Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Outlook
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
SF6-ReUse-Concept
A contribution on the
sustainability of SF6
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Greenhouse Effect
Reduction
Increase
of greenhouse gases
6 major greenhouse
gasses included
3 Energy/ human
related CO2, CH4 and
N2O
3 Industrial related
HFCs, PFCs and SF6
empowered 2005-02
after 55 states incl.
Russia signed the
document
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
27 000 tons
2 000 tons / y
1 200 tons / y
5)
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
CO2
26
60%
16
40%
0.07
~40
0.16%
100%
FC and SF6
Total emissions
"Electrical" SF6
2200
0.05
0.1%
1000
0.02
0.05%
- 33%
appr. 55,000
tons
Use/Applications of SF6
Accelarator
Semi-conductor industry
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
AWACS Aircraft
04.07.2007
04.07.2007
04.07.2007
04.07.2007
Consequences EC:
Open SF6-Applications are prohibited and/or replaced!
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Losses during
SF6-Handling
Recommendation
acc. to Cigr:
SF6-Handling-Guide
Leakage
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Greenhouse Gas
Emissions
Source: EEA
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Target Path
2010
Source:
-EEA, 2004
-Ecofys 2005
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Kyoto Protocol
SF6 as a Greenhouse Gas
Over a 100-year period, SF6 is 23,900 times more
effective at trapping infrared radiation than an
equivalent amount of carbon dioxide
With an atmospheric lifetime of 800 - 3,200 years, SF6
is also a very stable chemical
Present contribution to global warming is 0.1% (and
estimated at 0.01% in 100 years)
Atmospheric concentration increasing 7-9% per year
(space shuttle measurements) between 1985-94,
showed that this was the largest increase of any
greenhouse or ozone gas
Now development slowed down
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
16000
14000
500
12000
400
10000
300
8000
6000
Emission
Reduction
200
4000
100
2000
0
1990
1995
2000
Year
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
2005
2010
600
Photo Excitation
Electron raised to higher energy state, they returns to
ground state, emitting a photon
Relaxation time
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
He+
He
Ions Vs Electrons
Mass of an electron vs. mass of SF6 1 to 125,000
(1500 lbs vs 95,000 tons)
vs.
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Free Electrons in a
Non-homogeneous Gap
Free electrons repelled
from negative rod
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
E
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
+
+
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
E critical
E
kV/m
Distance
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
SF6 Features
Quenching Capacity of SF6
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
SF6 Features
50 Hz breakdown voltage in
a hogeneous field as a
function of the distance
between electrodes at
various gas pressures (ETZ
Supplement 3 [1966])
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
SF6 Replacement
Gas
GasMixtures
Mixtures
First
Firstused
usedin
inCBs
CBsfor
forlow
lowtemperature
temperatureapplications
applications
Gas
Gasmixtures
mixturesnow
nowbeing
beingused
usedon
onGIL
GILapplications
applications
10%
10%or
or20%
20%SF
SF66with
withNitrogen
Nitrogenisistypical
typicalsolution
solution
Switching
Switchingperformance
performancestill
stilllimited
limited
Special
Specialgas
gashandling
handlingfacilities
facilitiesrequired
required
For
Formost
mostapplications
applicationsmixtures
mixturesare
arenot
notattractive
attractivefor
for
GIS
GIS
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
SF6 Replacements
Relationship between GWP and dielectric strength of
various Gases
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Principle
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
N2
100 % SF6
0,5 MPa
400 mm
20 % SF6 / 80 % N2
0,7 MPa
400 mm
?
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
100 % N2
2,0 MPa
400 mm
20 % SF6 /
80 % N2
0,5 MPa
560 mm
100 % N2
0,5 MPa
1600 mm
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Targets on
emission rates of
SF6 for
switchgear
systems and
switching
devices:
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Air
CF4
H 2O
Mineral oil
Acidity, in terms of
HF
Hydrolyzable
fluorides terms of HF
Important: As soon as the gas is taken from the cylinder in which it has been delivered
in, it is considered to be used gas!
