Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PII:
DOI:
Reference:
S0963-8695(15)00112-7
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ndteint.2015.10.002
JNDT1720
Ana Paula Pereira FulcoI,*; Jos Daniel Diniz MeloI; Carlos Alberto PaskocimasI;
Suzana Nbrega de MedeirosII; Fernando Luis de Araujo MachadoIII; Alexandre
Ricalde RodriguesIII
RN, Brazil
III
However, it resulted in better signal-to-noise ratio for the intermediate and larger size
notches.
Keywords: polymer-matrix composites (PMCs); magnetic markers; non-destructive
testing; ferrites.
1. Introduction
Polymer composite materials offer a combination of properties that makes them
advantageous for many applications. These properties include low density, high
mechanical strength and elastic modulus and corrosion resistance. Due to these unique
characteristics, these materials are widely used in applications such as aeronautical and
aerospace structures, sporting goods and various industrial applications.
Polymer composites are increasingly recognized as an enabling technology to
meet specific and ever-increasing demanding requirements of the oil and gas industry.
As corrosion poses major challenges for conventional steel pipes, the inherent corrosion
resistance of polymer composites combined with their superior mechanical properties
and low density has made them the natural choice of material [1-4]. Currently, many
types of fiber-reinforced polymer materials are used in oilfields. While fiberglass has
been the typical reinforcement, the predominant resins are polyester, vinyl ester and
epoxy [1].
Damage in composite structures are known to affect their mechanical properties
and functionality. In some cases, damage progression may ultimately lead to structural
failure with potential consequences that include damage to property or the environment
and even loss of human life. While some surface damages may be easily detected
during routine inspections, internal damages that are often undetectable by simple visual
inspection can cause significant reductions in strength and stability of the structure.
Therefore, approaches for the detection of internal damages in polymer composite
materials are of great interest. The use of nondestructive evaluation (NDE) techniques
allows assessing the structural integrity of the component without damaging the
materials. Typical nondestructive testing (NDT) techniques currently used to examine
polymer composite materials include ultrasound, thermography, shearography and x-ray
computed tomography (XR - CT) [5-7].
Shearography has been used to assess damages, including the detection of
delamination, with various types of excitation such as temperature, vacuum and internal
pressure [6]. Thermography is a highly sensitive technique to detect delamination, but
there are limitations to measurements on thick laminates [6]. X-ray computed
tomography (X-ray CT) provides high-resolution images and full 3D reconstruction of
the assessed part and can detect defects such as voids, cracks, inclusions, dry fibers and
delamination. In this case, the specimens to be tested may be thicker than those
evaluated by thermography due to low x-ray attenuation of polymer composites.
Ultrasound have been widely used for the inspection of metallic parts [7].
In
2. Experimental
2.1. Preparation and characterization of the ferrite particles
Cobalt ferrite particles were synthesized by the Pechini method. Stoichiometric
amounts
of
citric
acid
(C6H8O7,
99%
purity),
nitrate
cobalt
hexahydrate
(spongy and dark colored product). The product was then milled to form fine and
homogeneous cobalt ferrite powders. Subsequently, the powders were calcined at 800C
for 6 h in a muffle furnace using a heating rate of 10C/min.
Commercially available barium hexaferrite produced by Fermag Ltda Brazil
was milled to reduce particle size using a high-energy attritor mill at room temperature.
The milling process was conducted using zirconia balls in wet medium (isopropyl
alcohol) for 12 h and 20 h. The process was interrupted for 30 min, at every 3 h, to
minimize heating. The different milling times were used to allow the evaluation of
effect of particle size on the magnetic properties of the composites.
The crystalline structure of the ferrites was analyzed by X-ray diffraction (XRD)
using a XRD -7000 Shimadzu diffractometer with CuK radiation source. Crystallite
sizes were obtained with Scherrer's equation [10]. The Rietveld method was used to
refine the XRD data [11] using the MAUD (Materials Analysis Using Diffraction)
program [12]. Ferrite particles were also observed by field emission scanning electron
microscopy FEG SEM (FEI Inspect F50) operating at an acceleration voltage of 20 kV.
