You are on page 1of 8

Newsletter Issue 1 at CRU’s 9th World Copper Conference, produced by Thomson Reuters

Compiled on Monday, April 5, 2010

Contact: metals@thomsonreuters.com

TABLE OF CONTENTS The following is a column from the CRU Group ahead of the 9th
annual CESCO/CRU copper conference in Chile. The views
WANTED: 11.3MT COPPER, NO REASONABLE OFFER expressed are those of CRU.
REFUSED WANTED: 11.3MT COPPER, NO REASONABLE OFFER
CRU FORECASTS A STRONG MEDIUM-TERM REFUSED
OUTLOOK FOR COPPER The harbingers of doom have been proven wrong, at least
temporarily, as the copper market has surprised all but its most
COST INCREASES RAISING THE ‘FUNDAMENTAL fervent supporters in the strength and rapidity of its price recovery
FLOOR’ during 2009.
Twelve months ago the world was staring into an abyss,
SULPHURIC ACID, A DRAMATIC TURNAROUND, BUT
consumption looked dreadful, prices had fallen off a cliff, risk capital
IS IT SUSTAINABLE? for investment purposes was non-existent and the decoupling theory
was being dismissed as the stuff of nonsense.
LONG-TERM OUTLOOK, INVESTORS REQUIRED TO
FILL SUPPLY GAP Today the world is a different place. Consumption may still be weak
(particularly in North America and Europe) and uncertainty may still
MAJORS NEED TO DEVELOP MORE OF THEIR surround the strength and sustainability of growth across the world.
PROSPECTS What is apparent, though, is that in developing economies, such as
China and India, the question has not been “When will we recover
AN ASIA-CENTRIC FUTURE AWAITS THE COPPER from this recession?” but rather “Recession, what recession?”
INDUSTRY This combination of anticipation for the future and lingering concern
for the here and now creates a perfect backdrop for the market as
METALS INSIDER-DANCING IN DR COPPER'S BLIND CESCO Week and the 9th CRU World Copper Conference begin in
SPOT Santiago.
CRU/CESCO-AS COPPER NEARS RECORD PEAK, ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
EXECS TO ASK 'HOW HIGH'
CRU FORECASTS A STRONG MEDIUM-TERM OUTLOOK
CRU/CESCO-MINER ANTOFAGASTA SETS PACE FOR COPPER
WITH BIG SPENDING PLAN Copper prices are currently trading well above $7,000/tonne. CRU
expects LME prices to remain at or about these levels for the next 4-
CRU/CESCO-CHILE SET TO RAISE 2010 COPPER 5 years. There are five factors driving our strong medium term
VIEW TO $3.30/LB outlook.

POLL-ROBUST DEMAND TO PUSH COPPER INTO • Chinese demand growth continues to drive our forecast, with
DEFICIT IN 2010 copper consumption growth now broad-based and domestically
generated. This will equate to a 3Mt increase in Chinese refined
CODELCO SEES SHORT-TERM COPPER VOLATILITY copper consumption by 2014. However, continued high copper
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- prices and constrained supply will result in substitution or
rationing in low-value-added (non-electrical) applications.

• Prices will be supported in the short term by a lag in scrap


supply, as industrial production and construction activity in
developed markets remain well below pre-crisis levels. Further
support will be apparent from the limited primary supply
response in 2010. Furthermore, we believe investors will
support prices unless the economic picture turns decidedly
worse.
REUTERS COVERAGE ON CRU’S 9TH WORLD COPPER CONFERENCE 05 APRIL 2010

