You are on page 1of 18

FSICA E ONTOLOGIA

PHYSICS AND ONTOLOGY

DCIO KRAUSE
8QLYHUVLGDGH)HGHUDOGH6DQWD&DWDULQD%UDVLOGHFLRNUDXVH#JPDLOFRP
RECIBIDO EL 29 DE FEBRERO Y APROBADO EL 1 DE ABRIL DE 2008

RESUMEN
/D SUHJXQWD GH 4XLQH 4Xp HV OR TXH
KD\" UHFLEH XQD FDUDFWHUtVWLFD SHFXOLDU
HQODItVLFDDFWXDOHVSHFLDOPHQWHFXDQGR
RWRUJDPRV DWHQFLyQ DO FRQFHSWR GH
HQWLGDG ItVLFD X objeto fsico VREUH OR
TXH GLFHQ DOJR DO PHQRV LGHDOPHQWH
las teoras fsicas. En la medida en que
la fsica se ocupa de los constitutivos
~OWLPRVGHODPDWHULDHQWUDHQHVFHQDOD
FXHVWLyQ GH ORV REMHWRV ItVLFRV GH PRGR
esencial. A pesar de que la fsica actual no
VHRFXSDSURSLDPHQWHGHRQWRORJtDVLQR
de explicar por qu el mundo es como
HVODVFXHVWLRQHVRQWROyJLFDVLQWHUHVDQDO
OyVRIR\VLpVWHQRTXLHUHOLPLWDUVHDOD
PHUD HVSHFXODFLyQ VH GHEH DFHUFDU D OR
TXHSDVDHQODFLHQFLDDFWXDO\QRSXHGH
LJQRUDU OD WHRUtDV YLJHQWHV HQ HVSHFLDO
las fsicas.

PALABRAS CLAVE
4XLQH ItVLFD ItVLFD GH SDUWLFXODV
RQWRORJtD

ABSTRACT
4XLQHVTXHVWLRQZKDWLVWKHUH"KDVD
SHFXOLDUFKDUDFWHULVWLFLQFXUUHQWSK\VLFV
VSHFLDOO\ ZKHQ ZH JLYH DWWHQWLRQ WR WKH
FRQFHSWRISK\VLFDOHQWLW\RUSK\VLFDO
REMHFWDERXWZKDWSK\VLFDOWKHRULHVVD\
VRPHWKLQJ DW OHDVW LGHDOO\ ,Q VR IDU DV
SK\VLFVGHDOVZLWKWKHXOWLPDWHFRQVWLWXHQWV
RIPDWWHUWKHSUREOHPRISK\VLFDOREMHFWV
JHW LQ WKH SLFWXUH $OWKRXJK FXUUHQW
SK\VLFVGRHVQRWGHDOZLWKRQWRORJ\EXW
RI WKH H[SODQDWLRQ RI KRZ WKH ZRUOG LV
WKHZD\LWLVRQWRORJLFDOTXHVWLRQVDUHRI
LQWHUHVWIRUWKHSKLORVRSKHUZKRVKRXOG
EH IDPLOLDUL]HG ZLWK WKH VLWXDWLRQ RI
DFWXDOVFLHQFHDQGFDQQRWLJQRUHFXUUHQW
WKHRULHVXQOHVVKH]ZDQWVWROLPLWKLPVHOI
to speculation.

KEY WORDS
4 X L Q H   S K \ V L F V   T X D Q W X P  W K H R U \ 
RQWRORJ\

*UXSRGH/yJLFDH)XQGDPHQWRVGD&LHQFLD'HSDUWDPHQWRGH)LORVRItD

'LVFXVLRQHV)LORVyFDV$xR1(QHUR-XQLRSS

Dcio Krause

INTRODUO
$SHUJXQWDGH4XLQH2TXHKi"JDQKDXPDFDUDFWHUtVWLFDSHFXOLDU
QD ItVLFD SUHVHQWH HVSHFLDOPHQWH TXDQGR GDPRV DWHQomR DR FRQFHLWR
GH HQWLGDGH ItVLFD RX objeto fsico FRPR SUHIHULPRV GL]HU DRV TXDLV
DVWHRULDVItVLFDVDRPHQRVLGHDOPHQWHGL]HPUHVSHLWR1DPHGLGDHP
TXHDItVLFDVHRFXSDGRVFRQVWLWXLQWHV~OWLPRVGDPDWpULDDTXHVWmR
GRREMHWRItVLFRHQWUDHPFHQDGHPRGRHVVHQFLDO$LQGDTXHDItVLFDGH
KRMHQmRVHRFXSHGHRQWRORJLDSURSULDPHQWHPDVHPH[SOLFDUDUD]mR
GRPXQGRVHUFRPRpTXHVW}HVRQWROyJLFDVLQWHUHVVDPDROyVRIRHVH
HVWHQmRGHVHMDFDUUHVWULWRjSXUDHVSHFXODomRGHYHVHDFHUFDUGRTXH
UHDOPHQWHRFRUUHFRPDFLrQFLDSUHVHQWHHHQWmRQmRSRGHGHL[DUGH
GDUDWHQomRjVWHRULDVYLJHQWHVHPHVSHFLDOGDItVLFD
1DV WHRULDV TXkQWLFDV H UHODWLYLVWD GH FDPSRV TXH DOLFHUoDP D ItVLFD
SUHVHQWH VmR GHVFULWDV DV FKDPDGDV partculas elementares DLQGD TXH
DSDODYUDSDUWtFXODQDGDWHQKDDYHUFRPDLGpLDLQWXLWLYDGHXPD
pequena coisa R PHVPR GH XPD FRQFHSomR DWRPLVWD QR VHQWLGR GRV
DQWLJRVJUHJRV FRPR'HPyFULWR $ItVLFDGHSDUWtFXODVGHKRMHDLQGD
TXHHPSUHJXHHVWHWHUPRGHVFUHYHHVVDVHQWLGDGHVPDWHPDWLFDPHQWH
TXHQmRQRVVmRGDGDVFRPRSRUH[HPSORQRVHGDGRXPREMHWRQRYR
SDUD TXH R FRQKHoDPRV GLJDPRV XP QRYR PRGHOR GH YHtFXOR TXH
GHVFUHYHPRV SRU VXDV FDUDFWHUtVWLFDV  $V SDUWtFXODV HOHPHQWDUHV GH
KRMH SRGHP VHU virtuais QR VHQWLGR GH TXH VXD H[LVWrQFLD RFRUUH HP
LQWHUYDORV GH WHPSR WmR SHTXHQRV TXH QmR SRGHP VHU REVHUYDGDV H
KiDOJXPDVGHODVTXHDSHVDUGHVHUHPHVVHQFLDLVSDUDTXHDVWHRULDV
ItVLFDVIXQFLRQHPDFRQWHQWRFRPRRFKDPDGREyVRQGH+LJJVTXHHP
WHRULDVHUYHSDUDMXVWLFDUDH[LVWrQFLDGHPDVVDHPRXWUDVSDUWtFXODV
QXQFD IRUDP REVHUYDGDV H WDOYH] QXQFD R VHMDP FRPR RV WiTXLRQV
3DUWtFXODV VmR KRMH quanta de campos FHUWDV IRUPDV GH H[FLWDomR
HQHUJpWLFDGHHQWLGDGHVPDWHPiWLFDVFKDPDGDVFDPSRVGHVFULWDVHP
HVSDoRVPDWHPiWLFRVGHYiULDVGLPHQV}HVHDYDULiYHLVFRPSOH[DV RX
VHMDGHSHQGHPGHIRUPDHVVHQFLDOGRVFKDPDGRVQ~PHURVFRPSOH[RV 
3RUH[HPSORQDItVLFDTXkQWLFDGHKRMHXPDGDVFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVPDLV
LQWXLWLYDVGHXPREMHWRItVLFRHDFHLWDSHODItVLFDFOiVVLFDDLGHQWLGDGH
transtemporal (que Hans Reichenbach denominava de genidentitt 
QmRVHPDQWpPQDPDLRUSDUWHGDVLQWHUSUHWDo}HV
(PVXPDDQRomRGHREMHWRItVLFRQHFHVVLWDVHUUHYLVDGDjOX]GDItVLFD
SUHVHQWHHFRPRLVVRHVWiQDEDVHGHTXDOTXHUVXSRVLomRRQWROyJLFD
VREUH D FLrQFLDDWXDO RDVVXQWRWRUQDVH UHOHYDQWH SDUD D ORVRD $

58

'LVFXVLRQHV)LORVyFDV$xR1(QHUR-XQLRSS

FSICA E ONTOLOGIA

SURSyVLWRVDOLHQWDPRVTXHDQRomRTXHDVVXPLUHPRVGHREMHWRItVLFR
QHWVQRWDVpVXFLHQWHPHQWHDPSODSDUDHQJOREDUSURFHVVRVRXHYHQWRV
FRQVWDQWH GD ORVRD GH DOJXQV SHQVDGRUHV TXH SDVVDP GDTXL SDUD
IUHQWH D VHU WUDWDGRV FRPR REMHWRV ItVLFRV tout court $GHPDLV SDUD
GHOLPLWDUPRV R QRVVR DVVXQWR H QmR QRV HVWHQGHUPRV HP GHPDVLD
YDPRV UHVWULQJLU QRVVD DWHQomR j TXHVWmR GD LQGLYLGXDOLGDGH GRV
REMHWRV ItVLFRV TXkQWLFRV TXH p GH JUDQGH DWXDOLGDGH H QRV WUDUi D
SRVVLELOLGDGHGHGLVFXWLULQWHUHVVDQWHVTXHVW}HVRQWROyJLFDV
$ ItVLFD FOiVVLFD DVVXPH SUHVVXSRVWRV FRQVRDQWHV FRP XPD YLVmR GR
REMHWRItVLFRFRPRVHQGRXPindivduoDOJRTXHSRGH SHORPHQRVHP
SULQFtSLR VHUVHPSUHLGHQWLFiYHOUHFHEHUXPQRPHVHUGLVWLQJXLGR
GHRXWURVPHVPRTXHVLPLODUHVHWF'HDFRUGRFRPDItVLFDFOiVVLFD
PHVPR GRLV HOpWURQV SRGHP VHPSUH VHU GLVFHUQLGRV SRU H[HPSOR
SRU VXD SRVLomR HVSDoRWHPSRUDO XPD YH] [DGR XP VLVWHPD GH
FRRUGHQDGDV 1R HQWDQWR QD PDLRU SDUWH GDV LQWHUSUHWDo}HV GR
IRUPDOLVPR GD PHFkQLFD TXkQWLFD HVVH QmR p R FDVR H HVVH IDWR WHP
LPSRUWDQWHV LPSOLFDo}HV SDUD TXDOTXHU GLVFXVVmR VREUH RQWRORJLD
&RPHIHLWRQmRKiTXDOTXHUVHQWLGRHPVHGLVFXWLUWHPDVORVyFRV
FRPRRVUHODFLRQDGRVjRQWRORJLDVHPVHOHYDUHPFRQWDDFLrQFLDGH
KRMH FRPR H[SUHVVRX R OyVRIR GD FLrQFLD DPHULFDQR $UWKXU )LQH
 DORVRDGDFLrQFLDGHYHHVWDUVHPSUHHQJDMDGDFRPDFLrQFLD
do momento (apud)UHQFK 

