Professional Documents
Culture Documents
This publication has been prepared in the framework of a study contract with:
The views expressed may not in any circumstances be regarded as stating an official
position of the European Commission.
Photo credit: Austria - Salzburg Festival, Spain - Barcelona Forum 2004, France Quiksilver,
Greece - Thessaloniki International Film Festival, Hungry - Szigeti Festival, Italy - 2006
Torino Winter Olympic Games, Portugal - 2004 European Nations Football Championship,
Czech Republic - Prague Spring Festival, Slovakia Vychodna, Sweden Malm turism/
City of Malm.
SUMMARY
Introduction
Cultural and sport events, a potential for tourism development in Europe
1
1
A practical guide for optimising CSE impacts on the development of tourist destinations 5
13
13
Factor 2. Define the CSE project and it's relation to regional development
21
Stage II: The action programme promoting the regional tourism assets
28
28
Factor 4. Define the impacts targeted by the CSE and enable SME to anticipate
33
39
45
52
52
55
58
Factor 9. Carry out a shared evaluation of the durable benefits for the tourist destination58
Factor 10. Consolidate the local partnerships in order to develop sustainable tourism in
the region
69
73
75
81
102
Introduction
C u l t u r a l a n d s p or t e v e n t s , a p o t e n t i a l f or t o u r i sm
d e v el o pm e n t i n E ur op e
1
2
Including hotels, restaurants, coffee shops, bars, travel agencies and tour operators.
Sectors connate to tourism, such as transport or construction
-1-
The European Commission committed itself to designing a new European policy for
tourism in order to reinforce the partnership for tourism in Europe3.
This policy aims at promoting the development of "sustainable tourism", meaning
tourism which relies on human activities using natural, cultural and historic resources
without limiting the use for future generations.
Sustainable tourism relies on the balance of three main poles:
- Economic sustainability, to encourage job creation and increase global turn over,
- Environmental sustainability, to guarantee the protection of natural resources,
- Socio-cultural sustainability which underlines the importance of respecting values,
traditions and maintaining social balances.
Sustainable tourism can only exist with the participation of all actors: economic,
environmental, socio-cultural. The partnership in tourism projects, constitutes a major
action principal.
To reinforce this policy, the European Commission has defined a certain number of
priority orientations, all aiming to promote sustainable tourism:
-
Support for SME whose activities are related to tourism and exchange of best
practices.
Cultural and sport events can constitute a lever for increasing the development
of tourism in Europe
European cities and areas accommodate many cultural or sporting events, i.e. events
which can play a major part in promoting the image of the event destination, during
and after the event itself. All local actors, and specially SME for whose activities are
related to tourism, can greatly benefit from such events.
COM (2006) 134 final, "A new European policy for tourism: reinforce the partnership for tourism
in Europe".
-2-
Indeed, cultural or sporting activities constitute one of the main motivations in the
choice of the tourist destinations. The empowerment of the civilisation of leisure
contributes to the development of this leisure tourism (increase in spare time,
increase in purchasing power). Approximately four fifths of European tourism would
be of leisure type.
In the current context of competition between tourist destinations, the hotel and
catering offer (hardware), is no longer enough to provide a sufficient competing
advantage. The tourism competitiveness of a destination relies strongly on its offer in
leisure, culture, sport, and environment (software). This leisure offer makes it
possible to better develop the regional natural and cultural inheritance. The tourism
offers must thus be more imaginative to bring something extra compared to the
other destinations.
The expectations as regards to tourism have changed: holidays are more and more
supposed to be a moment of discovery (cultural, environmental), of acculturation,
informal education, and maintenance of good health (in particular in relation to the
ageing of populations) Therefore it is logical that that cultural and natural heritage
tourism will experience the most significant growth.
The cultural inheritance of Europe is one of the richest and most diversified.
Consequently, it is a great tourist attraction. The UNESCO list of world inheritance
sites, confirms the richness of Europe. This inheritance was promoted by the
European council campaign "Europe, a common inheritance" (European days of
inheritance, European Association of historical cities, decorative art workshops,
Networks of natural inheritance, etc.) and by the European Union which defines each
year, one or several "European Capitals of Culture" (Lille and Genova in 2004, Cork
in 2005, Patras in 2006, Luxembourg and Sibiu in 2007, Liverpool and Stavanger in
2008).
Sporting events, and more particularly sporting competitions, also generate important
flows of population, and constitute a vector of regional promotion. In this respect, the
European Economic and Social Committee recently affirmed that sport and tourism
constitute a "means of exchange of positive values" and are likely to contribute to
achieving Lisbons aims. The Committee thus formulated various proposals for better
tourism and sport association and development: the creation of a common European
observatory and a data bank gathering the best practices, the promotion of studies
and research, and the creation of a European tourism agency.
See COM (2006) 665 final, related to the development of a cooperative approach, for the future
of European tourism.
-3-
Cultural and sporting events are not always conceived and organised in order
to benefit sustainable regional tourism development
The CSE are often organised as isolated actions, unrelated to regional economics
and tourism development:
-
The CSE are not always organised in a way that respects the aims of
sustainable development. For example, certain events need large and
expensive infrastructures, which are not profitable, due to lack of planning
concerning their future use.
SCE organisers must increase the association for all regional actors, for the
conception and the organisation of the event. Indeed, local authorities, inhabitants,
SME, tourism representatives, economic development agencies, consular
chambers constitute incontrovertible actors for fully achieving CSE integration in a
regional development strategy. In other words, it is a question of better combining,
associating and integrating cultural, sporting and tourism policies, helping towards
the same regional development strategy.
It is in this context that the European Commission, Enterprise and Industry General
Management - Tourism Unit, launched a survey in order to elaborate a Practical
Guide to help maximise sustainable impacts for SCE, on the growth and
competiviness of tourism.
-4-
A pr a c ti c a l g u i d e f or o p t i m i s i n g C S E i m pa c ts o n t he
d e v el o pm e n t o f t o ur i s t d e s t i n a t i o n s
The conception and organisation of CSE should use better tools to make "Win
- Win" partnerships, associating local authorities, SCE organisers and local
SME
The impact of a cultural or sporting event on sustainable tourism development of a
destination, strongly depends on the quality of the partnerships set up before, during
and after the event.