Based on the FEG SEM images, average particle size and size distribution were
estimated using a minimum of 15 particles in a typical sample. Magnetic measurements
were performed at room temperature using a vibrating sample magnetometer (VSM).
90:10 (resin:particles). Composite materials with magnetic particles fillers have been
reported in the literature with particle contents up to 60 wt.% [13,14,15]. In this work,
the particle content was limited to 10 wt.% in order to maintain the low viscosity of the
epoxy, which is an important advantage in thermoset polymer composite
manufacturing.
Figure 1 Polymer matrix composite plates with notches. Stickers on each side
of the notches limits the region analyzed on the magnetic measurements.
Nanovoltmeter
Circular plate
Hall sensor
Current source
Stepper motor
The Hall sensor detected the magnetic field produced by the magnetized
composite plate along with distortions produced in the field by the notches. There are at
least two reasons for the measured variations in magnetic flux lines at the notches. First,
as observed in stainless steel, the flux lines are more concentrated at the notches
because of the reduction in thickness that, in turn, increases locally the magnetic field
and saturates the local magnetization. Secondly, a smaller component of the magnetic
field produced by the magnetic particles is detected at the notch area due to the
increased sensor-to-surface distance. Data were acquired via a LabView-based
computer controlled data acquisition system using a GPIB interface. In order to verify
the repeatability of the measurements, the direction of rotation of the circular plates was
reversed over the limits of each notch using the stepper motor controller. Symmetrical
curves about the turning point indicate a clear correlation of the notch with the
deformation of the magnetic field lines over the region.
8
5000
CoFe2O4
Fe2O3
Co3O4
Intensity (CPS)
4000
3000
2000
1000
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
also observed on X-ray diffraction patterns of the milled samples. The appearance of
this phase can be explained by contamination and broken bonds between Fe atoms
during the milling process. Furthermore, the diffraction peak broadening observed in
the milled samples indicates fragmentation of the material and refinement of crystallite
size to the nanometer range, as result of the milling process. Similar observation has
been reported in the literature [16].
Intensity (CPS)
1200
1000
800
600
400
200
0
500
400
300
200
100
0
800
700
600
500
400
300
200
100
0
10
BaFe12O19
Fe2O3
(a)
20
40
60
80
(b)
20
40
60
80
(c)
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Figure 4 X-ray Diffraction pattern of barium ferrite samples: (a) without milling, (b)
milled for 12 h and (c) milled for 20 h.
Average particle size and crystallite size of ferrite particles are shown in Table 1.
10
CoFe2O4
256.53
340
181.76
750
24.49
670
18.58
400
According to the data presented in Table 1, the milling process was effective in
reducing the particle size of BaFe12O19 ferrites from an average of 750 nm to 670 nm,
after 12 h, and to 400 nm after 20 h milling time. For CoFe2O4, the average estimated
particle size was 340 nm.
For BaFe12O19 samples, it was observed that the milling process reduced the
average crystallite size to the nanometer range, in agreement to results previously
reported in literature [16]. Therefore, there was a reduction from 181.76 nm (starting
BaFe12O19) to 18.58 nm (20 h milling time).
crystallite size was during the first 12 h of milling time when the average crystallite was
reduced from 181.76 nm to 24.49 nm. The average crystallite size measurements agree
with the results of the X-ray diffraction peaks for the BaFe12O19 samples for which
sharper peaks imply larger crystallite size.
For CoFe2O4, the crystallite size determined was 256.53 nm. The literature
reports crystallite size for cobalt ferrite [17] when synthesized by another method at
11
temperature of 800C/6h, obtaining crystallite size of 102.32 nm. This larger average
crystallite size is due to the effect of diffusion, which occurs between ions at high
temperatures, since this favors the coalescence of grains, forming larger crystals.
Although Scherrer equation is known to be applicable to crystallite sizes below 200 nm,
the value measured is an indication that the crystallite size of the CoFe2O4 produced is
larger than that obtained by a different synthesis method published in the literature [17].
