Professional Documents
Culture Documents
NGOS
(UNOFFICIAL)
OFFICIAL
DEVELOPMENT
ASSISTANCE
AID
BILATERAL
MULTILATERAL
AID
TIED
UNTIED
HUMANITARIAN
AID (SR)
FOOD AID
MEDICAL AID
EMERGENCY RELIEF
AID
DEVELOPMENT
AID (LR)
GRANTS
PROGRAMME
AID
CONCESSION
AL LONGTERM LOANS
PROJECT AID
8. "Maybe," he says, "there should be a new assessment of all the needs as this would
bring to the forefront that there is a massive amount of work to be done and we are
not talking about months here. We are talking about years that this is going to take for
these areas to recover.
9. "I hear too many people talk about six months or 12 months. This is not the scale we
are looking at. We are looking at three to five years or more."
10. At a school I visited, they have put up a temporary classroom to replace one that was
badly damaged but are still waiting to repair damaged parts of the roof. Other schools
had their roofs blown off, too.
11. Efforts are apparently being stepped up to relocate those who were living within 40m
of the shore - on the grounds that they will then be less vulnerable in future typhoons.
But there is a backlash from some local fishermen who say this will discriminate
against them.
12. A local administrator, Felisa Osabel, told me the government needed to resolve the
issue and wanted to make progress. But she acknowledged: "For the poor it is hard."
And she undoubtedly spoke for many in this community when she said that from now
on "with every single storm we will be afraid, always afraid".
Adapted after: http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-26088854, published 7 February 2014, written by Mike Wooldridge, accessed
10 March 2014
ASSIGNMENT 1
The three above articles clearly show the difference between short and long-term foreign
aid. Explain why type of aid would be most needed in the Philippines at this moment.
Question:
8
10
DA
TA RESPONSE 1
11
12
Questions:
a) Using the article, give an example of the following terms and define the term:
i.
Food aid
ii.
Emergency (relief) aid
iii.
Bilateral aid.
iv. Official Development Assistance (ODA)
v. Programme aid
b) Explain the barriers which limit the effectiveness of foreign aid in Haiti.
c) Explain the motivations of Spain to give aid to Haiti.
d) With reference to Figure 1, explain why there is a difference between the Human
Development Index (HDI) figures for Haiti and Madagascar.
e) Using information from the text / data and your knowledge of economics, evaluate aid as
a means of achieving economic development in Haiti.
13
1.
2.
1.
2.
3.
4.
Questions:
Which type of country receives the largest share of ODA?
Give a reason why upper-middle income countries (UMICs) would need to receive
ODA.
The share of ODA given to low and lower-middle income countries seems to have falling
since the late 1980s. Does this mean that these countries receive less ODA than before?
What is meant by unallocated ODA?
14
ASSIGNMENT 5
1. Explain to what extent this cartoon is still relevant in the world today.
ASSIGNMENT 6
1. When it comes to overseas aid, the
British are hard-headed but not hardhearted, David Cameron declared on
July 19th 2011 in Nigeria. The line
was in part a snappy soundbite. But it
was also a plea, as voters rebel against
the ideapopularised under the
previous, Labour government but
embraced by Mr Cameronthat
Britain should become an aid
superpower.
2. In Lagos, Mr Cameron painted a vision of British aid as a catalyst for economic growth.
To reassure aid sceptics back home, who worry about money going astray, Britain will
focus its cash on things that are quantifiable and measurable, such as campaigns to
vaccinate millions of children, he vowed. The prime minister talked of unclogging
regional and international trade with investments in new internet links, roads and more
professional customs services. Yes, Britain should help the starving and those ravaged by
war, drought and disease, he said; but growth, nurtured by free trade and political
reforms, had the potential to wean Africa off aid altogether.
15
Question:
Explain Britains position of foreign aid.
ASSIGNMENT 7
1. Give reasons why ODA for economic and production sectors could have fallen.
ASSIGNMENT 6
a) Define untied aid.
b) Study the figure on the next page and explain the reasons for the trend in untying aid
in the 1995 -2010 period.
16
UNTIED AID
Evidence has shown that the tying of aid - offering aid on the condition that it be used
to procure goods or services from a specific country or region - can increase the costs of a
development project by as much as 15-30%. In addition, the administration of tied aid
requires larger bureaucracies in both the donor and recipient countries.
