Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Introduction:
In this Chapter the laboratory plate load tests results and analysis have been discussed for
black cotton soil treated with stabilisers.
Effect of optimum stabilisers on the load- deformation behaviour of black cotton soil:
Plate load tests are the most promising method of determining the load-deflection of subgrade
it is conducted to evaluate the supporting power of subgrade. Data from the tests are
applicable for the design of both flexible and rigid pavement, in the present study, an attempt
has been made to study the structural characteristics of the clayey soil and clay soil stabilized
with various percentages of Ground granulated blast furnace slag (GGBS),Road building
international (RBI-81) , coir fiber and polypropylene fiber under plate load tests to investigate
the load deflection characteristics of clayey soil and different combinations of soil stabilized
with above said stabilisers.
EXPERIMENTAL PROGRAMME
The experimental programme to study the strength behaviour of black cotton soil
treated with different stabilizer have been shown in Table2. The study of strength properties
have been planned for black cotton soil treated with optimum percentage of GGBS, RBI-81,
coir fiber and polypropylene fiber. Optimum percentages of stabilisers are mixed with black
cotton soil and load deformation characteristics are studied. The optimum percentage of
stabilisers used is decided on the basis of higher UCS value. The following table 1 shows the
optimum percentage of stabilizer.
Optimum
Material
RBI-81
Polypropylene(PPF)
RBI+PPF
Coir fiber(CF)
GGBS
content
8%
2%
3%+0.75%
0.3%
10%
Combination
Experiments Conducted
BC Alone
slag(GGBS)
hydraulic jack. Deflection of the plate was measured by means of deflection dial gauges
placed usually at near its outer edge. To minimise the bending, a series of stacked plates was
used. The load deformation values were recorded by applying incremental loads through
hydraulic jack. Precaution was then taken to ensure that the magnitude of load applied at the
surface subgrade level. The load was then released in stages and rebound deflection values
were recorded. Deflection measurements were also made at radial distances of 25 and 35cm
from the loaded point. This procedure was repeated for ten cycles and total and rebound
deflection values were recorded. The load v/s deformation and rebound curves are plotted
after each cycle of loading and unloading. The total plastic and elastic deformation were
calculated, the elastic modulus and modulus of subgrade reaction of stabilised soil was
computed. The variation of plastic and elastic deformation, elastic modulus (E) and modulus
of subgrade reaction (K) of stabilised soil with the number of cycles and their variation
different stabilisers are found out.
p
where K=Modulus of subgrade reaction, =deflection (0.125cm) and
p=unit load on circular plate corresponding to deflection , kg/cm2 and Modulus of elasticity
(E) was evaluated from relation, = 1.18 x p x a / E, or E = 1.18 x a x K.
Table 3 plate load test results for black cotton soil alone:
LOAD in kg
AREA in cm2
PRESSURE in
SETTLEMENT in
0
250
500
750
1000
1250
1500
1750
2000
2250
2500
706.85
706.85
706.85
706.85
706.85
706.85
706.85
706.85
706.85
706.85
706.85
kg/cm2
0.00
0.35
0.71
1.06
1.41
1.77
2.12
2.48
2.83
3.18
3.54
mm
0.00
0.28
0.84
1.28
1.75
2.28
2.73
3.36
4.13
4.13
3.90
or
78480 kN/m3
W r t, = 1.18 x p x a / E, K = p / , E = 1.18 x a x K
Here, a = radius of plate, p = pressure = 1.18 x 15 x 8.00 = 141.60 kg/cm2
Modulus of Elasticity (E) = 141.60 kg/cm2
or
13890.96 kN/m2
From the above investigation it is found that the Modulus of subgrade reaction (K) and
Modulus of elasticity (E) for BC soil alone is 78480 kN/m3 and 13890.96 kN/m2 respectively.
Cycles
Total deflection in mm
plastic deflection in mm
elastic deflection in mm
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
0.280
0.835
1.275
1.750
2.275
2.730
3.360
4.125
0.235
0.705
1.035
1.330
1.595
1.850
2.400
2.925
0.045
0.130
0.240
0.420
0.680
0.880
0.960
1.200
4.365
3.125
1.240
10
4.580
3.260
1.320
From Table 4, it is found that there is an increase in the elastic deformation with the increase
in number of cycle, but the rate of increase of elastic deformation is found to be more in
black cotton soil alone. From the present investigation, At the 10 th cycle the total deflection is
4.58mm when tested by of 30cm diameter plate. After the application of correction for
modulus of sub grade reaction it is found that, there is an increase in K with the increase in
number of cycles, but the increase of K is considered as not more significant for black
cotton soil alone. There is an increase in modulus of elasticity E with the increase in number
of cycles. Similarly rate of increase of E is found to be more significant for black cotton
soil.
