24357749?
seq=1#page_scan_tab_contents, pg. 560-561, JSTOR, accessed July 5,
2016 //SL]
This definition implies that three necessary conditions must hold for
engagement to constitute an effective foreign policy instrument. First , the
overall magnitude of contacts between the sender and target states
must initially be low . If two states are already bound by dense contacts
in multiple domains (i.e., are already in a highly interdependent relationship),
engagement loses its impact as an effective policy tool. Hence, on could not
reasonable invoke the possibility of the US engaging Canada or Japan in
order to effect a change in either countrys political behavior. Second , the
material or prestige needs of the target state must be significant . As
engagement derives its power from the promise that it can fulfill
those needs. The greater the needs of the target state, the more amenable
the engagement by the US dramatically increased in the wake of the demise
of its chief patron, the Soviet Union, and the near-total collapse of its national
economy.28
Third , the target state must perceive the engager and the
international order it represents as a potential source of the
material or prestige resources it desires. This means that autarkic,
revolutionary and unlimited regimes which eschew the norms and
institutions of the prevailing order, such as Stalins Soviet Union or Hitlers
Germany, will not be seduced by the potential benefits of engagement.
339510607
339510607
339510607
Modify Perspective
Engagement is direct talks used to change a countrys
perspective and modify it
Crocker, Georgetown University Strategic Studies Professor, 9
[Chester A., 9-13-9, Terms of Engagement,
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/09/14/opinion/14crocker.html?_r=1, NYT,
accessed 7-3-16, ZT]
339510607
Positivity
Engagement is continuance and promotion of positivity
Sheen, Seoul National University international security
Assistant professor, 2
[Seongho, Spring 2002, The Korean Journal of Defense Analysis, Vol XIV, no.
1, US Strategy of Engagement During the Cold War and Its Implication for
Sunshine Policy, Pg. 211,
http://www.kida.re.kr/data/2006/04/14/seongho_sheen.pdf, accessed 7-3-16,
ZT]
Can the sunshine policy really bring positive changes within the North Korean
regime and peace to the Korean peninsula? The logic behind Kim Dae-jungs
policy is a refinement of one of the major strategies of economic statecraft
and military competition. In his discussion of US economic statecraft towards
the Soviet Union during the Cold War, Michael Mastanduno provides a useful
framework for understanding President Kims engagement policy towards the
North. In general, engagement promotes positive relations with an enemy as a
means of changing the behavior or policies of a target government. It accepts the
legitimacy of that government and tries to shape its conduct.
Engagement also requires the establishment and continuance of political
communication with the target. In engaging the enemy, the state sees
political polarization with target or isolation of the target country as
undesirable.
339510607
Positive Incentives
Engagement involves the use of positive incentives to alter
another states behavior
Borer, Naval Postgraduate School Department of Defense
Analysis Associate Professor, 4
[Dr. Douglas A., 7-4, Problems of Economic Statecraft: Rethinking
Engagement, Chapter 12, U.S. Army War College Guide to National Security
Policy & Strategy, p. 169, NVM]
339510607
state? In other words, why did the United States not use its significant power
over Iraq?
339510607
Avoid Conflict
Diplomatic engagement involves communication to avoid
conflict
Maller, MIT, Security Studies Program, 09
[Tara, 2009, Studies in Conflict & Terrorism, 32:511536, The Dangers of
Diplomatic Disengagement in Counterterrorism,
http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/10576100902888479?
journalCode=uter20, pg. 512, accessed: July 8, 2016 //SL]
339510607
Involvement
Engagement requires involvement
WordNet, Princeton University Cognitive Science Laboratory
[engagement, http://wordnetweb.princeton.edu/perl/webwn?
