The Harvard Design School Project
on the City began as a response to a
aeRO elmo l melee tiie
practice, in which the architect is
asked to intervene in, but never to
appreciate or understand, a given
SUE me aes tee)
are ultimately determined by a
Teel meee ema
projects and clients that do not
allow an independent investigation
Clemo Lome Tl
bits Moe RMLs te
Coe Fa ON LEU =U
He at] Ce| NCO
independent analysis, research or
investigation is simply not within
their repertoire. It is becoming
increasingly important for architects
to operate on a level independent of
architecture, in order to understand,
Elam Memory (ea
phenomena affecting the development
Cleland C-eLemnee
The Project on the City is an
investigation of a series of issues
ice ate mom -M Tarlo ee La
OEMS (MEN ele)
(ilies ie ele Lea
Clean Tame Lao Mela RL TL
mutations taking place at this
moment in the world. The project has
itm eCoT tetas ele rae
Tle Macty-t La Tne) [amelie LOLel tLe)
Saito Met a (el Tal LOM) 9) elk)
specific subject each year.Airport Church
Mall MallGovernment Education
Shopping ShoppingMuseum Military
SOeRITG ShoppingShopping
loro ao Rha)
re eg Ce eT
Donnan anew rie Ta
eMC MC ects mc eet ta
Shopping is arguably the last remaining
meee es al
Tee PCAN a arc
een oe eee
almost every aspect of urban life. Historical
OCS MSRM
Ree eu ue U eRe sae ae e
Racine aut neu INA
frees DMeuE er aR CaE Se
Peon Ture ese rT)
Arey turn eae reais
PR SUE CR Nae
een pact erences
Museums are turning to shopping to survive.
aaa ete unis Regn
eee uaa eR ag
rere eet n-GaN e
tects disdain the world of retailing yet use
ACen ed eeu nune
and universities. Ailing cities are revitalizedby being planned more like malls.
Sida Tree Mae Nemec Tie
unrelenting transformation of the city with-
Cae sa eae aR aT Us
cally prepared and modified the built envi-
eluate eel Le
activity. Air conditioning freed new depths
Pe Cue elk Teel sit Ry
Mame measly
UU MMR te] Ike mT Re Lalo) od
Pace SN aae ena
cM eceicne te leenecseu ne nicn
tur ee UN en LT
PEN aaa Neus ORT TN
DTU aM Lea el
ReMMCu esau
rire Trees eur it AUT Aya EL]
RSE TEM ice EMT Neg
remo eM nEMe Ul Titel us Es
beyond replication and scale, by infiltrating
Pees ceetla cme
Peete ects Reena
and tracking devices, which record our lives
AMM M Ue TAUE-LCOER(-1e-T LOLALL yy
BS irel=foliat eae SLE
nok
Recaise cents
Ronee eer a
BAA, formerly the British Airports Authority runs seven British airports,
Petr eee eee me
ra ee rent ete a ac ice
‘and Harrisburg; plus Naples, Melbourne, and Launceston, Australi
eres ee cre er ets
See Eee Te Coe ane)
one ts= City = Shopping | - 4 Shopping > Museum
ee
|
Sern a
Ec ae . t |
Pereinees =
Peete) : i
PCr epee) . ,
Bon 4See ee ery
perenne ee es ae eee ed
found downtown has moved to suburban shopping centers, which have
substantially displaced the downtown business districts as the centers
‘of commercial and social activity... The predominant characteristic of
ee a een ees
eco eee oer
te ase ne hee cece
‘only stores of every kind and size, but lage open spaces available to
Roe eee carer a ee eC
erectaSee eee eres
ee eee oe en cued
ere eet oe nee etn
planned withthe small stores situated on the routes that link major
pee ee ee re ena
Ree eae en Tice
eee
eRe conc a es
ce eee ae onan)
by Van Ginkel Associates that would remove vehicular traffic from
See a nace)
portion ofthe avenue to pedestrian and bicycle use, but the cohesive
force, the attraction that would encaurage pedestrians inthe fist place,
SR ene ta
note thatthe most vociferous support for the malling of Madison
‘Avenue came from the mayor's office civie Groups, and even the New
See eae|e
ETC Be Mee
Pere ern see ae
eee eae a ase etd
a5 a concent for Disney-styled architecture is introduced by Peter
Pen rerec ne eee ear)
Pete era ee ay
(na joined Disney ust before the opening of Disneyland ParW) reveals
Senter ei cotor
Ce le ee eee oe)
pret ee ee oo
cs
Paes
Deen nee nc acc
Cea none
Coe acon nrr
eee een eas
ere eee
Tell one story ata tine
ere ee
Pee ta eer
poreSee ee ee
ee re ee
Sri anne rere net ee eee ey
ic eee enc ce arn
ee er es
eet ee ee
cre ee een ee ens
Roe eee ee eos
oo
See ee ec eee nr)
Pe eee ee eed
Pen ae ee Rea ee anc
Sc eee aT eee ey
Pte eee ot ee
Ste eR eo cei ee once
Pee ea eee een Roca
Finish up by decorating with some potted plants, miscellaneous flower
eee se reese tas
Lye 1Architecture = Shopping
Pee eee roe
eee et
re eee eee ote ee
shopping seem now to dictate the expectations on architects.
