You are on page 1of 31

2#$,"'3//&0#

;
f)IV G=;B=:=75 5:=FA5F EI9 J=J=ACG 9B IB5 9F5 G97I@5F 5G= HC8CG 7C=B7=8=FY5ACG
9B EI9 9B 7=9FHC G9BH=8C 9G 5GY EI=9FC 897=F 9@ hHC8CGi EI9 J=J=ACG 9B '77=89BH9
C EI=NQ 9B 9@ BCFH9 89 '77=89BH9 C 8=7<C 89 CHFC AC8C 9B 9@ AIB8C 89@ H@QBH=7C
&CFH9 l5IBEI9 @5 G97I@5F=858 G9 9LH=9B89 H5A6=VB D5F7=5@A9BH9 M 89 8=:9F9BH9G
:CFA5G AQG 5@@Q 89 9GH9 AIB8Cl 1 @5 75@=:=757=]B 89 G97I@5F=858 D5F979 8=:Y7=@ 89
F9:IH5F 7I5B8C 7CAD5F5ACG 9GH5G GC7=98589G 7CB 7I5@EI=9F CHF5 9B @5 <=GHCF=5
<IA5B5 9G 897=F 7CB 75G= HC85G @5G CHF5G GC7=98589G 7CBH9ADCFQB95G DCF 9>9A
D@C @CG D5YG9G =G@QA=7CG @5 !B8=5 p:F=75 DCF IB @58C M 7CB 9@ F9GHC 89 @5 <=GHCF=5
<IA5B5 @589@H@QBH=7CC89CHFCG@I;5F9GDCF9@CHFC
(9FC BC F9GI@H5 89@ HC8C 7@5FC 9B EIV 7CBG=GH9 9G5 G97I@5F=858 5M 8CG
;F5B89G 75B8=85HCG lC H5@ J9N G9FY5 A9>CF 897=F 8CG :5A=@=5G 89 75B8=85HCGl D5F5
75F57H9F=N5F@5 $5 DF=A9F5 G9 7CB79BHF5 9B @5G =BGH=HI7=CB9G M DFQ7H=75G 7CAIB9G
l9@ 75GC AQG C6J=C D9FC BC 9@ `B=7C 9G 9@ GH58Cl $5 8=:9F9B7=5 9BHCB79G 7CBG=
GH=FY5 9B EI9 A=9BHF5G EI9 @5 CF;5B=N57=]B DC@YH=75 89 @5G GC7=98589G


 

DF9AC89FB5G 89 5@;IB5 :CFA5 9GH565 7CB97H585 5 7=9FH5 :9 9B =CG C 5 IB5


58<9G=]B 5 =CG C 5 5@;IB5 BC7=]B 89 F95@=858 `@H=A5 9B @5 EI9 G9 65G565B M 89
@5G EI9 C6H9BY5B GI ;5F5BHY5 9@ GH58C C77=89BH5@ AC89FBC 9GHQ 89GDFCJ=GHC 89
9GH5 7CB9L=]B $5G !;@9G=5G 57HI5@A9BH9 9GHQB G9D5F585G 89 @5G 9GHFI7HIF5G DC@YH
=75G 7CB IB D5F 89 9L79D7=CB9G 9B F5B F9H5\5 M @CG D5YG9G 9G75B8=B5JCG 8CB89
GCB H5B AC89F585G M DC7C 89A5B85BH9G EI9 9B F95@=858 BC 7CBGH=HIM9B 9L79D
7=CB9G $5 F9@=;=]B C GI 5IG9B7=5 9G 9B ;F5B A98=85 IB 5GIBHC DF=J58C +9 7CB
G=89F5 EI9 @5 GC7=9858 DC@YH=75 9GHQ 7CB:CFA585 DCF 7F9M9BH9G 89 HC8CG @CG
7C@CF9GMBC7F9M9BH9GDCF=;I5@
=7<C 89 CHF5 A5B9F5 9B BI9GHF5G GC7=98589G hG97I@5F9Gi 9G DCG=6@9 D5FH=
7=D5F D@9B5A9BH9 9B DC@YH=75 G=B 9B7CBHF5FG9 BIB75 7CB =CG 9G 897=F G=B @@9;5F 5@
DIBHC 9B 9@ 7I5@ 9B HC85 9GH5 9ADF9G5 G9 <5;5 D5H9BH9 89 A5B9F5 :CFNCG5 9
=B9EIYJC75 @5 =ADCFH5B7=5 7FI7=5@ 89@ =CG 89 6F5<5A $CG DC7CG ACA9BHCG EI9
EI985B 89 F=HI5@9G C D@9;5F=5G 7CBGH=HIM9B IB 9B7I9BHFC 89 9G9 H=DC D9FC 9@@CG
<56FY5BG=8C=B9@I8=6@9G9B@CGG=;@CGD5G58CG897F=GH=5B=GAC
(F9G9BH5F @5 7I9GH=]B 89 9GH5 :CFA5 BCG D9FA=H9 5DF97=5F EI9 9B 9GH9 75A6=C
D5FH=7=D5 5@;C AQG EI9 9@ GH58C += F9HFC7989ACG 5@;IBCG G=;@CG 9B BI9GHF5 7=J=@
=N57=]B J9ACG EI9 =CG 9B 9@ G9BH=8C 5BH9G F9:9F=8C 9GH565 DF9G9BH9 9B IB5 ;F5B
75BH=858 89 DFQ7H=75G GC7=5@9G lBC G]@C 9B @5 DC@YH=75l M 9B HC8CG @CG B=J9@9G 89 @5
GC7=9858 DCF 9>9AD@C 7I5B8C 9@ AC8C 89 :IB7=CB5A=9BHC 89@ ;C6=9FBC @C75@ 9F5
@5 D5FFCEI=5 M @5 D5FFCEI=5 HC85JY5 9F5 :IB85A9BH5@A9BH9 IB5 7CAIB=858 89
CF57=]B C 7I5B8C @5G 7C:F58Y5G @@9J565B IB5 J=85 F=HI5@ EI9 BC 9F5 A9F5A9BH9
:CFA5@ C 7I5B8C @CG `B=7CG AC8CG 9B @CG EI9 @5 GC7=9858 9B HC8CG GIG 7CADCB
9BH9G DC8Y5 9L<=6=FG9 5BH9 GY A=GA5 9F5B @5G :=9GH5G F9@=;=CG5G 7CAC DCF 9>9AD@C
@5 DFC79G=]B 89 CFDIG <F=GH= B 9G5G GC7=98589G 9F5 =ADCG=6@9 D5FH=7=D5F 9B
5@;IB5 57H=J=858 D`6@=75 G=B h9B7CBHF5FG9 7CB =CGi 9B 9@ G9BH=8C 5BH9G =B8=758C
(9FC<CM@5G=HI57=]B9G7CAD@9H5A9BH98=:9F9BH9
1 G= F9HFC7989ACG 5`B AQG 9B @5 <=GHCF=5 <IA5B5 @@9;5ACG 5 @5G GC7=98589G
5F75=75G 9B @5G EI9 HC8C 9@ 7CB>IBHC 89 8=GH=B7=CB9G EI9 <579ACG 9BHF9 @CG 5GD97
HCG F9@=;=CGCG DC@YH=7CG 97CB]A=7CG GC7=5@9G 9H7VH9F5 89 BI9GHF5 GC7=9858 89>5
89 H9B9F G9BH=8C B 9GH5G DF=A9F5G GC7=98589G @5 F9@=;=]B 9GH565 h9B HC85G
D5FH9Gi 9BHF9@5N585 7CB HC8C @C 89AQG M 9B AC8C 5@;IBC 7CBGH=HIY5 IB5
h9G:9F5iG9D5F58589@F9GHC
BHCB79G @5 G97I@5F=858 DI989 G9F 9BH9B8=85 9B HVFA=BCG 89 @CG 9GD57=CG
D`6@=7CG +9 5:=FA5 EI9 5 VGHCG G9 @CG <5 J57=58C 89 =CG C 89 HC85 F9:9F9B7=5 5

 

IB5 F95@=858 `@H=A5 ' 89G89 CHF5 D9FGD97H=J5 DI9GHC EI9 BCG ACJ9ACG 89BHFC
89 J5F=5G 9G:9F5G 89 57H=J=858 l97CB]A=75 DC@YH=75 7I@HIF5@ 98I75H=J5 DFC:9
G=CB5@ F97F95H=J5l @5G BCFA5G M @CG DF=B7=D=CG EI9 G9;I=ACG @5G 89@=69F57=CB9G
9B @5G EI9 D5FH=7=D5ACG DCF @C ;9B9F5@ BC BCG F9A=H9B 5 =CG B= 5 B=B;IB5 7F99B
7=5 F9@=;=CG5 @5G 7CBG=89F57=CB9G 89 57I9F8C 7CB @5G 7I5@9G 57HI5ACG GCB =B<9F
9BH9G 5 @5 hF57=CB5@=858i 89 7585 9G:9F5 l@5 AQL=A5 ;5B5B7=5 89BHFC 89 @5 97C
BCAY5 9@ A5MCF 69B9:=7=C D5F5 9@ A5MCF B`A9FC 9B 9@ QA6=HC DC@YH=7C M 89AQGl
GHC 7CBHF5GH5 7CB @CG D9F=C8CG 5BH9F=CF9G 9B @CG EI9 @5 :9 7F=GH=5B5 9GH56@97Y5 5
A9BI8C DCF 6C75 89@ 7@9FC DF9G7F=D7=CB9G D9F9BHCF=5G EI9 BC DC8Y5B G9F =;BCF5
85G :Q7=@A9BH9 9B B=B;IBC 89 9GCG QA6=HCG 7CAC @5 DFC<=6=7=]B 89 @5 IGIF5 C @5
C6@=;5HCF=9858895D@=75F@5CFHC8CL=5
(9FC M5 G95 EI9 7CBG=89F9ACG EI9 G9 HF5H5 89 DF9G7F=D7=CB9G C 89 IB5 DF9G9B
7=5 F=HI5@ C 79F9ACB=5@ 9GH9 J57=5A=9BHC 89 @5 F9@=;=]B 89 @5G 9G:9F5G GC7=5@9G
5IH]BCA5G 9G 89G89 @I9;C 7CAD5H=6@9 7CB 9@ <97<C 89 EI9 IB5 ;F5B A5MCFY5 89
D9FGCB5G 5`B 7F99B 9B =CG M DF57H=75B GI F9@=;=]B 7CB :9FJCF .=9B9 5 BI9GHF5
A9BH9 9@ 75GC 89 @5 (C@CB=5 7CAIB=GH5 5IBEI9 H5@ J9N VGH9 BC G95 9@ A9>CF 9>9A
D@C DCFEI9 5@@Y @5 G97I@5F=858 D`6@=75 :I9 =ADI9GH5 DCF IB FV;=A9B 8=7H5HCF=5@ 9
=ADCDI@5F @ 75GC 89 GH58CG -B=8CG 9B 75A6=C 9G 65GH5BH9 BCH56@9 9B 9GH9
G9BH=8C 589AQG 89 <569F G=8C IB5 89 @5G DF=A9F5G GC7=98589G 9B G9D5F5F @5
!;@9G=5 89@ GH58C 9G @5 GC7=9858 C77=89BH5@ 9B @5 EI9 G9 F9;=GHF5B @5G 9GH58YGH=75G
AQG5@H5G897F99B7=5MDFQ7H=75GF9@=;=CG5G
1 G=B 9A65F;C 5 9GHC G9 F9:=9F9 @5 ;9BH9 7I5B8C 5:=FA5 EI9 @5 BI9GHF5 9G IB5
VDC75 G97I@5F M @5 7CAD5F5 C 6=9B 7CB BCGH5@;=5 C 6=9B 7CB 5@=J=C 7CB VDC75G
5BH9F=CF9G A5F7585G DCF @5 :9 C @5 89JC7=]B B 9GH9 G9;IB8C G9BH=8C @5 G97I@5F
=858 7CBG=GH9 9B 9@ 897@=J9 89 @5 7F99B7=5 M @5G DFQ7H=75G F9@=;=CG5G 9B 9@ 5@9>5A=
9BHC 89 =CG DCF D5FH9 89 @5 ;9BH9 M 9B @5 BC 7CB7IFF9B7=5 5 @5 =;@9G=5 $5 A5MCFY5
89 @CG D5YG9G 89 IFCD5 C77=89BH5@ =B7@IGC 5EIV@@CG EI9 7CBG9FJ5B J9GH=;=CG 89
IB5 F9:9F9B7=5 D`6@=75 5 =CG 9B 9@ 9GD57=C D`6@=7C G9 <5B JI9@HC G97I@5F9G 9B 9GH9
G9BH=8C
<CF5 6=9B 7F9C EI9 J5@9 @5 D9B5 9L5A=B5F @5 G97I@5F=858 89 9GH5 VDC75 9B IB
H9F79F G9BH=8C 9GHF97<5A9BH9 F9@57=CB58C 7CB 9@ G9;IB8C M EI9 BC 75F979 89 7CB
9L=]B 7CB 9@ DF=A9FC OGH9 G9 F9:=9F9 5@ 9GH58C 89 @5 :9 $5 =BGH5@57=]B 89 @5 G97I@5F
=858 9B 9GH9 G9BH=8C 7CBG=GH9 9BHF9 CHF5G 7CG5G 9B 9@ D5GC 89 IB5 GC7=9858 9B @5
EI9 @5 :9 9B =CG 9F5 =B7I9GH=CB56@9 M 9B J9F858 9GH565 @9>CG 89 G9F DFC6@9AQH=75
5 IB5 GC7=9858 9B @5 EI9 G9 7CBG=89F5 EI9 9G5 :9 9G IB5 CD7=]B 9BHF9 CHF5G M 7CB

 

:F97I9B7=5 BC @5 AQG :Q7=@ 89 58CDH5F B 9GH9 G9BH=8C 5 8=:9F9B7=5 89@ G9;IB8C


G9BH=8C 5@ A9BCG AI7<CG 9BHCFBCG GC7=5@9G 89 GH58CG -B=8CG 9GHQB G97I@5F=N5
8CG M 8=FY5 EI9 GH58CG -B=8CG 9B GI HCH5@=858 @C 9GHQB CAC 7CBHF5D5FH=85
9GHQB @5 A5MCFY5 89 @5G GC7=98589G AIGI@A5B5G C @CG 9BHCFBCG GC7=5@9G 9B @CG EI9
J=J9 @5 ;F5B A5MCFY5 89 @CG <=B8`9G &585 75A6=5FY5 G= G9 89ACGHF5FG9 EI9 @5G
9GH58YGH=75G 89 7CB7IFF9B7=5 5 @5 =;@9G=5 C 5 @5 G=B5;C;5 9B GH58CG -B=8CG C 9B
5@;IB5G 89 GIG F9;=CB9G G9 579F75B 5 @5G 89 @5 7CB7IFF9B7=5 5 @5 A9NEI=H5 @CG 8Y5G
J=9FB9G C @5 7CB7IFF9B7=5 AQG @5 CF57=]B 8=5F=5 9B DCF 9>9AD@C (5?=GHQB C "CF8
5B=5 GH5 9J=89B7=5 D9FA=H=FY5 7@5G=:=75F 5 9GH5G GC7=98589G 9B @5 A=GA5 75H9;CFY5
G9;`B 9@ G9;IB8C G9BH=8C &C C6GH5BH9 7F9C EI9 9G C6J=C EI9 9L=GH9B ;F5B89G
8=:9F9B7=5G 9BHF9 9GH5G GC7=98589G 9B 7I5BHC 5 @DR @D84A4 3428A 2A44A EI9 9B
D5FH9 DFCJ=9B9B 89@ <97<C 89 EI9 @5 7F99B7=5 9G IB5 CD7=]B M 9B 7=9FHC G9BH=8C
IB5 CD7=]B 7CBHFCJ9FH=85 9B @5 GC7=9858 7F=GH=5B5 C hDCG7F=GH=5B5i A=9BHF5G
EI99B@5GGC7=98589GAIGI@A5B5GBC@C9GCBCHC85JY5
(CF @C H5BHC A9 DFCDCB;C 9L5A=B5F BI9GHF5 GC7=9858 7CAC G97I@5F 9B 9GH9
H9F79F G9BH=8C @C EI9 EI=NQ DC8FY5 F9GIA=F 89 9GH5 A5B9F5 9@ D5G5>9 EI9 EI=9FC
89:=B=F M HF5N5F 9G 9@ D5G5>9 89 IB5 GC7=9858 9B @5 EI9 9F5 J=FHI5@A9BH9 =ADCG=6@9
BC 7F99F 9B =CG 5 IB5 GC7=9858 9B @5 EI9 @5 :9 5IB D5F5 9@ 7F9M9BH9 AQG 57VF
F=AC 9G 5D9B5G IB5 DCG=6=@=858 <IA5B5 9BHF9 CHF5G (I989 D5F979FA9 =B7CB79
6=6@9 565B8CB5F A= :9 D9FC <5M CHF5G D9FGCB5G =B7@IM9B8C EI=NQ 5@;IB5G AIM
79F75B5G 5 AY 7IM5 :CFA5 89 J=85 BC DI98C 7CB HCH5@ <CB9GH=858 89G9GH=A5F DCF
89DF5J585 C 7=9;5 C =B8=;B5 G=AD@9A9BH9 DCFEI9 BC GCB 7F9M9BH9G 5@ A9BCG BC
9B =CG C 9B @C HF5G79B89BH9 $5 :9 9B =CG M5 BC 9G 5L=CAQH=75 5M 5@H9FB
5H=J5G 1 DFC656@9A9BH9 9GHC H5A6=VB G=;B=:=EI9 EI9 5@ A9BCG 9B 7=9FHCG A98=CG
GC7=5@9G DI989 G9F 8=:Y7=@ GCGH9B9F @5 DFCD=5 :9 56FQ ;9BH9 EI9 G9 G=9BH5 C6@=;585
5 565B8CB5F@5 5IBEI9 @5A9BH9 GI DVF8=85 OGH5 <5 G=8C IB5 9LD9F=9B7=5 F97CBC
7=6@9 9B BI9GHF5G GC7=98589G DCF @C A9BCG 89G89 A98=58CG 89@ G=;@C 0!0 56FQ
AI7<CG CHFCG 5 EI=9B9G @5 :9 BIB75 @9G D5F9N75 IB5 DCG=6=@=858 J=56@9 5@;C EI9
=B8I856@9A9BH99GJQ@=8CD5F5A=@@CB9G89D9FGCB5G<CM9B8Y5
$5 G97I@5F=858 9B 9GH9 G9BH=8C G9 F9:=9F9 5 HC8C 9@ 7CBH9LHC =BH9@97H=JC 9B 9@ EI9
H=9B9 @I;5F BI9GHF5 9LD9F=9B7=5 M BI9GHF5 6`GEI985 ACF5@ 9GD=F=HI5@ C F9@=;=CG5
(CF h7CBH9LHC =BH9@97H=JCi 9BH=9B8C H5BHC 5EI9@@5G 7I9GH=CB9G EI9 DFC656@9A9BH9
<5B G=8C :CFAI@585G 9LD@Y7=H5A9BH9 DCF 75G= HC8CG 7CAC @5 D@IF5@=858 89
CD7=CB9G 7CAC CHF5G EI9 7CB:CFA5B 9@ H9@]B 89 :CB8C =AD@Y7=HC 9B ;F5B A98=85

 

BC AIM 7@5FC 89 9GH5 9LD9F=9B7=5 M 9GH5 6`GEI985 GI hDF9CBHC@C;Y5i D5F5 IG5F


IBHVFA=BC<9=89;;9F=5BC
-B5 9F5 C IB5 GC7=9858 G9FY5B 9BHCB79G G97I@5F9G C BC 9B J=FHI8 89@ 9GH58C 89
@5 9LD9F=9B7=5 M @5 6`GEI985 89 @C 9GD=F=HI5@ '6J=5A9BH9 8]B89 G9 G=H`9B 9B 9GH5
8=A9BG=]B H9B8FQ AI7<C EI9 J9F 7CB GI ;F58C 89 G97I@5F=858 9B 9@ G9;IB8C G9B
H=8C EI9 85 @I;5F 5 8=J9FGCG B=J9@9G 89 7F99B7=5 M DFQ7H=75 5IBEI9 BC 9L=GH9 IB5
7CFF9@57=]B G=AD@9 9BHF9 5A6CG 7CAC @C 89AI9GHF5 9@ 75GC 89 @CG GH58CG
-B=8CG B 7I5BHC 5@ DF=A9F G9BH=8C F9:9F=8C 5@ 9GD57=C D`6@=7C VGH9 DI989 BC
H9B9F B=B;IB5 7CFF9@57=]B 7CB @CG CHFCG 8CG 7CAC DC8FY5 5:=FA5FG9 F9GD97HC 89@
75GC 89 @5 !B8=5 (9FC 7CBG=89FC EI9 89 <97<C 9B 9@ 75GC 89 '77=89BH9 9@ D5G5>9
5 @5 G97I@5F=858 D`6@=75 <5 G=8C 9B D5FH9 @C EI9 5MI8] 5 :CF>5F IB5 9F5 G97I@5F 9B
9@H9F79FG9BH=8C

