Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ScienceDirect
RESEARCH ARTICLE
New Mexico State University, Agricultural Science Center, Clovis, NM 88101, USA.
Nepal Agricultural Research Council, Soil Science Division, Khumaltar, Nepal
3
Oklahoma State University, Department of Natural Resource Ecology and Management, Stillwater, OK 74078, USA
4
Oregon State University, Columbia Basin Agricultural Research Center, Pendleton, OR 97801, USA
2
Abstract
Soil organic carbon (SOC) sequestration is one of the major agricultural strategies to mitigate greenhouse gas emissions,
enhance food security, and improve agricultural sustainability. This paper synthesizes the much-needed state-of-knowledge
on the effects of tillage, crop residue, and nutrient management practices on SOC sequestration and identifies potential
research gap, opportunities, and challenges in studying SOC dynamics in rice (Oryza sativa L.)-based cropping systems in
South Asia, mainly in Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, Nepal, Pakistan, and Sri Lanka. Improved management practices such
as reduced- and no-tillage management, nitrogen (N) fertilizer and farmyard manure (FYM) application, and crop residue
addition can improve SOC accumulation. Positive effects of no-tillage, crop residue addition, N addition through manure or
compost application, and integration of organic and chemical fertilizers on SOC accumulation in rice-based cropping systems
have been documented from South Asia. However, limited data and enormous discrepancies in SOC measurements across
the region exist as the greatest challenge in increasing SOC sequestration and improving agricultural sustainability. More
research on SOC as influenced by alternative tillage, crop residue, and nutrient management systems, and development
of SOC monitoring system for existing long-term experiments will advance our understanding of the SOC dynamics in ricebased cropping systems and improve agricultural system sustainability in South Asia.
Keywords: carbon mapping, carbon sequestration, crop residue, no-tillage, rice-wheat system
1. Introduction
residue and nutrient management to improve SOC accumulation, and (III) highlight the opportunities, challenges,
and research gaps to increase sustainability of rice-based
production systems in South Asia.
Agroecosystem of South Asia represents the area of
humid to sub-humid tropical and sub-tropical climate with
frequent extreme precipitation events during summer. The
region spreads around 642 millon ha area and resides 1.6
billion people (FAO 2013). Precipitation ranges from 1 000
to 2 000 mm, approximately 70% of which occurs during
the summer monsoon, and facilitates rice production (Yao
et al. 2008; Ghimire et al. 2012). Continuous rice cultivation is commonly practiced in irrigated areas and lowland
environments, where continuous embankment of water is
possible, or water supply is assured throughout the year.
Areas that do not have a year-round water supply are used
for growing rice in rotation with other crops such as wheat
(Triticum aestivum L.), maize (Zea mays L.), and vegetables.
In South Asia, continuous rice cropping and rice-wheat
rotation occupy approximately 26% of the cultivated land
with additional 30% area under the rainfed mixed farming
that includes upland rice production (FAO 2001). Upland
rice is produced in areas with low precipitation and limited
opportunities for irrigation.
We mapped SOC distribution at different soil depths in
South Asian landscape and reviewed SOC accumulation as
influenced by tillage, crop residue, and nutrient management
practices in rice-based cropping systems. The SOC map
was developed at the spatial resolution of 1 km (Fig. 1) using
a SoilGrids1km - a global 3D soil information system using
a spatial prediction function for some selected soil properties
at six standard depths. To our knowledge, this map is the
first of its kind to demonstrate SOC distribution in South
Asia. The spatial data delineating the rice production area
is not available for the entire region. However, rice-based
production system predominates the region and SOC mapping for the entire region provides a baseline for South Asia
and serves as a good reference for comparing SOC in the
future. In this map, field-based soil profile data and various
covariate layers representing soil forming factors were used
to predict SOC distribution. 2D and 3D regression and regression-kriging were combined with splines for numerical
properties as implemented in the GSIF package of R. The
regression was fitted using general linear models (GLMs)
with a log-link function to predict SOC by using field-based
measurements (Hengl et al. 2014; ISRIC 2015). Selection of
spatial prediction models for making these maps was based
on the iterative evaluation for each soil variable by assessing
the success of cross-validation (Hengl et al. 2014). We also
cross checked the mapped and measured SOC values in
long-term experimental locations across the region, which
revealed reasonable accuracy of kriging-based data to es-
Fig. 1 Soil organic carbon distribution in different soil depths in South Asia.
Table 1 Area under rice production and rice yield in irrigated, rainfed, upland, and flood prone areas in South Asia (Seck et al. 2012)
Country
Bangladesh
Bhutan
India
Pakistan
Nepal
Sri Lanka
Total area
(million ha)
10.25
0.03
42.64
2.01
1.41
0.79
means no data.