• In the medium term, we see a balanced market moving towards SULPHURIC ACID, A DRAMATIC TURNAROUND, BUT IS IT
deficit, driven by continued and sustainable consumption SUSTAINABLE?
growth. This will be met by a supply-side push in 2011-2013 2009 was an extremely difficult year for producers of sulphuric
driven by strong cash-flow and a return of risk appetite. acid. Many were forced to cut production or even close down
temporarily during 2009 owing to weak demand from key acid-
• The economic downturn means the near-term mine project consuming industries such as phosphate fertilizers, the industrial
pipeline is insufficient to meet demand growth by 2014. The sector and copper leaching. This situation significantly impacted
majors control many of the best projects but also have other base metal smelters (who make up almost 30% of the sulphuric
acid supply market), as in their case sulphuric acid is essentially a
demands on their limited capital in markets such as Iron Ore
by-product of their main business – the business of copper, zinc,
and Potash. lead or nickel smelting. High inventory levels impacted their ability
to produce these metals and, in desperation, many were forced to
• Over our forecast period the world of copper will change to an supply sulphuric acid at negative FOB prices in order to maintain
Asia-centric world. China will become self-sufficient in semis operating rates.
production, putting pressure on semis exporters elsewhere, The market underwent a dramatic turnaround in the first quarter of
while the rest of Asia and the Middle East will see solid 2010 as rising demand from the industrial sector, the phosphate
consumption growth. The Chinese smelting industry will look to fertilizer industry and copper leaching operations vastly improved
supply as much of the copper required by its domestic semis the logistical position of sulphuric acid producers.
industry as it can. The resulting growth in Chinese smelting Negative netback prices for exports disappeared at the beginning
capacity will keep TC/RCs from rising much, putting financial of January as smelters In North West Europe reduced their acid
pressure on other smelters that may lead to closures. inventories to manageable levels and resumed production at full
capacity.
Crucially, Crucially, though, CRU does not believe that current prices However, the improvement in acid’s fortunes appears to have
are sustainable beyond the medium term. If the forecast is correct, come as much from supply side issues as it has from demand
CRU calculates nine uninterrupted years of LME prices above the improvements. The majority of sulphuric acid supplied to the
industry Long Run Marginal Cost (LRMC). This will attract market comes from suppliers who burn elemental sulphur to
investment into the copper market, increasing mine supply. produce material either for in-house consumption, or for resale.
Over the long term CRU expects prices to revert to lower levels Sulphur in itself arises as a by-product of oil and gas production,
although price volatility will remain. However, CRU does not expect and the ongoing economic crisis in developed economies such as
the price or cost of copper to revert to the levels witnessed in the the US and North West Europe, combined with a change in
early part of this century. feedstock as well as logistical difficulties in some of the main
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- exporting regions, led to a rapid increase in sulphur prices. This
benefited base metal smelters by making their output more
COST INCREASES RAISING THE ‘FUNDAMENTAL FLOOR’ competitive against that of voluntary production.
Consumables, power, labour and fuel costs to rebound in 2010 However, in the case of copper smelters, lack of raw materials in
the form of copper concentrate has further limited acid production.
The chart, below, created from CRU’s proprietary Copper Mine Cost The effects of this have been felt by Japanese smelters in
Model, clearly shows that inflationary pressure has returned at particular, leaving domestic smelters to make up the difference in
existing mine operations following the decline in 2009. This supports the Chinese market. As a result, prices in Asia have also risen,
our long-term copper view and will arguably lift floor prices in a and Chinese smelters have ceased their calls for anti-dumping
‘normal’ copper market. regulations on acid imports, a threat which concerned many
Average business costs are forecast to increase by 20% from the market observers throughout 2009.
2009 recent low to reach over $3,000/mt by 2013. These increases Global sulphuric acid prices increased steadily through January
will be driven in particular by increases in consumables and labour and February, approaching $100/mt CFR in Brazil and the US Gulf
costs. and passing this level in Chile. In the second half of March
phosphate fertilizer prices began to weaken, undermining
sentiment in the sulphur and sulphuric acid markets. It is too early
Inflationary pressures return in 2010 to say whether the price boom has come to an end, but market
after a short respite activity is very thin and there are growing indications that further
3500 increases may not be sustainable. In the case of sulphuric acid,
Realisation Costs the dominance in the Chilean market of copper-related acid
3000 demand (for SX-EW leaching) has allowed prices to reach $150/mt
Average global mining costs US$/tonne

Working Capital

2500 CFR, but quantities are small and business is limited.


Sustaining Capital

2000 Maintenance
Looking ahead, supply for both sulphur and sulphuric acid is
forecast to remain tight, meaning that a sudden drop in prices is
Consumables
1500 unlikely for the next few months. However, the peak application
1000
Fuel
season for phosphate fertilizers is almost over, and stocks of
Power sulphur and sulphuric acid are expected to gradually increase over
500 Labour
the summer. For this reason, the second half of the year will
0 Sustaining Capital
probably see prices coming down for both products.
2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2014 2018
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Data: CRU Copper Mine Costs Model © 2010 CRU International Limited confidential
REUTERS COVERAGE ON CRU’S 9TH WORLD COPPER CONFERENCE 05 APRIL 2010

