Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Published by
African Centre for Media Excellence
Plot 124 Nanjala Road (Bunga-Soya), off Ggaba Road
P. O Box 11283 Kampala, Uganda
Tel: +256393202351
info@acme.org
www.acme-ug.org
Facebook: ACME.UG
Twitter: @ACME_Uganda
CopyrightACME 2015
Layout and Design
Harriet Anena
hanena@acme-ug.org
Cover Photo
www.prepareyourselfenglish.wordpress.com
ACKNOWLEDEGMENT
This report is published with support from the Democratic Governance
Facility (DGF), which has funded ACMEs project on monitoring media
coverage of the 2016 elections. We are grateful for the partnership with
DGF.
Several individuals have contributed to the report and we single out a few.
Project Manager Mohles Kalule Segululigamba, technical advisor George
Lugalambi, and statisticians Yusuf Mulumba and Brian Ssenabulya. We
also recognise the contribution of ACME staff Peter G. Mwesige and
Harriet Anena.
ACME would also like to thank the panel of advisors that reviews
the findings every month before they are shared with the public.
Panel members are David Ouma Balikowa, Charlotte Kawesa Ntulume,
William Tayeebwa, Patricia Litho and Joseph Ssemakula.
ACME further thanks the coders who tirelessly entered data and the
research assistants who recorded broadcast content.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY................................................................................................1
INTRODUCTION................................................................................................3
Background.......................................................................................................3
The Media and Elections.........................................................................................5
METHODOLOGY...................................................................................................11
Scope of the Monitoring.......................................................................................11
Sample and Sampling Methods........................................................................12
Methods of Data Collection..................................................................................15
Freedom to Report....................................................................................................26
FINDINGS........................................................................................................27
Tone............................................................................................................40
Reporting Approach................................................................................................43
Number of Sources..................................................................................................54
CONCLUSION.................................................................................................................56
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
This report presents the results of the monitoring of newspaper coverage
of the Ugandan presidential and parliamentary elections in the month of
October 2015. Following are the key findings:
The volume of election stories grew by about 47% to 493.
INTRODUCTION
This report presents the results of the monitoring of newspaper
coverage of the Ugandan presidential and parliamentary elections in
the month of October 2015. Comprehensive findings on the quantity
and the quality of the reporting in nine newspapers are presented and
discussed. Subsequent reports will go beyond newspapers to include
radio, television and online content.
Background
For an electoral process to qualify as free and fair, not only must the
election unfold in adequate political and administrative conditions,
but citizens must also have access to sufficient information about the
parties, candidates and voting procedures to ensure that they will make
an enlightened and valid choice. Elections will only be free if all players
candidates, political parties, citizens, civil society and, journalists
can express themselves on all matters of public concern.
The media play five essential roles in the electoral process:
2 Marie-Soleil Frre (2010). The Media and Elections in Post-Conflict Central African Countries. Brussels: University
of Brussels.
Although both the Constitution and electoral laws provide for equal
access to candidates on state or public media, in all previous elections
the latter have been accused of paying disproportionate attention to
the activities of the incumbent and ruling party at the expense of the
challengers and the opposition. This practice denies the viewing/
listening public access to adequate information against which to judge
all sides in the election.
Denial of access to state/public media by opposition candidates
The media have also been accused of focusing more on the drama and
daily routine of the election campaign at the expense of the issues. They
also tend to report the election as an event rather than a process. This
practice denies the public not only information but also the context
within which to judge candidates, parties, electoral authorities, as well
the process.
No serious interrogation of candidate claims and promises
It has been said that voters are the most critical players in
elections. Unfortunately, it has been pointed out that media coverage in
Uganda, as in many other countries, tends to pay far more attention to
the candidates and their parties than to the voters. Lost in this kind of
reporting, for instance, are the issues that matter most to the voters as
well as their own evolving evaluation of the electoral process.
Attempts by political actors, especially those in government, to
influence visuals in newspapers and on television
In the last two elections, for instance, the New Vision was accused
of overplaying, under pressure, pictures that showed huge crowds
at President Musevenis rallies and downplaying those of his main
opponent, even where Dr Besigye had attracted similar or higher
numbers of people. This practice denies voters the complete picture of
the real popularity of candidates judged by attendance of their rallies.
Lack of fairness and balance
Inaccurate reporting.
Bribery of journalists.
Self-censorship.
