Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Nicholas Hirsch
facsimilesmiles@gmail.com
1
Cyborgs as Discourse: The Intersection of Feminism, Postmodernism
Harrison Ford leans menacingly over a beautiful woman. Her back is to the wall,
her hair loose and wild. She is visibly shaken, perhaps scared. Ford’s expression is
ambiguous, somewhere between attraction and rage. “Say, ‘kiss me’,” he tells her. She
tells him she can’t rely on her memories, and he demands again that she tell him to kiss
her. Still hesitant, she nods; tears stand out in her eyes. He makes her tell him she wants
him twice more before kissing her. In this moment, it is unclear whether he actually
would have respected her wishes if she refused him, or if her reason for saying yes was
reflection of gender politics in the real world. Ford's “romantic” advances are
disturbingly reminiscent of sexual assault. Further complicating the issue is the fact that
Rachel, his love interest, is a replicant, a manufactured organism with memories which
she has only recently discovered are not real.1 Rachel's tragedy is in the question of her
agency, first as a programmed being, then as a woman; in either case, her consent is
This love scene from the 1982 blockbuster film Blade Runner raises a number of
questions about gender and agency. Would Decker (Ford's character) have stopped, if
Rachel said no? As a replicant, a programmed being, would she have been capable of
saying no? If Decker didn't stop, would he be disregarding a woman's right to control her
own body, or simply ignoring a programmed response, or both? If Rachel was never a
1 Ridley Scott, et al, Blade Runner (Burbank, CA: Warner Home Video, 1982 (2007)).
2
human being in the first place, would it be possible for her to give meaningful consent in
the first place? More to the point, as a created being, does the combination of Rachel's
gender and her status as a sexualized object reflect a broader conflation of these
characteristics? In this film, which describes male cyborgs as worker drones, and females
as “your basic pleasure model”, gender is literally a construct. Blade Runner thus uses
This is the focus of cyborg feminism: how does the cyborg, as an imaginative
construction, help us to analyze the role and nature of identity from a postmodern,
feminist perspective? The period in which this film was released was one of intense
cyborg iconography. I will argue that, from the late 1970s to the mid 1980s, feminism,
postmodernism and the conception of the cyborg became inextricably entwined. This
vital cross-section is illustrated in the work of Donna Haraway and Anne Balsamo, two
feminist theorists of that decade who helped to create the framework for “cyborg
feminism”, a unique style of feminist social and literary criticism which has become
What follows will be a historical analysis of the context in which cyborgs entered
begin with an overview of what the term cyborg means, its changing relationship within
science fiction and with feminist critique. Second, I will briefly examine the
3
Baudrillard, Lyotard and Foucault, focusing primarily on the role of technology and
gender in their work. Finally, I will relate the inception of cyborg feminism by Donna
Haraway and Anne Balsamo in the context of postmodern philosophy and some of the
developing schisms within feminism in the late 1970s and early 1980s.
which biological and technological components are fused within a single entity. The term
Clynes and Nathan Kline in a 1960 paper about the possibility of altering the bodies of
This early usage introduced the use of cybernetics (a relatively new field at the
time) for body augmentation, an idea which captured the popular imagination through the
next several decades, leading to the creation in the 1970s of popular television shows like
The Six Million Dollar Man (1973) and its spinoff series The Bionic Woman (1976) – a
series which, according to feminist critic Sharon Sharp, had an ambiguous relationship
with other feminist writers of the period.4 A somewhat more successful coupling between
feminism and cyborgs is evident in The Stepford Wives; though, as A. K. Silver points
out, feminist theorists at the time were not yet ready to accept a meaningful relationship
Anne Balsamo to describe it as “the decade of the cyborg.”6 In the first half of the
2 Donna Jeanne Haraway, The Haraway Reader (New York: Routledge, 2003), 7.
3 Manfred E. Clynes, and Nathan S. Kline, “Cyborgs and Space”, Astronautics (September,
1960).
