Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Article
INTRODUCTION
Correspondence:
Dr. Qamar Rizvi, Assistant Professor,
Department of Pharmacology & Therapecutics,
Hamdard College of Medicine & Dentistry, Karachi.
Phones: 4642383, 0333-2216131.
E-mail: dr_qamar@hotmail.com
Group 5 - Co-trimox Group receiving oral Co-trimoxazole 960mg twice daily for 14 days.
Assessments
All patients were hospatalised for 24 hours for the purpose of observation and collection of relevant samples.
Patients subsequently attended the clinic for assessment
at days 2,3,5,7 and 14. Post-treatment follow-up was
conducted at day 28 ( 2 days). Blood and stool samples
were collected for bacterial culture at the days 0,3,5,7,14
and 28. Where day 0 denotes the baseline test.
Bacteriological Evaluation
The bacteriological outcome for each patient was classified into the following categories:
Bacteriological Cure
Means that the initially susceptible pathogen was eliminated from blood or stool on day 7 or as per term of treatment with that drug and did not reappear within three
weeks after the end of treatment.
Bacteriological Failure
Means persistence of S. Typhi and S. Paratyphi on day
7 or 14 or recurrence of the initial pathogen at the end
of treatment.
Bacteriological Relapse
Means elimination of pathogen within 7 or 14 days, but
reappearence in blood and / or stool within three weeks
after the end of treatment.
Clinical Assessment of Efficacy
This was based on the disappearance of clinical signs
and symptoms on clinical assessment. All cases were
classified into one of the following categories:
Treatment
The patients were randomly assigned to one of the following treatment groups, and the drugs administered
for 7 or 14 days:
Clinical Cure
Reduction of maximum daily temperature equal to or
<37oC and /or and disappearance of clinical signs and
symptoms at the end of treatment with no clinical
evidence of infection during further follow-up.
Clinical Improvement
All clinical signs and symptoms subsiding significantly
within 7 and 14 days, respectively, but with incomplete
resolution of clinical evidence of infection.
58
Cipro
Group
Oflox
Group
Cefixime
Group
Chloram
Group
Co-trimox
Group
Total
Male
25
21
26
20
20
112
Female
23
24
20
24
24
115
Total
48
45
46
44
44
227
32.082
318.5
31.58.2
31.98.4
31.98.4
31.78.2
Mean Age
Clinical Failure
No significant clinical response to therapy.
Not Assessable
A clinical judgement of cure, improvement or failure
could not be made for various reason such as no followup evaluation tests performed, an underlying condition,
or premature termination of the treatment.
RESULTS
A total of 227 patients, 112 males and 115 females were
included in the study. Their mean age was 31.78.2
years. The demographic characteristics of the study
population are presented in Table I. There were 48 pati-
Cipro
Group
Oflox
Group
Cefixime
Group
Chloram
Group
Co-trimox
Group
Average
Abdominal Pain
76
80
78
82
77
79
Splenomegaly
30
35
28
41
37
34
Hepatomegaly
21
19
26
18
22
21
Dehydration
19
17
10
13
15
15
Diarrhoea
58
51
50
47
49
51
Vomiting
04
20
05
09
21
12
25
05
32
16
07
18
Temperature (C)
38.91.5
391
39.11.2
38.81.2
39.21.5
391
Pulse (beats/min)
8913
8812
8711
8812
8913
8812
Systolic BP(mmHg)
11615
11211
11413
11112
11716
11413
Diastolic BP (mmHg)
6410
659
6311
648
659
649
59
Salmonella Typhi
Blood culture
Stool culture
Total
Salmonella Paratyphia
Blood culture
Stool culture
Total
Ciprofloxacin
