Professional Documents
Culture Documents
R E C E N T A D VA N C E S I N
W I R E L E S S T E C H N O L O G I E S F O R S M A RT G R I D
ABSTRACT
Home area
network
48
INTRODUCTION
The electricity supply industry has been facing
significant challenges in terms of meeting the
projected demand for energy, environmental
issues, security, reliability and integration of
renewable energy. Currently, most of the power
grids are based on many decades old vertical
hierarchical infrastructures where the electric
power flows in one direction from the power
generator to the consumer side and grid monitoring information is handled only at the operation side. It is generally believed that a
fundamental evolution in electric power generation and supply system is needed to make the
grids more reliable, secure and efficient. This
can be achieved by enabling the future generation electricity network smarter and intelligent
by embedding bi-directional information and
communication architecture with power grids.
Various countries around the world such as
the US and several European countries have
already launched development projects on what
Power line
Transmission
Bi-directional
communication link
Possible
communication link
Distribution
substation
Distributed
generation
Industrial
consumer
Transmission
Transmission
substation
Operation
control centre
Home
consumer
Bulk generation
Distributed
generation
Distributed
storage
49
CHALLENGES
There are various perceived challenges spanning
from policy level to technology level including
social and behavioral aspects. The policy level
challenges include capital investment, enforcement rules on grid operators to provide considerable incentives to consumers, standardization
of electrical appliances and third party engagement of consumer raw data. The social and
behavioral aspects include trust and engagement
of consumers in the demand management. The
technological level challenge mainly spans the
integration of high quality and low delay twoway communication infrastructure with the
power grids. There are various state of the art
communication technologies available, however,
it is the choice of the most appropriate technology and the integration of all the components of
the smart grids that will form the important
challenge. To balance the supply and demand,
similar techniques as used in communication
50
WIRELESS TECHNOLOGIES
To facilitate demand management, suitable communications technologies must be chosen to
address various requirements in the different
parts of the AMI. The neighborhood area networks (NANs) and home area networks (HANs)
of AMI communications infrastructure are particularly suitable for wireless deployment, largely
due to the ease and low cost of adopting wireless
instead of wired solutions. The backhaul network connecting the AMI headend and the data
aggregation points (DAPs) can either be wireless
or wired. The AMI communication architecture
is illustrated in Fig. 2.
The link between the DAPs and consumers
requires NANs with a coverage in the range of
thousands of meters. Each DAP can connect to
hundreds of smart meters (SMs). As a result, a
key requirement of candidate wireless solutions
is coverage of wide area, which can also be
achieved through a mesh network architecture
or relay stations. Additionally, the wireless network must be able to provide a certain level of
reliability as well as low enough latency not only
to satisfy demand side management (DSM)
requirements but also to serve all other AMI
applications. According to communication
requirements from OpenSG [3], this translates
to a minimum reliability figure of 99.5 percent
and a latency requirement of less than 1 second,
which is a relatively relaxed figure as compared
to the commercial broadband requirements.
On the other hand, HANs which facilitate
energy management and planning within customer premises, require a relatively smaller coverage area. The requirements are also relatively
less stringent as there are less control messages
and information exchange between the smart
meter and smart appliances (and plug-in hybrid
electric vehicle (PHEV)). In general, the HAN
requires a minimum reliability figure of 99.5 percent and a latency requirement of less than 5
seconds [3].
DAP
DAP
AMI
headend
Home area
network
Backhaul network
Neighbourhood
area network (NAN)
DEVELOPMENTS OF
DEMAND MANAGEMENT APPROACHES AND
PROPOSED MECHANISMS
The success of smart grid lies in the design of
flexible and robust demand management techniques underpinned by the deployment of ICT
infrastructure mentioned earlier. Apart from
improving the legacy load control approaches,
the main contributions of recent research have
been in the demand side consumption scheduling, dynamic pricing and load balancing using
distributed energy resources (DER).
51
As an analogy to the
design of hierarchical
topology based
Internet routing,
finding the most
suitable system
architecture of
consumption
management system
in smart grid is
an important
research topic.
