Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Kirsti Davidson
Ms. Krachenfels
English 11
June 6, 2010
Dinosaurs have fascinated people for years. They are featured in movies such as
Jurassic Park, are plastered across the news and media, and some have even been turned
into cuddly stuffed animals. But what is it about this huge, carnivorous monster that is so
enticing to us? There is a sense of mystery attached to dinosaurs. What were they like?
When did they go extinct? Why did they die out? Dinosaurs and their extinction are a
mystery in today’s world (Ham 169). So what did really happen to the dinosaurs?
235 million years ago as part of the Mesozoic Era (Ham 155). They were an extremely
successful group of animals that are said to have dominated the Earth and were the top of
the food chain for over 170 million years. If these dinosaurs were the prevailing creature
and had thrived for so long, why would they go extinct? Many feel that it doesn’t make
sense for them to die out of natural causes such as lack of food, increased predation (they
were at the top of the food chain), climate change, or destruction of habitat unless some
global catastrophic event took place. The fossils of most of the dinosaur bones, along
with many other types of animals, are grouped together in close layers of strata, meaning
that lots of them died at the same time, or as a result of the same catastrophic event. One
This “impact theory” started gaining popularity in the 1980’s (Taylor 64). Its
hypothesis is based on the fact that a high amount of the element iridium is found in the
Davidson 2
rock layers that contain many dinosaur fossils. Evolutionists assign the layers of rocks in
the Earth’s crust to coordinate with the evolutionary time scale, meaning fossils found in
the rock layer associated with the Mesozoic Era, for example, would be dated from that
time period. Where the Cretaceous Period (abbreviated as K) and the Tertiary Period rock
layer (abbreviated as T) meet is know as the KT boundary (Taylor 65). Most, but not all,
extinction event, when a number of organisms appear to be missing in one layer of rocks
but are present in the layer right below that. Rocks samples taken from this KT boundary
very heavy element. Evolutionary scientists, assuming that the Earth is 4.5 billions years
old, concluded that the iridium could not be from the Earth, as it should have sunk to the
core over the millions of years. They then hypothesized that since asteroids contain
iridium, the iridium could have come from an asteroid impact to the Earth. These
scientists went on to say that this large impact would have caused global destruction,
sending a dust cloud into the atmosphere, blocking the sun, and causing slightly cooler
“remnants of a very large impact crater” (Taylor 65). The crater remnant is approximately
110 miles in diameter, and this size of crater would have been caused by an asteroid or
comet of about 6 miles in diameter (“Chicxulub Crater”). Scientists searching for more
evidence of their hypothesized impact theory immediately assumed this crater to be the
remnants of the asteroid impact that wiped out the dinosaurs (Taylor 65).
An impact of this size would cause a great deal of localized destruction to the area
surrounding the impact. A 110 mile crater caused by an asteroid of 6 miles in diameter
Davidson 3
sounds significantly large, but taking into account that the surface area of the Earth is
196,935,000 square miles (Chen) it seems unlikely that something inflicted on a mere
0.000056 % of the Earth’s surface could cause world wide damage1. This is
proportionally the same as saying that the impact of a piano2, 3 creating a crater the size of
about half a football field4 would cause destruction to the whole state of Virginia. It is
also proportionate to an M&M mini, or 0.03 inches, hitting the City of Salem5, 6. If a mini
M&M crashed into the parking lot of the Salem Civic Center, even if it was going
extremely fast, it doesn’t seem like the students of Salem High School would be too
worried about any effects of that impact from all the way across town.
The main problem with the “Impact Theory” is that there is too much iridium. It is
known that asteroids contain some amount of the element, but it wouldn’t spread out
upon impact. “The iridium anomaly, or spike, has been found all over the world in layers
of rock” (Richmond). It especially couldn’t spread all over the world (Taylor 65). An
significant amount of iridium and can easily spread it out through lava (Taylor 66).
