Professional Documents
Culture Documents
of Psychiatry
http://hpy.sagepub.com/
Published by:
http://www.sagepublications.com
Additional services and information for History of Psychiatry can be found at:
Email Alerts: http://hpy.sagepub.com/cgi/alerts
Subscriptions: http://hpy.sagepub.com/subscriptions
Reprints: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsReprints.nav
Permissions: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.nav
Citations: http://hpy.sagepub.com/content/10/38/269.refs.html
History of Psychiatry,
Pnnted in England
269(1999)) 269-278.
by
clinical23 and
270
271
melancholia).&dquo;
Interest in the Cotard state was renewed after the Second World War. For
example, Perris suggested that Cotards intention had been to describe a
single symptom, a hypochondriacal delusion that occurred in anxious
melancholia; he added, however, that it may be accompanied by disorders of
sensation and that it rendered the melancholia refractory to treatment; i.e.
once the nihilistic delusion was established, it dominated the clinical picture
and made it chronic.28
During this period the old syndromatic view,29,3o was also challenged by
the notion that it might, after all, be a different entity. For example, De Martis
reported a case of a 38-year-old woman who after surgery showed a change
272
picture.32
Tremine has also considered Cotards syndrome as a separate clinical
entity which may develop in the chronic course of mental illness; but which
was a reflection of the attitudinal changes brought about by chronic institutionalization ; he believed that Cotards syndrome was a perfect illustration
of the decontextualized method of description employed in psychiatry during
the second half of the nineteenth century.33 A similar view about the role of
institutionalization has been taken by Lafond34 and also by Bourgeois who
has claimed that Cotards syndrome is a vestige of the asylums, and of the
chronicity of the pre-therapeutic era.35 If so, it could be surmised that the
therapeutic revolution should have an important impact on its frequency;36
this hypothesis, however, has not yet been tested.
Summary
In summary, in his lecture of 1880 Cotard suggested that a symptom cluster
including anxious and agitated melancholia, delusions of negation of bodily
organs and metaphysical entities and of damnation and enormity may
constitute a recognizable and different syndrome. There has since been much
debate on the nature of this clinical phenomenon. After Cotards death, a
syndromatic view predominated until recently when some authors have
returned to Cotards old view that, whether produced by a brain lesion or a
social effect, dlire de negation might after all constitute a specific condition.
Impervious to the fact that dglire means far more than delusion, some current
authors use Cotard syndrome to refer to the isolated belief of being dead.
From the clinical and evolutionary perspectives, it is unclear why a
delusion should merit, simply because of its nihilistic content, a special
brain location. The historical account offered here suggests that, before
speculation starts on any neurobiological basis for the dlire des negations,
efforts should be made to re-map its epidemiology, clinical features and basic
clinical correlations. 37
REFERENCES
1.
Förstl, H. and Beats, B., Charles Bonnets description of Cotards delusion and reduplicative
clx (1992), 416-18.
of Psychiatry
paramnesia, British Journal ,
273
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
Greenberg, D. B., Hochberg, F. H. and Murray, G. B., The theme of death in complex partial
seizures, American Journal of Psychiatry
, cxli (1984), 1587-9.
Campbell, S., Volow, M. R. and Cavenar, J. O., Cotards syndrome and the psychiatric
manifestations of typhoid fever, American Journal ,
of Psychiatry cxxxviii (1981), 1377-8.
Joseph, A. B. and OLeary, D. H., Brain atrophy and inter-hemispheric fissure in Cotards
syndrome, Journal Clinical Psychiatry
, xlvii (1986), 518-20.
Joseph, A. B., Cotards syndrome in a patient with co-existent Capgras syndrome, syndrome
of subjective doubles, and palinopsia, Journal Clinical Psychiatry
, xlvii (1986), 605-6.
Young, A. W., Robertson, I. H., Hellawell, D. J. et al., Cotard delusion after brain injury,
, xxii (1992), 799-804.
Psychological Medicine
p.220, American Psychiatric Association: Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorder,
Third Edition, Revised (Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association, 1987).
The ICD-10 Classification of Mental Disorders (Geneva: World Health, 1992).
Cotard, J. and Prévost, J. L., Études physiologiques et pathologiques sur le ramollissement
cérébral, in Études sur les maladies cérébrales et mentales (Paris: J. B. Baillière, 1891 (originally
published in 1865)).
Cotard, J., Étude sur latrophie partielle du cerveau, in Études sur les maladies cérébrales et
mentales (Paris: J. B. Baillière, 1891 (originally published in 1868)).
Cotard, J., De lorigine psycho-motrice du délire, in Études sur les maladies cérébrales et mentales
545-66.
19. Cotard, J., Perte de la vision mentale dans la mélancolie anxieuse, in Études sur les maladies
cérébrales et mentales (Paris: J. B. Baillière, 1891).