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
High voltage
- 36 C dew point
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
EU-Regulations
EG directive on Fluor gases 842/2006
Valid for: Fluorinated greenhouse gases
- Fluorcarbon = HFC
(quenching agents, cooling agents)
- Fluorcarbon PFC
- SF6-gas
Aims:
Limitation and reduction of emissions for
fluorinated greenhouse gases, gradual abandoning of
R134a cooling agent for air-conditioned cars
Purview: EU (25 countries) + Norway, Switzerland and Iceland
Effective as of: 14th June 2006, directly valid after publication in
all member countries , no incorporation into national
legislation required
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
EU-Regulations
Most important articles/content, applicable for high-voltage
switchgear >1kV
Article
no.
3
4
5
Containment
Recovery
Training and Certification
6
7
8
9
10
11
13
Reporting
Labelling
Control of use
Placing on the market
Review
Promotion of alternatives
Penalties
EC Article 95
(Internal EC market)
Minimum
requirements
EC Article 175
(Minimum requirements
in EC regulation. National
implementation in
member states of EC)
EU-Regulations
EG directive on Fluor gases 842/2006
Art. 4) The gas must be reused and recycled in accordance with the corresponding
regulations during gas recovery. The gas handling must be carried out from
qualified personnel
Art. 5) Any gas work on devices or plants as well as reclaiming and treatment
of gas is to be carried out by trained and authorized personnel only.
Art. 6) Companies producing, importing / exporting more than 1 ton of
greenhouse gases per year must give a report to the EU commission.
Art. 7) On high voltage switchgear (> 1 kV) the utilization of the greenhouse gas
used must be indicated.
EU-Regulations
Labelling of SF6-filled Equipment inside the manual
- Specification in VO Nr 842/2006, Article 7 (1):
Die mitgelieferten Bedienungsanleitungen enthalten
Informationen ber die fluorierten Treibhausgase, einschlielich
ihres Treibhauspotenzials.
- Recommandation in implementation guide of T&D Europe
for the Text inside the manual:
EN
This equipment contains the fluorinated greenhouse gas SF6 covered by the Kyoto Protocol
and with a global warming potential (GWP) 22 200. SF6 shall be recovered and not released
into the atmosphere.
For further information on use and handling of SF6 please refer to IEC 62271-303: Highvoltage switchgear and controlgear Part 303 Use and handling of sulphur hexafluoride (SF6).
DE
Das Betriebsmittel enthlt das vom Kyoto-Protokoll erfasste fluorierte Treibhausgas SF6 mit
einem Treibhauspotenzial (GWP) 22 200. SF6 muss zurckgewonnen werden und darf nicht in
die Atmosphre entlassen werden. Bei dem Umgang und der Handhabung mit SF6 ist IEC
62271-303: High-voltage switchgear and controlgear Part 303 Use and handling of sulphur
hexafluoride (SF6) zu beachten.
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
EU-Regulations
Labelling art. 7 acc. 1494/2007
Contents of the EU directive on F-gas
- Labelling, article 7 -
On the one hand, reference to the use of SF6 and its environmental influence is
currently made in the documents for switchgear
Contents of
Manual
EU-Regulations
Labelling art. 7 acc. 1494/2007
Contents of the EU directive on F-gas
- Labelling, article 7 and on the other hand directly on the GIS operating panel.
Contents of
Operating Panel
Name plate
(with Closed pressure system note and
information on SF6 quantity)
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
EU-Regulations
Article 5 Training and Certification
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
EU-Regulations
f Additional Commission Regulation (EC) No 305/2008
Requirements in detail:
ANNEX
Minimum requirements as to the skills and knowledge to be covered by
the evaluation bodies
Test Type
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
EU-Regulations
f Additional Commission Regulation (EC) No 305/2008
Requirements in detail:
ANNEX
Minimum requirements as to the skills and knowledge to be covered by
the evaluation bodies
No.
Test Type
10
11
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
EU-Regulations
f Additional Commission Regulation (EC) No. 305/2008
Requirements in detail:
ANNEX
Minimum requirements as to the skills and knowledge to be covered by
the evaluation bodies
No.
12
13
14
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Test Type
EU-Regulations
f Additional Commission Regulation (EC) No305/2008
EU-Regulations
Article 6 Reporting
Additional regulation
no. 1493/2007
Article 6 of the regulation
no. 842/2006 stipulates
that producers, importers
and exporters of
fluorinated greenhouse
gases will have to submit
annual reports on certain
activities, starting as from
2008 (for 2007).
The following form is to be
filled in by producers
who produce, import or
export more than one
tonne of fluorinated
greenhouse gases per
year.