From Decon to Minimalism via the Post-Modern, all ofthese
Prete eee as
‘The most experimental, avant-garde architecture may now merely
pee ere me ne
ea eee Se
Cro
a ee ra bath 7
id
Las Vegas = SIREN |
teh me
ee eee et ae)
and lznour visited Las Vegas, the modification of the city has been over-
‘whelming. Las Vegas is now a hypersubstantial contin, an accumulation of
een ee ogo eee sae errs
eer he ery
eee arene eee neater May
fee eter eyee eu)
with American-style shopping are compelled to align with financial
peer anaes
‘The resistance must decide “how to spur growth without sacifcing
the quality of centuries-old, town-centere life.” It sa strange demand
pee ee eee)
erence te rs ae
vents impacting urban habits and activities, the choices are often
Peetu eer enone eet ee
Creer er ron eee
eee Cn Tt
experience and densifying city centers, large-format retailing, however
Peer eon om csc ee
Renner ete on net Suc i aaaiy
Pie etre eran et a Ed
Saeco
Europe vs Shopping
teSe cee
eer emer eter eee Ig
more than 20 years of committed urban planning, Singapore no longer
Beare ren enter Tc cone a
eet are nor es
Integration and exchange which would be best developed as a series of
Peete eee en eed
ee ae aa eC
Rear ae Or eae ar
pene ert eee cae ee eT
retwork’ a planning diagram which inks diverse progran
ce eta ee RO ad
Soe aa
%, ; a
Singapore = Mall‘The advantages of being incorporated int the infrastructure of public
transportation systems were recognized early In the development of the
depato [the Japanese department store), Public transportation, consisting
Potrero eae ey
Urban centers such as Tokyo and Osaka ace simply too large to walk from
ee eer cr tg
transportation systems serving as intricate but efficient lifelines forthe
Brenner ret sina or cere ics
‘stream of people—and money—into the stores. The depato fist merged
re eee REC ce
pay for the construction ofa subway station that would be directly
fonnected fo the store and that would bear the store's name, In 1932
ee eee reso
subway system, prompting other depatos to extend their domains
throughout the ety in a similar fashion and simultaneously contributing
eee eee ed
various depatos on the major stops, demonstrates the extent to which
the depato had become synonymous with the infrastructure of the city
In Tokyo's amorphous urban environment, shopping acts as collagen,
‘creating spatial and programmatic seamlessness and territorial
definition. Shopping is material for negotiation and accommodates in its
See cee eae es
Tevenue distributions, lan claims, and neighborhood concerns. Shopping
ese ee errr eee
Sener rece
Pee ee asec era
With twice the population and twenty-five tines the land area of Japan.
Seen reac ect
cr reece ee ae ec
eat
ee ace eee
‘exchange, diversion, and entertainment. In Tokyo ts still an arena
oe eer ce
In short, shopping creates a landscape in which potential and excitement
Seer eee eas
Sore eee essUV
—
33 x Manhattan land area
Peer ane)
Dee
just-in-time delivery, and a highly computerized system for store
eee ee ee ers
pee oe a
ce eee eee ene rae
Se oe eee ea
ee a ee eee
Per ee ee oor)
Cee eae eer cee ea cS
Pree nee eeSe ean
Ree ee eee er)
Sete ee ste eae Ss
Pee ee ees
ee
Sree ti:
Re eee ee ee ney
basic human necessity, there Is no guaranteed frequency or density of
ee eee
Peer era eee ee
Pree ne ee Nar enn oes
Always almost obsoleteaa
PAU EN um i]
‘As many 2s 600 of the nation's 2,000 regional malls may be closed or Se ee eee eee
converted to other uses in the coming years eee eco ere)
See ee te ae
cheaply, aling to pieces as they greet the arrival of The Next Big Thing
Those which endure must be constantly updated through renovation and
Ree ees keer eee
Pee eee ee en ee
eee re eee genes
Plywood walls ples of sand, dumpsters—in shopping architecture, the
een eat eeeSe ee eae en
ee eee eee ed
took place when credit card companies discovered the gold mine of
Information on buying activity siting in their databases. Precise
purchasing data a5 ta who bought what, where and when they bought it
‘what else they bought, where they live, and how often they go shopping,
Senne er eet i
ee eee oes
paneer ae ete ere eas
cre ren eee a er
stopped shopping at certain stores. With these new maps, retalers are
See ee ec)
Pr ea ae er Rn aos eed
er eee gona a
has historically never been innocent. In similar fashion, these new
maps have aided the commercial world to form, by entering realms once
thought of as private and invisible, Increasingly intimate relationships
reneeNoll wouldn't know where to begin, Were he tobe given the task of
Se ea Mee nets
eee eee ne ane
Ser eee ee Moc
Ret a eee ne
for the material density ofthe city, the markers of private or public,
space that distinguish inside from outside, and the monumental and
Civic icons that serve as points of orientation or focus would be litle
more than obsolete gestures towards faint memories of urban ideals
eee ten tecnicos
ere Re eet eS
Se ee ee
Poe eee ae ee ey
rege epee erent
eee Ce ene
Pe ee ee
eee ena oe CORE eT
Pee ee ets
CeCe en eee
Preeti oate eecee eatcs
urbanism‘Contour maps" no longer describe geological features but altitudes
Cheer eon ee ees
but represent a topography of market potential, indicating levels of
De acne eae
Pe eee eee ee eens
ard down the asl, a celling grid of recelvers picks up the unique cart
Rea ric ecm ace
oars
eee eee eee ee
ee atc oe ees
Se en eet
Reread
Se rece
See eee teers