!"##$%&' 6"%"# 789"%'
())*++,(-.,/012/2*1)34)5( :;<= *(-)/4)(,42>,
&JKLM NOLOPQRS
TUVU WOXQY ZMQOOM
[\MML]KQ^S_ [` VabVc
m@F" F
n <;o /p2) <q ) /2*1)3 2 ;=<; 2/ *12 D2)5( <;=
<;5(*
<;o
)12*/<;= +I p5p,+*1; D2)*,/2 032I 5r21
;
)12*/2>
*)),1*)I * > 2s01* t2*0,12/ 50 p5/o
/w;<D+2 E <;03 = 2 ; 21*+u v2D o E <>2<x/2*1)3 ;2 ;=<;< 2/4o
t510, *02+Iu 032I *12 *+/5 > ),+0 * > 0 (2
)5 ; /,( <;= 05 (* <;<;0* <; 4 y3;<;=</ p*p21;<zp15p5/2/
032
5t (*)3 2 +2*1< ; ; 02)3 <; ,2/; ; 05
= 12*0+I,/2*,05(*02
032 )12*0 ;=<;
5 * > (* 02 * < )2
5t; >5(* <;o /p2)<;<q ) /2*1)3
2
D2
<; t51)2(2 ;02/4+2*1v2;<;=>2/)1
2E <q12/2*1)3
12
u
02s0
)+*// )*0 <5 ; * ; > <; t51(*0 <5 ; 2s01*)0 <5 ; < 03*0<o
2 ; *D+2/< 2x );<2 ;0< /p;<>21<q <;=<;u p5p,+*02/
05p ) 3=o
<{2 02s0
21*1)3
2/u
*
>
>2
0
2/
t51(*0
;<z ,2/u E2 3*{ 2 D,/2<+0
(2 ;0/4 ;w /<;=< 032/2
02)3
* >2(5 /01*0< ;5 ; /I/02(| * /2*1)3 {2 ;=<;
2 t51
)5(p,021 /)2 )2 12/2*1)3 p*p21/ * * <+*D+2 *0
}}}~~ ~4
FA$ F8A
/ 032 *(5, ;0 5t <; t51(*0 <5 ; 5 ; 032 v51+> v <>2 v2D
= 15E/u
<
<; <;= +I > <x ),+0 05 q; > .,/0 E3*0
;040 D2)5(2/
<+2 = 2 ;)12*/
o p,1p5/2 /2*1)3 2 ;=<; 2/ /,)3 */
E2
E*
v3
* ; > 21*+
<= {21* = 2u 032I 5t02 ; p15 o
{<>2 5 ; +I +5E p12) </<55r21
; u 2 {32 ; 3t51)5>20*
<+2> z ,21 <2/4
; E2 :; 5E 03*0 E2 E* ;0 <; t51(*0
<5 ; 5t * )21o
v32
0* <; 0Ip2u;=<;51 5 ;; * )210* <; 05p <)u * >5(* <;o /p2)<q )o
/2*1)3 2 2 )* D2 * p5E21t,+ 055+4 z 51< 2s*({
p+2u }}}~ ~
*++5E/<)5(p+2s< ;,21;2/ 5 21
= 2 o= 15,pu
/,((21
)*(p/
DI
*
<0 <55; *+u* =>2 ;)5/04
21t51( <;= /,)3 /2*1)32/ E <03 / * 2u01*>+5)*0
21*+o
;=<;
<
p,1p5/2
2 < 2 E5,+>
D2 2s012(2+I
5,/ 51;o
<(p5//<D+24/2*1)3
; u >5(*
<;o /p2) <q ) 02>
51
03
/
12*/5
/2*1)3
2
=<; 2/ *12 D2)5( <;= <; )12*/<;= +I p5p,+*14 w; t510, ; *02+Iu
o<;02 ; /<{2 p15)2//u
D, <+>< <;= 032/2
/2*1)3
2 ;=<; 2/; </ ;* +*D51
z
<
<;=
<=;<q
;=
0Ip )*++I
12 , 1 </ )* 0 * > 5 5 <;=; 3,(* ; 2r5104o
y3 </ p*p21
>2/)1 D2/ 032 <;=;  <;* <;<;=
2r510 05 *,05<;o
(*02<q(* ; I */p2)0/
5t
)12*0
*
>
(*
0*
;=<; 2/ DI ,/<;= (*)3 <; 2 +2*1 ;<;=>5(*02)3 o
/p2)
)
/2*1)3
2
;<z ,2/4 y32/2 02)3 ;<z ,2/ *++5E /2*1)3 2 ;=<; 2/ 05 D2
)12*02> z , <): +I E;<03 ( <;<<;(*+ 2r510u
* ; > *12 /,;<02> t51o
</ p*p21
12o<;,/2 *)15//
(*
I
>5(*
/4
y3
p12/2 0/ (*
)3 2 +2*1;<;= (2035>/ t51 2x )<2 ;0 05p <)o > <12)02> /p <>21o

   

  