The partnerships must be at the heart of the action, on all levels. They must strongly
integrate the different actors throughout the process. It is for this reason that a
Practical Guide is necessary for:
-
Defining the key factors for the success of a CSE, so it can participate to the
development of the destination.
Define and improve the coordination of each actors role (public and private),
associated to the conception and organisation of the CSE.
The Practical guide presented in this document answers to three main requirements:
1. Organise the awareness and mobilisation of all actors concerning the
potential represented by the CSE and the need of partnerships.
2. Present the key factors allowing optimisation of the CSE impact, socially,
economically, environmentally and on tourism.
3. Improve role definition for actors involved in the organisation of CSE: local
authorities, CSE organisers, tourism orientated SME and the local population.
-5-
Companies indirectly linked to tourism, for example suppliers and subcontractors as well as all activities generated by the tourism
development. These activities constitute, in many cases, the framework
of regional economical development and create a large amount of jobs.
This is why tourism development and regional development are strongly
linked.
In most cases, these four categories of actors have preoccupations and play highly
different roles: the CSE organisers tend to favour the cultural or sporting quality of
the event, while the local authorities help with the CSE organising and financing
process without knowing how to include it in a stronger strategy for economical and
tourism development for the hosting region. The SME, are often detached from any
kind of participation in the organisation of a CSE.
This Guide should enable all actors to improve the rationalisation of their work
methods, teamwork, define a shared project conduct, so that the hosting destination
can fully benefit from all the impacts generated by the CSE.
-6-
-7-
-8-
Local authorities: local and inter-communal groups, state services (in charge of
sport or tourism)
-9-
Each of the four stages is divided into a number of success key factors (see. graph
below).
On the whole, 10 success key factors were identified.
For each of the 10 key factors, the Practical guide describes:
1. The aims.
2. One or more case studies illustrating the key factor. These case studies
are extracts from 10 studied events5.
3. The proposal of tools and an organisation method.
A synthesis for each of the 10 events is offered in the appendix, on page 52. A detailed
monograph (around 10 pages) has been formalised in addition. These monographs are available
on the European Commission internet site
(http://ec.europa.eu/enterprise/services/tourism/studies_and_publications.htm) as well as on
request at the AMNYOS Consultant cabinet (info@amnyos.com).
- 10 -
- 11 -
Four stages and ten key factors for maximising CSE sustainable benefits
A flexible Guide for adapting to the diversity of local context and CSE
- 12 -
Sta g e I :
The local CSE organisation
pa r t n e r s h i p
F a c t o r 1 . B u i l di n g a l o c a l p a r t n e r s h i p
The local partnership is without a doubt, the most important factor to achieve the
integration of a cultural or sporting event, with the largest dynamic for local and
tourism development. Without a large local partnership, the event may have a
good cultural or sporting quality but may struggle to reach a local development
aim.
Particular attention must be paid to the first factor. Even more so, due to the fact
that partnerships between cultural or sporting actors, local authorities and
enterprises (notably tourism enterprises) are not made in a natural and
spontaneous way.
In certain cases, event organisers find it difficult to be recognised as potential
tourism development levers. In other cases, it is the event organisers themselves
who refuse the company offers, for fear of denaturing their events. In the end, the
local authorities or CSE organisers, are too often closed in isolated
representations, with insufficient space for regional socioeconomic actors.
Analysing CSE shows that their organisation is often reduced to specialised
technical partners, who tend to forget the region where the event is held. It is
suggested to distinguish two types of partnerships:
-
and
material
Each type of partnership has its own added value. Strategic partnerships are
meanwhile to be promoted, in order to favour relationships with stronger synergy
between the actors.
- 13 -
Elsewhere, the quality of the local partnership and the way that it integrates the
region, are not without consequences on the way the population "lives" the event:
they can feel little concerned by the CSE, and may even reject it, creating a
unfavourable atmosphere for welcoming tourists coming from outside the region.
It is for this reason that all CSE must be prepared with prior mobilisation and
information for all regional inhabitants: youths, scholars, employees
Aims
Turning the event into a regional development tool for the economy, needs the
creation of an Event Organisation Committee, gathering organisers, local
authorities, the company tourism representatives. According to local
configurations, the local resident representatives may also find their place in this
kind of Committee.
The Event organisation Committee can only be installed with the following
conditions:
- 14 -
Case study
Malm Skne, "Louis Vuitton, Acts 6&7 of the 32nd Americas Cup"
(Sweden): a partnership open to dialogue with the companies
The town of Malm, organiser of an
America's Cup stage, installed a close
partnership with the Skne region which
aims at building a common marketing
position for water sport. A brand strategy
was developed around the Sailing
Region.
In addition, the organisation of an
Americas cup stage was subject to discussion with the companies within the
framework of the three informal platforms: accommodation, restaurants, and
town centre shops.
Moreover, 3 series of qualitative and quantitative surveys were conducted with
the companies: before, during and after the event.
These three surveys made it possible to collect the suggestions and
expectations of the companies:
-
Develop a long term offer of regional services for the sailing activity.
- 15 -
The French Federation of Surfing - FFS. The federation can present and
promote the various federal products thanks to the provision of certain
sites: promotion of the added value to the community life and the federal
licence, promotion of social integration actions, accessibility for the
handicapped and environmental awareness.
Quiksilver is an international company, intervening mainly in the conception and sale of material
and textiles related to surf ware .
- 16 -
- 17 -
Respective role
Regional SME
(association of retailers, hotel and
restaurant trade unions)
Community
and local associations
(sport and cultural associations and
area associations)
Economic development
agencies, Consular
Chambers, economic and
social partners
- 18 -
Mobilisation levers
Organisation of a lunch/debate with the company clubs,
retailer associations, consular chambers.
Presentation of positive CSE experiences throughout
Europe: positive impacts for the region and the
enterprises, the factors for achieving
Socioeconomic
actors7
The local
population
Campaign for
associations.
social
and
professional
insertion
Socioeconomic actors
and local population
- 19 -
The different
organisation
Committee actors
(elected representatives
and
local community services)
Identify
collectively the
products, activities
and services that
represent the most
the region.
Prepare a
decoration for the
town in function with
the MCS thematic.
Setup a welcome
and information desk
at the airport and
train station.