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
SF6-filled Equipment
GIT
AIS
GIS
MTS
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Characteristics of SF6-filled
Equipment
1.
2.
3.
4.
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Strea
m
Parti er Deve
al Di
l
scha opment?
rges
?
ischa
rges
Sing
le Pa
rtial D
Putti
ng in
to
oper
ation
Frequency
FaultFault
Frequency
FORECAST
Exchange
Maintenance
Repair
0
Week
Commissioning
Month
10 Years
Year
Years
20 Years 10 30
Years
Time of Operation
Years
Time of Operation
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Others
12.3%
Gas Leak
12.4%
Mechanism
Trouble
18.1%
Insulation
Failure
57.3%
SOURCES OF IMPURITIES
POSSIBLE IMPURITIES
DURING HANDLING
AND IN SERVICE
INSULATING
FUNCTION ONLY
IN SWITCHING
EQUIPMENT
Mechanical erosion
INTERNAL ARC
SF6-filled Chamber
(Institute of High Voltage and Electrical Equipment, Dortmund)
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Experimental Setup
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Flushover at aged
epoxy resin sample
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
SF6-Decomposition Scheme
possible surface
reactions:
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
3%
Decomposition
Products
Moisture
> -5C td
Maximum tolerable
impurity level in
equipment
Recycling Guide: 23.10 Task Force, Page 20
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Literature: Guide for the preparation of customised Practical SF6 Handling Instructions, CIGRE Task Force B3.02.01, August 2005, page 18
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Moisture 40 Ln/h
Decomposition
Products > 1 Ln/h
Disadvantages single Devices:
Very time- and SF6-consumption high !
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Temperature/Density Distribution of
SF6 in GIS
Solar radition
Ambient temp.
Load current
CFD
Thermal
Network
Pmodeled
Pfiltered
Leakage
Alternative: Measurement of
Temperature Distribution
Pmeasured
SF6
GIS or Circuit-Breaker with monitoring
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Electro-chemical Sensor
SO2/SOF2
Main Advantages
of the SF6-Breaker-Analyser
SF6-Breaker-Analyser fulfils maintenance staff requests !
One gas connection
Easy one-click operation
No consumables
Storage of 150 measurements
on memory
Battery operated (max. 8 hours)
Internal mass flow control
Modular System (operation
with 1,2, or 3 sensors)
Measurement within max. 7 min
Total gas consumption 0.4 Ln/min
and 2.8 Ln per measurement
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
New gas
Electrical
apparatus
good
Incineration
Solvay, GERMANY
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Oil
Normal Case
Producer
SOLVAY
Special Case
Producer
SOLVAY
Exceptional Case
Principle
Comparison of Solvay and IEC 376 product specification for new SF6,
analysis of liquid phase
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Solvay, GERMANY
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Alternativ
with GIS
AIS Technology
GIS Technology
four substations on outskirts Three substations in the city
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
- 21%
- 19%
- 27%
- 29%
- 86%
Primary
Energy
Space
Consumption
Global
Warming
Potential
Acid Rain
Potential
Nutrification
Potential
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Reduction Potential
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Mobile
Mobile
gascart
gascart
for
forcollecting
collectingof
of
used
usedgas
gas
DILO, Germany
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Testing
Pressure and Gas Tightness
Routine Test with Helium
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
transportable
transportable
SF6
SF6maintenance
maintenance
cart
cart
DILO, Germany
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
portable SF6
Service - Units
DILO, Germany
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
DILO, Germany
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Cleaning Station
( SF6 decomposition products )
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
50
mbar
evacuation-pressure (mbar)
Impurity in
used SF6
(LOD)
Limit of detection
in ppm by weight
(precision
+ / - 3 % rel.)
Oxygen (O2)
1
Nitrogen (N2)
1
Carbon Dioxid
(CO2)
1
Tetra Fluoro Methan
(CF4)
1
Thionyl Fluoride(SOF2)
1
Sulphuryl Fluoride
(SO2F2)
1
Fluorinated Hydrocarbons,
e.g. Oxifluorides
10
User Agreements
Generally recognized, that there are no suitable
alternatives for SF6 in the short or medium term
No plans foreseen to legislate phase-out of SF6
Government bodies and agencies have implemented
a number of voluntary programs aimed at reducing
SF6 emissions
-
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Europe - CIGRE
USA - EPA
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant
Conclusion
Wolfgang Degen
Senior Technical Consultant