A LINGUAGEM E OS OBJETIVOS DO FSICO


$ ItVLFD GH KRMH OLGD FRP XPD JUDQGH YDULHGDGH GH HQWLGDGHV TXH
VmR GHQRPLQDGDV GH SDUWtFXODV HOHPHQWDUHV $SHVDU GR QRPH
HODV QDGD WrP GH SDUWtFXODV TXH QRVVD LPDJHP LQWXLWLYD DVVRFLD D
XPD SHTXHQD EROLQKD RX D XP FRUSR PLQ~VFXOR FRPR SHQVDYDP
RV DQWLJRV DWRPLVWDV JUHJRV FRPR /HXFLSR H 'HPyFULWR  H QHP GH
HOHPHQWDUHVWHUPRTXHRULJLQDOPHQWHYLVDYDGHVLJQDUDVHQWLGDGHV
PDLVEiVLFDVGDPDWpULDTXHQmRSRGLDPVHUGHFRPSRVWDVHPRXWUDV
DLQGDPDLVHOHPHQWDUHV+RMHSUyWRQVSRUH[HPSORVmRSDUWtFXODV
HOHPHQWDUHV DSHVDU GH VHUHP IRUPDGRV SRU TXDUNV TXH QmR VH
VDEHDLQGDVHVmRRXQmRFRPSRVWRV 2ItVLFRWUDWDGHVVDVHQWLGDGHV
QD FKDPDGD ItVLFD GH SDUWtFXODV HODERUD H[SHULPHQWRV HP TXH HVVDV
SDUWtFXODV FROLGHP D JUDQGHV YHORFLGDGHV GHVFUHYHDV SRU PHLR
GH SURSULHGDGHV OLGD FRP HODV FRPR VH H[LVWLVVHP GH IDWR DSHVDU
GHTXHPXLWDVYH]HVQmRKiTXDOTXHUHYLGrQFLDH[SHULPHQWDOGHVXD

59

Dcio Krause

real H[LVWrQFLD (VVDV HQWLGDGHV EiVLFDV TXH DV WHRULDV ItVLFDV VXS}HP
QmR SRGHP VHU DFHVVDGDV GLUHWDPHQWH VHQmR SRU PRGRV LQGLUHWRV
3RUXPDVpULHGHPRWLYRVTXHWrPWLGRFDGDYH]PDLVFRPSURYDo}HV
H[SHULPHQWDLV RV REMHWRV TXkQWLFRV QmR SRGHP VHU FRQFHELGRV
mais como entidades que existam em perfeito isolamento. A natureza
RQWROyJLFD GHVVDV HQWLGDGHV p XP GRV WHPDV FDQGHQWHV QD SUHVHQWH
ORVRDGDItVLFD
2TXHRItVLFRTXHUGL]HUHQWmRTXDQGRDVVHYHUDFRLVDVFRPR([LVWH
XPD SDUWtFXOD HOHPHQWDU FRP HVWD RX DTXHOD SURSULHGDGH" 6HUi
TXH HOH HVWi IRUPXODQGR XPD TXHVWmR GH QDWXUH]D RQWROyJLFD FXMD
resposta depende do seu conhecimento sobre a natureza da entidade
HOHPHQWDUGDTXDOLQGDJD"2XVHMDVHUiTXHRItVLFRQHFHVVLWDFRQKHFHU
RVREMHWRVItVLFRVFRPRHQWHVHQTXDQWRHQWHVSDUDGHOHVWUDWDU"&ODUR
TXHLVVRpRTXHQRVVDFRQFHSomRLQIRUPDOGDFLrQFLDSDUHFHLQGLFDU
$ULJRUQRHQWDQWRWHQGRHPYLVWDDItVLFDGHKRMHSRGHPRVVXVWHQWDU
TXHGHQLWLYDPHQWHHVWHQmRpRFDVR$ ItVLFD GH KRMH QmR VH RFXSD
SURSULDPHQWH GH RQWRORJLD H QmR GHSHQGH GH TXH VH conhea (no
VHQWLGRWUDGLFLRQDO DYHUGDGHLUDQDWXUH]DGDVHQWLGDGHVFRPDVTXDLV
OLGD$OLiVDSUHRFXSDomRFRPDQDWXUH]D~OWLPDGDUHDOLGDGHSDUHFH
TXHIRLGHL[DGDGHODGRSHODFLrQFLDMiDSDUWLUGRVVpFXORV;9,H;9,,
1mR TXH R ItVLFR QmR VH RFXSH HP GHVYHQGDU D QDWXUH]D GR PXQGR
2TXHRFRUUHpTXHLVVRYHPFRPRFRQVHTrQFLDGHVXDVVXSRVLo}HV
WHyULFDVHQmRpRVHXDVVXQWRIXQGDPHQWDO&RPRVXVWHQWRXRODXUHDGR
FRP R 1REHO HP )tVLFD HP   6WHYHQ :HLQEHUJ FRQWUDULDQGR D
SUHRFXSDomR RQWROyJLFD FOiVVLFD R ItVLFR GH KRMH HVWi PDLV RFXSDGR
HPH[SOLFDUSRUTXHRPXQGRIXQFLRQDGRPRGRFRPRIXQFLRQDHQmR
SURSULDPHQWHHPGHVYHQGDUDQDWXUH]DGDVFRLVDV :HLQEHUJ 
'LWR GH RXWUR PRGR HQTXDQWR R OyVRIR GD FLrQFLD VH SUHRFXSD se
XPDWHRULDVHUHIHUHDDOJRQRPXQGRRFLHQWLVWDHVWiSUHRFXSDGRHP
saber quo bemXPGHWHUPLQDGRPRGHORWHyULFRGHVFUHYHRXSUHGL]
RFRPSRUWDPHQWRGRVLVWHPDDRTXDOVHUHIHUHVHPID]HUVXSRVLo}HV
VREUHDVXDH[LVWrQFLD WDPEpPFI)DONHQEXUJ 
&RP HIHLWR XPD JUDQGH UHYROXomR HP FLrQFLD RFRUUHX TXDQGR RV
FLHQWLVWDV GHL[DUDP GH VH SUHRFXSDU FRP D QDWXUH]D GDV HQWLGDGHV
SDVVDQGRDVHLPSRUWDUFRPRVHXFRPSRUWDPHQWR1DDQWLJXLGDGHH
DWppSRFDEHPDYDQoDGDQD,GDGH0pGLDDRFXSDomRGRFLHQWLVWD RX
OyVRIR HUDVREUHDVcoisasSURSULDPHQWH9HMDVHSRUH[HPSORRWtWXOR
GRFpOHEUHWUDEDOKRGH/XFUpFLR D& De Rerum Natura (Sobre a
1DWXUH]DGDV&RLVDV XPDH[FHOHQWHH[SRVLomRGRDVVXQWRHGHVXDV

60

'LVFXVLRQHV)LORVyFDV$xR1(QHUR-XQLRSS

FSICA E ONTOLOGIA

LPSOLFDo}HVQDFLrQFLDDWXDOpROLYURGH7RUDOGRGL)UDQFLD1D
pSRFD GR JUDQGH PDWHPiWLFR -RVHSK )RXULHU   KDYLD XPD
SUHRFXSDomRHQRUPHMiSUHVHQWHQDDQWLJXLGDGHFRPDQDWXUH]DGR
FDORURTXHcausava RFDORUTXHHPHVSHFLDOVXVWHQWDDYLGDKXPDQD"
5HFRUGHPRV TXH +LSyFUDWHV HP FHUFD GH  D& FRQMHWXURX TXH
R FDORU TXH VHUYH SDUD DQLPDU >RV VHUHV YLYRV@ GHULYD GH XP IRJR
LQWHUQRORFDOL]DGRQRYHQWUtFXORHVTXHUGR([SOLFDo}HVFRPRHVVDQmR
HUDPLQFRPXQV$LPSRUWkQFLDGHPHQFLRQDU)RXULHUQmRpXPDFDVR
Teorias como a do RJLVWRVHJXQGRDTXDORVFRUSRVFRQWLQKDPXPD
VXEVWkQFLD R RJLVWR  TXH HUD OLEHUDGD TXDQGR TXHLPDYDP IRUDP
abandonadas e Fourier simplesmente desconsiderou a natureza do
calor em prol de uma anlise de seu comportamento.2XVHMDHOHQmR
VHRFXSRXGHH[SOLFDUDQDWXUH]DGRFDORUPDVSDUWLQGRGDVXSRVLomR
GHVXDH[LVWrQFLDWUDWRXGHFRQVLGHUDUFRPRHOHVHSURSDJD A teoria
UHVXOWDQWHFRQVWLWXLXXPDGDVPDLVQRWiYHLVFRQTXLVWDVGDPDWHPiWLFD
GDQGRRULJHPDRTXHKRMHVHFKDPDGH$QiOLVHGH)RXULHUTXHDOpP
GHXPDJUDQGHEHOH]DLQWUtQVHFD SDUDTXHPJRVWDGHPDWHPiWLFD p
parte essencial da matemtica aplicada.
'D PHVPD IRUPD ,VDDF 1HZWRQ QmR VH SUHRFXSRX FRP o que fazia
RV FRUSRV VH PRYLPHQWDUHP RX VHMD FRP D natureza do movimento.
6LPSOHVPHQWH DVVXPLX TXH RV FRUSRV VH PRYLPHQWDP VRE D DomR
GH IRUoDV  H RFXSRXVH FRP DV WD[DV GH YDULDomR GD YHORFLGDGH GRV
FRUSRVDVXDDFHOHUDomR&RPRVHVDEHXPDGDVOHLVEiVLFDVGDItVLFD
GH1HZWRQpDHTXDomRF maRQGHFpDIRUoDDSOLFDGDDXPFRUSR
de massa m H a D VXD DFHOHUDomR R QHJULWR LQGLFD TXH DPEDV VmR
JUDQGH]DVYHWRULDLV $OEHUW(LQVWHLQQDPHVPDOLQKDQmRTXHVWLRQRX
sobre porque a luz de tal natureza que tem velocidade constante
HP WRGRV RV UHIHUHQFLDLV LQHUFLDLV VLPSOHVPHQWH DVVXPLX HVWH IDWR
como um dos princpios bsicos da teoria da relatividade restrita. Em
RXWUDV SDODYUDV D natureza GDV HQWLGDGHV SDVVRX D VHU DOJR SDUD VHU
TXHVWLRQDGRHPVHJXQGRSODQRVHpTXHKiXPSODQRTXHOKHFDLED
6HDFUHGLWDUPRVHP:HLQEHUJVXSRVWDPHQWHQmRKi,VWRFHUWDPHQWH
QmR FRQWHQWD R OyVRIR RFXSDGR FRP RQWRORJLD PDV YDPRV DGLDQWH
PHVPRSRUTXHQmRFUHPRVTXHHOHWHQKDUD]mR
6DOLHQWHPRVHQWmRTXHDItVLFDGHKRMHVXS}HDH[LVWrQFLDGHHQWLGDGHV
TXHQmRWrPFRPSURYDomRH[SHULPHQWDO(PJHUDOHVVDVXSRVLomRYHP
GH QHFHVVLGDGHV PDWHPiWLFDV GH FRHUrQFLD GDV WHRULDV FRQVLGHUDGDV
H VXUSUHHQGHQWHPHQWH D H[SHULrQFLD WHP FRPSURYDGR D SRVWHULRUL 
HVVDVVXSRVLo}HV DLQGDTXHQmRSRVVDPRVJDUDQWLUTXHLVVRFRQWLQXDUi