?"@A B8'
68@F8 GH%A'
: /2I(512-1< 4)(,42>,
.1CD-* ; >12E4)(,42>,
'ZRSdde df gdhiKMOQ ZR\OXRO
gPQXO^\O jOeedX kX\lOQL\MY
[\MML]KQ^S_ [` VabVc
<;= u D, <+> <;= * D15E/*D+2 05p <) 3 <21*1)3Iu * ; > 2s01*)0 <;=
05p <)o 12+2 {<;=* ;0 /,D/01 <;= /4= y32/2 *12 D1 <2I >2/)1 <D2> <;
032{t5++5E 03122;=<;
p*1* 1*p3/4 =<; <
21I /2*1)3
2
)5++2)0 <5 ;
;0/ 05 <; >2s42 (,/0
;D2 * <( <;=E 0305 *p5p,+*02
5t >5),(2
v32
<;o /p2)<q ) /2*1)3 2 ;=<; 2u * E2D o )1*E+<;= /p <>21*
>5(*
; 22> ; 50 2sp+512 032 v2D <; > </)1 <( <; * ;0+Iu D,0 /35,+>
<; < t*/3 <5 ; 05 q; > >5(* <;o 12+2 {* ;0 >5)o
2sp+512
;0/ 2 x*)<>2 ;12)02>
,(2
0+I4 v2 t1*(2 :032 /p <>21<;=<;= 0*/ : <; * o

t1*(2E51
Cu
*+
<;= ,/ 05 (*032(*0
<)*++I >2 q;*2+D+
<(*+ ~uD23*
{<514
+5E
2
5p0
,1 2sp21<(2 ;0*+ 12/,+0/ /35E 03*0 * /<(p+2 12 <; t51)2 o
(2< ;0 +2*1<;=;<;= /p <>21 oq</ 03122 0 <(2/ (512 2 x )<2 ;0 03* ; *
/p >21 ,/ ;=<;D12*>03 ; 1/0 /2*1)34
2*1)3 2 < 2/ 5t02 p15{<< >2 * D15E/*D+2 05p <) 3 <<21*1o
)3I<;=*355 / 032
)*++I
;0/ p15050Ip
<;05 * 05p)*+<) 32s*(p+24
<21*1)3I )* ;,05(*0
*>> >5),(2
D2
p5/2>
;0 2s02 ; /<5 ; / 05 032*/
* 02s0 )+*//<q )*0 <5 ; 0*/<q: 4 v2 p12/2
; 02s0; )+*//
21 ~~<;<;= )*++,( <~u
o
03*0
,/2 5 3* ><q+*D2+2>
>*0*u I20 /0 ++ 12/,+0<o
<; *)),1*02
<5 ; 4 01*
<03 , ; +*D2+2>
)+*//
)*0
v
>*0*u 032 =3 o
; > * t2E : 2IE51>/ t51 2*)3 )*02 = 51Iu
21*1)3I
*
<; 2/ ; * <{2 *I2/u 3 <21*1)3 <)*+ /31 <;:032* = 2*+* ;5>
1<03( )5(D
<5 ;o *s <( < *0 <5 ; 4 0 p+*)2/ >5),(2 ;0/ <;05 *
<03 CC *)),1*)I
osp2)0*0
+2*t )5(p,021
/) <2 ; )2<;=3 <21*1)3I
; )2 *pp15*)3
; * =E122(2
;0 +2 {2+/4
p21t51(*
3,(*
<5 ; t15(
s01*)0 <;= 05p <)o12+2 {* ;0 p <2)2/ 5t <; t51(*0
;
<;o
<q
;=<;
032 >5),(2 0/ 5t * >5(*
/p2) ) /2*1)3<; 2 2 *+o
{ 21 032/2
+5E/
032
,/21
05
/2*1)3
5
* E*I 03*0
= 2 ; 21*+ /2*1)3 2 ;=<; 2/ )* ;; 504 ;t2*0,12/
<5 ; 2s01*)0
<;
t51(*0
<)*++I q; > <;= /p2) <q ) 02s0,*+ /,D5 ou
032<;=p15)2//
5t
*,05(*0
/01 / <; <;* >5),(2< ;;0u </ E2++< /,; <02>< 05 03 <;<z
/ 0*/: 4 v2
*pp15*)3
t51(*0
5
2s01*)0
5
E
03
02)3
<; /0*0 </0 <)*+ +* ;= ,* = 2 (5>2+<;= * ; > /p22)3 12)5,2/=;<0,/2>
<;
; *(2+I *D <; 21u 4 ,1 5*+ou
= 51<03( 2s01*)0/ q 2+>/ /,)3 */ 0 <0+2u *,0351/u * ; > *x +<* o
0 <5 ; t15( {12/2*1)3= p*p21 32*>21/ E{ <03o < *)),1*)I4<;
v2 3* 2 D15,
D2>
;<z ,2/3005 =*++20321032<; *D5
2u *>2/)1
<)+I o *(*)3
{* <+*D+22
+2*1 ;<;= 02)3
p,D+
/2*1)3 2 ;=<; 2 5; )5(p,021 ;/) <<;2 ; )2 <=12/2*1)3
;0 /p <>21p*p21/
}}}~~ ~4
02++
2
/0*10/
= 2/ 5t )5(p,021 /)<2 ; )2 >2p*10(2
;
t15(
032
35(2
p*
<;: / 05 p5/0/)1<p0 >5),0/o
* ; >; +*D51*051 <2/ * ; > )5++2)0/
+
(2 0/4 y32/2 >5),(2 ;0/ *12 )5 ;{ 2102> 05 p+* <; 02s0

   

   


   
  

! " # $ % & '(

> 0 /45 / 6 = A 0: : 0 / : B 7 8 : B 0 }~ ~ t v {uw t => ,? 0 / ,8 : B 0 A 0 - ,8 C

8 ,8 - E ; B 0 8 4. : . /0 / 0 ; 7 / ? 6 . = : A 0 . = 0 ? : 5 = 0 <0 9: 7 6 5 8 7 <: 0 /8 7: , @ 0 A / 7 8 9B 0 = E 8 5 8 0 5 4 ; B ,9B - , @ 0 ,6 6 0 ? ,7: 0 /0 C