Untied aid avoids these unnecessary costs by giving recipient countries the freedom to
use their aid to procure goods and services from virtually any country. From 1999-2001
to 2008, the proportion of untied bilateral aid rose progressively from 46% to 82%.
Source: http://www.oecd.org/dac/untied-aid/untyingaidisitworking.htm (accesed 04 March 2013)
The DAC defines ODA as those flows to countries and territories on the DAC List (see
further in this hand-out) of ODA Recipients and to multilateral institutions which are:
o provided by official agencies, including state and local governments, or by their
executive agencies; and
o each transaction:
i.
is administered with the promotion of the economic development and welfare
of developing countries as its main objective; and
ii.
is concessional in character and conveys a grant element of at least 25 per cent
(calculated at a rate of discount of 10 per cent).
In 2012, DAC members provided USD 125.9 billion in net ODA, representing 0.29% of
their combined gross national income (GNI). This was a a drop of 3.9% in real terms
compared to 2011. The financial crisis and euro zone turmoil led many governments to
implement austerity measures and reduce their ODA budgets.
In 2012, the largest donors by volume were USA, UK, Germany, France and Japan.
Denmark, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Norway and Sweden are the only five countries
which exceed the UN ODA target of 0.7% of GNI. Among DAC members, G7 countries
provided 70% if total net DAC ODA in 2012, a decrease from 75% in 2005. The DAC
EU countries share (51%) is the lowest it has been since 2001.
There is a shift noticeable in aid away from the poorest countries towards middle-income
countries
17
Country programmable aid (CPA) is a subset of total ODA. It is also known as core aid
and represents the portion of aid donors programme for individual countries, and over
which partner countries could have a significant say. CPA is defined through exclusions
by subtracting from total gross bilateral ODA the following activities: that are inherently
unpredictable (e.g. humanitarian aid and debt relief), entail no cross-border flows and do
not form part of co-operation agreements between governments (e.g. food aid, core
funding to NGOs)
Untied aid is defined by DAC as loans and grants whose proceeds are fully and freely
available to procurement (the purchase of goods and services by the government) from all
OECD and partner countries. If this is not the case, then aid is tied (buy only from
suppliers in the donor countries) or partially untied aid (procurement open to a restricted
number of countries). The idea is that untied aid promotes cost-effective use of aid and
promotes free and open trade. Multilateral aid is untied.
DAC members are asked to screen their aid against the gender inequality marker.
18
19
20
21
You should be aware of the current status of international development goals. The most
important and influential are the Millennium Development Goals which will expire by
2015. The UN organisation has therefore started a very ambitious programme to develop
new indicators of development and to set new goals. A data response question could
report on the status of these MDGs. Please make sure that you know the goals by heart
and if you want to read more about them, go to http://www.un.org/millenniumgoals/
22
Aid can be given to different sectors and projects. After the Millennium Development
Goals (MDG) were formulated, changes in the areas where aid was distributed has been
clear.
Since 2002, Official Development Assistance (ODA) for health per capita/year in the
WHO African Region has increased from US$ 2.7 to US$ 9.8 in 2010. Most of the
increase has been however targeting MDG6, with all other health development priorities
together receiving in 2010 less than 50% of the resources disbursed for MDG6. 768% is
the increase of Official Development Assistance (ODA) disbursements for health from
2000 to 2010 and 58%of all ODA commitments for health were to combat HIV/AIDS,
malaria and other diseases in 2009-2010
23
24
25
10. Not only does the group provide seeds, fertiliser and pesticide but each $75 package
also provides sacks for storage, insurance, and, perhaps most important of all,
training.
11. The poverty trap is not averted just yet, however. Rampant speculation means maize
prices fluctuate wildly: low during harvest times and close to three times as high
during the interim. Few smallholder farmers can afford to wait.
12. If I didnt have to pay school fees I could withhold my maize, but I have to sell it
when prices are low to pay the fees, says Mrs Simiyu.
13. Even so, the One Acre Fund approach is so successful some have even abandoned
sugar cane, the regions lacklustre cash crop.