<
FH=7I@5F 9@ 9GH58C 89 @5 9LD9F=9B7=5 9G AQG 8=:Y7=@ 89 @C EI9 DC8FY5 D5F979F @@C G9
8969 9B D5FH9 5 EI9 @5G D9FGCB5G H=9B89B 5 DCB9F @5 A=F5 9B @5 7F99B7=5 A=GA5
EI9@@C 9B @C EI9 @5G D9FGCB5G GI9@9B =BH9F9G5FG9 @C EI9 9G D5F5 9@@5G IB5 :I9BH9
89 5B;IGH=5 M 7CB:@=7HC 9G @5 G9;IB85 7I9GH=]B f9B EIV 7F99B M EIV DF57H=75B @5G
D9FGCB5G f7IQBHCG 7F99B 9B =CG f7IQ@ 9G @5 H9B89B7=5 @ =BH9FVG DCF @5 G97I
@5F=858 D`6@=75 5 A9BI8C G9 J=B7I@5 7CB @5 7I9GH=]B 89 5EI9@@C 9B @C EI9 @5G D9F
GCB5G 7F99B C @C EI9 DF57H=75B M 89 7]AC GCB HF5H585G 9B 7CBG97I9B7=5 fBI9GHFC
FV;=A9B G97I@5F=GH5 A5F;=B5 5 @CG 7F=GH=5BCG 7CAC 5:=FA5B 5@;IBCG 9B GH58CG
-B=8CG fC 9GH=;A5H=N5 5 7=9FHCG ;FIDCG <5GH5 5<CF5 BC F97CBC7=8CG 7CAC @CG
5:FC5A9F=75BCGC@CG<=GD5BCGC6=9B5@CG;5MGM@5G@9G6=5B5G
(9FC 9B BI9GHF5G GC7=98589G 9@ ;F5B H9A5 89 @5 F9@=;=]B ;9B9F5@A9BH9 G9
89:=B9 9B HVFA=BCG 89 7F99B7=5 B DF=A9F @I;5F 9@ 7F=GH=5B=GAC G=9ADF9 G9
89:=B=] 5 GY A=GAC 9B F9@57=]B 7CB 5:=FA57=CB9G 89@ 7F98C 1 9@ G97I@5F=GAC 9B 9@
G9;IB8C G9BH=8C AI7<5G J979G :I9 7CBG=89F58C 7CAC 9@ 897@=J9 89 @5 :9 7F=GH=5B5
M 9GH9 897@=J9 9B ;F5B A98=85 7CAC 9@ DFC8I7HC 89@ GIF;=A=9BHC 89 CHF5G 7F99B
7=5G 7CAC @5 7F99B7=5 9B @5 7=9B7=5 C @5 F5N]B C 89 @5 9A5B7=D57=]B 89 @5G 7=9B7=5G
D5FH=7I@5F9G 7CAC @5 H9CFY5 89 @5 9JC@I7=]B C @5G 9LD@=757=CB9G B9IFC:=G=C@];=75G
89@:IB7=CB5A=9BHC89@5A9BH9

  

(5FH9 89 @5 F5N]B DCF @5 EI9 A9 =BH9F9G5 9B:5H=N5F 9@ 9GH58C 89 @5 7F99B7=5 @5


9LD9F=9B7=5 M @5 6`GEI985 9G EI9 BC 9GHCM G5H=G:97<C 7CB 9GH5 9LD@=757=]B 89@ G97
I@5F=GAC 9B 9@ G9;IB8C G9BH=8C @5 7=9B7=5 F9:IH5 M DCF @C H5BHC 89G75FH5 @5 :9 F9@=
;=CG5 &C 9GHCM G5H=G:97<C 9B 8CG B=J9@9G EI9 ;I5F85B F9@57=]B 9BHF9 GY B DF=A9F
@I;5F BC J9C @5 7CBHIB89B7=5 89 @CG GIDI9GHCG 5F;IA9BHCG 89 DCF 9>9AD@C @CG
<5@@5N;CG 89 5FK=B D5F5 5DCM5F @5G DF9GIBH5G F9:IH57=CB9G 89 @5 F9@=;=]B 1 9B
G9;IB8C @I;5F 9B D5FH9 DCF 9GH5 F5N]B BC J9C EI9 VG5 G95 IB5 9LD@=757=]B
5897I585 89 DCF EIV 89 <97<C @5G D9FGCB5G 565B8CB5FCB GI :9 5IB 7I5B8C 9@@5G
A=GA5G 9BIB7=5B @C GI798=8C 9B HVFA=BCG H5@9G 7CAC h5FK=B F9:IH] @5 =6@=5i
7CAC 5@ D5F979F 8=>C IB 5@IABC 89 5FFCK 9B @5 8V7585 89 
 9G89 @I9;C
@CG A5@CG 5F;IA9BHCG DI989B H9B9F IB @I;5F 79BHF5@ 9B 9LD@=757=CB9G DG=7C@];=75G
C <=GH]F=75G D9F:97H5A9BH9 6I9B5G (9FC @CG A5@CG 5F;IA9BHCG 7CAC VGH9 EI9
89>5B :I9F5 H5BH5G DCG=6=@=8589G J=56@9G 9BHF9 9@ :IB85A9BH5@=GAC M 9@ 5H9YGAC
7@5A5B DCF IB5 9LD@=757=]B 89 DCF EIV BC G9 F97CFF=9FCB 9GHCG CHFCG 75A=BCG
GH5 9LD@=757=]B AQG DFC:IB85 G9;`B A= D5F979F DI989 9B7CBHF5FG9 9B 9@ B=J9@
EI99GHCMHF5H5B8C899LD@CF5F.C@J9FV59GH9DIBHCAQG589@5BH9
(5F5 57@5F5F IB DC7C AQG @5G 7CG5G 9B 9GH9 B=J9@ EI=G=9F5 F9:9F=FA9 5 @5 :9 M 5
@5 :5@H5 89 :9 BC 7CAC C4>AU0B F=J5@9G 9G 897=F 7CAC :CFA5G 89 9LD@=75F @5 9L=GH9B
7=5 C @5 ACF5@ M5 G95 A98=5BH9 =CG C A98=5BH9 5@;C EI9 9GH5FY5 DF9G9BH9 9B @5
B5HIF5@9N5 C @C EI9 :I9F9 %QG 6=9B EI=9FC 79BHF5F A= 5H9B7=]B 9B @CG 8=:9F9BH9G
H=DCG 89 9LD9F=9B7=5 J=J=85 EI9 =BH9FJ=9B9B 9B @5 7CADF9BG=]B 89 BI9GHF5 J=85 89
IBAC8CC89CHFC9B7]AC9GJ=J=F7CAC7F9M9BH9C7CACBC7F9M9BH9
CAC DF=A9F5 =B8=757=]B 5DFCL=A585 89 @5 8=F977=]B 9B @5 EI9 A9 9B75A=BC
DC8FY5ACG 897=F EI9 VGH5G GCB :CFA5G 5@H9FB5H=J5G 89 J=J=F BI9GHF5 J=85 ACF5@
9GD=F=HI5@9B9@G9BH=8CAQG5AD@=C
,C8CG 7CBG=89F5ACG EI9 BI9GHF5 J=85 M C 9@ 9GD57=C 9B 9@ EI9 J=J=ACG BI9GHF5
J=85 H=9B9B 7=9FH5 :CFA5 ACF5@ 9GD=F=HI5@ B 5@;`B @I;5F 9B 5@;IB5 57H=J=858 C
9B 5@;`B 9GH58C <5M IB5 D@9B=HI8 IB5 F=EI9N5 9G 897=F 9B 9G9 @I;5F 57H=J=858 C
9GH58C @5 J=85 9G AQG D@9B5 AQG F=75 AQG DFC:IB85 AQG J5@=CG5 AQG 58A=F
56@9 AQG 7CAC 8969 G9F )I=NQ VG9 G95 IB @I;5F 89 DC89F AI7<5G J979G 9LD9F=
A9BH5ACG 9GHC 7CAC 5@;C DFC:IB85A9BH9 ACJ=@=N58CF =BGD=F58CF )I=NQ 9GH5
G9BG57=]B 89 D@9B=HI8 G95 5@;C 89 @C EI9 H9B9ACG 5H=G6CG 9B @5 8=GH5B7=5 H9B9ACG
@5 DC89FCG5 =BHI=7=]B 89 @C EI9 G9FY5 @5 D@9B=HI8 G= 9GHIJ=VG9ACG 9B 9G9 9GH58C DCF
9>9AD@C 89 D5N C 7CAD@9H=HI8 C G= DI8=VG9ACG 57HI5F 9B 9G9 B=J9@ 89 =BH9;F=858
;9B9FCG=858 565B8CBC C 89GDC>C 89@ MC (9FC 5 J979G <5M ACA9BHCG 9B @CG EI9

  

9LD9F=A9BH5ACG D@9B=HI8 5@9;FY5 M G5H=G:577=]B 9B @CG EI9 G9BH=ACG EI9 9GH5ACG


5@@Y.95ACGIB9>9AD@C9LHF5Y8C89@55IHC6=C;F5:Y589989F=::=H<G

IF5BH9 A= `@H=AC HF=A9GHF9 9B @5 IB=J9FG=858 IB 8Y5 G5@Y 5 75A=B5F GC@5 DCF @5 H5F89 M
9G7I7<V 9@ 75BHC 89 @CG DQ>5FCG :CFA5B8C 9G9 7CFC D@9BC EI9 G]@C DI989 9G7I7<5FG9 9B
9G5 VDC75 89@ 5\C 8IF5BH9 9@ 5A5B979F C 9@ 5H5F8979F *97I9F8C @5 GCFDF9G5 EI9 A9
DFC8I>C 9@ =AD57HC 89@ GCB=8C 9B A=G CY8CG ,9BY5 @5 G9BG57=]B 89 EI9 9F5 @5 DF=A9F5
J9N EI9 9G7I7<565 @CG DQ>5FCG 75BH5F M A9 DF9;IBHV G= 575GC 75BH565B 5GY HC8C 9@ 5\C M
MC BIB75 @C <56Y5 BCH58C %=9BHF5G 75A=B565 J= 5@;IBCG 9GD=BCG 9B :@CF M BI9J5A9BH9
D9BGV EI9 BIB75 5BH9G <56Y5 J=GHC 5@;C H5B 69@@C B= 9LD9F=A9BH58C H5BH5 8I@NIF5 += A9
<I6=9F5B7C@C758C89F9D9BH99BHF9@CGQF6C@9G89@"5F8YB89@8VBM<I6=9F59G7I7<58C
9@ 75BHC 89 IB 7CFC 89 QB;9@9G A= GCFDF9G5 BC <56FY5 G=8C A5MCF BHCB79G J= 7]AC 9@
GC@ G9 DCBY5 HF5G @CG 75ADCG 89 >I9;C +`6=H5A9BH9 IB5 5@CB8F5 G9 9@9J] 89G89 5@ @58C
89@ D=9 89 IB QF6C@ EI9 9GH565 79F75 89 AY 89FF5A] GI 75BH5F GC6F9 A= 7569N5 M @I9;C
JC@J=] 5 GIA=FG9 9B 9@ 89G75BGC G=B 89>5F 89 75BH5F ,C8C G9 5EI=9H] 7I5B8C 9@ GC@ G9
5D5;] M 9@ J9@C 89@ 7F9D`G7I@C 7CA9BN] 5 7I6F=F @5 H=9FF5 *97I9F8C 5<CF5 @5 G9BG57=]B
89 GC6F97C;=A=9BHC EI9 A9 =BJ58=] ,IJ9 9@ =ADI@GC 89 5FFC8=@@5FA9 GC6F9 9@ GI9@C
7CAC G= <I6=9F5 9GH58C 9B DF9G9B7=5 89 IB QB;9@ M 5D9B5G A9 5HF9JY 5 A=F5F 9@ 7=9@C
EI9BCD5F97Y5CHF57CG5AQGEI9IBJ9@CGC6F99@FCGHFC89=CG

B 9GH9 75GC @5 G9BG57=]B 89 D@9B=HI8 GIF;=] 7CAC IB5 9LD9F=9B7=5 EI9 D9FHIF65 9
=FFIAD9 9B BI9GHF5 G9BG57=]B 7CFF=9BH9 89 9GH5F 9B 9@ AIB8C 7CB GIG C6>9HCG
57H=J=8589G M DIBHCG 89 F9:9F9B7=5 :5A=@=5F9G CAC G9\5@5 (9H9F 9F;9F 5@
89G7F=6=F @5 C6F5 89 *C69FH %IG=@ VGHCG GCB ACA9BHCG 9B @CG EI9 h@5 F95@=858
CF8=B5F=5 EI985 56C@=85 M 5D5F979B 89GH9@@CG 89 5@;C 5H9FF58CF5A9BH9 >CA>i IB
9GH58C 89 7CB7=9B7=5 EI9 %IG=@ 89G7F=69 7CAC 34A =34A4 -DBC0=3 9@ CHFC
9GH58C
(9FC D5F5 EI9 G95 DCG=6@9 =89BH=:=75F 9@ 9GH58C 89 D@9B=HI8 BC 9G B979G5F=5 IB5
9LD9F=9B7=5 @YA=H9 89 9GH5 7@5G9 M5 G95 9L5@H5BH9 C 5H9ACF=N5BH9 +=AD@9A9BH9
DI989 <569F ACA9BHCG 9B @CG EI9 89 5@;`B AC8C @5G DFC:IB85G 8=J=G=CB9G
89G5H9B7=CB9G DF9C7ID57=CB9G C HF=GH9N5G EI9 D5F979B 565H=FBCG G9 8=GI9@J9B C
@C;F5B CF89B5FG9 M 9BHCB79G BCG G9BH=ACG IB=8CG 9B A5F7<5 G`6=H5A9BH9
75D579G M @@9BCG 89 9B9F;Y5 &I9GHF5G AQL=A5G 5GD=F57=CB9G M BI9GHF5 9B9F;Y5 89
J=85 89 5@;IB5 A5B9F5 G9 CF89B5B M G9 :CFH5@979B 9BHF9 GY 9B @I;5F 89 DFC8I7=F

  

IB5 D5FQ@=G=G DGYEI=75 OGH9 9G 9@ H=DC 89 9LD9F=9B7=5 EI9 +7<=@@9F HF5H] 89 8=G79FB=F
7CBGIBC7=]B89h>I9;Ci

GH5G 9LD9F=9B7=5G M CHF5G EI9 BC A9 9G DCG=6@9 9BIA9F5F 5EIY BCG 5MI85B 5


I6=75F IB @I;5F 89 D@9B=HI8 9B :IB7=]B 89@ 7I5@ BCG CF=9BH5ACG ACF5@ C 9GD=F=HI
5@A9BH9 G5G 9LD9F=9B7=5G BCG CF=9BH5B DCFEI9 BCG D9FA=H9B D9F7=6=F 89 EIV
9GHQB <97<5G @5 DF9G9B7=5 89 =CG @5 JCN 89 @5 B5HIF5@9N5 @5 :I9FN5 EI9 :@IM9 5
HF5JVG 89 HC85G @5G 7CG5G @5 DI9GH5 9B A5F7<5 9B BCGCHFCG 89@ 89G9C M 9@ =ADI@GC
D5F5 7CBGHFI=F (9FC H5A6=VB 5 A9BI8C GCB D9FHIF658CF5G M 9B=;AQH=75G &I9GHF5
D9F79D7=]B 9B 7I5BHC 5 GI DFC7989B7=5 DI989 BC G9F 89@ HC8C 7@5F5 G=BC AQG 6=9B
7CB:IG5 M :F5;A9BH5F=5 &CG 89>5B DFC:IB85A9BH9 7CBACJ=8CG D9FC H5A6=VB
89G7CB79FH58CG M 9GHF9A97=8CG ,9B9ACG EI9 9G:CFN5FBCG D5F5 89G7F=6=F @C EI9
BCG <5 GI798=8C += @C;F5ACG <579F@C 5IBEI9 G95 D5F7=5@A9BH9 BCG G9BH=ACG
5@=J=58CG 7CAC G= 9@ DC89F 89 @5 9LD9F=9B7=5 <I6=9G9 5IA9BH58C DCF 9@ <97<C 89
<569F@579FB=8C9LDF9G58CMDCF@CH5BHCDCF<569F@9D9FA=H=8CG9FD@9B5A9BH9
GHC DI989 5MI85F 5 85F@9 IB5 8=F977=]B 5 BI9GHF5 J=85 (9FC @5 G9BG57=]B 89
CF=9BH57=]B H5A6=VB H=9B9 GI @58C B9;5H=JC 9B 9@ EI9 9LD9F=A9BH5ACG GC6F9 HC8C
IB5 8=GH5B7=5 IB5 5IG9B7=5 IB 9L=@=C IB5 =B75D57=858 5D5F9BH9A9BH9 =FF9A98=
56@9 89 5@75BN5F 9GH9 @I;5F IB5 5IG9B7=5 89 DC89F IB5 7CB:IG=]B C D9CF 5`B 9@
9GH58C EI9 @5 HF58=7=]B 5 A9BI8C 89G7F=69 7CAC A9@5B7C@Y5 <5GHYC 9@ B?;44= 89
5I89@5=F9 $C H9FF=6@9 89 9GH9 `@H=AC 9GH58C 9G EI9 D9F89ACG @5 BC7=]B 89 8]B89
9GHQ 9@ @I;5F 89 @5 D@9B=HI8 9 =B7@IGC 89 EIV DC8FY5 G9F @5 D@9B=HI8 G9BH=ACG EI9
BCG <9ACG C@J=858C 89 7]AC G9FY5 C M5 BC DC89ACG 7F99F 9B 9@@5 (9FC @5 89GJ9B
HIF5 89 @5 5IG9B7=5 89 @5 DVF8=85 G=;I9 9GH5B8C 5@@Y 9B F95@=858 9B 7=9FH5 :CFA5
9G5`BAQG5;I85

5M CHF5G :=;IF5G 89@ 9L=@=C EI9 DC89ACG C6G9FJ5F 9B @5 HF58=7=]B 8CB89 @C


EI9 8CA=B5 9G IB5 G9BG57=]B 89 7CB89B5 89 9L7@IG=]B 9H9FB5 A9F97=85 M
897=8=85 89 @5 D@9B=HI8 C =AQ;9B9G 89 75IH=J9F=C 89BHFC 89 :CFA5G 9L97F56@9G EI9
9B75FB5B @5 B9;57=]B A=GA5 89 @5 D@9B=HI8 @5G ACBGHFICG5G :CFA5G 5B=A5@9G EI9
J9ACG9B@5GD=BHIF5G89"9F]B=ACCG7<DCF9>9AD@C
$I9;C 9B H9F79F @I;5F <5M IB5 9GD97=9 89 9GH58C =BH9FA98=C 9GH56=@=N58C 5@
EI9 5GD=F5ACG 7CB :F97I9B7=5 G IB 9GH58C 9B 9@ EI9 <9ACG 9B7CBHF58C IB5
:CFA5 89 9G75D5F 5 @5G :CFA5G 89 @5 B9;57=]B 9@ 9L=@=C 9@ J57YC G=B <569F 5@75B
N58C @5 D@9B=HI8 79DH5ACG @5 DCG=7=]B =BH9FA98=5 AI7<5G J979G 5 HF5JVG 89
7=9FHC CF89B FIH=B5F=C 9GH56@9 7CBGH5BH9 9B @5 J=85 9B 9@ EI9 <579ACG 7CG5G EI9

  

