Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The mutual funds are the trusts which collect the savings by many investors who are having a
common financial goal. The money which is collected is invested in the capital instruments like
debentures, shares and other securities.
The mutual fund helps the investors to pool their money into diversified selection of securities which
is managed by professionals. The mutual fund offers a selection of innovative products like fixed
maturity plans, sector funds and many more.
The main objective of investor is to minimize the risk and maximise the return. The market and the
credit risk can be reduced through diversification. The mutual funds are the smartest ways for the
people to invest their money. The people prefer Bank as the first priority to invest and Mutual fund
as second priority.
The study is conducted on the performance evaluation of equity funds at Anand Rathi financial
services Ltd. This project helps to know about the concept of mutual fund and how to evaluate the
performance of equity funds. The Statistical tools used to evaluate is mean, standard deviation and
the Performance measures used for the study are Sharpes ratio, Treynors ratio and Jensen ratio and
also it helps to know about which equity fund is doing better. The main objective of the study is to
find out the return and risk of equity funds, to compare the performance of equity funds with BSE
Sensex and see if it is outperforming the market and to calculate Sharpe, Jensen and Treynors ratio
to the equity funds and rank them.
The major finding is the selected equity funds for the study are performing well, all selected equity
funds returns are more than the market return so the selected equity funds for the study is
outperforming the market. According to Sharpes, Treynors and Jensens ratio index funds are not
performing well and UTI-MNC fund (UGS10000) is performing well.
CHAPTER- 1
1.1 INTRODUCTION ABOUT THE INTERNSHIP:
Internship is an integral part of students academic curriculum. The period of internship is 10
weeks helps to bridge the gap between knowledge and its application. It helps the students to
gain insights and exposure to the industry. It helps to know about the functioning of the
company and work environment. It enables student to understand the problem of the
company and suggest ways to overcome the problems.
SAMPLING POPULATION
The equity funds of India.
SAMPLE SIZE:
Six types of equity funds are selected. In each type, two schemes are considered for study.
The selected equity fund schemes are launched on or before 01-01-2011 are taken into
consideration. The risk free rate of investment is taken as 7.27 which is the interest rate on
the 5 year government securities.
RESEACH DESIGN:
Descriptive research
It is the study of existing facts to come to a conclusion. In this study tried to analyze the past
performance of the equity funds. The study is done on different types of equity funds to know
if it outperforms the market or not.
HYPOTHESIS:
H1: The equity mutual funds are outperforming the market.
investment in HDFC balanced, equity and gilt mutual funds are better than the SBI
funds over the last three years.
2. Prof. Mahesh K Patel and Prof. Kalpesh Prajapathi (2012) did a study on
performance evaluation of mutual fund schemes of India. In this study they did risk
and return analysis and calculated Famas measure, Jensens ration, Sharpes ratio and
Treynors ratio. They have taken daily closing NAVs to calculate all the Ratio and
the period of coverage is from January 1st 2007 to December 31st 2011. The major
finding by this study is the mutual funds have given good returns during 2007 to
2011.
3. Sukhwinder Kaur Dhanda and Dr. G. S. Batra (2012) they did a study on
performance evaluation of selected open ended schemes in term of risk and return.
They used standard deviation, Beta, Sharpe ratio and Treynor ratio. They used BSE30 as a benchmark to study the performance of mutual funds. The period of coverage
is 1st April 2009 to 31st march 2011. The major findings is only three schemes are
performed better than benchmark.
4. Panwar and Madhu mathi (2006) they did a study on performance and characteristics
of mutual funds. They used sample of public sector sponsored fund and private sector
sponsored mutual fund of different net assets. They statistical tool used for this study
are standard deviation, variance and average co efficient of variation to investigate the
differences in characteristics of assets. The major finding is the public sector
sponsored funds and private sector sponsored fund is performing same in terms of
returns but not in terms of variance, standard deviation and co efficient of variation.
Daily NAV would have given more precise result, monthly NAV is taken for
study.
Only 5 years data is taken for the study the whole data would have given clear
picture.
4
Only three measures are taken to evaluate the equity funds namely Treynors,
Jensens and Sharpes ratio.
CHAPTER - 2
INDUSTRY AND COMPANY PROFILE
2.1 INDUSTRY PROFILE
2.1.1 INTRODUCTION
The stock is nothing but the share of the company which is held by group or an individual. It
represents outstanding asset of the company which is payable to shareholders after giving of
secured and unsecured debt.
Stock markets: It is a market where selling and buying of listed and unlisted securities takes
place. It facilitates pubic to trade in securities.
The market is divided into two:
1. Primary market
2. Secondary market
Primary market is the place or a market where the first time or the new issue of the shares
are offered to public. It is also called as new issue market.
Secondary market is a place or a market where the securities which are issued in the
primary market are traded.
2.1.2 Stock Exchanges: Stock Exchanges are well planned market place. It is a mutual
organization or corporation where the members of the organization get together to buy or sell
securities. The members act as agents for their customers and also as principals for their own
accounts. A stock exchange gives facilities like issue and deliverance of securities and other
financial instruments. It also facilitates the payment of dividends and incomes. The stock
exchanges are a market for old securities, where already issued shares are bought and sold.
by securities and exchange board of India. The separate power has given to stock exchanges
on behalf of government control for the development and regulation of the market.
NSE holds 12th place in largest stock exchanges as of 23 January 2015. It has the market
capitalization US$ 65 trillion. The most used index by investors around the world as a
barometer of the Indian capital markets is 50 stock index.
Providing a ready market to investors: it helps public to trade securities which are
already issued by providing ready market to investors, speculators and industrial
enterprises.
Safeguarding the activities of investors: It makes fair judgment and directors will
disclose all material facts to their respective share holders so it helps in safeguarding
activities for investors.
Operating a compensation fund: when the investor suffers loss due to speculating
dealing in the stock exchange it gives compensation to investors and also operate it.
Creating the discipline: The rules of the stock exchanges are very strict which are
designed to protect its members and general public so this helps in creating discipline
among its members.
Checking of equilibrium: The securities are checked before it is admitted for the
listing and checked.
Promotion of capital formation: It helps the public to save the money and
investment in the government securities, by this government will get money to do
projects of social value and national importance.
Deals in second hand securities: The securities which are already issued in the
primary market are traded in the stock exchange.
Regulates trade in securities: It does not trade any securities in its account. It
ensures that the trading is fair and also it provides the infrastructure which is
necessary and facilitates to trade in securities for its members.
Transactions are done only by members: The outsiders or direct investors are
not allowed to trade in the stock exchange only the members of stock exchange
can trade in stock exchange.
Working as per rules: The stock exchange follows the guidelines given by SEBI.
Specific location:
Money market is further divided into organized money market and unorganized
money market. The unorganized money market considers players like money lenders,
chits funds etc and organized sector considers commercial banks.
2. Capital market:
National securities depository limited (NSDL), United stock exchange(USE), ARN holder
and Central depository services limited (CDSL).
VISION: To become a leader in innovation and to become the first choice for
clients and employees
11
Preferred - These are the type of customers to whom Anand Rathi offers customised
financial planning solutions through detail client profiling. Here investments are
strategically planned to meet financial goals and objectives of the customer.
WEALTH MANAGEMENT:
Anand Rathi has a good wealth management modes and it gives constant returns and
protects wealth by employing suitable safety nets and estate planning solutions.
Anand Rathi is ranked as no 1 private bank in both the years 2009 and 2010, by their
clients in an international private banking poll conducted by Asia money magazine.
Clients voted Anand rathi as the best domestic private bank in India for 5 consecutive
years from 2009 to 2013. This shows the faith and trust of clients on Anand Rathi.
INVESTMENT BANKING:
Anand Rathi investment banking has grown into a leading partner for mid cap growth
companies. It is a leading investment focused on the middle market in India. The
firms core principle is integrity and dedication to the clients success. It offers clients
high quality products and unbiased advice. It has group of experts and experienced
professionals recruited from global financial institutions.
INSTITUTIONAL EQUITY:
Anand Rathi is the Indias leading broker in institutional equity which provides
superior corporate access, inclusive and broad research coverage, market lending
trading in mid and small cap market companies. It became the Go-To house by for
small and mid market by organising industry leading investors conferences and
meets, providing high quality research reports and executing transactions.
