Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 1 of 40

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA

FILED BY

JUL 25 2216
FORT LAUDERDALE DIVISION

STEVEN M LARIMORE

cuEnxui.DlsT.c'r
s.D.oFFZA.Fr.LAui.

CASE NO.16-cv-61511-W JZ
W ILDING eta1,
Plaintiffs,

V.

M OTION TO INTERVENE

DNC SERVICES CORPORATION eta1,

D efendants.

EXPEDITED M OTION TO INTERVENE OF STEVE SCH ONBERG

M ovantSchonberg seeksto intervene undertheFederalRulesofCivilProcedure,Rule

24(a)(2)whichreads:

(a)Intervention ofRight.
On tim ely motion,the courtm ustperm itanyone to intervene who:

(2)claimsan interestrelating to the propertyortransaction thatisthe subjectof

the action,and is so situated thatdisposing ofthe action m ay as a practical
matterimpairorimpede the m ovant's ability to protectits interest,unless existing
parties adequately representthatinterest.
M ovantw asa m em ber ofthe classofplaintiffs represented by the Beck and Lee 1aw

fil'm .Pursuantto the tilingofthismotion,movanthereby giveswritten noticethathe is

term inating the lR etainerA greem ent''with Beck and Lee,w hich w as signed by m ovantbefore a

copyofthe Amended Complaint,(Doc.8),wasavailableforhisreview on July 17,2016.

A srequired by the rulesofintervention,m ovanthas attached asExhibit1,the pleading he
asks thatthe Courtorderbe filed upon granting of thisM otion. Expedition isrequested because
1

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 2 of 40

theDem ocraticNationalConvention endson July 28,2016,afterwhich itisunlikely thatany

reliefsoughtin ExhibitIcan be obtained.

M EM OM NDUM IN SUPPORT OF M OTIO N TO INTERVENE

A. INTRODUCTION
Exhibit1,movant'sf om plaintIn Intervention...,''setsforth thefactualbasisforthis
motion,and itishereby incorporated into thismem orandum asiffully setforth. Paragraphs2,
3,and 6 ofExhibitlclearly show thatBeck and Lee,plaintiffs'1aw tirm ,cannotpossibly
representmovantadequately. Paragraph 4 ofExhibitIsetsforth factualclaim sthatarenot
contained in Doc.8,Plaintiffs'FirstAmended Complaint. Paragraphs5 and 7-12 ofExhibit
allegenew claim sforreliefnotcontained in Doc.8.ExhibitIsatistiesa1lrequirementsof

FRCP Rule24(a)(2).
B. ARGUM ENT
Schonberg SatisnestheRequiremenl forIntervention ofRight

FederalRuleofCivilProcedureRule24(a)providesthatupontimelyapplication,anyone
shallbe perm itted to intervene in an action'
.
W hen the applicantclaim s an interestrelating to the property ortransaction w hich

isthesubjectoftheaction and theapplicantisso situated thatthedisposition of

the action m ay as a practicalmatterimpairor im pede the applicant's ability to
protect that interest,unless the applicant's interest is adequately represented by
existing parties.

Fed.R.Civ.P.24(a)(2).Foxv.Tyson Foods,Inc.,519F.3d 1298,1302-03(11thCir.2008)

(quotingChilesv.Thornburghn865F.2d 1197,1213(11thCir.1989));seealsoStonev.First

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 3 of 40

UnionCorp.,371F.3d 1305,1308-09 (11thCir.2004).

Here,movant'srequestforinterventionsatisfiestherequirementsofRule24(a)(2)for

interventionasofright.M ovanthasasubstantiallegalinterestinthesubjed matteroftheaction

becausehewasaform erplaintiffto theaction,asdocumented in the paperswhich movantsent
to Beck and Lee,including a signed retaineragreementand proofofmovant'scontributionsto
theBem ie Sanderscampaign.l M ovantisnotadequately represented by Beck and Leebecause
ofitsconflictofinterestand failureto seek any equitablereliefforM ovant. M ovanthasno
substantialinterestin m oney dam agesbecause hisclaim forthem is so sm all;m oreover,m ovant
hasdirectand signitk antinterestsin this action thatcannotbe adequately protected by existing
counselforplaintiffs.

1.

Schonberg'sM otion to InterveneisTim ely

n eEleventh Circuithas identified severalfactorsrelevantto determ ining w hethera

requestforintervention is tim ely'

.

(1) the length of tim e during which the proposed intervenor knew or
reasonably should have known of the interest in the case before m oving to

intervene;(2)the extentofprejudiceto theexisting partiesasa resultofthe

proposed intervenor's failure to m ove for intervention as soon as itknew or

reasonablyshouldhaveknownofitsinterest;(3)theextentofprejudicetothe
proposed intervenorifthe motion isdenied'
,and (4)theexistence ofunusual
circum stances m ilitating eitherfor or againsta determ ination thattheirm otion

wastim ely.

Georgiav.U.S.ArmyCorpsofEngineers,302F.3d 1242,1259 (11thCir.2002)(quoting Chilesn

865F.2d at1213).

lSeeEXHIBIT A,to theComplaintin lntervention.

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 4 of 40

Applying thesefactorsto theinstantcase,Schonberg'sapplication forintervention is

iled theirresponse to theAm ended Com plaint.
tim ely. 'I'hedefendantshave notyeteven t'
2.

M ovanthasa SubstantialLegalInterestin thisLitigation

Foranapplicant'sinterestinthesubjectmatterofthelitigationtobecognizableunder
Rule24(a)(2),itmustbetkdirect,substantialandlegallyprotectable.''U.S.ArmyCorpsof
Engineers,302F.3d at1249.Seealso Chiles,865F.2dat1212-13(notingthatthefoeusofa
Rule24inquiryisiwhethertheintervenorhasalegallyprotectableinterestin thelitigation.'')
The inquiry on thisissue tis Ea flexible one,which focuses on the particularfacts and

circumstancessurrounding each gmotion forinterventionl.'''Chiles,865 F.2d at1214 (quoting

UnitedStatesv.PerryColfnr.
vBd.ofEduc,567F.2d 277,279(5thCir.1978)).
M ovanthas a legally protectable interestin thislitigation. H e is a financialand

emotionalsupporteroftheBernieSanderscampaignforPresidentoftheUnited States(POTUS).
M ovanthasbeen cheated bythedefendants'fraud and misrepresentation such thatHillary

Rodham Clinton,(HRC),unfairly and illegally received moredelegatesto theDem ocratic

NationalConvention thanBernieSanders.PlaintiffsFirstAmended Complaint,Doc.8,doesnot
seek to rightthatwrong,butm ovant'sExhibit1does.
3.

The D isposition ofthe InstantLitigation W illIm pair the Ability ofM ovantto

ProtectH is Interest

M ovant'sopportunity to protecthissubstantiallegalinterestwillbeessentially
extinguished absentintervention. The D em ocratic N ationalConvention,com posed ofits
delegates,willnom inate itscandidate forPresidentnextw eek. A fterthattim e,itwilllikely be
futile form ovantto file a separate law suitseeking the redress setforth in Exhibit1. A nd the
filing ofa separate com plaintw illwaste the C ourt's resources,tim e,and m oney.

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 5 of 40

And theoutcomeofthiscase,including the potentialforappealsby existing parties,

im plicatesstare decisisconcernsthatwarrantmovant'sintervention.SeeStone,371F.3d at

1309-10(recognizingthatpotentialforanegativestaredecisiseffectEmaysupplythatpractical
disadvantagewhichwarrantsinterventionofright.''l(citingChiles,865F.2d at1214);seealso

United Statesv.Cityoff-XM Angeles,Cal.,288F.3d391,400(9thCir.2002)(holdingthat

amicuscuriae statusmay be insuftk ientto protecttherightsofan applicantforintervention

tbecausesuch statusdoesnotallow Ethe applicantlto raise issuesorargumentsform ally and

givesitnorightofappeal'').
4.

TheExisting PartiesDo NotAdequately RepresenttheUnited States'Interests

Thefourthand finalelementtojustifyinterventionofrightisinadequaterepresentation
oftheproposed intervenor'sinterestbyexistingpartiesto thelitigation.Thiselementissatisfied
iftheproposed intervenorStshowsthatrepresentation ofhisinterestEm ay be'inadequate.''