Spidering CS Departments

Percent Research Papers Found

100
90

; 7/? I
8 7 @ 0 / 7 - 0 : B 0 }~ ~ t v {uw t => ,? 0 / : 7 K 0 = 8 0 7 / <J
: B /0 0 : ,6 0 = 7 = <5 8 - 7 = zw st : 5 D 8 ? : B 0 D / = : 1 a kf l
5 4 : B 0 > 7 > 0 / = I j 0 B 7 @ 0 7 < = 5 / . 8 0e > 0 / ,6 0 8: = 5 8 : 7 = K =

80
70
60

; ,: B 7 = ,8 - <0 : 7 / - 0 : > 7 - 0 E ; B 0 / 0 4. : . / 0 / 0 ; 7 / ? ? 0 9, = ,5 8 =
7 / 0 6 5 / 0 9/ . 9,7 < I ]8 : B , = 9 7 = 0 E : B 0 zw st => ,? 0 / / 0: / ,0 @ 0 =
: 7 /- 0: > 7 - 0 = :; ,9 0 7 = 0 9,0 8: <J 7 = : B 0 }~ ~ t v {uw t => ,? 0 /
0 8 8 ,0 7 8 ? 9 G 7 <<. 6 E _` ` `
I ]8 + ,- . /0 1 E 7 4: 0 / : B 0
D / = : f h 5 4 : B 0 > 7 > 0 / = 7 /0 45 . 8 ? E : B 0 }~ ~ t v {uw t => ,C

50
40
30

RL Immediate
RL Future
Breadth-First

20
10
0
0

+ ,- . / 0 1 2

10

20

30 40 50 60 70 80
Percent Hyperlinks Followed

90

100

3 0 /45 / 6 7 8 90 5 4 :; 5 / 0 ,8 45 / 90 6 0 8: <0 7 / 8 ,8 -

=> ,? 0 / = @ 0 / = . = : / 7 ? ,: ,5 8 7 < A /0 7 ? : B CD / = : = 0 7 / 9B E 7 @ 0 / 7 - 0 ?
5 @ 0 / 45 . / : 0 = : F: / 7 ,8 => <,: = ; ,: B ? 7: 7 4/5 6 45 . / G H ? 0C
> 7 /: 6 0 8: = I

; 5 / K ; 0 7 /0 ,6 > / 5 @ ,8 - : B 0 7 9 9. / 7 9J 5 4 : B 0 9 <7 == ,D 9 7 : ,5 8
; B 0 8 : B 0 / 0 , = 4. : . /0 / 0 ; 7 / ? 7 8 ? 7 <7 /- 0 / 8 . 6 A 0 / 5 4 A ,8 = I

6 0 8 ? / 0 <0 @ 7 8: B J > 0 /<,8 K = : 5 : B 0 . = 0 / I

L MN

? 0 / > 0 /45 / 6 = = <,- B: <J A 0:: 0 / E A 0 9 7 . = 0 6 7 8 J <,8 K = ; ,: B

,6 6 0 ? ,7 : 0 / 0 ; 7 / ? B 7 @ 0 A 0 0 8 ? , = 9 5 @ 0 / 0 ? E 7 8 ? : B 0 }~ ~ ty
v {uw t => ,? 0 / / 0 95 - 8 , 0 = : B 0 6 6 5 /0 7 9 9. / 7: 0 <J I ]8 5 8 - 5 ,8 -

d5 > ,9 B ,0 / 7 / 9B ,0 = 7 / 0 7 8 0 9 ,0 8: ; 7J : 5 5 /- 7 8 , 0 7 8 ?
@ ,0 ; <7 / - 0 . 7 8: ,: ,0 = 5 4 ,8 45 / 6 7 : ,5 8 : B 7 : ; 5 . <? 5 : B 0 /C
; , = 0 A 0 9. 6 A 0 / = 5 6 0 I
^ = 7 B 5 5 B 7 = = B 5; 8 E 7 : 5 > ,9