Table 5 Plate load test results of black cotton soil with RBI-81
LOAD in kg
AREA in cm2
PRESSURE in kg/cm2
SETTLEMENT in mm
706.85
0.00
250
706.85
0.35
0.34
500
706.85
0.71
0.88
750
706.85
1.06
1.34
1000
706.85
1.41
1.71
1250
706.85
1.77
2.07
1500
706.85
2.12
2.50
1750
706.85
2.48
2.98
2000
706.85
2.83
3.50
2250
706.85
3.18
4.05
2500
706.85
3.54
4.60
Fig 3 Load deformation curve for RBI 81 stabilised black cotton soil
K = Pressure / 0.125 = 1.05/0.125 = 8.40 kg/cm3
Modulus of subgrade reaction (K) = 8.40 kg/cm3
W r t, = 1.18 * p * a / E ,
K=p/ ,
or
82404 kN/m3
E = 1.18 * a * K
or
14585.50 kN/m2
From the Table 7 and Fig 3 it is found that the Modulus of subgrade reaction (K) and
Modulus of Elasticity (E) is found to be 82404 kN/m3 and 14585.5 kN/m2 for Black Cotton
soil stabilised with RBI-81.
Table 6 cyclic plate load test of Black cotton soil treated with RBI Grade-81
Cycles
Total deflection in mm
Plastic deflection in mm
Elastic deflection in mm
0.340
0.330
0.010
0.875
0.790
0.085
1.340
1.165
0.175
1.710
1.41
0.300
2.065
1.685
0.380
2.500
2.00
0.500
2.980
2.405
0.575
3.500
2.840
0.660
4.045
3.270
0.775
10
4.600
3.790
0.810
From Table 6. It is found that there is an increase in the elastic deformation with the increase
in number of cycle, but the rate of increase of elastic deformation is found to be more
predominant for RBI stabilized soil when compared to black cotton soil alone. From the
present investigation, At the 10th cycle the total deflection is 4.60mm when tested by of 30cm
diameter plate. After the application of correction for modulus of sub grade reaction it is
found that, there is an increase in K with the increase in number of cycles, but the increase
of K is found to be more significant for RBI stabilized soil. There is an increase in modulus
of elasticity E with the increase in number of cycles. Similarly rate of increase of E is
found to be more significant for RBI stabilized soil.
Table 7 plate load test for black cotton soil stabilised with PPF
LOAD in kg
AREA in cm^2
0
250
500
750
1000
1250
706.85
706.85
706.85
706.85
706.85
706.85
PRESSURE in
kg/cm^2
0.00
0.35
0.71
1.06
1.41
1.77
SETTLEMENT in
mm
0
0.19
0.34
0.52
0.75
0.88
1500
1750
2000
2250
2500
706.85
706.85
706.85
706.85
706.85
2.12
2.48
2.83
3.18
3.54
1.09
1.32
1.51
1.61
1.72
Fig 4 Load deformation curve for PPF stabilised black cotton soil
K = Pressure / 0.125 = 2.6/0.125 = 20.80 kg/cm3
Modulus of subgrade reaction (K) = 20.80 kg/cm3
w k t, = 1.18 * p * a / E ,
K=p/ ,
or
196980 kN/m3
E = 1.18 * a * K
or
34866.30 kN/m2
From the above table 7 and fig4 it is found that the Modulus of subgrade reaction (K) and
Modulus of elasticity is 196980 kN/m3 and 34866.3 kN/m2 for Black cotton soil stabilised
with PPF.
Table 8 cyclic plate load test for soil treated with Polypropylene fiber
Cycles
Total deflection in mm
Plastic deflection in mm
Elastic deflection in mm
0.190
0.110
0.080
0.335
0.215
0.120
0.520
0.340
0.180
0.750
0.310
0.440
0.880
0.375
0.505
1.085
0.505
0.580
1.210
0.585
0.625
1.320
0.660
0.660
1.510
0.700
0.810
10
1.610
0.775
0.835
From table 8 It is found that there is an increase in the elastic deformation with the increase in
number of cycle. But the rate of increase of elastic deformation is found to be more
predominant for PPF stabilized soil when compared to Black cotton soil alone. From the
present investigation, At the 10th cycle the total deflection is 1.61mm when tested by 30cm
diameter plate, After the application of correction for modulus of sub grade reaction it is
found that, there is an increase in K with the increase in number of cycles. But the increase
of K is found to be more significant for PPF stabilized soil. There is an increase in modulus
of elasticity E with the increase in number of cycles, similarly rate of increase of E is
found to be more significant for PPF stabilized soil.