Kerala
Assam
Madhya Pradesh
12
Bihar
Maharashtra
Chhattisgarh
Orissa
Delhi
Punjab
Goa
Rajasthan
Gujarat
Tamil Nadu
Haryana
Uttar Pradesh
Uttaranchal
Jharkhand
West Bengal
Karnataka
REGIONAL:
Bengaluru
Banahatti
Bailhongal
Bellary
Belgaum
Bijapur
Davangere
Dandeli
Dharwad
Gadag
Gulbarga
Hospet
Hubli
Harihar
Kolar
Kundapur
Manglore
Mysore
Nipani
Raichur
Ranebennur
Shivmoga
Sirsi
Tumkur
Udupi
Yadgiri
- Anand Rathi
- Pradeep gupta
Managing director
- Amith rathi
Executive director
- Prithi gupta
Director
- Supriya rathi
Independent directors
13
2.2.7 COMPETITORS:
The main competitors are
2.2.8 ACHIEVEMENTS/AWARDS
2015: The best wealth manager of India by capital finance international.
2014: winner of best domestic private bank and best private bank of India by Asia money
poll of polls.
14
2013: It is recognised as one of the top 10 performers in equity segment by BSE and also got
award of best private bank in India in Asia money private banking polls.
2012: In ET Star mine awards the Anand rathi selected as 1st in stock picker, 1st in overall
stock picker, and 1st in stock picker- consumer category.
MILE STONES:
In 1994 company was started by Mr. Pradeep Gupta and Mr. Anand Rathi
ACQUISITIONS:
By Anzgrindlay
: $1.32bn
: $320 million
15
To establish new branches to serve affluent and aggressive traders through highly
skilled financial advisors.
The customers being served through central call or web solutions.
To render best financial services by upgrading the servicing process.
New initiatives in portfolio management services and commodities trading.
To be a lead manager for many forth coming IPO issues.
To extend the wings of customer care desk.
To increase the client base from existing.
16
Opportunities:
The company can increase the awareness among the clients and increase the business.
The company can come up with new products and services.
There are opportunities to tap the FOREX market.
Opportunities for the expansion and additional capital investment.
In Indian economy the financial sectors are in boom stage, this is the advantage to
broking house.
Threats:
Many new brokers entering the field.
Nowadays the banks are providing mutual funds services along with their regular
services.
Changing of the government policies.
Price war between the competitors.
17
CHAPTER - 3
THEORITICAL BACKROUND OF THE STUDY
3.1 MUTUAL FUND:
A mutual fund is a organization or a trust which accepts the savings by many investors who is
having a common financial goal. The collected money are invested in capital market
instruments like debenture, shares and others securities. The incomes gained from the mutual
funds are shared by all the investors or mutual fund holders. It is best investment for common
man because it gives an opportunity to invest in a variety of securities which is professionally
managed by the organization. The cost of investing in mutual fund is low compared to
directly investing in shares.
Investors
Fund
manager
Returns
Securities
18
Step4: The returns are distributed to mutual fund holders in the proportion of units owned by
the investors.
Trust:
Mutual fund trusts are managed by a trust company or by the board of Trustees. A Trust
Company is a body of individuals or corporate body which manages the mutual funds. The
board of trustees in India manages the majority of the mutual funds. The portfolio of
securities is not directly managed by the trustees. The portfolios are managed by AMC (asset
management companies) as per the SEBI mutual funds regulations.
OTHER
Other than the above some constituents involved in some funds such as depositors and
custodians, banks transfer and distributors.
The custodian helps in safe keeping and safe guarding of securities, the bankers helps in the
financial dealings of the fund. The agents help in redemption and issues of units of mutual
funds.
bank fixed deposit, the investor will get reasonable return with minimum risk but when the
investor selects the capital market the investor may get more return than the bank but it is
more risk than the bank.
The investors prefer to invest in mutual funds because it provide various facilities like
diversification, liquidity, professional management and convenience. The mutual funds
investments are not risk free investments but the money collected in mutual funds are
invested not only in the less riskier fund like debt fund but also invest in the stock market.
The stock markets are the high risk investments but one can expects higher returns.
20
1993. The mutual fund regulations are started in 1993 in which except UTI every fund should
be governed and registered.
The 1993 mutual fund Industry was functioning under the SEBI Mutual Fund Regulations. In
this stage the mutual funds are increased many foreign mutual funds was set up and also lot
of mergers and acquisitions were happened in 1993, At the end of 2003 the 33 mutual funds
has the total assets of Rs 1,21,805 cores.
The first one is specified undertaking of unit trust of India. it is functioning by the
rules and regulations set by government of India. It has the assets under management
of Rs 29,835 crores at the end of 2003.
The Second one is UTI mutual funds limited. It is sponsored by SBI, PNB, BOB and
LIC and it is registered with SEBI. It functions under the mutual fund regulations. At
the end of 2004 the UTI mutual fund ltd has 29 funds and they manage 421 schemes
which have assets of 153108 cores.
Diversification Mutual funds helps the investors to diversify the money by investing
in a more number of companies of various industries and sectors. The diversification
of investment helps the investor to reduce the risk because all the industry will not fall
at the same time. One can diversify their investment with low cost by investing in
mutual funds.
Return potential: The potential of returns in mutual fund is high because mutual
funds are invested in securities which are performing well.
Liquidity: liquidity means the case to convert the mutual funds into cash, In closed
end schemes the mutual funds can be sold in the stock exchanges at market price in
case of open ended schemes the net asset value of the funds are returned to the
investors.
21
Low Costs: Mutual funds are costs less to invest compared to directly investing in
capital market. The custodial, brokerage and other fees are less when compared to
directly investing in capital market.
Transparency: The mutual fund gives information about how much invested and the
proportion invested. Is also discloses all the matters which are related to the mutual
fund schemes.
Flexibility: The investors can invest in a series of schemes like regular withdrawal
plans, regular investment plans and dividend reinvestment plan so the investor can
switch to another company stocks according to needs and convenience.
Choice of schemes: Mutual Funds provide a variety of schemes. One can invest in
the scheme which satisfies his needs and objectives.
Affordability: The mutual fund helps small investors to invest in high grade stocks
with less investment who finds difficult to invest in high rating stocks.
Well Regulated: all mutual funds are well regulated and are registered with SEBI and
all mutual funds follows the rules and regulations of SEBI. The mutual funds follow
strict regulations which are designed to protect interest of investors. The SEBI
monitors the operations of mutual funds.
On the basis:
BY STRUCTURE
Open-ended funds
This type of fund does not have fixed maturity period and the main feature of this fund is
liquidity. It can be subscribed all through the year. The investors trade this type of fund at
NAV (net asset value).
22
Interval funds
These funds have both the feature of close ended and open ended schemes. These
funds can buy and sell in the stock exchange and it is also has an option of redemption
of fund at NAV related price.
BY NATURE
Equity funds: These type of funds invest maximum part of collected money into
equity related instruments or equity holdings. It may show loss because of fluctuation
of share prices, however the fluctuations will not affect in the long term. Historically
equity funds are performed well in the long term so to take good returns one should
invest in equity funds for a longer period time at least for 3 to 5 years.
Equity funds are divided into:
Index funds: It is a type of equity fund in which the portfolios of securities
are constructed to match the market index like S & P index 500. It has low
operating expenses, low portfolio turnover and broad market exposure.
Equity diversified funds: This is the type of equity fund which 100 percent
of the capital is invested in the equity shares of different sectors to reduce the
risk of the fund. The diversification of the fund helps to reduce risk because all
sectors does not affect at a time. It has less chances of huge loss.
Large-cap equity funds: It is a type of equity fund which invests a major
portion of their collected money into the companies which has large market
capitalization. These funds offer sustainable and stability returns over a period
23
Debt fund: In this type of equity fund the whole money which is collected are
invested in the debt instruments. It invests mainly in fixed income instruments like
government of Indian securities, bonds, debentures and money market instruments
such as commercial paper, certificate of deposit and call money. It is a low risk
investment and gives stable income to investors.