4 Sharon Sharp, "Fembot Feminism: The Cyborg Body and Feminist Discourse in The Bionic
Woman", Women's Studies. 36, no. 7 (2007), 507-523.
5 A. K. Silver, "The Cyborg Mystique: The Stepford Wives and Second Wave Feminism", The
Arizona Quarterly. 58 (2001), 109-126.
6 Anne Marie Balsamo, Technologies of the Gendered Body: Reading Cyborg Women (Durham:
4
decade, science fiction author William Gibson spearheaded the cyberpunk literary
stories featuring cyborg assassins and hacker cowboys7. These aesthetic qualities were
popularized by the movie Blade Runner, as well as other films like The Terminator,
RoboCop and Weird Science. By the end of the decade, the assimilationist Borg were
terrorizing the crew of the Enterprise in Star Trek: the Next Generation, and Voltron and
references to cyborgs in the 80s alone would be beyond the scope of this paper.
What is relevant is that, during this period, the definition of the cyborg broadened
Runner and The Terminator, for example, cyborgs are artificial intelligences which
imitate human beings with biological skin and eyes. According to Despina Kakoudaki
(writing a feminist critique of cyborg imagery within the last decade), skin was the
defining characteristic of the cyborg, as it indicated the cyborg's unique quest to “pass”
for human, or even to become human8, reflecting a growing paranoia (still present,
against their creators. Kakoudaki argues that this is parallel to what she perceives as a
growing fear of women’s sexuality in the period, so that gender in cyborgs became a “site
5
In cyberpunk fiction, the cyborg was as often as not defined in terms of the
interface between a human mind and a vast communications network. This interface was
Interface”, feminist writer Claudia Springer examines the sensualist aspects of this
theoretical unbound by physical reality. Springer points out that “collapsing the
sexual act in popular culture”.11 Not was technology feared, it was also fetishized,
perhaps for its transgressive potential – a theme discussed by Donna Haraway at length,
as we shall see.
The projection of the cyborg/hacker's human mind into a digital environment also
What is important to note is the existing connection between Gibson's fictional cyborgs
and Baudrillard's postmodern philosophy – a connection made directly in the 1999 movie
The Matrix, in which the character Morpheus describes the “mental projection of your
digital self”, and the stark contrast between the Matrix and the “desert of the real” (a
backdrop against which the cyborg became a tool for social and critical analysis.
6
resists simple definition. Rather than any single cohesive idea, postmodernism is a “set
[and] historical progress ...”13 In this sense, postmodernism is the process of challenging
that which is known or knowable in a fundamental way, and is best understood in the
arguments of postmodernists themselves. In the late 1970s and early 1980s, postmodern
different ways, the construction of knowledge and innateness. As a close look reveals,
the writings of all three had some bearing on the parallel developments of feminism and
In Simulacra and Simulation (1981), Baudrillard argued that, with the advent of
become so advanced and so prescient that they began to replace the reality they were
representing: “The territory no longer precedes the map, nor does it survive it.”14 Reality
ceased to exist in a state of causality, instead rendered into a map, so detailed that it not
only could, but inevitably would, become confused with reality. In fact, Baudrillard
argued, reality was already a simulation, in the sense that human experience already
Vitally, Baudrillard claimed that identity itself was subject to this process of
simulation, touching on the fading role of gender as cloning became possible through
7
“the genetic matrix of identity”15. Given the obsolescence of gender as a defining
characteristic, what then would become of identity and sexuality? The cyborg created the
This argument followed the lead of Lyotard, who argued in The Postmodern
Lyotard's arguments followed the formal logic of Wittgenstein and used computer
context of that language, but the language itself must follow a set of internal rules which
are not innate to the computer16. It is interesting to note that both Baudrillard and Lyotard
and cultural suppositions: the same sort of technology that their contemporary, William
The History of Sexuality that, over the last several centuries, human sexuality had been
relegated to public discourse as a tool of power and control. He wrote about a “great
Foucault wrote that this process occurred first under the guise of religious propriety, then
nationalism, then scientific inquiry. Foucault argued that this rendering of sex into
discourse made it into a hierarchical tool by allowing those in power to define, isolate and
8
Like Baudrillard and Lyotard, Foucault argued that language and communication
had been superimposed over reality, but unlike them he did not place it strictly in the
context of current technology. Instead, this control of language was a long-term (though
explains, “for Foucault, those who define truth possess power.”19 For feminists, those in
power were men, and for postmodern feminists, gender was another truth which had been
feminism which, as will be shown, became vital from the late 1970s on, was exemplified
for Cyborgs”, published in the Socialist Review 1985. In this “Manifesto”, Haraway
1960s and 70s. Haraway argued for the cyborg's usefulness as “a fiction mapping our
social and bodily reality and as an imaginative resource suggesting some very fruitful
couplings.”20
The social reality to which Haraway was referring was the one in which gender
politics were tied into the divided into an array of dualisms of “mind and body, animal
and machine, idealism and materialism in the social practices”21, a feminist reflection of