10
METHODOLOGY
This section presents the scope of the monitoring exercise, the sample
and sampling methods, methods of data collection as well as the tools
that we used.
Scope of the monitoring
11
Television
The five TV channels included in the sample collectively cover the whole
country. All but one broadcast primarily in English. Bukedde broadcasts in
Luganda and is one of the platforms owned by the Vision Group. Uganda
Broadcasting Corporation (UBC) is the public broadcaster. The rest
of the stations are privately owned. The channels included in the TV
samples are:
1. Bukedde
2. NBS
3. NTV
4. UBC
5. WBS
Radio
The radio stations selected for monitoring collectively cover the entire
country and represent Ugandas seven major regions: Kampala, central,
eastern, western, south-western, northern, and North-Western/West
Nile. This sample constitutes about 13% of the 250 or so stations in
operation across the country. The selected radio stations generally
accommodate all audience profiles as defined by social class, language,
religion, ethnicity, and geography/geo-politics. Except UBC, the public
broadcaster, all the other channels are either private, faith-based, or
community radio stations. The stations that make up the radio sample
are presented by region on Page 14.
13
MEDIA
FREQUENCY
Kampala (5)
Capital Radio
KFM
Top Radio
Simba FM
UBC Blue Channel
FM 91.3
FM 93.3
FM 89.6
FM 97.3
FM 98
Baba
Open Gate
Rock Mambo
Kioga Veritas
Voice of Teso
Signal FM
FM 87.7
FM 103.2
FM 106.8
FM 91.5
FM 88.4
FM 88.1
Central (5)
Eastern (6)
Western (5)
South-Western (2)
Northern (4)
14
Radio Sapientia
Voice of Africa
Central Broadcasting Services
Buddu
Spice FM
Kasese Guide
Voice of Toro
Bushenyi
Bunyoro Broadcasting Services
Radio West
Rukungiri FM
Voice of Kigezi
Mighty Fire
Dokolo FM
Mega FM
Rhino
FM 94.8
FM 92.3
FM 89.2
FM 101.9
FM 89.9
FM 100.5
FM 101
FM 92.2
FM 98.2
FM 100.2
FM 96.7
FM 89.5
FM 91.5
FM 102.4
FM 102.1
FM 96.1
FM 89.1
FM 94.1
FM 100.9
FM 87.8
FM 88.7
FM 90.9
Social media
Twitter will be monitored in the coming months. It has been selected
over other social media platforms on pragmatic grounds. The objectives
is to ascertain the extent to which the main presidential candidates use
Twitter as an alternative media form during and after the campaign
season as well as to assess candidates use of Twitter to listen to and
respond to queries, demands and debates from the electorate online.
Methods of data collection
15
For TV news/current affairs, the monitoring will focus on the two most
important daily news bulletins broadcast at the top of the hour during
the morning and evening prime viewing times between 7 a.m. 9 a.m.
and 7 p.m. 10 p.m. The scheduling of these programmes generally
varied by TV station within those time segments.
ACME plans to pay for and receive comprehensive analytics from the
online monitoring company, Social Bakers as well as internal Twitter
analytics. Areas of interest will include number of followers, change in
followers over time, incoming and outgoing interactions, as well as total
and frequency of tweets.
Key Informant Interviews
17
Radio remains the biggest source of information for most Ugandans (55
per cent of households receive information through radio, according to the
2014 census report)6 although newspapers are influential agenda-setters
for the public, political class, as well as other media.
Although Uganda has some of the most vibrant media in east and southern
Africa, in the last five years, the country has been characterised by Freedom
House as partly free. In one of its more recent reports, the international
press freedom watchdog concluded that although the countrys constitution
provides for freedom of expression and press freedom, several laws negate
these guarantees, and the government continues to crack down on critical
journalists and media houses using both subtle and blatant methods7.
Legal framework
18
These laws provide for statutory regulation and establish the Media
Council as the primary regulator of the print media but also aspects of
broadcast media, and the Uganda Communications Commission as the
regulator of electronic media and telecommunications. All journalists
are supposed to be licensed by the Media Council, which is by law
required to recognise only those enrolled under the National Institute
of Journalists of Uganda (NIJU). Journalists require university degrees to
become full members of NIJU. These regulations have not been followed
strictly in the last 15 years although they continue to attract criticism
from media freedom watchers, who also fault Ugandas regulatory regime
for not having the necessary independence from the government.