Irrigated
Area (%) Yield (Mg ha1)
24.2
2.6
50.0
43.8
3.6
100
2.4
23.0
4.2
77.1
3.7
Production system
Rainfed
Upland
Area (%) Yield (Mg ha1) Area (%) Yield (Mg ha1)
43.1
4.3
8.6
1.6
3.80
3.8
30.1
2.4
14.6
0.8
0
60.6
2.2
3.1
1.0
14.9
2.5
6.9
1.0
Flood-prone
Area (%) Yield (Mg ha1)
21.4
2.5
42.3
11.4
1.5
0
13.3
0.8
1.1
1.0
1)
16
15
FYM, farm yard manure; NPK , nitrogen-phosphorus-potassium (chemical fertilizers). The same as below.
3
30
4
25
60
30
15
30
15
15
60
5
19
2
32
29
15
10
1215
9
Bhattacharyya et a. (2012a)
Conventional tillage
No-tillage
Majumder et al. (2008)
Control
NPK + FYM, straw and green manure
Sharma and Prasad (2008)
No crop residue
Crop residue
Rasool et a. (2007)
No fertilizer and FYM
NPK, FYM
Manna et al. (2005)
Unfertilized
NPK, and NPK+ FYM
Bhandari et al. (2002)
No fertilizer
NPK+GM
Sharma and Bhushan (2001)
Control
Organic residue addition
Yadav et al. (2000)
No fertilizer
FYM+NPK
Chettri et al. (2003)
No fertilizer , green
FYM
manure and FYM
Alam et al. (2014)
Conventional till, deep
No-tillage
tillage
Hossain (2009)
Conventional till
No-tillage, crop residue retention
14
Rice-wheat
Rice-wheat
Rice-rice-wheat
Rice-wheat
Sandy Loam
Sandy clay loam
Silty loam
Sandy
Chitwan, Nepal
Chitwan, Nepal
Bhairahawa, Nepal
Parwanipur, Nepal
Uttranchal, India
Sandy clay loam
Rice-wheat
Sandy loam
West Bengal, India
Rice-wheat
New Delhi, India
Sandy clay loam
Ludhiana, India
Sandy loam
Rice-wheat
Barrackpore, India
Sandy loam
Rice-wheat-jute
Ludhiana, India
Loamy sand
Rice-wheat
Palampur, India
Silty clay loam
Rice-wheat
Various Locations, India Sandy loam-clay loam
Rice-wheat
Wangdue- Phodrang,
Sandy clay loam/silty
Rice-wheat
Bhutan
clay
Gazipur, Bangladesh, Grey Terrace soils/clay Wheat-Mung beanloam
Rice
Rajshahi, Bangladesh
Silty loam
Wheat-Mung beanRice
Rajshahi, Bangladesh
Silty loam
Rice-based rotations
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
Typical practice
Conventional tillage
Conventional tillage
No fertilizer
Control/ no fertilizer
Year
Depth
(cm)
20
50
15
20
Cropping system
Soil type
Location
Serial
no.
1
2
3
4
Table 2 Effects of alternative management on soil organic carbon in rice-based annual rotations in South Asia
Treatments1)
Alternative management
No tillage, crop residue retention
no-tillage
FYM
FYM, chopped wheat straw added
Reference
Soil C storage
Tillage management
Residue management
Reduced-tillage
No -tillage/direct drilling
Surface mulching
Residue incorporation
under conventional tillage
tillage
Nutrient management
Soil C sources
Aboveground biomass
Chemical fertilizer
Microbial biomass
Organic amendments
manure
Legume integration,
microbial fertilizers
Soil C loss
Fig. 2 Conceptual framework to describe the influence of tillage, residue, and nutrient management practices on soil organic
carbon in rice-based cropping systems. Carbon sources are present in a box marked with solid lines, and management practices
are shown in boxes with dotted lines.
over 80% of the rice straw and nearly 50% of the wheat straw
are burnt after crop harvest (Katyal et al. 2001). In recent
years, crop residues have been removed for other purposes
such as bioethanol production, mushroom cultivation, and
bedding material for farm animals (Ptn et al. 2004; Gadde
et al. 2009; Dahiya et al. 2013). Rice and wheat residues
are also used as animal feed since centuries in South Asia.
However, crop residue burning or removal is not desired
as it reduced SOC content and negatively influenced the
sustainability of the rice-wheat system. Retention of crop
residues in a field after crop harvest can supply essential
plant nutrients, accumulate SOC, and thereby maintain
or improve soil fertility status (Walters et al. 1992). Crop
residue is a primary substrate for SOC accrual and improvement of soil productivity (Havlin et al. 1990). They supply
essential plant nutrients upon mineralization and improves
soil biophysical conditions (Nyborg et al. 1995). For example, rice straw contains 58 kg N, 0.71.2 kg P, 1217 kg K,
0.51 kg S, 34 kg Ca and 13 kg per 1000 kg straw on dry
weight basis (Dobermann and Witt 2000). These nutrients
are released upon the decomposition of the crop residue
and support SOC accumulation as well as crop production.
The benefits of sequestering SOC by adding crop residues have been well documented in the temperate regions
(Aulakh et al. 2001). Relatively less information is available
from tropical systems, specifically from rice-based production systems in South Asia (Table 2). In the conventionally
tilled rice-wheat system in Nepal, Ghimire et al. (2012) did
not find any significant effect of crop residues incorporation
to increase SOC in a conventionally tilled rice-wheat system.