H=9B9B 7=9FHC G=;B=:=758C D5F5 BCGCHFCG DCF 9>9AD@C EI9 7CBHF=6IM9B 5 BI9GHF5
:9@=7=858 CF8=B5F=5 C EI9 GCB G5H=G:57HCF=5G 9B J5F=CG G9BH=8CG C EI9 7CBHF=6IM9B
5 @C EI9 7CBG=89F5ACG 9G 9@ 6=9B ' AI7<5G J979G 9B 9@ A9>CF 89 @CG 9G79B5F=CG
@5G HF9G 7CG5G (CF 9>9AD@C @I7<5ACG DCF J=J=F :9@=NA9BH9 7CB BI9GHF5 9GDCG5 M
BI9GHFCG <=>CG M 9>9F79ACG IB5 JC757=]B EI9 BCG F9GI@H5 G5H=G:57HCF=5 M EI9 H5A
6=VB7CBGH=HIM9IB57CBHF=6I7=]BC6J=55@6=9B9GH5F<IA5BC
(9FC D5F5 9GH9 9GH58C =BH9FA98=C 9G 9G9B7=5@ DF=A9FC EI9 @5 FIH=B5 9@ CF89B
9@ 7CBH57HC F9;I@5F 7CB 9@ G=;B=:=758C 9B BI9GHF5G 57H=J=8589G 8=5F=5G 89 5@;`B
AC8C 7CB>IF9B M A5BH9B;5B 5 F5M5 9@ 9L=@=C 9@ <5GHYC C @5 F97@IG=]B 9B @C ACB
GHFICGC M G9;IB8C EI9 H9B;5ACG 5@;IB5 G9BG57=]B 89 9GH5F 9B 7CBH57HC D9FA5B
9BH9 7CB 9@ @I;5F 89 @5 D@9B=HI8 M 89 9GH5F 9B75A=BQB8CBCG @9BH5A9BH9 <57=5 V@ 5
@C @5F;C 89 @CG 5\CG &C DC89ACG F9BIB7=5F 5 9GH9 @I;5F C D9F89F HCH5@A9BH9 @5G
9GD9F5BN5G 89 5@75BN5F@C G=B EI9 9@ 9EI=@=6F=C 89@ 9GH58C =BH9FA98=C EI989 896=@
=H58C
5GH5 5EIY DC8FY5 D5F979F EI9 A= 89G7F=D7=]B 89 9GH5 9GHFI7HIF5 GIDI9GH5
A9BH9 ;9B9F5@ 89 BI9GHF5 J=85 ACF5@ 9GD=F=HI5@ G9 =B7@=B5 5 :5JCF 89@ 7F9M9BH9 G
7@5FC EI9 @5G `@H=A5G CF57=CB9G 89@ DQFF5:C 5BH9F=CF G9 5>IGH5B 65GH5BH9 6=9B 5 @5
8=GDCG=7=]B A9BH5@ 89@ 7F9M9BH9 9B 9@ 9GH58C =BH9FA98=C OGH9 7CBH=B`5 89DCG=H
5B8C GI :9 9B IB 9GH58C AQG D@9BC 5 A9BI8C 89G7F=HC 7CAC G5@J57=]B M BC DI989
89>5F 89 9GD9F5F@C M H5A6=VB EI9FFY5 G9BH=F EI9 5@ A9BCG 9GHQ 5J5BN5B8C <57=5 V@
G=9GEI9M5BC9GHQ85B8CD9EI9\CGD5GCG9B9G58=F977=]B
(9FC G=B 8I85 <5M AI7<CG BC 7F9M9BH9G D5F5 EI=9B9G 9GH5 J=85 9B @C EI9 <9
89G7F=HC 7CAC 9@ h9GH58C =BH9FA98=Ci 9G HC8C @C EI9 <5M OG9 9G 9@ C6>9H=JC $5
J=85 BC 7CBG=GH9 AQG EI9 9B J=J=F 89 9G9 AC8C 6=9B M D@9B5A9BH9 lDCF 9>9AD@C
G9;`B @5G HF9G 8=A9BG=CB9G 89@ 9G79B5F=C EI9 5756C 89 89G7F=6=Fl GC 9G HC8C
7I5BHC @5 J=85 <IA5B5 C:F979 D9FC G9;`B 9GH5 D9FGD97H=J5 9GC 5 BC 9G DC75 7CG5
M 6 7F99F EI9 <5M 5@;C AQG DCF 9>9AD@C 89GDIVG 89 @5 AI9FH9 C 9B 5@;`B 9GH58C
=ADCG=6@9 89 G5BH=858 9G F9<I=F M GC75J5F @5 6`GEI985 89 9GH5 9L79@9B7=5
<IA5B5
9 A5B9F5 EI9 89G7F=6=F @5 D@9B=HI8 7CAC CHFC h@I;5Fi 5 D5FH=F 89 9GH9 9GH58C
=BH9FA98=C DI989 85F @I;5F 5 7CB:IG=CB9G 1 G=B 9A65F;C 9B 9GH9 DIBHC <5M IB5
5B5@C;Y5 9GHFI7HIF5@ @ BC 7F9M9BH9 EI=9F9 G9F 9@ H=DC 89 D9FGCB5 D5F5 EI=9B 9GH5
J=85 9G D@9B5A9BH9 G5H=G:57HCF=5 9B @5 EI9 DI989 F9;C7=>5FG9 DCF 7CAD@9HC 9B @5
EI9 HC8C GI G9BH=8C 89 @5 D@9B=HI8 DI989 9B7CBHF5F IB C6>9HC 5897I58C 1 V@ BC
9GHQ 5@@Y HC85JY5 ' 6=9B BC 9GHQ J=J=9B8C F95@A9BH9 @CG G=;B=:=758CG 7CBGH=HIH=JCG

  

89 GI J=85 9B :CFA5 D@9B5 lBC 9G F95@A9BH9 :9@=N 9B GI A5HF=ACB=C C BC G9 G=9BH9


F95@=N58C 9B GI HF565>C C BC H=9B9 7CB:=5BN5 9B EI9 GI HF565>C F95@A9BH9 =AD@=EI9
IB 6=9B D5F5 @5 <IA5B=858l C 6=9B 7CB:Y5 F5NCB56@9A9BH9 9B EI9 @5G 65G9G 89
HC8C 9GC 9GHQB D9FC 5@ 7CBHF5F=C 89 GI 7CB79D7=]B 9LDF9G5 BC DI989 9B7CBHF5F @5
D@9B=HI8 89 @5 D5N M IB5 G9BG57=]B 89 G5H=G:577=]B M 7CAD@9H=HI8 9B GI J=85 B
CHF5G D5@56F5G 5GD=F5 5 5@;C EI9 9GHQ AQG 5@@Q 89 8CB89 V@ 9GHQ )I=NQ HC85JY5 BC
<5 8CA9\58C D@9B5A9BH9 @5 BCGH5@;=5 DCF 5@;C HF5G79B89BH9 9 IB AC8C C 89
CHFC 5`B H=9B9 IB 75A=BC DCF F97CFF9F 1 VG9 9G 9@ DIBHC GI6M579BH9 5 9G5 =A5;9B
89@ @I;5F 5IBEI9 9G9 @I;5F BC G95 hCHFCi 9B 9@ G9BH=8C C6J=C 89 =AD@=75F 57H=J=8
589G7CAD@9H5A9BH98=:9F9BH9GCIB9GH58CAQG5@@Q899GH5J=85
<CF5 6=9B 9@ C6>9HC 89 89G7F=6=F 9GH5G 8=A9BG=CB9G HYD=75G 89 @5 J=85 ACF5@
9GD=F=HI5@ 7CAC AC8CG 89 =89BH=:=75F @5 D@9B=HI8 @5G :CFA5G 89 9L=@=C M @CG H=DCG 89
9GH58CG =BH9FA98=CG 9G 7CADF9B89F A9>CF @5 :9 M @5 :5@H5 89 :9 7CAC 9GH58CG
J=J=8CG M BC G=AD@9A9BH9 7CAC H9CFY5G C 7CB>IBHCG 89 H9CFY5G 5 @5G EI9 BCG
58<9F=ACG
@ ;F5B 7CBHF5GH9 C6J=C 5EIY 9G EI9 D5F5 @CG 7F9M9BH9G @5 9LD@=757=]B 89@ @I;5F
89 @5 D@9B=HI8 F9EI=9F9 IB5 F9:9F9B7=5 5 =CG 9G 897=F 5 5@;C EI9 9GHQ AQG 5@@Q 89
@5 J=85 <IA5B5 M C @5 B5HIF5@9N5 A=9BHF5G EI9 D5F5 @CG BC 7F9M9BH9G 9G 8=:9F9BH9
9@@CG AQG 6=9B 89>5B 56=9FH5 7I5@EI=9F 9LD@=757=]B C 9BH=9B89B @5 D@9B=HI8 9B
HVFA=BCG 89 IB5 DCH9B7=5@=858 89 @CG G9F9G <IA5BCG 7CB796=85 9B :CFA5 B5HIF
5@=GH5 (9FC <5GH5 9@ ACA9BHC 9G5 89G7F=D7=]B 89@ 7CBHF5GH9 HC85JY5 D5F979 IB5
89G7F=D7=]B 89 @5 7F99B7=5 $C EI9 B979G=H5ACG <579F 9G H9B9F IB5 5DF9<9BG=]B 89
@58=:9F9B7=589@59LD9F=9B7=5J=J=85
(CF GIDI9GHC 9GC 9G 5@;C =B7F9Y6@9A9BH9 8=J9FGC (9FC H5@ J9N G95 DCG=6@9 =89B
H=:=75F 5@;IBCG H9A5G F97IFF9BH9G  @CG 7F9M9BH9G DCF @C ;9B9F5@ @5 G9BG57=]B 89
D@9B=HI8 @9G @@9;5 9G 5@;C EI9 F97=69B AQG 5`B F97=69B 5@;C 5GY 7CAC IB5 F9@5
7=]B D9FGCB5@ 7CB CHFC EI9 9G 75D5N 89 5A5F M 85F 579F75FG9 5 @5 D@9B=HI8 =AD@=75
D5F5 9@@CG 9BHF9 CHF5G 7CG5G DFQ7H=75G 89 89JC7=]B M CF57=]B 5GY 7CAC 89 75F=858
M 8Q8=J5 M GCB 7CBG7=9BH9G 89 9GH5F AIM @9>CG 89@ 9GH58C 89 89JC7=]B M 8Q8=J5
D@9BCG GCB 7CBG7=9BH9G 89 9GH5F 9B79FF58CG 9B GY A=GACG @=;58CG 5 C6>9HCG M
C6>9H=JCG A9BCF9G =B75D579G 89 56F=FG9 M 85F M F97=6=F 7CAC @C <5FY5B 9B 9@ @I;5F
89 @5 D@9B=HI8 9 A5B9F5 EI9 9L=GH9 @5 BC7=]B 89 F97=6=F DC89F C D@9B=HI8 9B IB5
F9@57=]B D9FC 9@ EI9 F97=69 BC EI985 G=AD@9A9BH9 :CFH5@97=8C 9B GI 9GH58C 57HI5@
B979G=H59GH5F56=9FHCHF5BG:CFA5FG9G5@=FG989GY

  

OGH5 9G IB5 :CFAI@57=]B AIM 7F=GH=5B5 (5F5 DC89F 7CAD5F5F@5 7CB @5 :5@H5 89
:9 AC89FB5 EI=NQ G9FY5 6I9BC MILH5DCB9F@5 5 CHF5 :CFAI@57=]B AQG h6I8=GH5i
9B @5 EI9 @5 F9@57=]B D9FGCB5@ DC8FY5 89>5F 89 G9F 79BHF5@ D9FC 8CB89 G9 DCB8FY5
AI7<C AQG VB:5G=G 9B @5 HF5G79B89B7=5 89@ MC 9B GI 5D9FHIF5 9B F97=6=F IB DC89F
EI9J5AQG5@@Q89BCGCHFCG
(5F5 @CG BC 7F9M9BH9G AC89FBCG @5 G=HI57=]B 9G 65GH5BH9 8=:9F9BH9 @ DC89F 89
5@75BN5F @5 D@9B=HI8 9GHQ 89BHFC M 9@@C H=9B9 8=J9FG5G J5F=5BH9G -B5 9G @5 EI9 ;=F5
9B HCFBC 5 BI9GHF5 B5HIF5@9N5 7CAC G9F9G F57=CB5@9G $5 J5F=5BH9 ?5BH=5B5 9G @5
:CFA5 AQG 8=F97H5 CAC 5;9BH9G F57=CB5@9G H9B9ACG 9@ DC89F 89 9@56CF5F @5G
@9M9G 89 57I9F8C 7CB @5G EI9 J=J=ACG GH9 DC89F 9G H5B GID9F=CF 5 @5 :I9FN5 89 @5
A9F5 B5HIF5@9N5 EI9 <5M 9B BCGCHFCG 9B @5 :CFA5 89@ 89G9C EI9 7I5B8C @C 7CB
H9AD@5ACG G=B 8=GHCFG=]B BC DC89ACG G=BC G9BH=F F9J9F9B7=5 27CD=6 DCF V@ @
@I;5F 89 @5 D@9B=HI8 9G 8CB89 :=B5@A9BH9 @C;F5ACG 85F@9 F=9B85 GI9@H5 5 9GH9
DC89F M DCF @C H5BHC J=J=F 89 57I9F8C 7CB V@ ,9B9ACG IB G9BH=A=9BHC 89
F979DH=J=858 7I5B8C 7CB BI9GHFC G9BH=8C D@9BC 89 BI9GHF5 DFCD=5 :F5;=@=858 M
BI9GHFC ?0C7>B 7CAC G9F9G 89G95BH9G A=F5ACG 7CB 58A=F57=]B M H9ACF 9@ DC89F
89 8=7H5F @9M9G (9FC 9B `@H=A5 =BGH5B7=5 9GHC BC G=;B=:=75 EI9 <5M5 IB5 F979D7=]B
89G89 :I9F5 9@ DC89F 9GHQ 89BHFC M 7I5BHC AQG 58J=FH5ACG 9GH9 DC89F AQG 7CB
G7=9BH9G G9F9ACG 89 EI9 9GHQ 89BHFC 89 EI9 @5 ACF5@ 8969 G9F 5IH]BCA5 M BC
<9H9F]BCA5
%QG H5F89 5 9GHC DI989 5\58YFG9@9 IB5 H9CFY5 89 @5 5@=9B57=]B 89 9I9F657<
DFCM97H5ACG 5 =CG 896=8C 5 BI9GHF5 G9BG57=]B H9ADF5B5 89 9GH9 DC89F GC6F9
7C;98CF EI9 9EI=JC7585A9BH9 G=HI5ACG :I9F5 89 BCGCHFCG 8969ACG F95DFCD=
5FBCG89V@MDCB9F@C5@G9FJ=7=C89@CGG9F9G<IA5BCG(9FC#5BHBC8=C9G9D5GC
(CF GIDI9GHC H5A6=VB <5M AI7<5G J5F=5BH9G AQG B5HIF5@=GH5G 89@ DC89F 89 @5
F5N]B EI9 D5FH9B 89 @5G 8=A9BG=CB9G 8I5@=GH5G F9@=;=CG5G 89@ D9BG5A=9BHC 89
#5BH GI 7F99B7=5 9B @5 @=69FH58 F58=75@ 89@ 5;9BH9 ACF5@ @5 =BACFH5@=858 =CG
l@CG HF9G DCGHI@58CG 89 @5 F5N]B DFQ7H=75l )I=NQ <5M5 IB B5HIF5@=GAC AQG F=;IF
CGC EI9 @9 89>5 5 @5 F5N]B <IA5B5 DC7C 9GD57=C D5F5 A5B=C6F5F ;I=585 DCF IB
@58C DCF 9@ =BGH=BHC M DCF 9@ CHFC G=H=585 DCF @5G 9L=;9B7=5G 89 @5 GID9FJ=J9B7=5 ,5@
J9N BC <5M5 9LD@=757=]B 89 DCF EIV H9B9ACG 9GH9 DC89F OGH9 DI989 7CBG=GH=F 5
;F5B89G F5G;CG 9B @CG IGCG =BGHFIA9BH5@9G 89 @5 F5N]B 9B 9GH9 DIBHC BI9J5A9BH9
5 8=:9F9B7=5 89 #5BH (9FC 89BHFC 89 9GH9 H=DC 89 B5HIF5@=GAC AI7<5G J979G
9B7CBHF5ACG IB5 58A=F57=]B <57=5 9@ DC89F 89 @5 F5N]B G9F9B5 89GJ=B7I@585
75D5N 89 7CBH9AD@5F 9@ AIB8C M @5 J=85 <IA5B5 G=B =@IG=]B M 89 57HI5F 7CB


 

@I7=89N 9B DCG 89 @5 9JC@I7=]B <IA5B5 ,C85JY5 7=9FHC GC6F97C;=A=9BHC FC895 5 @5


F5N]B 7CAC DC89F 7FYH=7C 75D5N 89 @=69F5FBCG 89 @5 =@IG=]B M @5G :I9FN5G 7=9;5G 89@
=BGH=BHC 5GY 7CAC 89 @5G :5BH5GY5G 9B;9B8F585G 5 D5FH=F 89@ A=98C @5 9GHF97<9N M
@5 DIG=@5B=A=858 $C AQG 79F75BC 5 @5 D@9B=HI8 F9G=89 9B 9GH9 DC89F 89 @5 F5N]B M
9G 9BH9F5A9BH9 BI9GHFC M G9 <5 89G5FFC@@58C 5 HF5JVG 89 BI9GHF5 DFCD=5 577=]B
<9FC=75 1 5EIY G9 GI9@9 A9B7=CB5F 5 @CG ;=;5BH9G 89 @5 F5N]B h7=9BHY:=75i CDVF
B=7C5FK=BF9I8
B J9F858 9GH9 G9BH=8C 89 BCGCHFCG A=GACG 7CAC G9F9G :FQ;=@9G M 5 @5 J9N
J5@=9BH9G 75D579G 89 9B:F9BH5F IB IB=J9FGC :5@HC 89 G=;B=:=758C M <CGH=@ G=B EI9
BI9GHFC 7CF5N]B 89G:5@@9N75 M 89 9GH5F 5 @5 5@HIF5 89@ 89G5:YC 89 9GH56@979F
BI9GHF5G DFCD=5G F9;@5G D5F5 @5 J=85 DI989 G9F =BGD=F58CF 7CAC DC89ACG
5DF97=5F 9B @CG 9G7F=HCG 89 5AIG DCF 9>9AD@C B @5 A98=85 9B EI9 9GHV 5 @5
5@HIF5 89 9GH9 89G5:YC :CFH5@97=8C DCF 9GH9 G9BH=8C 89 BI9GHF5 DFCD=5 ;F5B89N5
9GH9 9GH58C 5@ EI9 5GD=F5ACG D9FC EI9 G]@C F5F5G J979G 5@75BN5ACG G= 9G EI9
@@9;5ACG 5 <579F@C DI989 :IB7=CB5F 7CAC GI DFCD=C @I;5F 89 D@9B=HI8 9B 9@ G9B
H=8C9BEI9@C<9D@5BH958C5BH9F=CFA9BH9
B 7CBHF5DCG=7=]B 5 9GHCG AC8CG 89 F9;C7=>C 9B 9@ DC89F 5IHCGI:=7=9BH9 89 @5
F5N]B <5M CHFCG AC8CG 89 :5@H5 89 :9 EI9 89 A5B9F5 5BQ@C;5 5 @5G 7CB79D7=CB9G
F9@=;=CG5G 7CBG=89F5B EI9 D5F5 5@75BN5F @5 D@9B=HI8 B979G=H5ACG F97=6=F DC89F 89
7I5@EI=9F CHFC @58C EI9 BC G95 @5 F5N]B 5IH]BCA5 $5 F5N]B 9B GY A=GA5 9G
9GHF97<5 7=9;5 5 @5G 89A5B85G 89 @5 D@9B=HI8 M EI=NQ 5J5B79 <57=5 @5 89GHFI77=]B
H5BHC <IA5B5 7CAC 97C@];=75 G= BC F97CBC79 B=B;`B @YA=H9 EI=NQ G95 57H=J585
DCF IB5 GI9FH9 89 GC69F6=5 89 5FFC;5B7=5  A9BI8C 9B 9GH9 DIBHC F9GI9B5B 97CG
89 IB5 7FYH=75 F9@=;=CG5 89 @5 F5N]B AC89FB5 89GJ=B7I@585 EI9 BC 7F99 9B B585
L79DHC EI9 @5G :I9BH9G 89 DC89F BC GCB HF5G79B89BH9G 5B 89 9B7CBHF5FG9 9B @5
&5HIF5@9N5 9B BI9GHF5G DFCD=5G DFC:IB8=8589G =BH9FB5G C 9B 5A6CG @I;5F9G
(C89ACG F97CBC79F 5EIY @5G H9CFY5G 89 @5 =BA5B9B7=5 EI9 GIF;9B 89 @5 7FYH=75 89@
*CA5BH=7=GAC 89 @5 F5N]B 89GJ=B7I@585 M 9GD97=5@A9BH9 7=9FH5 VH=75 97C@];=75 89
BI9GHF5 VDC75 9B D5FH=7I@5F @5 97C@C;Y5 DFC:IB85 344? 42>;>6H $5 A9BH9
F57=CB5@ 8969 56F=FG9 5 5@;C AQG DFC:IB8C M D@9BC 5 5@;C =BH9F=CF 5@ A9BCG 9B
D5FH9 BI9GHFCG DFCD=CG G9BH=A=9BHCG C =BGH=BHCG (CF @C H5BHC 8969ACG GI6G5B5F
@5 9G7=G=]B EI9 H9B9ACG 9B BI9GHFC =BH9F=CF 7F9585 DCF @5 F5N]B 89GJ=B7I@585 EI9
CDCB99@D9BG5A=9BHC5@G9BH=A=9BHCC5@=BGH=BHCC5@5=BHI=7=]B
9 A5B9F5 EI9 5EIY H9B9ACG 7CB79D7=CB9G EI9 7CAC 5756C 89 A9B7=CB5F
H=9B9B 7=9FH5G 5B5@C;Y5G 7CB @5 F9577=]B F9@=;=CG5 5 @5 !@IGHF57=]B BC 7F9M9BH9 DCF