s=engagement&sub=Search+WordNet&o2=&o0=1&o8=1&o1=1&o7=&o5=
&o9=&o6=&o3=&o4=&h=, accessed 5-15-16]
Noun
S: (n) battle, conflict, fight, engagement (a hostile meeting of opposing
military forces in the course of a war) "Grant won a decisive victory in the
battle of Chickamauga"; "he lost his romantic ideas about war when he got
into a real engagement"
S: (n) date, appointment, engagement (a meeting arranged in advance) "she
asked how to avoid kissing at the end of a date"
S: (n) betrothal, troth, engagement (a mutual promise to marry)
S: (n) employment, engagement (the act of giving someone a job)
S: (n) engagement, booking (employment for performers or performing
groups that lasts for a limited period of time) "the play had bookings
throughout the summer"
S: (n) engagement, mesh, meshing, interlocking (contact by fitting together)
"the engagement of the clutch"; "the meshing of gears"
S: (n) engagement, participation, involvement, involution (the act of
sharing in the activities of a group) "the teacher tried to increase
his students' engagement in class activities"
Engagement is involvement
Macmillan Dictionary
[Engagement, Macmillan Dictionary,
http://www.macmillandictionary.com/us/dictionary/american/engagement,
accessed 5-15-16]
339510607
339510607
339510607
Agreement
Engagement is an agreement
Ballentines Law Dictionary, 1969
[engagement, 3rd edition, edited by James A. Ballentine,
http://citizenlaw.com/pdf/e.pdf, accessed 5-16-16]
339510607
Diplomatic Relations
Engagement is diplomatic relations
Maller, New America Foundation National Security Studies
Program research fellow, 5-29-09
[Tara, 5-29-09, Studies in Conflict & Terrorism, The Dangers of Diplomatic
Disengagement in Counterterrorism, p. 512, Vol. 32, Iss. 6, Taylor & Francis]
339510607
339510607
339510607
339510607
Obligation
Engagement is an obligation
Black's Law Dictionary Free Online Legal Dictionary
[Black's Law Dictionary Free Online Legal Dictionary 2nd Ed., What is
ENGAGEMENT? definition of ENGAGEMENT (Black's Law Dictionary),
http://thelawdictionary.org/engagement/, accessed 5-16-16]
What is ENGAGEMENT?
In French law. A contract. The obligation arising from a quasi contract
The terms obligation and engagement are said to be
synonymous, (17 Toullier, no. 1;) but the Code seems specially to apply the
term engagement to those obligations which the law imposes on a man
without the intervention of any contract, either on the part of the obligor or
the obligee, (article 1370.) An engagement to do or omit to do
something amounts to a promise. Rue v. Rue, 21 N. J. Law, 309. In
English practice. The term has been appropriated to denote a contract
entered into by a married woman with the intention of binding or charging
her separate estate, or, with stricter accuracy, a promise which in the case of
a person sui juris would be a contract. but in the case of a married woman is
not a contract because she cannot bind herself personally, even in equity.
Her engagements, therefore, merely operate as dispositions or appointments
pro tanto of her separate estate.
339510607
Unconditional Generic
Engagement is unconditional conditioning runs counter to
engagement
Smith, London School of Economics foreign policy Professor
and director, 5
[Karen E, May, Engagement and conditionality: incompatible or mutually
reinforcing?, Global Europe: New Terms of Engagement,
http://fpc.org.uk/fsblob/484.pdf, Pg. 23, accessed 7-3-16, ZT]
339510607
339510607
Non-Punitive
Punitive measures are the opposite of engagement in both
diplomatic and economic contexts
Maller, MIT, Security Studies Program, 09
[Tara, 2009, Studies in Conflict & Terrorism, 32:511536, The Dangers of
Diplomatic Disengagement in Counterterrorism,
http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/10576100902888479?
journalCode=uter20, pg. 512, accessed: July 8, 2016 //SL]
339510607
339510607
The U.S. government has recently begun to emphasize the need for
greater engagement with problem states. Proponents of this approach
argue that diplomacy is necessary, even with these regimes. Critics,
however, maintain that engagement with these regimes is tantamount to
appeasement and signals acceptance of behavior that ought to be
condemned. In their view, there is little to be gained by talking to these
states. Thus, diplomatic sanctions or sanctions characterized by political
disengagement are seen as a low-cost means of isolating and
delegitimizing regimes.
339510607
Yet a state can take two different strategies in engaging its enemy to
influence the behavior or policies of a target government in positive way.
First, a government may condition or calibrate engagement according to
changes in target behavior. Conditioned engagement strategy rewards good
behavior by promoting engagement and punishes bad behavior by restricting
engagement. To be effective, the engaging state must employ both positive and
negative measures in order to maintain credibility . Positive engagement can
bring concessions only if the target is convinced that it will be
removed if the concessions are not forthcoming.