Chiles,865F.2dat1214 (citingTrbovichv.UnitedMine WorkersofAmerica,404 U.S.528,538

n.10(1972)).Theburdenontheproposedintervenortoshow thatexistingpartiescannot

adequatelyrepresentitsinterestistminimal-''Stone,371F.3d 1311'
,U.S.An'
nyCorpsof
Engineers,302F.3dat1259 (citingTrbovich,404U.S.at538n.10).Anydoubtconcerningthe
propriety ofallowing intervention should be resolved in favor ofthe proposed intervenors

becauseitallowsthe courtto resolve allrelated disputesin a singleaction.Lloyd v.Alabama

Dep'tofCorrections,176F.3d 1336,1341(11thCir.1999);FederalSav.andLoanIns.Corp.v.
FallsChaseSpecialFcxfng Dist.,983F.2d 211,216 (11th Cir.1993).
M ovantallegesin ExhibitIthatBeck and Lee only zealously representing them selves,

thatBeck and Lee haveviolated the rtllesofprofessionalconduct,thatBeck and Leehavefailed

to seek any equitable reliefform ovant,and thatBeck and Lee m ay have m ade unethical

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 6 of 40

m isrepresentationsto the Court. M ovant'sattorney-clientrelationship with Beck and Leehas

been severed forever.

CONCLUSIO N
Forthe foregoing reasons,the Courtshould grantSchonberg'sm otion to intervene asa

matterofrightpursuanttoRule24(a)(2)oftheFederalRulesofCivilProcedure.
D ated:July 21,2016

RESPECTFULLY SUBM ITTED BY

hN. JzS!
..

:...'.- .
.
.

g*
,'.

y
.
s,
(.'-,i'j
. zl
:
u
//
j
1 tzJ
''
>*
,
-:k .'
.

..e.

y.
)J.
,
.'
..,
.
,
.
-.
-.
'
----e'
a

g .r-.

..
..,..

Steve Schonberg,Pro Se
7938 SE 12thcircle
Ocala,FL 34480
352-789-0610
sschonberg@ aol.com

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 7 of 40

E X H IB IT 1

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 8 of 40

UNITED STATES DISTRICT CO URT

SOUTH ERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
FT.LAUDERDALE DIVISION

CASE NO.16-cv-61511-W JZ
STEV E SCH ON BERG ,Pro Se
7938 SE 12thCircle
Ocala,FL.34480
352-789-0610
sschonberg@ aol.com
Plaintiffin lntervention,

Com plaintin Intervention

TH E DEM OCRATIC N ATION AL COM M ITTEE
and ITS CH AIRW OM AN :
D EBBIE W A SSERM A N SCH U LTZ,
Defendants.

COM PLAINT IN INTERVENTION OF STEVE SCHONBERG FO R FRAUD AND

M ISM PM SENTATIONUESTO PPELnAND FOR AN EM ERGENCY INJUN CTION
PRO HIBITING THE DNC FROM NOM INATING HILLARY RODHAM CLINTON AS
THE DEM OCRATIC CANDIDA TE FOR PRESIDENT
lntroduction

This Com plaintin Intervention isbeing filed pursuantto the FederalR ules ofCivil
Procedure and the localrules ofthism ostHonorable Court. Intervenorfirsttiled a related case
in the U SD C for the M iddle DistrictofR orida,O cala Division in Schonberg etalv.Bernie

Sandersetal,CaseNo.5:09-cv-534-Oc-32-JRK. In thispriorcase,intervenorclaimed thatthe

FederalElection Campaign Actof1974 (6617ECA'')wasunconstitutional,and thatcom lption in

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 9 of 40

Congresswasgoing to preventaddpublic option''in health insurancefrom becominglaw .Bernie

Sanderswasnamed asadefendantonlybecause ofintervenor'shopethatSenatorSandersmight
agree on the record,in courq thatthere w as pervasive,extensive,unrelenting corruption of
m em bersofCongress because ofFECA . SenatorBernie Sandershasbeen a nationalproponent
ofelection refonn form any years,and intervenorhassupported him in thatendeavorforalm ost
a decade.

Paragraphs 1,153-173,185-205,229,231 and 232 ofDoc.8,plaintiffs'FirstA m ended

Com plaint,are true and are hereby adopted by reference asiffully setforth. Intervenor
Schonberg w as a m em berofthe 6sanders''class ofplaintiffsbefore he term inated the litigation
RetainerA greem entw ith Beck and Lee. A copy of the agreem ent,questionnaire,and proofof
donationsw hich intervenorsentto Beck and Lee on June 25,2016 is attached asEX H IBIT A .
2.

Paragraphs5,7,9,14,21,37,89 ofD oc.8 are adopted by reference because eitherthe

am ountofthe Sandersdonationsforthe individualsare incorrectly represented on D oc.8,or

there isan errorofaccounting show n by the individualsearches on the FederalElection

Com mission's(FEC's)website atfec.gov. Asexamples,see attached EXHIBIT B,(theW illiam

Franzsearch),andEXHIBIT C,(theW illiam Crandallsearchl.lNoneoftheindividuals

identified in theseparagraphscontributed morethan $200 to theBernieSanderscampaign
according to the FEC,contrary to the representation ofBeck and Lee in D oc.8. Beck and Lee,
eitherintentionally or negligently,m isrepresented the classm em bers'dollaram ountof
contributions to the Bernie Sanders cam paign forPresidentin the above paragraphs. Even

negligentm isrepresentationsto the Courtare violations ofthe rulesofethicsforattorneys.

lDue to a shortage oftim e,intervenorstopped searching fec.govforalleged high-dollardonorstotheSanders

campaign at%89ofDoc.8.M r.Crandallwasclaimedto havecontributed $21,705.34 in%37of

Doc.1and$1,705.34 in137 ofDoc.8,butExhibitC showsno contributionof$200 ormore,theminimum amount
required by the FEC to t'
ind the contribution on itssearchable database. Based on intervenor'sfamiliarity with
fec.gov,reportablecontributionsthatinclude34 centsinthetotalareextremelyrareorcompletelynon-existent.

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 10 of 40

lntentionalm isrepresentationsto the Courtaregroundsfordisbannent.

3.

W hen intervenor signed hisagreem entwith Beck and Lee,he believed thatBeck and Lee

wasgoingto representthem embersoftheclasstzealously''and twithin theboundsofthelaw,''

as required by the M odelRules ofProfessionalConductofthe Am erican BarA ssociation.
Instead,because ofan undisdosed conflictofinterest,Beck and Lee are zealously representing
them selves atthe expense oftheirclass m em bers.
CO U N T I
Intervenor's Claim s W hich Are N otInduded in D oc.8

HillaryRodham Clinton (HRC)isunt'itto becomethePresidentoftheUnited States

(POTUS)foratleastthefollowingreasons:
(a)AsSecretary ofState,HRC setup andusedaprivateemailservertoconduct
governm entbusiness. Thism atterw asextensively investigated by the FBland itsD irector,
Jam esCom ey. Director Com ey concluded thatH RC and heraides were Gdextrem ely careless in
theirhandling ofvery sensitive,highly d assitied inform ation.'' A lthough no crim inalcharges
w ere filed againstH RC ,the State Departm entprobe has been reopened.z No supporterofBernie
Sanders wantsan extrem ely carelessD em ocratic Nom inee forPO TU S, including intervenor.

(b)FBIDirectorCom ey continned theprobability thatHRC lied to Congressand tothe

Am erican publicwhen sherepeatedly said didn'tsend orreceive any e-m ailsthatwereclassified
t'atthe tim e.'' H RC also probably lied repeatedly by claim ing she had turned overallofher
Sdwork related''em ails,when D irector Com ey found hundreds thathad notbeen turned over.
H RC also probably lied in claim ing heruse ofa private serverand e-m aildom ain w as permitted

2See BBC reportathttp://ww w .bbc.co* news/election-us-2016-36742095.

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 11 of 40

by 1aw and regulation.Thisclaim wasrefuted by the State Departm ent'sInspectorGeneral.3Itis

likely thatthe 1781hasgotten orw illgeta referralfrom Congress to determ ine ifH RC

committedperjurywhenshetoldasubcommitteethat''therewasnothingmarkedclassitiedin
m y em ails.''4 Neitherintervenornorm ostotherBernie Sanderssupportersw anta liarw ho
m ightbe indicted astheirPOTU S nom inee.