It is further divided into:
Gilt Funds: This type of funds invests the collected money in the securities
like government of India debt papers which is issued by government. This
fund does not have risk but it is associated with interest rate risk. This scheme
is the safest schemes among all.
Income funds: These types of funds invest their major collected money into
various debt instruments like corporate debentures, bonds and government
securities.
24
MIPs: these funds invest their maximum corpus in debt instruments and they
invest minimum corpus in equities. The fund gets benefit of both equity and
debt market. These funds rank high on risk return matrix when compared to
other debt schemes.
These funds invest both in equity and debt instruments. The minimum portion
of collected money is invested in equities and maximum in debt instruments.
Short term plans (STP): These funds are invested in the short term papers
like commercial paper and certificate of deposits and a small portion in
corporate debentures. The time period is normally 3 to 6 months.
Liquid funds: these funds also called as money market schemes. These funds
provide liquidity and preservation of capital. These funds invests in the short
term instruments like treasury bills, inter-bank call money market, CPs and
CDs these funds invests for a period of 1 day to 3 months. These funds main
feature is liquidity which means it is easy to convert into easy. These funds
normally invest in money market instruments such as certificate of deposits
and commercial papers. The time period is normally 1 day to 3 months.
Balance fund: these funds are combination of both debt and equity funds as the name
suggests in invests in mix with equities and fixed income securities. The investment in
equity helps in the growth and the investment in the debts helps to get stability of
returns.
BY INVESTMENT OBJECTIVE
Growth schemes: These funds are also named as equity schemes. The major part of
collected money is invested in equities. The main aim is to provide the capital
appreciation to the investors for medium or long term investment.
Income schemes: These schemes are also named as debt schemes. It invests the
collected money into the fixed income securities like debentures and bonds. The main
25
aim is to provide regular and steady income to the investors. The capital appreciation
is limited.
Balanced schemes: These funds invest their collected money in both fixed income
securities as well as shares in the proportion 50:50. The main aim is to provide
income and growth. In this scheme the incomes are earned periodically.
Money market scheme: These funds invest the collected money into short term
instruments or money market instruments like certificate of deposit, treasury bills,
commercial paper and inter-bank call money. The main aim of these funds is to
provide liquidity.
funds" a certification programme has started for the intermediaries by AMFI which is
mandatory for them and the risks to be faced by the investors which were involved in the
scheme on which investor going invest is the main aim of AMFI and also to help the
investors on what he is going to invest and to choose the right fund .even though the investors
are ready to invest but due to lack of picking the right fund they are to be educated regarding
the how to choose fund. It is not only their guilty but also the duty of industry to guide them
in the every step of investment.
If the industry ignores the above matter they have to pay for the aspect associated with the
industry.
Investors are not only important for the industries but also for the mutual funds .It is the right
of every investor to ask the questions regarding the funds as per their risk bearing capacity.
As per the investors need it is most important to educate the investor to pick the schemes
which help them to accomplish their financial objectives.
If the investors are educated well in advance then the risks to be faced after the investment by
the investors can be overcome and can make the investors to invest faithfully on the industry
and the investor education is the only key for mutual fund which helps to run the same
investor for a long period in the same industry .it also results in educating the intermediaries.
REPURCHASE PRICE:
Repurchase price is a price at which the mutual fund schemes are repurchased by the mutual
fund companies. Normally it is purchased in NAV of the scheme.
SALE PRICE:
It is the price in which one can buy the mutual fund. It is also called as offer price. The sales
load also included in sale price.
27
SALES LOAD:
At the time of selling the charge is collected by a scheme called as front end load. If there is
no charge is called as no load scheme.
REDEMPTION PRICE:
It is the price in which the mutual funds are redeemed. The mutual funds are redeemed on
their units on maturity in closed ended schemes.
High Expense Ratios and Sales Charges In mutual fund there is expense ratio which
is higher than 1.20% and it also has advertising fees and sales charges in general.
Cost-at the time of purchase the entry and exit load is high.
Dilution the funds have only small holdings in different companies. The funds get
high returns only from a few investments and it does not make much different on the
overall return.
28
CHAPTER - 4
The important part in calculation of NAV is The valuation of the assets owned by the fund.
Once it is calculated it is easy to determine NAV. The complete method for the calculation
of the net asset value is:
NAV = current assets and other assets + market value of investments+ accrued
income- accrued expenses current liabilities and other liabilities.
4.1.2 RETURN
Returns are the amount of revenue generated by an investment over a period of time.
Total return is calculated by:
R= income + (-) price appreciation or depreciation
29
4.1.4 RISK
Risk is defines as the probability that the actual returns or outcomes of investment different
from the expected outcome or return of investment. It also refers to variability or dispersion.
If return of the assets has no variability or dispersion then it has less risk. To measure the risk
of the portfolio there is various ways the commonly used to measure the risk are :
1. Variance
2. Beta
STANDARD DEVIATION AND VARIANCE
Standard deviation ( ) is a statistical tool to measure the dispersion or the deviation from the
mean. This is used by investors to measure the risk involved in the investments. It is widely
used to determine unsystematic risk.
Formula:
30
) and it is used to
Formula
(X-X)2
2
N-1
Where:
X : return of stock
X : arithmetic mean of the return
BETA:
Beta is measure of Systematic Risk. It measures the sensitivity of the stock. In other words it
is the sensitivity of a security to the market movements. The beta measure is mostly accepted
measure in the world.
Beta of a portfolio can be calculated as
Beta () = COV (ri,rm )/Variance of Market
Where
Rm= return of the market M
Ri= return of the portfolio
(Ri-Ri)(Rm-Rm)
COV(Ri,Rm) =
(N-1)
31
(Rm-Rm)2
2
Variance of market: =
(N-1)
Where:
Ri : return of portfolio A
Ri: average rate of return of portfolio A
Rm: return of market
Rm: Average rate of return of market.
N: number of periods
Rp - Rf
Sharpes ratio (S)=
p
Rp : average rate of return of portfolio A
Rf: Average rate of return on a risk free
investment
32
Rp Rf
T=
p
Rp : average rate of return of portfolio A
Rf: Average rate of return on a risk free investment
p: beta of portfolio A
Jensen Ratio p
= Rp - [Rf + a(Rm-Rf)]
Where:
a : beta of portfolio A
Rm: average rate of return of market.