339510607
Conditionality Generic
For the aff to use conditionality effectively they must prove the
following four things:
1.
2.
3.
4.
In the case of policy towards the EUs neighbours, a mix of engagement and
conditionality is unlikely to be effective because of the double standards
problem: some neighbours will want to know why they are subject to
conditionality while others are merely engaged. And it is clear that the EU
cannot just engage with several of its neighbours, precisely because it would
be seen as rewarding bad behaviour but also because engagement is
unlikely to work in practice given conditions in some of the neighbours
(Belarus is arguably the most obvious example here). Creating ties without
strings is infeasible and impractical. Therefore, to try to avoid the pitfalls of using
conditionality in its neighbourhood policy, the EU could do the following: 28
Global Europe
1) Ensure that the benefits on offer are desirable to the neighbours. All but institutions
should mean what it implies , and the EU should be much more generous and
open than it has so far indicated it will be. At the very least, this entails
promising additional aid, softer visa requirements, and freer trade in
agricultural products. Not only could this inspire reformers to
undertake hard political and economic choices, but the benefits
themselves once extended could reinforce processes of reform,
because such engagement can help create the basis for lasting change. The
Neighbourhood Policy has been launched because the EU is trying rightly
to reduce the effects of exclusion, of leaving out countries from the
enlarging EU. This means minimising the importance of the border between
the enlarging EU and its neighbours - as it stands, the Neighbourhood Policy
does not yet do this sufficiently.
339510607
2) Be clear about what neighbours must do to earn the benefits on offer and then
follow through with extending them . This means setting clear benchmarks, to
use the European Commissions original language. This will also require the
EU to be much clearer about all of its policy priorities with respect to
particular neighbours including the promotion of human rights and
democracy, and the fight against terrorism, organised crime, the
proliferation of weapons of mass destruction, or illegal immigration.
Better yet, the EU needs to think about how best it could combine such
policy objectives so as to avoid having them cancel each other out. For
example, the fight against illegal immigration should not entail the violation
of the human rights of presumed illegals on the EUs periphery.
3) Just as the conditions for the benefits on offer need to be made clear, so do the
conditions for having such benefits withdrawn or other negative measures taken . And
again, the EU must follow through. It does not make sense to insert New
Terms of Engagement 29 human rights clauses in all the EUs agreements
with its neighbours and then not utilise them when human rights violations
occur. Of course, this means that all of the member states and the
EU institutions - will need to agree to use negative measures in
certain circumstances, and such agreement in an enlarged EU could
continue to be quite difficult. Yet if the EU is to derive leverage from its policy
instruments, then it must be firmer in its demands on third countries
including the southern Mediterranean countries, where until recently the EU
was very hesitant to insist on political and economic reform. As the European
Security Strategy promises, the EU should not hesitate to withdraw benefits
if conditions are not fulfilled. Needless to say, it should ensure that it
acts consistently, that all countries are treated similarly.
4) Finally, any actor that seeks to impose conditionality should ensure that its own house is
in order . The treatment of third country nationals and asylum seekers within
the EU, the democratic deficit, the failure of member states to implement
EC laws on time and in full all of these do not help to give the EU legitimacy
when making demands on its neighbours. And without legitimacy, the
EUs influence will suffer.
339510607
AT Negative Conditionality
Negative conditionality is bad; it ignores human rights
violations
Smith, London School of Economics foreign policy professor
and director, 5
[Karen E, May, Engagement and conditionality: incompatible or mutually
reinforcing?, Global Europe: New Terms of Engagement,
http://fpc.org.uk/fsblob/484.pdf, Pg. 23, accessed 7-3-16, ZT]
339510607
339510607
strong signal about U.S. willingness and desire to communicate and creates
substantial barriers to doing so.
339510607
Engage
339510607
Active
Engage is active
Ballentines Law Dictionary, 1969
[engage, 3rd edition, edited by James A. Ballentine,
http://citizenlaw.com/pdf/e.pdf, accessed 5-16-16]
339510607
Attention
Engage is to keep attention
Macmillan Dictionary
[engage, Macmillan Dictionary,
http://www.macmillandictionary.com/us/dictionary/american/engage,
accessed 5-15-16]
/ned/Word Forms
Related words
engage in PHRASAL VERB
engage with PHRASAL VERB
enter into/engage in a transaction
engage someone in conversation
339510607
Explore Thesaurus
2 [INTRANSITIVE/TRANSITIVE] if a part of a machine engages, or if you
engage it, it fits into another part so that they work together
A microswitch in the gear shift automatically engages and disengages the
clutch.