14. Sugar cane takes a longer time to mature and it doesnt help our suffering with
hunger, says Esther Muricho, a 57-year-old mother of ten children. Now I plant
maize.
Adapted after: The Financial Times, http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/662506c6-e642-11e1-bece-00144feab49a.html?
ftcamp=published_links%2Frss%2Fworld%2Ffeed%2F
%2Fproduct&ftcamp=crm/email/2012816/nbe/WorldNews/product#axzz23iZBYl7a, 15 August 2012, written by Katrina Manson.
Question:
Explain the importance of strengthening the agricultural sector in Kenya.
ODA: TOTAL vs. % of GNI
Official Development Assistance (ODA) does not include private contributions or private
capital flows and investments such as FDI or donations by private charities. The main
objective of ODA is to promote growth and development. Pekka Hirvonen from the
Global Policy Forum and author of Stingy Samaritans; Why Recent Increases in
Development Aid Fail to Help the Poor states that recent increases [in foreign aid] do
not tell the whole truth about rich countries generosity, or the lack of it. He feels that
development assistance is often of dubious quality. He gives several reasons for this.
In many cases, aid is primarily designed to serve the strategic and economic interests of
the donor countries or to benefit powerful domestic interest groups. It may be that aid
systems are based on the interests of donors instead of the needs of recipients so that too
little aid reaches countries that most desperately need it or is wasted on overpriced goods
and services from donor countries.
26
27
ASSIGNMENT 8
It could be that you get a data response question in which you will be asked to compare
and contrast the extent, nature and sources of ODA to two economically less developed
countries. Although it is impossible to predict whether this will be the type of data
response question you will get and which two countries could be compared and
contrasted, we could try to simulate this type of question. Compare and contrast Haiti and
Pakistan using your own knowledge and the information which follows.
28
29
The DAC1 List of ODA Recipients shows the countries and territories eligible to receive official development assistance (ODA). The
DAC is the Development Assistance Committee of the OECD. The list consists of all low- and middle-income countries based on
gross national income (GNI) per capita as published by the World Bank, with the exception of G8 members, European Union (EU)
members and countries with a firm accession date for entry into the EU. The list also includes all of the Least Developed Countries
(LDCs) as defined by the United Nations (UN).
30
Advantages of Trade (also see your notes from International Economics (section 3))
Some outward-oriented countries have experience high rates of economic growth as a
result of their rapidly-expanding exports.
Trade enables countries to specialise in production in which the country has a
comparative or absolute advantage which makes the use of resources more efficient.
The Asian Tigers and Newly Industrialised countries (although not so new anymore) are
real world examples of this strategy. In 1993, the World Bank published a report, entitled
the ``East Asian Miracle,'' which identified eight countries that had achieved ``seemingly
miraculous'' rates of sustained growth over the 25-year period from 1965 to 1990. The
eight were Japan, the ``Four Tigers:'' Hongkong, South Korea, Singapore, and Taiwan;
followed by the ``newly industrializing economies,'' now called ``emerging Tigers:''
Indonesia, Malaysia, and Thailand.
Specialisation and producing for foreign markets can create economies of scale.
Trade can provide countries new export opportunities which could ceteris paribus
increase a countrys net exports, increase output and create additional jobs.
Exports can lead to an inflow of foreign currency.
Disadvantages of Trade
World trade is dominated by high income countries and MNCs (multinational
corporations). It is difficult for low income countries to enter the world market and
compete against established exporting countries and MNCs. Trade blocs and tariffs create
additional barriers for low-income countries in accessing international markets.
Many low income countries depend heavily on the export of one or two often primary
commodities and the importing of manufactured goods; deteriorating terms of trade have
harmed both economic growth and development.
31
lack of financial capital and expertise is a barrier to development which aid can fill.
the donor as well as receiver benefiting from higher income in the recipient country
aid could be used to bridge the savings gap and investment gap
fill the technology gap
can provide needed foreign exchange currency.
empirical evidence supports that NGO aid is successful in contributing towards
development.
aid (and especially aid for trade) could be used as a transition strategy
aid given to finance:
provision of merit goods in recipient country
to finance imports of appropriate technology
to finance infrastructure projects in low-income countries (however, supporting noncommercially viable projects may give benefits such as reducing unemployment
whilst the project is being constructed. However when the development assistance is
withdrawn the project may fail to stand on its own and either collapse or require
additional funding).