LONG-TERM OUTLOOK, INVESTORS REQUIRED TO FILL Majors are now bearing the brunt of both exploration and mine
SUPPLY GAP development. Juniors either went out of business or stopped
spending to weather the recession. Our data suggests that 55% of
Consumption: China the major driving force the production from 82 of the best copper projects in our database is
As the chart below demonstrates, CRU believes that World refined owned by only six major mining companies.
copper consumption will double from 2010 levels to reach 37.0Mt in Non-ferrous exploration expenditure needs to recover from the global
2035, with growth averaging 2.9% per year. This is comparable to recession-induced 42% fall to US$7.3 billion in 2009. To meet our
the average 2.7% rate in the 1960-2010 period. Demand growth will demand projections, exploration expenditure and mine investment
be less than both forecast World GDP (3.2%) and IP (3.5%) as will have to be undertaken in both historically stable countries like
copper’s high cost relative to competing materials prompts continued Chile and in regions and countries with a real and perceived higher
marginal substitution (or rationing) away from copper, particularly risk profile, such as DR Congo, Pakistan and Mongolia.
towards aluminium.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
China will continue to dominate world copper demand, accounting for
over 54% of consumption in 2035, compared to 38% today. AN ASIA-CENTRIC FUTURE AWAITS THE COPPER
Meanwhile, India will record the strongest growth rate during our INDUSTRY
forecast period, more than doubling its share of global copper
consumption to 8.3% in 2035 due to urbanisation and rising wealth. The last twelve months have served to solidify China’s position as
the major consumer of copper and have turned the metal into a truly
global commodity. Its logistics chain is global, mining is operated by
Refined consumption outlook: multi-national giants and much of the consumption growth will be
China will be the major driver of growth Asia-centric. This means mismatches will occur again between long-
term supply investment decisions, short-term consumer needs and
2035 North America government policies. Other factors to keep under observation
2030
EU-EEA include influences from the energy and currency markets, adding
Japan volatility and non fundamental factors, often driven by the relative
2025 Oceania performance of the copper market rather than the actual performance
Rest of Europe
and CIS
of the market itself.
2020 South & East Asia

Latin America
2015 Africa/Middle East The CRU Group is uniquely positioned to help the metals industry to
2010
India maximise value in volatile times. Our dedicated analysts in Beijing,
China London, Pittsburgh and Santiago produce a portfolio of world class
2005 products to service managers with the data and market opinions they
need; our consultancy team (CRU Strategies) provides client-specific
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 services, based on experience and insight gained since the 1960’s.
Refined Consumption (million tonnes)
© 2010 CRU International Limited confidential If you would like to speak to a member of CRU’s team please
contact:
Non Ferrous Metals
MAJORS NEED TO DEVELOP MORE OF THEIR PROSPECTS Paul Robinson, paul.robinson@crugroup.com;
In 2035 we forecast a supply gap of 11.3Mt based upon today’s Tel +44 20 7903 2221
known project developments. Put another way, we envisage that at Business Development
least seven new Escondidas (or 57 x 200,000t/y projects) will need to
Marcio Goto, marcio.goto@crugroup.com; Tel +55 11 5051 8124
be developed. As CRU can only identify the first two or three
Escondidas from known projects in our “prospect” category, we Copper
would urge the industry to accept any reasonable offers to bridge this Eleni Joannides, eleni.joannides@crugroup.com;
gap. Tel +44 20 7903 2203
Sulphur and Sulphuric Acid
The 10-year wait - a wave of new entrants Joanne Peacock, Joanne.peacock@crugroup.com;
finally due to start production Tel +44 20 7903 2121
CRU Strategies
After Escondida, insufficient influx of Major new entrants
new supply into the copper market, Juan Esteban Fuentes, juan.fuentes@crugroup.com;
from relatively “new”
locations: Mongolia, Tel +56 2 231 3900
1200 Pakistan, Alaska
10 years of
inactivity Or visit us at www.crugroup.com
1000
Production (‘000 t contained Cu)

800

600
Collahuasi ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Escondida
400

200 Los Pelambres

0
1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020
Start-up Year

Note: the size of the bubbles is proportional to the resource size in contained Cu at start-up