 

7I5BHC 9B:5H=N5B @5 F979D7=]B DCF GC6F9 @5 5IHCGI:=7=9B7=5 D9FC GCB 7CB79D7=CB9G


EI9 DFC7IF5B G9;I=F G=9B8C =BA5B9BH9G M DCF @C H5BHC AI7<5G J979G 7CAC AYB
=ACH5B<CGH=@9G<57=5@5F9@=;=]B7CAC@5G7CB79D7=CB9G89GJ=B7I@585G
L=GH9 IB5 H9F79F5 75H9;CFY5 89 9B:CEI9 EI9 F9GI@H5 8=:Y7=@ 89 7@5G=:=75F 5EIY
D9FC EI9 9GD9FC DC89F 89GD@9;5F AQG 589@5BH9 5M 7CB79D7=CB9G 7CAC @5 89
7=9FH5G AC85@=8589G 7CBH9ADCFQB95G 89@ DCGAC89FB=GAC EI9 B=9;5B 5H575B C G9
6IF@5B 89 EI=9B9G DFC7@5A5B @5 F5N]B 5IHCGI:=7=9BH9 D9FC EI9 BC C:F979B IB5
:I9BH9 9LH9FB5 D5F5 @5 F979D7=]B 89@ DC89F GHQB H5B F9GI9@H5G 5 896=@=H5F M B9;5F
@5G BC7=CB9G 89@ *CA5BH=7=GAC 89 7CBGI9@C 9B 9@ G9BH=A=9BHC C 9B @5 IB=858 F97I
D9F585 7CAC 5 5H575F 9@ GI9\C 89 @5 !@IGHF57=]B 89@ D9BG5A=9BHC DIFC M 5
A9BI8C D5F979B 5`B AQG 89G9CG5G 89 DCB9F 89 F9@=9J9 GIG 7CBJ=77=CB9G 5H95G +9
DFCDCB9B AIM 9GD97=5@A9BH9 9B:5H=N5F @5 B5HIF5@9N5 =FF9A98=56@9 89 @5 9G7=G=]B
@5 :5@H5 89 79BHFC @5 5IG9B7=5 D9FD9HI5 89 D@9B=HI8 @C EI9 9B 9@ A9>CF 89 @CG
75GCG 9G IB GI9\C B979G5F=C 5@;C EI9 EI=NQ 8965ACG GIDCB9F D5F5 85F IB G9B
H=8C AYB=AC 5 BI9GHFC AIB8C D9FC EI9 G=9ADF9 9GHQ 9B CHF5 D5FH9 M EI9 9B DF=B
7=D=CBCDC8FY5G9F<5@@58C
GH5 :5A=@=5 89 7CB79D7=CB9G D5F979 I6=75FG9 89:=B=H=J5A9BH9 DCF :I9F5 89 @5G
9GHFI7HIF5G 5 @5G EI9 A9 9GHCM F9:=F=9B8C 5EIY 1 G=B 9A65F;C 7F9C EI9 DI989
89ACGHF5FG9 EI9 89 J5F=5G A5B9F5G G9 5DCM5B 9B 9G5G 9GHFI7HIF5G B D5FH=7I@5F
C6H=9B9B GI :CFH5@9N5 89@ G9BH=8C 89 BI9GHF5 J5@9BHY5 M ;F5B89N5 D5F5 DC89F
5:FCBH5F @C =FF9A98=56@9 M G9;I=F 589@5BH9 5 D9G5F 89 HC8C .C@J9FV GC6F9 9GH9
DIBHCAQG589@5BH9
GY <9ACG 5J5BN58C IB DC7C 5@ <56@5F 89 @5 :9 M @5 :5@H5 89 :9 7CAC :CFA5G 89
J=J=F C 9LD9F=A9BH5F @5 J=85 ACF5@ 9GD=F=HI5@ 9B @5G HF9G 8=A9BG=CB9G EI9 A9B
7=CBV 5BH9F=CFA9BH9 CAC AYB=AC G9\5@V 5@;IBCG 7CBHF5GH9G 9B @5 DF=A9F5
8=A9BG=]B 9B @5 :CFA5 89 9LD9F=A9BH5F @5 D@9B=HI8 9B @5 :I9BH9 89 DC89F EI9
DI989 579F75FBCG 5 9G5 D@9B=HI8 9B G= G9 9B7I9BHF5 h89BHFCi C h:I9F5i M 9B EIV
G9BH=8C  7CBH=BI57=]B DF9G9BHV @5G 8=:9F9B7=5G 7CFF9GDCB8=9BH9G 9B 7I5BHC 5 @5G
9LD9F=9B7=5G899L=@=CM55EIV@@5GD9FH9B97=9BH9G5@9GH58C=BH9FA98=C
G B979G5F=C 897=F 5@;C AQG GC6F9 9GH5 8=GH=B7=]B 89 @C =BH9F=CF @C 9LH9F=CF
D9FC 5BH9G 89 7CBH=BI5F 89G5FFC@@5B8C 9GH9 DIBHC 8969ACG 9LD@CF5F CHF5 :579H5
=ADCFH5BH9 89 9GH5 9LD9F=9B7=5 89 D@9B=HI8 7CAC hG=HI585i 9B 5@;`B @I;5F
9ACG =8C AQG 5@@Q 89 @5 A9F5 7F99B7=5 M BCG 579F75ACG 5 @5 9LD9F=9B7=5 J=J=85
5EIY D9FC 5`B 9G DF97=GC 89GH575F =ADCFH5BH9G 8=:9F9B7=5G 9B 9@ AC8C 9B EI9 @5
J=J=ACG

 

f)IV EI=9F9 897=F EI9 D5F5 AY @5 D@9B=HI8 DFCJ=9B9 89 IB DC89F EI9 A9 HF5G
7=9B89 EI9 896C F97=6=F 9H7VH9F5 CM 9G DCG=6@9 EI9 EI=9F5 897=F 5@;C 5GY 9@
A9>CF 9G79B5F=C EI9 DI98C =A5;=B5F D5F5 A= 9LD9F=9B7=5 ACF5@ M 9GD=F=HI5@ 9B
7CB:@=7HC 9G 75DH58C DCF IB5 7CB79D7=]B H9C@];=75 89 9GH9 H=DC G 897=F G9;`B A=
DFCD=5 9LD9F=9B7=5 9B @5 CF57=]B 9B ACA9BHCG 89 D@9B=HI8 9B @5G 9LD9F=9B7=5G
89 9L=@=C GID9F585G 9B @C EI9 C6G9FJC 5 A= 5@F9898CF 9B @5G J=85G 89 CHF5G D9FGC
B5G lJ=85G 89 D@9B=HI8 9GD=F=HI5@ 9L79D7=CB5@ C J=85G 89 5IHC9B7=9FFC 9LHF9AC
J=85G 89 IB A5@ 89ACBY57C 9H7VH9F5l VGH9 D5F979 G9F 9@ 7I58FC EI9 GIF;9 (9FC
BIB75 C F5F5G J979G 89>C 89 8I85F DCF 7CAD@9HC G=9ADF9 A9 FCB85 5@;IB5 C6>9
7=]B l896=8C 5 5@;IB5 9LD9F=9B7=5 EI9 BC F9GI@H5 5DFCD=585 5 5@;IB5G J=85G EI9
AI9GHF5B D@9B=HI8 89G89 CHF5 D9FGD97H=J5 5 5@;IB5 :CFA5 5@H9FB5H=J5 89 D@9B=HI8
EI95J979GA99A65F;59H7VH9F5l
GHC 9G 5@;C HYD=7C 89 @5 7CB8=7=]B AC89FB5 M 7585 IBC 89 @CG BC 7F9M9BH9G
DC8FY5 F9@5H5F IB5 <=GHCF=5 D5F97=85 .=J=ACG 9B IB 9GH58C 9B 9@ EI9 BC DC89ACG
9J=H5F G9F 7CBG7=9BH9G 89 EI9 <5M IB5 G9F=9 89 =BH9FDF9H57=CB9G 8=:9F9BH9G 7CB79D
7=CB9G 7CB @5G EI9 AI7<5G D9FGCB5G =BH9@=;9BH9G M F5NCB56@9A9BH9 6=9B CF=9BH5
85G DI989B BC 9GH5F 89 57I9F8C &C DC89ACG 9J=H5F A=F5F 89 F9C>C 89 J9N 9B
7I5B8CMJ=J=FBI9GHF5:9H5A6=VB9B IB9GH58C898I859=B79FH=8IA6F9
GH9 YB8=79 89 8I85 9G 9@ EI9 =B8I79 5 @5G D9FGCB5G 5 <56@5F 89 hH9CFY5Gi 9B
9GH9 DIBHC (I9GHC EI9 5 A9BI8C @5G H9CFY5G GCB <=D]H9G=G EI9 G9 GCGH=9B9B 9B @5
A5MCF =B79FH=8IA6F9 M EI9 5;I5F85B @5 5D5F=7=]B 89 BI9J5G 9J=89B7=5G GD9FC
<569F 89>58C 9B 7@5FC EI9 BC DC89ACG 7CADF9B89F@5G 7CAC A9F5G H9CFY5G EI9
89 5@;`B AC8C HC85 BI9GHF5 9LD9F=9B7=5 G9 7CBH5;=5 G= J=J=ACG 9B IB5 I CHF5
:CFA5 89 9GD=F=HI5@=858 (9FC =;I5@A9BH9 <CM G569ACG EI9 DC89ACG J=J=F @5 J=85
9GD=F=HI5@ 89 CHF5 A5B9F5 EI9 9@ DC89F @5 D@9B=HI8 9@ 9L=@=C 9H7VH9F5 DI989B
5GIA=F:CFA5G8=:9F9BH9G
(9FC 7@5F5A9BH9 9L=GH9 CHF5 A5B9F5 89 J=J=F 9G5G 7CG5G M 9GC 9G @C EI9 <=7=9FCB
AI7<CG G9F9G <IA5BCG +9 HF5H5 89 IB 9GH58C 9B 9@ EI9 @5 9LD9F=9B7=5 =BA98=5H5
89 DC89F IB @I;5F 89 D@9B=HI8 9L=@=C G9 D@5BH95 9B HVFA=BCG EI9 =>B>CA>B =89BH=
:=75FY5ACG 7CAC IB5 89 @5G 5@H9FB5H=J5G DCG=6@9G D9FC 9B 9@ EI9 D5F5 @5G D9FGCB5G
7CB79FB=85G BC GIF;=] H5@ 8=GH=B7=]B 9BHF9 @5 9LD9F=9B7=5 M GI =BH9FDF9H57=]B
,CA9ACG 9@ 9>9AD@C 89 "9F]B=AC CG7< GIG 9G79B5F=CG 85BH9G7CG 89 DCG9G=]B
89 9GDYF=HIG A5@=;BCG 89 75IH=J9F=C 9B :CFA5G 5B=A5@9G ACBGHFICG5G (C89ACG
=A5;=B5F EI9 9B @5 9LD9F=9B7=5 J=J=85 89 AI7<5G D9FGCB5G 89 5EI9@@5 VDC75 VG5G
BC 9F5B hH9CFY5Gi 9B B=B;`B G9BH=8C G=BC C6>9HCG 89 IB J9F8589FC H9ACF 89 IB

 

H9ACF H5B 5DF9A=5BH9 EI9 BC 9F5 DCG=6@9 7CBG=89F5F G9F=5A9BH9 @5 =895 89 EI9
DI8=9F5B G9F =FF95@9G &CGCHFCG C 5@;I=9B EI9 7CBC7=ACG 9LD9F=A9BH] 5@;C 5GY 1
H5@J9NB58=99BBI9GHFC9BHCFBC@@9;]BIB75H5BG=EI=9F55GI;9F=FGI=FF95@=858
9 A5B9F5 5BQ@C;5 7I5B8C 9@ DI96@C 89 @5 (5@9GH=B5 89@ &I9JC ,9GH5A9BHC
J9Y5 5 5@;I=9B DCG9Y8C DCF IB 9GDYF=HI A5@=;BC G9 9B:F9BH565 89A5G=58C DFCBHC
7CB 9@ GI:F=A=9BHC F95@ 89 9G9 9GH58C 9B IB J97=BC C 9B IB5 D9FGCB5 5A585 7CAC
D5F5 DC89F 7CB796=F @5 =895 89 EI9 VG5 9F5 IB5 9LD@=757=]B =BH9F9G5BH9 89 IB5
9B:9FA9858 DG=7C@];=75 =89BH=:=756@9 9B HVFA=BCG DIF5A9BH9 =BHF5DGYEI=7CG D9FC
EI9DCG=6@9A9BH9<56Y5CHF5G9H=C@C;Y5GAQG7CB:=56@9GD5F59G59B:9FA9858
' D5F5 HCA5F IB 9>9AD@C 7CBH9ADCFQB9C 89 p:F=75 '77=89BH5@ 9B 9GH9 75GC
9GC 9G @C EI9 8969 89 <569F@9 C7IFF=8C 5 9@9GH=B9 EI=9B G9;`B 9@ F9@5HC F=;=H
%9M9F 5 D5FH=F 89 @5 9BHF9J=GH5 EI9 @9 F95@=N5 h75A=B] 89G89 J9H=@9 <5GH5 GI
75G5 7CB GI A58F9 57CAD5\585 DCF IB 9LHF5\C J9GH=8C 7CB IB5 H`B=75 6@5B75
HYD=75 89@ BCFH9i !BH9FFC;585 AQG H5F89 GC6F9 9GH9 <97<C GI A58F9 B9;] <569F
J=GHC 5@ <CA6F9 OGH9 F9GI@H] G9F +CK@I= IB 9GDYF=HI 89 ?5B M 9@9GH=B9 :I9 C6@=
;585 5 G9FJ=F@9 B 9@ AIB8C 89 9@9GH=B9 EI=NQ @5 =89BH=:=757=]B 89@ <CA6F9 7CB
9GH9 9GDYF=HI DC8FY5 89BCA=B5FG9 h7F99B7=5i DCF 7I5BHC GIF;=] @I9;C 89 5EI9@@5
9LD9F=9B7=5 7CAC IB =BH9BHC DCF 9LD@=75F @C EI9 <56Y5 GI798=8C (9FC 9@ <CA6F9
EI9 @5 57CAD5\565 9F5 G]@C 5@;C EI9 @9 <56Y5 C7IFF=8C 5 9@@5 IB 57CBH97=A=9BHC
89GIAIB8C
(CF @C H5BHC <5M IB 9GH58C 89 @5 9LD9F=9B7=5 J=J=85 9B 9@ EI9 @C EI9 DC8FY5ACG
@@5A5F IB5 =BH9FDF9H57=]B 89 @C ACF5@ 9GD=F=HI5@ BC 9G J=J=85 7CAC H5@ G=BC 7CAC
IB5 F95@=858 =BA98=5H5 7CAC @5G D=98F5G @CG FYCG M @5G ACBH5\5G 1 9GHC 7@5F5
A9BH9 H5A6=VB 9G JQ@=8C D5F5 9@ @58C DCG=H=JC 89 @5G 7CG5G DCF 9>9AD@C @5G 5@H9FB
5H=J5G EI9 9B:F9BH565B 9B @5 J=85 @5G D9FGCB5G EI9 J=J=9FCB 9B VDC75G D5G585G 89
BI9GHF5 7I@HIF5 lD5F5 EI=9B9G @@9;5F 5 @5 D@9B=HI8 G=AD@9A9BH9 9F5 579F75FG9 AQG
5 =CGl 9F5B J=J=F IB5 89JC7=]B AQG D@9B5 C 7CBH=BI5F J=J=9B8C 9B DCG 89 6=9B9G
A9BCF9G 5 IB5 8=GH5B7=5 D9FA5B9BH9 89 @5 D@9B=HI8 G9F 3RE>C4B C <>=308=4B 9B
HVFA=BCG 89 @5 F5B7=5 89@ G=;@C 0.!! BC D9FG9;I=F IB5 =BH9FDF9H57=]B 8=:9F9BH9 89
@CEI9DC8FY5G=;B=:=75F@5D@9B=HI8
<CF5 6=9B D5FH9 89 @C EI9 <5 C7IFF=8C 9B BI9GHF5 7=J=@=N57=]B 9G EI9 <9ACG
9FCG=CB58C 9B ;F5B A98=85 9GH5G :CFA5G 89 79FH=8IA6F9 =BA98=5H5 G 897=F
D5F979 7@5FC EI9 BIB75 DC8FQB G9F H5B D@9B5A9BH9 h=B;9BI5Gi  D5F5 BCGCHFCG
7CAC @C 9F5B 9B H=9ADCG 89 "9F]B=AC CG7< (9FC HC85JY5 H9B9ACG 5@;C 5BQ@C;C 5
9GC 5IBEI9 AQG 8V6=@ %9 F9:=9FC 5 @5 A5B9F5 9B EI9 @5 J=85 ACF5@ 9GD=F=HI5@

  

H=9B89 5 A5B=:9GH5FG9 9B 7=9FHCG QA6=HCG G 897=F 5IBEI9 HC8CG G569B EI9 <5M
AQG 89 IB5 CD7=]B 9G DCG=6@9 EI9 9B BI9GHFC QA6=HC IB5 =BH9FDF9H57=]B G95 9GH5
7F9M9BH9 C BC 7F9M9BH9 H=9B85 5 A5B=:9GH5FG9 7CAC @5 AQG 56FIA58CF5A9BH9
D@5IG=6@9 +569ACG EI9 <5M CHF5G CD7=CB9G M G= BCG =BH9F9G5ACG DCF CHF5 EI9
9>9F79 IB5 5HF577=]B GC6F9 BCGCHFCG EI=NQ DC85ACG D9BG5F 9B @5 A5B9F5 89 579F
75FBCG 5 9@@5 C @I7<5F DCF 5@75BN5F@5 BHCB79G FCAD9ACG 7CB BI9GHF5 7CAIB=858
7F9M9BH9 M BCG JC@J9ACG 5H9CG C 6=9B @C 7CBHF5F=C (9FC IB5 CD7=]B 9G DCF 5GY
897=F@5CD7=]BDCFCA=G=]B
B 9GH9 G9BH=8C G9 <5 DFC8I7=8C IB 75A6=C H=HQB=7C 9B BI9GHF5 7=J=@=N57=]B
C77=89BH5@ &C G]@C <9ACG D5G58C 89 IB 9GH58C 9B 9@ EI9 @5 A5MCFY5 89 @5 ;9BH9
J=JY5 h=B;9BI5A9BH9i 89 57I9F8C 7CB IB5 =BH9FDF9H57=]B 9B D5FH9 7F=GH=5B5 9B
D5FH9 F9@57=CB585 7CB @CG h9GDYF=HIGi 89 CF=;9B D5;5BC H9B=85 DCF IB5 F95@=858
G=AD@9 5 IB 9GH58C 9B 9@ EI9 75G= B58=9 9G 75D5N 89 5@;C 5GY G=BC EI9 HC8CG 7CB
G=89F5ACG EI9 9G5 CD7=]B 9G 5D9B5G IB5 9BHF9 AI7<5G CHF5G ,C8CG 5DF9B89ACG 5
B5J9;5F 9BHF9 8CG DIBHCG 89 J=GH5 IBC hJ=B7I@58Ci 9B 9@ EI9 J=J=ACG @C A9>CF
EI9 DC89ACG @5 F95@=858 5 @5 EI9 BI9GHFC DIBHC 89 J=GH5 BCG 56F9 M IBC h89GJ=B
7I@58Ci 9B 9@ EI9 DC89ACG J9FBCG 5 BCGCHFCG A=GACG GCGH9B9F IB DIBHC 89 J=GH5
9BHF9 IB5 G9F=9 89 CHFCG DCG=6@9G 7CB @CG EI9 8969ACG 7C9L=GH=F 89 AI7<5G
:CFA5G
,5A6=VB <9ACG D5G58C 89 IB 9GH58C 9B 9@ EI9 @5 7F99B7=5 9F5 @5 CD7=]B DCF
CA=G=]B BC G]@C D5F5 @CG =B;9BICG G=BC H5A6=VB D5F5 EI=9B9G G56Y5B 89@ 5H9YGAC
@C 7CBG=89F565B 7CAC DCG=6=@=858 M <56@565B 579F75 89 V@ 5 IB 9GH58C 9B 9@ EI9
7585 J9N D5F5 AQG D9FGCB5G @5G =BH9FDF9H57=CB9G BC 7F9M9BH9G D5F979B 5 DF=A9F5
J=GH5 @5G `B=75G D@5IG=6@9G +]@C DI989B 579F75FG9 5 7F9M9BH9G G9A=D5;5BCG G=B
BIB75 5@75BN5F 9@ 9GH58C 89 5H9CG h=B;9BICGi 9B 9@ G9BH=8C 9B EI9 @C 9F5B GIG
5B79GHFCG D9FC VGH5 @9G D5F979 @5 =BH9FDF9H57=]B AQG 56FIA58CF5A9BH9 D@5IG=6@9
M @9G F9GI@H5 8=:Y7=@ 7CADF9B89F 5 @5G D9FGCB5G EI9 58CDH5B CHF5  H5@ DIBHC EI9
G9 =B7@=B5B :Q7=@A9BH9 <57=5 H9CFY5G :F5B75A9BH9 9FF]B95G D5F5 9LD@=75F @5 :9 F9@=
;=CG5 @5G D9FGCB5G H=9B9B A=98C 89 @5 =B79FH=8IA6F9 89 @C 89G7CBC7=8C GCB
8V6=@9G899GDYF=HI@5GD5F5@=N5@57I@D59H7VH9F5
GHC BC EI=9F9 897=F EI9 HC8CG G9 9B7I9BHF9B 9B 9G9 9GH58C &I9GHF5 7=J=@=N5
7=]B AC89FB5 9GHQ 7CB:CFA585 DCF IB5 G9F=9 89 GC7=98589G GI6GC7=98589G M
QA6=HCG AIM 8=:9F9BH9G 9BHF9 GY (9FC 9@ GIDI9GHC 89 @5 :5@H5 89 :9 <5 D5G58C 5 DF9
J5@979F 9B 7585 J9N AQG QA6=HCG M <5 @C;F58C IB5 <9;9ACBY5 9B 7=9FHCG QA6=HCG