61

Dcio Krause

DVVLPQRIXWXUR 'HIDWRDOJXPDVGDVSDUWtFXODVHOHPHQWDUHVIRUDP
descobertas experimentalmente somente bem depois de haverem tido
VXDV FDUDFWHUtVWLFDV SUHYLVWDV WHRULFDPHQWH FRPR D FpOHEUH SDUWtFXOD
RPHJDPHQRV0HVPRKRMHDItVLFDDWXDOUHTXHUDH[LVWrQFLDGHXPD
SDUWtFXODFKDPDGDGHEyVRQGH+LJJVTXHVHULDUHVSRQViYHOSHODPDVVD
GH RXWUDV SDUWtFXODV HOHPHQWDUHV TXH QmR WHP DLQGD FRPSURYDomR
experimental.
'HDFRUGRFRPRTXHDSUHQGHPRVGDORVRDGH4XLQHHRXWURVDV
SDUWtFXODVHOHPHQWDUHVFRPRRVTXDUNVH[LVWHPVHHVRPHQWHVHRPXQGR
ItVLFRTXHFHUWDPHQWHH[LVWHpIRUPDGRWDPEpPSRUTXDUNVRXVHMDVH
DWHRULDTXHHQYROYHTXDUNVIRUYHUGDGHLUDVerdadeDTXLQRHQWDQWR
SRGH QmR VLJQLFDU H[DWDPHQWH FRQFRUGkQFLD RX FRUUHVSRQGrQFLD
GLUHWD FRPDVREVHUYDo}HVFRPRTXDQGRGL]HPRVTXH$VHQWHQoD
2 FDUUR TXH WUDQVSRUWD R 3UHVLGHQWH GD 5HS~EOLFD VH GHVORFD D 
.PKpYHUGDGHLUDSRLVQHVWHFDVRSRGHPRVVLPSOHVPHQWHFRQIHULU
D VXD YHORFLGDGH 0XLWDV YH]HV D YHUDFLGDGH GH XPD VXSRVLomR RX
WHRULDDGYpPGHVXDVFRQVHTrQFLDVTXHSRGHPVHUGHDOJXPDIRUPD
FRQIHULGDVH[SHULPHQWDOPHQWHDLQGDTXHDSUySULDVXSRVLomRRXWHRULD
QmRSRVVDeDVVLPFRPJUDQGHSDUWHGDVWHRULDVItVLFDVGHKRMH3DUHFH
TXHRSURFHGLPHQWRHPFLrQFLDVHFRQIRUPDjFpOHEUHIUDVHGH&KDUOHV
6DQGHUV3HLUFHVHJXQGRTXHPDFRQFHSomRGHXPREMHWRGHSHQGHGRV
efeitos prticos que dele advm$WHRULDGDVFRUGDV VXUJLGDQRVDQRV
GRVpFXOR;; VHIRUPRVLQGDJDUVREUHVXDVVXSRVLo}HVRQWROyJLFDV
DGPLWH TXH D RQWRORJLD EiVLFD GR PXQGR p FRPSRVWD GH FRUGDV
(strings TXHSRGHPVHUDEHUWDVRXIHFKDGDVHTXHWrPXPFRPSULPHQWR
QD FKDPDGD HVFDOD GH 3ODQFN FHUFD GH FP  1mR Ki DLQGD FRPR
YHULFDUVHKiGHIDWRHQWLGDGHVGHVVHWDPDQKRRXVHDVFRUGDVexistem
UHDOPHQWH SRLV QmR DOFDQoDPRV DLQGD FRQGLo}HV H[SHULPHQWDLV SDUD
SHVTXLVDU HQWLGDGHV GHVVH WDPDQKR ,VVR QmR LPSRUWD &RPR GLVVH
:HLQEHUJRTXHpUHOHYDQWHpTXHFRPHVVDVXSRVLomRFKHJDVHXPD
WHRULD QDYHUGDGHDYiULDVGHODV TXHUHVSRQGHVDWLVIDWRULDPHQWHjV
LQGDJDo}HV GR ItVLFR DLQGD TXH DSUHVHQWH YiULRV SUREOHPDV  Ergo
essas entidades existemSDUDDVQDOLGDGHVGDWHRULDFRQVLGHUDGDRX
SHORPHQRVtudo se passa como se elas existissem de fato.
1DYHUGDGHDVWHRULDVItVLFDV HGRPHVPRPRGRDVGHRXWUDViUHDV 
VmRHODERUDGDVFRPRLGHDOL]Do}HV)D]HPRVFRPDVWHRULDVRPHVPRTXH

$IUDVHGH3HLUFHTXHpFRQVLGHUDGDXPDPD[LPDGRSUDJPDWLVPRpDVHJXLQWH&RQVLGHUZKDW
HIIHFWVZKLFKPLJKWFRQFHLYDEO\KDYHSUDFWLFDOEHDULQJVZHFRQFHLYHWKHREMHFWRIRXUFRQFHSWLRQ
WRKDYH7KHQRXUFRQFHSWLRQRIWKHVHHIIHFWVLVWKHZKROHRIRXUFRQFHSWLRQRIWKHREMHFW

62

'LVFXVLRQHV)LORVyFDV$xR1(QHUR-XQLRSS

FSICA E ONTOLOGIA

ID]HPRVTXDQGROHPRVXPOLYURFRQFHQWUDQGRQRVHPFHUWRVGHVHXV
DVSHFWRV H SURSRVLWDGDPHQWH RX LQFRQVFLHQWHPHQWH  ID]HPRV YLVWD
JURVVDDPXLWRVRXWURVFRPR QRFDVRGROLYUR TXHHOHpFRPSRVWRSRU
FpOXODVRUJkQLFDVPRUWDVFRPLQWULQFDGDVHVWUXWXUDVYHJHWDLVTXHHVVDV
FpOXODV VmR IRUPDGDV SRU PROpFXODV TXH VmR FRPSRVWDV SRU iWRPRV
etc'DPHVPDIRUPDHPQRVVDVWHRULDVID]HPRVXPDVLPSOLFDomR
enorme de nosso contorno muitas vezes introduzindo elementos
LGHDOL]DGRVTXHQmRWrP SHORTXHVHVDEH FRUUHVSRQGHQWHQDUHDOLGDGH
FRPRSRUH[HPSORFRQMXQWRVLQQLWRVHREMHWRVLVRODGRV 
4XLQHGL]TXHuma teoria se compromete unicamente com aquelas entidades
jVTXDLVDVYDULiYHLVGDWHRULDVHUHIHUHPDPGHTXHDVVHQWHQoDVGDWHRULD
sejam verdadeiras. 1R HQWDQWR FRPR D DUJXPHQWDomR DFLPD SURFXUD
PRVWUDUPXLWDVYH]HVQmRQRVUHIHULPRVSRUPHLRGHQRVVDVWHRULDV
jTXLORTXHH[LVWHQRPXQGRItVLFRPDVjVFRLVDVTXHGHYHPRVDGPLWLU
D P GH TXH DV WHRULDV VHMDP YHUGDGHLUDV $VVLP SRGH QmR VHU TXH
VHMDP SURSULDPHQWH DV VHQWHQoDV TXH IRUPXODPRV RX DV HQWLGDGHV
que supomos que devam existirPDVRTXHUHVXOWDGHVVDVVXSRVLo}HV
UHFRUGH D IUDVH GH 3HLUFH YLVWD DFLPD  'HVWH PRGR TXDQGR R ItVLFR
diz que uma partcula elementar resulta de um particular modo de
YLEUDomRGHXPDFRUGD FRPRRFRUUHFRPDVWHRULDVGHFRUGDV SRGHPRV
WRPDU HVVD DUPDomR FRPR DFHUWDGD PHVPR TXH HVVDV FRUGDV QmR
H[LVWDPGHIDWR$VXDH[LVWrQFLDFDGHOLPLWDGDDRkPELWRGDWHRULD
e tudo se passaFRPRVHHODVGHIDWRH[LVWLVVHP(PRXWUDVSDODYUDVR
FRPSURPHWLPHQWRRQWROyJLFRGHL[DGHVHUabsoluto (da realidade como
HODpRXGHYHVHU SDUDVHWRUQDUrelativo DXPDWHRULD 1RHQWDQWR
SDUD TXH SRVVDPRV FRQWLQXDU D XVDU D FRQFHSomR GH 4XLQH TXDQGR
ele diz que os valores pretendidos das variveis de uma teoria so apenas
aqueles que a teoria admite, e no aquilo que realmente h, a no ser que a teoria
por acaso seja verdadeiraWHPRVTXHH[LELOL]DURFRQFHLWRGHYHUGDGH
TXHMiQmRSRGHPDLVVHUFRUUHVSRQGHQFLDOSRLVLVVRLPSOLFDULDTXHDV
FRUGDVSRUH[HPSORWHULDPTXHexistir de fato. O conceito de verdade
TXHPHOKRUGHDGDSWDjVWHRULDVItVLFDVSRUpPQmRVHUiWUDWDGRQHVWH
WH[WRHpGHQRPLQDGRGHquase-verdade (o leitor interessado pode ver
'D&RVWDFDStWXOR 
&RPHIHLWRHPItVLFDTXDQGRVHID]DVVHUo}HVH[LVWHQFLDLVGLFLOPHQWH
VHXWLOL]DPWHUPRVVLQJXODUHV FRPRQRPHVRXGHVFULo}HVHPFRQWUDVWH
FRPRVWHUPRVJHUDLV &RPRUHDOoDP'DOOD&KLDUDH7RUDOGRGL)UDQFLD