The idea that the iridium was the result of volcanic eruptions is supported greatly
by a global flood. In a massive worldwide flood, “all the foundations of the great deep
[would be] broken up” (Genesis 7:11). The breaking up of the Earth’s crust would cause
an unprecedented amount of simultaneous volcanoes to erupt all over the Earth, easily
1
110 miles2 of crater/196,935,000 miles2 of the Earth’s surface x 100 = .000056%
2
The State of Virginia has a surface area of 42, 769 mi2 (“Virginia”).
3
6mi2 / 196,935,000 mi2 = x / 42,769mi2. x = 0.0013 mi = 6.9ft2
4
6mi2 / 110mi2 = 6.9ft2 / x. x = 126.5ft2 = 42yd2
5
The City of Salem has a surface area of 15 mi2 (“Virginia Cities and Towns”).
6
6mi2 / 196,935,000mi2 = x / 15mi2 . x = 4.57x10-9 mi2 = 0.03in2
Davidson 4
A global flood is also supported by the fact that the same rapidly deposited
sediment layers are spread across vast areas. The exposed rock layers of the Grand
Canyon can be traced all across North America, showing evidence that is was deposited
rapidly and all at once. There is slight or no erosion between these strata layers, providing
the argument that there wasn’t any long period of time between the depositing of the
layers of sediment (Snelling 81). Also, there are fossils of sea creatures, such as that of
ammonites (coiled marine gastropods), found high on the Himalayan mountain range.
How could a marine fossil be found 20, 029 feet above sea level unless the whole earth
Today we are able to find lots of perfectly preserved fossils; even whole dinosaur
skeletons have been found. “Fossil formation requires a sudden burial. When an animal
dies, it usually gets eaten or decays until there is nothing left. To form a fossil, unique
conditions are required to preserve the animal and replace it with minerals” (Ham 166).
The flood brings great explanation to how and why so many fossils were formed.
Fossils of all the ten layers that are supposed to represent the evolutionary time
scale are only found in correct sequence in less than 1% of the Earth’s crust. Scientists
have determined that in order to account for over four billion years of the Earth’s history,
the geologic column should be at least 100 miles thick. At best, they have found areas
where the column is about 16 miles deep while the average depth is only about one mile.
In a very few amount of locations, paleontologists have found the fossils in the order of
the evolutionary time scale: small sea creatures, then free swimming fish, leading to land
dwelling animals, and then birds. But, if this were the true evolutionary time scale then
they wouldn’t find all of these fossils buried within just a few miles depth of each other.
Davidson 5
They should be miles and miles apart because they were supposedly separated by
The evolutionary time scale also claims that it goes from simplest to more
complex creatures, when, in fact, fish are just as complex as any land creature. Instead,
this order of marine sessile, to free swimming fish, to land dwelling creatures, and then to
birds simply follows the order of the habitats in which they live. “Imagine a bulldozer
rapidly covering a duck pond with soil. The organisms in the pond would be buried in
sequence. The bottom dwelling worms and snails would be at the bottom. The fish would
be somewhat higher, and the ducks would be on top. The sequence would represent
where the animals lived—not the order they evolved in. The same holds true for the fossil
record” (Veith). In the event of the flood the “animals that were already at the bottom of
the sea would be the first to be buried in the mud slides etc. caused by the flood.
Dinosaurs, mammals, and man would be able to flee to higher grounds (only to be buried
later). And birds would be on the higher levels because they would have the best chance
Fossils that scientists find, such as dinosaur fossils, are dated using radioactive
dating methods. One of these is the carbon – 14 (14C) dating method. The element of
carbon has an atomic number of six, meaning that in its usual state it contains six protons
(P) and six neutrons (N). This gives it an atomic mass of 12 (6P+6N=12) and thus we
refer it as carbon – 12 (12C). But, carbon has three different isotopes, or 3 different
protons and 7 neutrons (6P + 7N = 13). And Carbon – 14 has 6 protons and 8 neutrons
Unlike 12C and 13C, 14C is unstable and will radioactively decay overtime. This
process, called beta decay, occurs when one of the neutrons in 14C is converted into a
proton, creating a new element. This new element, which now contains 7 protons (6P +
1P = 7P) and 7 neutrons (8N – 1N = 7N), is a nitrogen atom. So, 14C atoms are constantly
decaying into nitrogen, but more carbon – 14 atoms are also constantly being produced.