Do you want to see advocates and adversaries of aid in action, then go to:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=INVMnknVHLU&list=PLB325301664E84EE0&index=3
32
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eMGM-_Ifli0&list=PLB325301664E84EE0&index=2
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=av1FFB9M5uU&index=6&list=PL3E8055D35B1F4A5F
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HIPvlQOCfAQ&list=PL3E8055D35B1F4A5F
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yhiRYn6df9Q&list=PL3E8055D35B1F4A5F
33
o
o
o
o
o
o
o
The U.S. currently spends $450 billion on its military, but only about $16
billion in official development assistance.
In Sub-Saharan Africa, more than 15 of every 100 children die before the
age of five. In western Kenya, fertilizer costs more than twice what it costs in France
or the U.S. Ethiopia is so deforested that rural households cannot use manure as
fertilizer because they need it as cooking fuel.
The rich countries have repeatedly promised to give $210 billion (0.7% of
their incomes) in official development assistance, but only give $69 billion.
Because of HIV/AIDS, life expectancy in crisis countries like Botswana
has dropped to below 40 years.
Millions of people, mostly children, die from malaria every year. For
about $3 billion from the rich world, 2 million malaria deaths could be averted.
$25 billion a year would be enough to deliver life-saving health services to
the low-income countries. The U.S. has recently given $200 billion per year in tax
cuts.
Preliminary estimates show that the Millennium Development Goals can
be met if foreign aid were increased by $75 billion per year, well within the promise
of 0.7%.
34
35
36
Questions:
(a)
(b)
[2 marks]
Explain how foreign aid can help a country such as Malawi to
break out of a poverty cycle.
[4 marks]
(c)
(d)
37
Trade can be a powerful engine for economic growth and poverty reduction, but
according to the OECD many developing countries may find it difficult to take advantage
of all the benefits. This is particularly true for the least developed countries where there is
often a lack of capacity in terms of information, policies, procedures, institutions,
and/or infrastructure to integrate and compete effectively in global markets.
To address these barriers, the WTO has led the call for more and better aid for trade. In
fact, aid for trade increased 62% in real terms between the 2002- 05 baseline period and
2008, with commitments in 2008 totalling USD 41.7 billion. Aid for trade can provide a
short-term stimulus with long-term impacts on improving the ability of enterprises in
low-income countries to respond to trade opportunities. Aid for trade bolsters the
contribution of trade to economic growth and poverty reduction.
There is a large and growing body of evidence that there are positive links between
openness to trade and economic performance. Steady reduction in trade barriers
particularly in manufactured goods has enabled these countries to rapidly integrate into
world markets through an export-led industrialisation process.
Opening up trade regimes and enhancing market access is often not sufficient, however,
to enable developing countries to participate and reap all the potential benefits of trade
liberalisation. These countries need help in building their trade-related capacity if they are
to benefit. There is no doubt that this may sometimes require painful structural
adjustment.
Strengthening the linkages between trade and human development is very much part of
the broader development agenda. In particular, this is an integral part of the global
partnership for development mapped out by the Millennium Development Goals (goal
number 8). Aid for trade underpins these objectives by strengthening the positive links
between trade, economic growth and poverty reduction.
Source: http://www.oecd.org/dataoecd/30/36/45581702.pdf
38
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
39
[8
marks]
40
41
Questions:
a) With reference to the article, define the following terms highlighted in bold:
i. privatisation,
ii. capital market liberalisation;
iii.
subsidies;
iv. capital flight;
v. free trade.
[2 marks]
b) Using a supply and demand diagram, explain why market-based pricing may result in
higher prices.
[4 marks]
c) Using the article and your own knowledge of economics evaluate the view that the
IMF and the World Bank policies are designed to further their interests of more
developed countries at the expense of less developed countries.
[8 marks]
Note:
The term "Structural Adjustment Program" has gained such a negative connotation that
the World Bank and IMF launched a new initiative, the Poverty Reduction Strategy
Initiative. Countries are now to develop Poverty Reduction Strategy Papers (PRSP).
