Professional Documents
Culture Documents
First Edition
To order or to receive additional information on these or any other Haestad Press titles,
please call 800-727-6555 (US and Canada) or +1-203-755-1666 (worldwide) or visit
www.haestadpress.com.
HAESTAD METHODS
First Edition
Authors
Haestad Methods
Thomas M. Walski
Thomas E. Barnard
Eric Harold
LaVere B. Merritt
Noah Walker
Brian E. Whitman
Managing Editor
Thomas E. Barnard
Project Editors
Kristen Dietrich, Adam Strafaci, Colleen Totz
Contributing Authors
Christine Hill, Gordon McKay, Stan Plante, Barbara A. Schmitz
Peer Review Board
Jonathan Gray (Burns and McDonnell), Ken Kerri (Ret.),
Neil Moody (Moods Consulting Pty, Ltd.), Gary Moore (St. Louis Sewer District),
John Reinhardt (Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection),
Reggie Rowe (CH2M Hill), Burt Van Duin (Westhoff Engineering Resources)
HAESTAD PRESS
Waterbury, CT USA
Wastewater Collection System Modeling and Design provides a unique blend of the principals and practices of engineering for academia and professional engineers. This text
provides its readers with modeling guidance that is both technically sound and relevant for improving the performance of existing systems.
-Gary Moore, PE
Metropolitan St. Louis Sewer District
USA
Wastewater Collection System Modeling and Design is a great addition to what has
become my Haestad Methods library. This book is a must for all practicing engineers
that work in sewer system design and is a great reference for use by college students.
Finally, a single book that links fundamental sewer hydraulics to practical sewer
design and modeling practiced by professional engineers.
Wastewater Collection System Modeling and Design is the culmination of the efforts of
many individuals, the most significant of which are the thousands of engineering professionals around the world who dedicate their careers to managing wastewater and
providing basic sanitation services to ensure the health of the public. Haestad Methods has been serving wastewater engineers around the world for over 20 years, and
our discussions with the community have provided the inspiration to write this book.
Many authors contributed to the success of Wastewater Collection System Modeling and
Design. Primary credit goes to Tom Walski, Eric Harold, LaVere Merritt, Noah Walker,
and Brian Whitman. Significant contributions were also made by Christine Hill, Gordon McKay, Stan Plante, Barbara A. Schmitz, and the staff of Haestad Methods. Information on the individual authors and the chapters to which they contributed is
provided in the next section, Authors and Contributing Authors. It is the synthesis
of everyone's ideas that really makes this book such a practical resource. Extra special
thanks to the project editors, Kristen Dietrich, Adam Strafaci, and Colleen Totz for
their countless hours of hard work and dedication to weave the information from
many authors and reviewers into a cohesive and accessible textbook.
We greatly appreciate the efforts of our peer reviewers Jonathan Grey, Ken Kerri, Neil
Moody, Gary Moore, John Reinhardt, Reggie Rowe, and Bert van Duin. They provided exceptional insight and shared practical experiences that added enormously to
the utility of this book.
Many engineers at Haestad Methods contributed to editing, reviewing, content development, exercise review, and fact checking for this book, making its final delivery a
company-wide effort. Their input played an enormous role in shaping the text into its
final form. Special thanks to Brian Bauer, Jack Cook, Ryan Cournoyer, Norelis Florentino, Michael Glazner, Sharavan Govindan, Andres Gutierrez, Juan Carlos Gutierrez,
Jennifer Hatchett, Gregg Herrin, Keith Hodsden, Ming Jin, Tasneem Khomusi, Elizabeth Lipovsky, Douglas Maitland, Christopher Moks, Guillaume Pelud, Richard
Sappe, Mal Sharkey, Angela Suarez, Karthik Sundaresan, and Somchit Thor. Brian
Whitman and Tom Walski contributed to the discussion topics and exercises at the
end of each chapter.
The illustrations and graphs throughout the book were created and assembled under
the direction of Mike Campbell with the assistance of Caleb Brownell. We also wish to
thank the following individuals and organizations for providing us with additional
illustrations and photographs: Tom Walski, Getty Images, Cole Publishing, University
of Iowa, Maria do Cu Almeida, John Barton, Daniel Sztruhar, Duncan Mara, Peerless
Pump Company, Aquacraft, LNEC, MGD Technologies, Thel-Mar Company, Campbell Scientific, Marsh-McBirney, Unidata, Renaissance Instruments, Water Environ-
ment Research Foundation, Pearson Education, R.D. Zande & Associates, ITT Flygt
Corporation, and Environment One Corporation. Special thanks to Meredith Miller at
cartoonbank.com for the New Yorker cartoons throughout the book.