O P Q R S TU R VW X Y Z R [ \ YW [

]8 ^ . - . = : _` ` a ; 0 4. <<J 6 7 > > 0 ? : B 0 G H ? 0 > 7 /: 6 0 8: ; 0 A

= ,: 0 = 7 : b /5; 8 c 8 , @ 0 / = ,:JE G 5 / 8 0 << c 8 , @ 0 / = ,:JE c 8 , @ 0 / = ,:J
5 4 3 ,:: = A . / - B 7 8 ? c 8 , @ 0 / = ,:J 5 4 d0e 7 = I d B 0 J ,8 9 <. ? 0
f g Eh _1 ? 5 9 . 6 0 8: = 7 8 ? f ` 1 E1 _i BJ > 0 / <,8 K = I j 0 > 0 /45 /6
45 . / : 0 = : F: / 7 ,8 => <,: = E ; B 0 / 0 : B 0 ? 7: 7 4/5 6 : B / 0 0 . 8 , @ 0 /C
= ,: ,0 = , = . = 0 ? : 5 : / 7 ,8 7 => ,? 0 / : B 7 : , = : 0 = : 0 ? 5 8 : B 0 45 . /: B I
d B 0 : 7 /- 0: > 7 - 0 = k45 / ; B ,9B 7 / 0 ; 7 / ? 5 4 _ , = - , @ 0 8 l 7 / 0
95 6 > . : 0 / = 9,0 8 90 / 0 = 0 7 / 9B > 7 > 0 / = E ,? 0 8: ,D 0 ? = 0 > 7 / 7: 0 <J
A J 7 = ,6 > <0 B 7 8 ? C 9 5 ? 0 ? 7 <- 5 / ,: B 6 ; ,: B B ,- B > / 0 9 , = ,5 8 I
j 0 9 . / /0 8: <J : / 7 ,8 : B 0 7 - 0 8: 5 m C <,8 0 I j 0 D 8 ? 7 << : 7 /C
- 0 : > 7 - 0 = ,8 : B 0 : / 7 ,8 ,8 - ? 7: 7 E 7 8 ? 9 7 <9 . <7 : 0 : B 0 n C @ 7 <. 0
7 = = 5 9 ,7 : 0 ? ; ,: B 0 7 9B B J > 0 /<,8 K 7 = : B 0 ? , = 95 . 8: 0 ? = . 6
5 4 / 0 ; 7 / ? = : B 7: /0 = . <: 4/ 5 6 0e 0 9. : ,8 - : B 0 5 > : ,6 7 < > 5 <C
,9J k7 = ? 0: 0 / 6 ,8 0 ? AJ 4. << K 8 5; <0 ? - 0 5 4 : B 0 ; 0 A - / 7 > B l I

B ,0 / 7 / 9B J 9 7 8 A 0 7 8 ,8: 0 - / 7 < > 7 /: 5 4 7 = 0 7 / 9B 0 8 - ,8 0 I +5 /

su E ; 0 B 7 @ 0 9 /0 7: 0 ? 7 hC <0 74 B ,0 / 7 / 9B J 5 4 95 6 > . : 0 / = 9,C
0 8 90 : 5 > ,9 = E : B 0 : 5 > > 7 /: 5 4 ; B ,9B , = = B 5; 8 ,8 + ,- . / 0 _ I
G / 0 7: ,8 - : B 0 B ,0 / 7 / 9B J = : / . 9: . /0 7 8 ? = 0 <0 9: ,8 - . = : 7 40 ;
K0 J ; 5 / ? = 7 == 5 9,7: 0 ? ; ,: B 0 7 9B 8 5 ? 0 : 5 5 K 7 A 5 . : : B /0 0
B 5 . / = E ? . /,8 - ; B ,9B 7 8 0e > 0 /: 0e 7 6 ,8 0 ? 9 5 8 40 /0 8 90 > /5 C
90 0 ? ,8 - = 7 8 ? 95 6 > . : 0 / = 9 ,0 8 90 j 0 A = ,: 0 = I
^ 6 . 9B 6 5 / 0 ? , 9 . <: 7 8 ? : ,6 0C 95 8 = . 6 ,8 - > 7 /: 5 4 9 /0 C
7: ,8 - 7 B ,0 / 7 / 9B J , = > <7 9 ,8 - ? 5 9. 6 0 8: = ,8: 5 : B 0 95 // 0 9:
: 5 > ,9 8 5 ? 0 = I 7 B 5 5 B 7 = B ,/ 0 ? 6 7 8J > 0 5 > <0 : 5 9 7: 0 - 5 C
/ , 0 ; 0 A > 7 - 0 = ,8: 5 : B 0 ,/ B ,0 / 7 / 9B J I ]8 9 5 8: / 7 = : E 6 7 C
9B ,8 0 <0 7 / 8 ,8 - 9 7 8 7 . : 5 6 7: 0 : B , = : 7 = K ; ,: B = . > 0 / @ , = 0 ?
: 0 e : 9<7 = = ,D 9 7 : ,5 8 I

5; 0 @ 0 / E 7 9 . ,/,8 - 0 8 5 . - B <7 A 0 <0 ?

: / 7 ,8 ,8 - ? 5 9 . 6 0 8: = : 5 A . ,<? 7 8 7 9 9 . / 7: 0 9<7 = = ,D 0 / , = 5 4C

d B 0 7 - 0 8: 95 . <? 7 < = 5 <0 7 / 8 4/5 6 0 e > 0 /,0 8 9 0 5 8 C<,8 0 . = C

,8 - d o C p I ^ => ,? 0 / , = 0 @ 7 <. 7: 0 ? 5 8 0 7 9B : 0 = : F: / 7 ,8 => <,:
A J B 7 @ ,8 - ,: => ,? 0 / : B 0 : 0 = : . 8 , @ 0 / = ,:JE = : 7 /: ,8 - 7: : B 0

: 0 8 > /5 B ,A ,: , @ 0 <J 0e > 0 8 = , @ 0 I

? 0 > 7 /: 6 0 8: q= B 5 6 0 > 7 - 0 I ]8 + ,- . / 0 1 ; 0 /0 > 5 /: /0 = . <: =

4/ 5 6 : / 7 ? ,: ,5 8 7 < r st u vw xy z {s|w = 0 7 / 9B 7 = ; 0 << 7 = :; 5 ? ,4C

7 8 ? : B 0 9<7 = = B ,0 / 7 / 9B J I ]8 = : 0 7 ? 5 4 7 = K ,8 - : B 0 A . ,<? 0 /
: 5 B 7 8 ? C<7 A 0 < : / 7 ,8 ,8 - 0 e 7 6 > <0 = E : B 0 A . ,<? 0 / = ,6 > <J > /5 C
@ ,? 0 = 7 40 ; K0 J ; 5 / ? = 45 / 0 7 9B 9 7: 0 - 5 /J I ^ <7 /- 0 95 <<0 9: ,5 8