While the name has changed, the World Bank and IMF are still forcing countries to adopt
the same types of policies as SAPs.
World Banks structural adjustment programmes often consisted of:
improved management public investments;
revised agricultural pricing policies (no longer maximum prices and guaranteed prices
producers);
revised industrial incentives;
reform of budget and tax system;
improvement of export incentives.
IMFs stabilisation programmes often consist of:
reduction of public sector / budget deficit;
devaluation of exchange rate;
liberalisation;
privatisation;
trade liberalisation;
creating more competition.
42
43
During the 1990s, the IMF and World Bank together launched two major initiatives to
help poor countries. In 1996, the organizations introduced the Heavily Indebted Poor
Countries (HIPC) Initiative to reduce the external debt burdens of the most heavily
indebted poor countries.
In 1999, the IMF and the World Bank initiated the Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper
(PRSP) approacha country-led strategy for linking national policies, donor support, and
the development outcomes needed to reduce poverty in low-income countries. PRSPs
underpin the HIPC Initiative and concessional lending by the IMF and World Bank.
In July 2004, the Fund and Bank launched the Global Monitoring Report (GMR). This
annual report assesses progress on policies and actions needed to achieve the UN
Millennium Development Goals (MDGs). The GMR also considers how well developing
countries, developed countries, and the international financial institutions are contributing
to the development partnership and strategy to meet the MDGs as reaffirmed at a summit
in Monterrey in March 2002.
The IMF and World Bank are also working together to make financial sectors in member
countries resilient and well regulated. The Financial Sector Assessment Program (FSAP)
was introduced in 1999 to identify the strengths and vulnerabilities of a country's
financial system and recommend the appropriate policy responses.
44
45
Light-weight BRICS
Jun 6th 2011, 11:29 by The Economist online
How IMF voting shares compare with global economic heft
MANY argue that IMF vote-shares (and the amounts countries are required to put
into the fund's kitty) should reflect countries' relative economic heft. At the moment,
however, that is far from being the case. Taken together, the economies of the
European Union countries amount to just under 24% of the global economy. The
economies of Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa together make up about
21% of world GDP. But the European countries have 32% of the votes in the IMF,
while the BRICS have 11%. No wonder the BRICS' representatives to the fund issued
a rare joint statement deploring Europe's lock on the top job at the IMF, which is
made possible in part by the fact that Europe and America between them have
nearly 50%of the votes in the IMF's board. Proportionately, sub-Saharan Africa,
(excluding South Africa) is the most over-represented region, with 3.1% of the vote
but a mere 1.35% of the world economy.
46
47
Evaluate the role of multilateral organizations like the World Bank and the IMF in
assisting the economic development of Heavily Indebted Poor Countries.
Answers may include:
overview of the assistance provided by the IMF such as financial assistance to correct
balance of payment deficits or structural adjustment programmes
overview of the assistance provided by the World Bank such as offering
developmental assistance to middle and poor-income countries
evaluation of assistance provided to HIPC
evaluation of impact on economic growth
evaluation of impact on development such as income distribution, reduction of
absolute poverty, income distribution
evaluation of impact on human development such as literacy, life expectancy, HDI
progress
evaluation of macro impact on unemployment, inflation, exchange rate, fiscal and
monetary stability, saving, investment, role of government
evaluation of impact on balance of payments performance such as current account
and capital account
critical approach towards the IMF and the World Bank
any money received may often not get to the intended recipients because of
corruption
IMF Lending: When can a country borrow from the IMF?
A member country may request IMF financial assistance if it has a balance of payments
need when it cannot find sufficient financing on affordable terms to meet its net
international payments while maintaining adequate reserve buffers going forward. An
IMF loan eases the adjustment policies and reforms that a country must make to correct
its balance of payments problem and restore conditions for strong economic growth.
The changing nature of IMF lending
The volume of loans provided by the IMF has fluctuated significantly over time. The oil
shock of the 1970s and the debt crisis of the 1980s were both followed by sharp increases
in IMF lending. In the 1990s, the transition process in Central and Eastern Europe and the
crises in emerging market economies led to further surges of demand for IMF resources.
Deep crises in Latin America kept demand for IMF resources high in the early 2000s, but
these loans were largely repaid as conditions improved. IMF lending rose again starting
in late 2008, as a period of abundant capital flows and low pricing of risk gave way to
global deleveraging in the wake of the financial crisis in advanced economies.