FEG SEM micrographs of the ferrites are shown in Figure 5. For the CoFe2O4
sample, the material obtained is composed of coarse clusters and of finely divided
particles (Figure 5 a). This can be attributed to the characteristic of the carbonized
material, which has been first disaggregated in a mortar, yielding particles with a broad
distribution of cluster sizes and that preserves the size distribution after calcination.
Thus, clusters with estimated sizes ranging from 10 m to 2 m associated with
particles of sizes ranging from 1 m to 300 nm were observed. The estimated average
particle size in this case was 340 nm.
For the BaFe12O19 sample before milling (Figure 5 b), the micrograph indicates
that the original barium ferrite is composed by clusters of tightly bound smaller
particles. These clusters were found to have an average size of about 13 m consisting
of particles of about 750 nm in size.
manufacturing process of these ferrites which were obtained by solid state reaction
using high heat treatment temperatures, typically above 1200 C. This process results in
the formation of the desired phase, as well as powder sintering.
After the milling process, clusters of finer particle sizes are obtained, as shown
in Figure 5 a) and b). The powder showed average particle size of about 670 nm and
400 nm, after milling for 12 h and 20 h, respectively. This suggests that the milling
12
process was effective in breaking the clusters and reducing the particle size of the
original material. However, the presence of some particles with angular shape and
average size of around 2.30 m was verified. These particles are remaining fragments
of the original unmilled particles.
a)
b)
c)
d)
13
The highest
saturation magnetization value, 76 J/T-kg, was obtained for the unmilled BaFe12O19
sample. In this case, the largest particle size (Figure 5 b) favored the formation of
magnetic fields of greater magnitude.
magnetic domain, which favors increased magnetization. Therefore, the milling process
of the ferrites resulted in lower saturation magnetization.
It was also observed that the milling process of barium ferrites resulted in the
formation of hematite phase, as previously discussed and shown in Figure 4. The
formation of this phase was explained by contamination of the milling system
(polyamide 66 - Technyl ball and support) or broken bonds between Fe atoms during
the milling process. The presence of hematite may have influenced the saturation
magnetization measurements.
For BaFe12O19 sample (before milling), the coercivity value was 0.25T. After
the milling process for 12 h and 20 h, this value was reduced to approximately 0.19T.
This can be explained by the fact that a smaller coercivity implies in a smaller saturation
field and easier magnetization of the material.
14
80
60
40
M (J/T-kg)
20
0
-20
CoFe2O4
-40
BaFe12O19 - no grinding
BaFe12O19 - 12 hours
-60
BaFe12O19 - 20 hours
-80
-2000
-1500
-1000
-500
500
1000
1500
2000
H (T)
Figure 7 shows FEG SEM micrographs of the polymer matrix composites with
the addition of ferrite particles. Clusters of about 4.0 m were observed in composites
with BaFe12O19 (unmilled) and CoFe2O4 ferrites, as shown in Figure 7 a) and b),
respectively. In figure 7 c), which corresponds to the composite with BaFe12O19 (milled
for 20 h), it can be observed that the milling process favored not only the reduction of
particle size but also their dispersion in the polymeric matrix. Uniform dispersion of the
magnetic particles on the composite is essential for damage detection since areas
without magnetic particles may produce a false indication of damage.
15
a)
b)
c)
Figure 7 FEG SEM micrographs of the polymer matrix composite with the addition of
the following particles: a) BaFe12O19 (unmilled), b) CoFe2O4, c) BaFe12O19 (milled for
20 h).
Figures 8, 9 and 10 show variation in magnetic field (mT) measured
perpendicular to the plane of the circular plates versus distance (mm) for circular
notches of 1 mm, 5 mm and 10 mm in diameter, respectively, as previously shown in
Figure 2. The curves of magnetic field variation (Figures 8 to 10) clearly indicate the
presence of notches on the circular plates. The beginning and end of each notch marked
with arrows in Figures 8 to 10 match the notch diameter on the circular plates, thereby
confirming that the field signal obtained is characteristic of each notch.