(c)M illionsofdollarshavebeenspentinvestigatingHRC'Sextremecarelessnesswith
herhom eserver,including oneby JudicialW atchbecauseofHRC m ishandling documentsthat
should havebeen availablethrough theFreedom ofInfonnation Act. ln thatcase,USDC Judge

EmmetG.Sullivanremarked,iglltjustbogglesthemindthattheStateDepartmentallowedthis
circum stance to arise in the firstplace.''s Neither intervenornorm ostotherBernie Sanders
supporters wanttheirPOTU S candidate to have wasted tens of m illionsoftax dollarsbecause of

misconductoracandidatewho'smisconductStbogglesthemind''ofafederaljudge.
(d)HRC has,forthelastseveralmonths,receivedunfavorableratingsfrom thegeneral
population,fand herituntrustworthy''rating is overw helm ingly bad. Sixty-seven percentof
voters in a recentN Y T/CBS pollsay Siclinton isnothonestand trustworthy.''!!7 N either

intervenornorthemajorityofplaintiffswanttheDNC tofraudulentlyselectacandidatewhois
nothonestand trustw orthy. The defendantsshould know now ,and should have known a long

tim e ago,thatthey should notrig elections to selecta tloser''forthe D em ocratic N om inee for
POTU S. HRC isa loser.
3TheseHRC em ailstatementshavebeenextensivelycom mented uponin onlinem edia. See,e.g.
htto.
'//www.nationalreview.coe article/4376o6l illarv-clintons-eioht-em ail-lies-exposed-l
'ames-comev, and
httos'
.//en.wikipedia.orc/wiki/H illarv Clinton em ail controversy#FBl investigation.
4A referralhasbeen sentto the U .S.Attorney forW ashington,D.C .,http'
.//www .cbsnews.com/news/house-gopchairs-cftll-for-hillarv-clinton-perl
'urv-investication/
5Seehttpr//www.nytim es.com/zol6/o3/o3/us/politics/as-nresidential-camoaitrn-unfolds-so-do-inguiries-into-hillaryclintons-emails.htm l? r=0.
6Seehttn://www.pollincrepon.com/hrc.htm .
1Seehttn'
.//townhall.colm/tipsheevcuvbenson/zol6/o7/ls/nvtcbs-poll-hillarvs-untrustworthv-rating-soars-to-67percent-nzl92807

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 12 of 40

(e)IntervenorallegesthattheDNC tdsystem wasrigged''infavorofHRC andagainst

BernieSanderslong before aDemocraticprimary election washeld in any state. tilillary for
America''isthename oftheHRC principlecam paign comm ittee. tllillary V ictory Fund''is the

nameofajointfundraisingcommitteebetweenand amongHillaryforAmerica,theDNC,and
33 stateDem ocraticcom mittees.Here isasnip from theFEC fileproving thatthe Hillary

VictoryFundbeganasajointfundraisingcommitteebetweenHillaryforAmericaanddefendant
D NC :
JointFundralsing Bep- entatlve:

(g) 'M'M,' Ri
eOmmitt * 1
0E7
%(ms
co,nat
butkms,paysfuneaisirNexpen- arddlbursesnetpreeafortwoorrrreml
i
te
tm mid
tleastone olwhk)h isanatlthxize ctxnmitte olafe eralcandzate
.

(h)

Thi
s comrnitl
eecol
e are butils.paysftmdraieirN expensesanddi
sbursesnetprtx)e

commtee organizalns.Ixmeofwhe 1 an authorized O mmitteeofa federalcartklale.

for1% (x'rrrreIxHi
ti
cal

Committees Particlpating inJointFundraiser

I Il !5Y
F Ri
.I 1 1 1 l I 1
t
,
, t
j E I II
,1FEcIDnumbertC.
y cccszszgs
0NC SERVICES CORPORATIOND EMOCRATIC NATIONAL

! -> -

ICF I
'U
1I
XIEI l l
.I
1l I
.l 1.
11
. I l l 1 ! I l IFECIDnumber;'
,4,;s<yyrj(
1
70
(:uj1
1
06()3
.sc
.-a.-z.
jjn,
,
N.
sEr.E.
xs
tqjryAuk,,q:,:,:j).
..

l'- Ey
r1-e''''k<r
*r$>''t
;F'-p-Ns
>

'
d
.

jyoxqyzraralkz,p
sy,r
j:lyyyzyy;..;.
4j

EX H IBIT D hasadditionalsnips from the FEC t'ilings,show ing thatthe H illary V ictory Fund

began in Septemberof2015 and theDNC had raised millionsofdollarsforitselfand Hillaryfor

Am elica before the 2016 D em ocratic prim ary season had begun.8 Hillary Clinton w aspartand

parceltothefraudandmisrepresentation allegedinDoc.8and11above.Neitherintervenornor
m ostotherBernie Sanders supportersw anttheirPOTU S candidate to have com m itted fraud and
m isrepresentation.

5.

Butforthe fraud and m isrepresentation ofH RC and the D N C,Bernie Sanders would

havereceivedthemajorityofdelegateandsuper-delegatecommitmentsforsupportatthe

8DefendantW asserm anSchultzm usthave beentheinstigatorofthefraud and misrepresentationalleged in Doc. 8.

Herfraudwasm assive,intentional,and maydepriveBernie SandersofhisrightfulplaceastheDem ocraticnominee
forPOTUS.W assermanSchultzappearstohave violated 18 U .S. Codej 1341which makesfraudsand swindlesa
federalcrim e.Intervenorm ay t'
ileacrim inalcomplaintagainstherwhenhehastheopportunityatalaterdate.

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 13 of 40

DemocraticNationalConvention;and BernieSanders,notHRC,would bethepresumptive

POTUS nomineeofthe DNC beforethe convention beginsonJuly 25,2016.

C O U NT 11

Beck and Lee Violated Florida StateBarDisciplinary Rulesand

Failed to Divulge a HugeContlktofInterest.

On page2 oftheBeck and Leeretaineragreementin EXHIBIT A,Beck and Leeagreed,

df ounselshalldisclose to you anyconflictsassoon astheybecome known to the Counsel.''
Beck and Leeknew orshouldhaveknown thattherewasaconflictofinterestatthe tim eDoc. 8
w as tiled,because:

(a)Thevastmajorityofclassmembersgavelessthan$100totheBetmieSanders
cam paign. Bernie Sanders often said during the cam paign thatthe average contribution to his

campaign was64$27bucks.''

(b)Ifasettlementorjudgmentagainstthedefendantswereobtained,thevastmajorityof
theclassmem berswould receiveonly afew centson the dollaron thecostoftheircontributions
to Bernie Sanders.

(c)lfasettlementorjudgmentagainstthedefendantswereobtained,BeckandLeecould
eam m illionsofdollars in attorney feesaeven though m ostclass m em bers, including intervenor,
would only be awarded a few dollars in dam ages. The dam agesintervenorcould possibly
recoverare lessthan the costofpreparing and m ailing hism otion to intervene in thislaw suit.

(d)M ostdassmembers,including intervenor,believed thatthe prim ary pum ose ofthis

lawsuitw as to com pensate the class m em bersby obtaining a C ourtOrderpreventing the DN C

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 14 of 40

from nom inating HRC as the D em ocratic nom inee forPO TU S. Intervenorw as stunned when he
reviewed the docketin thism atter,and there w as nota single claim thatH RC w as going to
unfairly and inequitably becom e the D em ocratic nom inee in spite of widespread fraud and
m isrepresentation by the D N C and H RC.

(e)IfBeckand Leeadequatelyrepresentedintervenorandthousandsofotherclass
m em bers,itw ould have pled thatH RC 'S presum ptive nom ination w as based on fraud and

misrepresentation.And Beck and Leewould have demanded thatBernieSandersbecome the

DemocraticNomineebecauseHRC'Spresum ptive nomination isbased on fraud,
m isrepresentation and abuse by H RC and the insidersofthe D NC .Buthad Beck and Lee

succeeded in pursuingthesecontentions,itsclaim fora20% attorney feewould vanish.A1l

m em bers ofthe class action law suitwould be Gm ade w hole''if Bernie Sandersbecom es the
D em ocratic nom inee forPOTUS. N o m oney dam agesw ould flow .Beck and Lee outrageously
violated the conflictofinterestrule ofthe R orida Bar.9 Beck and Lee pum osely failed to plead

causesofaction to preventHRC from becomingtheDem ocraticNomineeforPOTUS becauseit

wascontrary to the econom ic interests ofB eck and Lee.