52
Coverage
NAN
HAN
Technology
Range
Latency
Reliability
WiMAX
30km
Low
High
Medium/Medium
UMTS/LTE
30km
Low
High
Medium/Low
802.22
30km
Medium
Medium
High/Medium
WiFi
200m
Medium-High
Low-Medium
Low
ZigBee
100m
Low-Medium
Medium
Low
Bluetooth
100m
Low
Medium
Low
Power
Power
Operation time
Operation time
Power
Power
(a)
Operation time
Operation time
(b)
pb, N
pb,1
pb, 4
pb, 2
pb, N 1
pb, 3
pb, 2
pb, 3
.
pb,1
(1)
Time-shiftable
appliances are those
that the consumers
can tolerate
postponing the
operation. For
example, a washing
machine or a dish
washer. However,
for these appliances,
the power may not
be shiftable.
L , x R+, s b Z+ N 1
s.t.
b
N
x a , xa,t = la , a
(2)
t =1
xb = Pb s b , 1T s b = 1, b.
The above problem can be solved using mixed
integer linear programming (ILP) [13]. As an
example, we consider an hourly consumption
scheduling, i.e., N = 24, for a group of four
households. Every household is assumed to have
a similar set of appliances, however with different consumption requirements. Assume the total
daily requirement is 43 units. Without optimal
scheduling, it is likely that many appliances may
be operating simultaneously because users may
have similar consumption behaviors. The overlapping loads could generate undesirable peaks.
As illustrated in Fig. 4 (left), the loads are high
in the evening with a peak of 3.72kWh while
they remain low in the day time. Appliances
scheduling will reduce the peak demand through
coordination between households and adjusting
the operation time and the power of shiftable
appliances.
Figure 4 (right) depicts the optimal hourly
consumption scheduling result using the ILP
optimization in Eq. 2. The optimization schedules appliances to minimize the peak load L
over t = [1, 2, , 24]. As seen, there is no significant peak and the load allocation is fairly balanced. This is because the shiftable
consumptions are reallocated optimally through-
53
2.5
Scheduled load
3.5
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
1.5
0.5
0.5
0
0
10
15
Time (hour)
20
25
0
0
10 12 14
Time (hour)
16
18
20
22
2425
Figure 4. Hourly load over the day. Left: without scheduling, right [13]: after scheduling.
DYNAMIC PRICING
Generally, issuing dynamic pricing policies as
user incentive is the most effective way to
achieve indirect demand management for the
grid side operators and controllers. Dynamic
pricing mainly consists of time-of-use (ToU)
pricing, critical peak pricing (CPP), time block
based pricing (TBBP), and real-time pricing
(RTP), as listed in Table 2.
ToU and CPP rates have already been included in many utility contracts/tariffs in the current
electricity markets for load control purposes. In
order to account for the dynamic demand in
smart grid, pricing policies should be updated
54
Pricing policy
Characteristics
Time-of-use pricing
One-off issuing rates depending on the time of use Limited performance for dynamic demand control
Real-time pricing
Residential DER management based on instantaneous supply conditions (both from the central
energy source and the distributed energy sources)
is also an important research topic. For example,
various households in a neighborhood area can
share locally generated power and draw power
from the central energy source only when it is
required. The authors of [15] developed a decision-support algorithm using particle swarm optimization (PSO) to support this kind of schemes.
CONCLUSIONS
The main ingredient of smart grids is the integration of ICT into the grids to monitor and regulate energy generation and demand. The smart
meters and sensors will be deployed in various
parts of the grid, starting from the generation,
through distribution, and all the way to the
household level. These will be interconnected
through both wired and wireless connections.
Due to the consideration of cost effective implementation, wireless solutions are preferred at
the NAN and HAN levels and wired connections
could be used for backhaul networks. In addition
to the integration of renewable energy, one of
the main goals of the smart grids is to perform
demand management to reduce peak loads. This
requires acquision of real time data from various
points in the grid and optimization of the power
supply and demand. In order for the demand
management to be successful, consumers should
be given adequate incentives for full participation. This article covered various candidate communication technologies and mathematical
optimization algorithms to enable demand management. As communication is an underpinning
technology for the success of smart grid, we
envisage that smart grids will be an exciting
research area for communication engineers for
many years to come.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The authors would like to express sincere thanks
to Toshiba Research Europe Limited for funding this work.