The
16
CoFe2O4
BaFe12O19 (no grinding)
H (mT)
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
d (mm)
Figure 8 Magnetic field curves (mT) versus distance measured in composite plates
with CoFe2O4, BaFe12O19 (no milling), BaFe12O19 (12 h) and BaFe12O19 (20 h) at the
1mm notch. Arrows indicate the beginning and end of each notch.
17
H (mT)
CoFe2O4
-2
10
15
20
25
30
d (mm)
Figure 9 Magnetic field curves (mT) versus distance measured in composite plates with
CoFe2O4, BaFe12O19 (no milling), BaFe12O19 (12 h) and BaFe12O19 (20 h) at the 5 mm
notch. Arrows indicate the beginning and end of each notch.
without milling. This can be explained by the higher magnetization of these samples
which results in higher equipotential lines and consequently greater magnetic flux
leakage, thereby contributing to higher resolution in detecting the notch, as evidenced
by the hysteresis curves of these materials (Figure 6). However, the curves presented in
Figures 9 and 10 indicate that the smallest particle size allowed producing smoother
magnetic curves with fewer discontinuities.
homogeneous particle distribution within the polymer matrix. Moreover, the magnetic
field curves of composites with barium ferrite of smaller particles showed peaks only
over the regions of the notches, which did not occur for barium ferrites without milling
or for cobalt ferrites, i.e., it allowed better signal-to-noise ratio.
CoFe2O4
BaFe12O19 (no grinding)
H (mT)
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
d (mm)
Figure 10 Magnetic field curves (mT) versus distance measured in composite plates
with CoFe2O4, BaFe12O19 (no milling), BaFe12O19 (12 h) and BaFe12O19 (20 h) at the 10
mm notch. Arrows indicate the beginning and end of each notch.
19
4. Conclusions
In this study, fiberglass reinforced polymer matrix composite circular plates with
the addition of ferrites (10 wt.%) were produced for magnetic characterization using
magnetic flux leakage (MFL) technique. Barium ferrites were added to the composites
with different particle sizes: without milling and milled in a high-energy mill for 12h
and 20h.
synthesized by the Pechini method and the results were compared with those obtained
with barium ferrite. Circular notches of 1, 5 and 10 mm in diameter were introduced on
the composite plates to investigate the potential use of the magnetic characterization
technique for the identification of defects and damages in polymer composites.
According to the results obtained, changes in the magnetic signal of samples
with 10 wt.% of cobalt ferrite were reproducible and characteristic for all notch sizes
studied. For composites with barium ferrite, 5 and 10 mm notches were detected with
all particle sizes analyzed, and the magnetic signal showed good correlation with the
location and size of the notches. However, the notch of 1 mm was detected only for
larger particle sizes (micrometric clusters formed by particles of approximately 0.75
m). For composite plates with barium ferrite milled for 12 and 20 h, 1 mm notch did
not produce a significant variation in the magnetic field, suggesting that the milling of
particles did not favor the detection of smaller notches. Nevertheless, the smaller
particle size allowed producing smoother magnetic curves with variations only over the
notch regions and therefore a better signal-to-noise ratio. Moreover, smaller variation in
the baseline is expected with narrower particle size distribution and better particle
dispersion in the polymer matrix. The overall results indicate that the proposed
technique has great potential for the detection of defects and damages in polymer matrix
composites by using non-destructive magnetic testing.
20
Acknowledgments
This study was supported by the National Council for Scientific and
Technological Development (CNPq-BRAZIL) through the Petrobras Technology
Award (5th Edition). Special thanks to FERMAG Ltda for the donation of the barium
ferrites.
References
[1] HOSSAIN ME (2011) The current and future trends of composite materials: an
experimental
study.
Journal
of
Composite
Materials
45:2133-2144.
doi:
10.1177/0021998311401066
[2] YANG C (2000) Design and analysis of composite pipe joints under tensile loading.
