Professional Documents
Culture Documents
3.
3.1
Document Information
Author
Responsible
Director
Summary/Purpose
This report considers the submissions received in response to the draft Domestic Animal
Management Plan and recommends that Council adopts the amended Domestic Animal
Management Plan 2016-2021 (DAMP).
Policy Context
City of Greater Bendigo Council Plan 2013-2017 (2015-2016 Update):
Theme 3.
Strategy:
3.5
Action
3.5.2
Adopt the updated Domestic Animal Management Plan (20162021) and implement the first-year actions.
PAGE 58
Councils are required to submit a DAMP to the Secretary of the Department of Economic
Development, Jobs, Transport and Resources (DEDJTR) every 4 years. The next
submission of DAMP was due to the Secretary on 3 November 2016. However, as this
date coincides with Council elections, the Secretary has agreed to accept submissions of
new DAMPs by 3 November 2017.
As some Councils, including City of Greater Bendigo have almost completed the next
DAMP, DEDJTR have advised that these plans can still be submitted prior to 3
November 2016 and although required to be reviewed annually, will not need to be
renewed until 3 November 2021.
Report
The draft DAMP was forwarded to all respondents who registered their interest.
Public notice was given in local newspapers seeking comment and submissions on the
draft plan. It was also made available on the internet and social media.
In addition to the issues and initiatives Council has already reviewed, which were
received as part of developing the draft DAMP, a total of 48 submissions have been
received on the draft DAMP. Some of these contain several topics/issues (9). The topic
of cat curfew received the most responses (44). No person asked to be heard.
A petition with 365 signatures was presented to Council requesting the opening of 2 dog
parks in Bendigo. This is addressed further in the body of the report.
The 2 issues that received the most comment are the creation of 2 extra dog parks (off
leash exercise areas) and whether or not to extend the current cat curfew.
A summary of the submissions are included in the following table
Submitters Topic / Issue
Number of
Officer Comments
Responses
PAGE 59
Number of
Officer Comments
Responses
Maybe
offer
much
cheaper 1
registration for desexed cats and
dogs. Ideally desexing should be
compulsory for all cats and dogs
unless a registered breeder.
29
Number of
Officer Comments
Responses
PAGE 61
Number of
Officer Comments
Responses
cats.
A 24/7 curfew would not allow
effective rodent / vermin capture at
properties and there would be a rise in
vermin / rodent populations.
It is only an initiative so that Council
can raise more revenue.
For - reasons
14
PAGE 62
Number of
Officer Comments
Responses
1
The
Citys
Animal
Management Officers would
be responsible. Would require
further
resources
from
Council if 24/7 curfew was
introduced.
PAGE 63
Agree.
Officers
already
distribute information packs
on responsible pet ownership
to all owners registering their
dog for the first time and also
visit popular dog walking
locations
to
hand
out
information packs.
Number of
Officer Comments
Responses
General comments
There are many good features of the 1
plan including:
Encouragement of microchipping;
Encouragement of
paying /
castration;
Eschewing the requirement for
dogs to always be on leash.
Agree.
Reduced
registration
for
rural
PAGE 64
Number of
Officer Comments
Responses
allows
for
discounted
registration for working dogs.
Agree
Noted
Agree - requires
investigation.
PAGE 65
further
PAGE 66
PAGE 67
Crusoe Reserve
Kangaroo Flat
Negatives
No infrastructure
Expensive to provide water to site
No trees
No fencing
Close proximity to sporting field
Limited parking during sporting events
(weekends)
Flood retention area
Limited fencing
No trees
The oval has been developed as a sporting
field
PAGE 68
PAGE 69
Negatives
Impact on other user groups
No shade
No infrastructure
High costs to fence
Scout Hall Reserve, Eaglehawk Impact on residents - residents on 2 sides
Small area
Limited parking
Lake Tom Thumb, Eaglehawk
Gets very wet in winter
(Golf course end of lake)
Contamination of lake (if not fully fenced)
Is a Natural Reserve and will conflict with
Conservation Principles
Difficult to fence
Rough ground
No infrastructure
Prouses Road to Finn Street, Impact on residents and nursing home
Holdsworth Road
No infrastructure
(This area may be considered should CoGB
consider further on leash controls in the future)
Havilah Road / Dillon Street, Impact on residents - residents on 2 sides
Long Gully
Limited parking during the week
McGowan Street, Long Gully
Impact on residents - residents on 3 sides
Lack of parking
Limited infrastructure
Costs
Turner Street site:
Capital costs for installing fencing, gates and signage approximately $27,000
Capital costs for reticulated water and drinking fountain for dog and owner
approximately - $5,000
Recurrent maintenance costs approximately $6,500 per annum
PAGE 70
PAGE 71
The provision of additional dedicated fenced dog exercise areas is a positive initiative
and will reduce the use of active sporting fields by owners for exercising dogs.
The recommendation is to approve the creation of 2 additional dog exercise areas,
Turner Street, California Gully and Allingham Street, Kangaroo Flat and that these
sites are considered for future funding bids.