Economical actors
(Agency of development,
Consular Chambers,
economic and social
partners )
Local associations
(sport and cultural
associations and area
associations)
The CSE
assessment and
the promotion of
assets
To be informed on
the regions tourism
offer.
The running of
preparatory actions
and the CSE
realisation
Install peripheral
animations to the
MCS
Etc.
- 20 -
Conduct a
financial balance for
activity made during
the CSE. Measure
the rise of activity.
F a c t or 2 . D e f i n e t he C S E pr o j e c t a n d i t ' s r e l a t i on t o
r e gi o n a l d e v e l o p m e n t
Constructing a local partnership, enables to identify finalities and the main lines
for the CSE, as well as the level of federation for the different actors. It is now
advisable to formalise these finalities and main lines in a "CSE project". The
regional companies and tourism do not benefit from a cultural and sporting event,
just because it is a success: the CSE project must clearly show its link to the
regional development.
The CSE project must in fact be able to answer the two following questions:
-
What are the regional objectives that the event could contribute to (social
cohesion, tourist development, fame, image)?
How can we adapt the event to the region's social and economical
context? In other words, how can we give the event a real "regional
anchoring"?
In practice, the assessment of cultural and sporting events often shows a gap
between the event and the socioeconomic configuration of the accommodation
destination. The risk of having a gap is increased when the organisers are
located at a distance from the event destination. It can be called the parachuting
effect ".
In addition, it can be observed, in Europe, that new regions are structuring
themselves around strategic development projects: competiveness poles,
regional charters, rural excellence poles The European Commission
encourages local partnerships and the regional dynamics which are linked.
The cultural and sporting events should be seen more as contributors better
identified with these regional development dynamics. They must be firmly placed
as a more articulated link, more readable, better assured with the local
partnerships in charge of regional development where cultural or sporting events
are held.
The CSE project must be inscribed, as from the elaboration stage, all the
regional objectives as a vital part for the success of the event .
- 21 -
Aims
The CSE project should be formalised in order to clearly show:
It's link to the regional development strategy. The event project must
identify, with the economic actors, the returns and benefits that the event
can bring to regional development.
The benefits for local actors through their participation to the event:
reinforce the regions fame, raise out of season tourism
- 22 -
Case study
The Quiksilver Pro France: a lever for the regional economic and tourist
development through the Economical Pole of Competitiveness ski
sports".
The professional surfing world championship is highly complementary with the
regions identity. The region is characterised by a truly economic branch
evolving around the surfing activity:
-
Today, the Aquitaine area is the first European area for ski sports: it
accounts for 34% of the European ski sport market (385 companies,
- 23 -
The
"Quiksilver
Pro"
professional
championship solidifies the branch:
world
- 24 -
A.
Targets
Socioeconomic actors
The local
authorities
Local population
- 25 -
Collectively validate
the regional tourism
strategy
Who are the key actors that the event should include
to ensure it corresponds the regional tourism project?
- 26 -
Architecture of the
CSE project
Chapter 1/
The technical objectives
of the CSE
Information
to be displayed
Qualify CSE: scope, periodicity,
organiser status, targeted public
duration,
Chapter 2/
The CSE link with the
regional development
strategy
Chapter 3/
The benefits for local
actors through event
participation
Scheduled impacts
inheritance).
for
the
region
(local
The quality of the assessment depends on the quality and precision of the objectives (See.
factor 9 on page 1).
- 27 -
S ta g e I I :
The action programme promoting
t h e r e g i o n a l t o u r i s m a s s e ts
F a c t or 3 . C r e a t e a d i v e r s i f i e d o f f e r o f s e r v i c e s
Accommodating a CSE boosts activity for the destination. If the public restricts
itself to the event, meaning only the purchase of tickets, the regional returns will
be very limited. The rise of activity related to the CSE will only benefit the region,
if we can provide the public with an interesting offer of diverse services.
Event analysis reveal that all too often, the event organisers do not think (or do
not know how) to provide a larger range of services for the public, which would
encourage them to stay longer in the region, discover other aspects, or even
return for reasons other than the initial one (i.e. the cultural or sporting event).
More over, by comparing the European tourist expense analysis, to the
American, we can see that tourists spend a lot less in Europe. The gap can be
explained mainly by a less interesting service offer in Europe.
The CSE organisation committee should dispose of the experience and know
how, to differentiate different public segments and "sell" composite offers which
include the event: other cultural visits or sport activities, tourist trips, regional
product promotion
This globalisation of offered services, benefits not only the region but the cultural
or sporting event as well, which will find new sources for continuation and
development, or even a demarcation element compared to other similar events.
- 28 -
Aims
The event should be the occasion for structuring derived service offers,
peripherals, service offer combinations ("packaging").
Event analysis shows four main groups of services which are advised to be
installed around the CSE:
1. The tourist offers directly resulting from the CSE and which often
require better structuring. They are activities generated by the event,
i.e. accommodation, catering and transport offers.
2. Event related activities: derived products, sale of theme related
products (musical instruments, sport equipment ), training related to
the event theme
3. The regional tourism offers, which may benefit from the event: trips,
tour operators, receptive agencies
4. The offers linked to the regions assets: craftwork, regional products,
leisure activities, local heritage, discovery related trips and the
different products and services
It is advices to correctly decline the event according to each of the four
mentioned components (See following chart).
Installing this offer of services provides the following benefits:
Better anchoring of the CSE in the region: satisfaction of the different
partners from the local organisation Committee, help the local population
feel more concerned
Federate an important offer of services.
Promote regional assets.
Attract a more diverse public.
Develop public loyalty.
And to finish, distinguish the CSE from the other events, hold a CSE which
is unique and singular.
- 29 -
Case study
The festival of Salzburg (Austria): exploiting the regional offer during the
festival.
The festival of Salzburg is the opportunity
to exploit various tourist offers:
- 30 -
The festival is in this way clearly positioned as a promotional period for the
regional tourism assets, with a view to improving the balance between the
winter and summer seasons.
The festival public has a privileged access to these different offers if the festival
promotes them as a group, on the internet site. These offers are today so well
imbricated, it is difficult to know if the public comes to Salzburg specifically for the
festival, or if the festival is only an addition to the other offered activities.