Neutrons from fragmented atoms collide with Nitrogen as a result of cosmic rays
colliding with atoms in the atmosphere. This causes the Nitrogen atom to convert one of
its protons into a neutron, leaving it with 6 protons and 8 neutrons. This is how 14C is
Carbon – 12, the normal carbon atom, and 14C, an isotope of 12C, both behave the
same way in the atmosphere. Both forms of carbon attach onto oxygen molecules to form
CO2. Plants then take in CO2 as part of photosynthesis, and all other living things, either
directly of indirectly, eat plants as a source of energy. This means that all living things
will contain the same ratio of 12C to 14C that is in the atmosphere at that time. When an
organism dies it stops taking in carbon. The 12C level will remain the same since it is
Carbon – 14 has a half-life of 5,730 years. As an example, a jar with all 14C atoms
at time zero will contain only half of the 14C atoms after one half-life of 5,730 years (the
other half will be nitrogen as a result of the beta decay). After 11, 460 years (2 half-lives)
the jar will contain half of a half, or ¼, of the original amount carbon atoms and ¾ of it
The current ratio of 12C to 14C in the atmosphere is one 14C atom for every 1
trillion 12C atoms. Assuming the ratio of 14C to 12C has always been this number,
scientists could determine the starting amount of 14C that was in the organism when it
Davidson 7
died by doing a simple proportion calculation. By knowing the half-life of 14C, the
current amount of 14C in the fossil, and the starting amount of 14C, scientists could date a
fossil to about 80,000 years. But, if the ratio of 12C to 14C was not the same when the
organism died as it is now, then scientists would have no way of determining the starting
amount of 14C, and therefore have no way of knowing the exact age of the fossil (Riddle
82).
For the ratio of 14C to 12C to remain constant, it means that it would be in a state
the amount being removed. Dr. Willard Libby, the developer of the carbon – 14 dating
method, “calculated that if the Earth started with no 14C in the atmosphere, it would take
up to 30,000 years to build up to a steady state of equilibrium” (Riddle 83). Dr. Libby
also noted that the atmosphere does not currently appear to be in this steady state of 14C
production and decay. “The Specific Production Rate (SPR) of 14C is 18.8 atoms per
gram of total carbon per minute. The Specific Decay Rate (SDR) is known to be only
16.1 disintegrations per gram per minute” (Riddle 83). If it would take only 30,000 years
to reach this state of equilibrium and our present day Earth has yet to reach that steady
state, it strongly suggests that the Earth cannot be more than 30,000 years old (Riddle
83).
The Earth also has a magnetic field around it to protect it from radiation. The
stronger this field, the less cosmic ray collisions there would be, resulting in a smaller
amount of 14C production. In 1845, German mathematician Carl Friedrich Gauss started
tracking the strength of the Earth’s magnetic field. Based on his calculations and the
current strength of the field, we know that this magnetic field is about 10% weaker now
than in 1845 (Riddle 83). A stronger field in the past would mean more 14C production
Davidson 8
than present day. If the 14C product rate in the past was less, “the dates given using 14C
dating method would incorrectly assume that more 14C had decayed out of a specimen
than what has actually occurred” (Riddle 84). This would result in older dates than the
scientists called RATE (Radioisotopes and the Age of The Earth), showed that coal
samples taken from the different layers in the geological column representing the
Cenozoic, Mesozoic, and Paleozoic periods all contained a measurable amount of 14C.
Since the half-life of 14C is relatively short “there should be no detectable 14C left after
about 100,000 years” (Riddle 85). Evolutionary scientists dated these coal samples to be
millions of years old. The average age given to all three coal samples by the RATE
research team, using the Carbon – 14 dating method, is about 50,000 years assuming the
ratio of 14C to 12C has remained constant. Knowing that the production rate of 14C was
less in the past, the realistic age of the coal would be just around 5,000 years old (Riddle
85).
dated to be over 65 million years old, that weren’t completely fossilized and even
contained measurable amounts of red blood cells and hemoglobin (“Dino Flesh from
Fossil Bone”). Blood cells cannot be preserved because they are made mostly of water.