The mechanism failed to engage, causing a fault.
Synonyms and related words
To make a machine or piece of equipment work:activate, actuate, coax...
Explore Thesaurus
Synonyms and related words
To work, or to start working (of a piece of machinery):operate, come on,
function...
Explore Thesaurus
3 [INTRANSITIVE/TRANSITIVE] FORMAL to start to fight with an enemy in
battle
Synonyms and related words
Fighting in a war and relating to fighting in a war:active duty, active service,
aggressor...
339510607
Involve
Engage is to cause someone to become involved in an activity,
to fit one part of a machine into another so they move
together, to attack or begin to fight an enemy, and to arrange
to employ someone
Cambridge Academic Content Dictionary
[Engage, Cambridge Academic Content Dictionary,
http://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/engage, accessed 7-516, NVM]
339510607
339510607
339510607
Dictionary Lists
Engage is to occupy the attention or efforts of, to secure for
aid, to attract and hold fast, to attract or please, etc.
Dictionary.com
[Engage, Dictionary.com Unabridged,
http://www.dictionary.com/browse/engage, accessed 7-5-16, NVM]
339510607
339510607
339510607
339510607
In essence her method of engaging with people and thus creating action can
be defined as a type of leadership that gains momentum from common
cause.
3 (With reference to a part of a machine or engine) move into position so as
to come into operation:
[NO OBJECT]: the clutch will not engage
[WITH OBJECT]: he engaged the gears and pulled out into the road
When a data cartridge is inserted into the data storage system, the
cartridge directly or indirectly engages and moves the shield from the first
position to the second position.
The Patrol has a part-time, four-wheel drive system, which can be engaged
on the move at speeds up to 40 kph.
I found a big sweet spot where the clutch lets the gears engage after raising
the pedal a few inches.
4 [WITH OBJECT] (Of fencers or swordsmen) bring (weapons) together
preparatory to fighting.
Engage your brain before you engage your weapon.
The sword darted out as he'd expected, engaging his dagger, and the knife
drove forward for his belly, but his left hand struck like a serpent.
Suddenly he lunged and engaged his opponent's sword.
4.1 Enter into conflict or combat with (an enemy).
When a unit is engaged by an enemy force, it is likely that the commander
will react by maneuvering forces to counter the enemy and, if possible, to
pursue any evading forces.
Our soldiers engaged hostile enemies in combat, preserved peace on
strange frontiers and symbolized American values both at home and abroad.
Mongol commanders would also send portions of their force well past and
around the enemy lines while the main body engaged the enemy army.
339510607
And/Or
339510607
And/Or
339510607
And/or Either/Both
And/or is inclusive and can be one or both options
Adams, University of Pennsylvania Law Lecturer & Kaye, Cal
State University-Fullerton English professor, 7
[Kenneth and Alan, June 2007, St. Johns Law Review, And and or in legal
drafting, http://www.adamsdrafting.com/downloads/Ambiguity-And-Or.pdf,
p. 25-6, accessed 7-2-16, ZT]
AND/OR Drafters sometimes use and/or to convey the meaning of the inclusive or .
Judges and legal-writing commentators have fulminated against use of
and/or,75 but it has gained greater acceptance among general authorities.76
It does, after all, have a specific meaning X and/or Y means X or Y or
both . One could use Acme may dissolve Subsidiary A and/or Subsidiary B as
an alternative to [13b]. (X, Y, and/or Z means X or Y or Z or any two or more
of them).
and/or (ndr)
conj.
Used to indicate that either or both of the items connected by it are
involved.