20. Cotard, J. De lorigine psycho-motrice du délire (see note 11above).
21. Régis, E., Note historique et clinique sur le délire des négations, Gazette Médicale de Paris, ii
(1893), 61-4.
pp.66-67, Séglas, J., Note sur un cas de mélancolie anxieuse (délire des négations), Archives
de Neurologie
, xxii (1884), 56-68.
23. p.419, Séglas, J., Mélancolie anxieuse avec délire des négations, Progrés Medical, xlvi (1887),
22.
417-19.
24.
Séglas, J., Séméiologie et pathogénie des idées de négation (Les altérations de la personalité
dans les délires mélancoliques), Annales Médico-Psychologiques
, xlvii (1889), 5-26.
Séglas, J., Le Délire des négations (Paris: Masson, 1897).
Berchene, P., Les Fondements de la clinique (Paris: La Bibliothèque dOrnicar, 1980).
25.
26.
27. For a full history of Cotards syndrome see Berrios G. E. and Luque R. (1995), Cotards
delusion or syndrome? Comprehensive Psychiatry, xxxvi, 218-23.
28. Perris, C., Sul delirio cronico di negazione (Sindrome di Cotard), Neuropsichiatria
, xi (1955),
175-201. This point had of course been already made by Cotard himself in his 1880 lecture to
the SMP and herewith translated.
29. Ahlheid, A., Considerazione sullesperienza nichilistica e sulla sindrome di Cotard nelle psicosi
organiche e sintomatiche, Il Lavoro Neuropsichiatrico
, xliii (1968), 927-45.
30. Vitello, A., Melancolia di Cotard con paranoidismo schizoide, Rassegna Studi Psichiatrici
, lix
(1970), 195-210.
31. De Martis, D., Un caso di sindrome di Cotard, Rivista Sperimentale di Freniatna, lxxx (1956),
491-514.
32. Enoch, D. and Trethowan, W., Uncommon Psychiatric Syndromes, 3rd edn (Oxford: Butterworth
and Hememann, 1991).
33. Trémine, T., 1880-1980: Centenaire du syndrome de Cotard, LÉvolution Psychiatrique
, xlvii
(1982), 1021-32.
274
A. M., Du délire chronique des négations comme survivance asilaire (Paris: Thèse n° 112,
1973).
35. Bourgeois, M., Jules Cotard et son syndrome. Cent ans après, Annales Médico-Psychologiques
,
34.
Lafond,
cxxxviii
36.
37.
(1980), 1165-80.
Bourgeois, M., Le syndrome de Cotard aujourdhui, Annales Médico-Psychologiques
, cxxvii
(1969), 534-44.
On this see: Berrios, G. E. and Luque, R.(1985), Cotard Syndrome: clinical analysis of 100
cases, Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, xci, 185-8.
On
Dr Jules Falret and I have had the opportunity to observe a patient suffering
from a specific form of hypochondriacal delusion.3 Miss X claimed that she
did not have a brain, nerves, chest, stomach or guts; all she had left was the
1
Read before the Médico-Psychological Society in Paris on 28 June 1880, and published in the
Annales-Médico Psychologiques in September 1880.
NT: Full reference is: Cotard, J. (1880), Du délire hypocondriaque dans une forme grave de la
2
mélancolie anxieuse, Annales-Médico Psychologiques, iv, 168-74.
NT: Délire is often rendered as delirium or delusion. Both translations are wrong. On the one
3
hand, délire does not refer in France to organic delirium or organic confusion: at the time of Cotard
these states were called délire aigu (see Ball, B. and Chambard, E., Délire aigu, in Dechambre, A.
and Lereboullet, L. (eds), Dictionnaire encyclopédique des sciences médicales
, Vol. 26 (Paris: Masson,
1881), 408-34) and confusion mentale (see Chaslin, Ph., La Confusion mentale primitive (Paris:
Asselin et Houzeau, 1895)). On the other hand, délire means far more than delusion in the AngloSaxon sense of this term (in French this narrow meaning is referred to as idée or thème délirante
) (see
Porot, A., Délires, in Manuel alphabétique de psychiatrie (Paris: Presses Universitaires de France,
1975), 177-86)). Délire may include symptoms pertaining to the intellectual, emotional or volitional
spheres and hence is a sort of syndrome (see Garrabé, J., Dictionnaire taxinomique de psychiatrie
(Paris: Masson, 1989)). Hence, translating délire des négations as nihilistic delusion gives the wrong
impression (caused by the intellectualistic semantics attached to the term delusion in English) that it
exclusively refers to a thought. As is clear from the lecture here translated and from the 1882
paper, Cotard never meant it to be an isolated thought but a symptom-cluster, i.e. to include
anxiety, agitation, severe depression, suicidal behaviour and other attending delusions.