- 31 -
- 32 -
F a c t o r 4 . D e fi n e t h e i m p a c t s t a r ge t e d b y t h e C S E a n d
e n a b l e S M E t o a n ti c i p at e
The analysis of the cultural and sporting events, reveals that socio-economic
impacts are always generated. (increase of activity, realisation of certain
installations). The socio-economic impacts of a CSE are indeed often related
to the size of the initial investment: the greater the initial investment, the greater
the impact will be9.
However, these impacts are often noted after the event and not planned
beforehand. The consequence is a low economical and tourism added value
produced in an empirical way, making it difficult to evaluate the events cause
and effect ratio.
Moreover, due to lack of communication with the companies, the event can have
a negative effect. We have seen security services imposing the closure of
commerce because of to many people coming to the event. We have also seen
events attracting publics, which are not really targeted or expected by the
destinations tourism companies.
It is for this reason advised to favour close communication with the companies in
order to anticipate the impacts: maximise positive returns and limit negative
effects.
Aims
The Local CSE Organisation Committee should define beforehand, the targeted
impacts. This enables the inscription of the event in a true economic and tourism
development strategy for the accommodating destination.
The methodology proposed in this Guide should enable to change the linear and mechanical
relation between investments and returns: with the methodology, a modest size event should be
able to generate important impacts (by promoting the region's assets, diversifying the offer of
proposed services, improving the consideration for different types of public by raising the
consummation rates
- 33 -
These two objectives must be combined. The CSE must take the particularities of
the event destination into account and must contribute to the regional economic
and tourism development.
Defining the impacts concerned, during CSE planning, makes it possible for the
companies to anticipate them and therefore maximises sustainable regional
benefits.
Case study
The 2004 European Nations Football Championship (Portugal).
This event was a great popular success. The local populations passion for
football generated a great impact for the
event.
The organising body for the event
considered that the important financial and
human investments exploited, fell under the
longer-term aims of the event itself.
In a country with strong tourism assets and
strong development margins, the organisers
aimed at using the event as a vector for attracting potential and future tourists.
The following initiatives were taken:
-
Avoiding the event to disturb the tourists in Portugal, for other reasons.
- 34 -
The steps for making the companies aware and including them in the
event organisation, concerns mainly SME in the hotel and transport trade.
Other tourism SME did not highly concern the organisers.
- 35 -
Finalities or
targeted goals
Justifying
diagnostic
- Tourist activity
subject to seasonal
effects
- Event held in low
season.
- Tourist activities
presenting
development margins
related to the event.
Develop emerging
tourist activities in
the region
Etc.
- Activities relying
mainly on close
internal tourism.
Estimated means
implemented
The targeted
impacts
Human and financial
means made available by
the organisers, enabling
the promotion of the
event as a tourist offer.
- 36 -
- Increase of x% of
the tourist
frequentation in low
season.
- Proportion of the
frequentation
directly generated by
the event
- Improvement of the
tourism offer
catalogue
- Agreements
between commercial
operators and public
decision makers
- Rise of daily tourist
consummation rate.
B.
Targeted impact
examples
Frequentation growth
for the destination
Structures to be
informed
Trade within the
concerned
geographical zone
Hotel and caterers
Other tourism
companies
SME
Structuring Tourism
Competitiveness Poles
Required information
Development
agencies
Local authorities
Intermediary
structures for job
offers
Scheduled works
Estimated localisation of these works
Town centre
Architectural renewal
Etc.
- 37 -
Undesired impacts
Etc.
- 38 -
F a c t or 5 . A n s w e r t h e n e e d s o f a l l p u b l i c c o n c e r ne d b y
the CSE
Different types of public go to cultural or sport events: people directly concerned
by the event (festival goers, supporters, fans, music lovers), "VIPs" invited by
the sponsors or organisers, youths, people simply passing by
However, the analysis of certain events reveals the following elements:
-
Aims
The organiser need to professionalise their methods and have different service
offer strategies towards the type of public.
It is advised to differentiate at least three types of public, each calling for adapted
service offers:
Non captive publics, more or less attracted by the event but who can
find an additional interest if other associated tourism offers are offered. A
- 39 -
Case study
- 40 -
The festival's internal piloting: follow the public's evolution from one year
to another, orient communication towards target regions or public
The survey results are meanwhile little used for defining public typ ologies for
elaborating activity offers, adapted service and products for these profiles.
Partners and sponsors, as well as certain local companies use the data to direct
their offers. But these initiatives are not monitored or capitalised by the
Organisation Committee.
- 41 -
coach
train
plane
City................................................
in a holiday home
free accommodation (for example with friends)
.......persons
......person (S)
11. How much did you spend during your stay at the festival (approximately)?
Amount in Euros: ... of which:
Lodging per person and night...
Shopping (total)...
Survey continued
on following page
- 42 -
Occupation
employee (executive? yes no)
contractor / liberal profession
scholar/student
retired
unemployed
- 43 -
B.
Public typology
examples
The "passionate"
(supporters, fans,
music lovers)
Useful information
Number:
Duration of stay:
Daily expenses:
Specific expectations:
External spectators
indirectly interested by
the event
(non captive)
Spectators from
outside
the region
The event
organisation team
(technical team, stage
management)
Artists or sportsmen
carrying out the event
Public invited by
the sponsors
Personnel linked to the
sponsors (animators,
reception, receptionist)
Accredited
Media
Disabled public
- 44 -
F a c t o r 6 . D e f i n e a c om m u n i c a ti o n p l a n
By nature, an event is a distinct communication period. All event organisers plan
communication in order to promote the event: the destination, date, programme,
main artists or sport persons
Event organisers have extended experience in communication. They are able to
mobilise a variety of tools to ensure the event's visibility: posters, newspapers,
radio, television, and also live internet broadcasting, information with SMS, fax
But this communication does not does not always fully integrate the region.
Sometimes it is hardly even mentioned! SCE analysis have been able to identify
that the more we move away from the region holding the event, the more the
public retains the thematic or activity of the event rather than the region itself. It is
as if the region was absorbed by the event!
An event can be a powerful marketing tool for promoting the region: its sociocultural identity, economic assets, as well as the geographical, nature and
tourism specifics
Different experiences show how an event can be used for renewing the image of
an event. The most recent example is the Torino Olympic Games (Italy): the
Olympic Games enabled to erase an industrial image lacking modernity, and
promote a town of culture, tourism and trade.