Usage Note: And/or is widely used in legal and business writing. Its use in
general writing to mean "one or the other or both" is acceptable but can
appear stilted. See Usage Note at or1
339510607
The legal phrase and/or, indicating that you can either choose
between two alternatives or choose both of them, has proved
irresistible in other contexts and is now widely acceptable though it irritates
some readers as jargon. However, you can logically use it only when you
are discussing choices which may or may not both be done: Bring
chips and/or beer. Its very much overused where simple or would do,
and it would be wrong to say, you can get to the campus for this mornings
meeting on a bike and/or in a car. Choosing one eliminates the possibility of
the other, so this isnt an and/or situation.
339510607
and/or
Either or both of two stated possibilities:
audio and/or video components
More example sentences
What's your favorite thing to eat (and/or drink) on the bike?
339510607
And/or is used to only convey the or, means you cant do both
Adams, University of Pennsylvania Law Lecturer & Kaye, Cal
State University-Fullerton English professor, 7
[Kenneth and Alan, June 2007, St. Johns Law Review, And and or in
legal drafting, http://www.adamsdrafting.com/downloads/Ambiguity-AndOr.pdf, p. 26, accessed 7-2-16, ZT]
On the other hand, X or Y or both is generally clearer than and/or. And
drafters sometimes use and/or when the only possible meaning is that conveyed by
or : Acme shall incorporate Subsidiary in Delaware and/or New York.
On balance, it is best to avoid and/or.
339510607
And
339510607
Together
339510607
Consequence
And includes a consequence
Collins English Dictionary 12 [ and, Collins English Dictionary
complete and unabridged, http://www.dictionary.com/browse/and?s=t,
accessed 7-5-16, ZT]
and
/nd; unstressed nd; n/
conjunction (coordinating)
1.
along with; in addition to: boys and girls
2.
as a consequence : he fell down and cut his knee
3.
afterwards: we pay the man and go through that door
339510607
Joined
And connects things that are meant as a joint statement.
OxfordDictionaries.com ND [ and, Oxford Dictionaries,
http://www.oxforddictionaries.com/us/definition/american_english/and,
accessed 7-5-16, ZT]
Used to connect words of the same part of speech, clauses, or sentences that are to be taken
jointly:
bread and butter
red and black tiles
they can read and write
a hundred and fifty
339510607
Strengthens
And has to make the two added things stronger
Cambridge Academic Content Dictionary ND [ and, Cambridge
University Press, http://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/and?
q=And, accessed 7-5-16, ZT]
and conjunction (VERY)
(used to join two words, esp. two that are the same, to make their meaning
stronger ):
The sound grew louder and louder.
339510607
Interjection
And is an interjection or question
OxfordDictionaries.com ND [ and, Oxford Dictionaries,
http://www.oxforddictionaries.com/us/definition/american_english/and,
accessed 7-5-16, ZT]
Used to introduce an additional comment or interjection:
if it came to a choice and this was the worst thing she would turn her back on
her parents
they believe they are descended from him, and quite right, too
More example sentences
2. 1Used to introduce a question in connection with what someone else has just
said:
I found the letter in her bag. And did you steam it open?
339510607
Slash
339510607
339510607
Or
339510607
Or Alternatives
or1
/; unstressed /
conjunction (coordinating)
1.
used to join alternatives : apples or pears, apples or pears or cheese, apples,
pears, or cheese
2.
used to join rephrasings of the same thing: to serve in the army, or rather to
fight in the army, twelve, or a dozen
3.
used to join two alternatives when the first is preceded by either or whether:
whether it rains or not we'll be there, either yes or no
339510607
Diplomatic Engagement
339510607
Violations
339510607
339510607
339510607
Adjective
S: (adj) diplomatic (relating to or characteristic of diplomacy)
"diplomatic immunity"
S: (adj) diplomatic, diplomatical (using or marked by tact in dealing with
sensitive matters or people) "the hostess averted a confrontation with a
diplomatic chenage of subject"
339510607
339510607
It is Obama's declared engagement policy that has raised the ire of critics
and led them to once more take refuge in the spurious yet incendiary charge
of appeasement. Columnist Charles Krauthammer recently exclaimed, "When
France chides you for appeasement, you know you're scraping bottom."
Acknowledgement of America's misjudgments is derided as an unseemly
apologia while diplomacy is denigrated as a misguided exercise in selfdelusion. After all, North Korea continues to test its nuclear weapons and
missiles, Cuba spurns America's offers of a greater opening, and the Iranian
mullahs contrive conspiracy theories about how George Soros and the CIA
are instigating a velvet revolution in their country. Tough-minded
conservatives are urging a course correction and a resolute approach to the
gallery of rogues that the president pledges to embrace.