40 / 0 8: /0 ,8 45 / 90 6 0 8: <0 7 / 8 0 / = I

}~ ~ t v {uw t . = 0 =  h E
7 8 ? / 0 > / 0 = 0 8: = : B 0 n C4. 8 9: ,5 8 7 = 7 A ,8 7 / J 9<7 = = ,D 0 / : B 7 :
5 8 <J ? , = : ,8 - . , = B 0 = ,6 6 0 ? ,7: 0 /0 ; 7 / ? 7 9: ,5 8 = I zw st . = 0 =

 h f E 7 8 ? / 0 > / 0 = 0 8: = : B 0 n C4. 8 9: ,5 8 ; ,: B 7 6 5 / 0
D 8 0 <J C ? , = 9 /,6 ,8 7 : ,8 - gC A ,8 9<7 = = ,D 0 / : B 7 : . = 0 = 4. : . /0 /0 C
; 7/?= I
^ : 7 << : ,6 0 = ? . / ,8 - ,: = > / 5 - /0 == E A 5 : B / 0 ,8 45 / 90 6 0 8:
<0 7 / 8 ,8 - => ,? 0 / = B 7 @ 0 45 . 8 ? 6 5 / 0 /0 = 0 7 / 9B > 7 > 0 / = : B 7 8
A / 0 7 ? : B CD / = : = 0 7 / 9B I 8 0 6 0 7 = . /0 5 4 > 0 /45 /6 7 8 90 , = : B 0
8 . 6 A 0 / 5 4 BJ > 0 / <,8 K = 45 <<5; 0 ? A 045 /0 f 5 4 : B 0 / 0 = 0 7 / 9B
> 7 > 0 / = 7 / 0 45 . 8 ? I b 5 : B / 0 ,8 45 / 90 6 0 8: <0 7 / 8 0 / = 7 / 0 = ,- 8 ,4C
,9 7 8: <J 6 5 / 0 0 9,0 8: E / 0 . ,/,8 - 0e > <5 / 7: ,5 8 5 4 <0 == : B 7 8
_i 5 4 : B 0 B J > 0 /<,8 K = ,8 9 5 6 > 7 /, = 5 8 E r st u vw xy s|w /0 C
. ,/0 = a I d B , = / 0 > /0 = 0 8: = 7 4 7 9: 5 / 5 4 : B /0 0 ,8 9 /0 7 = 0 ,8
=> ,? 0 / ,8 - 0 9 ,0 8 9J I
5 : 0 : B 7: : B 0 zw st / 0 ,8 45 / 9 0 6 0 8: <0 7 /8 ,8 -

=> ,? 0 /

]8 : B , = > 7 > 0 / E ; 0 0 7 = 0 : B 0 A . / ? 0 8 5 8 : B 0 9<7 = = ,D 0 /

A . ,<? 0 / A J . = ,8 - 5 8 <J . 8 <7 A 0 <0 ? ? 7 : 7 E = 5 6 0 K 0 J ; 5 / ? =

5 4 . 8 <7 A 0 <0 ? ? 5 9 . 6 0 8: = 7 / 0 : B 0 8 > /0 <,6 ,8 7 /,<J <7 A 0 <0 ?

A J . = ,8 - : B 0 K0 J ; 5 / ? = 7 = 7 / . <0C <, = : 9<7 = = ,D 0 / k= 0 7 / 9B ,8 7 ? 5 9. 6 0 8: 45 / 0 7 9B K0 J ; 5 / ? 7 8 ? > <7 9,8 - ,: ,8 : B 0 9<7 = =
5 4 : B 0 D / = : K 0 J ; 5 / ? 45 . 8 ? l I d B 0 = 0 > /0 <,6 ,8 7 / J <7 A 0 < =
7 / 0 8 5 , = JE 7 8 ? 6 7 8 J ? 5 9. 6 0 8: = / 0 6 7 ,8 . 8 <7 A 0 <0 ? I 5; C
0 @ 0 / E ; 0 : B 0 8 A 5 5 : = : / 7 > 7 8 ,6 > / 5 @ 0 ? 9 <7 == ,D 0 / I c = ,8 - : B 0
? 5 9. 6 0 8: = 7 8 ? > / 0 <,6 ,8 7 / J <7 A 0 < = E ; 0 ,8 ,: ,7 <, 0 7 8 7 , @ 0
b 7J0 = : 0 e : 9<7 = = ,D 0 / 4/5 6 : B 0 > /0 <,6 ,8 7 / J <7 A 0 < = I d B 0 8 E
e > 0 9: 7: ,5 8 C 7e ,6 , 7 : ,5 8 o 0 6 > = : 0 / E _` 0 = : ,C
6 7: 0 = <7 A 0 < = 5 4 . 8 <7 A 0 <0 ? ? 5 9. 6 0 8: = 7 8 ? / 0C 0 = : ,6 7 : 0 =
<7 A 0 < = 5 4 K0 J ; 5 / ? C <7 A 0 <0 ? ? 5 9. 6 0 8: = I H : 7: , = : ,9 7 < = B / ,8 K C
7 - 0 , = 7 < = 5 ,8 9 5 / > 5 / 7 : 0 ? ,8 5 / ? 0 / : 5 ,6 > / 5 @ 0 > 7 / 7 6 0: 0 /
0 = : ,6 7: 0 = A J . = ,8 - : B 0 9<7 = = B ,0 / 7 / 9BJ I ]8 : B , = > 7 > 0 / ; 0
95 6 A ,8 0 45 / : B 0 D / = : : ,6 0 ,8 5 8 0 ? 5 9. 6 0 8: 9 <7 == ,D 0 / A 5 : B
45 / . 8 <7 A 0 <0 ? ? 7: 7 7 8 ? B ,0 / 7 / 9B ,9 7 < = B /,8 K7 - 0 I

 

  


   




 

5++

++
+

5*6

/+6

5.6

5*6
--6

*6

"

; <=>?@ABCD?= EFC@BGCD?=


 ! 