© 2010 CRU International Limited confidential


REUTERS COVERAGE ON CRU’S 9TH WORLD COPPER CONFERENCE 05 APRIL 2010

METALS INSIDER-DANCING IN DR COPPER'S BLIND SPOT Chinese production, the other component of domestic market supply,
grew by 14.7 percent last year to 4.252 million tonnes.
- Andy Home is a Reuters columnist. The opinions expressed are his
own. For more Metals Insider columns, top Reuters metals stories Inevitably then, the ICSG's apparent consumption calculation for
and third party content, please visit the free Base Metals Community China rocketed. It was up 38 percent year-on-year, completely
website at (www.metalsinsider.com) -- offsetting a 16-percent decline in consumption in the rest of the
world.
By Andy Home
Except that Chinese real consumption couldn't possibly have
LONDON, April 1 (Reuters) - "Dr Copper" is so named because of expanded at that pace. For what it's worth, the official figure for
the red metal's reputed ability to act as a lightning rod for the world's
products output growth was "only" 19 percent.
manufacturing sector, a quality that has accorded it an honorary
degree in economics. The obvious conclusion is that there was a statistically significant
build in non-exchange stocks, but how big a build is the subject of
However, those who know him best know that "Dr Copper" has a
renewed heated argument between bulls and bears.
blind spot. Actually he has several but there is one that is so large
that it prevents any consensus as to the market's fundamental The ICSG itself has unwittingly fuelled that argument in the form of
dynamics at any one time, copper's very own Uncertainty Principle. It an invitation to analysts to discuss the topic of "unreported stocks" at
is the statistical black hole that exists at the very heart of the copper its late-April meeting in Lisbon.
market, namely China. That black hole got a whole lot bigger last
Bears have seized upon the invitation as proof that the ICSG knows
year, which is why bulls and bears have rejoined battle over whether
its figures are "wrong." That's an incorrect assumption.
this market is in deficit or in surplus and over whether China is sitting
on huge surplus stocks or hungry for more. The ICSG invites outside parties to present papers on copper market
themes at all of its meetings. It's just that the theme this year will be
BLACK HOLE
that of unreported stocks and that the invitation email, by the group's
Analysts have three key sources of data for what is happening, own admission, was inadvertently sent to a wider-than-intended
copper-wise, in China. distribution list.
The first are the country's refined copper production figures released The ICSG is not going to change its methodology. It will continue to
each month by the National Bureau of Statistics. The second are the use the only reliable data that are available to calculate "apparent
import/export figures released each month by the country's customs consumption." Others will continue to be welcome to use that data to
department. The third are the warehouse stocks figures reported by "guesstimate" Chinese consumption and/or internal stocks build.
the Shanghai Futures Exchange.
What no one knows is the true level of the country's consumption or
the level of stocks cumulatively held by the government's State
Reserves Bureau (SRB), industrial entities and speculative players.
Monthly figures for output of copper products are used by some as a
proxy for consumption but there are serious doubts as to whether
they can capture anything other than the largest semi-fabricators.
Nor do they provide any clue as to the mix of refined metal and scrap
going into individual product lines.
Thus, the International Copper Study Group (ICSG), the foremost
collector of copper market statistics, uses the three sets of
(moderately) reliable data to calculate what it calls "apparent
consumption." The formula runs as follows: production plus net
imports plus/minus changes in Shanghai exchange stocks.
It is not alone in using this methodology. The same statistical black
hole exists in other metals. The problem for copper is that China is by SHADOW DANCE
some margin the world's largest consumer of the red metal and,
because the country suffers from a structural domestic shortfall, the Which brings us back to where we started. Everyone has their own
biggest single buyer of copper in the international market. "guesstimate" as to how much stocks build took place in China last
year.
EXPANDING DARKNESS
Long-standing bears posit a number in excess of one million tonnes.
Actually, 1.8 million tonnes seems to be the latest extrapolation
derived from local producer Jiangxi Copper's estimate of Chinese
consumption at its press conference on Wednesday.
Others, such as Macquarie Bank, which has an extensive "on-the-
ground" research presence, suggest a much lower figure of around
700,000 tonnes. There is a single shaft of light, albeit a very weak
one, in terms of assessing Chinese stocks build. The State Reserves
Bureau said in June last year that it had bought 235,000 tonnes.
It also said it had halted purchases but that was eight months ago
and it's a moot point as to whether it has since resumed.
Macquarie has factored that and a 77,500-tonne build in Shanghai
exchange stocks into its calculation. The balance 400,000 tonnes it
splits between commercial stocks build (actually re-stocking) and
"speculative" stocks build, a label that can include anything from the
world's largest physical traders to the smallest Chinese speculators
At 3.112 million tonnes net imports were a record high and more than using government loans to play the metals market.
double the 1.360 million tonnes imported in 2008.
REUTERS COVERAGE ON CRU’S 9TH WORLD COPPER CONFERENCE 05 APRIL 2010