Such views miscast the essence of diplomatic engagement. Diplomacy is
likely to be a painstaking process and it may not work with every
targeted nation. However, the purpose of such a policy is not to transform
adversaries into allies, but to seek adjustments in their behavior and ambitions. North
Korea, Cuba, Syria, and Iran would be offered a path toward
realizing their essential national interests should they conform to
global conventions on issues such as terrorism and proliferation.
339510607
339510607
Diplomatic Engagement
339510607
Adjustments in Behavior
Diplomatic engagement only involves seeking adjustments in
behavior and ambitions, not transforming adversaries into
allies
Takeyh, Council on Foreign Relations Middle Eastern Studies
senior fellow, 9
[Ray, 10-7-09, Council on Foreign Relations, The Essence of Diplomatic
Engagement, http://www.cfr.org/diplomacy-and-statecraft/essencediplomatic-engagement/p20362, accessed 7-2-16, NVM]
339510607
The United States will persistently confront crises that require the totality of
its national power. The tumultuous Bush years have demonstrated the
limitations of military force. Diplomatic interaction requires mutual concessions and
acceptance of less than ideal outcomes. Moreover, as the United States charts its
course, there is nothing wrong with acknowledging past errors. Instead of
clinging to its self-proclaimed exceptionalism, America would be wise to take
into account the judgment of other nations that are increasingly central to its
economy and security.
339510607
Mutually Acceptable
Diplomatic engagement entails negotiations to find mutually
acceptable solutions
Azel, Institute for Cuban and Cuban-American Studies Senior
Research Associate, 9
[Jos, 4-6-09, Information and Analysis from the Institute for Cuban and
Cuban-American Studies University of Miami, In Defense of Carrots and
Sticks, p.2, unsure of publisher, NVM]
339510607
Relationship-Building
Engagement requires the building of substantive relationships
gets the core purpose of diplomacy and limits out one-off
encounters
Wallin, American Security Project Public Diplomacy fellow, 13
[Matthew, 6-11-2013, American Security Project, "Engagement: What does it
Mean for Public Diplomacy? -,"
http://www.americansecurityproject.org/engagement-what-does-it-mean-forpublic-diplomacy/, accessed: 7-5-2016, S.C.]
339510607
339510607
Non-Military
Diplomatic engagement is distinct from military engagement
Brown et al, George Washington University Elliott School of
International Affairs Dean, 13
[Michael E., Timothy J.A. Adamson, Mike M. Mochizuki, Deepa Ollapally,
Robert G. Sutter, Elliott School of International Affairs Master of Arts
graduate, Elliott School of International Affairs Political Science and
International Affairs Associate Professor, Elliott School of International Affairs
International Affairs Associate Research Professor, Elliott School of
International Affairs International Affairs Professor of Practice, 8-13,
Balancing Acts: The U.S. Rebalance and Asia-Pacific Stability, p. 29, NVM]
339510607
Security
Security operations are diplomatic engagement
Reveron, Naval War College National Security Affairs Professor,
7
[Derek S., Aug 30-Sept 2, Shaping and Military Diplomacy, Prepared for
delivery at the 2007 Annual Meeting of the American Political Science
Association,
http://www.faoa.org/resources/documents/apsa07_proceeding_210193.pdf,
pg. 11, accessed 7-3-16, ZT]
339510607
Military Cooperation
Diplomatic engagement includes expansion in military
cooperation
Brown et al, George Washington University Elliott School of
International Affairs Dean, 13
[Michael E., Timothy J.A. Adamson, Mike M. Mochizuki, Deepa Ollapally,
Robert G. Sutter, Elliott School of International Affairs Master of Arts
graduate, Elliott School of International Affairs Political Science and
International Affairs Associate Professor, Elliott School of International Affairs
International Affairs Associate Research Professor, Elliott School of
International Affairs International Affairs Professor of Practice, 8-13,
Balancing Acts: The U.S. Rebalance and Asia-Pacific Stability, p. 23, NVM]
Vietnam: Since the normalization of diplomatic relations between the
United States and Vietnam in July 1995, the two countries have
significantly expanded ties in trade and military cooperation.