"

# $ % &'


( )
*+
/+ -!
0123
4

-.

! K

.

N O NP ,
7

H 

 QR

Q Q QS T T TQU V MW

0.86
0.80
institution

0.14
tech

0.03
0.91

0.03

institution

0.85
0.82

0.03

0.37

editor

title

0.18
author
0.03

0.80

0.20

0.89
0.09

0.03
0.66

0.20
date

0.11
booktitle

journal

1.0
0.33

volume

XYZ[\] ^_ `aa[bc\dcYe] ]fdgha] ij dk lmm ji\ \]j]\]kn]

]fc\dncYiko
}
p qr st u v d\Z gdf ~ q   u q  r  u q^u
wxyyywz{| z 

]\] m Yb c ] gi]a q   u Yb c ] h\idYaYc ij

c\dkbYcYikYkZ ]c ]]k bcdc]b

dk  dk q  r  u
]gYccYkZ
Yb c ] h\idYaYc ij bcdc]
i[ch[c bgia

o

]
Yc]\Y
daZi\Yc
g
Yc]\Y

r]nY]kca
b][]kn]o ndk ] [b] ci
 \]nie]\ c Yb bcdc]

lmmb gd ] [b] ji\ ]fc\dncYkZ Ykji\gdcYik j\ig

\]b]d\n hdh]\b ji\g[adcYkZ d gi]a Yk c ] jiaai YkZ
d_ ]dn bcdc] Yb dbbinYdc] Yc d nadbb c dc ] dkc
ci ]fc\dnc b[n db cYca] d[c i\ i\ daYdcYiko dn bcdc]
]gYcb i\b j\ig d nadbbbh]nYn [kYZ\dg Ybc\Y[cYiko
`k i\]\ ci ad]a k] c]fc Yc nadbb]b ] c\]dc c ] i\b
j\ig c ] k] c]fc db ib]\edcYikb
dk \]nie]\ c ] gibc
aY]a bcdc] b][]kn]o ] bcdc] c dc h\i[n]b ]dn i\
Yb c ] nadbb cdZ ji\ c dc i\o k Yaa[bc\dcYe] ]fdgha] ij
dk lmm ji\ \]j]\]kn] ]fc\dncYik Yb b i k Yk XYZ[\] ^o
[\ i\ Yc lmmb ji\ Ykji\gdcYik ]fc\dncYik ji
n[b]b ik a]d\kYkZ
c ] dhh\ih\Ydc] gi]a bc\[nc[\] qc ]
k[g]\ ij bcdc]b dk
c\dkbYcYikbu d[cigdcYndaa j\ig
dcdo c ]\ bbc]gb [bYkZ lmmb ji\ Ykji\gdcYik ]f
c\dncYik Ykna[] c dc ]] Yn ]fc\dncb Yk
ji\gdcYik di[c Z]k] kdg]b dk aindcYikb j\ig bnY]kcYn
dbc\dncb dk c ] ga] bbc]g Y]a ji\
kdg]]kcYc ]fc\dncYiko
]b] bbc]gb i kic nikbY]\
d[cigdcYndaa ]c]\gYkYkZ gi]a bc\[nc[\] j\ig dcd
c ] ]Yc ]\ [b] ik] bcdc] h]\ nadbb i\ [b] dk[Yac
gi]ab dbb]ga] Ykbh]ncYkZ c\dYkYkZ ]fdgha]bo

] Zida ij i[\ Ykji\gdcYik ]fc\dncYik ]fh]\Yg]kcb Yb
ciYke]bcYZdc] ]c ]\ d gi]a Yc g[acYha] bcdc]b h]\
nadbb ]Yc ]\ gdk[daa i\ d[cigdcYndaa ]\Ye] i[ch]\
ji\gb d gi]a
Yc ika ik] bcdc] h]\ nadbb ji\ ]d]\
]fc\dncYiko ] ]k]
c ] ]d]\ ij d \]b]d\n hdh]\
ci ] daa ij c ] i\b j\ig
c ] ]ZYkkYkZ ij c ] hdh]\

[h ci ]Yc ]\ c ] \bc b]ncYik ij c ] hdh]\ [b[daa c ]