ICICI
RETURNS NAV
BSE
Date
NAV
RETURNS SENSEX
Jan-11
56.4
Feb-11
54.05
-4.167%
105.26
-3.564%
17823.4
-2.752%
Mar-11
58.13
7.549%
115.89
10.099%
19445.22
9.099%
Apr-11
60.78
4.559%
114.91
-0.846%
19135.96
-1.590%
May-11
60.68
-0.165%
111.75
-2.750%
18503.28
-3.306%
Jun-11
62.52
3.032%
112.5
0.671%
18845.87
1.852%
Jul-11
64.05
2.447%
109.75
-2.444%
18197.2
-3.442%
Aug-11
60.59
-5.402%
99.67
-9.185%
16676.75
-8.355%
Sep-11
61.21
1.023%
98.64
-1.033%
16453.76
-1.337%
Oct-11
61.8
0.964%
104.76
6.204%
17705.01
7.605%
Nov-11
58.52
-5.307%
94.25
-10.032%
16123.46
-8.933%
Dec-11
56.75
-3.025%
89.1
-5.464%
15454.92
-4.146%
Jan-12
60.56
6.714%
101.79
14.242%
17193.55
11.250%
Feb-12
64.57
6.622%
106.94
5.059%
17752.68
3.252%
Mar-12
67.48
4.507%
105.63
-1.225%
17404.2
-1.963%
109.15
34
RETURNS
18327.76
Apr-12
67.98
0.741%
104.29
-1.269%
17318.81
-0.491%
May-12
65.49
-3.663%
97.58
-6.434%
16218.53
-6.353%
Jun-12
66.64
1.756%
104.8
7.399%
17429.98
7.470%
Jul-12
66.03
-0.915%
105.28
0.458%
17236.18
-1.112%
Aug-12
67.59
2.363%
105.11
-0.161%
17429.56
1.122%
Sep-12
70.06
3.654%
114.65
9.076%
18762.74
7.649%
Oct-12
70.43
0.528%
113.99
-0.576%
18505.38
-1.372%
Nov-12
72.42
2.826%
119.46
4.799%
19339.9
4.510%
Dec-12
74.49
2.858%
121.65
1.833%
19426.71
0.449%
Jan-13
72.21
-3.061%
122.35
0.575%
19894.98
2.410%
Feb-13
68.54
-5.082%
114.4
-6.498%
18861.54
-5.194%
Mar-13
68.04
-0.730%
112.27
-1.862%
18835.77
-0.137%
Apr-13
72.62
6.731%
117.6
4.747%
19504.18
3.549%
May-13
76.21
4.944%
118.31
0.604%
19760.3
1.313%
Jun-13
73.03
-4.173%
115.61
-2.282%
19395.81
-1.845%
Jul-13
72.28
-1.027%
112.31
-2.854%
19345.7
-0.258%
Aug-13
69.32
-4.095%
109.22
-2.751%
18619.72
-3.753%
Sep-13
73.46
5.972%
113.99
4.367%
19379.77
4.082%
Oct-13
76.51
4.152%
124.73
9.422%
21164.52
9.209%
Nov-13
77.78
1.660%
124.08
-0.521%
20791.93
-1.760%
Dec-13
82.4
5.940%
129.46
4.336%
21170.68
1.822%
Jan-14
77.3
-6.189%
123.93
-4.272%
20513.85
-3.103%
Feb-14
78.65
1.746%
128.06
3.333%
21120.12
2.955%
35
Mar-14
86.93
10.528%
139.38
8.840%
22386.27
5.995%
Apr-14
86.11
-0.943%
140.34
0.689%
22417.8
0.141%
May-14
95.35
10.730%
156.09
11.223%
24217.34
8.027%
Jun-14
103.94
9.009%
168.49
7.944%
25413.78
4.940%
Jul-14
105.08
1.097%
169.71
0.724%
25894.97
1.893%
Aug-14
112.11
6.690%
176.04
3.730%
26638.11
2.870%
Sep-14
119.39
6.494%
180.55
2.562%
26630.51
-0.029%
Oct-14
122.86
2.906%
187.38
3.783%
27865.83
4.639%
Nov-14
132.41
7.773%
196.48
4.856%
28693.99
2.972%
Dec-14
134.27
1.405%
193.96
-1.283%
27499.42
-4.163%
Jan-15
143.48
6.859%
202.42
4.362%
29182.95
6.122%
Feb-15
148.55
3.534%
202.24
-0.089%
29361.5
0.612%
Mar-15
150.75
1.481%
198.24
-1.978%
27957.49
-4.782%
Apr-15
145.2
-3.682%
197
-0.626%
27011.31
-3.384%
May-15
150.52
3.664%
202.36
2.721%
27828.44
3.025%
Jun-15
150.35
-0.113%
200.72
-0.810%
27780.83
-0.171%
Jul-15
159.21
5.893%
209.52
4.384%
28114.56
1.201%
Aug-15
153.64
-3.499%
202.09
-3.546%
26283.09
-6.514%
Sep-15
151.55
-1.360%
201.46
-0.312%
26154.83
-0.488%
Oct-15
153.81
1.491%
205.25
1.881%
26656.83
1.919%
Nov-15
149.89
-2.549%
203.81
-0.702%
26145.67
-1.918%
Dec-15
151.26
0.914%
199.93
-1.904%
26117.54
-0.108%
36
MNC ICICI
FUND
Prudential
(UGS
10000)
fund
SENSEX
TOTAL RETURNS
105%
68%
41%
1.773%
1.147%
0.698%
SD ( )
4.24%
4.89%
4.44%
Rf
7.27%
7.27%
7.27%
BETA ()
0.689376534 1.044656
4
SD
3
BETA
RETURNS(%)
0
UTI MNC FUND
INTERPRETATION:
The above table 4.2.2 shows both the funds performance is better than the
market. The risk of ICICI prudential multi cap fund is high, but the returns are low
compared to UTI MNC fund so among both the funds UTI MNC is better as it
gives more returns for lower risk.
37
AXIS
RETURNS
NAV
BSE
Date
NAV
RETRNS
Jan-11
45.36
Feb-11
43.52
-4.06%
11.49
-3.12%
17823.4
-2.75%
Mar-11
46.91
7.79%
12.42
8.09%
19445.22
9.10%
Apr-11
47.44
1.13%
12.52
0.81%
19135.96
-1.59%
May-11
46.45
-2.09%
12.47
-0.40%
18503.28
-3.31%
Jun-11
46.98
1.14%
12.87
3.21%
18845.87
1.85%
Jul-11
46.56
-0.89%
12.84
-0.23%
18197.2
-3.44%
Aug-11
43.92
-5.67%
12.12
-5.61%
16676.75
-8.36%
Sep-11
43.42
-1.14%
11.98
-1.16%
16453.76
-1.34%
Oct-11
45.54
4.88%
12.61
5.26%
17705.01
7.60%
Nov-11
42.32
-7.07%
11.63
-7.77%
16123.46
-8.93%
Dec-11
38.69
-8.58%
11.08
-4.73%
15454.92
-4.15%
Jan-12
41.81
8.06%
12.04
8.66%
17193.55
11.25%
Feb-12
42.13
0.77%
12.51
3.90%
17752.68
3.25%
Mar-12
41.86
-0.64%
12.51
0.00%
17404.2
-1.96%
Apr-12
41.6
-0.62%
12.79
2.24%
17318.81
-0.49%
May-12
39.53
-4.98%
12.08
-5.55%
16218.53
-6.35%
Jun-12
41.68
5.44%
12.81
6.04%
17429.98
7.47%
Jul-12
42.16
1.15%
12.83
0.16%
17236.18
-1.11%
Aug-12
42.82
1.57%
13.13
2.34%
17429.56
1.12%
Sep-12
45.14
5.42%
14.25
8.53%
18762.74
7.65%
Oct-12
44.91
-0.51%
14.1
-1.05%
18505.38
-1.37%
Nov-12
47.29
5.30%
14.76
4.68%
19339.9
4.51%
Dec-12
46.06
-2.60%
14.81
0.34%
19426.71
0.45%
Jan-13
46.32
0.56%
14.7
-0.74%
19894.98
2.41%
Feb-13
43.93
-5.16%
14.07
-4.29%
18861.54
-5.19%
Mar-13
43.71
-0.50%
14.15
0.57%
18835.77
-0.14%
11.86
38
SENSEX
RETURNS
18327.76
Apr-13
44.75
2.38%
14.83
4.81%
19504.18
3.55%
May-13
45.59
1.88%
15.35
3.51%
19760.3
1.31%
Jun-13
44.96
-1.38%
14.84
-3.32%
19395.81
-1.84%
Jul-13
44.13
-1.85%
14.66
-1.21%
19345.7
-0.26%
Aug-13
42.5
-3.69%
14.05
-4.16%
18619.72
-3.75%
Sep-13
44.64
5.04%
14.72
4.77%
19379.77
4.08%
Oct-13
47.98
7.48%
16.14
9.65%
21164.52
9.21%
Nov-13
47.25
-1.52%
16.72
3.59%
20791.93
-1.76%
Dec-13
47.19
-0.13%
17.26
3.23%
21170.68
1.82%
Jan-14
45.92
-2.69%
16.78
-2.78%
20513.85
-3.10%
Feb-14
47.29
2.98%
17.78
5.96%
21120.12
2.96%
Mar-14
50.25
6.26%
19.17
7.82%
22386.27
5.99%
Apr-14
50.16
-0.18%
19.28
0.57%
22417.8
0.14%
May-14
55.32
10.29%
21.23
10.11%
24217.34
8.03%
Jun-14
59.66
7.85%
23
8.34%
25413.78
4.94%
Jul-14
60.68
1.71%
23.9
3.91%
25894.97
1.89%
Aug-14
62.85
3.58%
25.15
5.23%
26638.11
2.87%
Sep-14
65.13
3.63%
25.95
3.18%
26630.51
-0.03%
Oct-14
66.5
2.10%
27.09
4.39%
27865.83
4.64%
Nov-14
69.24
4.12%
28.34
4.61%
28693.99
2.97%
Dec-14
67.28
-2.83%
28.69
1.24%
27499.42
-4.16%
Jan-15
72.05
7.09%
30.43
6.06%
29182.95
6.12%
Feb-15
70.52
-2.12%
30.75
1.05%
29361.5
0.61%
Mar-15
70.21
-0.44%
31.06
1.01%
27957.49
-4.78%
Apr-15
66.98
-4.60%
30.01
-3.38%
27011.31
-3.38%
May-15
70.12
4.69%
30.9
2.97%
27828.44
3.03%
Jun-15
68.11
-2.87%
30.69
-0.68%
27780.83
-0.17%
Jul-15
72.19
5.99%
31.45
2.48%
28114.56
1.20%
Aug-15
69.42
-3.84%
30.76
-2.19%
26283.09
-6.51%
Sep-15
69.94
0.75%
30.61
-0.49%
26154.83
-0.49%
Oct-15
70.74
1.14%
30.93
1.05%
26656.83
1.92%
Nov-15
71.26
0.74%
30.11
-2.65%
26145.67
-1.92%
39
Dec-15
72.89
2.29%
30.61
1.66%
26117.54
-0.11%
4.3.2 TABLE SHOWING RISK, RETURN AND BETA OF ELSS EQUITY FUNDS:
TATA
INDIA
AXIS LONG
TAX
TERM
SAVING
EQUITY
BSE
FUND
FUND
SENSEX
TOTAL RETURNS
53%
101%
41%
0.890%
1.703%
0.698%
SD ( )
4.14%
4.15%
4.44%
Rf
7.27%
7.27%
7.27%
BETA ()
0.829833
0.84917
SD
BETA
RETURNS(%)
1.5
1
0.5
0
TATA India tax saving fund
40
INTERPRETATION:
The above table 4.3.2 shows both the funds performance is better than the
market. The risk of Axis long term equity fund is high and returns also high
compared to Tata India tax saving fund. So among both funds Axis long term
equity fund is better as it gives more returns.