(VWHH[HPSORpH[SORUDGRSRU0DULR&DVWDJQLQRHP&DVWDJQLQR\6DQJXLQHWL  

63

Dcio Krause

 TXDQGRRItVLFRGL]TXHH[LVWHXPHOpWURQDVVLPHDVVLP
HOHQmRHVWiRFXSDGRHPHVSHFLFDUXPSDUWLFXODUHOpWURQPDVVLPXP
REMHWRGHXPFHUWRWLSRSHUWHQFHQWHDXPDFODVVHGHHQWLGDGHVQRFDVR
HOpWURQV1DYHUGDGHHPWHUPRVGHHOpWURQV HRPHVPRVHGiFRPDV
GHPDLVHQWLGDGHVEiVLFDVGDItVLFD WDQWRID]VHpeste ou aquele eltron
TXHGHVHPSHQKDXPFHUWRSDSHOSRVWRTXHqualquerHOpWURQGHFHUWR
PRGRVHUYHSDUDWRGRVRVSURSyVLWRVItVLFRVRTXHQmRRFRUUHFRPRV
REMHWRVXVXDLV FRPRXVXDOPHQWHVHVXS}H &RPRGL]HPHVVHVDXWRUHV
os fsicos, salvo em casos excepcionais, (...) fazem naturalmente a operao
de eliminao dos termos singulares proposta por Quine 1R HQWDQWR
HVVDDUPDWLYDGHYHVHUROKDGDFRPFXLGDGR6XSRQKDTXHXPItVLFR
TXkQWLFR HVWi WUDEDOKDQGR FRP XP iWRPR QHXWUR GLJDPRV GH /tWLR
VVSV TXHWHPXPHOpWURQHPVXDFDPDGDGHYDOrQFLD DFDPDGD
PDLVH[WHUQD HGHVHMDLRQL]iORSDUDREWHUXPLRQQHJDWLYR2ItVLFR
VDEHSHUIHLWDPHQWHEHPDWpDTXDQWLGDGHGHHQHUJLDTXHGHYHXWLOL]DU
para desprender aquele eltron que est na camada mais externa. Ele
VHUHIHUHPHWDOLQJXLVWLFDPHQWHqueleHOpWURQHQmRDRXWURTXDOTXHU
KDYHQGR XPD IRUPD GH GHVFULomR TXH FKDPDPRV GH GHVFULWRU
TXkQWLFRHP.UDXVHE GRWLSRo REMHWRTXkQWLFR assim e assim
,VVRQmRpSRUVXSRVWRXPDGHVFULomRGHQLGDQRVHQWLGRGH5XVVHOO
FXMD GHQLomR SUHVVXS}H D QRomR GH LJXDOGDGH LGHQWLGDGH  H QmR p
WDPSRXFRXPDGHVFULomRLQGHQLGDSRLVRItVLFRQmRHVWiVHUHIHULQGR
DXPHOpWURQDUELWUiULRPDVqueleHOpWURQRTXHHVWiQDFDPDGDPDLV
H[WHUQDGRiWRPR1DPHWDOLQJXDJHPHOHSRGHDWpQRPHiORFKDPi
ORGH3HGULQKRPDVHVVHQRPHFRPRVDOLHQWDUDPRVOyVRIRVLWDOLDQRV
PHQFLRQDGRVDFLPDQmRWHPVHQWLGRQDOLQJXDJHPSUySULDGDItVLFD
SRLVXPDYH]TXHHODID]XVRGDOyJLFDHGDPDWHPiWLFDFOiVVLFDVQRV
FRPSURPHWHULDFRPDLQGLYLGXDOLGDGHGHVVHHOpWURQHLVVRQmRpRTXH
VHVXS}HKDYHU QDPDLRULDGDVLQWHUSUHWDo}HVGDItVLFDTXkQWLFD 'H
IDWR R ItVLFR ID] D DSUHJRDGD HOLPLQDomR GH WHUPRV VLQJXODUHV PDV
DLQGDXVDGHVFULo}HVGHDOJXPWLSRDTXHODVSUySULDVGHVXDOLQJXDJHP
TXkQWLFD
+i XPD GLVWLQomR IXQGDPHQWDO D VHU IHLWD DTXL TXH QRV UHPHWH
QRYDPHQWHjGLVWLQomRDSRQWDGDDFLPDHQWUHTXHVW}HVHSLVWHPROyJLFDV
H TXHVW}HV RQWROyJLFDV 1mR FXVWD LQVLVWLU QR DVVXQWR $OJXpP SRGH
WHQWDUDUJXPHQWDUTXHHVVDSURSDJDGDHOLPLQDomRGHWHUPRVVLQJXODUHV
DFRQWHFHWDPEpPQDPDWHPiWLFDSRUH[HPSORTXDQGRRPDWHPiWLFR
GL]TXHH[LVWHXPPHQRUQ~PHURSULPRGDIRUPDpFRPPDLVGH
GtJLWRVDLQGDTXHQmRVDLEDPRV DWpRPRPHQWR TXHQ~PHURpHVVH R
PDLRUSULPRGDIRUPDpFKDPDGRVGHSULPRVGH0HUVHQQHTXH

64

'LVFXVLRQHV)LORVyFDV$xR1(QHUR-XQLRSS

FSICA E ONTOLOGIA

VHFRQKHFHpTXHWHPGtJLWRVGHVFREHUWRHP 
1RHQWDQWRSRGHPRVQRPHiORFKDPDQGRRGH3HGUR3ULPRHHVWH
QRPH ID] SHUIHLWDPHQWH VHQWLGR SRLV XP GLD SRGHUHPRV GLVWLQJXLU
3HGUR3ULPRGHTXDOTXHURXWURSRUVXDVSURSULHGDGHVSHFXOLDUHV FRPR
VHURPHQRUSULPRH~QLFRFRPPDLVGHGtJLWRV ,VVRQmRDFRQWHFH
com eltrons ou com outros constituintes bsicos da matria. Mesmo
TXHYRFrFKDPHGH3ULVFLOODXPFHUWRSyVLWURQDSULVLRQDGRHPXP
H[SHULPHQWRHQYROYHQGRFDPSRVHOHWURPDJQpWLFRV KiH[SHULPHQWRV
GHVVH WLSR QRV TXDLV VH WUDEDOKD FRP WUDSSHG TXDQWD RX VHMD
REMHWRVTXkQWLFRVFRPRHOpWURQVRXtRQVGHEiULRDSULVLRQDGRVFRPR
R 1REHO HP ItVLFD +DQV 'HKPHOW DSULVLRQRX R SyVLWURQ 3ULVFLOOD
SRU WUrV PHVHV  D LGHQWLFDomR VH SHUGH DSyV TXDOTXHU SRVVtYHO RX
LPDJLQiYHO  SHUPXWDomR SRLV qualquer psitron pode ser Priscilla PDV
VRPHQWHXPQ~PHURSULPRSRGHVHU3HGUR3ULPR,VVRLOXVWUDEHPR
TXHGL]HPRVGRLVDXWRUHVFRQVLGHUDGRVPDVPHUHFHXPDH[SOLFDomR
DGLFLRQDODOJRWpFQLFD1mRVHSUHRFXSHFRPRVGHWDOKHV RERPVHULD
VHLVVRGHVSHUWDVVHDVXDFXULRVLGDGHSDUDHVWXGRVPDLVGHWDOKDGRV 
'H IDWR SRU PHLR GR IRUPDOLVPR GD ItVLFD TXkQWLFD DVVXPLUHPRV
DTXLXPDYHUVmRPDLVVLPSOHVGDPHFkQLFDTXkQWLFDQmRUHODWLYtVWLFD 
SRGHPRV GHVFUHYHU XP HOpWURQ TXH HP XP FHUWR PRPHQWR HVWHMD QD
SRQWDGRQDUL]GR3UHVLGHQWHGD5HS~EOLFDSRUXPYHWRU e um outro
TXH HVWHMD QD SRQWD GR QDUL] GD 3ULPHLUD 'DPD SRU  H FKDPiODV
UHVSHFWLYDPHQWH GH -RmR H 0DULD (OHV VmR SRUWDQWR LGHQWLFiYHLV
WrPDWpQRPHV 1RHQWDQWRVHFRQVLGHUDPRVRVLVWHPDFRQMXQWRHVVH
VLVWHPDGXSORpUHSUHVHQWDGRSRUXPYHWRUGDIRUPD 
H[FHWR SRU DOJXQV IDWRUHV FRQVWDQWHV TXH QmR QRV LQWHUHVVDP DTXL 
O que interessa achar a densidade de probabilidade relacionada ao
VLVWHPDTXHLQIRUPDOPHQWHGLULDGDSUREDELOLGDGH TXHpWXGRRTXH
SRGHPRV FRQKHFHU VHJXQGR D PHFkQLFD TXkQWLFD  GH uma partcula
HVWDU QR QDUL] GR 3UHVLGHQWH H outra QR QDUL] GD 3ULPHLUD 'DPD
(VWH p FHUWDPHQWH XP H[HPSOR H[DJHUDGR PDV PRVWUD R SULQFLSDO
DUJXPHQWRTXHSRGHVHUDGDSWDGRSDUDVLWXDo}HVItVLFDVFRQFUHWDV6H
HODVIRUHPLQGLVFHUQtYHLV IRUHPGHPHVPDHVSpFLH SDODYUDVFRPR
esta e aquelaGHL[DPGHWHUXPVHQWLGRSUHFLVRWHQGRPHUDPHQWHXP
uso metafrico. A densidade de probabilidade dada pelo quadrado
GRPyGXORGHRXVHMD____TXHUHVXOWDUiHPXPDH[SUHVVmR
FRQWHQGRXPWHUPRGHLQWHUIHUrQFLDQmRHOLPLQiYHOTXHQmRSHUPLWH
que determinemos qualpDSDUWtFXODTXHHVWiQRQDUL]GR3UHVLGHQWH
Sabemos apenas que uma delasHVWiOiPDVQXQFDTXDOp2XVHMDRV
QRPHVGDGRVDQWHV-RmRH0DULDQmRID]HPPDLVVHQWLGRqualquer

65

Dcio Krause

HOpWURQSRGHVHU-RmRHqualquer eltron pode ser Maria. Como dizem


'DOOD &KLDUD H 7RUDOGR GL )UDQFLD R PXQGR GHVFULWR SHOD PHFkQLFD
TXkQWLFDpRPXQGRGRDQRQLPDWR$GHPDLVVHWHQWDUPRVLQWURGX]LU
RXWUDV YDULiYHLV TXH LQIRUPDOPHQWH SRGHULDP VHU SHQVDGDV FRPR
FDSD]HVGHIRUQHFHUDLGHQWLFDomR DVFKDPDGDVYDULiYHLVRFXOWDV 
QRV GHSDUDUHPRV FRP VpULDV GLFXOGDGHV FRPR PRVWUDP DOJXQV
resultados clebres sobre o assunto.