The fourth Schedule of the Press and Journalist Act provides for a
professional code of ethics that lists nine commandments:
1. No journalist shall disseminate information or an allegation without
establishing its correctness or truth.
2. No journalist shall disclose the source of his or her information; he or she
shall only divulge the source in the event of an overriding consideration of
public interest and within the framework of the law of
Uganda.
3. No journalist shall solicit or accept bribes in an attempt to publish or
suppress the publication of a story.
4. A journalist shall not plagiarise the professional work of others or
expropriate works or results of research by scholars without acknowledging
their contribution and naming his or her sources of information.
5. A journalist shall obtain his or her information through the
skillful application of journalistic principles and shall never bribe or offer
inducements to his or her source.
6. No journalist shall deny any person with legitimate claim a right to
reply to a statement. Corrections and rejoinders are to be published in
19
appropriate form without delay and in a way that they will be noticed by
those who have received the original information.
7. A journalist shall at all times strive to separate his or her own opinions
from factual news. Where personal opinions are expressed, the public shall
be made to know.
8. A journalist shall take the necessary steps to correct any damaging
report he or she has made on any individual or organisation.
9. A journalist shall not originate or encourage the dissemination of
information designed to promote or which may have the effect of promoting
tribalism, racism or any other form of discrimination.
Schedule 4 of the Uganda Communications Act on the other hand
provides for minimum broadcasting standards. It states:
A broadcaster or video operator shall ensure that
(a) any programme which is broadcast
(i) is not contrary to public morality;
(ii) does not promote the culture of violence or ethnical prejudice among
the public, especially the children and the youth;
(iii) in the case of a news broadcast, is free from distortion of facts;
(iv) is not likely to create public insecurity or violence;
(v) is in compliance with the existing law;
(b) programmes that are broadcast are balanced to ensure harmony in
such programmes;
(c) adult-oriented programmes are appropriately scheduled;
(d) where a programme that is broadcast is in respect to a contender for
20
See http://www.ucc.co.ug/files/downloads/Q3-Market%20Report%20%20for%20Third%20Quarter%20
-%20July-September%202015.pdf.
21
22
12 https://hrnjuganda.org/?p=1438
14 http://www.ucc.co.ug/files/downloads/Annual%20Market%20Industry%20Report%202014-15-%20October%2019-2015.pdf.
15 http://www.contadorharrison.com/social-media-use-in-uganda/
16 http://www.observer.ug/news-headlines/38278-who-s-tom-voltaire-okwalinga-tvo
17 https://www.facebook.com/tom.okwalinga?fref=ts
18 https://www.facebook.com/Tvo-Uganda-654610647943658/?fref=ts
19 http://www.monitor.co.ug/News/National/Lawyers-demand-release-of-social-media-critic-/-/688334/2747382/-/r3f7qaz/-/index.html
23
posts that mocked the government for holding the wrong person.
24
A Photo montage showing crowds at rallies of presidential candidates Yoweri Museveni, Amama
Mbabazi and Kizza Besigye. The politics of crowds was a big part of the 2016 poll. ACME Photo.
Paper Presented at Breakfast Meeting for Media Owners Hosted by the Civil Society Capacity Building Programme. Kampala, November 15, 2006
25
Experience
The rate of occupational mobility in political reporting, and Ugandan
journalism generally, remains high. Many experienced journalists
have moved on to other fields such as marketing and public relations.
Commentators note that such haemorrhage weakens institutional
memory and diminishes the intellectual capital and credibility of news
organisations.22
Freedom to report
22 Mwesige, P.G & D.K. Kalinaki (2007). East Africa: 50 years of media, in E. Barratt & G. Berger (Eds.). 50
Years of Journalism: African media since Ghanas independence. (pp. 97-109). Johannesburg: African Editors Forum,
Highway Africa, and Media Foundation for West Africa.
26
THE FINDINGS
Volume of election stories
Although the media monitoring is for both presidential and parliamentary
elections, these results mainly focus on the presidential elections as they
continued to dominate media coverage in October.
27
28
29
30
Among the dailies, Daily Monitor (32.7%) accorded the most space to the
elections with Bukedde following at 26%. At 17.4%, the New Vision dedicated
significantly less space.
Figure 3-1: Space to elections by dailies
31
32
33
34
However, Vision Group publications Etop (100%), Rupiny (58.3%) and New
Vision (38.4%) gave more space to incumbent Museveni. Red Pepper (54.1%)
and The Observer (48.0%) gave more space to Mbabazi, while Besigye was
covered most by Orumuri (54.3%) and Daily Monitor (35.7%).