They should have disintegrated over the course of at least a few thousand years, yet they
claim these fossils to be 65 million years old (Ham 162). More un-fossilized dinosaur
bones have also been found on the North Slope in Alaska. “These bones could not have
survived for millions of years un-mineralized” (Ham 163). These “fresh” dinosaur bones
provide strong evidence that dinosaurs are, in fact, not millions of years old but only
Davidson 9
thousands of years old. So, if dinosaurs were around a couple thousand years ago, that
means that people and dinosaurs could have lived together on Earth at the same time. If
this is true, why isn’t the word dinosaur found in any historical records?
Interestingly enough, the word “dinosaur” wasn’t even coined until 1841 by a
famous British anatomist named Sir Richard Owen (Ham 157). Earlier, in 1677, Dr.
Robert Plot discovered giant bones of a new creature no one had ever seen before. He
fittingly named the enormous animal as the Megalosaurus. In 1822, Dr. Mantel of
Sussex, England found another set of unusually large bones. Concluding that the
organism had similar features to that of a reptile, only on a much larger scale, he named
the organism an Iguanodon. When examining the bones of the Megalosaurus and the
Iguanodon, Sir Richard Owen concluded that these animals belonged to a unique group
of reptiles that were yet to be classified. He then coined the term “dinosaur” which is the
might sound crazy that dinosaurs would have lived together with people because they are
usually portrayed as such vicious creatures. While some were carnivores, such as the T-
rex, the majority of dinosaurs were vegetarian. The T-rex, for example, would prey on
and eat other dinosaurs so they didn’t pose a big danger to people (“Why the Dinosaurs
Died Out”). Lots of times these creatures resembling the dinosaurs we recognize today
are referred to as dragons. An ancient Sumerian story dating back to 2000 B.C. accounts
the adventures of a hero named Gilgamesh who single handedly slew a vicious dragon. It
is recorded that in 330 B.C. Alexander the Great found a tribe of Indian people who
“worshipped huge hissing reptiles that they kept in caves” (Ham 161). China is very
famous for its dragon tales, which are prominent all throughout their culture. The story of
Davidson 10
St. George, who slew a dragon that was living in a cave, is recognized greatly throughout
England. Also recorded is a tenth-century Irishman’s writing of his encounter with what
appears to have been a Stegosaurus (Ham 161). Furthermore, there are petroglyphs (cave
paintings) found in Native American caves that depict what look to be dinosaurs (Ham
171). There are also many accounts in the Bible of dinosaur like creatures including a
“great sea monster” (Genesis 1:21), “dragons in the water” (Psalm 74:15), and a “fiery
To quickly recap, there is a layer of iridium in the rock layer that can be explained
formation is possible because of a rapid burial such as that of a global flood. The fossil
record only follows the order of “simple to complex” evolution in 1% of the Earth’s
surface. Since the C14 production and decay rate is not in equilibrium, the Earth can’t be
more than 30,000 years old. Coal that was supposed to be millions of years old contained
old. Scientists found “fresh” dinosaur bones containing red blood cells and hemoglobin
in them. And, there are many accounts of dinosaur-like creatures, such as dragons, in
history, but we don’t see the word dinosaur because it wasn’t even used until 1841.
According to the book of Genesis, all land dwelling creatures, including the
dinosaurs and people, were created on the sixth day (Genesis 1:20-25). Dinosaurs, living
along side of people, thrived on Earth for about 2,000 years. Then, just as two of every
kind of land animal did, each different kind of dinosaurs boarded the Ark, two by two.
The rest were instantly killed, along with all other living creatures, and buried in the
Flood creating mostly all of the fossils that we have today. When the animals came off
the Ark to begin repopulating, they found themselves in a much harsher post-flood world.