Ykc\i[ncYik i\ ci c ] ]k ij c ] \bc hdZ] Yn ]e]\
inn[\b \bco bYkZa] ci]k ]Yc ]\ i\
Yb d] ci c ] ]k ij ]dn ]d]\ ci YkYndc] c ] ndb]
Yc Yn Yc c]\gYkdc]o Y] Yb] c ] dbc\dnc Yb d[ci
gdcYndaa
aindc] dk b[bcYc[c] Yc c ] bYkZa] ci]k
o j] bh]nYda nadbb]bij i\b
d\] Y]kcY
] [bYkZ bYgha] \]Z[ad\ ]fh\]bbYikb dk nike]\c] ci
ci]kb b[n db o aa h[knc[dcYik ndb] dk k]
aYk] Ykji\gdcYik Yb \]gie] j\ig c ] c]fco ] cd\Z]c
nadbb]b ] Yb ci Y]kcYj Ykna[] c ] jiaai YkZ jc]]k
ndc]Zi\Y]b_ cYca] d[c i\ daYdcYik d\]bb kic] ]gdYa
dc] dbc\dnc Ykc\i[ncYik h ik] ] i\b ] ]
Z\]] h[aYndcYik k[g]\ dk hdZ]o
mdk[daa cdZZ] ]d]\b d\] bhaYc Ykci d ]d]\
c\dYkYkZ b]c dk d ^ ]d]\
^ i\ ci]k ad]a]
^ i\ ci]k c]bc b]co kYZ\dg adkZ[dZ] gi]ab
d\] [Yac ji\ ]dn nadbb dk bgiic ] [bYkZ d giY]
ji\g ij dbia[c] Ybni[kcYkZo dn bcdc] [b]b Ycb nadbb
[kYZ\dg Ybc\Y[cYik db Ycb ]gYbbYik Ybc\Y[cYiko
] nighd\] c ] h]\ji\gdkn] ij d gi]a Yc ik] bcdc]
h]\ nadbb qu
ci c dc ij gi]ab Yc g[acYha] bcdc]b
h]\ nadbb q uo
] g[acYbcdc] gi]ab
d\] ]\Ye] j\ig c\dYkYkZ dcd Yk c ] jiaai YkZ d_ d
gdfYgdaabh]nYn lmm Yb [Yac ]\] ]dn i\ ci]k
Yk c ] c\dYkYkZ b]c Yb dbbYZk] d bYkZa] bcdc] c dc ika
c\dkbYcYikb
ci c ] bcdc] c dc jiaai b Yco dn bcdc] Yb db
binYdc] Yc c ] nadbb ad]a
ij Ycb i\ ci]ko ]k
c ] lmm Yb h[c c \i[Z d b]\Y]b ij bcdc] g]\Z]b Yk i\
]\ ci Z]k]\daY] c ] gi]ao XY\bc k]YZ i\ g]\ZYkZ
nigYk]b daa bcdc]b c dc b d\] d [kY[] c\dkbYcYik dk
de] c ] bdg] nadbb ad]ao Xi\ ]fdgha] daa ddn]kc cYca]
bcdc]b
d\] g]\Z] Ykci ik] cYca] bcdc]o b c i bcdc]b d\]
g]\Z] c\dkbYcYik ni[kcb d\] h\]b]\e] Ykc\i[nYkZ
d
b]ajaiih ik c ] k] g]\Z] bcdc]o ] k]YZ i\g]\Z]
gi]a Yb [b] db c ] bcd\cYkZ hiYkc ji\ c ] c i g[acYbcdc]
gi]abo mdk[da g]\Z] ]nYbYikb d\] gd] Yk dk Yc]\d
cYe] gdkk]\ ci h\i[n] c ] gi]a dk dk d[
cigdcYn ji\ d\ dk dn d\ g]\ZYkZ h\in][\] Yb
[b] ci h\i[n] c ] gi]ao g]\ZYkZ nikbYbcb
ij g]\ZYkZ dk c i bcdc]b c dc b d\] c\dkbYcYikb j\ig i\
ci d niggik bcdc]
dk de] c ] bdg] ad]ao \dkbYcYik
h\idYaYcY]b ji\ c ] c \]] gi]ab
d\] b]c ci c ]Y\ gdf
Yg[g aY]aY ii ]bcYgdc]b c ] db]aYk] gi]a cd]b Ycb
c\dkbYcYik ni[kcb Y\]nca j\ig c ] ad]a] c\dYkYkZ dcd
]\]db c ] g[acYbcdc] gi]ab [b] c ] ni[kcb c dc de]

]]k h\]b]\e]
[\YkZ c ] bcdc] g]\ZYkZ h\in]bbo
mi]a h]\ji\gdkn] Yb g]db[\] i\ nadbbYndcYik
dnn[\dn Yn Yb c ] h]\n]kcdZ] ij ]d]\ i\b c dc
d\] ]gYcc] d bcdc] Yc c ] bdg] ad]a db c ] i\b
c\[] ad]ao fc\dncYik \]b[acb
d\] h\]b]kc] Yk da] o
lY]k md\ie gi]ab i ]aa dc ]fc\dncYkZ ]d]\ Yk
ji\gdcYik c ] ]bc h]\ji\gdkn] ij o Yb icdYk]
c ] gi]ao ic ij c ] g[acYbcdc] gi
]abYc i[ch]\ji\g
c ] gi]a YkYndcYkZ c dc c ]
\Yn ]\ \]h\]b]kcdcYik
dedYada] c \i[Z gi]ab ]\Ye]
j\ig dcd Yb ]k]nYdao li ]e]\
c ] d[cigdcYndaa
]\Ye] gi]a i]b kic h]\ji\g
db ]aa db c ]
gdk[daa]\Ye] gi]ao ]
gi]a

   

 
 
     
   
   


    !" # $%&
 '  ( ' 



) * + (   
  ' 

,

-  (  .     '
 
 ' 
   / ( - ' 
     
, '  
.
  012 + ( -   
3 ' ,
,  

 44 
' 
5

6 $ 7 89 :;$ 7:

 '  1

  

 


      

 
<=>? @A=B   
 
   
, 
,    '

  ,

 1
. 