40
44
Ofloxacin
33
39
--
Cefixime
38
42
Chloramphenicol
37
41
Co-trimoxazole
36
42
--
184
24
208
15
18
Total
Group
Total
Ciprofloxacin Group
35
17
52
Ofloxacin Group
30
19
49
Cefixime Group
32
17
49
Chloramphenicol Group
31
18
49
Co-trimoxazole Group
31
16
47
Total
Cipro
Group
Oflox
Group
Cefixime
Group
Chloram
Group
Co-trimox
Group
Total
Diabetes Mellitus
--
--
16
Hypertension
--
15
Bronchial Asthma
--
--
--
--
--
--
20
11
41
Total
60
Clinical Cure
Patients (%)
Defervescence (Days)
Ciprofloxacin Group
100%
31
48
Ofloxacin Group
100%
2.5 1
45
Cefixime Group
100%
3.5 1.5
46
Chloramphenicol Group
80%
62
35
14
Co-trimoxazole Group
70%
6.5 2
31
14
Cipro
Group
Oflox
Group
Cefixime
Group
Chloram
Group
Co-trimox
Group
Average
Nausea/Vomiting
10
24
Abdominal pain
--
14
Diarrhoea
--
--
Heartburn
--
--
Headache/Dizziness
--
--
Anorexia
--
--
--
Cough
--
--
--
--
Palpitation
--
Anaemia
--
--
--
--
mild
mild
mild
mild
mild
mild
Mild/Moderate/Severe
61
The Ofloxacin regimen recommended by the manufacturers for typhoid fever is 200mg twice daily for 5-10
days. However, some studies revealed that short course
treatment with oral ofloxacin (5 days) is significantly
better than with ceftriaxone (3 days i.v.) and will be of
particular benefit in areas where multiresistant strains
of S. typhi are encountered12. A three day course of ofloxacin proved to be safe and highly effective in the
treatment of uncomplicated, multidrug-resistant typhoid
fever13. Treatment with ofloxacin for 2-3 days is equally
effective in adults with uncomplicated enteric fever
caused by nalidixic acid sensitive strains of S. typhi14.
However another study recommended that short courses
of quinolones should not be used in patients infected
with NARST (Nalidixic acid resistant srains), as they
may require re-treatment15,16. In this study we prescribed
200mg of the drug twice daily for seven days per oral
in order to avoid any relapse or treatment. Here also
we found excellent (100%) efficacy and compliance.
Not even a single case of relapse was encountered. The
few adverse events seen were of mild nature and left
no permanent sequelae.
CONCLUSION
There were no significant discrepancies among the effect of the drugs in the study population with respect to
gender, age, weight, height, climate, racial factor and
dietary habits. Most of the patients belonged to the lower socioeconomic stratum and were living in unhygienic conditions, the main source of the spread of disease.
9. Limson BM. Short course quinolone therapy of Typhoid fever in developing countries. Drug 1995;
49 (Suppl.2): 13608.
10. Alam MN, Haq SA, Das KK, Baral PK, Mazid
MN, Siddique RU, Rehman KM, Hasan Z, Khan
MA, Dutta P. Efficacy of ciprofloxacin in Enteric
fever: Comparison of treatment duration in sensitive
and multidrug-resistant Salmonella. Am J Trop Med
Hyg 1995 Sep; 53(3): 306-311.
REFERENCES
12. Smith MD, Duong NM, et al. Comparison of Ofloxcin and Ceftriaxone for short-course treatment of
Enteric fever. Antimicrobial Agents and Chemoth.
1994 Aug; 38(8): 1716-20.
6. Prabhakar H, Kaur H, Lal M. Prevalance of multidrug resistant S. Typhi in Ludhiana, Punjab. Indian
J Med Sci 1996 Aug; 50(8): 227-279.
7. Atkins BL; Gottilieb T, Licciardone J, Gleckman
R, Zenilman JM. Emerging drug resistance and
vaccination for Typhoid fever. JAMA Feb 1998;
279: 579-80.
17. United States Pharmacopia, 15th ed. Drug information for the Health care professional; 1995. p.338.
63
64