Aims
The local organisation Committee should for this reason, define a communication
plan which makes the link between the CSE and the event destination. This
communication plan must clearly show:
the message content to display throughout the event,
the targets to reach,
the communication channels used.
The message content, the targets as well as the communication channels should
be in ad equation with the regional tourism objectives.
- 45 -
More precisely, the communication plan should be able to expertly promote four
dimensions (See graph below).
1. Characteristic elements of the cultural or sporting event (quality of the
artists and sportspersons).
2. Regional tourism offers proposed in a related or peripheral way to the
event (hotels, catering, local inheritance, sporting and cultural activities).
3. The regional assets and specificities (regional image, craftwork, local
produce, economic activities ).
4. The local partnership set up at the time of the event (to describe the
dynamics of the partnership, the values of this partnership, the dynamics
of social cohesion related to the event ).
- 46 -
Case study
- 47 -
In addition, completing these visual supports used by the region, the Quiksilver
Pro France organisers mobilise a large variety of communication tools ("mixed
media"), with a strong international orientation:
Live internet broadcasting of the event. The whole of the event was
diffused on internet. 200.000 internet users saw the final. The internet
users geographical origin, showed a planetary visibility for the event:
- 48 -
- 49 -
Characteristic
elements
of the CSE
Regional tourism
offers proposed in a
related or peripheral
way to the event
transport?
The
socioeconomic
companies,
associations
other
local
actors:
- 50 -
Targets identified
within the framework
of the regional tourism
strategy10
Local population
Communication and diffusion
plan supports11
Press
Radio
Television
Internet
Posters
10
This is the public targeted by the regional tourism strategy. The public can be defined in
different ways: where they come from, age, buying power and social status
11
In the diffusion plan, it is adviced to at least indicate the referee contact and provisional
diffusion date.
- 51 -
S ta g e I I I :
The CSE realisation.
F a c t o r 7 . C a r r y o u t t h e pr e p a r at o r y w or k for t h e C S E
A CSE is a punctual event, isolated in time: an evening, a few days, a week
Due to this punctual character, does not enable the local actors and population to
fully feel part of the event: its thematic, history, philosophy of action, organisation
methods
To prepare the arrival of the CSE and favour the implication of all the local actors,
the event must be preceded by publicity campaigns and mini local events, in
relation with the CSE thematic. For example, the comic strip festival in
Angoulme, is preceded by plastic art works in the schools and by the installation
of synergy between editors, libraries, producers, visual art companies
The conception of these preparatory actions requires creativity and imagination.
It is a new occasion for using the advantages of having a Local Organisation
Committee, gathering CSE organisers, local authorities and companies.
Aims
Imagine and put into action, a few months before the event, CSE preparatory
actions.
The different types of preparatory actions can be put into four groups:
1. Information and awareness actions targeting different types of local
public. These kind of actions may correspond to all or a part of the
following aims:
- 52 -
Case study
The Prague Spring festival (Republic of Czech).
The festival, created in 1946, is organised by the Spring of Prague company,
transformed in the year 2000 into a public utility company employing 10 people
full-time.
The Organisation Committee develops
a permanent animation leading up to
the festival aiming to involve the civil
company in the organisation, but also
the installation of a permanent musical
animation before the main event:
bands, parades, folkloric animations,
guided tours...
- 53 -
Surveys reveal, that the two thirds of the population over 15 years of age are
concerned by the festival.
It is largely thanks to these preceding operations, led by the Organisation
Committee, that Prague is visited as a musical city outside the festival period.
The event thus represents the summit of the cultural season, which tends to
gradually exist throughout the year.
Information and
awareness actions
targeting different types
of public.
Installation modalities
Precise sequence of
operations:
Installation date:
Necessary methods:
Training and
professionalising
actions
Local development or
tourism development
actions
Actions aiming to
structure
competitiveness
branches or poles.
- 54 -
F a c t o r 8. K e e p u p - t o -d a t e th e C S E m o ni t or i n g c h a r t
The organisation of a CSE has a true project conduct approach. This step is
expressed through the definition of aims in order to improve the defining of
foreseeable and desired event impacts (See factor 4 on page 1).
During the running of the CSE, the Local Organisation Committee should monitor
the level reached for the aims targeted. To do this, it is advised to keep daily a
monitor chart for obtained impacts and gap measures for the targeted aims.
Polls and surveys will be needed for the chart during the event. Indeed, certain
information can only be collected during the event. Particularly the surveys on the
events spectators (See tool proposed for factor 5 on page 1).
For long running events, the chart may be used for piloting and continuous
reorientation of the event. It is the case for the "European Capitals of Culture",
which run for a whole year. The town of Turku (Finland), European Capital of
Culture candidate for 2011, plans to elaborate one of these charts.
Aims
The monitor chart show how the aims were really reached.
This follow-up will allow:
1. To check if the aims have been reached, if they were realistic
and identified, if not, the reasons why they were not reached
(gap measures of and reasons).
2. Use the results to reorient the approach for a forthcoming event.
3. Identify what the event brought to the tourism strategy and for
regional development.
- 55 -
Case study
The last investigation carried out in 2002 made it possible to estimate the
financial effects of the festival at 168 million euros. The revenues from taxes
generated by the festival for the State, the Land and the City are higher than the
subventions.
- 56 -
Finalities or
targeted aims
Targeted
impacts
Evaluation
methods for
measuring the
impacts
- Increase of x% of the
tourist frequentation in low
season.
- Proportion of the
frequentation directly
generated by the event
Survey on
spectators during
and after the
event.
- Improvement of the
tourist offer catalogue
Develop emerging
tourist activities in
the region
- Agreements between
company operators and
local authorities
Company survey
Reporting of the
investigation
results and
observations
Determine, within the guide lines of a work group, the desired information to collect.
2.
Elaborate the questionnaire: formulate the questions and the answer items. Use
straight forward, simple vocabulary and formulations.
3.
4.
5.
Train the surveyors, responsible for administering the questionnaire to the public and
recording results.
6.
7.
8.
Present the results to the work group to generate a debate on the interpretation of
these results and conclusions to be made.