DR COPPER MAY BE BLIND BUT IS HE WRONG? Inside the dark, humid tunnels that extend for nearly 2,400 Km (1,490
miles) into the bowels of the Andes mountains in central Chile,
This bear-bull dance in "Dr Copper's" blind spot is not going to stop
miners are digging deeper to tap fresh resources as copper prices
any time soon, or at least not until a Chinese entity with sufficient
race to within sight of 2008's record highs, leading the post-crisis
credibility provides the missing data.
recovery in commodity prices.
But does any of it really matter? Is this the modern-day equivalent of
But with high-quality ores harder to produce and some new projects
medieval theologians arguing about how many angels could stand on
hindered by politics, executives gathering at next week's annual
the head of a pin?
CRU/CESCO conference have yet to commit to a fresh wave of
Arguably, it only matters if the flow of copper into China goes into massive spending -- fearful that today's gains, as those in 2008, may
reverse and this seems highly unlikely. prove all too fleeting. While some companies have already started to
revive projects that were put on ice during the worst of the crisis,
As shown in the next graphic China has been a significant exporter of
worries over the strength of top consumer China's appetite for copper
refined copper in only one year in the last six. It happened in 2006
and the pace of the global economic recovery has kept spending
and it's worth remembering the unique circumstances that
limited -- for now.
occasioned the reverse-flow. That was the year that the State
Reserves Bureau shipped large tonnages against short positions
accumulated on the London Metal Exchange by its star-turned-rogue
trader Liu Qibing. Of the total 243,000 tonnes of exports 165,000
tonnes went to South Korea and Singapore, the nearest LME
warehouse locations.
It was an episode that caused much embarrassment for the Bureau
and which resulted in the imprisonment of Mr Liu for illegal use of
state funds.
The SRB after all is not meant to be stockpiling copper for delivery to
the LME. It is charged with maintaining reserves to release at times
of high prices and physical scarcity to meet the country's strategic
requirements.
That is also why China's commercial players build stocks at times of
low prices and, indirectly, why speculators hold stocks in China (and
in bonded warehouse at Chinese ports), not elsewhere. China, after
all, is the world's largest consumer, the one with the fastest present
consumption growth, even if it's not 38 percent, and the one with the "One of the things people will probably be discussing is really the
projected fastest consumption growth for the foreseeable future. sustainability of current price levels, which is actually quite high," said
Patricia Mohr, vice president of economics at Scotiabank Group in
No one is holding stocks in China with a view to re-exporting the Toronto.
metal. The bet, and it seems a reasonable one, is that if that copper
is going to be sold at a profit anywhere in the world, it will be in The question they will be asking: Is $8,000 a tonne, high enough to
China. make most operations profitable in the long run, the new norm?
According to industry sources in Chile, which supplies a third of the
That may be what the current copper price, still largely predicated on world's supply, that answer is far from certain.
continued strong demand from China, is saying.
"We are happy with prices, there is no question about that, but how
"Dr Copper" may be partially blind but he may not be entirely wrong! long will those happy days last? We need to think carefully about
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- how much to spend," said a foreign mining executive in Santiago.
Increased optimism among market players ahead of next week's
CRU/CESCO-AS COPPER NEARS RECORD PEAK, EXECS
CRU/CESCO mining conference, the world's biggest copper
TO ASK 'HOW HIGH' gathering, contrasts with jitters during last year's meeting as prices
By Alonso Soto and Fabian Cambero collapsed amid the global financial meltdown. Copper has risen
sharply, hitting 20-month highs of $7,939.75 a tonne on Thursday as
EL TENIENTE MINE, Chile, April 1 (Reuters) - Here at the world's market sentiment improved, sparking fears of a price correction as
biggest underground mine, Chile's state mining enterprise Codelco fundamentals remain weak. The benchmark COMEX May copper
plans to spend tens of millions of dollars to extend the life of a contract also hit a 20-month high on Thursday of around $3.60 per lb.
century-old operation.
But even if prices falter, most experts see them staying far above the
lows seen in late 2008 when prices hit $1.25 a lb as the world
plunged into recession. The value of the metal used to make cars
and build homes saw an outstanding comeback of 139 percent last
year as massive stimulus packages boosted hopes of a solid
economic recovery.
Global miner BHP Billiton is studying whether to revive key projects
in top producer Chile, but has said it could lower an original price tag
of $7.6 billion. Juan Carlos Guajardo, head of the influential
Santiago-based CESCO copper think tank, urged more, saying
companies are being too timid in getting into the action as Chinese
consumption stays strong.
"Companies should take advantage of China's rapid growth in
consumption, which should be a sign that the previous paradigm of
cyclical prices has been left far behind," said Guajardo. "If companies
continue with the old paradigm, we will continue to see a tight market
in coming years."
REUTERS COVERAGE ON CRU’S 9TH WORLD COPPER CONFERENCE 05 APRIL 2010