(9 The doctrine ofestoppel,in itsbroad interpretation,preventsaperson and an entity

from benefitting from theirown w rongdoing.The D N C and HR C are estopped from benefitting

bytheirperversion ofthenllesoftheDNC assetforth int

I1,above. Beck and Leeknew or

9 Rule 4-1.7 ofthe Rules ofProfessionalConductofthe Florida Bar states:

(a)Representing AdverseInterests.Exceptasprovided insubdivision (b),a lawyermustnotrepresentaclientif:

(l)therepresentationoflclientwillbedirectlyadverse to anotherclient'
,or
(2)thereisasubstantialriskthattherepresentation of1ormoreclientswillbemateriallylimited bythe
lawyer'
sresponsibilitiesto anotherclient,aformerclientorathird personorby apersonalinterestofthe
lawyer.

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 15 of 40

should haveknown theirlawsuitwasan unethicalttm oney grab''forattorney feesbecausethe

law firm failed to allege estoppelorany othertheory in Doc.8 to preventHRC from becoming
theDemocraticNominee forPOTU S.

(g)BeckandLeeknew whentheyaskedintervenortobecomeamemberoftheclassthat
ithad violated the term sofitsow n agreem entin EX HIBIT A by failing to disclose its conflictof
interest. Atthe very least,Beck and Lee should have tried to obtain intervenor's inform ed
consentto itsrepresentation in the presence ofa conflictofinterest.

(h)TheCourtshouldappointclasscounselotherthanBeck andLee,sothataSecond
AmendedComplaintcan befiled alleging equitablereliefrequiring BernieSanderstobe the
D NC 'Snom inee forPO TU S. Intervenoragreesto be a m em ber ofthisclass as willthousandsof
otherplaintiffsin thislaw suit.

COUNT III
D efendantD N C Is Estopped and Prohibited from N om inating H illary Rodham Clinton
to be the D em ocratic N om inee for Presidentofthe U nited States.
Each and every paragraph above ishereby restated and incorporated asif fully setforth.
8.

HRC received a greaterdelegate countthan Bernie Sanders because the dem ocratic

prim ariesweretrigged''in favorofHRC dueto thedefendants'fraud and misrepresentation.

Defendantsknew before and duringthe pdm ary season thattheDNC wassupporting HRC with
m oney and voterturnoutto the detrim entofthe Bernie Sanderscam paign.
By rigging the D em ocratic caucusesand prim aries in favorofH RC and againstBernie
Sanders.the DN C violated its charter. Butdespite the rigged elections, the delegate countw as
very close,w ith H RC getting 2205 delegates and Bernie Sandersreceiving 1846 delegates.lo

10See httpr//www .bloomberc.coe politics/craphics/zol6-delecate-tracker/

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 16 of 40

10.

M athematicalanalysiscan detenninehow much apresidentialcam paign spendsto obtain

the supportofa single delegate. The H illary V ictory Fund w as illegaland contrary to the charter

oftheDNC. Attached asEXHIBIT E isthe 2 yearsumm aryoftheHillary Victory Fund. lt

shows$42m illion in expenses,ofwhich 2/3rdsorabout$28m illion wentto payexpensesvia

theHillary forAmericacommittee.l1 And $22 millionofthetrp ansfersto Affiliated

Committees''wenttotheHillaryforAmericacommittee,(seeattachedEXHIBIT F,the2year
summaryoftheHillaryforAmericacommittee.) EXHIBIT F alsoshowsexpendituresof$192
m illion,which is the num erator in the fraction to determ ine costperdelegate,w ith the

denominatorbeing the 2205 delegatesofHRC. The costperdelegateforHRC is$192 million

divided by 2205,or$87,000perdelegate.
11.

Had theDNC prim ariesnotbeen rigged,the $22 million illegally received bytheHillary

for Am erica from the H illary V ictory Fund would nothave occurred. Butforthe rigged election,
HRC w ould have obtained only 1954 delegates and Bernie Sandersw ould have received 2097
delegates based on the sim ple m ath ofcam paign expenditures perdelegate.lz
lntelwenor,like m ostofthe plaintiffs,has been cheated outofthe nom ination oftheir

POTUS candidate,Bernie Sanders,by the defendants'm isconduct. The law suitfiled by Beck
and Lee isutterly uselessto intervenor.The law suittiled by Beck and Lee failsto requestany

equitablereliefso thattheDNC mustnom inateBernieSandersasitscandidate forthePresident

ofthe U nited States.

llSeehttos://www .washinctonpost.coe nolitics/democratic-pany-fundraisinc-et'

fod-helps-clinton-Gnd-new-donorstoo/20l6/02/l9* 8535cea-d68f-l1e5-bl95-2e29a4el3425 story.htm l
12IfClintonforAmericahadn'treceived the $22millionfrom theHillaryVictoryFund, itsexpenditureswould have

decreased from $192millionto $170 million. $170 milliondivided bythe$87,000costperdelegate= 1954

delegatesforHRC.Thiscalculation doesn'teventakeinto accountthe$28 millioninexpensesfrom theHillary
V ictory Fund forthe benetitofHillary for America.

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 17 of 40

PRAYER FOR RELIEF

W HEREFO RE,Intervenorprays forthe follow ing relief:

FordeclaratoryjudgmentandimmediateEM ERGENCYinjunctivereliefenjoiningthe
defendants from opposing the nom ination ofBernie Sandersasthe Dem ocratic N om inee for
Presidentofthe United States.

B.

Fordeclaratoryjudgmentand immediateEM ERGENCYinjunctivereliefenjoining

defendantDN C from nom inating Hillary Rodham Clinton as the D em ocratic Nom inee for
Presidentofthe United States.

Fordeclaratoryjudgmentandinjunctivereliefdeclaringillegalandenjoiningdefendants'
violation ofand failure to follow the Charter and Bylaw s ofthe Dem ocratic Party;
D.

Foran O rderpreventing Beck and Lee from becom ing classcounselbecause oftheir

conflictofinterestand violation ofthe RulesofProfessionalConductofthe R orida Bar.

E.

Foran Orderrequiring Beck and Lee to give notice and access to a1lclass m em bers ofthe

filing ofthisCom plaintin Intervention.

Foran O rderrequiring Beck and Lee to give noticeto a11classm em bersofBeck and

Lee'sm isrepresentation and conflictofinterestthatw asnotdivulged in the Attorney-client

Retaineragreem entsigned by the m em bers ofthe class.

G.

Foran Orderappointing classcounselotherthan Beck and Lee who can competently

representtheclassmem bersso thata Second Amended Complaintcan befiled with claim s

proving thatBernie Sandersis the only legitim ate nom inee forPresidentofthe U nited Statesof

the Dem ocratic N ationalCom m ittee.

H.

Foran O rderrequiring Beck and Lee to provide allofits inform ation to new class

counselin regard to every one ofitsproposed classm em bers.

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 18 of 40

1.

Foran Ordernotifying theFloridaBarofBeck and Lee'sprobable violationsofthe bar's

Rules ofProfessionalConduct.

W hateverotherandadditionalrelieftheCourtdeemsjust.