REFERENCES
[1] US DoE, Smart Grid Research & Development: MultiYear Program Plan(MYPP) 20102014, Available
http://www.oe.energy.gov.
[2] European Commission, European Smart Grids Technology Platform Vision and Strategy for Europes Electricity Networks of the Future, Directorate-General for
Research Sustainable Energy Systems, 2006, available http://www.smartgrids.eu.
[3] OpenSG, SG Network Systems Requirement Specification v5.0 (draft), Aug. 2011, available
http://osgug.ucaiug.org.
[4] IEEE Standard for Local and Metropolitan Area Networks Part 16: Air Interface for Broadband Wireless
Access Systems, IEEE Std 802.16-2009 (Revision of
IEEE Std. 802.16-2004), May 2009, pp. C12004.
[5] H. Zhu and J. Wang, Chunk-based Resource Allocation
in OFDMA Systems Part I: Chunk Allocation, IEEE
Trans. Commun., vol. 57, Sept. 2009, pp. 273444.
[6] IEEE Standard for Local and Metropolitan Area Networks Part 16: Air Interface for Broadband Wireless
Access Systems Amendment 1: Multiple Relay Specification, IEEE Std. 802.16j-2009 (Amendment to IEEE Std.
802.16-2009), pp. C1290, Dec. 2009.
[7] 3GPP TSG RAN, Evolved Universal Terrestrial Radio
Access (E-UTRA); Physical Channels and Modulation
(Release 8), TS 36.211, V8.9.0, Dec. 2009.
[8] 3GPP TSG RAN, Evolved Universal Terrestrial Radio
Access (E-UTRA); Physical Channels and Modulation
(Release 10), TS 36.211, V10.4.0, Dec. 2011.
[9] IEEE Standard for Information Technology Telecommunications and Information Exchange Between
Systems Wireless Regional Area Networks (WRAN)Specific requirements Part 22: Cognitive Wireless RAN
Medium Access Control (MAC) and Physical Layer (PHY)
Specifications: Policies and Procedures for Operation in
the TV Bands, IEEE Std. 802.22-2011, Jan. 2011, pp.
1680.
[10] C. Gellings and W. Smith, Integrating Demand-Side
Management into Utility Planning, Proc. IEEE, vol. 77,
no. 6, 1989, pp. 90818.
[11] V. Bakker et al., Demand Side Load Management
Using A Three Step Optimization Methodology, 1st
IEEE Intl. Conf. Smart Grid Communications (SmartGridComm), Gaithersburg, Maryland, USA, Oct. 2010,
pp. 43136.
[12] A. Mohsenian-Rad et al., Autonomous Demand-Side
Management based on Game-Theoretic Energy Consumption Scheduling for the Future Smart Grid, IEEE
Trans. Smart Grid, vol. 1, no. 3, Dec. 2010, pp. 32031.
[13] Z. Zhu et al., An Integer Linear Programming based
Optimization for Home Demand-Side Management in
Smart Grid, IEEE PES ISGT, Washington DC, USA, Jan.
2012.
[14] A. Brooks et al., Demand Dispatch, IEEE Power and
Energy Mag., vol. 8, no. 7, pp. 2029, Jun. 2010.
[15] M. Pedrasa, T. Spooner, and I. MacGill, Coordinated
Scheduling of Residential Distributed Energy Resources
to Optimize Smart Home Energy Services, IEEE Trans.
Smart Grid, vol. 1, no. 2, Sept. 2010, pp. 13443.
BIOGRAPHIES
Z IMING Z HU received the M.Sc. degree in Communication
Networks and Signal Processing with Distinction from Bristol University, U.K., in October 2010. He is currently a Ph.D.
student within the Advanced Signal Processing Group
(ASPG) at Loughborough University, U.K. His research inter-
55
56