Davidson 11
They were faced with a new climate, new habitat, and different food sources. Where
people had previously received all their required nourishment from plants, men were now
allowed to hunt animals for food, and even the air pressure of the atmosphere had
completely changed. The dinosaurs slowly died out over the course of the next 1,500 to
2,000 years, just as many, many other creatures did, due to these new changes that they
But could all the dinosaurs really have fit on the Ark? Contrary to popular belief,
the average size of a dinosaur, based on skeletons and bones found all over the Earth, is
just about the size of a sheep or pony. Only a select few of them, such as the
Brachiosaurus and the Apatosaurus, grew to be very large. The biggest fossil dinosaur
egg that has been found is about the size of a football, so the baby dinosaurs were
obviously rather small. They would have taken young animals on the Ark, not only to
conserve space and resources, but also so they would have a longer span of lifetime to
Some people still argue that the dinosaurs couldn’t fit on the Ark because there
are almost 1,000 different species of them. While there might be many species, there are
only about 50 “kinds” of dinosaurs. Many species can descend from one kind. For
example, there are a numerous amount of different cat species today that descended from
only a few kinds. Speciation occurs through the process of natural selection, which
allows for an organism to “select” between different genes. It draws from the genetic
information that is already present to help it adapt and survive better. A cat living in a
cold environment would most likely select the gene for long fur instead of short fur so it
will stay warmer, although, the cat already had the information for both fur lengths in its
DNA (Purdom 277). As you can see, this process does not create any new information
Davidson 12
and actually leads to a loss of genetic information. Speciation is when a certain kind of
animal becomes more and more specific. “It’s a downhill process, not involving an
evolution to occur.
Before the flood the average man lived to be around 900 years old. Recent studies
have shown that this is most likely because the air pressure prior to the flood was much
higher than it is in present day (“Windows of Heaven”). One way scientists are able to
study the effects of a greater air pressure is through Hyperbaric oxygen therapy (HBO),
where “a person is placed in a pressurized chamber, and the air pressure is increased 1 to
2 times of normal sea level atmospheric pressure. Under the increased air pressure more
oxygen gets into the bloodstream. This process seems to accelerate healing of wounds,
promotes tissue repair, and even favorably affects metabolic rates and the performance of
the hormonal systems” (“Windows of Heaven”). The increased air pressure seems to
have an abundant number of health benefits, which would allow for the longer lifespan. If
people lived to be that old, animals would have a longer lifetime too. Reptiles are the
only group of animals that continue to grow as long as they live. The dinosaur fossils we
find today that are almost 30 feet tall are the dinosaurs that had lived the longest (Ham
167). After the flood, the air pressure lowered and man’s life span was to be no more than
120 years (Genesis 6:3), about seven times less than before. At this new approximate
lifespan, dinosaurs could now only grow to be five feet at the most. They would have lost
their dominating factor because they could no longer live as long or grow to be as large.
When the dinosaurs got off the Ark to repopulate, they didn’t immediately go
extinct after that because of the harsher post-flood environment. As we observe through
Davidson 13
decreases year after year until there are eventually none left. The massive amount of
fossils found buried at the same time, which most scientists recognize as the extinction of
the dinosaurs, isn’t an extinction event at all but an instant death event. All except two of
each kind were killed and buried in the flood, but they were then able to repopulate to a
certain degree until they eventually died out of natural environmental changes that were
Everyone has the same facts to go by - the same fossils, the same bones, and the
same Earth. It’s the beliefs and presumptions one has that can cause different
interpretations of these facts. Dinosaurs are made out to be such a mystery in today’s
modern world, but their existence and extinction is actually very simple to explain.
Perhaps dinosaurs are only a mystery if you accept the questionable evolutionary story of
Works Cited
“More on the ‘Windows of Heaven’ of Noah’s Flood.” The Bible Genesis and Geology.
<http://www.kjvbible.org/windows_of_heaven.html>.
“Why the Dinosaurs Died Out.” Creation-Evolution Encyclopedia. 2006. Pathlights. June
2010. <http://www.pathlights.com/ce_encyclopedia/Encyclopedia/14flod05.htm>.
“Dino Flesh from Fossil Bone.” Science News for Kids. March 30, 2005. Society for
<http://www.sciencenewsforkids.org/articles/20050330/Note2.asp>.
“What caused the Dinosaurs to become extinct?” Jesus, Dinosaurs, and More. November
Veith, Walter J., PhD. “Order in the Fossil Record.” March 2010. Amazing Discoveries.