- 57 -
S ta g e I V:
CSE assessment
a n d t h e p r o m o t i o n o f a s s e ts
F a c t o r 9 . C a r r y o u t a s h a r e d e v a l u a t i o n of t h e d u r a b l e
b e n e f i t s f o r t h e t o u r i s t d e st i n a t i o n
Once the event is over, the evaluation period is capital. The evaluation must be
carried out associating the whole Organisation Committee. It must lead to one
shared event evaluation, identifying the strong and weak points in relation with all
of the goals fixed.
All events, what ever their size, should use evaluation methods. Indeed, the CSE
analysis reveals that it is only mega events, like World cups and Olympic
Games, which carry out ex post evaluations.
Aims
The final evaluation (or ex post) of the impacts produced by the event, obeys to
regional project evaluation rules12.
Concerning sport and culture events, we distinguish two evaluation levels:
-
The returns more specifically economic and tourism for the region.
Each country has it's own CSE impact evaluation methods, such as the
econometric model offered by the British government (based essentially on
economic flow measures), or the Swiss "score card" methodology (combining
12
- 58 -
It enables to show objectively the obtained impacts and, promote them to the
CSE partners.
Case study
o
o
o
o
o
Production 1.900 M
Employment 39.363
Added value 700 M
Wages 400 M
Revenues from taxes 57,5 M
Production 183,8 M
Employment 4.547
Added value 81 M
Wages 41 M
- 59 -
2002: 0,11%
2003: 0,32%
2004: 0,11%
A. Measure the gap between the targeted impacts and those finally
obtained, and search for areas of progress.
Obtained CSE
impacts
PROGRESS AXIS
enables sustainable
CSE benefit
maximisation
The areas of progress result from the differences between the targeted and the
obtained CSE impacts. The question grid for below makes it possible to seek
areas of progress on two levels:
1/ CSE benefit for the event destination development.
2/ CSE benefit for tourism based SME development.
- 60 -
- 61 -
2 evaluation
levels
3 analysis
times
Evaluative questions
Indicators
1/ Is the CSE
integrated from the
start, in an attraction
strategy for
sustainable regional
development?
Social level.
Integration of the population for running the CSE (voluntary work).
Level and methods for CSE appropriation by local populations (pride, sense of
membership, collective identity).
CSE educational value for local populations: knowledge contribution, skills,
etiquette (informal education).
Creation of new associative activities.
Number of participants (geographical source, proportion of women, young
people, over 55 years old, handicapped people).
The companies social engagement.
Economic level.
Volume of the initial economic injection (public, private).
Investments related to the CSE.
- Peripheral investments to the CSE.
Creation of new economic activities: craftwork, artist workshops
Job creation (realisation jobs/long term employment; proportion of women,
part time, low level of qualification).
Tax revenue evolution.
Estimation of the repercussions in terms of communication and fame: media
exposure, international press
Use of the TIC (mainly for communication).
Environmental level.
Integration methods of services and associations related to environmental
protection: consultation, integration in the project group.
- 62 -
creation
of
new installations,
- CSE installations.
- CSE peripheral installations.
Standards respected in the realisation of installations.
Particular efforts made in favour:
- Of the landscape and architectural insertion of installations.
- Of the long term for equipment usage (installation integration in a long term
strategy, re-conversion, modularity).
Environmental Management System.
Non CSE period installation usage type and volume.
Image and fame
Strategy and total communication plan and articulation with the operators,
event staging
Location of the impacts lower than the initial forecasts and reasons why.
Location of the impacts not obtained and reasons why.
Search for progress area, in terms of:
- CSE conception: initial diagnosis, regional attachment, partnership,
integration of the civil company
- project control: partnerships, communication, installations
- 63 -
Evaluative questions
Indicators
Exploitation of the event for the communication of the city, trade and
services
Social level.
Level and methods for CSE appropriation by tourism based SME (pride,
sense of membership, collective identity).
Economic level.
Tourist activity evolution indicators for the region (ad hoc local indicators):
Tourist frequentation evolution.
- Evolution of the activities directly related to tourism: hotel trade, catering,
leisure activities
- Evolution of the subsidiary activities: craftwork, industry
Creation of new tourist activities: craftwork, leisure activities
Job creation (realisation jobs/sustainable employments; percentage of women,
part time, low level of qualification).
Taxes revenue evolution.
Estimation of the repercussions in terms of communication and fame: media
exposure, international press
Use of the IC (mainly for communication).
- 64 -
Environmental level
Nature and amount of installations:
modernisation of what already exists.
creation
of
new
installations,
Location of the impacts lower than the initial forecast and reasons why.
Location of the impacts not obtained and reasons why.
Search for progress areas, in terms of:
- CSE conception: initial diagnosis, regional attachment, partnership,
integration of the civil company
- project control: partnerships, communication, installations
- activity creation and/or peripheral products.
- 65 -
Starting from the compared analysis of the methodologies used by the various
events, we propose the following methodology (summarised in the chart above).
It is a simple 5 step methodology, usable by the local actors.
Prior : delimit the evaluation subject. Before starting the evaluation, it is
advisable to delimit the geographical territory and the time scale that one
wishes to evaluate.
1. Measure the brut economic injection. The first step is to evaluate the
money flow generated by the event. Two main money flows are to be
measured and added:
- 66 -
2. Estimate leakage and crowding out effects . The second stage consists
in evaluating all money flows which do not profit directly to the region. This
work can be completed in a relatively approximate way. One
distinguishes:
Leakage effects. It is, for example all purchases made outside the
region: wages, material, but also, all subcontracting outside the
region
- 67 -
- 68 -
F a c t o r 1 0 . C o ns o l i d a t e t h e l o c a l p ar t n er s h i p s i n o r d er
t o d e v el o p s u s ta i na b l e t o ur i s m i n t h e r e gi o n
The local partnership, made during the first step (see page 15) and formalised
within the framework of an Organisation Committee, is an invaluable resource
to sustain after the event.
The partnership made for the CSE is indeed a fundamental asset for other
regional territorial and tourism development projects. The CSE feed back shows
the following main assets:
A opening for economic, tourism, social,
environmental, urban, and communication
cultural,
sportive,
The local partnership installed and tested for a CSE can be formalised with a
"Sustainable Regional Development Pole" or a "Regional Development Agency".