Table 9 Plate load test results of black cotton soil stabilised with RBI and PPF:
LOAD in kg
AREA in cm^2
0
250
500
750
1000
706.85
706.85
706.85
706.85
706.85
PRESSURE in
kg/cm^2
0.00
0.35
0.71
1.06
1.41
SETTLEMENT in
mm
0
0.29
0.65
1.01
1.30
1250
1500
1750
2000
2250
2500
706.85
706.85
706.85
706.85
706.85
706.85
1.77
2.12
2.48
2.83
3.18
3.54
1.64
2.06
2.40
2.79
3.40
3.90
Fig 7 Load deformation curve of black cotton soil stabilised with RBI & PPF
K = Pressure / 0.125 = 1.35/0.125 = 10.80 kg/cm3
Modulus of subgrade reaction (K) = 10.80 kg/cm3
W r t, = 1.18 x p x a / E,
K = p / ,
or
105948 kN/m3
E = 1.18 x a x K
or
18752.79 kN/m2
From the Table 9 and Fig 7 it is found that the Modulus of subgrade reaction and modulus of
elasticity is 105948 kN/m3 and 18752.79 kN/m2 for BC soil stabilised with RBI and PPF.
Cycles
Total Deflection in mm
Plastic Deflection in mm
Elastic Deflection in mm
0.28
0.19
0.09
0.65
0.46
0.19
1.01
0.76
0.25
1.29
0.93
0.36
1.63
1.23
0.4
2.06
1.47
0.59
2.4
1.8
0.6
2.79
2.22
0.57
2.49
0.91
3.12
0.78
3.4
9
10
3.9
Table 10 Cyclic Plate load test for black cotton soil stabilized with RBI and PPF
It is found from table 10 that there is an increase in the elastic deformation with the increase
in number of cycle. But the rate of increase of elastic deformation is found to be more
predominant for soil stabilized with RBI and PPF when compared to black cotton soil alone.
From the present investigation, the total deflection after completing 10 th cycle is 3.90 mm.
After the application of correction for modulus of sub grade reaction it is found that, there is
an increase in K with the increase in number of cycles. But the increase of K is found to be
more significant for soil stabilized with RBI and PPF. It is found that, there is an increase in
modulus of elasticity E with the increase in number of cycles, similarly rate of increase of
E is found to be more soil stabilized with RBI and PPF.
Table 11 Plate load test results of black cotton soil stabilised with coirfiber:
LOAD in kg
AREA in cm2
0
250
500
750
1000
1250
1500
1750
2000
2250
2500
706.85
706.85
706.85
706.85
706.85
706.85
706.85
706.85
706.85
706.85
706.85
PRESSURE in
SETTLEMENT in
Kg/cm2
0.00
0.35
0.71
1.06
1.41
1.77
2.12
2.48
2.83
3.18
3.54
mm
0.00
0.26
0.65
1.05
1.40
2.01
3.30
4.16
5.25
6.37
6.67
Fig 8 Load deformation curve of black cotton soil stabilised with coir fiber
K = Pressure / 0.125 = 1.35/0.125 = 10.8 kg/cm3
Modulus of subgrade reaction (K) = 10.8 kg/cm3
W r t, = 1.18 x p x a / E,
kg/cm2
or
K = p / , E = 1.18 x a x K,
105948.00 kN/m3
E = 1.18 x 15 x 10.8 = 191.16
or
18752.796 kN/m2
The maximum density is 1.77 g/cc for BC soil treated with 0.3 % coir fiber. In case of black
cotton soil treated with 0.2 % and 0.3 % of coir fiber, it is found that the dry density increases
with increase in optimum moisture content. Further increase in percentage of coir fiber from
0.4 % to 0.5 %, there is decrease in dry density. This is due to addition of coir fiber results
increase in tendency of moisture attraction From Table 15 and fig 8 it is found that the
Modulus of subgrade reaction and modulus of elasticity is 105948 kN/m 3 and 18752.79
kN/m2 for BC soil stabilised with coir fiber.