Bilateral trade has increased ten-fold since the normalization of trade
relations in 2001, with Washington now serving as Vietnams largest trading
partner. Military cooperation has grown substantially, with joint
exercises and information-sharing increasingly common. Growing
Chinese assertiveness in the South China Sea in recent years has concerned
both Vietnam and the United States, with Hanoi internationalizing its
sovereignty disputes with China by appealing to U.S. interests in freedom of
navigation and maritime security. Against this background, U.S. Secretary of
State Clinton stated in July 2010, that the Obama Administration is
prepared to take the U.S.-Vietnam relationship to the next level as
part of a strategy aimed at enhancing American engagement in the
Asia Pacific.48
339510607
Military Relationship
Diplomatic engagement includes military-to-military exchanges
Brown et al, George Washington University Elliott School of
International Affairs Dean, 13
[Michael E., Timothy J.A. Adamson, Mike M. Mochizuki, Deepa Ollapally,
Robert G. Sutter, Elliott School of International Affairs Master of Arts
graduate, Elliott School of International Affairs Political Science and
International Affairs Associate Professor, Elliott School of International Affairs
International Affairs Associate Research Professor, Elliott School of
International Affairs International Affairs Professor of Practice, 8-13,
Balancing Acts: The U.S. Rebalance and Asia-Pacific Stability, p. 13, NVM]
339510607
Diplomatic
339510607
339510607
/dplmtk/
1 relating to the profession or skill of preserving or creating friendly
relationships between countries
a diplomatic mission
diplomatic sources (=diplomats): According to diplomatic sources, elections
there have been canceled.
Synonyms and related words
Embassies and ambassadors: accredited, ambassador, ambassadorial...
Explore Thesaurus
Collocates: diplomatic
Nouns frequently used with diplomatic
activity, channel, initiative, link, mission, recognition, service, source
339510607
339510607
339510607
Relating to Diplomacy
Diplomatic is of or relating to diplomacy, skilled in negotiating,
tactful in dealing with people, and of or relating to diplomatics
Collins English Dictionary ND
[Diplomatic, Collins English Dictionary - Complete & Unabridged 10th
Edition, http://www.dictionary.com/browse/diplomatic, accessed 7-5-16, NVM]
339510607
339510607
339510607
Diplomatic Officers
Diplomatic officers are designated by their governments
Ballentines Law Dictionary, 1969
[diplomatic officers, 3rd edition, edited by James A. Ballentine,
http://citizenlaw.com/pdf/d.pdf, accessed 5-16-16]
339510607
Diplomacy
339510607
Non-Hostile
Diplomacy involves non-hostile negotiations and relations
between nations
State Department Diplomatic Dictionary
[Diplomacy, State Department Diplomatic Dictionary,
http://diplomacy.state.gov/discoverdiplomacy/references/169792.htm#top,
accessed 7-2-16, NVM]
339510607
What is DIPLOMACY?
The science which treats of the relations and interests of nations with
nations. Negotiation or intercourse between nations through their
representatives. The rules, customs, and privileges of representatives at
foreign courts.
