Professional Documents
Culture Documents
stress.
Its superior strength in tension permits engineers to design longer unsupported spans. Ultimately, the choice
between prestressed and conventional reinforced concrete should be made based on the type of project and the
properties it requires.
Prestressed concrete requires more complex formwork, so it has less design flexibility than other kinds of
reinforced concrete, which often makes design more challenging. Moreover, the margin for error in preparing
prestressed concrete is much smaller than other more conventional materials, so more care and caution must be
exercised in construction.
prestressed concrete, because stresses induced by steel cables in the material help to counterbalance tensile
stress.
Since the technique of prestressing eliminates cracking of concrete under all stage of loading, the
entire section of the structures takes part in resisting the external load. In contrast to this, in the
reinforced concrete, only portion of the concrete above neutral axis is effective.
2.
Since concrete does not crack, the possibility of steel to rust and concrete to deteriorate is minimized.
3.
Absence of cracks results in higher capacity of the structure to bear reversal of stresses, impact,
vibration and shock.
4.
In prestressed concrete beams, dead loads are practically neutralized. The reactions required are
therefore much smaller than required in reinforced concrete. The reduced dead load weight of the
structure results in saving in the cost of foundations. The neutralization of dead load is of importance
in large bridges.
5.
The use of curved tendons and the pre-compression of concrete helps to resist shear.
6.
The quantity of steel required for prestressing about 1/3 of that required for reinforced concrete,
though the steel for the former should have high tensile strength.
7.
In prestressed concrete, precast blocks and elements can be assumed and used as one unit. This saves
in the cost of shuttering and centering for large structures.
8.
With the advent of prestressed concrete, it has been possible now to construct large size liquid
retaining structures not economical to build otherwise. Such structures have low cost and are
preferably safe against cracking and consequent leakage.
9.
Prestressed concrete can be used with advantage in all those structures where tension develops, such
as tie and suspender of a bow string girder, railway sleepers, electric poles, upstream face of gravity
dam etc.
1.
It requires high quality dense concrete of high strength. Perfect quality concrete in production,
placement and compaction is required.
2.
It requires high tensile steel, which is 2.5 to 3.5 times costlier than mild steel.
3.
It requires complicated tensioning equipment and anchoring devices, which are usually covered under
patented rights.
4.
Disadvantages
1) Greater Building Complexity
Prestressing concrete on the construction site is a challenging and complex process. One must have thorough
knowledge of each step which is involved, along with complete knowledge of the use of the various equipment
that are required. Precast concrete structures once made, are difficult to alter, and hence, the complexity of initial
planning too is increased. Also, since the margin for error is very low, a lot of care needs to be taken while
constructing with it.
2) Increased Construction Cost
Prestressing concrete requires expertise and special equipment, both of which can be expensive to obtain. Even
the cost of precast blocks is significantly higher than reinforced blocks. In the construction of residential buildings,
the additional tensile strength offered by prestressed concrete may be unnecessary, as simple reinforced concrete,
which is much cheaper, is strong enough to fulfill almost all load requirements.
Post-tensioning
Pre-tensioning
The overall strength of concrete is determined through its water-cement ratio. Since prestressed concrete has
a lower water-cement ratio than reinforced concrete, the former makes a stronger concrete than the latter.
C) Elasticity
Due to the reduction of its tensile stress, prestressed concrete is more elastic than reinforced concrete
(PC)
Tensile
RC:
Tensile
strength
of
concrete
Strength
is
assumed
to
be
negligible.
Cracking
and
Deflection
RC
RC:
cracks
only
1/2-1/3
of
concrete
crosssection
contributes
to
effectiveness.
Cracking and deflection are typically irrecoverable after reaching these limit
states.
Limited by deflections because cracking reduces effective moment of inertia.
Service
deflections
are
typically
large.
PC:
Stiffness
RC:
Stiffness
is
difficult
to
control
economically.
strength.
Shear
RC:
No
PC:
direct
Some
assistance
assistance
from
longitudinal
from
steel.
longitudinal
steel.
Serviceability
RC:
Heavy
PC:
Lighter
Can
weight
accommodate
longer
spans
Safety
RC:
Safe
Economy
RC:
PC:
Less
More
material,
but
higher
material.
cost
materials
used.
of
Prestressed
Higher
Concrete
material
Prestressing
is
an
costs
added
cost
Formwork is more complex than for RC (flanged sections, thin webs) thus,
precast not as ductile as RC
Advantages
High
PC
steel
20-35%
Lighter
Prestressed
strength
PC:
of
section
in
of
active
RC
spans
RC
foundations
is
concrete
Longer
65-80%
Lighter
Entire
&
reinforcement
section,
depth
Concrete
depth
possible
(more
efficient)
Crackless
Better
corrosion
resistance,
better
durability
Deflection
Critical
for
spans
greater
control
than
Better
70-90
ft.
(excessive
shear
DL)
resistance
materials)
Linear
Prestressing
Circular
Prestressing
Methods
Pretensioning
Do
Load
not
is
self-react
transferred
by
bond
against
of
wire
member.
with
concrete.
Disadvantage:
Need
for
large
abutments.
Post-tensioning
React
Jack
and
(Bonded,
against
then
fix
tendon
Unbonded)
beam
with
one
itself.
end
anchored.
greased
tendons
or
tendons
wrapped
in
greased
paper).
pre-tensioning the reinforcement, in the form of tendons or cables, is stretched (put into
tension) across the concrete formwork before the concrete is placed. After the concrete has
hardened and a suitable strength developed, the tendons are released. The tendons attempt
to shorten and transfer the energy stored to the concrete through the bond between the
concrete and the reinforcement. A compressive force is therefore induced into the concrete.
Ordinary mild steel bars cannot be used because no prestress will be left in the bars after
shrinkage and creep losses have taken place instead of wires of high tensile is used
It is impossible to use high tensile steel as reinforcement for simple reinforced concrete if
high tension steel is used the high stresses in tensile reinforcement will result in such wide
cracks in tensile zone of concrete that the load carrying capacity of the members will
practically be lost
Prestress steel reinforcing bar placed in tension zone of a section subjected to tensile
stresses before casting the concrete