RESPECTFULLY SUBM IU ED BY:

/s/Steve Schonberg
Steve Schonberg,Pro Se
7938 SE 12tbCircle
Ocala,FL 34480
352-789-0610
Em ail: sschonberg @ aol.com
-

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 19 of 40

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 20 of 40

B E C K

&

L E E

tr Ia 1 Ia w y * r s m ia m i
C orporate Park at Kendall
12485 SW 137th A venue, Suite 205
M iam i,Florida :
53186

TEL:305-234-2060
FAx.:786-664-3334
w w w .beck.ndlee.com

June 18.2016

Re: DNC Fraud ClassAttionLa- ult- Attorn*yc lientRe -iner

> arCli
ent:

On behal
fofBeck & Lee TrialLao ers,Law Omces ofGulli
n O'Brien,P.
A .and M tonino

Hernandez,P.A.(colledively,rounsel
*),wewanttothankyotlformeoqpodunik to

representyouasa propoe plaine andclassrepresentative inconnee onwi

thyour
potentialdaimsagainstthe DemocraticNationalCommi
ttee and anyQtherafsliated

enti
tiesorpersonsCdefendantse),inconneeonwi
ththe Dema Ncprimariesof20152016 Ct-itigation*).
Fee M re mentand Costs
You willnot* - ponsible forany attorneys'G- orex- nles thatthe Counsel
incursincon- tionwiththisma- .Counselwillprosecuteyourclaimsona
con:ngencyfeebasisand advan aIIout-of-pocketcostsnecessaryforvi
gorousand
e#ecjve representati
on.
Allattorneys'fees in a certied classadi
on mustbe approved by the M lrt.Counsel
wilbecompensate basedonacoud-awarde reasoneble f* ,orcome nsation not
excee ing 33 1/3% ofthe totalrecovery in the Li
tigaKon asordered orapproved bythe
Coud.whicheveri
shige r.Inaddi
tion,Counselwillalso ---Kreimbursementofany
c0st:whichwe incuronyourO hal
ffrom thesameDnd,oralK dire ye m te
defendanl by agreementorCuud order.
Cosl may include,among o*erexpenses.o urtfiling fees,transcriptand deposiKon
costs,O mputerizedIegalresearchcosts, stsofreproduciY documenK,parkingand
travelcosts,feeswhi
ch accountank orexpertwiM- q-s retai on yourM halfcharge
us.and o> rsimilarexa nditures.Coun- lhave agre to> n st10 cosl andto

e--kreimbu mentOnN through an application tome Coud.

MutualResx nsibili
ti
es
Counselwillprovi
de the Iegalservi- q which are considered appropriateforthe matter
and in arM rdan wi
* prevailing standards.You willbe reasonabl
y available to O nfer
wi
thtlsuponm uest,wi
llprovideuswithsuchdM lmentsandinformaNon asyoumay
possessrela:ngtothe matter,willdisclose allfactsand circumstan sofwhichmay

Elizapelh Lee Beck' Esq. ) enzabeth*beckandlee.com I 305-234-2060

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 21 of 40

DNC Fl-audClassActionLawsuit
June 18.2016
Page2of2

bearupon ourhandling ofthe matter,and willothefwise assistoureffoftsas we request

orrequire.
You recognize thatthe Counselis representing otherindivi
duals orentiti
esin this
Ii
ti
gation and agree thatany conflictscaused by such representati
on are waived.

Fudhermore,you,asthe representativeplaintiftmustbe abl

e to representthe interests
ofthe classfairly and adequately and withoutany confli
ct-of-interestwith class
members. Counselshalldiscl
ose to you any conflids as soon as they become known
to the Counsel.
Termination

Counselantici
pates a Iong and mutuall
y,satisfactory relati
onshi
p. However,you have
the ri
ghtto term i
nate this li
tigation RetainerAgreementby giving us written notice, Ifyou
term i
nate this Retai
nerAgreement,you willhave no fudherobli
gati
on to us related to

thismatter.We also have the ri

ghtto terminateourengagementW gi
ving youwri
tten

notice i
fthe Counseldeterm ines thatcontinuing to representyou inthis Ii
tigation would
be unethi
cal,impradi
cal,i
m proper,oroutside the bestinterests ofthe class.Ifwe are
compell
ed to withdraw foranyofthese reasons,you willhave no furtherobl
igationto us
rel
ated to this matter.
Pl
ease revi
ew this agreementcarefully.lfthisagreementaccuratel
y reseds your
understanding ofourattom ey-clientrelati
onship,pl
ease i
ndi
cate yourapprovaland
acceptance by signi
ng bel
ow and returning i
tto me.W e look forward to working wi
th
you on this matter.
StatementofClient's Riqhts
Pl
ease read the copy ofthe StatementofCli
ent'
s Ri
ghts,attached hereto as Exhi
bitA,
before si
gning thisAgreement,and Dutiesofa Cl
ass Representative.attached hereto
as Exhibi
tB.

Very trul
y yo rs,
A
z''l

r...7
.

.'
''
wJ
. .

z'
El
izabethLee Beck, Esq.
Forallcounsel

Encls.

Agreed to by Client:
Steven Schonberg
Name:

Signature:
B E c K & Le E

12485 5;W 1:17th A venue,Su1tt' 2()5 l M iam i, Flo ritla 33186 I 305-234-20f:t)

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 22 of 40

CONFIDENTIAL- ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVIV GED

DNCFRAUDCLASSAW ION G W SUITQUESTIONNAIREFORCLIENTS(2PAGES)

Nam e

Address

Steven Schonberg
7938 SE 12t circle, Ocala,FL 34480

Email

sschonberc@ aol.com

Best# where you canbe

reached
Did you donateto the
Dem ocraticNational

352-789-0610
Idon'tthink so,butIdid donateto Berni
e,alwaysthru Act
Blue.

Commi
ttee?(Youmayhave
donated directl
y through their
website atwww.democrats.org,

orpossiblythroughActBlue)
w hen,and how much,did you
donate to the DNC?
How did w udonateto the DNC?

(checkinthemaitthrough
website,ActBlue,etc.)
Did you donate to Bernie's

Yes

campaign? (thisisalmost
alwaysdonethroughActBlue)
W hen,andhow much,didyou About$120splitoverseveraldonationsinthepastyear.
donate diredlyto Bernie?
How didyoudonateto Bernie?

AdBlue

(ActB1ue.mailedachecktohis
campaign,etc.)
Are ouaBerniesupporter? Y/N Y
Haveyou everdonated to Hillary NOI

Clinton'scampaignls)?
Anythingelsew uwould Iike us
to know?

Iftherewascollusion between the DNC and HillaryClinton's

cam paign to the benefitofHillaw Elinton.then Hillary
Clinton and hercampaign should be nam ed asdefendantsin
thisIawsuit.

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 23 of 40

Steven Schonberg PartialEvidenceofPoliticalDonationsto 2016 PresidentialRace

From American ExpressCard Statements

'M.G G PAA< aO

(- &/1s

.LA

* *<- D 1l KA I< TY

?T

$2:s*

@:$42:?-J
Y :tm * @Y.J c x
. #M * K*

es/zo/ls

ACT:tkE*@tAy.t-&htyE*1J.>1;.zb@Q A.x
61/.51?.'<

$lco;

SouthwestVisa2016
(::5QS
(k
('Q4
()$(14

IG KUE'D:,Y TETOLG G a'''k<x..r.c,''r'l,M.

aKWRDE'
X'Y TETSDW-MSE:tApoe.czafq1.$:

K'TKtlr D3*X'
CET'D!:*A.tSAf.rtkhorx..rIL1%

4 AC-BUJE BERhlF.se N attpkyAciutrmm

U K X BERNIESAY ERS 617.517M

VG

IQDQ
!()X
1(1.
X
!0.X

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 24 of 40

E X H IB IT B

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 25 of 40

E X H IB IT C

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 26 of 40

* 't.jj

N.

m
;
=

m
T
=

=
;
=

-Nl

:
F
I
F
D: L
>
z

>
:<

t
5
c1
o
G
*

(
5
k
z

-1

O
Z
tn

F
:

m
; m
;
z =

m
B
z

>1

>

.p4 .
%1

pl

>z

x
F1

x
>! x
F!

x
>!

x
F!