Cat curfew
The City has an existing curfew which requires cats to be confined between sunset and
sunrise. This curfew has been reviewed further following submissions received in
response to the draft DAMP. Extending the curfew to require cats to be confined at all
times was considered. The review found:
Disadvantages:
There would be significant resourcing costs to enforce cats wandering at large during
the day time. (additional staff would be required to meet the community expectation).
It is much more difficult and costly to confine a cat which may make it prohibitive for
some people to own a cat.
It is very difficult to catch a cat which does not wish to be caught.
Additional controls may provide a disincentive to register and or microchip, resulting
in more cats not being reclaimed and euthanized.
55% of respondents to the original survey and 69% of respondents to the draft plan
did not support extending the curfew to 24/7.
There are welfare considerations with 24/7 confinement as many residents would
need to lock their cat indoors.
Difficult to introduce and enforce at the local level.
Advantages:
It could reduce nuisance issues between neighbours.
Reduction in impact on native fauna.
Positive welfare consideration in relation to reduction in fighting and disease transfer.
Would be less spraying and faecal matter left in public areas and neighbouring
properties.
Cat kept in a safe house often live longer.
Cats who roam are at risk of injury from cars, human cruelty, poison baits, attacks
from other animals and unwanted pregnancies.
The Department of Economic Development, Jobs, Transport and Resources have
advised that 13 councils have cat curfews. Of these 7 have 24-hour curfews and 6
(including Bendigo), have night time curfews. No neighbouring municipalities have cat
curfews. Comments from councils with a 24 hour curfew:
o No one was able to provide statistics or other information on whether the 24-hour
curfew was effective, in reducing the impact on wildlife.
o One utilises resources to identify and educate owners of cats wandering or
trespassing, prior to attempting to trap the cats. Reluctant to trap cats as 80% of
impounded cats are not reclaimed. (88% not reclaimed in CoGB 14/15).
o One proactively traps cats in environmentally sensitive areas, (Dandenong Ranges).
PAGE 72
o One doesnt resource or actively enforce 24-hour curfew. Advised they would need to
increase staff resources to police 24-hour curfew.
o Councils proactively enforcing the 24-hour curfews have greater staffing resources
than CoGB, in comparison to the number of cats and dogs registered and area
covered:
Council 1- 2,500 square kms 3,927 registered cats and dogs per Animal
Management Officer.
Council 2 - 700 square kms 2,666 registered cats and dogs per Animal
Management Officer.
CoGB -3,000 square kms
Management Officer.
The Bendigo Advertiser conducted an online survey following the Council meeting to
release the draft DAMP for public comment, asking the question: Should cats be allowed
to roam the streets of Bendigo?
There were 2,255 responses.
17% responded Yes, all the time
39% responded Yes, but only during the day'
43% responded No
1% responded Other
The recommendation is to not extend the curfew during the life of the 2016 2021
plan.
Risk Analysis:
Council must have its Plan in place by November 2017 or risk not being in compliance
with the Act.
There is significant risk if Council does not have rigorous management processes to deal
with dog attack and other nuisance issues, with relevant delegations in place. This has
been an area of focus over the past 4 years.
There is also significant risk if Council does not have competent and trained enforcement
staff dealing with dog attack issues.
Consultation/Communication
Consultation with the community and relevant stakeholders is the key to the successful
implementation of any plan. The following consultation took place in the development of
the DAMP:
PAGE 73
Internal
Consultation has occurred with staff from Units including Parks and Natural Environment,
Community Partnerships, Building and Property, Strategy, Open Space Planning and
Active and Healthy Communities.
External
Initial consultation occurred with relevant stakeholders as part of the Local Law and
Domestic Animal Management Plan review. This consultation has included:
February July 2015
Community survey / questionnaire Completed by 643 persons. The information
gathered has helped validate the data and inform the actions within the Plan.
Media releases and paid advertisements in the Local media to advise the community
of the development of the new plan.
Information in the Greater Bendigo News and on social media
Information made available at the Customer Service Centers and on the City of
Greater Bendigo Web.
Mail out to relevant community contacts and interest groups.
Information at District Engagement and Ward Meetings.
Listening posts at several locations.
November December 2015
Promotion of the draft DAMP and comments were sought through the CoGB, social
media sites.
Copies of the draft DAMP were made available at Councils Customer Service Centre
and sent to people who registered their interest. It was also made available on the
internet.
Public notice was given in local newspapers.
Consultation has been ongoing and will continue with community members, stakeholder
and staff from other City departments throughout the implementation and life of the plan.
Amendments to the Plan
The following amendment has been incorporated into the draft plan:
Incorporate advice from the Secretary of the Department of Economic
Development, Jobs, Transport and Resources extending the life of this DAMP
until 2021.
PAGE 74
PAGE 75
RECOMMENDATION
That the Greater Bendigo City Council resolve to:
1. Adopt the Domestic Animal Management Plan for the period 2016 2021
2. Maintain the sunset to sunrise cat curfew during the life of the 2016 2021 Plan.
3. Approve the creation of 2 additional dog exercise areas, Turner Street, California
Gully and Allingham Street, Kangaroo Flat and that these sites are considered for
future funding bids within the life of the 2016 - 2021 Plan.
PAGE 76