339510607
339510607
339510607
Managing Relations
Diplomacy is the activity of managing international relations
by a countrys representatives abroad
Oxford Dictionaries
[Diplomacy, Oxford Dictionaries,
http://www.oxforddictionaries.com/us/definition/american_english/diplomacy,
accessed 7-3-16, NVM]
339510607
339510607
Relationships
Diplomacy involves strengthening alliances, building and
managing relationships, and deepening engagement
Brown et al, George Washington University Elliott School of
International Affairs Dean, 13
[Michael E., Timothy J.A. Adamson, Mike M. Mochizuki, Deepa Ollapally,
Robert G. Sutter, Elliott School of International Affairs Master of Arts
graduate, Elliott School of International Affairs Political Science and
International Affairs Associate Professor, Elliott School of International Affairs
International Affairs Associate Research Professor, Elliott School of
International Affairs International Affairs Professor of Practice, 8-13,
Balancing Acts: The U.S. Rebalance and Asia-Pacific Stability, p. 15, NVM]
339510607
339510607
With
339510607
Interaction
With requires some form of interaction
Random House Dictionary
[Dictionary.com Unabridged, Random House, Inc. 04 Jul. 2016, With,
http://www.dictionary.com/browse/with, accessed July 5, 2016 //SL]
339510607
Mutual Involvement
With means mutual involvement
Merriam-Webster
[Merriam-Webster.com, n.d., With, http://www.merriamwebster.com/dictionary/with, accessed: July 5, 2016 //SL]
339510607
Accompanying
With means to accompany in some way
Random House Dictionary
[Dictionary.com Unabridged, Random House, Inc. 04 Jul. 2016, With,
http://www.dictionary.com/browse/with, accessed July 5, 2016 //SL]
with
Top 1000 frequently used words
Pronunciation: /wiTTH/ /wiTH/
PREPOSITION
339510607
339510607
Cooperation
With implies cooperation
Cambridge Academic Content Dictionary
[Cambridge University Press, 2016, With,
http://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/with, accessed: July 2,
2016 //SL]
339510607
Transaction
With implies a transaction or arrangement
Merriam-Webster
[Merriam-Webster.com, n.d., With, http://www.merriamwebster.com/dictionary/with, accessed: July 5, 2016 //SL]
2 a used as a function word to indicate a participant in an action,
transaction, or arrangement <works with his father> <a talk with a friend>
<got into an accident with the car>
339510607
By Means Of
With means the subject achieves something by means of the
object
Cambridge Academic Content Dictionary
[Cambridge University Press, 2016, With,
http://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/with, accessed: July 2,
2016 //SL]
339510607
Support
With implies support
Cambridge Academic Content Dictionary
[Cambridge University Press, 2016, With,
http://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/with, accessed: July 2,
2016 //SL]
339510607
Opposition
With requires opposition to the direct object
Oxford Dictionaries
[Oxford University Press, With,
http://www.oxforddictionaries.com/us/definition/american_english/with,
accessed: July 5, 2016 //SL]
4. In opposition to:
we started fighting with each other
So much information has come up since my fight with Shirley and
none of it is good.
Teachers learned about the incident when Kyle was spotted fighting with the
boy.
He shows a teenage mother fighting with the father of her child about his
failings as a parent.
339510607
339510607
339510607
Government
The Peoples Republic of China refers to the government
BYU Law Review, 15
[8-17-15, BYU Law Review, Volume 2014 | Issue 3 Article 11, A Broken
System: Failures of the Religious Regulatory System in the Peoples Republic
of China, http://digitalcommons.law.byu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?
article=2934&context=lawreview, p. 754, accessed 7-10-16]
339510607
339510607
339510607
After the Kuomintang reunified China in 1928, most of mainland China was
governed by the Republic of China (ROC). The island of Taiwan was under
Japanese rule at the time. At the end of World War II in 1945, Japan
surrendered Taiwan to the Republic of China. In 1949, there was a civil
war in China and the government (ROC) lost control of mainland China
to the Communist Party, which established the People's Republic of
China (PRC) and took control of all of mainland China. Only the island
of Taiwan remained under the control of the ROC.
339510607
That is certainly true, but I would point out that the vast majority of the
countries that have diplomatic relations with the Beijing
government, at the time they established relations, almost
invariably also recognized Taiwan as a part of the People's Republic of China . Even
the U.S. at the time it set up official relations with Beijing acknowledged that there is
only one China and that Taiwan is a part of China.
Citing the resolution WHA25.1, which in 1972 expelled the ROC from the
WHO, the 2010 memorandum emphasizes the consequent obligation for the
[WHO] Secretariat of refraining from actions which could constitute or be
interpreted as recognition of a separate status of Taiwanese authorities and
institutions from China.[33] This provision constitutes Beijings bottom line
for Taiwans participation in the IHR: in the WHO, for all purposes, Taiwan is part
of China . Or rather, as the text specifies, the proper terminology to be used
regarding Taiwan is Taiwan Province of China. [34] With the official instruction
to call Taiwan Province of China, this document even goes beyond Ban Kimoons above statement, that for the UN, Taiwan is an integral part of the Peoples
Republic of China . Needless to say, for Taiwan, being called explicitly a
province of China is an important setback in its WHO participation. The
Taiwanese government launched an immediate protest to the WHO
339510607