OBJETOS QUNTICOS E OS QUANTIFICADORES


Recordemos que podemos supor que a teoria fsica que estamos
FRQVLGHUDQGR WHQKD VLGR D[LRPDWL]DGD ,VVR FRPR Mi UHVVDOWDGR p
VHPSUH SRVVtYHO DLQGD TXH SUHVHQWHPHQWH KDMD GLFXOGDGHV FRP
D IRUPXODomRGRVSRVWXODGRVGH FHUWDV WHRULDV H FRP D XQLFDomR GH
DOJXPDVGHODV LVVRRFRUUHFRPDVWHRULDVItVLFDVPDLVUHFHQWHVFRPR
D HOHWURGLQkPLFD TXkQWLFD D FURPRGLQiPLFD TXkQWLFD H RXWUDV 
'HVFRQVLGHUDUHPRV HVVDV GLFXOGDGHV QHVWH WH[WR H DVVXPLUHPRV
que toda teoria fsica T que considerarmos admite os trs nveis de
SRVWXODGRV TXH PHQFLRQDPRV QR FDStWXOR DQWHULRU &RP HIHLWR
SRGHPRV D[LRPDWL]DU D PHFkQLFD TXkQWLFD QmR UHODWLYLVWD GH YiULRV
PRGRV PRGRV HVVHV TXH GLIHUHP TXDQWR j OLQJXDJHP H TXDQWR DRV
SRVWXODGRV HVSHFtFRV SRUpP DGPLWLQGR SRU KLSyWHVH  VHPSUH RV
PHVPRVSRVWXODGRVOyJLFRV GLJDPRVRVGDOyJLFDFOiVVLFDGHSULPHLUD
RUGHPFRPLJXDOGDGH HPDWHPiWLFRV GLJDPRVRVGDWHRULD=HUPHOR
)UDHQNHO 
9LPRVDLQGDTXHFRPWDOEDVHOyJLFDHPDWHPiWLFDTXDQGRDUPDPRV
([LVWHXPREMHWRDVVLPHDVVLPHPVtPERORVxF [ HDVVXPLPRVTXH
HVWDVHQWHQoDpYHUGDGHLUDLVVRVLJQLFDTXHQRGRPtQLRGRGLVFXUVR
H[LVWHXPVXEFRQMXQWRDH[WHQVmRGHFFRPSHORPHQRVXPLQGLYtGXR
1RFDVRGHQRVVRH[HPSORLVVRLPSOLFDTXHVHDFHLWDPRVTXHpYHUGDGH
TXH VH H[LVWH XPD SDUWtFXOD HOHPHQWDU DVVLP H DVVLP HVVD SDUWtFXOD
ter que ser um indivduoDOJRFRPXPDidentidadeEHPGHQLGD SRU
H[HPSOR VDWLVID]HQGR D WHRULD XVXDO GD LGHQWLGDGH  IDWR HVWH HP
IUDQFR FRQWUDVWH FRP R TXH GL]HP D PDLRU SDUWH GDV LQWHUSUHWDo}HV
GR IRUPDOLVPR GD ItVLFD TXkQWLFD H DQWHFLSDGR SRU YiULRV GHQWUH RV
JUDQGHV ItVLFRV GR SDVVDGR FRPR :HUQHU +HLVHQEHUJ  

&RPRFXULRVLGDGHROHLWRUTXHFRQKHFHDOJRGHiOJHEUDOLQHDUVDEHTXH____ ____
____5H ________ HVWH~OWLPRWHUPRVHQGRRWHUPRGHLQWHUIHUrQFLD

3RUH[HPSORRWHRUHPDGH.RFKHQH6SHFNHUHRVWHRUHPDVGH%HOO

66

'LVFXVLRQHV)LORVyFDV$xR1(QHUR-XQLRSS

FSICA E ONTOLOGIA

(UZLQ6FKU|GLQJHU  0D[%RUQ  H+HUPDQQ:H\O


 GHQWHRXWURV&RPRDH[WHQVmRGHFQDVHPkQWLFDFOiVVLFD
um conjunto REMHWRGH=) HVVHREMHWRTXHVXSRPRVH[LVWLUSRGHVHU
LGHQWLFDGRSRUXPQRPHRXVHMDWHPDVSURSULHGDGHVGRVindivduos
FOiVVLFRV1RHQWDQWRFRPRYLPRVDFLPDQDItVLFDTXkQWLFD QDPDLRULD
GDVLQWHUSUHWDo}HV TXDQGRRItVLFRGL]TXH([LVWHXPHOpWURQDVVLP
HDVVLPHYDPRVVLPEROL]DULVVRWDPEpPSRUxF [ QmRpEHPLVVRR
TXHSUHWHQGHRXPHOKRUQmRpLVVRTXHFRQVHJXHH[SUHVVDU RXVHMD
TXHH[LVWHXPDHQWLGDGHLQGLYLGXDOL]iYHOLGHQWLFiYHOXPindivduo 
&RPRVHSRGHDFHLWDUTXHDVHQWLGDGHVTXkQWLFDVPDLVHOHPHQWDUHVQmR
SRGHPVHULQGLYLGXDOL]DGDVGHIRUPDQmRDPEtJXDDHODVQmRSRGHPRV
associar nomes prprios do modo usual. O que xF [ VLJQLFDHQWmRp
que existe uma certa entidade de um certo tipo satisfazendo uma determinada
condio FRPR p XP HOpWURQ DVVLP H DVVLP RX p XP TXDUN DVVLP
H DVVLP PDV QXQFD TXH VHMD XPD HQWLGDGH TXH VH FRPSRUWH FRPR
WHQGRLQGLYLGXDOLGDGHQRVHQWLGRXVXDO $EHPGDYHUGDGHDItVLFD
TXkQWLFDSRGHVHUIRUPXODGDFRPDVHQWLGDGHVEiVLFDVVHFRPSRUWDQGR
FRPR LQGLYtGXRV PDV Ki UHVWULo}HV D VHUHP IHLWDV QHVVH FDVR QDV
VXDV SURSULHGDGHV H QRV HVWDGRV D TXH SRGHP WHU DFHVVR $ YLVmR
tradicional que seriam entidades destitudas de individualidade.
2 OHLWRU LQWHUHVVDGR HP DSURIXQGDU HVWH WHPD SRGH YHU )UHQFK 
.UDXVH   ,QVLVWLPRV TXH HVVH TXDQWLFDGRU H[LVWHQFLDO WDPEpP
QmRSRGHVHUSHQVDGRFRPRXPWLSRGHGHVFULomRLQGHQLGD um tal e
tal QDPDLRULDGRVFDVRVQmRVHWUDWD SRUH[HPSOR GHTXHqualquer
SDUWtFXOD GH XP FHUWR WLSR LPSRUWH PDV TXH Ki XPD FHUWD SDUWtFXOD
DVVLPHDVVLPTXHQmRSRGHVHUWUDWDGDFRPRXPLQGLYtGXR OHPEUH
GR H[HPSOR DFLPD GD LRQL]DomR GR iWRPR GH OtWLR  $SDUHQWHPHQWH
HVWDPRVGLDQWHGHXPDHQWLGDGHGHFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVGLVWLQWDVGRVREMHWRV
GHQRVVDFRQFHSomRXVXDO$ItVLFDSDUHFHQRVLPSRUQRYDVFDWHJRULDV
GH HVWUXWXUDomR GD UHDOLGDGH SDUD DV TXDLV TXHP VDEH XPD QRYD
PDWHPiWLFD HXPDQRYDOyJLFD HVWHMDVHLPSRQGR$SURSyVLWRXP
GRV JUDQGH ItVLFRPDWHPiWLFRV GD DWXDOLGDGH R UXVVR <XUL 0DQLQ
 GL]TXHGHYHPRVROKDURPXQGRQRYDPHQWHFRPRID]LDP
RV PDWHPiWLFRV GR SDVVDGR FRPR R Mi PHQFLRQDGR -RVHSK )RXULHU
SDUDEXVFDUQRYDVLQVSLUDo}HVSDUDWHRULDVPDWHPiWLFDVHPSDUWLFXODU
SDUDWUDWDUGHREMHWRVLQGLVFHUQtYHLV YHMD)UHQFK .UDXVH  SDUD
XPDGLVFXVVmRGHWDOKDGDGRDVVXQWR 
'HSURQWRHVVDVFRQVLGHUDo}HVQRVWUD]HPXPSUREOHPDGHQDWXUH]D
ORVyFD6HFRPR4XLQHHVWDPRVGLVSRVWRVDDFHLWDUTXHH[LVWHPRV
TXDUNVVLJQLFDTXHH[LVWHP HPDOJXPGRPtQLR REMHWRVx que tm