Table 12 cyclic plate load test of Black cotton soil treated with Coir Fiber
Cycles
Cycles
1
2 1
3
Total deflection in mm
0.260
0.350
0.650
Plastic deflection in mm
Plastic deflection in mm
0.210
0.0400.525
Elastic deflection in mm
Elastic deflection in mm
0.050
0.310 0.125
1.050
0.210
1.400
0.410
2.015
0.695
3.300
4.165
0.980
0.3503.325
5.250
1.290
6.375
1.570
6.675
4.215
0.480
5.175
0.6305.165
1.830
0.775
1.055
2.065
0.845
1.220
10
2.180
0.905
1.275
4
5
8
9
2
3
10 7
It
Total deflection in mm
0.0650.690
0.860
0.130
1.480
0.2402.550
0.145
0.455
0.750
0.630
0.840
0.280
0.810
0.940
0.360
0.540
0.535
1.035
1.200
1.510
is
found from table 16 that there is an increase in the elastic deformation with the increase in
number of cycle. But the rate of increase of elastic deformation is found to be more
predominant for soil stabilized with coirfiber when compared to black cotton soil alone. From
the present investigation, the total deflection after completing 10 th cycle is 6.675 mm. After
the application of correction for modulus of sub grade reaction it is found that, there is an
increase in K with the increase in number of cycles. But the increase of K is found to be
more significant for soil stabilized with coir fiber. It is found that, there is an increase in
modulus of elasticity E with the increase in number of cycles, similarly rate of increase of
E is found to be more soil stabilized with coirfiber.
Table 13 cyclic plate load test of Black cotton soil treated with Ground Granulated blast furnace
slag (GGBS)
Effect of GGBS
From Table 13, K-value is increased from 3.914 kg/cm 3 to 6.72 kg/cm3 and E-value is increased
from 138.768 kg/cm2 to 297.36 kg/cm2 when 10 % of GGBS is added to black cotton soil. The
maximum density is 1.809 g/cc for black cotton soil treated with 25 % GGBS. In case of black
cotton soil treated with 5.0 % to 25.0 % of GGBS, the dry density increases with gradual
decrease in optimum moisture content. This is due to increase in amount of GGBS requires
lesser optimum moisture content to obtain higher dry density. Higher amount of GGBS
decreases the repulsive pressure of soil particles, reducing the resistance to compactive effort
resulting in higher densities.
Table 13 K-Values and E-values for Black Cotton soil treated with various stabilizers
Particulars
K-Value in Kg/Cm3
for 30cm dia plate
E-Value in
Kg/cm2
7.840
3.136
138.768
9.920
3.968
175.584
20.800
8.320
368.160
BC soil + RBI
8.000
3.200
141.600
BC soil + GGBS
16.800
6.720
297.360
Fig13
Fibers such as Coir and Polypropylene when used in BC soil improve strength and
prevent brittle failure.
Addition of stabilizers such as cement RBI Grade-81, and GGBS to the BC soil
reduces the liquid limit and plasticity index of soil.
When cement, RBI Grade-81 and GGBS are used in the BC soil improves the
unconfined compressive strength of the specimens increases as the content of these
stabilizers increases. Adding of these stabilizers to the BC soil reduces the liquid limit
and increases plastic limit of soil.
Even though the cost of RBI Grade-81 stabilizer is more when compared to other
conventional stabilizers such as Cement, Fly ash and GGBS it gives more strength to
the pavement thereby decreasing pavement thickness.
Thickness required for pavement with stabilized soil subgrade is much lesser than un-
The physical properties test on Black Cotton Soil has shown that Liquid Limit is
45.70 and Plastic Limit of Soil is 22.14. Hence the soil used for the investigation can
0.882 Kg/cm2.
From present investigations it is observed that, the K-value is 8 Kg/cm 3 and E-value is
138.768 Kg/cm2 in case of BC Soil alone.
Coir Fibers
It is observed that addition of coir fiber from 0.2 % to 0.5 % (at an increment of 0.1%)
results in the reduction of liquid limit from 45.70 to 39.96 and also the increase in
percentage of plastic limit from 22.14 to 26.89. Liquid limit decreases with increase in
percentage of coir fiber indicates minimum water content is required for soil to flow
under application of lower shearing force. In case of plastic limit, moisture necessary
for soil to remain in plastic state increases with increase in percentage of coir fiber.
