Professional Documents
Culture Documents
F.S. Harris
F.S. Harris Ltd, 14 Karen Close, Hethersett, Norwich NR9 3DG, UK
The technology to transport liquefied natural gas (LNG) safely by sea is well established and
many variations of cargo containment systems have been tested and developed since the
early 1950s. Examples of four current LNG ships incorporating different containment
systems are briefly described. Safety features are examined, now considered standard
practice on a modern LNG carrier, which have made a major contribution to the outstandingly good record of LNG ship operations. Examples are given of some LNG ship casualty
incidents.
Keywords:
*Paper presented at the "Low Temperature Engineering and Cryogenics Conference', 13-1 5 July 1992, Southampton, UK
0011-2275/93/080772~96
1993 Butterworth-Heinemann Ltd
772
systems
Technigaz membrane
Beginning with the smallest ship, Figure 1 shows an
outline arrangement of the 18 800 m 3 L N G carrier on
order, for the Nippon Yusen Kaisha (NYK)/Perbadanan
National Shipping Line joint partnership, from Japanese
shipbuilder NKK, incorporating the French developed
Technigaz Mark III membrane containment system.
The key to the Technigaz membrane system is the use
of waffled stainless steel for the membrane primary
barrier. The membrane is a flexible liner with a series of
corrugations perpendicular to each other which resist
thermal changes and ship bending deflections. The Mark
III design benefits from the experience gained from
earlier Technigaz membrane designs and includes an
Shipbuilders
Owners
Delivery
Length o.a.
Length b.p.
Breadth moulded
Depth moulded
Draught
Service speed
Figure 1
NKK
NYK/Perbad
1993
130.00 m
124.00 m
25.70 m
16.60 m
6.50 m
15.0 knots
i L
!iIll ' ~!
Shipbuilders
Owners
Delivery
Length o.a.
Length b.p.
Breadth moulded
Depth moulded
Draught
Service speed
Figure 2
IHI
Phillips/Marathon
(2) 1993
239.00 m
226.00 m
40.00 m
26.80 m
10.10 m
18.5 knots
773
r --
Figure 3
774
Shipbuilders
Owners
Delivery
Length o.a.
Length b.p.
Breadth moulded
Depth moulded
Draught
Service speed
Chantiers de l'Atlantique
Petronas
(5) 1994/1997
271.60 m
260.80 m
43.30 m
25.40 m
11.00 m
21.0 knots
Name
Shipbuilders
Owners
Delivery
Length o.a.
Length b.p.
Breadthmoulded
Depth moulded
Draught
Servicespeed
Figure 4
EKAPUTRA
Mitsubishi
H.I.
CometcoShippingInc.
1990
290.00 m
276.00 m
46.00 m
25.50 m
11.80 m
18.5 knots
M a t e r i a l s of Construction
Materials for the hull plating and stiffening, cargo tanks,
cargo piping and welding requirements are especially
selected and tested to suit their applications. Requirements include tensile tests, bend tests, Charpy V-notch
toughness tests and weld production tests. The extent of
the testing depends on the design temperature. Crack
arresting grades of steel are incorporated in the hull
structure at the deck, sheer strake and bilge strake.
Cargo c o n t a i n m e n t
The cargo containment systems, either with independent
tanks or membranes, are designed to take into account
combinations of various loads, including internal and
external pressure, dynamic loads due to the motion of the
ship, thermal loads, sloshing loads, loads corresponding
to ship deflections, tanks and cargo weight with the
corresponding reactions by way of the supports, and
insulation weight and loads by way of towers and other
attachments.
S u b m e r g e d cargo pumps
Segregation of cargo area
The cargo area of the L N G carrier is segregated from the
main machinery and boiler spaces, service and control
stations, chain lockers, drinking and domestic water
tanks and stores by gas-tight steel bulkheads. Cargo
spaces are located forward of the machinery spaces.
C r y o g e n i c s 1 9 9 3 V o l 33, N o 8
775
Emergency shut-down
The emergency shut-down (ESD) systems on L N G ships
will operate automatically due to loss of electric or
control power, valve actuator power or fire at the tank
domes or cargo manifolds. In addition, at various locations around the ship, stop control points are provided to
close the emergency shut-down system and stop cargo
pumps and equipment as necessary.
Electrical arrangements
Personnel protection
Certified safe type electrical equipment is fitted in gasdangerous spaces to minimize the risk of fire and explosion. The systems include flame proof and intrinsically
safe equipment and wiring.
Instrumentation
The instrumentation on a L N G carrier is extensive in
order to monitor all aspects of the cargo handling
systems. Level indicators, liquid level alarms, pressure
gauges and thermometers are fitted throughout the cargo
tanks and cargo handling systems. A fixed system of gas
detection with audible and visual alarms is fitted with
sampling heads located in all spaces where vapour may
accumulate. The equipment will take samples on a continuous basis at intervals not exceeding 30 min. Portable
gas detection equipment is also carried onboard. Instruments are tested for reliability in the working conditions
and recalibrated at regular intervals.
776
Skikda, Algeria. L N G from the no. 1 cargo tank overflowed on to the main deck, causing severe cracks to the
steelwork. The tank was discharged without further
incident. Extensive repairs were required resulting from
the spill.
Conclusions
The safe transportation of L N G by sea now spans 34
years. Developments have been gradual, with all components both large and small thoroughly tried and tested
before being used in practice. This brief presentation
shows that the safety features of L N G carriers have in no
small way contributed to the excellent operational record.
Acknowledgements
The assistance received from Chantiers de l'Atlantique
and Japanese shipbuilders N K K , IHI and Mitsubishi HI
in supplying information and data on their latest L N G
carrier designs is gratefully acknowledged.
777