Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ISSN: 2458-925X
Vol. 2 Issue 6, June - 2016
Tiza Michael2
M. Tech Scholar. (Civil engineering), Career Point
University
Kota, India .
tizamichael@gmail.com
Omale James3
M.Sc Architecture, Ahmadu Bello University .
Nigeria.
Talk2jameson@gmail.com
Abstract- A
building,
once
properly
constructed is expected to be in use for a very
long time. Although every society has its own
problems and Nigeria is not an exception yet the
very recent challenges of buildings collapsing in
various locations have been giving the various
arms of government and the people of Nigeria
sleepless nights in view of the enormous loss of
huge investments in housing, properties and
human life. News reports of such incidences are
frequently reported in the country by both the
print and electronic media. In 2006 alone, no fewer
than thirteen of such cases were recorded in
Lagos State alone while statistics of the previous
and subsequent years were not better off either.
This study was set out to empirically ascertain the
causes of such building failure and collapse from
the perspective of the stakeholders (comprising of
the professionals in the building industry,
contractors and house owners/developers) with a
view to proffering appropriate recommendations
to guide against occurrence, Lagos State was
chosen as the case study based on the frequency
of occurrence of building collapse in the State. To
achieve the objective of the study, questionnaires
were randomly administered on the professional;
Estate Surveyors and valuers. Architects, Town
Planners, Quality Surveyors, Engineers (structural
and
civil),
building
contractors
and
Landlords/developers in the study area to seek
their opinion on their perceived causes of building
collapse. The study identified the use of substandard building materials, poor workmanship by
contractors, use of incompetent contractors,
faulty construction methodology, heavy down
pour,
noncompliance
with
specifications/standards
by
developers/contractors,
inadequate/lack
of
supervision/inspection/monitoring,
structural
defects,
defective
design/structure,
illegal
conversion/alterations/additions
to
existing
structures and dilapidating structures as the
Lagos,
Building
INTRODUCTION
www.jmess.org
JMESSP13420118
547
Stakeholders
Architects
Building Contractors
Engineers
(Civil/Structural)
Estate
Surveyors/Valuers
Quantity Surveyor
Landlords/Develope
rs
Town Planners
Total
Questionnair
Respons Percentag
e
e Rate
e (%)
Distribution
12
35
9
20
75
57
12
12
100
12
67
12
11
92
150
90
60
12
245
7
157
58
64.08
Raft
Pile/Pad
Raft
Pad&Strip Strip
Fig.1.1
Reasons Adduced for Incessant Building
Failure and Collapse from the Building
Professionals Perspective
Perceived causes
SA A N D SD TOTAL
Dilapidating Structures
14 12 6 6 9
47
Defective Design/Structure
10 10 8 6 13 47
Heavy downpour
10 15 8 7 7
47
Sub-Standard building materials 18 12 5 7 5
47
Poor workmanship by
19 16 3 4 5
47
contractors
Use of incompetent contractors 15 12 7 5 8
47
Faulty construction methodology 10 13 6 7 11 47
Noncompliance with
specifications/standards by
14 13 6 5 9
47
developers/contractors
Inadequate/lack of
16 12 6 5 8
47
supervision/inspection/monitoring
Structural defects
13 12 8 3 6
47
Illegal
conversion/alteration/additions to 16 13 5 5 8
47
existing structures
www.jmess.org
JMESSP13420118
548
Institutional
Residential
Industrial
.
3. Conclusion
From the study the following conclusions are
made:
This study has been able to identify several causes
of building failure in Lagos State. It has highlighted
several case studies of building failure in Lagos State
including casualties of those incidents. The losses
always experienced as a result of building failure are
enormous; ranging from loss of lives, several forms
and degrees of injuries, loss of properties, etc. The
National Building Code is a very important document
which will greatly reduce the occurrence of building
failures in Lagos state and Nigeria at large.
www.jmess.org
JMESSP13420118
549
Comprehensive
and
Practical
Guide
Students.Oxford.Oxford University Press
for
and
pp. 1228.
pp 127
[25] . Hussey, J. and Hussey, R. (1997) Business
Research. A Practical Guide for Undergraduate and
Postgraduate Students, Palgrave. Basingstoke
[26] . Ikpo, I. J. (1998). Application of the Weibull
Distribution Technique in the Prediction of the Times
between Failures (MTBF) of Building Components,
Nigerian Journal of 27. Construction Technology and
Management, Vol. 1, Institute of Building, Ondo State
Chapter. 23-24 October, 2001.
[28] . Jennings, J.E.B. And Burland, J.B., (1962).
Limitations to the use of effective stresses concept in
partly saturated soils. Geotechniques, 12:125-144
Kumekpor, T.K.B (2002). Research methods and
techniques of social research. Accra: sonlife press.
[29] Marsh, D. and Furlong, E. (2002) Ontology
and Epistemology in Political Science in 30. Marsh,
David and Stoker, Gerry (eds.): Theory and Methods
in Political Science, 2nd Edition. Basingstoke:
Palgrave.
[31] Mason, J., (2006) Mixing Methods in a
Qualitatively Driven Way, Qualitative Research, Vol.6
Iss: 1, pp 9-25
[32] Miles M. B. Huberman A.M (1994) Qualitative
Data Analysis: An Expanded sourcebook, 2nd edition.
[33] Mohammed, S. M. (2004). Appraisal of
Sandcrete Block As Walling Unit in Nigeria,
Environmental Watch Journal, Federal Polytechnic,
Bida, Vol. 1, No. 1, pp. 251 257.
[34] Mouton J (2001) How to Succeed in Your
Master's And Doctoral studies. Pretoria, South Africa:
Van Schaik.79
[35] Naoum, S. G. (2007) Dissertation Research
and Writing for Construction Students 2nded.
News24.comdownloadedon28/08/13from:http://www.n
ews24.com/news24/Africa/news /0,2-11-1447_1977.
[36] Nigerian Tribune (2008). Building Collapse:
Will Building Code Be the Saving Grace? African
Newspapers of Nigeria PLC (Tuesday 12th August,
2008) No 1, P. 79 87
[37] Ogunsemi (ed.) Proceedings on Building
Collapse: Causes, Prevention and Remedies Ondo
www.jmess.org
JMESSP13420118
550
Collapse,
Causes,
www.jmess.org
JMESSP13420118
551