KOTAK
LIC
NIFTY
NOMURA
RETURNS
BSE
DATE
NAV
NAV
RETURNS
Jan-11
554.43
Feb-11
537.08
-3.13%
29.43
-3.10%
17823.4
-2.75%
Mar-11
587.3
9.35%
32.2
9.41%
19445.22
9.10%
Apr-11
578.82
-1.44%
31.73
-1.46%
19135.96
-1.59%
May-11
560.52
-3.16%
30.69
-3.28%
18503.28
-3.31%
Jun-11
571.78
2.01%
31.26
1.86%
18845.87
1.85%
Jul-11
555.82
-2.79%
30.39
-2.78%
18197.2
-3.44%
Aug-11
507.75
-8.65%
27.86
-8.33%
16676.75
-8.36%
Sep-11
502.06
-1.12%
27.56
-1.08%
16453.76
-1.34%
Oct-11
541.09
7.77%
29.62
7.47%
17705.01
7.60%
Nov-11
490.78
-9.30%
26.92
-9.12%
16123.46
-8.93%
Dec-11
469.5
-4.34%
25.78
-4.23%
15454.92
-4.15%
Jan-12
528.23
12.51%
28.9
12.10%
17193.55
11.25%
Feb-12
547.01
3.56%
29.89
3.43%
17752.68
3.25%
Mar-12
538.07
-1.63%
29.41
-1.61%
17404.2
-1.96%
Apr-12
532.97
-0.95%
29.12
-0.99%
17318.81
-0.49%
May-12
501.71
-5.87%
27.43
-5.80%
16218.53
-6.35%
30.37
SENSEX
RETURNS
18327.76
41
Jun-12
540.21
7.67%
29.46
7.40%
17429.98
7.47%
Jul-12
536.06
-0.77%
29.22
-0.81%
17236.18
-1.11%
Aug-12
539.73
0.68%
29.4
0.62%
17429.56
1.12%
Sep-12
585.39
8.46%
31.84
8.30%
18762.74
7.65%
Oct-12
576.89
-1.45%
31.36
-1.51%
18505.38
-1.37%
Nov-12
603.8
4.66%
32.78
4.53%
19339.9
4.51%
Dec-12
606.42
0.43%
32.91
0.40%
19426.71
0.45%
Jan-13
619.59
2.17%
33.55
1.94%
19894.98
2.41%
Feb-13
584.51
-5.66%
31.66
-5.63%
18861.54
-5.19%
Mar-13
583.82
-0.12%
31.6
-0.19%
18835.77
-0.14%
Apr-13
608.98
4.31%
32.95
4.27%
19504.18
3.55%
May-13
606.4
-0.42%
33.36
1.24%
19760.3
1.31%
Jun-13
593.2
-2.18%
32.6
-2.28%
19395.81
-1.84%
Jul-13
584.4
-1.48%
32.1
-1.53%
19345.7
-0.26%
Aug-13
557.2
-4.65%
30.58
-4.74%
18619.72
-3.75%
Sep-13
584.58
4.91%
32.01
4.68%
19379.77
4.08%
Oct-13
642.38
9.89%
35.13
9.75%
21164.52
9.21%
Nov-13
629.72
-1.97%
34.4
-2.08%
20791.93
-1.76%
Dec-13
642.79
2.08%
35.06
1.92%
21170.68
1.82%
Jan-14
610.56
-5.01%
33.86
-3.42%
20513.85
-3.10%
Feb-14
629.45
3.09%
34.87
2.98%
21120.12
2.96%
Mar-14
672.43
6.83%
37.19
6.65%
22386.27
5.99%
Apr-14
671.44
-0.15%
37.15
-0.11%
22417.8
0.14%
May-14
725.83
8.10%
40.05
7.81%
24217.34
8.03%
Jun-14
766.73
5.63%
42.32
5.67%
25413.78
4.94%
Jul-14
780.59
1.81%
43.05
1.72%
25894.97
1.89%
Aug-14
804.88
3.11%
44.34
3.00%
26638.11
2.87%
Sep-14
806.03
0.14%
44.36
0.05%
26630.51
-0.03%
Oct-14
842.69
4.55%
46.3
4.37%
27865.83
4.64%
Nov-14
859.78
2.03%
47.7
3.02%
28693.99
2.97%
Dec-14
829.11
-3.57%
45.95
-3.67%
27499.42
-4.16%
Jan-15
881.58
6.33%
48.8
6.20%
29182.95
6.12%
42
Feb-15
885.08
0.40%
48.95
0.31%
29361.5
0.61%
Mar-15
851.48
-3.80%
47.03
-3.92%
27957.49
-4.78%
Apr-15
820.32
-3.66%
45.3
-3.68%
27011.31
-3.38%
May-15
846.23
3.16%
46.68
3.05%
27828.44
3.03%
Jun-15
843.05
-0.38%
46.53
-0.32%
27780.83
-0.17%
Jul-15
861.94
2.24%
47.51
2.11%
28114.56
1.20%
Aug-15
805.75
-6.52%
44.38
-6.59%
26283.09
-6.51%
Sep-15
804.14
-0.20%
44.22
-0.36%
26154.83
-0.49%
Oct-15
816.96
1.59%
44.85
1.42%
26656.83
1.92%
Nov-15
803.92
-1.60%
44.08
-1.72%
26145.67
-1.92%
Dec-15
804.98
0.13%
44.07
-0.02%
26117.54
-0.11%
4.4.2 TABLE SHOWING RISK, RETURN AND BETA OF INDEX EQUITY FUNDS:
LIC NOMURA MF
KOTAK NIFTY INDEX FUND-
BSE
ETF
NIFTY
SENSEX
TOTAL RETURNS
43.66%
43.33%
41.20%
0.74%
0.734%
0.698%
SD ( )
4.67%
4.57%
4.444%
Rf
7.27%
7.27%
7.27%
BETA ()
1.044151
1.024343
43
3.5
3
SD
2.5
BETA
RETURN(%)
1.5
1
0.5
0
KOTAK NIFTY ETF
INTERPRETATION:
The above table 4.4.2 shows both the funds performance is better than the
market. The risk of Kotak nifty ETF fund is high and the return is also slightly
high compared to LIC nomura index fund. So the performance of both the funds is
almost at par.
