Professional Documents
Culture Documents
www.elsevier.com/locate/worpatin
Abstract
Barnes Neville Wallis (18871979) was probably Great Britains most distinguished 20th century aeronautical engineer, despite
being largely self taught. He led 140 GB patents alone between 1917 and 1959 which not only illustrate his own career but also
throw light on the rise, glory years and later decline of the British aerospace industry.
2005 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Barnes Wallis; Engineering patents; Historical review; Airships; Geodetic structures; Aeroplane design; Telescopes
1. Early years
He came from a fairly impoverished London middle
class family and, despite a good scientic grounding at
Christs Hospital school, left in 1904 at 16 for a menial
apprenticeship paid 4 shillings a week (about 20 now)
with a company making ships engines, having failed
his London matriculation exam. Not a very promising
start! Nevertheless after 3 years of routine work he
decided to be a marine engineer (at a time when British
marine engineering dominated the world) and transferred to a shipyard in the Isle of Wight where he soon
gained a place in the drawing oce and earned 25 shillings week. By 1911, he had nished his apprenticeship
and was working on sea trials for destroyers; later he
was an expert on diesel engines. However, at this stage
he showed no sign of his later distinction.
0172-2190/$ - see front matter 2005 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.wpi.2005.05.004
R80 was abandoned in 1921, and Vickers closed its airship department. Wallis was given a retainer to pursue
his own interests which he used to get an external London engineering degree in a year, subsequently teaching
maths in a Swiss school to perfect his French and hopefully get a job in aviation sales.
3. Patent applications
Meanwhile from 1917 he began ling patents on various aspects of this airship work (see Appendix A). His
rst patent (Fig. 1) concerned a portable riveting machine for light structural work, his co-applicant being
a director of Vickers [1].
One of his Patent Agents was Arthur Bloxham,
whose sister was Walliss step-Mother, and Wallis subsequently fell for Mollyone of Arthurs ve daughters.
As Wallis was 35 to Mollys 17 her Father strongly dis-
21
4. Airships revived
Despite the success of aeroplanes in WW1 they were
small, noisy and uncomfortable so there was a widespread, if ultimately misguided, belief that airships were
the future for long distance passenger transportation. In
Britain this resulted in two programs, the R100 run by
the Vickers backed Airship Guarantee Company where
Wallis was made chief designer in 1923, and the R101
program started by the brief 1924 Labour Government
who approved of government planning and whose pacist wing considered Vickers to be merchants of
death. These rival capitalist and socialist programs led to considerable political inghting when there
was barely enough technical expertise or money to run
one program and the rival German Graf Zeppelin was
achieving worldwide fame in 19281929. The outcome
of the airship program supports the view that a small
team led by someone who knows what they are doing
nearly always achieves more than a committee. Wallis
generally believed that what is aesthetically attractive
is usually more ecient and the R100 had a torpedo like
shape with the passenger/engine cars recessed inside
(Fig. 2), [2].
Technically Walliss design and practical implementation was superior and R100 completed a successful
trip to Canada in 1930 which led to high hopes of
commercial success, especially sales to the USA. R101
was pressed into a trip to India shortly afterwards
and crashed in France with great loss of life, including
most of her design team and Lord Thomson, the Air
Minister and Labour politician most associated with
it. The subsequent recriminations eectively nished
both British programs though Germany and USA
continued until the Second World War (WW2) intervened. The R100 resulted in 24 GB and 12 US patents
for Wallis, not just concerned with the structure but
22
Fig. 3. GB281041Rigid airships in which transverse frame torsion and/or bending of longitudinal girders is avoided.
5. Aeroplanes again
Wallis had briey worked on aeroplanes in 1920 and
worked part time with Vickers Supermarine from 1928,
transferring permanently in 1930 before the end of the
airships. Initially he did not get on with his colleague
Mitchell (eventual designer of the Spitre) and transferred to designing a ying boat yacht and later a ghter. His prime innovation was in applying geodetics to
aircraft to improve strength and decrease weight. For
example, see Fig. 4, [4].
Despite numerous objections, especially from the
Air Ministry, his views eventually prevailed and led to
the Wellesley bomber in 1935 and later the Wellington which was a highly successful RAF bomber in
WW2, consequently being produced in the largest
numbers. Thanks to its geodetic construction the Wellington could absorb a tremendous amount of damage
and still get home which made it very popular with
its crews who aectionately christened it the Wimpy.
Again he was granted numerous patents in Britain
and abroad since, as in the airship program, he
worked on all aspects of aircraft structures and ancillaries. For example gun turret windscreens as shown in
Fig. 5, [5].