  

7@5J9 9B @5 J=85 5758VA=75 9 =BH9@97HI5@ DCF 9>9AD@C 89G89 8CB89 @9 9G DCG=6@9


9LH9B89FG9AQG:Q7=@A9BH95CHFCG
(5F5 G=HI5F @5 8=G7IG=]B GC6F9 @5 :9 M @5 :5@H5 89 :9 9B BI9GHFCG 8Y5G M 9B BI9GHF5
9F5 8969ACG I6=75F@5 9B 9@ 7CBH9LHC 89 9GH5 9LD9F=9B7=5 J=J=85 M 89 @5G =BH9F
DF9H57=CB9G EI9 7CB:=;IF5B 9GH5 9LD9F=9B7=5 1 9@@C BC G]@C G=;B=:=75 7CBG=89F5F
EI9 G9 HF5H5 89 5@;C AQG EI9 89 IB5 7I9GH=]B 89 8=:9F9BH9G hH9CFY5Gi D5F5 9LD@=75F
@5G A=GA5G 9LD9F=9B7=5G G=BC H5A6=VB 7CADF9B89F @5 DCG=7=]B 8=:9F9B7=5@ 89 @5G
8=J9FG5G =BH9FDF9H57=CB9G 7]AC DI989B G9F J=J=85G h=B;9BI5A9BH9i C hF9:@9L=J5
A9BH9i 7]AC IB5 I CHF5 DI989 7CBJ9FH=FG9 9B @5 CD7=]B DCF CA=G=]B D5F5
AI7<5GD9FGCB5GCQA6=HCG
(5F5 9LDF9G5F@C 9B HVFA=BCG 8=:9F9BH9G @5 7F99B7=5 9B =CG BC 9G @C A=GAC 9B
9@ 

EI9 9B 9@

 &C A9 F9:=9FC 5@ <97<C 89 EI9 =B7@IGC 9@ 7F=GH=5B=GAC


CFHC8CLC <5 9LD9F=A9BH58C =ADCFH5BH9G 75A6=CG DCF 9>9AD@C 9@ hF97<5NC 89@
=B:=9FBCi BI9J5G 7CB79D7=CB9G 89 @5 9LD=57=]B IB F9GD97HC 89 DFCDCG=7=CB9G
=8VBH=75G 9B 7I5BHC 5@ 7F98C 9L=GH9 IB5 8=:9F9B7=5 =ADCFH5BH9 OGH5 5GCA5 H5B
DFCBHC 7CAC HCA5ACG 9B 7I9BH5 9@ <97<C 89 EI9 HC85G @5G 7F99B7=5G G9 GCGH=9B9B
89BHFC 89 IB 7CBH9LHC C A5F7C 89 @C EI9 G9 85 DCF G9BH58C EI9 ;9B9F5@A9BH9
D9FA5B979 HQ7=HC 9 =B7@IGC DI989 G9F BC F97CBC7=8C DCF 9@ 5;9BH9 DCFEI9 BIB75
:I9 :CFAI@58C GHC 9G @C EI9 @CG :=@]GC:CG =B:@I9B7=58CG DCF /=HH;9BGH9=B 9=89
;;9F C (C@5BM= 89BCA=B5FCB hHF5G:CB8Ci  CAC G9\5@5 /=HH;9BGH9=B  A=
=BJ9GH=;57=]B 89 @5G :CFA57=CB9G FC7CG5G 85 DCF G9BH58C EI9 9@ AIB8C BC
7CA9BN] <579 7=B7C A=BIHCG DI9G 9GHQ F9D@9HC 89 :]G=@9G M 9GHF=57=CB9G D9FC
BIB75 G9 A9 <56FY5 C7IFF=8C :CFAI@5F M F97CBC79F 9GC <5GH5 EI9 7=9FHCG :=@]GC:CG
89A9BH9G EI9 7565@;5B C6G9G=J5A9BH9 9B GIG 7565@@=HCG 89 65H5@@5 A9 @C
DFCDIG=9FCB
(9FC 575GC 5<CF5 @5 =BEI=9HI8 G9 <5M5 =BGH5@58C 89:=B=H=J5A9BH9 9B AY M M5 BC
DI98C G9;I=F 589@5BH9 =B;9BI5A9BH9 7CB A= =BJ9GH=;57=]B G=BC EI9 896C H9B9F 9B
7I9BH5 5EI9@@C 9B @C EI9 A9 <9 65G58C M H5@ J9N 7CBG=89F5F @5 DCG=6=@=858 89
<569FA9 9EI=JC758C GH9 EI=96F9 89 @5 =B;9BI=858 GI9@9 G9F 9@ 75A=BC D5F5 IB5
7CADF9BG=]B AQG D@9B5 5IBEI9 BC G95 VGH9 9@ 75GC )I=NQ IBC 9GHV CD9F5B8C 9B
IB A5F7C 9B 9@ EI9 HC8CG @CG ACJ=A=9BHCG G9 8=F=;=FY5B 5 IBC 89 @CG DIBHCG 75F
8=B5@9G C <57=5 5FF=65 C <57=5 565>C D9FC D5F5 8=F=;=F IB5 B5J9 9GD57=5@ =B7@IGC
D5F5 7CB796=F IB5 9G B979G5F=C H9B9F 9B 7I9BH5 7IQB F9@5H=JC M @=A=H58C 9G 9G9
A5F7C

  

$5 8=:9F9B7=5 89 @5 EI9 <9 <56@58C 5BH9G G9 F9:=9F9 5 HC8C 9@ A5F7C 7CBH9LHI5@


C 9@ HF5G:CB8C 9B 9@ EI9 7F99ACG C F9<IG5ACG 7F99F 9B =CG $CG A5F7CG 89 5M9F M
89 <CM G9 7CBG=89F5B h=B;9BICGi M hF9:@9L=JCGi F9GD97H=J5A9BH9 DCFEI9 9B 9@
`@H=AC G9 <5 D@5BH958C IB5 DF9;IBH5 EI9 9B 9@ DF=A9FC <56Y5 G=8C 89G75FH585
896=8C5EI9BCG9F97CBC7Y5@5:CFA589@ HF5G:CB8C
@ 75A6=C 89 HF5G:CB8C C A9>CF 8=7<C @5 FIDHIF5 7CB 9@ HF5G:CB8C 5BH9F=CF G9
J9 AQG 7@5F5A9BH9 7I5B8C BCG 7CB79BHF5ACG 9B 7=9FH5G 8=GH=B7=CB9G EI9 <579ACG
<CM DCF 9>9AD@C @5 8=GH=B7=]B 9BHF9 @C =BA5B9BH9 M @C HF5G79B89BH9 @C B5HIF5@ M
@C GC6F9B5HIF5@ ,C8CG 9BH=9B89B 9GH5G 8=GH=B7=CB9G H5BHC EI=9B9G 5:=FA5B 7CAC
EI=9B9G B=9;5B 9@ G9;IB8C HVFA=BC 89 7585 D5F GH5 9G7=G=]B 89 IB B=J9@ =B89
D9B8=9BH9 5IH]BCAC 9@ 89 @5 hB5HIF5@9N5i EI9 DI989 C BC =BH9F57HI5F 7CB 5@;C
HF5G79B89BH9 9G IB 9@9A9BHC 7@5J9 89 @5 H9CF=N57=]B AC89FB5 EI9 5 GI J9N 7CF
F9GDCB89 5 IB5 8=A9BG=]B 7CBGH=HIH=J5 89 @5 9LD9F=9B7=5 AC89FB5 7CAC 9GD9FC
ACGHF5F7CBA5MCF89H5@@9AQG589@5BH9
 9GH9 75A6=C 89 HF5G:CB8C 9B HC8C 9@ 7CBH9LHC 9B 9@ EI9 9LD9F=A9BH5ACG M
6IG75ACG @5 D@9B=HI8 A9 F9:=9FC 7I5B8C <56@C 89 @5 @@9;585 89 IB5 9F5 G97I@5F 9B
9@ H9F79F G9BH=8C G9\5@58C 5BH9F=CFA9BH9 f]AC D5G5ACG 89 IB 9GH58C 9B 9@ EI9
9B 9@ 7F=GH=5B=GAC @5G D9FGCB5G J=JY5B =B;9BI5A9BH9 89 57I9F8C 7CB IB5 =BH9F
DF9H57=]B H9YGH5 5 IB 9GH58C 9B 9@ EI9 HC8CG CG7=@5ACG 9BHF9 8CG DCG=7=CB9G 9B 9@
EI9 @5 =BH9FDF9H57=]B 89 7585 IBC G9 A5B=:=9GH5 7CAC H5@ M 9B 9@ EI9 AQG 5`B @5
:5@H5 89 :9 G9 <5 7CBJ9FH=8C D5F5 AI7<CG 9B @5 DF=B7=D5@ CD7=]B DCF CA=G=]B OGH5
9G @5 HF5BG:CFA57=]B EI9 EI=9FC 89G7F=6=F M EI=NQ H5A6=VB AIM D5F7=5@A9BH9
9LD@=75F9B@CGG=;I=9BH9G75DYHI@CG
&C G9FQ IB5 H5F95 :Q7=@ D9FC G]@C F97CBC7=9B8C EI9 9GH9 75A6=C G9 85 9B @5
9LD9F=9B7=5 J=J=85 DC89ACG 7CA9BN5F 5 D@5BH95F @5G DF9;IBH5G 7CFF97H5G M 9J=H5F
7I5@EI=9F H=DC 89 =B;9BI=858 C 6=9B @5 :5@H5 89 :9 9G G]@C 9@ 89GACFCB5A=9BHC 89
7I5@EI=9F G9BG57=]B 89 D@9B=HI8 C 6=9B GI HF5=7=]B @C EI9 @CG H9YGH5G 5 J979G G9
G=9BH9B H9BH58CG 89 D9BG5F 89 @CG 5H9YGH5G C 9G5 7F99B7=5 9G 5D9B5G IB 7CB>IBHC
89 H9CFY5G EI9 =BH9BH5B 89G9BHF5\5F @5G 9LD9F=9B7=5G EI9 HC8CG H9B9ACG M 7IM5
J9F8589F5 B5HIF5@9N5 DI989 G9F 7CADF9B8=85 9B :CFA5 DIF5A9BH9 =BA5B9BH9 @C
EI9@CG5H9YGH5G5J979GG9G=9BH9BH9BH58CG89D9BG5F89@CGH9YGH5G
9 <97<C 9G B979G5F=C 7CADF9B89F @5G 8=:9F9B7=5G 9BHF9 9GH5G CD7=CB9G BC
G]@C 9B HVFA=BCG 89 7F98CG G=BC H5A6=VB 9B HVFA=BCG 89 8=:9F9B7=5G 89 9LD9F=9B
7=5 M G9BG=6=@=858 1 9B 9GH9 `@H=AC B=J9@ 8969ACG H9B9F 9B 7I9BH5 8CG 8=:9F9B7=5G
=ADCFH5BH9G DF=A9FC EI9 9L=GH9 IB 75A6=C A5G=JC 9B HC8C 9@ HF5G:CB8C 89 :9 C

  

:5@H5 89 :9 9G 897=F 9@ 565B8CBC 89@ 5BH9F=CF A5F7C h=B;9BICi M 9@ GIF;=A=9BHC


89 BI9GHFC A5F7C hF9:@9L=JCi 1 G9;IB8C EI9 9G DF97=GC G9F 7CBG7=9BH9G 89 7]AC
@CG 7F9M9BH9G M @CG BC 7F9M9BH9G DI989B 9LD9F=A9BH5F GI AIB8C 89 AC8C AIM
8=:9F9BH9 $5 G9BG57=]B 89 EI9 @5 D@9B=HI8 8969 <5@@5FG9 9B 5@;C EI9 9GHQ AQG 5@@Q
89 BCGCHFCG DI989 =FFIAD=F 9B BCGCHFCG 7CAC IB <97<C 89 9LD9F=9B7=5 7CAC 9B
9@ 75GC 89 989 F=::=H<G 7=H58C 5BH9F=CFA9BH9 C 9B 9@ ACA9BHC 89 7CBJ9FG=]B
EI9 @5I89@ J=J=] 9B &^HF9 5A9 9B @5G .YGD9F5G GH5 9LD9F=9B7=5 DI989
9BHCB79G 9LDF9G5FG9 F57=CB5@=N5FG9 DI989 ;9B9F5F 7F99B7=5G D5FH=7I@5F9G GH9
DFC79GC DI989 @@9J5F H=9ADC M @5 7F99B7=5 9B 7I9GH=]B DI989 75A6=5F 5 @C @5F;C 89
@CG 5\CG 5IBEI9 @5 9LD9F=9B7=5 D9FA5B9N75 9B @5 A9ACF=5 7CAC IB ACA9BHC
D5F58=;AQH=7C GHC 9G @C EI9 @9 GI798=] 5 989 EI=9B 89GDIVG 89 5@;IBCG 5\CG
@@9;] 5 <579F IB5 @97HIF5 H9YGH5 89 9G9 ACA9BHC 7FI7=5@ M 9B 9@ 75GC 89 @5I89@
DI989 C6G9FJ5FG9 IB h89G:5G9i G=A=@5F  @ 9GH58C 89 G97I@5F=858 9B 9@ H9F79F
G9BH=8C DCF @C H5BHC 8969 G9F 89G7F=HC 9B HVFA=BCG 89 @5 DCG=6=@=858 C @5 =ADCG=6
=@=858897=9FHCGH=DCG899LD9F=9B7=59BBI9GHF59F5

=
5GH5 5<CF5 A9 <9 F9:9F=8C 5@ HVFA=BC hG97I@5Fi C hG97I@5F=858i BH9G 89
9AD9N5F 5 D9BG5F 9B V@ D5F979 IB HVFA=BC C6J=C D9FC H5B DFCBHC 7CAC @C 9L5A=
B5ACG GIF;9B HC8C H=DC 89 DFC6@9A5G ,F5HV 89 7CB>IF5F 5@;IBCG 89 9@@CG 8=GH=B
;I=9B8C HF9G G9BH=8CG 9B @CG EI9 IGC 9@ HVFA=BC @C 7I5@ 9B AC8C 5@;IBC F9GI9@J9
HC8CG @CG DFC6@9A5G D9FC DI989 65GH5F D5F5 D9FA=H=F 5@;`B DFC;F9GC 9B A=
=B85;57=]B
(9FC @5G HF9G :CFA5G 89 G97I@5F=858 <579B F9:9F9B7=5 5 @5 hF9@=;=]Bi 7CAC
5EI9@@C EI9 G9 F9H=F5 89@ 9GD57=C D`6@=7C   7CAC IB H=DC 89 7F99B7=5 M DFQ7H=75
EI9 DI989 9GH5F C BC 9B F9HFC79GC   M 7CAC 7=9FHC H=DC 89 7F99B7=5 C 7CADFCA
=GC 7IMC 9GH58C 9B 9GH5 9F5 9GHQ 65>C 9L5A9B   (9FC fEIV 9G @5 hF9@=;=]Bi
@QG=75A9BH9 9@@5 G9 F9G=GH9 5 IB5 89:=B=7=]B 9B ;F5B A98=85 DCFEI9 @CG :9B]
A9BCG EI9 BCG J9ACG H9BH58CG 89 75@=:=75F 7CAC F9@=;=CGCG 9B @5 J=85 <IA5B5 GCB
9LHF9A585A9BH9 J5F=58CG I5B8C HF5H5ACG 89 D9BG5F EIV <5M 9B 7CA`B 9BHF9 @5
J=85 89 @5G GC7=98589G 5F75=75G 9B @5G EI9 h@5 F9@=;=]B 9GHQ 9B HC85G D5FH9Gi M 9@
7CB>IBHC 7@5F5A9BH9 89@=A=H58C 89 7F99B7=5G DFQ7H=75G 9 =BGH=HI7=CB9G EI9 G9

  

I6=75B 65>C 9G9 HYHI@C 9B BI9GHF5 GC7=9858 BCG 9B:F9BH5ACG 5 IB5 H5F95 5F8I5
EI=NQ=BGID9F56@9
(9FC G= GCACG DFI89BH9G C H5@ J9N 7C65F89G M D9BG5ACG EI9 9GH5ACG
HF5H5B8C 89 7CADF9B89F IB 7CB>IBHC 89 :CFA5G M 75A6=CG EI9 GIF;=9FCB 9B IB5
7=J=@=N57=]B 9B D5FH=7I@5F @5 89@ '77=89BH9 AC89FBC lC 9B IB5 9B75FB57=]B
5BH9F=CF @5 7F=GH=5B858 @5H=B5l J9ACG 7CB 5@=J=C EI9 BC B979G=H5ACG :CF>5F IB5
89:=B=7=]B EI9 565FEI9 HC8C @C hF9@=;=CGCi 9B HC85G @5G GC7=98589G <IA5B5G 89
HC85G @5G VDC75G @ 75A6=C EI9 @9G =ADCFH] 5 @5G D9FGCB5G 89 BI9GHF5 7=J=@=N57=]B
89@ H@QBH=7C &CFH9 I hC77=89BH5@i M EI9 5`B @9G =ADCFH5 <CM 9B 7I5BHC 5@ 9GH5H
IHC 89 @5 F9@=;=]B 9B @5G HF9G 8=A9BG=CB9G 89 G97I@5F=858 EI9 =89BH=:=EIV 9G 9@ EI9
M5 <9 7CA9BN58C 5 9LD@CF5F 9B IB5 89 GIG :579H5G 79BHF5@9G <9ACG D5G58C 89 IB
AIB8C 9B 9@ EI9 G9 9BH9B8Y5 EI9 9@ @I;5F 89 @5 D@9B=HI8 9GH565 G=AD@9A9BH9 :I9F5
C hAQG 5@@Qi 89 @5 J=85 <IA5B5 5 IB5 9F5 7CB:@=7H=J5 9B @5 EI9 9GH5 =BH9FDF9H57=]B
9G DI9GH5 9B H9@5 89 >I=7=C DCF CHF5G EI9 @5 I6=75B 9B IB 5AD@=C 9GD97HFC 89
:CFA5G h89BHFCi 89 @5 J=85 <IA5B5 B HCFBC 5 9GH9 DIBHC <5B ;=F58C AI7<5G 89
@5G @I7<5G =ADCFH5BH9G AQG F97=9BH9G 5 8=:9F9B7=5 89 @C EI9 C7IFFY5 9B CHF5G VDC
75G 9B @5 EI9 G9 @=6F565B @I7<5G 5 AI9FH9 DCF 8=:9F9BH9G @97HIF5G 89 @5 =BH9FDF9H5
7=]B7F=GH=5B5
B CHF5G D5@56F5G IB5 @97HIF5 89 @5 hF9@=;=]Bi 9B HVFA=BCG 89 @5 8=GH=B7=]B
HF5G79B89BH9 =BA5B9BH9 G9FJ=FQ 5 BI9GHFCG :=B9G 5EIY OGH5 9G @5 J9BH5>5 89@ 9>9F
7=7=C DFI89BH9 C 7C65F89 EI9 9GHCM DFCDCB=9B8C 9 B=B;IB5 A5B9F5 9G DCG=6@9
89:=B=F @5 F9@=;=]B 9B ;9B9F5@ 9B HVFA=BCG 89 9GH5 8=GH=B7=]B !B7@IGC DC8FY5 5:=FA
5FG9 EI9 BI9GHF5 D5FH=7I@5F 8=GH=B7=]B =B:@9L=6@9 9G 5@;C EI9 BCGCHFCG
C77=89BH5@9G 7F=GH=5BCG @5H=BCG <9ACG <97<C DCF BI9GHF5 7I9BH5 G95 D5F5
BI9GHF5 ;@CF=5 C D5F5 BI9GHF5 F=8=7I@=N57=]B =BH9@97HI5@ IB DC7C 89 5A65G 7CAC
GCGH9B8FV AQG 589@5BH9 &C G9 @9 DC8FY5 9B8CG5F 9GHC 5 (@5H]B DCF 9>9AD@C BC
DCFEI9 BC DI985B 8=GH=B;I=FG9 @5G !895G 89 @5G 7CG5G 9B 9@ :@I=F EI9 @5G h7CD=5i
G=BC DF97=G5A9BH9 DCFEI9 9GH5G F95@=8589G 75A6=5BH9G G]@C DI989B G9F 9BH9B8=
85G 5 HF5JVG 89 @5G !895G $5 ;F5B =BJ9B7=]B 89 '77=89BH9 :I9 @5 89 IB CF89B
=BA5B9BH9 5 @5 &5HIF5@9N5 7IMC :IB7=CB5A=9BHC DI8C G9F 9BH9B8=8C M 9LD@=758C
89 A5B9F5 G=GH9AQH=75 9B GIG DFCD=CG HVFA=BCG 89>5B8C 56=9FH5 @5 DF9;IBH5 89 G=
9GH9 CF89B HCH5@ H9BY5 IB5 G=;B=:=757=]B AQG DFC:IB85 M 89 G9F 5GY G= 896Y5ACG
GIDCB9F IB F958CF HF5G79B89BH9 AQG 5@@Q 89 V@ GH5 BC7=]B 89 @C h=BA5B9BH9i
=AD@=7565 B9;5F lC 5@ A9BCG 5=G@5F M DFC6@9A5H=N5Fl 7I5@EI=9F :CFA5 89 =BH9F
D9B9HF57=]B 9BHF9 @5G 7CG5G 89 @5 &5HIF5@9N5 DCF IB @58C M h@C GC6F9B5HIF5@i DCF