IMF Facilities
Over the years, the IMF has developed various loan instruments, or facilities. Lowincome countries may borrow at a concessional interest rate through the Poverty
Reduction and Growth Facility (PRGF) and the Exogenous Shocks Facility (ESF).
48
Except for the PRGF and the ESF, all facilities are subject to the IMFs market-related
interest rate, known as the rate of charge.Source: http://www.imf.org/external/np/exr/facts/howlend.htm
(published 9 September 2009, viewed 24 march 2010)
49
50
While IBRD earns a small margin on this lending, the greater proportion of income
comes from lending out own capital. This capital consists of reserves built up over the
years and money paid in from the bank's 185 member country shareholders. IBRD
income also pays for World Bank operating expenses and has contributed to IDA and debt
relief.
The World Bank often has a surplus at the end of the fiscal year, which is earned from the
interest rates charged on some loans and from fees charged for some of our services.
Some of the surplus goes to IDAthe part of the bank that provides grants and interest
free loans to the world's poorest countries. The rest of the surplus is either used for debt
relief for heavily indebted poor countries, added to financial reserves, or helps us respond
to unforeseen humanitarian crises.
Why is there still so much poverty after 60 years of the World Bank's existence?
For the Bank, the bottom line is that there has been progress, but there has not been
enough. The World Bank has stated to continue to do all they can to make sure successful
projects and approaches are shared more widely so there's a greater impact on poverty
reduction. At the same time, they claim to have learned from past mistakes and constantly
work to improve our policies and programs. While poverty still exists, much progress has
been made:
Over the past 40 years, life expectancy in developing countries has risen by 20 yearsabout as much as was achieved in all of human history prior to the mid-20th century.
Over the past 30 years, adult illiteracy in the developing world has been nearly halved
to 25%.
Over the past 20 years, the absolute number of people living on less than one dollar a
day has begun to fall for the first time, even as the world's population has grown by
1.6 billion people.
Over the last decade, growth in the developing world has outpaced that in developed
countries, helping to provide jobs and boost revenues poor countries' governments
need to provide essential services.
The bank has assisted the nations of the former Soviet Union and Eastern Europe in
developing their economies to the point at which a large group of these countries
Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania, Poland, Slovakia, and Slovenia
qualified for and were admitted to membership in the European Union in 2004.
Bulgaria and Romania joined in 2008 and Croatia is currently a candidate for
membership.
Part of the eradication of river blindness in 11 West African nations
Facilitated Chinas entry into the global economy in the late 1970s and early 1980s
through advice and lending.
Helped India overcome famine in the 1960s through support for its green
revolution, which substantially increased the production of such crops as rice and
wheat by introducing new strains of highyield seeds.
51
52
53
Find below useful points to consider in an answering evaluation questions asking you to
compare and contrast the roles of aid and trade in economic growth and development.
You must be able to explain the concept of development. It is not sufficient to simply
define development. You need to clearly demonstrate how the points you explain can
actually contribute to development. The better responses will distinguish between the
effect of aid / trade on growth and the effect of aid / trade on development.
You should be able to explain whether the asked for strategy (aid, trade, import
substitution, export promotion (export-led growth), trade liberalization,
interventionist policies and / or market-oriented policies) is the most effective way to
bring about development versus other ways of achieving development (e.g. trade vs.
aid).
Better responses will discriminate between the effects of different types of aid. The
impact of humanitarian aid can not be compared with the effects of project aid or
programme aid.
In the case of aid, you might want to investigate the different effects on the donor and
the recipient country. To be aware of real-world examples will strengthen your
answer. The news sections of the IMF, World Bank or UN websites can provide you
with useful information.
Assistance from other countries can enable countries to improve their infrastructure,
stock of capital goods, education and health care. However, aid is not always given
appropriately and will not raise living standards in that case. An example might be to
provide capital for high-technology equipment to a very poor and overpopulated
agricultural country. The technology and trained labour force required to use this
equipment may not exist. Capital which takes advantage of the comparative
advantages of this country (climate, natural resources, labour intensive production)
are likely to have a larger effect.
54