Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Internet as a Western
A man rides into our town. There is nothing special about him
except that he is powerful through mastery of nature (in this case with
oratory - rhetorical gunslinging). He sees that the people of the town
are suffering, especially the weak. There is no authority to protect them
(or it is powerless). So he challenges the evildoers but they are many
and he is alone, so he builds a wall around the town to shelter the
people.
Some town folk, greedy or misguided, try to stop him. He
challenges them to a showdown and wins. He sets an example of
action and moral principle. The wall is built, the town is safe through
his action and moral principle, the man rides off. If at a later time, the
wall fails and the town is defenceless, well then, the town people were
weak or greedy. They didn’t follow the cowboy’s way. The cowboy is
Sheriff Conroy.
That’s not the movie you’re watching? Of course, if Marshall
Conroy didn’t earn his badge and doesn’t surrender it at the end, then
he is corrupt and must be serving the purposes of the greedy, the
ranchers or industrialists who want to monopolise resources and
prevent equal access to everything.
Then the town folk need a real hero or band of cowboys, to ride
out of the wilderness, to demonstrate their mastery of the nature of
technology, fight the evil doers and challenge or shame the marshall.
But how can we tell who is who if the cast are not wearing white
or black hats? Well, sometimes the cavalry will come to the rescue of
the good guys, usually at the expense of the indians. Google and the
US government have both appeared on the horizon of the Australian
internet filter debate. It appears that the cavalry are supporting the
‘intellectual elite’ cowboys and keeping the Electronic Frontiers open.
Kevin Kelly recalled the original design goals for the WELL team.. “
While the rhetoric leads many to believe the internet ethos springs
from either counterculture or the New Left politics, I believe that the it
Lessig is famous for his writings, including Code and Other Laws
of Cyberspace, and is a Professor of Law, who at one stage was
appointed a special master of the US Court in order to prosecute
Microsoft’s monopoly. As Weber’s charismatic hero is a cowboy’s
honour, it’s also apt that, in a global tradition, members of the judiciary
may be addressed as ‘your honour’.
Future Directions