67

Dcio Krause

DSURSULHGDGHGHVHUHPTXDUNVRXTXHquarkizamTXDOpRGRPtQLR
do discurso ao qual xVHUHIHUH"
$ItVLFDGHKRMHQRTXHFRQFHUQHjVHPkQWLFDGHVXDVWHRULDVDSHVDU
GH DSDUHQWHPHQWH HVWDUPRV YLYHQGR R SDUDGLJPD GD FKDPDGD
DERUGDJHP VHPkQWLFD FRP rQIDVH QRV PRGHORV GDV WHRULDV
SDUHFH SURFHGHU FRPR QR DQWLJR SRVLWLYLVPR OyJLFR HVWDEHOHFHQGR
os vnculos entre certos termos tericos e a experincia de modo
PHUDPHQWH LQIRUPDO SRU DVVLP GL]HU GHVFULWR QD PHWDOLQJXDJHP
FRUUHVSRQGHQWH1RHQWDQWRSDUDDQHFHVViULDSUHFLVmRORVyFDSDUD
HVVHVYtQFXORVQmREDVWDTXHVHDVVXPDXPGRPtQLRLQIRUPDOFRPR
XPD H[SHULrQFLD GH ODERUDWyULR DR TXH QRV UHSRUWDPRV TXDQGR QRV
SHUJXQWDPSRUH[HPSORRTXHUHHWHXPDSDUWLFXODUIXQomRGHRQGD
TXHHVWDPRVFRQVLGHUDQGRHUHVSRQGHPRVtrata-se da funo de onda
de uma partcula movendo-se em uma certa direo, como no experimento
que estou realizando3DUHFHTXHDVWHRULDVItVLFDVHPHVSHFLDODItVLFD
TXkQWLFD FDUHFH GH XPD VHPkQWLFD ULJRURVD VHQVDWD H LVVR VRPHQWH
SRGHVHUUHDOL]DGRHPXPDPDWHPiWLFDTXHVHMDFRPSDWtYHOFRPVXDV
SUHVVXSRVLo}HVPDLVEiVLFDVQDVTXDLVRVREMHWRVTXHYmRVHUGHVFULWRV
SHODVQRVVDVWHRULDVSRVVDPH[LVWLUHVHUHPGHDFRUGRFRPRTXHQRV
FRQWDQRVVDVWHRULDV6HPXPDWDOVHPkQWLFDRVLJQLFDGR Bedeutung 
GRV WHUPRV XWLOL]DGRV SRGH VHU GHVFULWR VRPHQWH GH PRGR LQIRUPDO
H HP ERD PHGLGD ORVRFDPHQWH LQVDWLVIDWyULR D VDEHU QD PHGLGD
HP TXH VHMDPRV LQVWLJDGRV ORVRFDPHQWH D SURYLGHQFLDU VHPkQWLFD
ULJRURVDSDUDQRVVDVOLQJXDJHQV 
&RPRGLWRDFLPDSDUHFHFDUFODURTXHVHDItVLFDTXkQWLFDQRVVXJHUH
TXH HQWLGDGHV FRPR TXDUNV QmR SRGHP VHU LQGLYLGXDOL]DGDV QD
YHUGDGH GHYLGR D FHUWDV IRUoDV TXH RV PDQWpP XQLGRV RV TXDUNV 
VHJXQGRDWHRULDQmRSRGHPVHUVHSDUDGRVORJRLQGLYLGXDOL]DGRV
SRLVDHQHUJLDQHFHVViULDSDUDLVVRVHULDWmSJUDQGHTXHQRYRVSDUHV
GHTXDUNVVHULDPFULDGRVVHPTXHKRXYHVVHDVHSDUDomR ORJRRXVR
GHXPDWHRULDFRPR=)QDPHWDPDWHPiWLFDSDUHFHVHUDOJREDVWDQWH
DUWLFLDO6HRVREMHWRVTXkQWLFRVQmRGHYHP FRPRXPDGDVSRVVtYHLV
DOWHUQDWLYDV  VHU FRQVLGHUDGRV FRPR LQGLYtGXRV FRPR XVDU =) QD
PHWDPDWHPiWLFD"

 ,VVR RFRUUH HP PXLWDV VLWXDo}HV 1RV condensados de Bose-Einstein TXH VmR DJUXSDPHQWRV GH
FHQWHQDVGHiWRPRVRXGHSDUWtFXODVUHVIULDGRVTXDVHDR]HURDEVROXWRHVVDVHQWLGDGHVSDVVDPD
DJLUHPXQtVVRQRFRPRVHIRVVHPXPDFRLVDVy$SHVDUGLVVRVmRYiULDVHQWLGDGHVPDVWRGDV
HPXPPHVPRHVWDGRTXkQWLFRDEVROXWDPHQWHLQGLVFHUQtYHLV8PDERDH[SRVLomRLQWURGXWyULD
VREUH RV %(& %RVH(LQVWHLQ &RQGHQVDWHV  SRGH VHU YLVWD HP KWWSZZZFRORUDGRHGX
SK\VLFVEHF.

68

'LVFXVLRQHV)LORVyFDV$xR1(QHUR-XQLRSS

FSICA E ONTOLOGIA

0HVPRTXDQGRRFRUUHXPDVXSRVWDLQGLYLGXDomRFRPRTXDQGRXP
REMHWRTXkQWLFRpaprisionadoHPFHUWRVWLSRVGHDUPDGLOKDVSRUPHLR
GHFDPSRVSRWHQFLDLVTXDOTXHULGHQWLFDomRHP VHQWLGR WUDGLFLRQDO
FRPRSRUH[HPSORDWULEXLQGRXPQRPHSDUDDSDUWtFXODHPTXHVWmR
TXHIRLRTXHIH]R3UrPLR1REHO+DQV'HKPHOWFRPXPSyVLWURQ D
DQWLSDUWtFXOD GR HOpWURQ  DSULVLRQDGR SRU HOH GXUDQWH DOJXQV PHVHV
H FKDPDGR GH 3ULVFLOOD HVVD LQGLYLGXDomR p PHUDPHQWH DSDUHQWH
'H IDWR VH R FLHQWLVWD YDL SDUD FDVD GRUPLU GHSRLV GH IHLWD D VXD
H[SHULrQFLDTXDQGRUHWRUQDDRODERUDWyULRSHODPDQKmMDPDLVSRGHUi
DUPDU TXH R SyVLWURQ DSULVLRQDGR p aquele psitron que ele deixou
na noite anterior. Ele pode continuar a realizar seus experimentos
VHP TXDOTXHU FRQVHTrQFLD ItVLFD SHUFHSWtYHO PHVPR VH D SDUWtFXOD
WHQKDVLGRWURFDGDSRURXWUDVLPLODU&RPHIHLWRDOJXpPTXHHVWHMD
fazendo a faxina do laboratrio durante a noite pode ter desconectado a
HOHWULFLGDGHSRUHQJDQRGHVID]HQGRRH[SHULPHQWR1RHQWDQWRVHQGR
REVHUYDGRUHEDVWDQWHHVSHUWRRID[LQHLURUHIH]DH[SHULPHQWDomRGH
IRUPDTXHRSURIHVVRUQDGDVXVSHLWDVVHQDPDQKmVHJXLQWH2FLHQWLVWD
HQWUD SHOD PDQKm HP VHX ODERUDWyULR H MDPDLV SRGHUi SHUFHEHU TXH
KRXYH XPD WURFD $ SURSyVLWR 'DYLG +XPH IDODYD H[DWDPHQWH LVVR
GRVREMHWRVFRPXQVFRPRVTXDLVQRVGHSDUDPRV LVVRFDFRPRXPD
SURYRFDomRSDUDYRFrSHQVDUDUHVSHLWRYHMD.UDXVH %HFNHU  
SDUDXPSULPHLURHQVDLRDUHVSHLWR0DVVHRVREMHWRVIRUHPFOiVVLFRV
LVVR QmR RFRUUH VH WURFDUPRV XP JrPHR LGrQWLFR SRU RXWUR FRP R
WHPSRSURYDYHOPHQWHVXVSHLWDUHPRVGDPXGDQoDGHFRPSRUWDPHQWR
GH QRVVR DPLJR Ki XPD GLIHUHQoD HVVHQFLDO SRUWDQWR SDUD R FDVR
GDV SDUWtFXODV HOHPHQWDUHV  R TXH QXQFD SRGHUi VHU SHUFHELGR FRP
UHODomR DRV REMHWRV TXkQWLFRV (P UHVXPR SDUD TXH XPD DUPDWLYD
FRPRH[LVWHPTXDUNVIDoDVHQWLGRGHYHPRVVHUFDSD]HVGHGHQLU
HPQRVVDPHWDWHRULDDRGRPtQLRGDVSDUWtFXODVHOHPHQWDUHVGDIRUPD
FRPRVXSRPRVVHUHPRVTXDUNVRXVHDFHLWDUPRVDVROXomRTXLQHDQD
GRVREMHWRVItVLFRVVREUHRTXDOSHUFRUUHUmRDVQRVVDVYDULiYHLV DOJXQV
GRVTXDLVUHSUHVHQWDUmRTXDUNV 
DOIS NVEIS DE EMPENHO ONTOLGICO
'DOOD &KLDUD H 7RUDOGR GL )UDQFLD IDODP GR HPSHQKR RQWROyJLFR GR
fsico como se dando em dois nveis. O primeiro relativo a uma teoria
7 LQGHSHQGHQWHPHQWH GH 7 VHU YHUGDGHLUD RX IDOVD FRP UHVSHLWR j
H[SHULrQFLD$WHRULDQmRVHUHIHUHQHFHVVDULDPHQWHjTXLORTXHH[LVWH
QR PXQGR ItVLFR PDV jV FRLVDV TXH deveriam existir D P GH TXH DV
VHQWHQoDVGH7VHMDPYHUGDGHLUDV2VHJXQGRQtYHOpUHODWLYRDXPD