Journal of Composite Materials 34:332-349. doi: 10.1177/002199830003400404
[3] PERREUX D, SURI C (1997) A study of the coupling between the phenomena of
water absorption and damage in glass/epoxy composite pipes. Composites Science and
Technology 57:1403-1413. doi: 10.1016/S0266-3538(97)00076-6
[4] FROST SR, CERVENKA A (1994) Glass fiber-reinforced epoxy matrix filamentwound pipes for use in the oil industry. Composites Manufacturing. 5:73-81. doi:
10.1016/0956-7143(94)90058-2
[5] HUANG YD, FROYEN L, WEVERS M (2001) Quality control and non-destructive
test in metal matrix composites. Journal of Nondestructive Evaluation, v. 20:113-132.
doi: 10.1023/A:1013503005743
[6] AMENABAR I, MENDIKUTE A, LPEZ-ARRAIZA A, LIZARANZU M,
AURREKOETXEA J (2011) Comparison and analysis of non-destructive testing
techniques suitable for delamination inspection in wind turbine blades. Composites: Part
B 42:1298-1305. doi: 10.1016/j.compositesb.2011.01.025
[7] BAYRAKTAR E, ANTOLOVICH SD, BATHIAS C (2008) New developments in
non-destructive controls of the composite materials and applications in manufacturing
engineering.
Journal
of
Materials
Processing
Technology
206:30-44.
doi:
10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2007.12.001
21
[8] GLORIA NBS, AREIZA MCL, MIRANDA IVJ, REBELLO JMA (2009)
Development of a magnetic sensor for detection and sizing of internal pipeline corrosion
defects. NDT & E International 42:669-677. doi: 10.1016/j.ndteint.2009.06.009
[9] SUGIMOTO M (1999) The Past, Present, and Future of Ferrites. Journal of the
American Ceramic Society 82:269-280. doi: 10.1111/j.1551-2916.1999.tb20058
[10] B.E. WARREN: X-Ray diffraction. London: Dover Publications, 1990
[11] JCPDS-ICDD Card, International Centre for Diffraction Data, Newtown
Square,PA, 2002
[12] L. Lutterotti, Total pattern fitting for the combined size-strain-stress-texture
determination in thin film diffraction, Nuclear Inst. and Methods in Physics Research,
B, 268, 334-340, 2010.
[13] MOU'AD A. TARAWNEH, SAHRIM HAJI AHMAD, YU LI JIUN, RADWAN
DWEIRI, IBRAHIM N. HASSAN (2014) Morphology and Mechanical Properties of
NiZn Ferrite/Thermoplastic Natural Rubber Composite. Advanced Materials Research.
308-312. doi: 10.4028/www.scientific.net/AMR.925.308
[14] ASIRI, A. M., HUSSEIN, M. A., ABU-ZIED, B. M. AND HERMAS, A.-E. A.
(2014), Enhanced coating properties of Ni-La-ferrites/epoxy resin nanocomposites.
Polym Compos. doi: 10.1002/pc.23095
[15] ANGELOS CHRISTOPOULOS, EVANGELOS HRISTOFOROU AND GEORGE
TSAMASPHYROS (2012). Strain sensing capabilities of iron/epoxy composites. Smart
Materials and Structures 21 085030,. doi:10.1088/0964-1726/21/8/085030
[16] V. SEPELAK et. al. (2014) The mechanically induced structural disorder in barium
hexaferrite, BaFe12O19, and its impact on magnetism. Faraday Discussions. 170:121135. doi: 10.1039/c3fd00137g
[17] BRICEO S, BRAMER-ESCAMILLA W, DELGADO GE, PLAZA E,
PALACIOS J, CAIZALES E (2012) Effects of synthesis variable on the magnetic
properties of CoFe2O4 nanoparticles. Journal of Magnetism and Magnetic Materials, v.
324:2926-2931. doi: 10.1016/j.jmmm.2012.04.051
22
Graphical abstract
23
Highlights
The potential of magnetic flux leakage testing for NDE of polymer composites
with embedded ferrite particles was assessed.
Changes in magnetic signals were reproducible and showed good correlation
with location and size of notches in the material.
Smaller ferrite particles did not favor the detection of smaller notches, but
resulted in better signal-to-noise ratio.
24