SBI
RETURNS
BSE
DATE
NAV
NAV
RETURNS
Jan-11
30.62
Feb-11
29.39
-4.02%
13.37
-4.98%
17823.4
-2.75%
Mar-11
31.67
7.76%
14.56
8.90%
19445.22
9.10%
Apr-11
31.32
-1.11%
14.62
0.41%
19135.96
-1.59%
May-11
30.82
-1.60%
14.27
-2.39%
18503.28
-3.31%
Jun-11
31.21
1.27%
14.34
0.49%
18845.87
1.85%
14.07
44
SENSEX
RETURNS
18327.76
Jul-11
30.78
-1.38%
14.15
-1.32%
18197.2
-3.44%
Aug-11
28.59
-7.12%
13.04
-7.84%
16676.75
-8.36%
Sep-11
28.02
-1.99%
12.77
-2.07%
16453.76
-1.34%
Oct-11
29.58
5.57%
13.44
5.25%
17705.01
7.60%
Nov-11
27.19
-8.08%
12.53
-6.77%
16123.46
-8.93%
Dec-11
25.99
-4.41%
11.98
-4.39%
15454.92
-4.15%
Jan-12
28.76
10.66%
13.25
10.60%
17193.55
11.25%
Feb-12
29.8
3.62%
13.82
4.30%
17752.68
3.25%
Mar-12
29.3
-1.68%
13.78
-0.29%
17404.2
-1.96%
Apr-12
28.98
-1.09%
13.79
0.07%
17318.81
-0.49%
May-12
27.17
-6.25%
13.2
-4.28%
16218.53
-6.35%
Jun-12
28.82
6.07%
13.94
5.61%
17429.98
7.47%
Jul-12
28.68
-0.49%
14.16
1.58%
17236.18
-1.11%
Aug-12
28.86
0.63%
14.49
2.33%
17429.56
1.12%
Sep-12
31.14
7.90%
15.46
6.69%
18762.74
7.65%
Oct-12
30.67
-1.51%
15.53
0.45%
18505.38
-1.37%
Nov-12
32.57
6.19%
16.34
5.22%
19339.9
4.51%
Dec-12
33.14
1.75%
16.56
1.35%
19426.71
0.45%
Jan-13
33.26
0.36%
16.87
1.87%
19894.98
2.41%
Feb-13
30.88
-7.16%
16.16
-4.21%
18861.54
-5.19%
Mar-13
30.3
-1.88%
16.14
-0.12%
18835.77
-0.14%
Apr-13
31.46
3.83%
16.72
3.59%
19504.18
3.55%
May-13
31.68
0.70%
16.78
0.36%
19760.3
1.31%
Jun-13
31.06
-1.96%
16.22
-3.34%
19395.81
-1.84%
Jul-13
29.83
-3.96%
15.81
-2.53%
19345.7
-0.26%
Aug-13
28.09
-5.83%
15.02
-5.00%
18619.72
-3.75%
Sep-13
29.93
6.55%
15.95
6.19%
19379.77
4.08%
Oct-13
33.07
10.49%
17.48
9.59%
21164.52
9.21%
Nov-13
33.1
0.09%
17.31
-0.97%
20791.93
-1.76%
Dec-13
33.85
2.27%
17.81
2.89%
21170.68
1.82%
Jan-14
32.48
-4.05%
17.54
-1.52%
20513.85
-3.10%
Feb-14
33.59
3.42%
18.11
3.25%
21120.12
2.96%
45
Mar-14
36.72
9.32%
19.13
5.63%
22386.27
5.99%
Apr-14
37.01
0.79%
19.18
0.26%
22417.8
0.14%
May-14
40.73
10.05%
20.92
9.07%
24217.34
8.03%
Jun-14
43.47
6.73%
22.5
7.55%
25413.78
4.94%
Jul-14
44.33
1.98%
22.99
2.18%
25894.97
1.89%
Aug-14
47.22
6.52%
24
4.39%
26638.11
2.87%
Sep-14
48.22
2.12%
24.67
2.79%
26630.51
-0.03%
Oct-14
51.3
6.39%
25.32
2.63%
27865.83
4.64%
Nov-14
53.98
5.22%
26.54
4.82%
28693.99
2.97%
Dec-14
53.67
-0.57%
26.33
-0.79%
27499.42
-4.16%
Jan-15
57.62
7.36%
27.98
6.27%
29182.95
6.12%
Feb-15
57.98
0.62%
28.36
1.36%
29361.5
0.61%
Mar-15
57.88
-0.17%
28.37
0.04%
27957.49
-4.78%
Apr-15
55.67
-3.82%
27.55
-2.89%
27011.31
-3.38%
May-15
57.95
4.10%
28.29
2.69%
27828.44
3.03%
Jun-15
57.2
-1.29%
28.43
0.49%
27780.83
-0.17%
Jul-15
58.97
3.09%
29.33
3.17%
28114.56
1.20%
Aug-15
55.38
-6.09%
27.8
-5.22%
26283.09
-6.51%
Sep-15
55.34
-0.07%
27.76
-0.14%
26154.83
-0.49%
Oct-15
55.93
1.07%
28.25
1.77%
26656.83
1.92%
Nov-15
55.74
-0.34%
28.23
-0.07%
26145.67
-1.92%
Dec-15
54.91
-1.49%
28.44
0.74%
26117.54
-0.11%
46
SBI
INDIA
BLUE
OPPORTUNITIES CHIP
BSE
Column1
FUND
FUND
SENSEX
TOTAL RETURNS
65%
76%
41%
1.10%
1.28%
0.70%
SD ( )
4.73%
4.15%
4.44%
Rf
7.27%
7.27%
7.27%
BETA ()
0.999828569
0.880277
2.5
BETA
RETURNS(%)
1.5
1
0.5
0
FRANKLIN INDIA OPPORTUNITIES
FUND
INTERPRETATION:
The above table 4.5.2 shows both the funds performance is better than the
market. The risk of Franklin India opportunities fund is high but the returns are
low compared to SBI blue chip fund. So among both the funds SBI blue chip fund
is better as it gives more returns for lower risk.