CODELCO SPENDS, RISKS LOOM "There is a short-term risk that supply stays limited because there is
little investment in the sector," Awad said. "Most of the projects that
Codelco, the world's No. 1 copper miner, is likely to continue to
are known to the market require a long-term (copper) price of $2.20 a
spend heavily even as the Chilean government scrambles to raise
lb to move ahead, and the industry is not yet convinced that copper
billions of dollars to rebuild towns and industries battered by a
could be at that level in the long run."
massive Feb. 27 quake.
Many are under increasing pressure from rising labor and machinery
The state giant will boost investment to $2.3 billion this year and
costs plus extra spending linked to tougher environmental regulation
expects to slightly increase output from near record highs of 1.7
across the world, Awad said.
million tonnes in 2009.
"We are finding that we need to spend more, meaning that the initial
For miners elsewhere, political risk at new exploration sites across
investment is bigger now than what is used to be two years ago," he
the world could continue to hamper output and slow projects, which
said.
will help keep supply from climbing more rapidly in coming years.
Antofagasta, a London-listed company that started as a railway
From Ecuador to Pakistan to the Democratic Republic of Congo,
company in Chile's arid north, is looking ahead as it nears the
miners face resource nationalism, armed conflict and little
completion of its Esperanza and Los Pelambres projects, which
infrastructure.
together are expected to lift output to 700,000 tonnes per year (tpy)
"Resource nationalization is a risk both for mining companies and for by 2011.
the nations involved, typically, particularly in developed nations," said
BUYING UP TO 1 MLN TPY
Fred McMahon of the Fraser Institute in Canada.
Beyond those projects, Antofagasta aims to hit 1 million tonnes a
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- year by 2015 via takeovers of early development stage projects,
CRU/CESCO-MINER ANTOFAGASTA SETS PACE WITH BIG although Awad said he may also look at producing mines.
SPENDING PLAN "In accordance with our policy, when it comes to projects in early
stages, yes, we will continue those investments this year," said
By Alonso Soto and Fabian Cambero
Awad. "When it comes to the purchase of projects in more advanced
SANTIAGO, April 5 (Reuters) - Antofagasta Minerals stood apart last stages, we are analyzing alternatives."
year by spending through the collapse in commodity markets. Now
He said the company favors partners with mining expertise instead of
it's set to stay ahead and ramp up investment even as rivals fret
more passive, financial associates. He said investment funds have
about the sustainability of near-record copper prices.
consolidated their participation in copper markets over the last
Predicting that prices will remain within sight of their 2008 peak decade, and he sees their share of daily transactions at between 15
through part of this year, Chief Executive Marcelo Awad says the and 20 percent as investors ponder over the future of prices.
mid-tier global copper miner could invest up to $7 billion in new
Unstable power supply to its biggest mine, Los Pelambres, in north-
projects over the next 10 years, even after several of its biggest
central Chile after a massive Feb. 27 earthquake hit Chile's main grid
projects come to fruition.
is not seen as a risk to output, Awad said. "We have the impression
In an industry that has been whipsawed by copper's dive below that measures were taken and we hope there are no (energy)
$1.30 a lb at the end of 2008 and its subsequent rally to last problems," Awad said.
Thursday's 20-month high of near $3.60 a lb, Awad's confidence is a
relatively rare commodity. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

"This price level allow us to keep dreaming of materializing projects CRU/CESCO-CHILE SET TO RAISE 2010 COPPER VIEW TO
that we have on our portfolio," he told Reuters ahead of the $3.30/LB
CRU/CESCO mining conference in Santiago, where copper
By Fabian Andres Cambero
executives from around the world will look for signs that current
prices could be sustainable. SANTIAGO, April 5 (Reuters) - Chile's state copper think-tank will
likely raise its 2010 average copper price outlook by about 6.5
percent to $3.30 lb thanks to strong demand from top consumer
China and as developed economies gradually recover from the
global financial crisis.
Although Cochilco, or the Chilean Copper Commission, says prices
are likely to soften later this year as China draws down inventories, a
reluctance among miners to restart projects that were shelved during
the collapse in prices should help markets resume their rally through
2011 and into 2012.
"We are probably going to upwardly revise the forecast we made in
January from around $3.10 lb to around $3.30 lb," Ana Isabel Zuniga,
head of research at Cochilco, told Reuters in an interview ahead of
the CRU/CESCO copper conference in Santiago.
However she warned that copper's latest rally to 20-month highs last
week -- within about 70 cents a pound from their all-time peaks in
mid-2008 -- would be hard to sustain.
Awad said copper prices are likely to hover close to $8,000 a tonne
or $3.62 a lb until mid-year, and expects prices to average $3.30 a lb "We think China's apparent demand should fall, though not in terms
($7,275 a tonne) in 2010, refining his forecast from March for prices of actual consumption, because they should use up part of the
to average above $3 a lb. For the moment, part of copper's buoyancy inventories built up over the last year," she said.
is due to a reluctance to increase spending by some of Awad's rivals. Zuniga sees room for continued strong copper demand by industrial
Awad said that unlike some of its peers, Antofagasta found itself with sectors in China for much of the rest of the decade, but says the risk
plenty of cash and little debt when the crisis dragged down copper of a slowdown in demand as the major consumer seeks to avoid
prices from historic highs in 2008, allowing the company to forge overheating remains one of the main risks for commodity markets.
ahead with investments.
REUTERS COVERAGE ON CRU’S 9TH WORLD COPPER CONFERENCE 05 APRIL 2010