the power dynamic described by Foucault. Haraway was asserting the transgressive
18 Ibid, 20.
19 Marysia Zalewski, Feminism After Postmodernism: Theorising Through Practice (New York:
Routledge, 2000), 26.
20 Haraway, The Haraway Reader, 8.
21 Ibid, 13.
9
potential of the cyborg both in and out of fictional narratives, in its capacity for
innocence.”22 Because the cyborg was a composite being without strictly defined,
The defining characteristic of the Haraway cyborg was its potential for
ambiguation and the blurring of boundaries which she identified as a tool of militarism
and patriarchal capitalism, of which the cyborg was the “illegitimate offspring”23. It
lacked history, culture, even definition, and could therefore serve as a blank slate for
cultural critique and a perfect expression of the desire to escape Lyotard's postmodern
cyborg was "a condensed image of both imaginative and material reality, the two joined
particularly useful for feminists who sought to avoid the ideological dangers of recourse
to an “authentic” female identity, which is one of the main postmodern feminist criticisms
rarely, if ever, has lived up to this idealized conception even in fiction. Haraway,
however, would later claim in a 1997 interview with Hari Kunzru that the cyborg was
22 Ibid, 9.
23 Haraway, The Haraway Reader, 11.
24 Judith Halberstam, "Automating Gender: Postmodern Feminism in the Age of the Intelligent
Machine", Feminist Studies 17, no. 3 (October 1, 1991): 439.
25 Marysia Zalewski, Feminism After Postmodernism: Theorising Through Practice (New York:
Routledge, 2000).
10
neither theoretical nor imaginary; by the late 1990s, Haraway was convinced that
everyone was already living a cyborg lifestyle in a postmodern reality26. Thus, Haraway
was not engaging in textual analysis of any particular fictional work; rather, the cyborg in
Haraway later explained that the paper was intended at the time to be a “nearly
sober socialist-feminist statement written for the Socialist Review to try to think through
how to do critique, remember war and its offspring, keep ecofeminism and technoscience
joined in the flesh, and generally honor possibilities that escape unkind origins.”27 To
understand these intentions, it is now necessary to explore the state of feminism in the
Socialist feminism, of which Haraway was an adherent, was one of several strains
of feminist theory that developed out of growing discontent with the perceived class and
race disparity in feminist politics at the time. Ecofeminism, which Haraway described in
terms of its worrying technophobia, emerged during the same period as a reaction against
“developing” nations.28 The parallel between these feminist theories highlights a general
shift in the perception of gender at the end of what is generally referred to as “second-
wave feminism”.
26 Hari Kunzru, “You Are Cyborg,” Wired Magazine 5.02 (February 1997)
http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/5.02/ffharaway.html (accessed December 2, 2009)
27 Haraway, The Haraway Reader, 3
28 Colleen Mack-Canty, "Third-Wave Feminism and the Need to Reweave the Nature/Culture
Duality," NWSA Journal 16, no. 3 (October 1, 2004).
