Professional Documents
Culture Documents
com
http://www.all-about-forensic-science.com/forensic-science-ebook.html
http://www.all-about-psychology.com/psychology-ebook.html
http://www.all-about-psychology.com/psychology-journal-articles.html
http://www.all-about-forensic-psychology.com/forensic-psychology-ebook.html
I have been reminded by the articles in the Popular Science Monthly, of the neglect of
the teeth as a means of identification, which to me, as a practical dentist, has always
seemed very remarkable.
It is a source of wonder to the dental profession that the signs furnished by the teeth
have been so persistently overlooked in systems of identification, especially by life-
insurance companies. The number of signs furnished by the teeth, both of natural
features and of artificial operations upon them, is so varied and extensive that they
present an amount of valuable data that ought not to be ignored.
A simple system of record of the natural peculiarities of the teeth and of the artificial
operations upon them could be devised which in the hands of a competent person,
who would need to be an expert dentist, of course, would furnish reliable and less
perishable evidence than the other external signs of the body.
Every dentist keeps a record of all the operations he performs for every patient, upon
an individual chart or page in a special diagram, for his own convenience and
protection. By means of these charts, dentists have, in several instances, assisted
materially in the identification of the bodies of persons for whom they have operated,
after catastrophes, notably the charity bazaar fire in Paris. A similar chart could be
incorporated in the examination records of life insurance companies, for instance, on
which the dental peculiarities could be recorded in a manner which could be easily
read by another expert.
Even if some teeth were lost or altered in the course of years, many signs would yet
remain on the surviving teeth, for the original form of a tooth would be the same and
an artificial operation could not be obliterated. Thus the size and width of the arch; the
1
size, shape and color of the teeth; teeth missing or altered; kind of fillings and location;
gold crowns, bridges or artificial plates, etc. All these and other distinct features could
be easily recorded with the subject, even if dead and if only skeleton remained, to
assist materially in identification by another expert.
By way of Suggesting a scheme for the tabulating of the dental peculiarities, the
following plan of classification is proposed, which covers all the general features of the
teeth and their environments and could be recorded by one and read by another
expert dentist. This scheme is merely suggestive and could be improved by practice
and experience.
(b) Width of arch, in centimeters from outside surfaces of first upper molars.
(f) Shape of teeth, whether wide or narrow, long or shore, worn or not, etc.
(g) Color of teeth, white or dark, yellowish, bluish or modification, etc (This factor
would be modified by time and habits, but the expert observer would estimate that.)
(h) Irregularities of the teeth, as to being out of normal place, crowding and
malpositions generally.
2
(l) Diseased teeth, dead teeth, chronic abscess, etc.
Many of these characteristics might be perishable, of course, and of value only for a
limited time, but others are of permanent durability and would last while the teeth
themselves lasted. The perishable data would need to be taken into consideration at a
later examination and a practical dentist would naturally make such allowances. The
absence of some data would not always mean lack of identity, for a reasonable
allowance would need to be made for perishable dental features.
3
(a) Round square. (b) 5.8cm. (c) 2.5cm. (d) Gum reddish pink; health line well marked;
rugae shallow and rather straight. (e) Medium small. (f) Rather wide and short, cusps
low and rounded. (g) Rich cream color shading to yellowish at cervical border. (h)
Upper laterals both everted at mesial border: right lower central crowded inward. (i)
First right upper bicuspid and second lower molar missing; first upper molar broken off
and roots remaining. (j) 1, gold filling; 2, larger amalgam filling; 3, cement filling. (k) 1,
deep decay; 2, shallow decay. (l) Dead tooth and chronic abscess and fistula. (m) 1,
gold teeth crown; 2, porcelain crown. (n) 1, third molar peg-shaped; 2, both lower
bicuspids of tricuspid form; 3, whitish spot on labial face.
The history of life insurance litigation demonstrates the value of imperishable physical
data for the purpose of identification, and these data the teeth furnish. It is more than
probable that much expensive litigation and unfair decisions would have been avoided
if these data had been heretofore utilized. In the celebrated Hillmon case, Which
dragged its slow length for twenty years through the United States courts of the West,
casts of the alleged corpse of Hillmon were placed in evidence which showed that the
denture was perfect and regular, while the teeth of Hillmon himself were said to be
irregular and some were absent. It was a case in which the body was so disfigured by
decomposition that evidence in regard to the teeth was of the utmost importance.
If a chart of Hillmon's own teeth could have been produced which showed some of his
dental peculiarities (missing teeth, irregularities, fillings, etc.) a comparison with the
teeth of the corpse would have been of advantage so that the case would have been
sooner settled and much tedious and expensive litigation avoided.
The data are so accessible and so important, that we feel justified in urging the matter
upon the attention of those who have charge of the classes of which physical records
are required. The dental data should be employed as supplementary to other systems
of signs for identification, and would thus be of value in the records of soldiers and
criminals as well as for insurance companies.
END OF ARTICLE
4
Free & Comprehensive Educational Resources
www.all-about-psychology.com
I will be using Twitter to keep people up-to-date with all the latest
developments on the All About Psychology Website.
http://twitter.com/psych101
5
Interested In Forensic Psychology?
www.all-about-forensic-psychology.com
Very popular website that provides a free & comprehensive guide to the
world of forensic science.
www.all-about-forensic-science.com