Figure 5-1: Space to presidential candidates by publication
35
36
37
38
Location of stories
Most election reporting continued to originate from the central region
as the figure below shows.
Figure 8: Location of election stories by region
39
Tone
This is the general character portrayed by the story. For purposes of this
study, it applies only to stories that focus on presidential candidates and
parties.
The tone is negative when the article in general paints the candidate
or party in bad light, or is critical of or questions the candidate, party or
a particular issue raised by these actors.
The tone is positive when the article expresses promise about or
celebrates a particular candidate or party or in general paints the
candidate or party in good light.
The tone is neutral when the article is neither negative nor positive.
The findings show that the general tone of newspaper coverage continued
to be neutral (57.2%) However, the frequency of stories with a negative
tone jumped to 30% from 21.4% in September.
Figure 9: General newspaper tone
40
The Independent had the highest number of stories with a negative tone
(45.5%), followed by Etop (36.8%), Red Pepper (35.5%), The Observer
(34.8%) and Daily Monitor (33.3%). Orumuri carried only stories with a
neutral tone, while the New Vision had the least number of stories with
negative tone.
Figure 9-1: Tone of coverage by publication
41
Besigye (34.2%) had the highest frequency of stories with a negative tone.
He was followed closely by Museveni who attracted 32% stories with
a negative tone. At 29.3%, Mbabazi was not that far behind. Its worth
noting that all three candidates attracted far more negative coverage in
October than in September, with Besigye registering the highest growth.
Minor candidates such as Baryamureeba and Mabirizi attracted the
highest proportion of stories in a positive tone (both at 42.9%).
Figure 9-2: Tone of newspaper coverage by presidential candidate
42
Reporting approach
The reporting approach is the style in which the election stories are
reported. Conventional reporting tends to focus on events (hard
news) with fact-reporting as the dominant posture. In interpretive
reporting, explanation is the dominant posture. Under the enterprise
reporting approach, the journalists own initiative and effort are critical
in originating the story, whereas in investigative reporting, exposition
is the dominant posture (i.e. the reporting uncovers information that
an individual or entity may have tried to conceal from public scrutiny,
or information that an individual or entity may have had an interest in
keeping out of the public domain).
The findings show that most of the election stories in October employed
the conventional reporting approach (61.5%). This was a significant
drop from the high of 70.2% in September. October registered a
corresponding increase in investigative stories (21.4%) and those
employing the interpretive approach (12.3%).
Figure 10: Reporting approach for election-related stories
43
Vision Group publications, with the exception of Orumuri, had a far higher
proportion of stories in the conventional format with Rupiny leading the
pack at 75%, followed by New Vision (70%), Bukedde (69.4%) and Etop
(68.4%). Orumuri carried the highest percentage of interpretive stories
(60%), The Independent led on enterprise stories (31.8%), while The
Observer outdid the others on investigative election stories (47.8%).
Figure 10-1: Reporting approach by newspapers
44
45
New Vision (50%), Etop (50%) and Daily Monitor (40.7%) carried the
highest percentage of issue-based stories. Bukedde (38.8%), Etop
(33.3%), The Independent (31.8%) and Red Pepper (31.7%) had the
highest percentage of election stories that focused on personalities.
Figure 11-1: Issues vs personalities reporting by publication
46
47
48
49
50
51
Gender of sources
The findings show that women constituted only 17.8% of human sources
in election stories, a slight increase from Septembers 15.7%. Some
journalists argued that many women, including those in the political
class, did not want to be interviewed or quoted. Others admitted the
inherent bias in source selection that is informed by the prevailing
patriarchy.
Figure 15: Sources of election stories by gender
52
53
Number of Sources23
The problem of single sourcing remained in October. Some 59% of stories
carried only one human source while 15.8% had two sources. Just about
a quarter of the stories had the desirable three or more sources.
Figure 16: Number of sources
54
55
CONCLUSION
October saw a marked increase in volume of election stories as well as
space given to the coverage. However, in terms of the quality of coverage,
the results present a mixed bag, once again. In some areas there was
notable improvement from September, in others a decline, and in most,
stagnation.
Following are the key findings from the monitoring of newspaper
coverage in October:
The volume of coverage increased as political activity grew.
The tone of coverage was in general still mostly neutral, although the
frequency of stories with a negative tone rose to 30%.
57
ACME 2015