11
wave feminism in the late 60s, when many feminists became disenchanted with existing
leftist political factions, which still tended to reinforce gender-typing despite nominal
progressivism.29 The focus of the second-wave (as opposed to the “first” wave) moved
the feminist bar forward from political inclusion (via voting) to social equality: equal pay
in the workplace, eradicating the illusion of the woman as an inferior domestic creature,
etc.
construction of what it meant to be a woman, who counted and who did not. As
mentioned above, socialist feminism came to conflate gender with class construction, and
challenged “mainstream” feminists for playing at politics within a political system which
was already rigged in favor of patriarchal power and dominance. Feminists looking to
Marxist theory saw in class conflict a reflection of the struggle to power of women in the
domestic sphere and otherwise.30 Marxism also served as a stepping stone toward
Haraway wrote the Manifesto; the cyborg represented a step toward postmodernist
29 Imelda Whelehan, Modern Feminist Thought: From the Second Wave to ‘Post-Feminism’
(New York: NY University Press, 1995), 1-5
30 Whelahan, Modern Feminist Thought, 47.
31 Ibid, 47.
32 Ibid, 127.
12
the late 70s and early 80s. Marysia Zalewski argues that, from the postmodern
perspective, the problem with second-wave feminism derived from the assumption that
there was an underlying, unified cultural identity around which a marginalized minority
could gather to support a political agenda; race and economic status were contending
with the notional identity of “woman”, fracturing the political power of each while
Postmodern feminists argued that these constructs may have an adverse effect, in
that the “identity” in question simply caused smaller sub-groups to be excluded in turn.33
In effect, modernist feminists and postmodernist feminists each blamed the other for the
splintering of feminism. Since then, Zalewski argues that postmodernism is one of the
characteristics which has differentiated the “third-wave” feminism of the late 80s and
early 90s from the modernist, “second-wave” feminist movements of the 70s34 just as
second-wave feminists differentiated themselves from the “first wave” of the late
Nineteenth and early Twentieth Centuries by shifting their focus from political inclusion
to social equality, particularly in the workplace. In the 1980s, the move toward
feminism35. This breach was addressed by the next cyborg feminist writer, Anne
Balsamo.
Haraway, addressed the fact that Foucault, in reading sexuality as a construct, failed to
follow through on his own ideas when he stopped short of reading the body itself as a
13
cyborg as a social metaphor for of the female body in the context of Foucault's discursive
space, “the site at which we can witness the struggle between systems of social order”36;
her argument was that the cyborg, like the female body, stood at an intersection between
gender idealism. However, she did agree with the basic idea that “cyborgs offer a
feminist discourse that, by 1987, Balsamo was wary that “the material body [had] all but
Haraway's cyborg metaphor to explore the way gender is constructed and deployed in a
technological society. The cyborg stood in a position at the cross section of feminist
cyborgs in the form of female body builders, public pregnancy, and genetically
engineered mice39.
Cyborg feminism itself is, admittedly, still fairly obscure, and feminist writers
who have addressed the cyborg since Haraway and Balsamo (like Kakoudaki and Silver,
mentioned above) have largely focused on its literary implications. In 1994, Jenny
Wolmark incorporated the work of both Donna Haraway and Anne Balsamo in her study
of feminist science fiction within the context of “the intersections between feminism,
36 Ibid, 39.
37 Balsamo, Technologies of the Gendered Body, 32.
38 Ibid, 12.
39 Balsamo, Technologies of the Gendered Body; Balsamo devoted an entire chapter to each of
these concepts.
14
postmodernism and science fiction”40. Aliens and Others approached the cyborg from the
than seems to have been intended by either Haraway or Balsamo. From that point,
cyborgs in feminist writings took two directions – as a literal vehicle for social critique
(including in Haraway's own work throughout the 1990s and 2000s), or as a metaphor for
serves readily as a figurative, analytical tool with which the relationship between
postmodernism and feminism can be examined. The cyborg is the product of an age, a
constructed, a raw depiction of the underlying assumptions of its creators. This is the
40 Jenny Wolmark, Aliens and Others (University of Iowa Press: Iowa City, 1994), 2.
15
Bibliography
Primary Sources:
Adams, Don. Inspector Gadget. The Original Series. Banyo, Qld.: Magna Pacific 1983
(2006).
