Professional Documents
Culture Documents
How Coffee-Growing
Households Experience
Hunger
Hunger and malnutrition in coffee growing
regions are seasonal crises that typically occur
during the rainy season, the food planting
season, or the early months of the harvest
season (Caswell, 2012). Since most coffee
growing households receive only one annual
paycheck for their crop, they face the difficulty
of distributing that lump sum throughout the
following year to meet all of their household
needs until the next harvest. Additionally, the
income that farmers earn from coffee is often
less than most farmers annual spending needs.
Unfortunately, this is true even among farmers
who receive a price premium for fair trade or
organic certifications (Bacon, 2008; Mndez,
2010; Beauchelt, 2011; Beauchelt, 2012).
Farmers are often pressured to make difficult
household purchasing decisions among critical
basic needs as they are forced to decide to
spend on shelter, food, or the farm investments
required for the next years harvest. They also
face debt, education and healthcare expenses.
In the face of such income scarcity, spending
on food is often compromised, and farmers
consistently face a situation where they can no
longer afford to feed their families regular,
healthy meals. In extreme situations, coffee
producing families run out of savings and are
R E CO MMENDATION # 1:
food consumed in the household (Bacon,
2008). These farmers tend to produce only
staple beans and maize, which is not enough to
feed the household throughout the year. Two
themes are important here. First, technical
assistance and access to sustainable inputs is
important to reduce the risk of crop loss and
increase yields of the substance crops. Second,
when farmers plant more fruit trees (Bacon et
al., forthcoming) or diversify their subsistence
cropping through growing vegetables in addition
to beans and corn, they are likely to be less
sensitive to the thin months and enjoy a more
Organizations that have launched projects
nutritionally balanced diet throughout the year.
targeting alternative livelihood strategies have
(Morris, 2013) In addition to diversifying
focused on helping small-scale farmers diversify crops, farming households can significantly
their farming to grow additional food for
benefit from technical improvements in food
family consumption. In Central America, most storage techniques. Post harvest crop loss is a
coffee farmers already reserve land for subsistence significant challenge and can initially be
addressed through modest investment.
agriculture and produce close to half of the
CONSTRUCT
silos to protect staple grains
from spoiling due to moisture
or rodents
PLANT
fruit trees that provide a
harvest during the lean
months and offer an
alternate source of income
INTRODUCE
new crops to farm plots
and train farmers on how
to prepare them in meals
PROVIDE
farmers with animals which provide
additional sources of protein,
other food products, and
manure to enrich compost
CASE EXAMPLE:
Pueblo a Pueblos
Organic School Garden
Impacts Rural Coffee-Growing
Communities in Guatemala
puebloapueblo.org/programs/
organic-school-gardens
RE CO MMENDATIO N # 2:
Supporting Livelihood
Diversification So That
Coffee Growers Have
Multiple Sources of
Income and Food Other
Than Coffee
CASE EXAMPLE :
Food 4 Farmers Promotes
Beekeeping Among Coffee
Communities in Latin America
http://food4farmers.org/
our-projects/beekeeping-in-latin-america/
12
RE CO MMENDATIO N # 3:
The problem of food insecurity in the coffeelands will not advance if the issue remains
unknown throughout the industry. Awareness
raising efforts have made progress over the last
decade, but the momentum must continue.
Currently, coffee industry actors have primarily
taken initiative through organizing corporate
social responsibility projects and investing in
suppliers, creating more direct and supportive
trade relationships between suppliers and
buyers, and funding NGO-partners to implement
producer-strengthening projects. The more
attention that is paid to these endeavors, the
better for all industry stakeholders.
CASE EXAMPLE :
After the Harvest Film
Draws Industry Attention
to The Thin Months
http://aftertheharvestorg.blogspot.com/
OR
YouTube: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WbLlqle7mBw
R E CO MMENDATION # 4:
CASE EXAMPLE :
The Roya Recovery Project Mobilizes
Multiple Stakeholders to Combat Roya
and Protect Coffee Yields
and Livelihoods
http://www.royarecoveryproject.org/
15
RE CO MMENDATIO N # 5:
Encouraging and
Supporting Research
That Contributes Timely
Empirical Evidence
16
CASE EXAMPLE:
Summary of Studies that have Generated Empirical Data on Food
Insecurity in Coffee Regions
REGION
STUDIED
Nicaragua, Mexico
Guatemala,
El Salvador
# OF
HOUSEHOLDS
STUDIED
STUDY TYPE/
RESEARCH DATE
% EXPERIENCING
FOOD INSECURITY
REFERENCE
469
Stratified survey,
2004-05
63%
Mndez, VE
et al, 2010
177
69%
Bacon, CM
et al, 2008
Mexico, Nicaragua,
Guatemala
179
Nicaragua: 44%,
Western El Salvador
29
Semi-structured
interviews, 2008
97%
Morris, K,
2013
Northern
Nicaragua
256
82%
Bacon, CM
et al;
unpublished
Northern
Nicaragua
87
100%
Pino, M,
unpublished
41
Participatory Action
Research, 2011
82.9%
Gross, L.,
2011
Northern
Nicaragua
Mexico: 31%,
Guatemala: 61%
Fujisaka, S
(CIAT), 2007
(Caswell, 2012 p. 5)
17
C OF F EE RETAIL ERS AN D C AF
OW N ERS
COFFE E RO ASTER S
B ARISTAS
18
RE CO MMENDED R EAD I N G:
Coffee Farmer Welfare in Nicaragua, Mexico, and Guatemala
Author: S. Fujisaka. Publisher/research sponsor: CIAT. Year: 2007.
http://www.slideshare.net/AfterTheHarvestorg/ciat-07-final-project-report-7206907
Effects of Fair Trade and Organic Certifications on Small-scale Coffee Farmer Households in Central America and Mexico
Authors: V.E. Mendez et al. Publisher: Renewable Agriculture and Food Systems (volume 25, issue 3).