Others involved in the production process for the book include Lissa Jennings (publishing logistics), Rick Brainard and Jim O'Brien (cover design), Matt Cole (web page
design), Jeanne and David Moody (indexing and proofreading), David Klotz (formatting and page layout), and Ann Drinan (indexing).
Finally, special thanks to Haestad Methods executive vice president, Niclas Ingemarsson, who provided the human resources and management guidance to get the job
done, and to the company president, John Haestad, who provided the vision and
motivation to make this collection of ideas a reality.
Tom Barnard
Author and Managing Editor
Haestad Methods, Inc.
Wastewater Collection System Modeling and Design represents a collaborative effort that
combines the experiences of over fifteen contributors and peer reviewers and the
engineers and software developers at Haestad Methods. The authors and contributing
authors and the chapters they developed are:
Thomas M. Walski
Haestad Methods, Inc. (Chapters 1, 3, 12, 13)
Thomas E. Barnard
Haestad Methods, Inc. (Chapter 15)
Eric Harold
Buchanan Street Consulting (Chapters 7, 11)
LaVere B. Merritt
Brigham Young University (Chapters 2, 4, 6, 10)
Noah Walker
Dudek and Associates (Chapters 8, 9)
Brian E. Whitman
Wilkes University (Chapter 5)
Christine Hill
XCG Consultants, Ltd. (Chapter 15)
Gordon McKay
Hong Kong University of Science and Technology (Chapter 15)
Stan Plante
CDM (Chapter 14)
Barbara A. Schmitz
CH2M Hill (Chapter 14)
The Haestad Methods Engineering Staff is an extremely diverse group of professionals from six continents with experience ranging from software development and engineering consulting, to public works and academia. This broad cross section of
expertise contributes to the development of the most comprehensive software and
educational materials in the civil engineering industry. In addition to the specific
authors credited in this section, many at Haestad Methods contributed to the success
of this book.
Thomas M. Walski, PhD, PE, Vice President of Engineering for Haestad Methods, has
been named a Diplomat by the American Academy of Environmental Engineers. Over
the past three decades, Dr. Walski has served as an expert witness; Research Civil
Engineer for the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers; Engineer and Manager of Distribution Operation for the City of Austin, Texas; Executive Director of the Wyoming Valley Sanitary Authority; Associate Professor of Environmental Engineering at Wilkes
University; and Engineering Manager for the Pennsylvania American Water Company. Over the past decade, he has also taught more than 2,000 professionals in Haestad Methods' IACET-accredited hydraulic modeling courses. His experience in
wastewater collection systems ranges from operating a large regional system made up
of a mixture of sanitary and combined collection systems to evaluating small pressure
sewer systems.
A widely published expert on hydraulic modeling, Dr. Walski has written several
books, including Analysis of Water Distribution Systems, Water Distribution Simulation
and Sizing (with Johannes Gessler and John Sjostrom), and Water Distribution Systems
A Troubleshooting Manual (with Jim Male).
He has served on numerous professional committees and chaired several, including
the ASCE Water Resources Systems Committee, ASCE Environmental Engineering
Publications Committee, ASCE Environmental Engineering Awards Committee, and
ASCE Water Supply Rehabilitation Task Committee. He also served on the committees that produced the Water Environment Federation's Pump Station Design (FD-4)
and Energy Conservation (MFD-2) manuals.
Dr. Walski has written over 50 peer-reviewed papers and made roughly 100 conference presentations. He is a three-time winner of the best paper award in Distribution
and Plant Operation for the Journal of the American Water Works Association and is a
past editor of the Journal of Environmental Engineering. He received his MS and PhD in
Environmental and Water Resources Engineering from Vanderbilt University. He is a
registered Professional Engineer in two states and a certified water and wastewater
plant operator.
Thomas E. Barnard, PhD, PE, is a senior engineer with Haestad Methods. He has
more than 20 years of experience in environmental engineering working as a consultant, researcher, educator, and author. He holds a BS in civil engineering from the University of Vermont, an MS in environmental engineering from Utah State University,
and a PhD in environmental engineering from Cornell University. His expertise
include water and wastewater treatment, hazardous waste management, surface
water hydrology, and water quality monitoring systems. His major consulting
projects include RCRA permitting for hazardous and radioactive wastes at the Rocky
Flats Plant in Colorado; water quality modeling of receiving wastes and analysis of
wastewater treatment/disposal alternatives in Alexandria, Egypt; and investigations
of regional water quality monitoring programs in the Chesapeake Bay watershed of
the United States.