  

CHFC M5 G95 EI9 9GHC G9 F9:=F=9G9 5 IB =CG HF5G79B89BH9 5 =CG9G C 9GDYF=HIG 5


:I9FN5GAQ;=75GC5@CEI9:I9F9 
9 A5B9F5 H5@ EI9 89:=B=F @5 F9@=;=]B 9B HVFA=BCG 89 @5 8=GH=B7=]B =BA5B9BH9
HF5G79B89BH9 9G IB 9>9F7=7=C <97<C 5 @5 A98=85 89 BI9GHF5 7I@HIF5 (I989 7CBG=8
9F5FG9 EI9 9@@C 9G 5@;C 9GHF97<C =B79GHICGC 7CAC A=F5FG9 9@ CA6@=;C D9FC G9;`B
A= D5F979F 9G IB 9>9F7=7=C =BH9@=;9BH9 M5 EI9 9GH5ACG HF5H5B8C 89 7CADF9B89F @CG
75A6=CG EI9 <5B H9B=8C @I;5F 9B IB5 7I@HIF5 D5F5 @5 7I5@ 9GH5 8=GH=B7=]B G9 <5
JI9@HC:IB857=CB5@
(CF 7CBG=;I=9BH9 9B @I;5F 89 DF9;IBH5FBCG G= @5 :I9BH9 89 @5 D@9B=HI8 9G 7CB
G=89F585 J=J=85 7CAC 5@;C =BH9FBC C 9LH9FBC 7CAC <=7=ACG 5BH9F=CFA9BH9
DC8FY5ACG DF9;IBH5FBCG G= @5G D9FGCB5G F97CBC79B 5@;C HF5G79B89BH9 C EI9 9GHV
AQG 5@@Q 89 GIG J=85G GY 9G 7CAC ;9B9F5@A9BH9 G9 D@5BH95 @5 7I9GH=]B M 5GY 9G
7CAC EI=G=9F5 D@5BH95F@5 D5F5 @C EI9 G=;I9 .5F=CG 75DYHI@CG AQG 589@5BH9 7I5B8C
@@9;I9ACG 5 9L5A=B5F @5G H9CFY5G AC89FB5G 89 @5 G97I@5F=N57=]B C:F979FV IB5
9LD@=757=]B 5@;C AQG 7CAD@9H5 89 @C EI9 EI=9FC 897=F 7CB 9GH5 8=GH=B7=]B +CM D@9
B5A9BH9 7CBG7=9BH9 89 EI9 9@ HVFA=BC hHF5G79B89BH9i 9G AIM 9G7IFF=8=NC 9B
D5FH9 DCFEI9 7CAC 5756C 89 GI;9F=F 9G5G 8=GH=B7=CB9G <5B G=8C 7CBGHFI=85G C
F989:=B=85G 9B 9@ DFC79GC A=GAC 89 @5 AC89FB=858 M @5 G97I@5F=N57=]B (9FC 7F9C
EI95D9G5F89GIJ5;I9858DI989G9FJ=F5BI9GHFCG:=B9G
(9FC DF97=G5A9BH9 DCF @5G F5NCB9G EI9 9LD@CFV 5BH9G EI=9FC 7CAD@9A9BH5F @5
9LD@=757=]B IGI5@ EI9 7CB7=69 @5 hF9@=;=]Bi 9B HVFA=BCG 89 @5 7F99B7=5 9B @C HF5G
79B89BH9 7CB IB5 9LD@=757=]B AQG 79BHF585 9B 9@ G9BH=8C EI9 H9B9ACG 89 BI9GHFC
7CBH9LHCDFQ7H=7C 95EIYIB5:CFA58989G9BHF5\5F9GHC
585 D9FGCB5 M 7585 GC7=9858 H=9B9B IB5 C AQG 7CB79D7=CB9G 89 @C EI9 9G @5
6=9B5J9BHIF5BN5 <IA5B5 C J=J9B 89 57I9F8C 7CB 9@@5G fEIV 9G IB5 J=85 F95@=N
585 fEIV <579 EI9 J5@;5 @5 D9B5 J=J=F @5 J=85 fEIV 9G @C EI9 AQG 58A=F5ACG 89
@5G D9FGCB5G &C DC89ACG 9J=H5F D@5BH95FBCG VGH5G M CHF5G DF9;IBH5G 89 9GH9 H=DC
8IF5BH9 BI9GHF5 J=85 1 BI9GHFCG 9G:I9FNCG DCF F9GDCB89F@5G 89:=B9B @5 C @5G 7CB
79D7=CB9G 89 57I9F8C 7CB @5G 7I5@9G HF5H5ACG 89 J=J=F C 9BHF9 @5G 7I5@9G BCG
8965H=ACG B CHFC B=J9@ 9GH5G 7CB79D7=CB9G 9GHQB 7C8=:=7585G 5 J979G 9B H9CFY5G
:=@CG]:=75G 5 J979G 9B 7]8=;CG ACF5@9G 5 J979G 9B DFQ7H=75G M 89JC7=CB9G F9@=;=C
G5G OGH5G M @5G 8=J9FG5G DFQ7H=75G A5@ :CFAI@585G 9B @5G EI9 D5FH=7=D5B @5G D9FGC
B5G EI9 BCG FC895B 7CBGH=HIM9B @CG F97IFGCG EI9 BI9GHF5 GC7=9858 BCG C:F979 5
7585IBC89BCGCHFCG7I5B8CHF5H5ACG8985FIB58=F977=]B5BI9GHF5J=85


 

'HF5 :CFA5 89 5DFCL=A5FBCG 5 @5 7I9GH=]B D@5BH9585 5BH9F=CFA9BH9 9B HVFA=


BCG 89 =BH9F=CF 9LH9F=CF 9G DF9;IBH5FBCG f@5 A9>CF J=85 @5 AQG D@9B5 =AD@=75
EI9 6IGEI9ACG F97CBCN75ACG C BCG DCB;5ACG 5@ G9FJ=7=C 89 IB 6=9B EI9 9GHQ
AQG 5@@Q EI9 G95 =B89D9B8=9BH9 89 @5 6=9B5J9BHIF5BN5 <IA5B5 B 7IMC 75GC @5
AQL=A5 6=9B5J9BHIF5BN5 <IA5B5 @5 AQG F95@ 5IHVBH=75 C 5897I585 DC8FY5
=AD@=75F EI9 89BHFC 89 BI9GHFC 9GD97HFC 89 C6>9H=JCG :=B5@9G H5A6=VB
=B7@IM5ACG 5@;C 8=:9F9BH9 89 @5 6=9B5J9BHIF5BN5 <IA5B5 =;C hC6>9H=JCG
:=B5@9Gi DCFEI9 =B7@IGC 9@ <IA5B=GAC AQG 5IHCGI:=7=9BH9 8969 =BH9F9G5FG9 DCF 9@
9GH58C 89 5@;IB5G 7CG5G BC <IA5B5G 89 A5B9F5 =BGHFIA9BH5@ DCF 9>9AD@C DCF 9@
9GH58C89@A98=C5A6=9BH9$57I9GH=]B9GG=9@@5GH5A6=VB=ADCFH5B5@:=B5@
G 7@5FC EI9 9B @5 HF58=7=]B 89 @5 F9@=;=]B >I89C7F=GH=5B5 @5 F9GDI9GH5 5 9GH5
DF9;IBH5 9G 5:=FA5H=J5 A5F J9B9F5F 5 =CG 9G 9@ :=B `@H=AC (CF GIDI9GHC 9B
9GH5 HF58=7=]B G9 7CBG=89F5 EI9 =CG 89G95 @5 6=9B5J9BHIF5BN5 <IA5B5 D9FC BC G9
7CBG=89F5 EI9 @5 89JC7=]B 5 =CG 89D9B85 89 9@@C $5 :F5G9 h Q;5G9 HI JC@IBH58i
BC 9G 9EI=J5@9BH9 5 h)I9 @CG <CA6F9G G95B 6=9B5J9BHIF58CGi 5IBEI9 G569ACG
EI9=CG89G95@56=9B5J9BHIF5BN5<IA5B5
OGH9 9G IB 75GC AIM :5A=@=5F D5F5 BCGCHFCG D9FC <5M CHF5G :CFA5G 9B @5G EI9
DC89ACG =F AQG 5@@Q 89 @5 6=9B5J9BHIF5BN5 <IA5B5 @ 6I8=GAC 9G IB 9>9AD@C
9 5@;IB5 A5B9F5 DC8FY5ACG =BH9FDF9H5F EI9 9@ A9BG5>9 89@ I85 BCG 8=79 7]AC
5@75BN5F @5 :9@=7=858 9G 897=F 7]AC 9J=H5F 9@ GI:F=A=9BHC M 5@75BN5F @5 8=7<5 
(9FC 9G 7@5FC EI9 @5 7CB79D7=]B 89 @5G 7CB8=7=CB9G 89 @5 8=7<5 9G H5B
hF9J=G=CB=GH5i EI9 9EI=J5@9 5 565B8CB5F @C EI9 BCFA5@A9BH9 9BH9B89ACG DCF
6=9B5J9BHIF5BN5 <IA5B5 EIY 9@ 565B8CBC DI989 G9F 7CBG=89F58C 9B HVFA=BCG
89 IB 75A6=C F58=75@ 89 =89BH=858 $5G 7CB79D7=CB9G BCFA5@9G 89 @5 6=9B5J9BHIF
5BN5 GIDCB9B IB MC 7CBH=BIC GI 69B9:=7=5F=C C 9B 9@ 75GC 89 GI :F575GC 9@ GI:F=
9BH9 $5 8C7HF=B5 6I8=GH5 89@ 0=0CC0 5DIBH5 5 @@9J5FBCG AQG 5@@Q 89 9GH5 =@IG=]B @
75A=BC <57=5 9@ &=FJ5B5 =AD@=75 F9BIB7=5F 5 HC85G @5G :CFA5G 89 6=9B5J9BHIF5BN5
<IA5B5C5@A9BCG=FAQG5@@Q899@@5G
B 9@ 6I8=GAC M 9B 9@ 7F=GH=5B=GAC 5 D9G5F 89 @5G ;F5B89G 8=:9F9B7=5G EI9 <5M
9B @5 8C7HF=B5 89 IBC M CHFC <5M 5@;C G=A=@5F 5 G569F EI9 9@ 7F9M9BH9 C 89JCHC 9G
@@5A58C 5 <579F IB5 DFC:IB85 FIDHIF5 =BH9FB5 7CB @CG C6>9H=JCG 89 @5 6=9B5J9B
HIF5BN5 9G 897=F 9G @@5A58C 5 89GDF9B89FG9 89 GI DFCD=5 6=9B5J9BHIF5BN5 <5GH5
9@ DIBHC 89 @5 9LH=B7=]B 89@ MC 9B IB 75GC C 89 @5 F9BIB7=5 5 @5 F95@=N57=]B
<IA5B5 D5F5 G9FJ=F 5 =CG 9B 9@ CHFC $CG D5HFCB9G F9GD97H=JCG GCB 7@5F5A9BH9

  

J=G=6@9G 9B @5G :=;IF5G 9>9AD@5F9G @ I85 5@75BN5 @5 +56=8IFY5 F=GHC 579DH5 IB5
AI9FH989;F585BH9D5F57IAD@=F@5JC@IBH5889GID58F9
(9FC fBC DC89ACG G=AD@9A9BH9 G9;I=F @5 GI;9F9B7=5 89 AQG 5FF=65 M F9=BH9FD
F9H5F EI9 @5 hJ9F8589F5i 6=9B5J9BHIF5BN5 =AD@=75 @5 F9BIB7=5 7CAC D5F979 <579F
9@ 9GHC=7=GAC DCF 9>9AD@C GHC BC :IB7=CB5 9B 9@ 75GC 89@ 7F=GH=5B=GAC M
GCGD97<C EI9 H5ADC7C 9B 9@ 89@ 6I8=GAC B 9@ 75GC 89@ 7F=GH=5B=GAC 9@ DIBHC 89
F9BIB7=5 A=GAC F9EI=9F9 EI9 @5 6=9B5J9BHIF5BN5 CF8=B5F=5 5 @5 EI9 G9 <5 F9BIB
7=58C G95 7CB:=FA585 7CAC JQ@=85 +]@C G= J=J=F @5 J=85 7CAD@9H5 9G IB 6=9B 9@
<97<C 89 EI9 F=GHC G9 9BHF9;5G9 5 @5 AI9FH9 DI989 H9B9F 9@ G=;B=:=758C EI9 H=9B9
B @C 7I5@ 9G 56GC@IH5A9BH9 8=:9F9BH9 89 @5 AI9FH9 89 +]7F5H9G EI=9B @5 DF9G9BH5
7CAC 9@ 57HC 89 89>5F IB 9GH58C D5F5 D5G5F 5 CHFC A9>CF EIY J9ACG 9@ 56=GAC
=BG5@J56@9 EI9 9L=GH9 9BHF9 9@ 7F=GH=5B=GAC M @5 :=@CGC:Y5 ;F=9;5 CA`BA9BH9 =CG
89G95 @5 6=9B5J9BHIF5BN5 <IA5B5 M ;F5B D5FH9 89 @C EI9 G9 HF5BGA=H9 9B @CG
9J5B;9@=CG 9G EI9 F=GHC <579 EI9 9GHC G95 DCG=6@9 D5F5 @5G D9FGCB5G 7IM5G 5:@=7
7=CB9G 7IF5 @ @@5A5A=9BHC 5 @5 F9BIB7=5 BC B=9;5 9@ J5@CF 89 @5 6=9B5J9BHIF5BN5
AQG 6=9B 9G IB5 @@5A585 5 79BHF5F HC8C 9B =CG 5IB G= 9@@C 9G 5@ 7CGHC 89 DF=J5FG9
89 9G9 6=9B =BGIGH=HI=6@9 M 9@ :FIHC 89 9GH5 DF=J57=]B 9G EI9 9B IB B=J9@ G9 7CB
J=9FH9 9B @5 :I9BH9 89 @5 6=9B5J9BHIF5BN5 89 CHFCG M 9B CHFC B=J9@ 9B IB5 7C@
56CF57=]B 7CB @5 F9GH=HI7=]B 89 IB5 6=9B5J9BHIF5BN5 AQG D@9B5 DCF D5FH9 89 =CG
G IB5 :CFA5 89 7IF5F @5G <9F=85G M hF9D5F5F 9@ AIB8Ci HCAC 5EIY @5 :F5G9
<96F95 C8::D=>;0<
GHC G=;B=:=75 EI9 @5 6=9B5J9BHIF5BN5 M @5 F9BIB7=5 BC DI989B :IB8=FG9 D5F5
7CB:CFA5F IB C6>9H=JC `B=7C H=F5B8C DCF @5 6CF85 DCF 5GY 897=F @CG 6=9B9G 5 @CG
EI9 G9 <5 F9BIB7=58C 7CAC G= :I9F5B IB @5GHF9 =BB979G5F=C 9B 9@ J=5>9 89 @5 J=85 5
@5 A5B9F5 89@ 9GHC=7=GAC B 9@ 7F=GH=5B=GAC GI6G=GH9 IB5 H9BG=]B :IB85A9BH5@
$5 6=9B5J9BHIF5BN5 9G 6I9B5 D9FC D9FG9;I=F@5 BC 9G BI9GHFC C6>9H=JC `@H=AC
(9FC =B7@IGC 7I5B8C F9BIB7=5ACG 5 9@@5 @5 F95:=FA5ACG DCFEI9 G9;I=ACG @5 JC@
IBH58 89 =CG 5@ 7CBGH=HI=FBCG 9B IB 75B5@ 89 9@@5 D5F5 CHFCG M 9B `@H=A5 =BGH5B7=5
D5F5HC8CG
fB 9@ 6I8=GAC DI989 C6G9FJ5FG9 IB5 F9@57=]B D5F58]>=75 G=A=@5F &C 9GHCM
G9;IFC D9FC 9B 9@ 6I8=GAC H5A6=VB 9L=GH9 @5 BC7=]B 89 EI9 9@ EI9 F9BIB7=5 9G IB5
:I9BH9 89 7CAD5G=]B D5F5 EI=9B9G GI:F9B L=GH9 IB5 5B5@C;Y5 9BHF9 :0AD=0 M
Q;5D9 1 D5F5@9@5A9BH9 5@ 7F=GH=5B=GAC 9B @5 7=J=@=N57=]B 6I8=GH5 G9 89G5FFC@@] 5
@C @5F;C 89 @CG G=;@CG IB5 8=GH=B7=]B 89 JC757=]B 9BHF9 F9BIB7=5BH9G F58=75@9G M
5EIV@@CG EI9 7CBH=BI565B J=J=9B8C 89BHFC 89 @5G :CFA5G 89 J=85 EI9 5DIBH565B 5

  