The example of the International Comic Strip Festival, more than 30 years old in
Angoulme, shows how the partnership formed for the event, favoured the
creation of the "Ple Image" gathering 40 regional companies, 600 employments,
a European School of Art, a national comic strip centre The partnership also
made it easier to bring to life the painted wall circuit, a real regional tourist
attraction.
- 69 -
Aims
The partnership may indeed, have several levels of added value after the CSE:
Continuous improvement of the event, within the
framework of a sustainable development strategy for the event
and region.
The installation of an event strategy, aiming to
accommodate and/or create in a recurring way cultural or sport
events. The analysis showed that several cities were based on
the partnership made up on the occasion of an event to
facilitate the organisation or to obtain new events. It is the case
of Barcelona who, following the 1992 Olympic Games, wished
to position themselves as an international capital through the
accommodation of events like the 2004 Universal Forum. It is
also the case of the town of Malm (Sweden), Torino (Italy)
The definition of an economic and tourist development
strategy transcending the framework of cultural or sport events.
The event becomes the starting point for new regional collective
development dynamics and the definition of an elaborated
strategy, as can be seen, in a particularly bright way, the
example of Torino after the 2006 Olympic Games.
Case study
- 70 -
The following levels could be implemented thanks to the sustainability of the local
partnership:
-
- 71 -
Define the future activities that will enable to install and promote local
partnership
Action typology
Installation of an event
strategy
- 72 -
Conclusion:
T h e i m p o r ta n c e o f e ve n ts
for regional development
Cultural and sport events can no doubt, constitute a powerful lever for regional
development and tourism based companies.
But, the practical guide reveals that this can only be achieved under certain
conditions, in particular:
1. Integrate approaches, by articulating the event's technical organisation, so cial
cohesion, improvement of lifestyle, local and tourism development of the
accommodation sites.
2. Resolutely integrate organisers into the regional projects and change the
vision of cultural and sport events which is too elitist or specialised. Join the
actors with a network - within the framework of partnerships and shared
strategies - sporting and cultural organisations, company representatives,
social partners, public communities and, more largely, regional inhabitants.
3. Have a rigorous project control methodology by identifying the most federating
impacts, those which exceed the strict framework of the CSE organisation to
place it in a more supple perspective of regional valorisation and sustainable
tourist assets. Integrate in this methodology a prospective vision for the
regions future, with a long term optic. This methodology for conducting
projects must enable anticipation for targeted impacts and reaction if they are
not reached.
4. Evaluate, objectively and continuously, the impacts really produced by the
event in order to re-orientate the steps and professionalise the project control
methods.
The training of actors and the installation of common and participative measures are
essential for uniting these different conditions.
- 73 -
The Practical Guide, and its adaptation to the specific situations of the
accommodation destinations, may also support networking and exchanges between
cultural and sporting event organisers in Europe.
During the European Conference in Angoulme (22/03/07), many participants
proposed the creation of a European Platform for exchange and capitalisation
between local authorities, CSE organiser and company networks.
The main objectives for this platform have been defined as follows:
-
Formalise criteria and a label for "CSE maximising their sustainable impacts
for the region and the companies".
The installation of this European platform for exchange and capitalisation, and the
realisation of the mentioned aims, are with no doubt a solid step ahead for making
cultural and sport events a real opportunity for the development of the tourist
destinations and companies.
- 74 -
A p p e n d i x I . G l o s s a r y - d e fi n i t i o n o f t h e m a i n k e y
c o n c e pt s
Sustainable
tourism
The usual environment often means the main residence including regular journeys (work, leisure
activities).
- 75 -
Event Tourism
Cultural Tourism
Sport tourism
Tourism or
accommodating
destination
- 76 -
2/ EVENTS OR SHOWS
Events or shows
The level of the event (only the two first levels are concerned by
this study):
- The "Mega events". They have a national impact and receive
global media coverage (international trade fairs, Football World
Cup, Olympic Games, etc).
- The "Hallmark" events. These events have an impact on the
region; they are mainly developed to increase or improve
attractiveness, profitability and help the destination be known.
- The "micro events". They have an impact on a local level
(commune, areas).
- 77 -
3/ IMPACTS
Impact
Economical
impact
Social Impact
Environmental
Impact
- 78 -
Sport Impact
- 79 -
Public authorities
CSE organisers
They are the professionals carrying out the operational plan for
Culture and Sport events
Recommendation of the Commission on the 06-May-2003 concerning the definition of micro, small and
medium size companies [notified under number C(2003) 1422].
- 80 -
A p p e n d i x I I . M o no gr a p h s yn t h e s i s f or 1 0 c u l t u r a l a n d
s p or t i n g e v e n t s
A diverse panel of 10 events, spread over ten European Union countries, in order
to nourish the work from the conference and formalise the key factors for
success of an event (See as follows).
The 10 events studied
1. Austria Salzburg Festival
6. Italy. 2006 Torino Winter Olympic Games to 26 February 2006 in Torino. Next edition
Vancouver 2010
- 81 -
Main variants
Event size
Event age
Event periodicity
Event duration
Target public
for the event
- 82 -
Each study has been formalised with a monograph enabling to analyse the
impact of events on the region and the companies and to identify key factors for
success (See typical plan for monographs on following page).
These monographs, from ten to 15 pages each, are available on the European
Commission or AMNYOS Consultant Cabinet internet site.
A synthesis for each monograph has been carried out in order to integrate in the
guide.
- 83 -
1/ Austria-Salzburg
Salzburg Festival 2005
- 84 -
The key factors of the event's success for the region and the tourism based
companies
1. Historical local anchorage (due to history).
2. Positive image portrayed by Salzburg
3. Quality of the programming.
4. Specially targeted public.
A few progress areas to maximise the benefits of the event for the region:
1. Installation of a yearly cultural offer to reinforce the destination's attractiveness.
2. Professionalise even more the actors.
3. Vary the public.
4. Identify the employments created (direct, indirect, inferred).
5. Reinforce the partnership with the local economic actors.
- 85 -
2/ Spain - Barcelona.
Universal Forum of Cultures - Barcelona Forum 2004
- 86 -
The key factors of the event's success for the region and the tourism based
companies
1/ Optimal management of the Olympic Games' organisational and decisional
inheritance for installing this event.