Other risks ahead include the specter of labor disputes or stoppages The copper market last year was boosted by Chinese government
which have prompted analysts to revise down their output forecasts and consumer demand, partly for stockpiling.
over the past 3-4 years.
Strong Chinese demand can be seen in the country's refined copper
imports -- a record 3.19 million tonnes last year, up 118.7 percent
from 2008.
Evidence of rising demand this year can be seen in stocks of copper
in London Metal Exchange warehouses which have fallen 35,400
tonnes since March 1 to 516,925 tonnes.
Benchmark copper on the London Metal exchange surged about 140
percent last year. On Friday it traded around $7,500 a tonne, having
hit a 2010 high of $7,796 a tonne on Jan. 7.
LONGER LEAD TIMES
Also behind the forecasts for a small deficit is the idea that copper
production may be prone to disruptions.
The earthquakes in Chile earlier this year illustrate the point. The
earthquake did no serious damage to mining infrastructure, but it did
hit power supplies.
"Refined production remains vulnerable to strikes, equipment
failures, low ore grades, and more recently the scarcity of copper
scrap," said Justin Lennon, analyst at Mitsui Bussan Commodities.
"(However) with the price of copper significantly above the cost of
production, miners are quickly increasing available capacities."
Forecasts for the market balance range from Deutsche Bank and
Mitsui's surplus of 300,000 tonnes to UBS's deficit of 1 million
tonnes.
However supply tightness should help underpin prices for now.
"We think copper is going to get excruciatingly tight by the middle of
"We see a tighter market in 2011 than in 2010, so prices next year the year because of the end of destocking and restocking in the
should be higher," Zuniga said, adding prices should remain strong world outside China," said Julien Garran, analyst at UBS.
going into 2012.
"Restocking is driven by the cost of capital and whether customers
The global financial crisis triggered a slump in demand for think the products they need are getting scarcer ... We are already
commodities, which hit the profitability of many mining projects and seeing sharply extended lead times for delivery of copper products."
slammed the brakes on some new ventures, which miners are now
starting to look at again as prices rebound. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cochilco has tallied investments and projects totaling $43 billion from CODELCO SEES SHORT-TERM COPPER VOLATILITY
2008 through to 2020, with around $5 billion a year earmarked for
2010 through 2012. By Alonso Soto and Fabian Cambero
SANTIAGO, April 5 (Reuters) - Chile's Codelco's CEO forecast a
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
"slight" surplus of global copper supply this year, at odds with a
POLL-ROBUST DEMAND TO PUSH COPPER INTO DEFICIT consensus view of a marginal surplus, but warned volatile prices are
IN 2010 in store as financial investors play a bigger role, at times
overshadowing fundamentals.
By Pratima Desai
Chief Executive Jose Pablo Arellano also stuck to the company's
LONDON, March 26 (Reuters) - Healthy global demand and the earlier guidance for a slight increase in output this year from the
possibility of supply disruptions mean the copper market could see a world's biggest producer, reiterating that the massive earthquake that
small deficit this year compared with previous forecasts of a surplus, forced it to briefly halt some mining operations in February would not
a Reuters survey showed. affect its forecast.
The survey of 13 metal analysts carried out over the last two weeks "Slightly higher production this year compared with 2009 is not at
showed the copper market was expected to have a deficit of 23,000 risk" due to the earthquake, he told reporters ahead of the
tonnes. In the January survey expectations were for a surplus of CRU/CESCO copper conference in Santiago.
115,000 tonnes.
With plans to invest $2.3 billion this year to offset dwindling output
Global demand for copper -- used widely in power and construction -- from older mines, Codelco had earlier predicted an increase on the
is expected to rise 4.5 percent to 18.5 million tonnes this year, the 1.7 million tonnes it produced in 2009, the first annual increase in
survey showed. production in five years.
China's refined copper imports at 220,530 tonnes in February were Arellano based his forecast for a supply surplus on the belief that
up 12 percent from the previous month, ahead of forecasts of recovering U.S. and European demand will offset any slowdown from
190,000 tonnes, a sign of robust demand from the world's largest top consumer China. It comes just two weeks after a Reuters poll
consumer of industrial metals. showed analysts had shifted expectations in favor of a marginal
"It has become clear from data so far in 2010 that the strength of deficit of 23,000 tonnes from January's forecast for a 115,000 tonne
economic growth will set a firm base for further strong gains in surplus.
China's copper demand," said Gayle Berry, analyst at Barclays That's a small fraction of the world's mine supply of 15 million tonnes,
Capital. "Continued expansion of the power grid, strong auto sales but still it marked a measurable shift.
and uptake of consumer appliances will be the key drivers."
REUTERS COVERAGE ON CRU’S 9TH WORLD COPPER CONFERENCE 05 APRIL 2010