>
r
z

=
Z
77
q
m
%
5

'
D
Z
7)
q
m
%
;

r
Z
77
q
m
%
5

=1
m
O
=d
m
>
=
c)

m
Om
=d
rn
=
>
tn

m
m
O
=1
m
=
>
tn

m
>

.
>

.
>

l
%
Q
C
D

m
B
=

ea

To
m
;
t
z
=
Nl

%
F
L!

m
<
=

>
D;
z

q
o.
s

>

>

Ng
o

tg
o;

&

m
g
o

r
='c
o
i
.
n
Q
<=
'
kc

r
o-m
;;
Q
()
r(
s
p
on
Z

=
om
;;
>
C
3
(
)
=
=
v
oo
D

=
m
o
.
=
mm
m

=
m
j)
z
mn
r
m

V
mO
Z
f
)
=
Ez
*

>
=
(
p

>
z
(
p

>
r

o
g

u;

(
oz:
m
=
%
m
o
>

>
z

u
-)

nm
<
=
sl
%

=
r
=

>

>
z

u
+).

m
;
z

hk

%
F
r
>
:<

>

a
o

m
%
=

sa

uz
>
u)
e.

c
o)5
I
%
o
g

c
o);
=
Z
3X
>
t
n
m
'
>
-

(
on;
I
>
m
o
g

;t
o
z

tn

tn

uu
n
tn)
h
x
NJ N)
t
, u)

z!
o
=

r
><
:
(n
op
(
>d
I
m
t
n
>

<
>

I
<
>

a
<
>

Mm
=
>

n
- zQ

4
-

e 3.
W
:

q
7
>: ' >.
r
' Q
c
>
o
j
z+
c
e
:
c
<
Q
w

m
;
=
?
%
z
)

=
o
M
m
w
I

m
7
m
:
<

p
*
. n
. Q

m=
a
=o
-1
ro
.
m<
o

m
c
m
o
m
o=

y
a
>
<
-

>

I
<
>

=
>

1
j
-.

>
a

.
x
' Mo
.
@
t
* x
o

-'- .

7
j M
'
>
' >
. X

<
>

>
-*

o
.
Q
2
s.
Z
vo

o
.
'
d
s
2a
o
i-

Na
kn

o
o

.< c7

o
.
e
o
t
o
o

7
(
'
7
M
o

c
*
o
tt
c
o
o

>
.
'
d
u;
Q
o

s.

o
4!
.
,w
2
o
sa

to

N)
N
J

tn
Gl

K)
(
D

NI
&

Q
xa
t
o
ew

7
,z
'
2
cp
co

e
o
sa
1
.
o
o

= '
< '<

o
%
sa
2
o
&

o
.
I
d
o
2
o
ew

e'

B
u
.
'
d
c)
o

. -*
7
m
. n
Q

'
< . j
.

&
b
o

o
b
&

r
o
o

r
&
>

r
=
&

o
i
o
D

'
o<

D
i
o
D I

&>
o
b
o
.

o
to
D
i
o
&

tu
o
b
c

tn
c
o
i
p
&

SA

*.

NJ
o
&
B
D

o
(
oD
b
o

>

N
m
* >.

>
zj
o
m
z
m
<

'
to
h
ta

;
o
n
.
m
c<

-u

c
o
a
r
On

hu

ch

Y
-

c
yj

hz
cl

rn=
m
m r
m7m
= m
(
nm
= m; r
mny
om om om n m n '
n
n
z
y
)
c
o
cm
o
m
m
m
o
(
7
o
(
p
a
m
z
r=
n
m
r=
n -m1>
=
xm
-1x
>
-#
-1
-1 o o
p
%
p
O
= O
z
z
a
,

xm
p<

uz
>
.q
4

cp
o
>

F
;
n

nk
(
>
o

nm
m
=
om
gl
q7
m
=1
%'

>
rz
z
(n
m
<
tn
l
>
'
I
a

M
-1

k>
o
e
u)
e>

;t
o
=

>
rz >
;z
a
z
c (7
>
>
r- =
:

m
r

-*

>

*
@

G
*
o
=

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 27 of 40

Xm

Ym

r;
u=

>
IM
M
r'x=
m
m
t-

p;
rc

fm
mI
r=

TF
m
m
w
P

r-'
z
.*.
w
.
ua
m

>M
N
M

m
.

>M
N
A

f=
pl
r=

>m
N
A
mF

fm
sl
rc

Im
p;
u=

'

.=

>m
N
z

>m
N
z

xm %= Im 1= 1=
pl
p; ar ar
B
u= n=
m c mc
=
>m
n
z
wc

>m
N
z
=

.>
x
F!
u
>
:<

am

xm

am

@
x
F1
u
>
:K

r7
m
<

c)
m
<

K r7
;K =

>
c

n
=

= r7
rn o

>1
r
'
=

>1
r'
r'

m
>1
r-

-#
m

=z
-1

N
:
F1
c
><
:

'-

>
x
p!
c
>
:r

x
F!
u
>
?

>
x
p!
u
>
M

'

t
n1
r-

tn
1
r-

Z
m

Z
(p

(7

ua

mn
t
(;
&

n
U

G
m

71
m
rc

to

o
o
tn

o
o
un

(
m
p

tn
m

:
K

q
r'
n
:r
F

:r
&
:
<
;
R

m7
:

m7
t

m7

o
<

C
)
<

(
7
<

=
<

m
o(
%
(7m
p

G
m7

ok
m
om

< (p
m
tn-m1
m

< (p

m
bnm1
x

=
co
.
<
.<

xny
r

n
co
m
m-m.
t
'
n
H
-Yt
>
mz

r7
m

t
a
m
<

(>
m
<

m1
m
Q

.
m
H
n
71

'
>d
rr-

>1
rr-

tn

m
fCl

tn
>
m
m

tO
>
s
m

im
>
m

to

m<
m
-

>
m

(
p1
z

n
C)

z3
(

:<
L

p!

p:

p!

p:

7
ko

oa

oa
p.
e
.
qp

ua
o
o
un

k,
o
o
=

cp
o
+
.
.>

cp
cp
gx

cp
co
e
a
w

o
o
.
.
.>

o
o
e
a
.w

=
.<
u
p
qo

=
-1:
=r
m<
;rZn

=
-1=
m<
TrZx1

r
tn

p
=
(7
m.
e

m
m
X
t
x

<
m
%
M m<
N1

c
ou

K
%
m<

>
m

>n :x
t
<
tn

;
R''
>
(
-p
1r'

=
-

*
E
z

>
w

r
7
m

mg
&m
M
f
2
n
7o;t

%m

oM

==
CD=$
X
m
m
(
'
p
d>
%

m
(5

(
w
p
C3

op

G3cc
m m>
H
71
m
z
o

z
=

uz
cp

un
w
x
a
sa

n
x)
5.
,

t:

m
>e
i
n
>

tmn

(n

cj

==
Mw
=m
<=
my
>
m<
m - cm
m ;
:2 KK co
m m
o
t
ao
nr ao
=
m r-
-1
m
'H

-1

r
Un

:
>
m
o
=
m

m
=
m
:
.
o
z

>
<
*

'%

-Q

r(7

:q
o

;
Dr
>.
1'
(
p
.
e-

(7 o
z

o
=
m

m
c

mm
co
ma
1>

<

-1

e
*
t*

r
n
<
-

n
>
*

<
>

X
>

<
>

<
>

<
>

<
>

Q.
c
=

> >
x x
F F!
c u
>
:< >
z
X

tn1
c

C7

u)

&
c
o
un

zm m
m
. ;
r
=
=

<
>

'
,

>

N
)
i
(
r
.
z
x
ip
W

c
Q
xa
k!
oa
o
s

7
'
.'
J
.
'
4
o
o
ko

e
&
D
&
&
cp

tn
o

o
=

&
kn

i
o
&

b
o

b
o

e
o
o
x
c
o

>

tn
o
B
o

&
'
z
c
p
e
k
mo

&
e
..
e
k
ko
o

&
e
s,
.
'
z
&
o

&
e
w
e
o
p

C
.
q
sa!
.
'
d
o
&

.
,
z
;
!
o
o

O
.
k
t
;
o
o

&
e
o
.
:
o
o

&
e
..
'
z
c
o

D
.
k
s,
.
'
4
o
&

&
.
q
'
o
.
k
&
o

c
'
.
4,
x
e
N
KD
o

&
o
b
o

cp
&
b
o

=
o
b
o

kn
o
b
o

&
o
b
o

>
c
i
p
o

o
&
b
o

o
c
b
c

o
D
b
o

o
o
b
o

o
o
i
o
o

o
o
b
o

4x

>

4x

?<

>

%<

cp

tu

hu

4x

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 28 of 40

E X H IB IT C

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 29 of 40

'

Contributions to M 1 Other PoliticalCom m ittees Except Joint Fundraising Com m ittees

:

* .4 *

.. *

CRANDALL,

MISSOULA MT

59808

MODERN

CRANDALL,

SAN MATEo cA

94402

COLLE
MATE
OGE OFSAN

WILLIAM
W ILLIAM

CRANDALL,

SAUSALITO CA

94965

CRANDALL,

SAUSALITO (2A

94965

WILLIAM

WILLIAM

CRANDALL
WILLIAM B,.