Year: 2010.
http://www.uvm.edu/~agroecol/MendezVEEtAl_EffectsFT&OrganicCoffeeHouseholdsMesoamerica_10.pdf
Food Security and Smallholder Coffee Production: Current Issues and Future Directions
Authors: M. Caswell, V.E. Mndez and C. Bacon. Publisher: Agroecology and Rural Livelihoods
Group, University of Vermont. Year: 2012.
http://www.uvm.edu/~agroecol/CaswellEtAl_FoodSecurityCoffeeARLG%20pb1_12.pdf
19
W O R KS CIT E D
After the Harvest (Video) 2011. (Available from YouTube: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WbLlqle7mBw)
Bacon, CM, Mndez, VE, Flores Gomez, MA, Stuart, D, Daz Flores, SR. 2008. Are Sustainable Coffee Certifications Enough to Secure Farmer Livelihoods? The Millennium Development Goals and Nicaraguas Fair Trade
Cooperatives 5(2): 259-274.
Beuchelt, TD, Zeller, M. 2011. Profits and poverty: Certifications troubled link for Nicaraguas organic and
fairtrade coffee producers. Ecological Economics 70(7): 1316-1324.
Beuchelt, TD, Zeller, M. 2012. The role of cooperative business models for the success of smallholder coffee
certification in Nicaragua: A comparison of conventional, organic and Organic-Fairtrade certified cooperatives. Renewable Agriculture and Food Systems 28(3): 195-211.
Campbell, Charlie. East Timorese Sell Their Coffee to Starbucks, Starve at Home. Oct 25 2013. Time Magazine.
http://world.time.com/2013/10/25/the-east-timorese-are-selling-tons-of-great-organic-coffee-but-they-still- starve/.
Caswell, Martha, Mndez, VE, Bacon, CM. 2012. Food Security and Smallholder Coffee Production: Current
Issues and Future Directions. The University of Vermont. Agroecology & Rural Livelihoods Group Policy Brief #
1: 1-12.
Chambers, R. and G.R. Conway. 1991. Sustainable rural livelihoods: Practical concepts for the twenty-first
century. Institute for Development Studies, IDS Discussion Paper 296, December.
Cravioto, Joaqun, Licardie, Elsa R.D. The Effect of Malnutrition on the Individual. (Available at: http://mitpress.mit.edu/sites/default/files/titles/content/9780262520348_sch_0001.pdf) (Accessed on 26 December
2013).
FAO. 2013. The State of Food Security in the World. (Available at: http://www.fao.org/docrep/018/i3458e/i3458e.pdf) (Accessed on 27 December 2013).
Fujisaka, S. 2007. Coffee farmer welfare in Nicaragua, Mexico, and Guatemala. Final Research Report. International
Center for Tropical Agriculture (CIAT) Green Mountain Coffee Roasters (GMCR).
20
W O R KS CIT E D
Grantham-McGregor, S. A review of studies of the effect of severe malnutrition on mental development. The Journal of
Nutrition 1995; 125; 2233S-2238S.
Kanyamurwa, JM, Wamala, S, Baryamutuma, R, Kabwama, E, Loewenson, R. 2013. Differential returns from globalization
to women smallholder coffee and food producers in rural Uganda. African Health Sciences. 13(3): 829-841.
Kremen, C., A. Iles, and C. Bacon. 2012. Diversified farming systems: an agroecological, systems-based alternative to
modern industrial agriculture. Ecology and Society 17(4): 44.
Mndez, VE, Bacon, CM, Olson, M, Petchers, S, Herrador, D, Carranza, C, et al. 2010a. Effects of Fair Trade and organic
certifications on small-scale coffee farmer households in Central America and Mexico. Renewable Agriculture and Food
Systems 25(3): 236-251.
Morris, KS, VE Mendez, & MB Olson. 2013. Los meses flacos: seasonal food insecurity in a Salvadoran organic coffee
cooperative. Journal of Peasant Studies 40(2): 423-446.
Pelletier DL et al. 1994. A methodology for estimating the contribution of malnutrition to child mortality in developing
countries. Journal of Nutrition 124: 2106-2122.
The World Bank. 2006. Repositioning Nutrition as Central to Development: A Strategy for Large Scale Action, Washington DC: The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development/The World Bank.
Whaley, Shannon E., Marian Sigman, Charlotte Neumann, Nimrod Bwibo, Donald Guthrie, Robert E. Weiss, Susan Alber,
and Suzanne P. Murphy. The Impact of Dietary Intervention on the Cognitive Development of Kenyan School Children.
The Journal of Nutrition 2003; 133: 3965S-3971S.