ExplosiveEvolutionOrderFossilRecord.html>.
Woodmorappe, John. “The Geologic Column: Does it Exist?” Exposing the Myth of
<http://www.trueorigin.org/geocolumn.asp>.
<http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chicxulub_crater>.
Richmond, Elliot. “K/T Boundary.” 2002. Macmillan Reference USA. June 2010.
<http://www.novelguide.com/a/discover/ansc_03/ansc_03_00204.html>.
Davidson 15
Chen, Daniel. “Area of Earth’s Land Surface.” The Physics Factbook. Ed.Glenn Elert.
<http://hypertextbook.com/facts/2001/DanielChen.shtml>.
site.org/Regional/North_America/United_States/Virginia>.
<http://www.virginiaplaces.org/vacities/index.html>.
Ham, Ken. The New Answers Book. 25 Top Questions on Creation/Evolution and the
Purdom, Georgia. The New Answers Book. 25 Top Questions on Creation/Evolution and
the Bible. Ed. Ken Ham. Green Forest, AR: Master Books, Inc., 2006.
Riddle, Mike. The New Answers Book. 25 Top Questions on Creation/Evolution and the
Bible. Ed. Ken Ham. Green Forest, AR: Master Books, Inc., 2006.
Taylor, Paul F. “Dinosaur Killer.” Answers Magazine. Vol.3 No.1. Jan.-Mar. 2008. 64-
66.
Snelling, Andrew A. “High and Dry Sea Creatures.” Answers Magazine. Vol. 3 No.1.
Why did the dinosaurs go extinct? Did a catastrophic global flood take place?
29% - Asteroid Impact
39% - Natural Causes 88% - Yes 13% - No
26% - Harsher Post-flood environment
6% - Other
Were Dinosaurs on the ark?
How long ago did dinosaurs go extinct?
60% – 65 million years ago 35% - Yes 65% - No
32% – 4,500 years ago after the flood
8% - Other
Did Dinosaurs and people live at the same time?
When did Dinosaurs first live on the Earth?
40% – Created on the sixth day 6000 years ago 46% - Yes 54% - No
51% – Evolved 235 millions years ago
How did the earth come about? Does Natural selection provide evidence for
3% – The Earth was created by some Supreme Being. evolution?
17% – God created the earth initially, then evolution 50% - Yes 50% - No
took place.
31% – God created the Earth, but not in 6 literal days.
40% – God created the Earth and everything in it in 6
literal days. Are Natural Selection and Evolution
7% – Big Bang and Evolution essentially the same thing?
3% – Other 42% - Yes 58% - No
*The survey above was distributed to friends and family, with a total of 74 responses. Because of the
informal nature of the survey, a broad cross-section of people wasn’t attained. However, these finding
reflect an interesting range of attitudes and perspectives amongst our Salem Community.
*Original survey questions that were distributed are attached on the next page.
Davidson 17
How do you believe the earth and all living creatures came about?
A. The earth and all living things were created by some Supreme Being.
B. God or a Supreme Being created the Earth initially making it able to sustain life.
Then evolution from simple one-celled organisms to the animals we know today took
place over millions of years.
C. God created the Earth and all living things, but not in 6 literal days. The earth could
still maybe be millions of years old.
D. God created the Earth and every living creature in it in 6 literal days.
E. The earth and all other planets resulted from an explosion or “Big Bang” of
primordial soup. Life forms eventually formed, evolving from the first single-celled
archebacteria to land dwelling creatures and eventually into people, over the course
of 4.5 billion years.
F. Other
Do you believe a catastrophic global flood took place? Yes or No
If so, do you believe that dinosaurs were on Noah’s Ark? Yes or No
Do you believe that dinosaurs and people could have lived at the same time? Yes or No
Do you believe natural selection, which Darwin observed though the finches on
Galapagos Island, provides compelling evidence that evolution from one kind of animal
to another (such as amphibians evolving into dinosaurs) is possible?
Yes No
Do you think natural selection and evolution are essentially the same thing? Yes No
Davidson 18