PALM CITY

CM NDALL,

PALM CITY

CRANDALL,

LEAW OOD

WILLIAM B. MR.
WILLIAM F

CRANDALL,

WILLIAM J

CRANDALL,
WILLIAM J
CRANDALL,
W ILLIAM J
CRANDALL,
W ILLIAM J
CRANDALL,
W ILLIAM J
CRANDALL
W ILLIAM J,
CRANDALL?
WILLIAM J

INCLINE

VILLAGE

34990

KS
NV

ROCHESTER NY

SMITHKEU LEWELL

N/A

. .

VP

SCIENTIS

14625

ROCHESTER NY

14625
14625

CDNGRESS
MARTIN,JAMES

. ''

. ''

250.00

11020151185

1000.00

99034731483

200.00

28020820740

ACTBLUE

10/19/2009

-15.00

29935478481

02/14/2008

500.00

28931145685

HARRELL,

500.00 201510209003213222

ATF 09/25/2008

250.00

28020633497

12/02/1997

250.00

98032660659

Y VIA FRIENDS OF
SENATOR DIAMATO (1998 03/31/1998

1000.00

98020080748

lNC
NATIONAL RFPUBLICAN
CONGRESSIONAL

COMMITTEE

CONTRIBUTIONS
D'AMATO,ALFONSE

ROCHESTER
LIQUOR

COMMITTEEI
LAZIO. RICK A VIALAZIO 08/07/2000
2000 lNC
LAZIO, RICKA VIALAZIO 09/04/2000
2000 INC
I-AZIO.RICKA W ALAZIO 09/04/2000
2000
INC
SCHUMER,CHARLES

EBER BROTHERS

'' .

11/25/2008

RETIRED
DEVELOPER

FRANCISVIA MARTIN
FOR SENATE INC

GAYLE HARRELL
MAGGACHUSFTTS
MUTUAL LIFE INSURANCE
09/21/2015
COMPANY POLITICAL
ACTION COMMITTEE
ROBFRTS.FPAT
VI
PAT
ROBFRTS
OR (J
SASEN

ROCHESTER NY

GAYLEVIAFRIFNDS OF

8945

14625

RETIRED

vs: Auurx spoup REAL ESTATE

ROCHESTER NY

W A TOM CAMPBELLFOR 03/02/1999

66208

14625

*e
'

SELF

14625

TFSTER,
J
ON VIAMO
NTANANS FOR 03/09/2011
TESTER
CAMPBELL
,THOMAS
J

34990

ROCHESTER NY

ROCHESTER NY

MACHINERY

GE
NERAL
MANAGER

2000.00
1000.00

20020270459

21020062037

1000.00

21020062037

VIA FRIENDS OF

07/19/2001

SCHLIMER
GEPHARDT.
RICHARD
AVI
A GEPHARDT
FOR

1000.00

22020130529

01/14/2004

2000.00

25990165560

10/27/2003

200.00

24961284284

1000.00

25980175754

2000.00

24162752467

03/16/2002

250.00

22990703658

09/06/2012

250.00

13020040520

07/10/2014

250.00

14970095657

PRFSIDENT.INC.

CRANDALL,

WILLIAM J BRIG. DELAND

GEN.
CRANDALL,
WILLIAM J MR

ROCHESTER NY

32724

RETIRFD

RETIRED

14625

BES
TEFFORTS
MADE

MADE

EBER BROS.
ROCHESTER

GENERAL
MANAGER

NRCC

NANCY
BEST EFFORTS 8NAPLES,
VIANANCY
NAPLES FOR 10/25/2004

CONGREGS
BUGH.GEORGE
q
1
VIABUS
fPRI
MARYJH-CHENEY 04 11/24/2003

CRANDALL,
WILLIAM J MR.

ROCHESTER NY

CRANDALL,

DE LAND

32724

PALMCI7'
Y

34990 BEST
REQUE
STEDPER PER
REQU
ESTED EVIAFISCAL
EFFO
BEST EFF RESPONSIBILITY PAC

PALMCITY

34990 SYSTEM

W ILLIAM J. GEN.
CRANDALL

WILLIAMjjR
CRANDALL

WILLIAMjjR

14625

MICAO OHN L.
MR

USAF

. W AMI
CA FOR
CONGRESS

RETIRED/RETIRED
INFORMATION
MARTIN HEALTH

INC

INFORMATION BROW N.SCOTT

TRUSTEF

AMERICAN HOSPITAL

ASSOCIATIONPAC

HUNTS-MAN,JON VIA JON

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 30 of 40

CRANDALL,
WILLIAM MR.

PAL

M CI7Y FL

CRANDALL,
SAN MATFO (7.A
WILLIAM W .PROF,

34990

94402

RETIRED

CSM/PROFESSOR

RETIRED

HUNTSMAN FOR

07/14/2011

PRESIDENT INC.
MCCAIN, JOHN

500.00

12950031034

02/07/2000

500.00

20990075160

S.W AMCCAIN 2000INC

TotalContributions:

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 31 of 40

E X H IB IT D

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 32 of 40

@.

>

.
'

Jurnp To 2016

New Search

Ex- ope s:

h<: J
x
as 1
.
,
1
4
.
1
4
.
:
)
j j
k
j;
:
;
i
.

Meodan

zMk LA

2%

Name:HILLARY VIG ORY FUND

Address:PO BOX 5256,NEW YORK, NY 101855256
Treasurer Name:JONES,EUZABETH

'rype:N -NON-QUALIFIED NON-PARTY

Designation:J -JOINT FUNDRAISER
Part#:
2:16
#.

'

*q

StatementOfOrganization
AprilQuarterly
AprilQuarterl
y -LobbyistBundlingReport
lul
yQuarterly
J
yQuarterly/Semi-Annual-Lobbyist
Bul
undling Report

a
: * :-:

Amend
New
New
New
New

-. #

07/01/2016
04/15/2016
04/15/2016
07/15/2016
07/15/2016

#. -

01/01/2016
01/01/2016
04/01/2016
04/01/2016

. :.

03/31/2016
03/31/2016
06/30/2016
06/30/2016

* ..* . * ...

..'

40
6801
2
19497
6

201607019020110028
2916041.59912546036
201604159012556278
2016071.5902@621332
201607159020642049

:.

. #

PDF HTML / FEC- 1080677

PDF HTML/ FEC-1064@@8
PDF HTML/ FEC- 106410*
PDF HTML / FEC-15@7146
PDF HTML/ FEC- 1087181

'

2415
#4

zx
*

''4

StatementOfOrganization

. '' :''.

New

StatementOfOrganization
Amend
StatementOfOrganization
Amend
OdoberQuarterly
New
Year-End
New
Quarterl
y YearEnd/Semi-Annual-Lobbyi
st New
Bundlin: Report

'' #

@. ..

g y. .
.

09/10/2015

*/16/2015
11/02/2015
10/15/2015 07/01/2015 09/30/2015
01/31/2016 10/01/2015 12/31/2015
01/31/2016 10/01/2015 12/31/2015

@ .@.

*... . . ....

.
'

4.

e..

4 201509109081633570 pDF HTML/ 12E(2- 1024437

35 2o1s0916@@Q2G8@6os
34 20151182908326123*
41 201510159003076346
s
e'
f:1.6=201601319:05283302
3 201691319(m5281865

PDF HTML/ FEC-1024@@2

PDF HTML / FEC- tOBIGOB

PDF HTML/ FEC-10295*4

PDF HTML/ 1
:E(:-1047317
pDF HTML/ 1
:E42-1047313

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 33 of 40

#'

>c

d .

d *

c*

m '

c .