,   
 


 
 C%7 8:
DEFGHI JK LMNO PQQRS T U EFGHIO VU WFIIHXO Y U VZ[\]X^_O ]`a
Y U bHFcZ[HaHIU defgIHh ] [Fi[jkHXlmXf ]`ZH IH]X`F`i
`]f Hjn`aHX U o` pqrs tuvO PQQRU

DEmII]ZGHX JK LMNO PQQwS x U EmII]ZGHXO VU y]\XH`ZH O ]`a z U y U

{FIHcU zF^HVHHXh |` ]}^m`mf m}c \Hg ]iH`^ lmX ]}^mf ]^FZ
XH^XFH~]I ]`a FaH`^FnZ]^Fm` ml F`^HXHc^F`i k}gIFZ]^Fm`cU o`
p JK uO PQQwU
Dzm[H` O PQQwS b U zm[H` U | \Hgjg]cHa F`lmXf ]^Fm` cec^Hf
^[]^ XH]cm`c \F^[ c^X}Z^}XHa ZmIIHZ^Fm`c ml ^H^ U o` p JK
uO PQQwU
DzX]~H` JK LMNO PQQwS W U zX]~H` O T U TF]c}mO T U XHF^]i O
| U WZz]II}f O U WF^Z[HIIO x U dFi]f O ]`a VU VI]^^HXeU
yH]X`F`i ^m H^X]Z^ cefgmIFZ G`m\IHaiH lXmf ^[H b mXIa
b FaH b Hg U o` ppptuO PQQwU
DTHf kc^HX JK LMNO PQRRS | U U THf kc^HXO d U W U y]FXa O ]`a
T U E U Y}gF` U W ]Ff}f IFGHIF[mma lXmf F`Zmf kIH^H a]^]
~F] ^[H W ]IimXF^[f U LM K J LM KLKKLM
JK JJ O QPhPwO PQRRU
Dm]Z[Ff c JK LMNO PQQRS U
m]Z[Ff cO
T U XHF^]iO ]`a U WF^Z[HIIU bHg\]^Z[HXh | ^m}X i}FaH
lmX ^[H b mXIa b FaH b Hg U o` ptuvO PQQRU
Dx ]HIgIF`i JK LMNO PQQS y U x ]HIgIF`i O W U yF^^f ]` O ]`a
| U WmmXHU YHF`lmXZHf H`^ IH]X`F`i h | c}X~HeU LM
pK LM KJMM JJ JJLO hRwO PQQ U
DyHHG O PQQRS U yHHG U o`lmXf ]^Fm` H^X]Z^Fm` }cF`i [FaaH`
W ]XGm~ f maHIcU W ]c^HXc ^[HcFcO zVT O PQQRU
DWZz]II}f JK LMNO PQQwS | U WZz]II}f O Y U YmcH`lHIa O
U WF^Z[HIIO ]`a | U diU of kXm~F`i ^H^ ZI]cFnZ]^Fm` ge
c[XF`G]iH F` ] [FHX]XZ[e ml ZI]ccHcU o` r tuO PQQwU
DWZz]II}f JK LMNO PQQQS | U WZz]II}f O x U dFi]f O U Y H``FH O
]`a x U VHef mXHU E}FIaF`i amf ]F`jckHZFnZ cH]XZ[ H`iF`Hc
\F^[ f ]Z[F`H IH]X`F`i ^HZ[`F}HcU o` ppp  t
KJMM JK p JK JLJO PQQQ U
DWH`Z_HXO PQQRS U WH`Z_HXU |Y|zdoT h |a]k^F~H XHj
^XFH~]I ]iH`^c Z[mmcF`i [H}XFc^FZ `HFi[gmX[mmac lmX F`lmXj
f ]^Fm` aFcZm~HXeU o` r tuvO PQQRU
DdFi]f JK LMNO PQQQS x U dFi]f O | U WZz]II}f O VU [X}` O ]`a
U WF^Z[HIIU H^ ZI]ccFnZ]^Fm` lXmf I]gHIHa ]`a }`I]gHIHa
amZ}f H`^c }cF`i W U LJ rJLO PQQQU m ]kkH]X U
DY ]gF`HXO PQwQS y U Y U Y]gF`HXU | ^}^mXF]I m` [FaaH` W ]XGm~
f maHIc ]`a cHIHZ^Ha ]kkIFZ]^Fm`c F` ckHHZ[ XHZmi`F^Fm` U
s JJ K J O RRhRwO PQwQU
DYH``FH ]`a WZz]II}f O PQQQS ]cm` YH``FH ]`a |`aXH\
WZz]II}f U cF`i XHF`lmXZHf H`^ IH]X`F`i ^m ckFaHX ^[H bHg
H ZFH`^IeU o` r tuuO PQQQU
DVHef mXH JK LMNO PQQQS x U VHef mXHO | U WZz]II}f O ]`a
Y U YmcH`lHIa U yH]X`F`i [FaaH` W ]XGm~ f maHI c^X}Z^}XH
lmX F`lmXf ]^Fm` H^X]Z^Fm` U o` ppp Lt
J rJL LK KLKO PQQQ U
DF^HXgFO PQRS | U U F^HXgFU XXmX gm}`ac lmX Zm`~mI}^Fm`]I
ZmaHc ]`a ]` ]cef^m^FZ]IIe mk^Ff}f aHZmaF`i ]IimXF^[f U
LLK LK JO ojP h
QO PQRU
Db F^^H` JK LMNO PQQwS oU b F^^H` O z U dH~FIIjW ]``F`i O Y U W Zj
d]g O ]`a VU U z}```F`i[]f U | k}gIFZ aFiF^]I IFgX]Xe
g]cHa m` l}IIj^H^ XH^XFH~]Ih zmIIHZ^Fm`c ]`a HkHXFH`ZH U
LK K J p O PhRPRO PQQw U