2/ Devoted support from the institutions.
3/ Efficient informal partnership between the organisers and private operators (for 1
public, 1.40 private; tax benefits)
4/ Clear development project to which the event participates.
5/ Thematic choice to fix the event at the heart of the population's current
preoccupations.
A few progress areas to maximise the benefits of the event for the region:
1. Refine the cultural project and structure the event's calendar.
2. Develop the international communication plan.
3. Articulate the event's cultural offer with the current offer.
4. Develop an evaluation philosophy to provide a stronger promotion of the event's
summary.
- 87 -
- 88 -
The key factors of the event's success for the region and the tourism based
companies
1. An event coherent with the regions identity and development dynamics.
2. A partnership with the local association network, making it easier to anchor the
CSE to the region.
3. A positioning on sporting excellence (higher level), enabling to distinguish from
other sport events.
4. An investment in the diversity of ICT (Information and Communication
Technologies), enabling a more efficient communication.
A few progress areas to maximise the benefits of the event for the region:
1. Provide the local authorities readability on how the CSE contributes to the
development of their region.
2. Install a collegial approach for the conception of the CSE between local authorities,
associations and companies (retailer associations).
3. Have a better understanding of the different types of public and propose
personalised service offers.
- 89 -
4/ Greece - Thessaloniki
Thessaloniki International Film Festival.
- 90 -
The key factors of the event's success for the region and tourism based companies
1. It's accessibility to the main public (conferences held by a Director commenting a
film, pedagogic sessions for children, student tariffs, attribution of a publics award
for a film from the international selection).
2. A festival which runs all year (climaxing in November) with punctual events or more
specialised events (documentary films, experimental films).
3. A growing support from private partners.
A few progress areas to maximise the benefits of the event for the region:
1. Develop private/public partnership.
2. Improve the distribution of the events throughout the year.
3. Link the organisation location to the event.
4. Improve cooperation between the different actors.
5. Find a good balance between an ambitious programming and one which is to
everyones taste.
6. Develop a coherent development strategy on an international level.
- 91 -
5/ Hungry. Budapest
Szigeti Festival
- 92 -
The key factors of the event's success for the region and the tourism based
companies
1. The professionalism of organisers and actors, enabling the mobilisation of diverse
local partnerships as well as important sponsors.
2. The quality of the artistic programming, due to detection work throughout the year.
3. Commercial strategy, enabling to propose a large range of services during the
festival (food and beverage, bar, camping).
A few progress areas to maximise the benefits of the event for the region:
1.
Provide the festival, which is in full growth, the capacity to increase development
and formalisation of the relations between the organisers and local authorities.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
- 93 -
The key factors of the event's success for the region and the tourism based
companies
1. Awareness programme towards the population and the schools during the five
years of preparation for the games.
2. Territorial dynamic.
3. Training and professionalising of voluntary workers who can now use their skills to
help the development of Torino.
4. Improvement of organisational and decisional capacities, notably for public/private
partnerships.
A few progress areas to maximise the benefits of the event for the region:
1. Increase the participation of local SME
- 94 -
7/ Portugal.
2004 European Nations Football Championship
The key factors of the event's success for the region and the tourism based
companies
1. Unconditional national adherence.
2. Support for the tourism actors for structuring their service offers and
professionalising their domains.
3. A quality work on welcoming (training for taxi drivers)
A few progress areas to maximise the benefits of the event for the region:
1. Associate the local economy actors, concerning tourism for elaborating the project.
2. Conciliate different tourisms (ensure that the CSE is focused on the targeted public,
but does not forget the region's traditional).
- 95 -
Prague.
It is organised by the town, the Ministry of Culture, sponsors and representatives of
diplomatic and commercial paths. The town is a strategic point and a meeting place
for people from neighbour and distant countries. It ia one of the oldest political,
economical and cultural centres in central Europe. It is one of the continents most
dynamic towns. The historical richness (the town centre is inscribed since 1992 as
world heritage by the UNESCO) and the strength of traditions motivate the new
generations, to maintain and reinforce Prague's position as a central European
metropolis. It is not only about preserving monuments and passed traditions, but
also about creating the space and conditions for new values, if possible in many
artistic and cultural domains.
The concerts are held in the town's gardens and parks (morning), in historical
edifices such as Palaces (Obecn dom, Rudolfnum) and religious edifices (St. Guy
Cathedral, St. Simon and Judas church turned into a concert hall, the St. Vojt ch
Church, the Spanish synagogue, etc...).
- 96 -
The key factors of the event's success for the region and the tourism based
companies
1. Historical local anchoring.
2. Positive image portrayed by Prague.
3. Quality of the programming.
4. Commercial strategy.
5. In phase with a specific public.
A few progress areas to maximise the benefits of the event for the region:
- 97 -
9/ Slovakia - Vychodna.
International Festival, for popular music, dance and traditions
- 98 -
The key factors of the event's success for the region and the tourism based
companies
1. Organisation locally anchored, with a big local partnership.
2. The event has a friendly atmosphere, which goes with the theme of the festival
(popular festival, promoting traditions).
3. Quality of the programming.
4. Targeted public and above all, loyal to the festival.
A few progress areas to maximise the benefits of the event for the region:
1. Professionalise the actors to develop the event.
2. Develop accommodation capacity
3. Develop the quality of welcoming and organisation.
4. Establish a communication plan.
5. Think of a tourism strategy to articulate around the festival.
6. Increase the association of the local economy actors.
- 99 -
- 100 -
The key factors of the event's success for the region and the tourism based
companies
1.
2.
3.
An event that is coherent with the region's and town's tourism and marketing
strategy.
A mobilisation (on different levels) of the region's economical actors.
An open consideration of the event.
A few progress areas to maximise the benefits of the event for the region:
1.
Maintain the marketing positioning and above all the use and promotion of the
brand Sailing Region .
2. Develop and widen public/private partnership (notably for the event elaboration) to
develop confidence and participation of companies.
3. Develop equipment suitable for receiving big events (conferences, business
tourism,
4. Develop training related to tourism to answer locally to job creations.
- 101 -
A p p e n d i x I I I . D e b a te c o n f e r e n c e pr ogr a m m e a n d
pr a c ti c a l g u i de f i n a l i s at i o n
- 102 -
- 103 -