&

%
#'

>

>

+Q

#*
*
>

N *

d'

d.

c
@
e
m
e)

R
e

*
*

r c
a

e
64

o
r

l!

m
o

=i y
c

O
+

s D

.
1
*

X
*

I
<

I:
2
E

?
'j
>

I
W
t I
I
I
El E

q =

<D a
W <s

r
v

l
c

N!
:
t)

!
a
!
1
!x1
.
1
: ,1
;'

! j
oj y jj
l
*1
k
:N* z -. 1 :P w*
c
O

'

m Ea
g

O'
j
*

oz
;
E: O Z o
:d

?m EE a

d#

az! z!
c

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 34 of 40

E X H IB IT E

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 35 of 40

-i11
@d
=
*

:1

c l

D kn
*!>.
2
V
a:
zo

i'5 *
= t6
c u
x
*

a r-*
x =9 C)E

!
1
>

.1 ;c
O

k
* kp
% o.

x O *1

O *

* j

g 'E
tto oE

(:
)L)
u
c
o2 =
w
m= 0

c
0g
D 'k

QJ

%D Xu
:k
9 =w
:0 (7
Z '
=* Wo
:72
'!

WD
:P
:=k

E :k

3=
m N N N
- m
N
& M
- &
N m& *>
+

V
*
*
D

CD F1 fn
*
*

* V
*

R m n

c c c - o c c o c c o
+ * * * * N
N * * * >
* N
*
&
m

Y
N
%

c &

*.

o o o m
* * N >

N
$ >w

t t

R
C< q
(N .

V %
G *

c c o c c m o o n
* * * * * * * 0 *
q
Rn
m o

*
*

#' #'
* *

*
*

%
t'
1
; -y
: I
o m

=2
.
.

@
F1

X
'
g
v

lD ?.?

.
:
:
>

>>1

uxj

<
u

=
h =

eod =oH

X
c
o

'

c
=Y

m
o
+k
z
O

m=

'
''
%b
xA
;S ;
'S

* ?z
.

'

Z E
Q (E
7
Q)

r
*

Q e

d
Q
q)

'k

21!:,X

;=K
p: xb
1

'Q E
:m
kq
E)

u v- 'u
* &
>'

Q ro
*o
t
?
E F- = .a

X:: z
e

$
;
:
l < ut J . ..
'0::..j
-i

t
< = ac:

je-E
c
*G
o
E c
* = c

z
x
M.
<

rc
<D

W
oN
i2 a:u > e :
m
e.
oo
=

x
m c'
=
!
oj
1
=
d
;
w
*
.
j
-X1
Qxx
=
j
E 'B w 1
> % % Q < =8 =

=q) F- F- F. - < <

o
n
1

11

Q)
u
&
M
=
c

c.
M
KI
c
=*
c

&
r

=
m

*
* E
= >w
m c.
E *

*
r
c
2*
>h
tm
c.

'B
1
zc.

(n c '
Q
2
.

X X
O O
.-I =

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 36 of 40

o o
>
* o
* o
* o* o
< o+
>
>. >
i

Y
o
= *

o
- ma m - o
* o
*

%+
m
t
.

X X
oo o

* *

*
nX Q)
h.
(J) =X

V (D
= .g
*

=
uM>

= = =

<= <= <o

=2
t; y>
z.
.!
! wa
W <
u c
=* uQl

*
E
*

S
D

*
n
.

* =
k.
.P
= 12
*
w2 %u
m
t) *

%=

< u.

I =

q
M
N
N
=
<

>
>
= C:
O
%>w -X
=
c 1

n
ax
*
s
<

G)
=
ku

cz

=m =c
c &

.R
Btc t>
o.#o
-

o X tn x
cr
*=
*

Cr
n
cu
P
=z u
aOaov
rt
oo
o'
LJ .q
=n po u,
s t
co t
co

Q
.
-

'
EL
JZ
q) -2
O -2
O
?
o,
(7 Ct
?
G o o l
o
,
+
Y
:
E
q) = 11 % o o

.G

:n ua a z o o

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 37 of 40

E X H IB IT F

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 38 of 40

-811
@d
*
*

E
E
O

:1

=Q)QJ

=
EN =

uO
c E
iQ

'

& 'L

*
*
C

D D

** G <
Qd :w, E
.v
- ;O
t
(
2
0.d

%
Q
1
*/
k

82 e1
Q E
!
D

- *

z=
q) u

r
c
G
N

t m
om P
Q

oc kD,

u,
:D r/

4*
:P c
aY
c (Q
J.
o4
o m fN
(
.
J
w
u
z
(
t5
-X tp ko
:D:9 .
o.e
CP =c (p
+k co .

=G
*
G
m

r
Q
2

c :u
h'e = QJ
xo X =
q) D *

W=
E
+Q

u2 O

'

E +y d:
* c o

D N r + c M m o o c c c N c c N m c
* > * * c & > &
* * * - * * - & >

K
G m
R R N.*
N
w
*
/ m
M & * N &

m
>
*

m *
N q
>
* N X

vu * rN

t
(
N
rtx
*r.>
*w
: *r
Nt* c&
%P.r:.
,
2
% &
%
*

(N
v
. *k='.x,?

tn
i
&u
*

r
mr O
*

x oo ..
i2

(n
&
*

o4

*
D-

) o o o o o o o vrg

CRX
'. * * * * * %
kP
n* o k
no
u
:

O.

%
.

(?.* PX
'
t
3

at

.
(N.

*
t
q X P4
*a
>*M
*

k
mD
m

X
&
>'
Z

t
tn
u
zr (

c11

c O
> 0

R <7
tu m

E 1

dq
m
N
M d
>
o
m
E

X
*
I
j

Y
I

N rc = e
rm
D
U <D =
t
'N =c

: *

**
=
=
<

5
0
*
1u

>

>

<
Y

= .,
E .

%
= Y
=

?a O
< * ..q +t %

'
:

3
E< ' q
%) %+J
=

.m

c o

- %-

'

o G

>

V
m

SJ

'

'
'

'

=
m

2
Q
o

=9
' D
c
1 2
' c =
O D
tl :9

'

3
t

1
Q

* z=x
F*
s -k

: 1 o
z
.
!
!*
k o
mI
>

8 =
r8 .g
.<
o 1
c
!I=!
g'
:
B:B
j .
s .j j
y =Qm of po d, u=: ppQ p.Q
.

'
'm

:
=

c
=
u.

E>. Q
& q)
c E
X >.
&
Q c

X X
O
= c
e XO
5
.2 .-ul
'o q)

c n

c O

J
k
t
>.. o
J

z
g

Q
P

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 39 of 40

%
o

%.
N
krl
Ch
v
vy

& m kD - C< &

* *
N*
>. &
@.r
>:
.(
@.
M
*
CN
*
*

V
O
%0
C7
rN
*

X
c
VD
X
*

X
X
TH
*

*< *- R >.

l
*
lr
=
f
?=
c=
*(
>
o.s
o.
*
oc xfn tn c
xz =
* =

C=
t
no
cw
c
9:k
u
o!Cv)o
:
q)
QJ .z
m? :=
Q us t
co m
c
cp f

O .uJ C q) fu
Q '
c
=n
.O
O
G G= ko
) O.S
..1 d
1S
-. .qp + +a .- .0 .o
-(
!u
Ca
:c
*=
n
*o
*

Case 0:16-cv-61511-WJZ Document 15 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2016 Page 40 of 40

Steve Schonberg,MD,JD
7938SE 12tbCircle
Ocala,FL 34480

July 21,2016

VIA USPS EXPRESS M AIL,NextDay Delivery

Clerk ofCourt
U .S.FederalBuilding and Courthouse
299 EastBroward Blvd #108
FortLauderdale,FL 33301

Re:M otion to Intervene,CASE NO.16-cv-6151I-W JZ, W ilding etalv.DNC etal

DearHonorableClerk ofCourt:
Enclosed pleasefind m yM otion to Interveneand accompanying Exhibitswhich 1ask be
scanned and filed as expeditiously aspossible. The M otion requestsem ergency reliefbecause itis
inregard to the DemocraticNationalConvention ending onJuly 28, 2016.
There arethreecopiesofthem otion enclosed fortheconvenienceoftheCourtand its1aw
clerksifneeded. Iam apro se t'iler.
Thank you foryourattention to this m ostim portantm atter

8'
m cef y yOu ,
. .
.
ej
.
-..

<

.
---'..-... 't
,.-49-..'..z'. ,1)
..

....- -

X< .
*. .'' A
. dFe'W ?
t..ct.-'.
/

Stev'
e Schonberg

Encl:(4)