One popular contemporary idea for repelling bombing aircraft was surrounding the target with barrage balloons whose securing cables posed a severe hazard to
aircraft. In wartime they were generally ineectual but
Walliss idea (Fig. 6, [6]) was a saw edge on the aircraft
wing which could sever the cable!
A radical suggestion but I would not like to have
been in the plane that tried it!
Fig. 5. GB494248Adjustable windscreens for use with guns, cameras or other instruments mounted on aircraft.
23
24
Fig. 6. GB568559Protecting aircraft from wire obstructions by providing a saw edge to the wings.
Fig. 7. GB937959Explosive missiles launched from aircraft with forward spinning motion.
25
26
27
28
1
Oxford Dictionary of Quotations (UK: Book Club Associates by
arrangement with Oxford University Press, 3rd ed. 1979) 364.9. The
full quotation is I often feel, and ever more deeply I realize, that fate
and character are the same conception.
Acknowledgment
16
14
12
10
NUMBER OF
PATENTS
8
6
4
2
0
1917
29
26
35
44
53
Appn year
Patent number
Appendix A
The esp@cenet database provided by the EPO lists
140 published GB patents with Barnes Neville Wallis
as Inventor/Applicant. There are also 41 US, 19 DE, 4
FR, 1 CH and 1 BE listed. Some of these non-GB patents are listed as GB equivalents and the others are
probably related. I have listed them by year of original
application as the grant dates vary considerably.
Most of these have as applicants the Airship Guarantee Company or various Vickers companies but a few are
in Walliss name only or have other inventors/applicants.
Subject matter
Other applicants/inventors
J. McKechnie
McKechnie/Vickers
Burney
Temple/Burney
Norway
Burney
(continued on next page)
30
Appendix A (continued)
Appn year Patent number Subject matter
1926
1926
1926
1926
1926
1926
1926
1926
1927
1927
GB282167
GB282518
GB283635
US1661206
US1713574
US1724440
US1758143
US1781100
GB301343
GB301347
Airship framework
Airship outer cover stretching
Airship bag relief valve
Airship
Airship
Airship
Airship
Airship
Bolted joint for anges
Connecting tanks
Aircraft
Some of these are in Walliss name only though he was clearly working for Vickers
1929
GB334405
Frame structures for aircraft wings/fuselages
1929
GB341937
Turning aircraft stress-distributing sleeves
(equivalents FR703228, DE558900)
1929
DE559305
Aircraft
1929
DE568607
Aircraft
1929
GB342268
Aircraft wing structures
1929
US1805964
Turning
1929
US1833696
Aircraft wings
1929
US1846772
Aircraft frame
1930
GB348936
Screwing and tapping for aircraft tubes
1931
GB376364
Aircraft framework
Vickers Aviation and later Vickers companies
1931
GB376365
Securing strengthening sleeves for aircraft tubes
1931
GB380091
Drilling metal aircraft tubes
1931
GB380093
Riveting metal aircraft tubes
1931
GB387346
Aircraft gun mounting
1931
GB387347
Aircraft wing bracing
1931
GB388437
Folding aircraft wings
1931
GB388438
Aircraft fuselages with geodetic bracing axes
1931
GB392905
Stressed skin aircraft fuselages
1931
GB392972
Spring buered arm for aircraft gun
1931
US1891127
Strengthening sleeves for tube ends
1931
US1894011
Construction if aircraft fuselage
1931
US1913097
Constructing a girder
1931
FR701140
Aircraft
1931
FR703261
Aircraft
1932
GB399555
Aircraft wing construction
1932
GB399887
Aircraft tail unit
1932
GB406747
Aircraft gun mounting
1932
GB406753
Spring hinged adjustable seat for aircraft gun mounting
(equivalents US1933197, FR751977, BE395143, DE586033)
1932
GB407009
Aircraft wings
1932
GB408674
Assembling geodetic aircraft bracing members
1932
GB412232
Aircraft wing upper and lower boom construction
1932
GB416841
Aircraft gun mounting
1932
US1935491
Aircraft gun mounting (equivalents FR753516, BE395477)
1932
US1967795
Aircraft cantilever wing
1932
US1985649
Aircraft wing construction
1933
GB418066
Aircraft biplane wing bracings
1933
GB419748
Aircraft control surface balancing
Other applicants/inventors
Burney
Burney
Temple/Burney
Temple/Burney/Norway
31
Appendix A (continued)
Appn year Patent number Subject matter
1933
1933
1933