Dr. Barnard is a contributing author to Computer Applications in Hydraulic Engineering
and Stormwater Conveyance Modeling and Design. He has contributed chapters to Principles of Environmental Chemistry and Chemometrics in Environmental Chemistry. He has
also served as a book reviewer for Water Environment and Technology and as a peer
reviewer for the Journal of the American Water Resources Association. He is a registered
professional engineer in Pennsylvania.
Eric M. Harold, PE, currently serves as Director of Buchanan Street Consulting. Mr.
Harold is an environmental engineer with over 13 years experience in combined
sewer overflow (CSO) and sanitary sewer overflow (SSO) analysis, hydrologic and
hydraulic modeling, sanitary sewer and stormwater flow monitoring, water quality
monitoring and modeling, and database management. He has made numerous presentations in hydraulic and hydrologic modeling. Mr. Harold holds a BS degree in
Civil and Environmental Engineering from the University of Cincinnati. He is a registered professional engineer in Maryland, Virginia, and the District of Columbia.
Dr. Merritt, Professor of Civil and Environmental Engineering at Brigham Young University, has broad research and design experience in sewer systems. Of particular note
is his experience in design optimization, cost sensitivity to design parameters, design
flow rates, infiltration and inflow analysis, and tractive force approaches to selfcleansing. His publications include over 10 peer-reviewed technical papers and over
50 research and consulting reports. He has made numerous technical presentations,
mainly on water quality and computer-aided sanitary engineering design.
S. M. Noah Walker, P.E. is the Principal Utility Planner for Dudek and Associates, Inc.
and Chief Technical Officer of 3-Waters Technical Services. Over the past 25 years, Mr.
Walker has served as Process Engineer for Continental Grain Co.; Assistant Director
of Systems Planning and Systems Services (IT) for the Water and Wastewater Utility in
Austin, Texas; Chief of Collection Systems, City of Las Vegas; and Regional Engineering Manager and Product Line Manager for software at ADS Environmental Services.
Over the past decade, he has taught hundreds of engineering professionals to use
leading collection system modeling software including through Haestad Methods'
IACET-accredited sewer modeling course. His career focus has been on applying rapidly changing hardware and software technologies to improve the management of
water, wastewater, and storm water utilities.
During his career, Mr. Walker has been involved in the implementation of large scale
data networks and temporary and permanent wastewater flow measurement installations. He has also developed graphical user interfaces for hydraulic models, developed software for the analysis and integration of wet weather flows, and contributed
ist to head up the Process Safety and Environmental Management teams and acted as
Project Manager for certain key projects. His work in the safety area included performing Safety Audits and serving as Hazop Chairman and Process Safety Training
Manager. In the environmental area, his work included responsibility for environmental impact statements, environmental audits, acquisition audits, IPC license applications, and implementation of environmental management systems.
Prior to establishing his own consultancy, Professor McKay was in the Chemical Engineering Department at Queens University, Belfast for 17 years. He has published over
300 research papers and authored/contributed to five books in the fields of environmental management systems and the design of environmental treatment systems. He
is currently Chairman of the Chemical Discipline for the Hong Kong Institution of
Engineers.
Stan Plante, PE, is a principal engineer with CDM and directs various information
technology projects in Ohio and surrounding states. Throughout his career, Mr. Plante
has focused on development and application of hydraulic models to support water
distribution and wastewater collection master plans. He has managed many water
and sewer master plan projects for both slow- and rapid-growth situations, and has
also provided technical direction and troubleshooting on modeling efforts around the
United States, particularly for water distribution projects. In the last few years, Mr.
Plante has worked on GIS implementation projects for a variety of environments
(large city, small city, airports, etc.), several of which have included modeling integration components.
Barbara A. Schmitz is a senior GIS consultant and project manager with more than 18
years of experience in developing and applying geospatial technologies. She is the
firm-wide technology leader at CH2M Hill for GIS applications related to water,
wastewater, and water resources management projects. Ms. Schmitz has expertise in
the integration of GIS technologies with water and wastewater utility maintenance
management systems for facilitating utility system inventories and digital mapping,
condition assessments, combined sewer overflow and sewer infiltration/inflow management, and general utility maintenance and management planning. She integrates
GIS databases with modeling applications, such as hydraulic models, to support system design, analysis, and optimization. Ms. Schmitz also provides training in GIS and
related technologies for CH2M Hill clients and in-house staff.
Ms. Schmitz has authored several peer-reviewed papers and conference presentations
on a variety of GIS topics. She has also contributed chapters on GIS applications to
several books about sewer and water system modeling and to a manual of practice for
implementing geographic information systems in utilities.