47
ICICI(TECH)
RETURNS
NAV
BSE
DATE
NAV
RETURNS
Jan-11
17.47
Feb-11
17.06
-2.35%
18.11
-5.28%
17823.4
-2.75%
Mar-11
19.16
12.31%
19.04
5.14%
19445.22
9.10%
Apr-11
18.79
-1.93%
18.28
-3.99%
19135.96
-1.59%
May-11
18.2
-3.14%
17.99
-1.59%
18503.28
-3.31%
Jun-11
18.43
1.26%
18.5
2.83%
18845.87
1.85%
Jul-11
18.24
-1.03%
17.53
-5.24%
18197.2
-3.44%
Aug-11
15.78
-13.49%
15
-14.43%
16676.75
-8.36%
Sep-11
15.7
-0.51%
15.53
3.53%
16453.76
-1.34%
Oct-11
16.51
5.16%
17.08
9.98%
17705.01
7.60%
Nov-11
14.4
-12.78%
16.33
-4.39%
16123.46
-8.93%
Dec-11
13.24
-8.06%
16.53
1.22%
15454.92
-4.15%
Jan-12
16.3
23.11%
17.07
3.27%
17193.55
11.25%
Feb-12
17.13
5.09%
18.62
9.08%
17752.68
3.25%
Mar-12
17.14
0.06%
18.56
-0.32%
17404.2
-1.96%
Apr-12
17.29
0.88%
18.36
-1.08%
17318.81
-0.49%
May-12
16.12
-6.77%
18.33
-0.16%
16218.53
-6.35%
Jun-12
17.59
9.12%
18.88
3.00%
17429.98
7.47%
Jul-12
18.03
2.50%
17.58
-6.89%
17236.18
-1.11%
Aug-12
17.78
-1.39%
18.65
6.09%
17429.56
1.12%
Sep-12
20.01
12.54%
19.58
4.99%
18762.74
7.65%
Oct-12
20.32
1.55%
18.88
-3.58%
18505.38
-1.37%
Nov-12
21.95
8.02%
19.53
3.44%
19339.9
4.51%
Dec-12
22.8
3.87%
19.36
-0.87%
19426.71
0.45%
Jan-13
22.91
0.48%
21.01
8.52%
19894.98
2.41%
Feb-13
20.93
-8.64%
21.38
1.76%
18861.54
-5.19%
Mar-13
20.6
-1.58%
21.33
-0.23%
18835.77
-0.14%
19.12
SENSEX
RETURNS
18327.76
48
Apr-13
22.1
7.28%
19.34
-9.33%
19504.18
3.55%
May-13
22.18
0.36%
19.66
1.65%
19760.3
1.31%
Jun-13
21
-5.32%
20.19
2.70%
19395.81
-1.84%
Jul-13
18.72
-10.86%
22.54
11.64%
19345.7
-0.26%
Aug-13
17.08
-8.76%
24.11
6.97%
18619.72
-3.75%
Sep-13
18.37
7.55%
25.06
3.94%
19379.77
4.08%
Oct-13
21.08
14.75%
27.98
11.65%
21164.52
9.21%
Nov-13
21.33
1.19%
28.89
3.25%
20791.93
-1.76%
Dec-13
22.2
4.08%
31.47
8.93%
21170.68
1.82%
Jan-14
19.82
-10.72%
32.06
1.87%
20513.85
-3.10%
Feb-14
20.49
3.38%
33.87
5.65%
21120.12
2.96%
Mar-14
23.97
16.98%
30.46
-10.07%
22386.27
5.99%
Apr-14
24.96
4.13%
30.34
-0.39%
22417.8
0.14%
May-14
28.9
15.79%
30.25
-0.30%
24217.34
8.03%
Jun-14
30.8
6.57%
33.31
10.12%
25413.78
4.94%
Jul-14
30.33
-1.53%
34.94
4.89%
25894.97
1.89%
Aug-14
31.2
2.87%
36.86
5.50%
26638.11
2.87%
Sep-14
31.43
0.74%
38.48
4.40%
26630.51
-0.03%
Oct-14
33.6
6.90%
38.75
0.70%
27865.83
4.64%
Nov-14
36.21
7.77%
41.18
6.27%
28693.99
2.97%
Dec-14
37.51
3.59%
39.76
-3.45%
27499.42
-4.16%
Jan-15
39.24
4.61%
41.74
4.98%
29182.95
6.12%
Feb-15
39.2
-0.10%
43.31
3.76%
29361.5
0.61%
Mar-15
36.45
-7.02%
40.51
-6.47%
27957.49
-4.78%
Apr-15
36.1
-0.96%
37.78
-6.74%
27011.31
-3.38%
May-15
37.54
3.99%
40.35
6.80%
27828.44
3.03%
Jun-15
37.09
-1.20%
38.57
-4.41%
27780.83
-0.17%
Jul-15
39
5.15%
41.57
7.78%
28114.56
1.20%
Aug-15
36.09
-7.46%
41.97
0.96%
26283.09
-6.51%
Sep-15
36.4
0.86%
42.83
2.05%
26154.83
-0.49%
Oct-15
35.55
-2.34%
42.32
-1.19%
26656.83
1.92%
Nov-15
35.85
0.84%
41.33
-2.34%
26145.67
-1.92%
49
Dec-15
34.8
-2.93%
41.33
0.00%
26117.54
-0.11%
4.6.2 TABLE SHOWING RISK, RETURN AND BETA OF SECTOR EQUITY FUNDS
ICICI
prudential
ICICI
banking
and prudential
financial
technology
BSE
services fund
fund
SENSEX
TOTAL RETURNS
85%
87%
41%
1.43%
1.47%
0.70%
SD ( )
7.33%
5.55%
4.44%
Rf
7.57%
7.57%
7.57%
BETA ()
1.44873888
0.590764183
BETA
3
RETURNS(%)
2
1
0
ICICI prudential banking and financial
services fund
50
INTERPRETATION:
The above table 4.6.2 shows both the funds performance is better than the
market. The risk of ICICI prudential banking and financial services fund is high
but the returns are low compared to ICCI prudential technology fund. So among
both the funds ICICI prudential technology fund is better as it gives more returns
for lower risk.
MIRAE
BSE
MORGAN
Date
NAV
RETURNS
NAV
RETURNS
Jan-11
7.36
Feb-11
7.03
-4.48%
9.84
-3.34%
17823.4
-2.75%
Mar-11
7.61
8.25%
10.73
9.04%
19445.22
9.10%
Apr-11
7.83
2.89%
11.04
2.89%
19135.96
-1.59%
May-11
7.8
-0.38%
11.28
2.17%
18503.28
-3.31%
Jun-11
7.79
-0.13%
11.52
2.13%
18845.87
1.85%
Jul-11
8.01
2.82%
11.51
-0.09%
18197.2
-3.44%
Aug-11
7.34
-8.36%
10.77
-6.43%
16676.75
-8.36%
Sep-11
7.17
-2.32%
10.73
-0.37%
16453.76
-1.34%
Oct-11
7.34
2.37%
10.94
1.96%
17705.01
7.60%
Nov-11
6.76
-7.90%
10.31
-5.76%
16123.46
-8.93%
Dec-11
6.28
-7.10%
9.54
-7.47%
15454.92
-4.15%
Jan-12
7.01
11.62%
10.72
12.37%
17193.55
11.25%
Feb-12
7.4
5.56%
11.39
6.25%
17752.68
3.25%
Mar-12
7.57
2.30%
11.56
1.49%
17404.2
-1.96%
Apr-12
7.55
-0.26%
11.43
-1.12%
17318.81
-0.49%
May-12
7.3
-3.31%
10.96
-4.11%
16218.53
-6.35%
Jun-12
7.56
3.56%
11.47
4.65%
17429.98
7.47%
10.18
51
SENSEX
RETURNS
18327.76
Jul-12
7.55
-0.13%
11.46
-0.09%
17236.18
-1.11%
Aug-12
7.73
2.38%
11.81
3.05%
17429.56
1.12%
Sep-12
8.36
8.15%
12.85
8.81%
18762.74
7.65%
Oct-12
8.31
-0.60%
12.92
0.54%
18505.38
-1.37%
Nov-12
8.76
5.42%
13.33
3.17%
19339.9
4.51%
Dec-12
9.09
3.77%
13.9
4.28%
19426.71
0.45%
Jan-13
8.96
-1.43%
13.78
-0.86%
19894.98
2.41%
Feb-13
8.51
-5.02%
12.86
-6.68%
18861.54
-5.19%
Mar-13
8.31
-2.35%
12.68
-1.40%
18835.77
-0.14%
Apr-13
8.54
2.77%
13.17
3.86%
19504.18
3.55%
May-13
8.75
2.46%
13.26
0.68%
19760.3
1.31%
Jun-13
8.44
-3.54%
12.69
-4.30%
19395.81
-1.84%
Jul-13
8.09
-4.15%
12.18
-4.02%
19345.7
-0.26%
Aug-13
7.75
-4.20%
11.75
-3.53%
18619.72
-3.75%
Sep-13
8.27
6.71%
12.4
5.53%
19379.77
4.08%
Oct-13
8.9
7.62%
13.62
9.84%
21164.52
9.21%
Nov-13
9.09
2.13%
14.18
4.11%
20791.93
-1.76%
Dec-13
9.71
6.82%
15.09
6.42%
21170.68
1.82%
Jan-14
9.22
-5.05%
14.92
-1.13%
20513.85
-3.10%
Feb-14
9.67
4.88%
15.96
6.97%
21120.12
2.96%
Mar-14
10.67
10.34%
17.16
7.52%
22386.27
5.99%
Apr-14
10.83
1.50%
17.49
1.92%
22417.8
0.14%
May-14
13.02
20.22%
19.79
13.15%
24217.34
8.03%
Jun-14
14.33
10.06%
21.7
9.65%
25413.78
4.94%
Jul-14
14.07
-1.81%
21.87
0.78%
25894.97
1.89%
Aug-14
14.62
3.91%
23.22
6.17%
26638.11
2.87%
Sep-14
15.35
4.99%
24.87
7.11%
26630.51
-0.03%
Oct-14
16.05
4.56%
25.76
3.58%
27865.83
4.64%
Nov-14
17.36
8.16%
27
4.81%
28693.99
2.97%
Dec-14
17.8
2.53%
27.87
3.22%
27499.42
-4.16%
Jan-15
18.74
5.28%
29.25
4.95%
29182.95
6.12%
Feb-15
19.03
1.55%
29.29
0.14%
29361.5
0.61%
52
Mar-15
19.39
1.89%
29.24
-0.17%
27957.49
-4.78%
Apr-15
18.47
-4.74%
28.6
-2.19%
27011.31
-3.38%
May-15
19.36
4.82%
29.55
3.32%
27828.44
3.03%
Jun-15
19.29
-0.36%
29.9
1.18%
27780.83
-0.17%
Jul-15
20.45
6.01%
31.76
6.22%
28114.56
1.20%
Aug-15
19.58
-4.25%
30.33
-4.50%
26283.09
-6.51%
Sep-15
19.35
-1.17%
30.51
0.59%
26154.83
-0.49%
Oct-15
19.34
-0.05%
30.91
1.31%
26656.83
1.92%
Nov-15
19.39
0.26%
31.35
1.42%
26145.67
-1.92%
Dec-15
19.47
0.41%
31.79
1.40%
26117.54
-0.11%
4.7.2 TABLE SHOWING RISK, RETURN AND BETA OF SMALL AND MID CAP
EQUITY FUNDS
JP MORGAN
MIRAE Asset
fund
BSE SENSEX
TOTAL RETURNS
106%
121%
41%
1.79%
2.05%
0.70%
SD ( )
5.27%
4.66%
4.44%
Rf
7.27%
7.27%
7.27%
BETA ()
0.940673053
0.860871
53
2.5
BETA
RETURNS(%)
1.5
1
0.5
0
JP morgan india mid and small cap
fund
INTERPRETATION:
The above table 4.7.2 shows both the funds performance is better than the
market. The risk of J P Morgan India mid and small cap fund is high but the
returns are low compared to Mirae asset emerging blue chip fund. So among both
the funds Mirae asset emerging blue chip fund is better as it gives more returns for
lower risk.