Balsamo, Anne Marie. Technologies of the Gendered Body: Reading Cyborg Women.
Durham: Duke University Press, 1996.
Baudrillard, Jean. Simulacra and Simulation. Trans. Sheila Faria Glaser. Ann Arbor:
University of Michigan Press, 1994.
Cameron, James, et al. The Terminator. Santa Monica, CA: MGM DVD, 1984 (2004).
Clynes, Manfred E. and Nathan S. Kline. “Cyborgs and Space.” Astronautics, September,
1960.
De Jarnett, Steve, et al. Cherry 2000. Santa Monica, CA: MGM Home Entertainment,
1987 (2001).
Foucault, Michel. The History of Sexuality. Trans. Robert Hurley. New York: Pantheon
Books, 1978.
Forbes, Bryan, et al. The Stepford Wives: Widescreen Collection. Hollywood, Calif:
Paramount Pictures, 1975 (2004).
Haraway, Donna Jeanne. “A Manifesto for Cyborgs: Science, Technology, and Socialist
Feminism in the 1980s.” San Francisco: Center for Social Research and
Education, 1985. Repreinted in The Haraway Reader New York: Routledge,
2003.
Irving, Richard, et al. The Six Million Dollar Man. United Kingdom: Universal Studios,
1973 (2005).
Johnson, Kenneth, et al. The Bionic Woman. Sydney, N.S.W.: ABC Studios, 1976 (2001).
̧
Lyotard, Jean-Francois. The Postmodern Condition: A Report on Knowledge. Theory and
History of Literature, v. 10. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1984.
16
Roddenberry, Gene, et al. Star Trek, the Next Generation: the Complete Series.
Hollywood: Paramount Home Entertainment, 1987 (2007).
Scott, Ridley, et al. Blade Runner. Burbank, CA: Warner Home Video, 1982 (2007).
Silver, Joel, et al. Weird Science. Universal City, CA: Universal Studios Home
Entertainment, 1985 (2008).
Sterling, Steve, et al. Voltron, Defender of the Universe. Collection One, Blue Lion. S.l.:
Anime Works, 1984 (2006).
Verhoeven, Paul, et al. RoboCop. Los Angeles, CA: Orion Home Video, 1987.
Wachowski, Andy, Larry Wachowski, Joel Silver, et al. The Matrix. Burbank, CA: Warner
Bros. Pictures, 1999 (2001).
Secondary Sources:
Haraway, Donna Jeanne. The Haraway Reader. New York: Routledge, 2003.
17
O'Brien, Jodi. Encyclopedia of Gender and Society. Los Angeles: SAGE, 2009. “cyborg”
Sharp, Sharon. 2007. "Fembot Feminism: The Cyborg Body and Feminist Discourse in
The Bionic Woman". Women's Studies. 36, no. 7: 507-523.
Silver, A. K. 2002. "The Cyborg Mystique: The Stepford Wives and Second Wave
Feminism". The Arizona Quarterly. 58: 109-126.
Slusser, George and Tom Shippey, eds. Fiction 2000; Cyberpunk and the Future of
Narrative. Athens, GA: University of Georgia Press, 1992.
Whelehan, Imelda. Modern Feminist Thought: From the Second Wave to ‘Post-
Feminism’. New York: NY University Press, 1995.
Wolmark, Jenny. Aliens and Others: Science Fiction, Feminism, and Postmodernism.
Iowa City: University of Iowa Press, 1994.
Additional Reading:
Kirkup, Gill. The Gendered Cyborg: A Reader. London: Routledge (Open University),
2000.
Walton, H. 2004. "The Gender of the Cyborg". Theology and Sexuality 10, no. 2: 33-44.
18