69

Dcio Krause

WHRULD TXH VHMD HPSLULFDPHQWH YHUGDGHLUD e ERP DVVLQDODU TXH D


GLVFXVVmRTXHOHYDPDFDERpEDVWDQWHVRVWLFDGDHRVWHUPRVDFLPD
DTXLWRPDGRVGHPRGRLQIRUPDOVmRWUDWDGRVFRPDGHTXDGDSUHFLVmR
2H[HPSORTXHGmRpRVHJXLQWHTXDQGRGL]HPRV8PtquionQmRSRGH
VHUGHVDFHOHUDGRDXPDYHORFLGDGHPHQRUGRTXHDGDOX]HVWDPRV
QRVFRPSURPHWHQGRFRPXPQtYHORQWROyJLFRGRSULPHLURWLSRSRVWR
TXHDWpRPRPHQWRQLQJXpPVDEHVHRVWiTXLRQVH[LVWHPGHIDWR 8P
WiTXLRQpXPDSDUWtFXODTXHYLDMDDXPDYHORFLGDGHVXSHULRUjGDOX]
HDWHRULDGDUHODWLYLGDGHDSUHJRDTXHQDGDSRGHVHUDFHOHUDGRDFLPD
GHVVDYHORFLGDGHGHFHUWRPRGRRVWiTXLRQVMiQDVFHUDPYLDMDQGRD
XPDWDOYHORFLGDGH 7HPRVHQWmRXPFRPSURPHWLPHQWRRQWROyJLFRGR
SULPHLURWLSRSRUTXHRItVLFRSRGHDVVHYHUDUTXHDVHQWHQoDDQWHULRUp
FRUUHWDDLQGDTXHRVWiTXLRQVSRVVDPQmRH[LVWLU QmRWrPFRPSURYDomR
H[SHULPHQWDOGHVXDH[LVWrQFLD 
3RURXWURODGRFRQWLQXDPHOHVVHGL]HPRVHOpWURQVWrPVSLQ R
VSLQpXPDSURSULHGDGHGDVSDUWtFXODVHOHPHQWDUHVHSDUDRVHOpWURQV
DVVXPHVHPSUHXPGRVYDORUHVRX HVWDPRVGLDQWHGHXPQtYHO
GHHPSHQKRRQWROyJLFRGRVHJXQGRWLSRSRLVDGPLWHVHQmRVRPHQWH
TXH RV HOpWURQV H[LVWDP FRP UHVSHLWR j WHRULD FRPSURPHWLPHQWR GH
SULPHLURQtYHO PDVWDPEpPTXHDWHRULDVHMDYHUGDGHLUDFRPUHVSHLWR
jH[SHULrQFLDFRPRpRFDVRFRPHOpWURQVSRLVWXGROHYDDFUHUTXHHOHV
H[LVWDPGHIDWR&DEHREVHUYDUQRHQWDQWRTXHDSHVDUGHLOXVWUDWLYD
DGLVWLQomRSURSRUFLRQDGDSHORVDXWRUHVLWDOLDQRVQRVSDUHFHXPWDQWR
DUELWUiULDXPDYH]TXHRVPHQFLRQDGRVQtYHLVGHHPSHQKRRQWROyJLFR
SRGHPFRQYHUWHUVHXPQRRXWURSRUTXHVW}HVH[SHULPHQWDLVGLJDPRV
TXDQGRVHGHVFREULUTXHRVWiTXLRQVGHIDWRH[LVWHPRXTXHHOpWURQV
DILQDO QmR SDVVDP GH ILFo}HV 1R HQWDQWR XPD GLVFXVVmR PDLV
SRUPHQRUL]DGD GHVWH WHPD IRJH DRV REMHWLYRV GHVWD GLVFLSOLQD H QRV
UHSRUWDGHQWUHRXWUDVFRLVDVDSHUFHEHUXPDYH]PDLVDLPSRUWkQFLD
de se discutir o conceito de verdade em fsica.
COMPROMETIMENTO ONTOLGICO
COM NO-INDIVDUOS
9DPRV DJRUD FXPSULU D QRVVD SURPHVVD GH PRVWUDU GH TXH IRUPD
PXGDQGR D WHRULD GH IXQGR PHWDPDWHPiWLFD  SRGHPRV QRV
FRPSURPHWHU RQWRORJLFDPHQWH FRP REMHWRV ItVLFRV TXH QmR WHQKDP
LGHQWLGDGHRXVHMDTXHQmRVHMDPindivduos$QWHVXPDEUHYHGLVFXVVmR
sobre o assunto.

70

'LVFXVLRQHV)LORVyFDV$xR1(QHUR-XQLRSS

FSICA E ONTOLOGIA

-i YLPRV DFLPD TXH Ki PXLWDV PDQHLUDV GH VH LQWHUSUHWDU RV
TXDQWLFDGRUHVHVDOLHQWDPRVGXDVDREMHWXDOHDVXEVWLWXFLRQDO$PEDV
apresentam problemas se supusermos que o domnio das variveis
IRUPDGR SRU REMHWRV LQGLVFHUQtYHLV &RP HIHLWR VH DGRWDPRV D YLVmR
REMHWXDOHDFHLWDQGRDYHUDFLGDGHGHxA [ GHYHKDYHUQRGRPtQLRXP
objetoTXHYHULTXHDIyUPXODADLQGDTXHDVHPkQWLFDXVXDOQmRH[LMD
TXHLGHQWLTXHPRVHVVHREMHWRHOHGHYHVHUFDUDFWHUL]DGRSHORPHQRV
SRU XPD GHVFULomR GHQLGD VHQmR SRU XP QRPH SUySULR OHPEUH R
FDVRGRQ~PHURSULPRFRPPDLVGHGH]PLOK}HVGHGtJLWRV 6HYDOH
xA(x HQWmRWRGRobjetoGRGRPtQLRYHULFDA6HDLQWHUSUHWDomRp
VXEVWLWXFLRQDOQRFDVRGHxA(x VHUYHUGDGHLUDGHYHKDYHUXPnome de
XPREMHWRTXHSRVVDVHUFRORFDGRQROXJDUGHx em AHVHYDOHxA(x 
todo nome YHULFD A $ YLVmR VXEVWLWXFLRQDO HQFRQWUD GLFXOGDGHV
FRP D WHRULD TXkQWLFD QD KLSyWHVH GH TXH RV REMHWRV TXkQWLFRV QmR
SRGHP VHU QRPHDGRV QD PHGLGD HP TXH R GRPtQLR TXkQWLFR p D
WHUUDGRDQRQLPDWR $LQWHUSUHWDomRREMHWXDOWDPEpPQmRpLPXQHD
GLFXOGDGHVMiTXHTXDQGRIRUPRVGHVFUHYHURTXHVHMDPDVHQWLGDGHV
TXHSRGHPVHUYDORUHVGDVYDULiYHLV GHXPDDGHTXDGDOLQJXDJHPSDUD
DWHRULDTXkQWLFDTXHOHYHHPFRQWDDLQGLVFHUQLELOLGDGH WHUHPRVTXH
HVFROKHUXPDPHWDPDWHPiWLFDFRPSDWtYHOFRPHVWDKLSyWHVHHQHP=)
QHPDVGHPDLVWHRULDVFRQKHFLGDVGHFRQMXQWRVQHPDVWHRULDVGHWLSRVH
QHPDWHRULDGHFDWHJRULDVGiFRQWDGDLGpLDGHTXHRVREMHWRVTXkQWLFRV
devem ser tomado ab ovoFRPRLQGLVFHUQtYHLVUHFRUGHHOHVso feitos
LQGLVFHUQtYHLVSHODLQWURGXomRGHSULQFtSLRVHVLPHWULDLPSRVWRVVREUH
DVIXQo}HVTXHGHVFUHYHPRVHVWDGRVItVLFRVHVREUHRVREVHUYiYHLV
Isso resultado dos postulados de ZF (coisas similares acontecem com
DVGHPDLVWHRULDVGHFRQMXQWRVPDLVFRQKHFLGDV WRGRREMHWR FRQMXQWR
RXiWRPRVHDWHRULDRVDGPLWLU pXPLQGLYtGXRSRLVGDGRXPREMHWR
qualquer aSRGHPRVIRUPDURFRQMXQWRXQLWiULR^a} a partir do axioma
GR SDU YHU R FDStWXOR SUHFHGHQWH  H GHQLU D SURSULHGDGH P(x  D
x^a` TXH p YHULFDGD XQLFDPHQWH SRU a $VVLP WRGR REMHWR SRVVXL
XPD SURSULHGDGH GLVWLQWLYD SRVVXtGD XQLFDPHQWH SRU HOH PHVPR
H TXH R GLIHUHQFLD GH TXDOTXHU RXWUR REMHWR 3DUWtFXODV HOHPHQWDUHV
LQGLVFHUQtYHLV QR HQWDQWR TXH RV ItVLFRV FKDPDP GH LGrQWLFDV 
SRGHPHPFHUWDVVLWXDo}HVWHUHPtodasDVSURSULHGDGHVHPFRPXP1R
H[HPSORMiFLWDGRGRVFRQGHQVDGRVGH%RVH(LQVWHLQ %(& SRGHPRV
WHUFHQWHQDVGHiWRPRVRXGHSDUWtFXODVHPXPPHVPRHVWDGRTXkQWLFR
(VVDVHQWLGDGHVVmRabsolutamente indiscernveis.

71

Dcio Krause

8P SUREOHPD SRU FHUWR p R VLJQLFDGR GR TXDQWLFDGRU XQLYHUVDO


WRGDVDVSURSULHGDGHV4XDOTXHUKLSyWHVHTXHGLJDTXHGHYDPVHU
FRQVLGHUDGDV DSHQDV DOJXPDV GHODV RX TXH DGPLWD TXH Ki RXWUDV
FDUDFWHUtVWLFDVGHVVDVHQWLGDGHVQmRGHVFULWDVSHORIRUPDOLVPRRXVHMDVH
KiSURSULHGDGHVHVFRQGLGDVHPSDUWLFXODUDVTXHSRVVDPHVWDEHOHFHU
DOJXPDGLIHUHQoDFRQGX]DGLFXOGDGHVMiTXHDVFKDPDGDVWHRULDV
GH YDULiYHLV RFXOWDV QmR UHFHEHP DFHLWDomR XQkQLPH SRU SDUWH GRV
OyVRIRVGDItVLFDGHKRMHFRPRMiFRPHQWDPRVDQWHULRUPHQWH&RPR
HQWmRVHOLGDFRPHVVDVLWXDomR"$ItVLFDPHLRTXHVHPVHLPSRUWDUFRP
DFRHUrQFLDOyJLFDGHVHXDVVXQWRID]H[DWDPHQWHDVXSRVLomRGHTXH
DSHQDV DOJXPDV SURSULHGDGHV QD OLQJXDJHP GRV ItVLFRV YDULiYHLV
GLQkPLFDV  VmR LPSRUWDQWHV $ ULJRU D FODVVLFDomR GDV SDUWtFXODV
HOHPHQWDUHV HP FDWHJRULDV p IHLWD SRU PHLR GD WHRULD PDWHPiWLFD GH
JUXSRV PDLV SUHFLVDPHQWH SHOR PRGR FRPR VH HQFRQWUDP FHUWRV
LQYDULDQWHV QRYDPHQWHSULQFtSLRVGHVLPHWULD SHODDomRGRVJUXSRV
relevantes(PRXWUDVSDODYUDVXPREMHWRItVLFRpFDUDFWHUL]DGRDWUDYpV
das propriedades invariantes que as simetrias da teoria (dadas por certos
JUXSRV SHUPLWHPLGHQWLFDU'HVWHPRGRRVREMHWRVItVLFRVVmRDTXHODV
entidades que possuem certas propriedades invariantes que a teoria
SUHVFUHYH2IDWRpTXHHVVDVROXomRSURSRVWDHPSHORJUDQGHItVLFR
HODXUHDGRFRPR1REHOHP(XJHQH:LJQHU  FRQVHJXH
FODVVLFDUDVSDUWtFXODVVRPHQWHHPespcies HOpWURQVSUyWRQVHWF PDV
QXQFDLQGLYLGXDOPHQWH &DVWHOODQL 
&RPHIHLWRRVItVLFRVDGPLWHPDLQGLVFHUQLELOLGDGHFRPRIDWRHVVHQFLDO
QDGHVFULomRItVLFDGRPXQGRPDVFRPRWUDEDOKDPSUHVVXSRQGRDOyJLFD
clssica e a matemtica tradicionais como alicerces (como constituindo
RV SRVWXODGRV OyJLFRV H PDWHPiWLFRV GH VXDV WHRULDV  D DOWHUQDWLYD p
WUDEDOKDU UHVWULWRV D DOJXPD IRUPD GH HVWUXWXUD QD TXDO XQLFDPHQWH
DVSURSULHGDGHVGHVHMDGDVVmRFRQVLGHUDGDV(QWmRLQGLVFHUQLELOLGDGH
WRUQDVH DOJR TXH H[LVWH XQLFDPHQWH HP UHODomR jV SURSULHGDGHV H
UHODo}HVGHVVDHVWUXWXUDPDLVWHFQLFDPHQWHLVVRVLJQLFDLQYDULDQoD
SHORVDXWRPRUVPRVGDHVWUXWXUD0DVQDWHRULDGHIXQGR HJHP=) 
RVREMHWRVFRQVLGHUDGRVVmRLQGLYtGXRVFRPRMiVDEHPRV