1933
1933
1934
1934
1934
1934
1935
1935
1935
1935
1935
1936
1936
1936
1936
1937
1937
1937
1937
1937
1937
1937
1937
1937
1937
1937
1938
1941
1941
1941
1941
1941
1941
1941
1941
1941
1941
1941
1941
1941
1942
1942
1942
1942
1942
1943
1943
1943
1943
1944
GB426134
GB426268
GB429186
GB429188
GB449234
GB441084
GB449236
GB449237
US1956480
GB452726
GB465734
GB478955
GB465733
US2060387
GB471124
GB471123
GB479858
US2115504
DE675983
GB478089
GB494109
GB494233
GB494248
GB505201
GB505202
GB505208
GB568559
US2234906
US2157042
GB510164
GB548287
GB549033
GB561929
GB562301
GB578152
GB573725
GB571719
GB565860
GB565771
GB565770
US2362951
US2365669
US2387219
GB581142
GB574576
GB574090
GB572303
GB937959
GB572816
GB567900
GB937960
US2388197
GB577154
Other applicants/inventors
32
Appendix A (continued)
Appn year
Patent number
Subject matter
1944
1944
1944
1944
1945
1945
1945
1945
1946
1946
1947
1947
1948
1948
1949
1949
1949
1949
1949
1949
1949
1949
1949
1949
1950
1950
1950
1950
1951
1953
1953
1954
1954
1954
1954
1955
1955
1955
1955
1955
1955
1956
1956
1956
1956
1956
1957
1957
1957
1958
1958
1958
GB575392
GB580574
DE805498
US2455838
DE820540
US2459009
GB595464
GB595490
GB595494
US2504767
GB586976
GB741717
GB741718
GB741719
GB673550
GB673551
GB692140
GB756019
GB756020
GB759677
GB759678
GB759679
GB759680
GB741720
GB764291
GB764292
GB764395
US2659553
GB731665
GB730818
GB832181
GB832606
GB832760
GB852881
US2915261
GB798953
GB820166
GB860823
GB861230
US2922601
US2990141
GB832761
GB832762
GB842363
GB854459
US2969938
GB839647
GB1148492
DE1083567
GB857832
GB870739
GB950400
Other applicants/inventors
33
Appendix A (continued)
Appn year
Patent number
Subject matter
Other applicants/inventors
1958
1958
1958
1958
1958
1958
1959
1959
1959
1959
1959
1959
1959
1959
1960
1960
DE1079465
DE1081765
DE1081766
DE1081767
DE1105727
DE977750
GB885033
GB885105
US2980366
GB894365
US3047255
DE1109038
DE1110526
DE1132000
DE1175997
CH400785
Aircraft
Aircraft
Aircraft
Aircraft
Aircraft
Aircraft
Variable sweepwing aircraft
References
[1] McKechnie J [Director, Vickers Ltd.], Wallis BN. Improvements
in or relating to riveting machine. GB Patent Specication 118162.
Earliest application date: 29 August 1917.
[2] Airship Guarantee Company, Wallis BN, Denniston C [Retired
Lieutenant-Commander, and Member of Parliament]. Improvements in or relating to lighter-than-air aircraft. GB Patent
Specication 250330. Earliest application date: 9 January 1925.
[3] Airship Guarantee Company, Wallis BN, Denniston C, Norway
NS, Temple JE. Improvements in or relating to rigid airships. GB
Patent Specication 281041. Earliest application date: 17 September 1926.
[4] Vickers (Aviation) Ltd. and Wallis BN. Improvements in the
structure of fuselages, wings, and other bodies of aircraft. GB
Patent Specication 452726. Earliest application date: 27 February 1935.
[5] Vickers (Aviation) Ltd. and Wallis BN. Improvements in and
connected with adjustable windscreens for use in conjunction with
guns, cameras and other instruments mounted on aircraft. GB
Patent Specication 494248. Earliest application date: 23 April
1937.
[6] Vickers (Aviation) Ltd. and Wallis BN. Improvements in or
connected with means for protecting aircraft from wire obstructions. GB Patent Specication 568559. Earliest application date:
23 December 1937. [Withheld from publication for several years,
under Section 30 of the Patents and Designs Acts, 1907 to 1939.]
[7] Vickers Aircraft Holdings Ltd. [and Wallis BN as inventor].
Improvements in explosive missiles and means for their discharge
[from aircraft with forward spinning motion]. GB Patent Specication 937959. Earliest application date: 11 August 1942.
Publication date: 25 September 1963.
[8] Wallis BN. Improvements in aeroplanes. [Control of yawing and
pitching of aircraft] GB Patent Specication 595464. Earliest
application date: 1 March 1945. Publication date: 5 December
1947.
Bibliography
[1] Morpurgo JE. Barnes Wallis. London: Penguin Books; 1973.
[2] Brickhill P. The dam busters, London, 1951.
[3] Shute N. Slide rule, London, 1954.