@5 6=9B5J9BHIF5BN5 CF8=B5F=5 A=9BHF5G HF5H565B 89 57IAI@5F hAVF=HCGi D5F5 IB5


J=85 :IHIF5 9G89 @I9;C 9GH5 8=GH=B7=]B :I9 h897CBGHFI=85i F58=75@A9BH9 9B @5
*9:CFA5 DFCH9GH5BH9 7CB F9GI@H58CG :5HY8=7CG D5F5 @5 <=GHCF=5 EI9 9GH5ACG B5F
F5B8C 5EIY 89 @CG EI9 HC8CG 89 5@;IB5 A5B9F5 GCACG 7CBG7=9BH9G 5IBEI9 @5
H5F95 89 HF5N5F GIG 7CB9L=CB9G 7CB 9@ G97I@5F=GAC AC89FBC 5`B 9GHQ @9>CG 89
<569F7CB7@I=8C
<CF5 6=9B 9GH56@979F 9GH5 8=GH=B7=]B 9BHF9 6=9B5J9BHIF5BN5 <IA5B5 M C6>9H
=JCG EI9 @5 HF5G7=9B89B H=9B9 IB G9BH=8C )I=G=9F5 G9\5@5F EI9 @5 @@9;585 89 @5 G97
I@5F=858 AC89FB5 9B 7I5@EI=9F5 89 GIG G9BH=8CG <5 G=8C 7CB7CA=H5BH9 7CB 9@
GIF;=A=9BHC 89 IB5 GC7=9858 9B @5 EI9 DCF DF=A9F5 J9N 9B @5 <=GHCF=5 IB <IA5B
=GAC DIF5A9BH9 5IHCGI:=7=9BH9 @@9;] 5 G9F IB5 CD7=]B 8=GDCB=6@9 D5F5 HC8CG CB
9GHC A9 F9:=9FC 5 IB <IA5B=GAC EI9 BC 579DH5 C6>9H=JCG :=B5@9G AQG 5@@Q 89 @5
6=9B5J9BHIF5BN5 <IA5B5 B= :=89@=858 5 B585 EI9 9GHV AQG 5@@Q 89 9GH5 6=9B5J9B
HIF5BN5GHCBCC7IFF=]7CBB=B;IB5GC7=9858DF9J=5
)I9 9GH9 <IA5B=GAC <5M5 GIF;=8C 5 D5FH=F 89 IB5 HF58=7=]B F9@=;=CG5 9B @5 EI9
@5 6=9B5J9BHIF5BN5 M 9@ C6>9H=JC HF5G79B89BH9 G9 8=GH=B;IY5B D9FC 9GH565B
D5F58]>=75A9BH9 F9@57=CB58CG M 9GHC HIJC 7=9FH5 =ADCFH5B7=5 D5F5 BI9GHF5 <=G
HCF=5 BC G=;B=:=75 EI9 HC85G @5G GC7=98589G DF9J=5G DFCM97H5F5B IB5 8I5@=858 89
9GH9 H=DC 7CAC G9\5@V F9GD97HC 89@ 6I8=GAC M 9@ 7F=GH=5B=GAC ,5A6=VB <I6C D9F
GD97H=J5G 7CAC D5F979 G9F @5 89@ H5CYGAC 9B @5G EI9 @5 6=9B5J9BHIF5BN5 G9 7CB79
6Y5 9B :CFA5 IB=H5F=5 =B7@IM9B8C @5 58CF57=]B 5 @C GID9F=CF (9FC 9B 9GHCG 75GCG
9G5 58CF57=]B 5IBEI9 9G9B7=5@ D5F5 @5 6=9B5J9BHIF5BN5 BC DC8Y5 G9F F95@=N585
7CB IB 9GDYF=HI DIF5A9BH9 =BGHFIA9BH5@ G 897=F BC DC8Y5 G9F 03>A028X= G= G9 @5
9BH9B8Y5899G5A5B9F5
B CHF5G D5@56F5G @5 7CB79D7=]B ;9B9F5@ 89 @5 DCG=7=]B 89@ <CA6F9 5BH9 @5
%C89FB=858 BCG I6=7] 9B IB CF89B 9B 9@ EI9 BC C7IDQ65ACG @CG DF=A9FCG DI9G
HCG $CG G9F9G GID9F=CF9G 7CAC =CG C @CG 9GDYF=HIG C IB H=DC GID9F=CF 89 G9F9G
7CAC @5G !895G C @5 7CGA]DC@=G 89 @CG =CG9G M @CG <IA5BCG 9L=;Y5B M A9F97Y5B
BI9GHF5 J9B9F57=]B F9J9F9B7=5 89JC7=]B C 5ACF B 5@;IBCG 75GCG G9 7CBG=8
9F565 EI9 9B ;9B9F5@ 9GH5 F9J9F9B7=5 C 89JC7=]B 9F5 =B<9F9BH9 5 @5 6=9B5J9BHIF
5BN5 <IA5B5 9F5 IB5 D5FH9 DFCD=5 89@ 6=9B <IA5BC @ H5CYGAC 9G IB 9>9AD@C 5@
=;I5@ EI9 @5G :=@CGC:Y5G 5BH=;I5G H5@9G 7CAC 9@ D@5HCB=GAC M 9@ 9GHC=7=GAC B CHFCG
75GCG G9 9L=;Y5 89JC7=]B 5IBEI9 :I9G9 5 BI9GHF5G 9LD9BG5G C 5IBEI9 7CB8I>9G9 5
BI9GHFC 6=9B G]@C G= ;5BQ65ACG 9@ :5JCF 89 IB =CG (9FC 5IB 5EIY @5 J9B9F57=]B
9L=;=85 9F5 F95@ GHCG G9F9G ;C69FB565B BI9GHFC H9ACF &C <56Y5 DCG=6=@=858 89

  

HF5H5F@CG 7CAC BCGCHFCG HF5H5ACG 5 @5G :I9FN5G 89 @5 B5HIF5@9N5 D5F5 C6H9B9F


9B9F;Y5
B 9GH9 75GC DC8FY5ACG <56@5F 89 IB <IA5B=GAC D9FC BC 89 IB <IA5B=GAC
5IHCGI:=7=9BH9 C 9L7@IG=JC EI9 9G 9@ EI9 9B 75A6=C 9B7CBHF5ACG 9B 9@ 7CF5N]B
89@5G97I@5F=858AC89FB5
(I989 D5F979F EI9 9GH5 H9G=G 5@ I6=75F 5@ <IA5B=GAC 9L7@IG=JC `B=75A9BH9
89BHFC 89 @5 %C89FB=858 9G 89A5G=58C G9B7=@@5 M DC7C 9L79D7=CB5@ D5F5 G9F J9F
8589F5 1 9B J9F858 <5M 9L79D7=CB9G B A= CD=B=]B 9@ 9D=7IF9YGAC 5BH=;IC 9F5
IB <IA5B=GAC 5IHCGI:=7=9BH9 8A=HY5 =CG9G D9FC @9G B9;565 HC85 F9@9J5B7=5 9B
@5 J=85 <IA5B5 $C EI9 MC GCGH9B;C 5EIY 9G EI9 IB5 ;C@CB8F=B5 BC <579 IB J9F
5BC %9 F9:=9FC 5 IB5 9F5 9B @5 EI9 9@ <IA5B=GAC 5IHCGI:=7=9BH9 G9 7CBJ=9FH9 9B
IB5 CD7=]B 8=GDCB=6@9 D5F5 HC8CG 5@;C EI9 BIB75 C7IFF=] 9B 9@ AIB8C 5BH=;IC
9B 9@ EI9 G]@C @C DFC:9G565 IB5 D9EI9\5 A=BCFY5 89 @5 9@=H9 EI9 9B GY A=GA5 M5
9F5IB5A=BCFY5
,5ADC7C EI=9FC 5:=FA5F EI9 @5 G97I@5F=858 AC89FB5 89 5@;IB5 A5B9F5 7C=B
7=85 7CB 9@ <IA5B=GAC 9L7@IG=JC BHF9 CHF5G 7CG5G 8585 @5 :CFA5 9B EI9 @5
89:=BC @5 G97I@5F=858 9G IB 9GH58C 9B 9@ EI9 H=9B9B @I;5F BI9GHF5 9LD9F=9B7=5 M
BI9GHF5 6`GEI985 89 @5 D@9B=HI8 M 9GHC 9G 5@;C EI9 7CAD5FH=ACG HC8CG 7F9M9BH9G
M BC 7F9M9BH9G DCF =;I5@ (9FC 589AQG H5ADC7C 9G A= =BH9B7=]B 5:=FA5F EI9 @CG
<IA5B=GACG 9L7@IG=JCG C:F9N75B @5G `B=75G 5@H9FB5H=J5G 5 @5 F9@=;=]B &I9GHF5 9F5
<5 G=8C H9GH=;C 89 IB =ADCFH5BH9 7CB>IBHC 89 7CFF=9BH9G EI9 DC8FY5B @@5A5FG9
5BH=<IA5B=GACG BC F9@=;=CGCG EI9 F97=69B 8=J9FGCG BCA6F9G <CM 9B 8Y5 7CAC
h897CBGHFI77=]Bi M hDCG9GHFI7HIF5@=GACi M EI9 9B7I9BHF5B GIG F5Y79G 9B @CG
AIM =B:@IM9BH9G 9G7F=HCG 89@ G=;@C 0!0 9GD97=5@A9BH9 9B @CG 89 &=9HNG7<9 @
A=GAC H=9ADC <5M =BH9BHCG 89 F97CBGHFI=F IB <IA5B=GAC BC 9L7@IG=JC GC6F9 IB5
65G9 BC F9@=;=CG5 5@;C EI9 DI989 C6G9FJ5FG9 9B 8=J9FG5G :CFA5G 89 @5 97C@C;Y5
DFC:IB85
$C EI9 GCGH9B;C 9G 5@;C 89 9GH5 B5HIF5@9N5 @5 G97I@5F=858 9B 9@ H9F79F G9BH=8C
58J=BC >IBHC 7CB @5 DCG=6=@=858 89@ <IA5B=GAC 9L7@IG=JC EI9 DCF @C H5BHC DCF
DF=A9F5 J9N 5AD@=] 9@ 9GD97HFC 89 CD7=CB9G DCG=6@9G DCB=9B8C :=B 5 @5 9F5 89 @5 :9
F9@=;=CG5 h=B;9BI5i B IB G9BH=8C 9@ <IA5B=GAC 9L7@IG=JC G9 =BGH5@]
G=;=@CG5A9BH9 9BHF9 BCGCHFCG 5 HF5JVG 89 IB5 :CFA5 =BH9FA98=5 9@ 89YGAC DFCJ=8
9B7=5@ M H5BHC 9@ 89YGAC 7CAC 9@ <IA5B=GAC :I9FCB DCG=6@9G ;F57=5G 5 @CG 89G5F
FC@@CG 5BH9F=CF9G 89BHFC 89@ 7F=GH=5B=GAC CFHC8CLC -B5 J9N EI9 9GH9 <IA5B=GAC
GI6=] 5 9G79B5 @5 BI9J5 DCG=7=]B D@IF5@ BC =B;9BI5 85 @I;5F 5 @5 AI@H=D@=757=]B

  

89 CD7=CB9G AQG 5@@Q 89 @5 ;5A5 CF=;=B5@ (9FC 9@ ACJ=A=9BHC HF5BG:CFA58CF :IB


85A9BH5@9B9@DFC79GC9G@5@@9;58589@<IA5B=GAC9L7@IG=JC
9G89 9GH9 DIBHC 89 J=GH5 DC8FY5 C:F979FG9 9GH5 89G7F=D7=]B IB=@=B95@ 89 @5
8=:9F9B7=5 9BHF9 VDC75G D5G585G M @5 9F5 G97I@5F IB5 9F5 G97I@5F 9G IB5 9F5 9B @5
EI9 9@ 97@=DG9 89 HC8CG @CG C6>9H=JCG EI9 G9 I6=EI9B AQG 5@@Q 89 @5 6=9B5J9BHIF
5BN5 <IA5B5 G9 JI9@J9 7CB796=6@9 C A9>CF 5`B 7569 89BHFC 89 IB5 J=85 =A5;=B
56@9 D5F5 @5G ;F5B89G A5G5G OGH9 9G 9@ JYB7I@C 7@5J9 9BHF9 @5 G97I@5F=858 M 9@
<IA5B=GAC5IHCGI:=7=9BH9

GY D5F5 BI9GHFCG :=B9G @5 hF9@=;=]Bi DI989 89:=B=FG9 9B HVFA=BCG 89


hHF5G79B89B7=5i D9FC 9GH9 `@H=AC HVFA=BC 8969 G9F 9BH9B8=8C 9B AQG 89 IB5
8=A9BG=]B @ <97<C 89 EI9 G9 7F95 9B 5@;`B H=DC 89 5;9BH9 C DC89F EI9 HF5G
7=9B89 9@ CF89B =BA5B9BH9 9G J9F8589F5A9BH9 IB F5G;C :IB85A9BH5@ 89 @5 hF9@=
;=]Bi H5@ 7CAC 5D5F979 9B @5G H9CFY5G 89 @5 G97I@5F=N57=]B G BI9GHF5 F9@57=]B 7CB
IB =CG HF5G79B89BH9 @5 EI9 <5 EI9858C 89GD@5N585 89@ 79BHFC 89 @5 J=85 GC7=5@
G97I@5F=858  9G @5 :9 9B 9GH9 =CG 5EI9@@5 7IM5 89G5D5F=7=]B 9G F5GHF9585 9B
9GH5G H9CFY5G G97I@5F=858  (9FC D5F5 7CADF9B89F A9>CF @CG :9B]A9BCG EI9
EI9F9ACG 9LD@=75F 8969FY5ACG 7CBG=89F5F @5 F9@57=]B 89 @5 F9@=;=]B 7CB IB hAQG
5@@Qi 9B HF9G 8=A9BG=CB9G 1 @5 8=A9BG=]B 7@5J9 5EIV@@5 EI9 <579 EI9 GI =AD57HC
9B BI9GHF5G J=85G G95 7CADF9BG=6@9 9G @5 EI9 <9 9GH58C 9LD@CF5B8C @5 G9BG57=]B
89 EI9 <5M IB 6=9B GID9F=CF 5 @5 6=9B5J9BHIF5BN5 <IA5B5 M EI9 G9 G=H`5 AQG 5@@Q
89 VGH5 B 9@ 75GC 89@ 7F=GH=5B=GAC DC8FY5 G9F 9@ Q;5D9 9@ 5ACF EI9 =CG BCG
H=9B9 M 89@ EI9 DC89ACG D5FH=7=D5F 5 HF5JVG 89 GI DC89F B CHF5G D5@56F5G G9
C:F979 IB5 DCG=6=@=858 89 HF5BG:CFA57=]B EI9 BCG @@9J5 AQG 5@@Q 89 @5 D9F:977=]B
A9F5A9BH9 <IA5B5 (9FC 89G89 @I9;C 9GH5 BC7=]B 89 IB 6=9B GID9F=CF EI9
DC89ACG 5@75BN5F G]@C DC8FY5 H9B9F G9BH=8C 9B 9@ 7CBH9LHC 89 @5 7F99B7=5 9B IB
DC89F GID9F=CF 9@ =CG HF5G79B89BH9 89 @5 :9 EI9 5D5F979 9B @5 A5MCFY5 89 @5G
89:=B=7=CB9G EI9 G9 85B 89 @5 F9@=;=]B (9FC 9BHCB79G 9B H9F79F @I;5F @5 <=GHCF=5
7F=GH=5B5 89 BI9GHF5 HF5BG:CFA57=]B DCH9B7=5@ DCF C6F5 89@ Q;5D9 F9EI=9F9 EI9
7CBG=89F9ACG EI9 BI9GHF5 J=85 HF5G7=9B89 @5G :FCBH9F5G 89 GI QA6=HC hB5HIF5@i
9BHF9 9@ B57=A=9BHC M @5 AI9FH9 BI9GHF5G J=85G G9 9LH=9B89B AQG 5@@Q 89 h9GH5
J=85i
(5F5 7CADF9B89F @5 @I7<5 @5 F=J5@=858 C 9@ 8965H9 9BHF9 @5 F9@=;=]B M @5 :5@H5 89
:9 9B BI9GHF5 7I@HIF5 8969ACG H9B9F 9B 7I9BH5 EI9 @5 F9@=;=]B 7CA6=B5 9GH5G HF9G
8=A9BG=CB9G 89 @5 HF5G79B89B7=5 @@C BC G9 8969 5 EI9 9B BI9GHF5 GC7=9858 BC G9

  

9LD@CF9B CHF5G DCG=6=@=8589G CD7=CB9G EI9 G9 I6=75B 9B 5@;`B @I;5F 9BHF9 9GH5
D9FGD97H=J5 89 HF5G79B89B7=5 HF=D@9 M @5 B9;57=]B 56GC@IH5 89 @5 F9@=;=]B (CF 9@
7CBHF5F=C 9GH5G CD7=CB9G 56IB85B %QG 6=9B G9 8969 5 EI9 7CAC 9LD@=75FV 5 @C
@5F;C 89 J5F=CG 75DYHI@CG 9@ 8965H9 EI9 H=9B9 AI7<5G 5F=GH5G 9GHQ 7CB:=;IF58C
DCF @CG 8CG 9LHF9ACG @5 F9@=;=]B HF5G79B89BH9 DCF IB @58C M GI B9;57=]B :FCBH5@
DCF 9@ CHFC G D9F:97H5A9BH9 @9;YH=AC D9BG5F EI9 VGH9 9G IB =B:CFHIB=C 89 @5 7I@
HIF5AC89FB5D9FCMCGCGH9B;CEI99GIB<97<C

>
9 AC8C H5@ EI9 @5 G97I@5F=858 9B 9@ H9F79F G9BH=8C EI9 9G @C EI9 A9 =BH9F9G5
5EIY 7CAD5F585 7CB @5 G97I@5F=858 9B 9@ DF=A9F G9BH=8C @CG 9GD57=CG D`6@=7CG
G97I@5F=N58CG M 9B 9@ G9;IB8C G9BH=8C 9@ 897@=J9 89 @5 7F99B7=5 M @5 DFQ7H=75 7CB
G=GH9 9B IB BI9JC 9GH58C 89 @5 7F99B7=5 9B IB5 BI9J5 :CFA5 89 @5 9LD9F=9B7=5 EI9
=B8I79 5 @5 7F99B7=5 M 9G 89:=B=85 DCF 9@@5 9B IB BI9JC 7CBH9LHC 9B 9@ EI9 8969
9B7I58F5FG9HC856`GEI985MHC8C7I9GH=CB5A=9BHCGC6F9@CACF5@M@C9GD=F=HI5@
@ DF=B7=D5@ F5G;C 89 9GH9 BI9JC 7CBH9LHC 9G EI9 DCB9 :=B 5@ F97CBC7=A=9BHC
=B;9BIC 89 @C HF5G79B89BH9 C 89 @CG C6>9H=JCG C @5G 5:=FA57=CB9G EI9 J5B AQG 5@@Q
89 @5 6=9B5J9BHIF5BN5 <IA5B5 (9FC 9GHC 9G 65GH5BH9 8=:9F9BH9 89 @CG JI9@7CG F9@=
;=CGCG 89@ D5G58C 9B @CG EI9 IB <CF=NCBH9 =B;9BIC H9FA=B5 F99AD@5N5B8C 5 CHFC
C @CG 8CG G9 :IB89B G=B7FVH=75A9BH9 7CAC DCF 9>9AD@C 9B 9@ 75GC 89 @5 7CBJ9F
G=]B 89 G=5 %9BCF 89@ 7F=GH=5B=GAC 5@ =G@5A=GAC 7CAC 7CBG97I9B7=5 89 @5 7CB
EI=GH5 89 @CG HIF7CG $5 =B;9BI=858 5<CF5 BC 9GHQ 8=GDCB=6@9 D5F5 B58=9 B= D5F5
@CG7F9M9BH9GB=D5F5@CGBC7F9M9BH9G
OGH9 9G 9@ 7CBH9LHC ;@C65@ 9B IB5 GC7=9858 7CB:CFA585 DCF 8=:9F9BH9G
9BHCFBCG 89BHFC 89 7585 IBC 89 @CG 7I5@9G @5 CD7=]B DCF CA=G=]B DI989 G9F 8=:9F
9BH9 89 @5G CHF5G 5IBEI9 @CG EI9 <56=H5B 89BHFC 89 7585 IBC 89 9@@CG GCB 7CB
G7=9BH9G 89 @5G CD7=CB9G 5 @5G EI9 58<=9F9B @CG CHFCG M BC DI989B 89G75FH5F@5G G=B
AQG5HYHI@C89IB=B9LD@=756@99FFCF9L]H=7C
@ 75A6=C 7FI7=5@ EI9 BCG 7CB8I>C 5 9GH9 BI9JC 9GH58C :I9 @5 @@9;585 89@
<IA5B=GAC 9L7@IG=JC 7CAC IB5 CD7=]B 8=GDCB=6@9 D5F5 HC8CG f]AC C7IFF=]
9GHC ' D@5BH958C 89 CHFC AC8C fEIV :I9 9L57H5A9BH9 @C EI9 C7IFF=] D5F5 EI9 9@
9GH58C 89 @5 7F99B7=5 G9 AC8=:=75F5 9B @5 :CFA5 9B EI9 <9 89G7F=HC OGH5G BC GCB
DF9;IBH5G:Q7=@9G89F9GDCB89F

  