,QIRUPDOPHQWHXPJUXSRpXPFRQMXQWRQmRYD]LRGRWDGRGHXPDRSHUDomRELQiULD TXHSHU
PLWH FRPSRU GRLV REMHWRV GHVVH FRQMXQWR UHVXOWDQGR DLQGD HP XP REMHWR GR FRQMXQWR  TXH p
DVVRFLDWLYDDGPLWHXPHOHPHQWRQHXWURHFDGDHOHPHQWRGRFRQMXQWRWHPXPLQYHUVRSDUDHVVD
RSHUDomRDLQGDSHUWHQFHQWHDRFRQMXQWR3RUH[HPSORRFRQMXQWRGRVQ~PHURVLQWHLURVGRWDGR
GD RSHUDomR GH DGLomR GH LQWHLURV p XP JUXSR R HOHPHQWR QHXWUR p R ]HUR H R LQYHUVR GH XP
elemento o seu oposto.

72

'LVFXVLRQHV)LORVyFDV$xR1(QHUR-XQLRSS

FSICA E ONTOLOGIA

3DUD TXH VH SRVVD DGPLWLU TXH DV YDULiYHLV GH QRVVD WHRULD SRVVDP
DGPLWLUYDORUHVTXHVHMDPREMHWRVlegitimamenteLQGLVFHUQtYHLV HQmRfeitos
LQGLVFHUQtYHLVSHODFRQVLGHUDomRGHXPQ~PHURUHVWULWRGHSURSULHGDGHV
FRPRSURFHGH4XLQH XPDVROXomRpPXGDUDWHRULDGHIXQGRRXVHMD
DPHWDWHRULDSDUDXPDPDWHPiWLFDTXHSHUPLWDDH[LVWrQFLDGHFROHo}HV
GHREMHWRVLQGLVFHUQtYHLVWRPDGRVFRPRWDLVdesde o princpio. Essa teoria
H[LVWH H FKDPDVH GH teoria de quase-conjuntos 1mR HQWUDUHPRV QRV
GHWDOKHV GHVVD WHRULD DTXL SDUD PDLV GHWDOKHV YHU )UHQFK  .UDXVH
  H SDUD XPD H[SRVLomR PDLV GHWDOKDGD GR FRPSURPHWLPHQWR
RQWROyJLFRFRPQmRLQGLYtGXRVYHMD.UDXVH D PDVGHVHMDPRV
DSHQDVUHJLVWUDUTXHFRPRVHXXVRSRGHPRVDGPLWLUTXHHPVHQWHQoDV
TXDQWLFDGDV DV YDULiYHLV OLJDGDV SRGHP WHU REMHWRV LQGLVFHUQtYHLV
FRPRYDORUHV8PDYH]TXHQDWHRULDGHTXDVHFRQMXQWRVRFRQFHLWR
GHLGHQWLGDGHQmRVHDSOLFDDWRGRVRVREMHWRVKiVHQWLGRSUHFLVRQD
DUPDomRGHTXHh entidades sem identidade3DUDPDLVGHWDOKHVYHMD
.UDXVH DE 

VOLTANDO DISCUSSO ONTOLGICA


$ ~OWLPD REVHUYDomR GR SDUiJUDIR DQWHULRU QRV UHPHWH QRYDPHQWH j
OyJLFD H j PDWHPiWLFD UHFRUGH TXH SDUD QyV DTXL OyJLFD VLJQLFD
JUDQGHOyJLFD 0HGLDQWHDGHTXDGDPXGDQoDQDOyJLFDVXEMDFHQWHR
FRPSURPHWLPHQWRRQWROyJLFRGHXPDWHRULDVHDOWHUD$OyJLFDFOiVVLFD
HVWiHQRUPHPHQWHFRPSURPHWLGDFRPFHUWRVSUHVVXSRVWRVRQWROyJLFRV
MiHYLGHQFLDGRVSHORDWRPLVPROyJLFRGH5XVVHOOH:LWWJHQVWHLQHQRVVD
GLJUHVVmR DQWHULRU DSRQWD SDUD XP RXWUR FRPSURPLVVR RQWROyJLFR
LPSRUWDQWH DTXHOH SDUD FRP indivduos $VVLP D OyJLFD FOiVVLFD QmR
p QHXWUD RQWRORJLFDPHQWH FRPR TXHUHP DOJXQV FRPR 0DULR %XQJH
 PDVIRUWHPHQWHFRPSURPLVVDGD3RUWDQWRQDPHGLGDHPTXH
as teorias fsicas que nela se assentam pretendem tratar de entidades
TXHGHVWRDPGRVREMHWRVItVLFRVXVXDLVDSUySULDYDOLGDGHGHVVDOyJLFD
posta em xeque.

73

Dcio Krause

REFERNCIAS
%81*(0  Treatise on basic philosophy. v.3 The Furniture of the
Word'RUGUHFKW5HLGHO
&$67$*1,120 6$1*8,1(7,--  7LHPSR\8QLYHUVR8QD
YLVLyQORVyFD\FLHQWtFD%XHQRV$LUHV&DWiORJRV
&$67(//$1, (   ,QWURGXFWLRQ H *DOLOHDQ SDUWLFOHV DQ
H[DPSOHRIFRQVWLWXWLRQRIREMHFWV,Q(&DVWHOODQL HG Interpreting
%RGLHV &ODVVLFDO DQG 4XDQWXP 2EMHFWV LQ 0RGHUQ 3K\VLFV 3ULQFHWRQ
3ULQFHWRQ8QLYHUVLW\3UHVVSS
'D&267$1&$ )5(1&+6  6FLHQFHDQG3DUWLDO7UXWK
$8QLWDU\$SSURDFKWR0RGHOVDQG6FLHQWLF5HDVRQLQJ2[IRUG2[IRUG
8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
'$//$ &+,$5$ 0 /  725$/'2 'L )5$1&,$ *  
,QGLYLGXDOVNLQGVDQGQDPHVLQSK\VLFV,Q*&RUVL0/'DOOD
&KLDUD *&*KLUDUGL HGV %ULGJLQJWKH*DS3KLORVRSK\0DWKHPDWLFV
and Physics 'RUGUHFKW .OXZHU $F 3UHVV %RVWRQ 6WXGLHV LQ WKH
3KLORVRSK\RI6FLHQFH SS
)5(1&+ 6  .5$86( '   ,GHQWLW\ LQ 3K\VLFV $ +LVWRULFDO
Philosophical, and Formal Analysis2[IRUG2[IRUG8Q3UHVV
)$/.(1%85* %   3DUWLFOH 0HWDSK\VLFV $ &ULWLFDO $FFRXQW RI
Subatomic Reality6SULQJHU
.5$86('  1RWDVREUHRFRPSURPHWLPHQWRRQWROyJLFRFRP
QmRLQGLYtGXRV A aparecer nos Anais do Congresso da Associao de
+LVWyULDH)LORVRDGD&LrQFLDGR&RQH6XO$)+,&
BBBBBBBB D /D0HWDItVLFDGHOD1R,QGLYLGXDOLGDG(QVD\RVREUHOD
Indiscernibilidad de los Quanta3UpSXEOLFDomR
BBBBBBBB E 4XDQWXPGHQLWHGHVFULSWLRQV3UpSXEOLFDomR
.5$86(' %(&.(5-  +XPH6FKU|GLQJHUHDLQGLYLGXDomR
GHREMHWRVItVLFRVRevista Eletrnica Informao e Cognio 5 (2)SS
SXEOLFDGDHP 
25(167(,1 $   W.V.Quine 3ULQFHWRQ 3ULQFHWRQ 8QLYHUVLW\
3UHVV
48,1(:9  2QWRORJLFDOUHODWLYLW\,QJ. of Philosophy 65 (7).
SS
BBBBBBBBBB  Ontological Relativity and Other Essays1HZ<RUN
&ROXPELD8Q3UHVV
BBBBBBBBBB   2QWRORJ\ DQG LGHRORJ\ UHYLVLWHG ,Q Journal of
Philosophy80 (9)SS
BBBBBBBBBB   7KH 3KLORVRSK\ RI : 9 4XLQH QGH[SDQGHG
HGLWLRQ ,Q / ( +DKDQ  3$ 6FKLOSS HG  The Library of Living
Philosohers, XVIII,2SHQ&RXUW6HFRQG([SDQGHG(GLWLRQ
725$/'2 'L )5$1&,$ *   Le Cose e i Loro Nomi %DUL
Laterza.
:(,1%(5*6  Dreams of a Final Theory/RQGRQ9LQWDJH

74

'LVFXVLRQHV)LORVyFDV$xR1(QHUR-XQLRSS