Libraries are wondrous institutions. Rows and rows of books create a feeling of awe
as they rise high above the floors of the great libraries of the world, such as the Bibliothque Nationale in Paris, The John P. Robarts Research Library at the University of
Toronto, and the Library of Congress in Washington, D.C. But, the true magnificence
of libraries lies in their ability to set in motion imagination and excitement in learning.
The books and other materials they house provide the opportunity to understand and
benefit from what others have experienced, and expand our ability to make informed
decisions. Indeed, the mission statement of the Library of Congress states the
Librarys aim to sustain and preserve a universal collection of knowledge and creativity for future generations.
Study of the decisions, actions, and results of others past activities under conditions
analogous to ones own situation helps in predicting the results of current decisions.
Social science scholars study human behavior and develop hypotheses or explanations of what to expect from humans in certain group interactions. Military scientists
explore the principles that control the conduct of war, and then apply those principles
to battle conditions. Scientists study the research and experiments of other scientists
to better understand the causes and effects of material, force, and environment variation. Each of these examples represents the premise of simulation and model software
development, which is that the past helps predict the future when combined with scientific or mathematical principles.
Like libraries, models can activate the imagination and generate excitement because
they provide information and knowledge that, in turn, enables more informed decisions or solutions. Decision makers use modeling tools to simulate actual conditions
and generate performance and functional assessments significantly more quickly than
with real-time observations. Generally, the only technical restriction on what can be
simulated is the complexity and power of the model.
The value and benefit of using models is increasingly being recognized. In the wastewater industry, utilities use hydraulic models in all phases of the collection and treatment systems life cycle: planning, design, construction, and operation. Hydraulic
models allow costly and complicated collection systems to be comprehensively evaluated prior to expending a community's limited resources to solve service or regulatory issues. Proposed infrastructure components can be assessed against the risk of
not achieving a utilitys mission and goals, or of incurring harmful health and environment consequences due to poor or unexpected performance.
Once wastewater collection and treatment systems have been built and put into service, their performance can be measured. Utility decision makers can then use the
measurement information to gauge earlier decisions and expectations. Knowledge
gained from past experience will aid the utility in achieving future goals, and can
assist others in similar situations if documented and exchanged in technical publications, manuals, or reference books.
This book has done an excellent job of capturing and communicating the knowledge
of several experienced hydraulic modelers. It presents a good, balanced perspective of
the alternatives and informational needs of a modeler starting a modeling project,
including how to build and assemble the hydraulic components and apply the software tool efficiently.
Undoubtedly, this book too will appear in libraries and be on the shelves of hydraulic
modelers who want to gain from the knowledge and experiences of their peers and
predecessors.
Reggie Rowe, PE
CH2M Hill
Preface
xi
xv
xvii
1.1
1.2
Modeling
5
Applications of Collection System Models .......................................... 5
Types of Collection System Modeling .................................................. 7
1.3
1.4
16
2.1
Fluid Properties
24
Density and Specific Weight ................................................................ 24
Viscosity .................................................................................................. 24
Fluid Compressibility............................................................................ 27
Vapor Pressure ....................................................................................... 27
2.2
2.3
Fundamental Laws
32
Conservation of Mass ............................................................................ 32
Conservation of Energy ........................................................................ 33
Conservation of Momentum ................................................................ 36
2.4
2.5
2.6
Hydraulic Elements
44
Open-Top Cross Sections ...................................................................... 44
Closed-Top Cross Sections.................................................................... 46
Noncircular Cross Sections................................................................... 49
2.7
Mannings n Variation
49
Calculating n with the Darcy-Weisbach Equation ............................ 50
Variation of n with Depth ..................................................................... 52
Recommended Values of Mannings n................................................ 53
2.8
2.9
2.10
2.11
3.1
93
3.2
Types of Routing
94
3.3
Hydrodynamic Equations
95
Saint-Venant Equations......................................................................... 95
Approximation to Hydrodynamic Equations ................................... 96
Diffusion Analogy ................................................................................. 97
Kinematic Wave ..................................................................................... 97
Muskingum Routing ............................................................................. 98
Muskingum-Cunge Routing ................................................................ 98
Convex Routing ................................................................................... 100
Weighted Translational Routing........................................................ 100
Level Pool Routing .............................................................................. 100
Summary of Methods.......................................................................... 101
3.4
4.1
Friction Losses
113
Darcy-Weisbach Equation .................................................................. 116
Colebrook-White Equation and the Moody Diagram.................... 117
Hazen-Williams Equation .................................................................. 118
Swamee-Jain Equation ........................................................................ 120
Manning Equation ............................................................................... 120
Pipe Roughness Changes ................................................................... 121
Comparison of Friction Loss Methods ............................................. 121
4.2
Minor Losses
122
Minor Loss Valve Coefficients ........................................................... 123
4.3
5.1
137
5.2
6.1
6.2
6.3