G 897=F 7F9C EI9 BC GCB :Q7=@9G (9FC D5F5 AI7<5G D9FGCB5G 9B @5 57HI5@=858
@5 F9GDI9GH5 D5F979 5@ A9BCG 9B @YB95G ;9B9F5@9G 65GH5BH9 C6J=5 $5 AC89FB=858
HF59 5D5F9>585 @5 G97I@5F=858 9B GIG HF9G :CFA5G GH5 7CB9L=]B 75IG5@ 9G =B9@I7H
56@9 M @5 H9CFY5 DF98CA=B5BH9 89 @5 G97I@5F=N57=]B G9 C7ID5 89 9LD@=75F DCF EIV 9G
5GY$57=J=@=N57=]BAC89FB5BCDI989AQGEI9575FF95F@5hAI9FH989=CGi
CBG=89FC EI9 9GH5 H9CFY5 9G AIM DC7C 7CBJ=B79BH9 D9FC D5F5 ACGHF5F DCF
EIV H9B;C EI9 @5BN5FA9 5 89GD@9;5F A= DFCD=5 <=GHCF=5 5@;C EI9 <5FV 9B @CG
75DYHI@CG EI9 G=;I9B B @5 `@H=A5 :5G9 JC@J9FV 5 @5 7I9GH=]B 89 EIV :CFA5 8969FY5
H9B9FIB5H9CFY57CBJ=B79BH989@5G97I@5F=N57=]B
(9FC DF=A9FC EI=G=9F5 897=F IB5G D5@56F5G GC6F9 9@ 8965H9 EI9 89G5FFC@@5FV
B F95@=858 8CG D5@56F5G B DF=A9F @I;5F A9 C7ID5FV 7CAC G9\5@V 5BH9G 89
'77=89BH9 C 89@ AIB8C 89@ H@QBH=7C &CFH9 C 9B CHFCG HVFA=BCG 89 @5 7=J=@=N5
7=]B 7IM5G DF=B7=D5@9G F5Y79G M579B 9B @C EI9 G9 GC@Y5 @@5A5F h7F=GH=5B858 @5H=B5i
(CF GIDI9GHC @5 G97I@5F=N57=]B M @5 G97I@5F=858 GCB :9B]A9BCG EI9 <CM J5B
AI7<C AQG 5@@Q 89 @5G :FCBH9F5G 89 9GH9 AIB8C @;`B 8Y5 8969FY5 G9F DCG=6@9
F95@=N5F IB 9GHI8=C 89 @5 HCH5@=858 89@ :9B]A9BC 5 9G75@5 ;@C65@ (9FC BC 7F9C EI9
DI985 7CA9BN5FG9 DCF 5@@Y 1 9@@C DCFEI9 @5 G97I@5F=858 7CAC CHFCG F5G;CG 89 @5
hAC89FB=858i l@5G 9GHFI7HIF5G DC@YH=75G @5G :CFA5G 89AC7FQH=75G @CG IGCG 89 @CG
A98=CG DCF 7=H5F 5@;IBCG CHFCG 9>9AD@CGl 89 <97<C 9B7I9BHF5B IB5 9LDF9G=]B
65GH5BH9 8=:9F9BH9 M G9 89G5FFC@@5B 65>C @5 DF9G=]B 89 8=:9F9BH9G 9L=;9B7=5G M
5GD=F57=CB9G 9B 8=:9F9BH9G 7=J=@=N57=CB9G .=J=ACG 9B IB AIB8C 7585 J9N AQG
75F57H9F=N58C DCF hAC89FB=8589G A`@H=D@9Gi BH9G 89 5DF9GIF5FBCG 5 9L5A
=B5F @5 ;9B9F5@=N57=]B ;@C65@ 9G DF97=GC EI9 9GHI8=9ACG 9GHCG 75A6=CG :IB85
A9BH5@9G 9B 8=:9F9BH9G @I;5F9G 89 @5 7=J=@=N57=]B %= DFCGD977=]B 9GHQ 5 DIBHC 89
G9F 9L79G=J5A9BH9 5AD@=5 9L=GH9B AI7<CG 75A=BCG F9;=CB5@9G M B57=CB5@9G <57=5
@5 G97I@5F=858 89BHFC 89@ AIB8C 89@ H@QBH=7C &CFH9 M BC <9 DC8=8C <579F@9G >IG
H=7=5 5 HC8CG 9@@CG 9 HC8CG AC8CG 9GD9FC DC89F 5FFC>5F 5@;IB5 @IN GC6F9 @5G
75F57H9FYGH=75G ;9B9F5@9G 89@ DFC79GC @ F97CFF9F 9GH9 75A=BC F9D=HC @C EI9
=BH9BHV <579F 9B '>DA24B >5 C74 '4;5 3D4=C4B 34; H>4 8CB89 H5A6=VB 56CF8V
IB5 G9F=9 89 7I9GH=CB9G 89 =BH9FVG IB=J9FG5@ D5F5 9@ <CA6F9 D9FC 89BHFC 89 IB
A5F7CF9;=CB5@
B G9;IB8C @I;5F 9B @CG G=;I=9BH9G 75DYHI@CG DC@9A=N5FV D9FA5B9BH9A9BH9
7CB @C EI9 89BCA=BC h<=GHCF=5G 89 GIGHF577=]Bi F9J9A9BH9 7CB 9GHC A9 F9:=9FC
5 @5G <=GHCF=5G 89 @5 AC89FB=858 9B ;9B9F5@ M 89 @5 G97I@5F=858 9B D5FH=7I@5F EI9

  

@5G 9LD@=75B GCGH9B=9B8C EI9 @CG G9F9G <IA5BCG D9F8=9FCB G9 89G<=7=9FCB C G9 @=6
9F5FCB 89 7=9FHCG 5BH=;ICG <CF=NCBH9G =@IG=CB9G C @=A=H57=CB9G 89@ 7CBC7=A=9BHC
EI9 @CG @=A=H565B $C EI9 GIF;9 89 9GH9 DFC79GC lAC89FB=858 C G97I@5F=858l
8969 9BH9B89FG9 9B HVFA=BCG 89 @CG F5G;CG GI6M579BH9G 89 @5 B5HIF5@9N5 <IA5B5
EI9 9GHIJ=9FCB 5@@Y 89G89 G=9ADF9 D9FC EI9 <56Y5B G=8C C6GH57I@=N58CG DCF @C EI9
5<CF5 9G 89>58C 89 @58C CBHF5 9GH9 H=DC 89 <=GHCF=5 GCGH9B8FV :=FA9A9BH9 EI9 @5
AC89FB=858 C77=89BH5@ =B7@IM9B8C GI G97I@5F=858 9G 9@ :FIHC 89 =BJ9B7=CB9G
BI9J5G 5IHC7CB79D7=CB9G F97=9BH9G M DFQ7H=75G F9@57=CB585G M BC DI989 9LD@=
75FG99BHVFA=BCG897=9FHCGF5G;CGD9FA5B9BH9G89@5J=85<IA5B5
GD9FC EI9 @5 8=G7IG=]B 89H5@@585 EI9 DF9G9BHC 5 7CBH=BI57=]B 9G7@5F9N75 @5G
=AD@=75B7=5G 89 9GH5 7I9GH=]B 5 @5 EI9 89 HC8CG AC8CG JC@J9FV 9B :CFA5 AQG G=G
H9AQH=75<57=59@:=B5@9B9@75DYHI@C 

("$).?
 9G89 @I9;C VGH9 9F5 <5GH5 <579 DC7C 9@ DIBHC 89 J=GH5 HYD=7C 89 @C EI9 89BCA=BC G97I@5F=858 9B
9@ DF=A9F G9BH=8C C G97I@5F=858  B J9F858 DC89ACG 7I9GH=CB5F 5@;IBCG 89 GIG 89H5@@9G 7CAC @5
BC7=]B 89 @5 F9@=;=]B 7CAC hDF=J585i .V5G9 "CGV 5G5BCJ5 $D1;82 &4;868>=B 8= C74 !>34A= +>A;3
<=75;C-B=J9FG=HMC:<=75;C(F9GG 
B GI HF565>C AQG F97=9BH9 5G5BCJ5 5<CB8] 9B 9@ 9G7@5F97=A=9BHC 89 @5 7CAD@9>=858 89 @C EI9 5EIY
@@5AC G97I@5F=858  =GH=B;I9 DCF IB @58C @5 G97I@5F=N57=]B 7CAC GIDI9GH5 DF=J5H=N57=]B 89 @5 F9@=;=]B
EI9 =;I5@A9BH9 89G95 7I9GH=CB5F 89 @5 G97I@5F=N57=]B 7CAC hIB5 8=:9F9B7=57=]B 89 @5G 9G:9F5G G97I@5F9G
GH58C 97CBCAY5 7=9B7=5 @C EI9 ;9B9F5@A9BH9 G9 9BH=9B89 7CAC h9A5B7=D57=]Bi 89 @5G =BGH=HI7=CB9G
M BCFA5G F9@=;=CG5G !89BH=:=75 9GHC 7CAC h9@ 7CADCB9BH9 79BHF5@ 89 @5G H9CFY5G 7@QG=75G 89 @5 G97I@5F=N5
7=]B EI9 G9 F9@57=CB5 7CB 9@ G=;B=:=758C 9H=AC@];=7C<=GH]F=7C CF=;=B5@ 89@ HVFA=BC OGH9 G9 F9:=9F9 5 @5
HF5BG:9F9B7=5 89 D9FGCB5G 7CG5G G=;B=:=758CG 9H7VH9F5 89G89 9@ IGC @5 DCG9G=]B C 9@ 7CBHFC@ 97@9G=QGH=7C
C F9@=;=CGC 5@ 7=J=@i .V5G9 GI @=6FC 89 DF]L=A5 5D5F=7=]B 9B 9@ EI9 8=GH=B;I9 @C EI9 9G JQ@=8C 89 @C EI9 9G
:5@GC9B@5GDF=B7=D5@9GH9CFY5G89@5G97I@5F=N57=]B
 h$5 F9@=;=CB 9GH D5FHCIHi JV5G9 @5 8=G7IG=]B 9B 5B=W@9 9FJ=9I$V;9F 4 $S;4A8= 4C ;4 >=E4AC
(5FYG@5AA5F=CB DQ;G
 
 -B5 F5A5 =ADCFH5BH9 89 @5 H9CFY5 7CBH9ADCFQB95 89 @5 G97I@5F=N57=]B G=;I=9B8C 5 %5L /969F G9
7CB79BHF5 9B 9GH5 h8=:9F9B7=57=]Bi M h5IHCBCA=N57=]Bi 89 @5G 8=:9F9BH9G 9G:9F5G ;I=585G DCF IB DFC
79GC 89 hF57=CB5@=N57=]Bi .V5G9 (9H9F 9F;9F (74 '02A43 0=>?H &I9J5 1CF? CI6@985M  M
'@=J=9F ,G7<5BB9B 4B (7R>A84B 34 ;0 B42D;0A8B0C8>= =B96F5 FCN   75DYHI@C !. %QG 589@5BH9
C:F979FVIB57FYH=75D5F7=5@899GH5DCG=7=]B
 @ 5@IABC 9F5 9CF;9 %575I@5M ,F9J9@M5B $5 :F5G9 9G =BJC7585 DCF 'K9B <58K=7? (74 '42D
;0A8I0C8>= >5 C74 DA>?40= !8=3 8= C74 "8=4C44=C7 4=CDAH 5A6F=8;9 5A6F=8;9 -B=J9FG=HM (F9GG
DQ; 
 989F=::=H<G (74>;34='CA8=6 $CB8F9GCIBH DQ;

  

 9F;9F (9H9F  0A ;>AH (74 %D4BC 5>A 08C7 8= C74 64 >5 A43D;8CH &I9J5 1CF? F99 (F9GG
,CFCBHC %5LK9@@ %57A=@@5B 5B585 &I9J5 1CF? %5LK9@@ %57A=@@5B !BH9FB5H=CB5@   DQ;G
 
 +7<=@@9F 4CC4AB >= C74 4BC74C82 3D20C8>= >5 !0= 98 M HF58 @=N569H< /=@?=BGCB M $ /=@
@CI;<6M 'L:CF8 @5F9B8CB (F9GG  75DYHI@C  3HF58 75GH 0AC0B B>1A4 ;0 43D2028X= 4BCRC820 34;
7><1A4 5F79@CB5BHFCD<CG 
4
 h(@9B=HI8i <5 D5G58C 5 G9F IB HVFA=BC EI9 F9GIA9 9@ 9GH58C 5@ EI9 5GD=F5ACG D9FC GCM AIM 7CB
G7=9BH9 89 7IQB =B5897I585G GCB HC85G @5G D5@56F5G 9B 9GH9 DIBHC I5@EI=9F 89G=;B57=]B DCG=6@9 F9GI@H5
9FF]B95 @ 9>9AD@C AQG BCH56@9 9B 9@ 75GC 89 @5 hD@9B=HI8i 9G EI9 89 57I9F8C 7CB IB 75A=BC 9GD=F=HI5@
AIM D@5IG=6@9 7@5F5A9BH9 J=G=6@9 9B 9@ 6I8=GAC DCF 9>9AD@C @5 AQL=A5 5GD=F57=]B G9 F9:=9F9 5 IB H=DC
89 J57YC BD=H0C0 C 9B HVFA=BCG AQG D5F58]>=7CG @5 J9F8589F5 D@9B=HI8 G]@C G9 5@75BN5 5 HF5JVG 89@
J57YC (9FC BC <5M IB5 GC@I7=]B H9FA=BC@];=75 D9F:97H5 M DCF @C H5BHC A5BH9B;C 9@ HVFA=BC 7CB HC85G
9GH5GF9G9FJ5G
]@9F5@HVFA=BC5D5F9799B=B;@VG9B9@DC9A59B:F5B7VG895I89@5=F93&89@5 ,4

 .V5G9 5BG "C5G A0D27C 34A !4=B27 &4;868>= F9=6IF; 9F89F

 9GD97=5@A9BH9 DQ;G


 M 
  D5F5 IB5 =BH9F9G5BH9 8=G7IG=]B GC6F9 @5 9LD9F=9B7=5 DCH9B7=5@A9BH9 F9@=;=CG5 M GIG
5FH=7I@57=CB9G
 B 9GH9 6CFF58CF 89 IB5 :9BCA9BC@C;Y5 89 @5 9LD9F=9B7=5 ACF5@ 9GD=F=HI5@ 7CB HF9G h@I;5F9Gi
5@HC 65>C M A98=C C6J=5A9BH9 IB5 ;F5B D5FH9 EI985 :I9F5 G 7@5FC EI9 DCF 9>9AD@C H5A6=VB 9LD9F=
A9BH5ACG @5 :I9FN5 89 @5G 9L=;9B7=5G ACF5@9G 9GD=F=HI5@9G 9B AI7<CG CHFCG @I;5F9G 7CAC 9B @CG >I=7=CG
EI9 <579ACG GC6F9 @5G 577=CB9G 89 @CG 89AQG M @5G BI9GHF5G 58A=F5B8C 5@;IB5G M H9A=9B8C CHF5G C
=B8=;BQB8CBCG 5BH9 9@@5G $5 8=A9BG=]B ACF5@ =ADF9;B5 BI9GHF5 J=85 CF8=B5F=5 M 9GHQ DF9G9BH9 9B 9@@5
89AI7<5GA5B9F5G
 0$4BC4 4!HC7434'8B8H?74
 %9M9FF=;=H (A0=B;0C8=6C744E8; ,F9BHCB:F=75/CF@8(F9GG DQ;  
 ,CAV 9GH9 HVFA=BC 89 @5 :5ACG5 8=GH=B7=]B EI9 <579 +7<=@@9F 9BHF9 @5 DC9GY5 h=B;9BI5i M @5 hG9B
H=A9BH5@i 896=8C 5 @CG 9J=89BH9G D5F5@9@=GACG EI9 <5M 9BHF9 9@ 7CBHF5GH9 EI9 V@ <579 M 9@ EI9 9GHCM
HF5N5B8C 5EIY .V5G9 +7<=@@9F hP69F &5[J9 IB8 G9BH=A9BH5@=G<79 =7<HIB;i 9B 'P<C;8274 +4A:4 JC@I
A9B%`B=7<5F@ 5BG9F.9F@5; 
DQ;G

 .V5G9 I69FH F9M:IG 48=6 8= C74 +>A;3 5A6F=8;9 %5GG %!, (F9GG   M "C<B +95F@9
(74>=BCAD2C8>=>5'>280;&40;8CH &I9J51CF?,<9F99(F9GG 
 /=HH;9BGH9=B $I8K=; #= 4AC08=CH 98   % BG7CA69 M   JCB /F=;<H HF58 9B=G (5I@
M%BG7CA69'L:CF8@57?K9@@ 3HF5875GH '>1A4;024AC4I05F79@CB598=G5 4
$9G7CIFF9H%5F=9BB9 ;0D34; (5FYG@5AA5F=CB

75DYHI@C 
 (CF GIDI9GHC 9GH5 =895 HIJC GIG DF97IFGCF9G 9B VDC75G F9ACH5G 7CB @CG 9D=7`F9CG DCF 9>9AD@C
D9FC 8=FY5 EI9 BC 7CB F=GH]H9@9G 7IMC =CG 89G9AD9\565 IB D5D9@ :IB85A9BH5@ 7CAC DC@C 89 5HF577=]B
9B 9@ 7CGACG +=B 9A65F;C DCF DF=A9F5 J9N 9B 9@ '77=89BH9 AC89FBC 9GD97=5@A9BH9 7CB @5 7=9B7=5 DCG
;5@=@95B5 9@ CF89B =BA5B9BH9 G9 JI9@J9 5@;C AQG EI9 IB5 H9CFY5 AQG 6=9B G9 7CBJ=9FH9 9B 9@ H9@]B 89
:CB8C89HC8CBI9GHFCD9BG5A=9BHC
 .V5G9 9@ 5@Q= $5A5 =284=C +8B3>< !>34A= +>A;3 C782B 5>A C74 "4F !8;;4==8D<
$CB8F9G$=HH@9FCKB 

 B 7=9FHC G9BH=8C D5F979FY5 EI9 5EIY 9GHCM HCA5B8C =AD@Y7=H5A9BH9 IB5 DCG=7=]B F9GD97HC 89 IB
H9A5 EI9 H=9B89 5 8=J=8=F 5 @CG H9]F=7CG 89 @5 hG97I@5F=N57=]Bi @5 7I9GH=]B 89 7]AC 89:=B=F @5 hF9@=;=]Bi
(5F5 5@;IBCG @5 9LD@=757=]B 9G :IB7=CB5@ 9G 897=F EI9 G9 65G5 9B @C EI9 @5 F9@=;=]B <579 D5F5 @5G D9FGCB5G
C @5 GC7=9858 DCF 9>9AD@C 7CBHF=6I=F 5 @5 h=BH9;F57=]Bi (5F5 CHFCG @5 89:=B=7=]B 8969FY5 G9F GIGH5BH=J5
M @5 A5MCFY5 89 VGHCG EI=9F9B HCA5F 7CAC 7F=H9F=C 5@;IB5 F9:9F9B7=5 5 G9F9G C :I9FN5G GC6F9B5HIF5@9G $5
9@977=]B =AD@=75 IB5 ;F5B 8=:9F9B7=5 9B 7I5BHC 5@ H=DC 89 H9CFY5 EI9 G9 DFCDCB9 9G89 IB5 D9FGD97H=J5

  

:IB7=CB5@ 9G DCG=6@9 GCGH9B9F EI9 @5 F9@=;=]B BC <5 897@=B58C 9B IB5 9F5 hG97I@5Fi DCFEI9 G9 7CBG=89F5
5 HC8CG @CG H=DCG 89 :9B]A9BCG 7CBH9ADCFQB9CG =B7@IGC @CG 7CB7=9FHCG 89 A>2: M @CG D5FH=8CG 89 :`H6C@
7CAC F9@=;=CGCG 9G89 IB5 D9FGD97H=J5 GIGH5BH=J5 9B =BB9;56@9 EI9 G9 <5 DFC8I7=8C 7=9FHC 897@=J9
.V5G9 @5 =BH9F9G5BH9 8=G7IG=]B 9B 5B=W@9 9FJ=9I$V;9F 0 &4;868>= ?>DA !R<>8A4 (5FYG 9F:  
75DYHI@CG M 
CB 9GHC BC EI=9FC 897=F 9B 56GHF57HC EI9 IB5 89 9GH5G 89:=B=7=CB9G G95 A9>CF EI9 @5 CHF5 G=BC GC@5
A9BH9 EI9 D5F5 AY 9@ DIBHC =BH9F9G5BH9 G9 9B7I9BHF5 9B @5 F9@=;=]B 9B IB G9BH=8C GIGH5BH=JC +]@C EI9
9@9;Y A= DFCD=C AC8C 89 7=F7IBG7F=6=F 9@ :9B]A9BC 9J=H5B8C @5 F9:9F9B7=5 5 @C hGC6F9B5HIF5@i DCFEI9 @5
8=GH=B7=]B B5HIF5@ GC6F9B5HIF5@ 8=GH5 89 G9F IB=J9FG5@ M GIF;9 9B J9F858 `B=75A9BH9 9B @5 HF58=7=]B
C77=89BH5@ 7CB @5 DCG=6@9 9L79D7=]B 89@ !G@5A 5 HF5JVG 89@ @I;5F 5G=;B58C 5 @5 6=9B5J9BHIF5BN5
<IA5B5
 .V5BG9 @CG JC@`A9B9G 89 0430;DB 98=H58CG DCF +<IA9@ =G9BGH58H h5F@M %C89FB=H=9Gi J9F
5BC 89  JC@IA9B  B`A9FC  M h%I@H=D@9 %C89FB=H=9Gi =BJ=9FBC 89

 JC@IA9B 
B`A9FC  M H5A6=VB =@=D (5F5A9G<K5F 5CB?5F 98 ;C4A=0C8E4 !>34A=8C84B IF<5A I?9
-B=J9FG=HM(F9GG


 ,5A6=VB GCM 7CBG7=9BH9 89@ D9@=;FC CDI9GHC 9@ 89 89G7I=85F @5G =BH9F7CB9L=CB9G EI9 9L=GH9B 9B
9@ DFC79GC 89 G97I@5F=N57=]B 9B @5G 8=:9F9BH9G 7=J=@=N57=CB9G (9H9F J5B 89F .99F M5 A9 <5 7F=H=758C 5 9GH9
F9GD97HC DCF 89G7I=85F @5 :CFA5 9B EI9 @5G D9F79D7=CB9G 7C@CB=5@=GH5G 89 @5G GC7=98589G BC 9IFCD95G 5@=
A9BH5FCB GIG 7CB79D7=CB9G 89 @5 F9@=;=]B .V5G9 J5B 89F .99F <?4A80; =2>D=C4AB (F=B79HCB (F=B
79HCB-B=J9FG=HM(F9GG


 5FJ5F8-B=J9FG=HM(F9GG 

You might also like