The maximum density is 1.77 g/cc for BC soil treated with 0.3 % coir fiber. In case of
black cotton soil treated with 0.2 % and 0.3 % of coir fiber, it is found that the dry
density increases with increase in optimum moisture content. Further increase in
percentage of coir fiber from 0.4 % to 0.5 %, there is decrease in dry density. This is
alone.
Unconfined compressive strength is 11.808 kg/cm2 for 28 days cured specimen, when
BC soil is treated with 0.5 % coir fiber. It is observed that addition of 0.5 % coir fiber
shows significant increase in the unconfined compressive strength with 28 days curing
period. Addition of coir fiber denotes an increase in reinforcement action with increase
in curing period.
The K-value is increased from 3.914 kg/cm3 to 3.968 kg/cm3 and E-value is increased
from 138.768 kg/cm2 to 175.584 kg/cm2 when 0.5 % of coir fiber is added to black
cotton soil.
Polypropylene Fibers
polypropylene fiber.
Maximum density is 1.848 g/cc for black cotton soil treated with 0.5 % of
polypropylene fiber. In case of black cotton soil treated with 1.0 % to 2.0 % of
polypropylene fiber, it is found that dry density decreases with increase in optimum
moisture content.
The CBR value is increased from 3.73 % to 5.13 % when 2.0 % of polypropylene fiber
is added to black cotton soil. Increase in strength is due to the reinforcement
phenomenon which is similar to coir fiber stabilization. The CBR value increased by
RBI Grade 81
From Table 4.8, it is observed that the addition of RBI Grade-81 from 2.0 % to 8.0 %
(at an increment of 2.0%) results in the reduction of liquid limit from 44.60 to 38.90 and
plastic limit from 23.90 to 26.66. Liquid limit decreases with the increase in percentage
of RBI Grade-81. This is due to presence of cementitious particle in RBI-Grade-81
resulting in reduction of moisture movement. Also plasticity index decreases rapidly
the addition of GGBS from 5.0 % to 25.0 % (at an increment of 5.0%) results in the
reduction of liquid limit from 42.35 to 35.30 and plastic limit from 29.16 to 23.21.
Increase in addition of GGBS results in decrease of liquid limit due to the effect of
dilution. Plastic limit also decreases due to the finer particles of GGBS get filled into
the voids of soil and resulting in lower water content to remain in plastic state.
The maximum density is 1.809 g/cc for black cotton soil treated with 25 % GGBS. In case of
black cotton soil treated with 5.0 % to 25.0 % of GGBS, the dry density increases with gradual
decrease in optimum moisture content. This is due to increase in amount of GGBS requires
lesser optimum moisture content to obtain higher dry density. Higher amount of GGBS
decreases the repulsive pressure of soil particles, reducing the resistance to compactive effort
resulting in higher densities.
The CBR value is increased from 3.73 % to 9.01% when 25 % of GGBS is added to black
cotton soil. Increase in CBR of soil is due to cementatious action by pozzolanic compounds
present in GGBS. The CBR value is increased by 2.41 times when compared to black cotton
soil alone.
Unconfined compressive strength is 9.877 kg/cm2 for 28 days cured specimen, when black
cotton soil is treated with 10 % GGBS. The 28 day curing period shows higher strength which
means that the unconfined compressive strength increases with higher curing periods. The
variation in strength is due to variation in cohesion of the soil with increasing addition of
GGBS.
From Table 4.13, K-value is increased from 3.914 kg/cm 3 to 6.72 kg/cm3 and E-value is
increased from 138.768 kg/cm2 to 297.36 kg/cm2 when 10 % of GGBS is added to black cotton
soil.
Conclusions
Fibers such as Coir and Polypropylene when used in BC soil improve strength and prevent
brittle failure.
Addition of stabilizers such as cement, RBI Grade-81, Fly ash and GGBS to the BC soil
reduces the liquid limit and plasticity index of soil.
When cement, RBI Grade-81, Fly ash and GGBS are used in the BC soil improves the
unconfined compressive strength of the specimens increases as the content of these
stabilizers increases. Adding of these stabilizers to the BC soil reduces the liquid limit
and increases plastic limit of soil.
Even though the cost of RBI Grade-81 stabilizer is more when compared to other
conventional stabilizers such as Cement, Fly ash and GGBS it gives more strength to the
pavement thereby decreasing pavement thickness.
Thickness required for pavement with stabilized soil subgrade is much lesser than un-