Peaking Factors
187
Peaking Factor Charts and Equations............................................... 188
Minimum Flows................................................................................... 190
Selection of Flow Generation Rate and Peaking Factor ................. 191
6.4
Time-Varying Flows
193
Diurnal Curves ..................................................................................... 193
Developing Systemwide Diurnal Curves......................................... 195
Defining Usage Patterns Within a Model......................................... 196
7.1
7.2
7.3
Rainfall
217
Rainfall Data ......................................................................................... 217
Selecting Model Simulation Events................................................... 218
Calibration Events ............................................................................... 219
Design Storms ...................................................................................... 219
Continuous Records ............................................................................ 228
7.4
Modeling Runoff
229
Rainfall Abstractions ........................................................................... 230
Horton Equation .................................................................................. 233
Green-Ampt Equation......................................................................... 233
Rational Method .................................................................................. 234
NRCS (SCS) Method............................................................................ 236
7.5
7.6
7.7
Snowmelt
262
Runoff Potential ................................................................................... 262
Snowmelt Models ................................................................................ 263
8.1
8.2
Flow Measurement
275
Hydraulic Control Sections in Open Channels ............................... 275
In-Pipe Methods................................................................................... 280
Manual Methods.................................................................................. 281
8.3
Instrumentation
283
Depth ..................................................................................................... 284
Velocity Meters..................................................................................... 287
8.4
Precipitation Measurement
292
Precipitation Data Acquisition........................................................... 293
Measurement of Rainfall..................................................................... 293
Gauge Operation Considerations ...................................................... 294
Radar Imagery...................................................................................... 295
9.1
9.2
9.3
9.4
9.5
Understanding Overflows
324
Estimating Combined Sewer Overflow ............................................ 325
Estimating SSOs ................................................................................... 326
Detecting Overflows with Scattergraphs ......................................... 326
305
10.1
Materials
334
Pipes....................................................................................................... 334
Manholes ............................................................................................... 335
Other Appurtenances .......................................................................... 336
10.2
Initial Planning
337
Decision to Provide Sewer Service to an Area................................. 337
Types of Conveyance........................................................................... 338
Separate versus Combined Systems.................................................. 338
10.3
10.4
10.5
10.6
10.7
Hydraulic Design
352
Pipe Sizing ............................................................................................ 354
Manholes............................................................................................... 355
Computer Modeling for System Design........................................... 356
Steady Flow versus Extended-Period Simulation
(EPS) Analysis ................................................................................ 356
Design Maximum Flow Rates with Pumping ................................. 358
10.8
Special Installations
358
Sewers in Steep Terrain....................................................................... 358
Sewers Along Streams......................................................................... 359
Elevated Crossings .............................................................................. 359
Inverted Siphons (Depressed Sewers) .............................................. 360
10.9
361
11.1
11.2
System Characterization
376
Review Existing Records .................................................................... 376
Update System Inventory................................................................... 378
Collection System Condition Investigation ..................................... 379
Inspection of the Condition of Controls and
Ancillary Structures....................................................................... 382
11.3
Hydraulic Investigations
384
Field Data Collection........................................................................... 385
Data Analysis ....................................................................................... 386
Application of Hydraulic Modeling ................................................. 390
Assess Hydraulic Performance.......................................................... 394
11.4
12.1
12.2
12.3
12.4
12.5
Efficiency Considerations
448
Constant-Speed Pumping................................................................... 448
Variable-Speed Pumping .................................................................... 451
Automated Energy Calculations ....................................................... 455
12.6
455
12.7
Hydraulic Transients
457
13.1
420
13.2
Estimating Flows
472
Empirical Approaches......................................................................... 473
Poisson Distribution to Estimate Loads ........................................... 475
13.3
13.4
478
14.1
GIS Fundamentals
490
Data Management ............................................................................... 491
Geographic Data Representations..................................................... 494
14.2
14.3
Model Construction
505
Model Sustainability and Maintenance............................................ 506
Communication Between the GIS and Modeling Staff .................. 507
Network Components......................................................................... 508
Wastewater Loads................................................................................ 510
Building the Model.............................................................................. 515
Pitfalls in Constructing Models from GIS ........................................ 517
Loading Model Results to GIS ........................................................... 520
14.4
15.1
15.2
15.3
551