However, SOC content was 11% greater under no-tillage and
residue added treatments than under conventional tillage
and no residue added treatments. The recent development
of machinery for simultaneously mulching rice straw while
sowing wheat allows surface application of rice residue,
which may be a significant achievement for tropical soils
such as in South Asia to avoid crop residue burning or incorporation (Sidhu et al. 2007). Surface application of crop
Table 3 Soil organic carbon in rice-based cropping systems after 20 years of alternative fertility treatments in India and Nepal
After 20 years (g kg1)1)
NPK+FYM
Control
NPK
4.1
5.9
7.6
1.9
4.0
5.0
3.0
3.2
3.5
4.9
8.4
14.9
6.0
9.0
14.4
Bhubneshwar, India
Faizabad, India
Karnal, India
Pantnagar, India
Pantnagar, India
Rice-rice
Rice-wheat
Fallow-rice-wheat
Rice-wheat
Rice-wheat-cowpea
Initial
(g kg1)
2.7
3.7
2.3
14.8
14.8
Bhairahawa, Nepal
Barrackpore, India
Rice-wheat
Rice-wheat-jute
10.3
7.1
7.3
4.0
8.8
4.3
4.5
Rice-wheat
1.8
2.0
3.7
Location
Ludhiana, India
1)
Cropping system
Reference
Lal et al. (2004a)
Lal et al. (2004a)
Lal et al. (2004a)
Ram (2000)
Ram (2000)
Regmi et al.
(2000)
Saha et al. (2000)
Rekhi et al.
(2000)
10
11
12
Acknowledgements
We are grateful to Drs. Jim Rasmussen and Tek B. Sapkota for review and suggestions on the earlier version of
the manuscript. We would also like to thank anonymous
reviewers for their helpful comments and constructive inputs
that improved the manuscript.
References
Adhikari K, Hartemink A E, Minasny B, Kheir R B, Greve M B,
Greve M H. 2014. Digital mapping of soil organic carbon
contents and stocks in Denmark. PLOS ONE, 9, e105519.
Alam M K, Islam M M, Salahin N, Hasanuzzaman M. 2014.
Effect of Tillage Practices on soil properties and crop
productivity in wheat-mungbean-rice cropping system
under Subtropical climatic conditions. The Scientific World
Journal, 2014, 115.
Aulakh M S, Khera T S, Doran J W, Bronson K F. 2001.
Managing crop residue with green manure, urea, and tillage
in a rice-wheat rotation. Soil Science Society of America
Journal, 65, 820827.
Baker J M, Ochsner T E, Venterea R T, Griffis T J. 2007. Tillage
and soil carbon sequestration - What do we really know?
Agriculture, Ecosystem and Environment, 118, 15.
Benbi D, Toor A, Kumar S. 2012. Management of organic
amendments in rice-wheat cropping system determines
the pool where carbon is sequestered. Plant and Soil, 360,
145162.
Bhandari A L, Ladha J K, Pathak H, Padre A T, Dawa D, Gupta
R K. 2002. Yield and soil nutrient change in a long-term
rice-wheat rotation in India. Soil Science Society of America
Journal, 66, 162170.
Bhattacharyya P, Roy K S, Neogi S, Adhya T K, Rao K S, Manna
M C. 2012b. Effects of rice straw and nitrogen fertilization on
greenhouse gas emissions and carbon storage in tropical
flooded soil planted with rice. Soil and Tillage Research,
124, 119130.
Bhattacharyya R, Tuti M D, Bisht J K, Bhatt J C, Gupta H S.
2012a. Conservation tillage and fertilization impact on soil
aggregation and carbon pools in the Indian himalayas under
an irrigated rice-wheat rotation. Soil Science, 177, 218228.
Bhattacharyya P, Neogi S, Roy K S, Dash P K, Nayak A K,
Mohapatra T. 2014. Tropical low land rice ecosystem is a
net carbon sink. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment,
189, 127135.
Bijay-Singh, Gajri P R, Timsina J, Yadavinder-Singh, Dhillon S
S. 2002. Some issues on water and nitrogen dynamica in
rice-wheat sequences on flats and beds in the Indo-Gangetic
plains. In: Humphreys E, Timsina J, eds., Modelling Irrigated
Cropping Systems, With Special Attention to Rice-Wheat
Sequence and Raised Bed Planting. Proceeding of a
Workshop, CSIRO Land and Water, Griffith, NSW, Australia.
pp. 115.
Bista P, Ghimire R, Shah S C, Pande K R. 2010. Assessment
of soil fertility management practices and their constraints
in different geographic locations of Nepal. Forum Geogr
- Geographical Studies and Environment Protection
Research, 9, 4148.
Bossuyt H, Six J, Hendrix P F. 2002. Aggregate-protected
carbon in no-tillage and conventional tillage agroecosystems
using carbon-14 labeled plant residue. Soil Science Society
of America Journal, 66, 19651973.
13
14
15
16