54
SD
UTI-MNC
BETA RETU
MKT
SHARP TREYN
RNS
RETURN
OR
JENSON
4.24%
.689
1.77%
.698%
.4999
.01692
.01103
1.04
1.14%
.698%
.1104
.0051
.0044
.849
1.70%
.698%
.2644
.0129
.0101
.829
.890%
.698%
.6877
.0034
.0020
1.044
.74%
.698%
.0286
.0012
.0003
1.02
.734%
.698%
.0281
.0012
.0003
.9998
1.10%
.698%
.1051
.0049
.0040
4.15%
.880
1.28%
.698%
.1633
.0076
.0059
emerging 4.66%
.860
2.05%
.698%
.2256
.0168
.0136
.9406
1.79%
.698%
.2256
.0126
.0110
1.44
1.43%
.698%
.1127
.0057
.0069
.590
1.47%
.698%
.1551
.0145
.0080
fund(UGS10000)
cap fund
Axis long term equity 4.15%
fund
Tata India tax saving 4.14%
fund
Kotak nifty ETF
4.67%
India 4.73%
opportunities fund
SBI blue chip fund
Mirae
asset
financial
services
fund
ICICI
prudential 4.44%
technology fund.
INTERPRETATION:
The above table 4.8 shows ICICI prudential banking and financial services fund has the
highest risk while the return is 1.43% and The Tata India tax saving fund has the minimum
risk among all. The Mirae asset emerging blue chip fund is giving highest return and LIC
Nomura index fund-nifty is giving lowest return among all. All selected equity funds are
55
performing better than the benchmark Sensex index and provides more return than the market
return. JP Morgan India mid and small cap fund is highly volatile to the market and ICICI
prudential technology fund is less volatility to market among all.
According to Sharpes the TATA India tax saving fund is performing well, according to
Treynors ratio UTI-MNC fund (UGS 10000) is performing well and according to Jensens
ratio Mirae asset emerging blue chip fund is performing well and the least in all the ratio is
LIC nomura index fund nifty.
SHARPE
TRENOR
JENSON
UTI-MNC fund(UGS10000)
10
10
11
11
11
12
12
12
10
10
and 8
fund
11
ICICI
prudential
banking
56
CHAPTER - 5
5.1 FINDINGS:
ICICI prudential banking and financial services fund has the highest risk and Tata
India tax saving fund has the lowest risk among all.
Mirae asset emerging blue chip fund has the highest return among all and LIC nomura
index fund-nifty has lower return among all.
It is observed that all the equity funds are performing better than the benchmark BSE
Sensex and provides more return than the market return.
According to Sharpes ratio Tata India tax saving fund has performed well and the
LIC nomura index fund-nifty is not performing well among all.
According to Treynors ratio UTI-mnc fund has performed well and the LIC nomura
index fund-nifty is not performing well among all.
According to Jensons alpha mirae asset emerging blue chip fund is performing well
and the LIC nomura index fund-nifty is not performing well among all.
5.2 SUGGESIONS
The investors will opt mutual funds to invest because the mutual funds are less risky
compared to investment in equity directly.
ICICI prudential banking and financial services fund has the highest risk and also it
gives more return so it is best suitable for high risk taker.
Tata India tax saving fund has the low returns and the risk involved also low so it is
best suitable for low risk takers.
Franklin India opportunities fund has the average risk among all so it is best suitable
for the investors who want to take moderate risk.
UTI-MNC fund (UGS10000) is raked well among all three measures, it has very low
risk and the returns are more than market so this fund is good to invest.
57
5.3 CONCLUSION
The investment in mutual fund is a very good opportunity for the small investors and also
for common man. It offers an opportunity to invest in diversified and professionally
managed securities at a very low cost. Mutual fund is a diversified portfolio and investor
get an opportunity to invest in more equity shares which are selected through the asset
management company which will minimise risk and maximise return.
The investors should have knowledge about mutual fund before making any investment
decision. While investing in equity funds the returns as well as risk also should be taken
into account. The risk and return are related to each other. The investor should do careful
evaluation, analysis of market and performance evaluation before investing in the equity
funds.
Over all, all the selected equity funds have performed well during 2011 to 2015 and they
are outperforming the market.
58
BIBILOGRAPHY:
Books:
1. Prasanna Chandra, Investment analysis and portfolio management, 2 nd edition,2005.
2. Prasanna Chandra, Financial management, 8th Edition,2009.
Articles:
1. Ms Dhanalakshmi k (2013), A Comparative analysis on performance of SBI and
HDFC equity, balanced and gilt mutual fund vidyaniketan journal of management
and research vol.1 Issue-2 July December 2013.
2. Prof. Kalpesh p Prajapathi and Prof. Mahesh. K. Patel (2012) Comparative study on
performance evaluation of mutual fund schemes of Indian Companies International
refereed research Journal of Arts, Science & Commerce E-ISSN 2229-4686 ISSN
2231-4172 VOL-III, Issue3(3), July 2012 [47].
3. Sukhwinder Kaur Dhanda, Dr G.S. Batra and Dr. Bimal Anjum (2012).
Performance evaluation of selected open ended mutual funds in India. International
journal of marketing, financial services & management Research Vol.1 No.1, January
2012, ISSN 2277 3622.
4. Sharad Panwar and Dr. R. Madhumathi (2006) Characteristics and performance
evaluation of selected mutual funds in India. Indian institute of India, Madras.
WEBILOGRAPHY
1. https://www.rathi.com/
2. http://www.moneycontrol.com/mutual-funds/best-funds/equity.html
3. http://portal.amfiindia.com/NavHistoryReport_Frm.aspx
4. http://portal.amfiindia.com/NavHistoryReport_Frm.aspx
59
ANNEXTURE
60
61
62