"We hope there will be some synchronization between a possible On the domestic front, he said he expected the Chilean government
slowdown in China with strengthening in the rest of the world, to quickly repair the central power grid damaged by a Feb. 27 quake
particularly the United States and Europe." that killed hundreds of people and destroyed roads, bridges and
buildings.
FUNDS VS FUNDAMENTALS?
Faults in the country's main power grid led to a massive blackout in
For the moment, fundamentals may not be paramount in a market
mid March that forced several Codelco copper mines to slow
that has rebounded more quickly than other commodities since the
operations briefly.
financial crisis of 2008. COMEX copper futures settled at a 20-month
high above $3.62 a pound on Monday, nearly triple their low in late Arellano said the current hike in copper prices was due to continued
2008. strong demand from Asia.
He said financial investors are likely to be a permanent fixture in
Echoing the views of many in the market, Arellano said the industry
copper markets, but fundamentals will still drive prices in the long
must brace for more years of volatility with the increased participation
term.
of financial players.
"Demand and supply of copper ... are not the only ones playing a
role," he said. "We have financial investors having an impact in the
price. For that reason we are going to expect more volatility than we
are used to" in the short to medium term.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Editorial contacts: For more information:


Send us a sales enquiry at:
Jonathan Leff (Editor in Charge, Commodities & Energy)
jonathan.leff@thomsonreuters.com; +1 646 2816026 http://financial.thomsonreuters.com/sales

Read more about our products at:


Simon Gardner (Senior Correspondent Chile)
simon.gardner@thomsonreuters.com; +569 98188538 http://financial.thomsonreuters.com

Find out how to contact your local office:


Alonso Soto (Commodities Correspondent Chile)
alonso.soto@thomsonreuters.com; +569 98188519 https://customers.reuters.com/Home/Default.aspx

Access customer services at:


Fabian Cambero (Commodities Correspondent Chile)
fabian.cambero@thomsonreuters.com; +569 62479675
http://financial.thomsonreuters.com/customers

Visit the Thomson Reuters Commodities & Energy Community


Reese Ewing (Correspondent Brazil)
reese.ewing@thomsonreuters.com; +5511 8160-4173 Site at:
https://customers.reuters.com/community/commodities/
Teresa Cespedes (Correspondent Peru)
teresa.cespedes@thomsonreuters.com; +511 9 97573480 Visit the Thomson Reuters Base Metals Community at:
http://communities.thomsonreuters.com/BaseMetals
Euan Rocha (Mining Correspondent Canada)
euan.rocha@thomsonreuters.com; +1 416 505 2445
Privacy Statement:
Eduardo Garcia (Correspondent Bolivia)
To find out more about how we may collect, use and share your
eduardo.garcia@thomsonreuters.com; +591 73002656
personal information please read the statement at
http://thomsonreuters.com/business_units/financial/integration/privacy/
Manual Farias (Treasury subeditor Spanish Language)
manuel.farias@thomsonreuters.com; +56 9 98375654 © 2010 Thomson Reuters. All rights reserved. Republication or
redistribution of Thomson Reuters content, including by framing or
Financial Graphics, Financial.graphics@thomsonreuters.com similar means, is prohibited without the prior written consent of
Thomson Reuters. "Thomson Reuters" and the Thomson Reuters
logo are trademarks of Thomson Reuters and its affiliated
companies.

Published by Thomson Reuters, Thomson Reuters


Building, 30 South Colonnade, Canary Wharf, London,
E14 5EP, UK 16329-04-06

You might also like