Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Participants:
Leaders,
governing
board
members,
teacher-leaders
Pre-Seminar
Reading
and
Listening:
Please
share
a
music
with
a
message
that
is
particularly
meaningful
to
you.
It
can
be
a
song
you
heard
in
childhood,
instrumental
music
that
moves
you
deeply,
or
music
that
you
have
created.
Please
e-mail
an
audio
file,
if
possible,
or
just
the
name
of
the
song,
to
Research@NonprofitLeaders.org.
Bonus
listening:
Beethoven,
4th
movement
from
the
9th
Symphony
Mozart,
Ah
vous
dirai-je,
Maman
(Variations
on
Twinkle,
Twinkle
Little
Star)
The
earliest
Beatles
recording
you
can
find
.
Handouts:
Available
electronically
from
the
NESA
site.
These
are
published
in
PDF
format
and
should
be
readable
on
any
electronic
device.
However,
please
be
sure
that
your
device
can
read
the
handouts
and
if
you
have
any
problems,
please
e-mail
Research@NonprofitLeaders.org.,
and
we
will
send
you
a
version
that
is
readable
by
your
device.
If
you
prefer
paper
handouts,
please
print
them
before
the
seminar,
or
e-mail
before
October
18th
to
Research@NonprofitLeaders.org.
.
Description:
Although
there
is
a
great
deal
of
consensus
about
the
need
for
21st
Century
Skills,
including
creativity
and
critical
thinking,
many
schools
continue
to
discourage
creativity
among
students
and
teachers.
The
principal
cause
is
that,
in
an
environment
dominated
by
evaluation,
the
risks
inherent
in
critical
thinking
and
creativity
are
too
high
for
students
and
teachers.
The
central
thesis
of
this
presentation
is
that
creativity
requires
risk,
risk
entails
error,
and
a
zero
error
environment
is
a
zero
learning
environment.
Dr.
Reeves
will
introduce
the
concept
of
B3
Leadership,
representing
the
combination
of
strategies
from
Bach,
Beethoven,
and
Blues
artists.
Creativity
relies
upon
the
tension
between
formal
structure
(exemplified
in
the
music
of
J.S.
Bach),
testing
the
boundaries
of
meaning
and
message
(Beethoven),
and
on-the-spot
improvisation
of
music,
message,
and
form
that
is
the
essence
of
the
Blues.
Presenter:
Dr.
Douglas
Reeves
is
the
founder
of
The
Center
for
Successful
Leadership.
The
author
of
more
than
thirty
books
and
many
articles
on
leadership
and
organizational
effectiveness,
he
has
twice
been
named
to
the
Harvard
University
Distinguished
Authors
Series.
He
was
named
the
Brock
International
Laureate
for
his
research
and
writing
and
received
the
Contribution
to
the
Field
Award
from
the
National
Staff
Development
Council.
Doug
raises
money
for
local
educational
groups
and
other
charities
by
running
marathons.
Among
those
he
has
completed
are
the
Boston
Marathon
(twice)
and
the
Marine
Corps
Marathon.
Doug
lives
with
his
family
in
downtown
Boston.
He
can
be
reached
at
Research@NonprofitLeaders.com.
Creativity
Quiz
Please
indicate
your
level
of
agreement
with
each
of
the
following
statements.
A
response
of
1
means
certainly
untrue
and
a
response
of
10
means
certainly
true.
1.
Creativity
is
a
natural
gift.
Attempts
to
teach
creativity
are
folly.
Mozart
wrote
symphonies
when
he
was
six
and
he
didnt
go
to
Julliard
to
learn
how
to
compose.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
2.
The
most
effective
group
creativity
exercise
is
brainstorming.
The
most
important
rule
is
no
criticism
and
anything
goes.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
3.
The
most
successful
creative
developments
come
from
experts
in
the
field.
You
dont
ask
an
engineer
to
be
creative
in
education
and
you
dont
ask
a
gardener
to
be
creative
in
engineering.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
4.
Creative
thinking
is
hard
work,
demanding
deliberate
practice,
feedback,
and
lots
of
mistake.
Its
not
the
burst
of
inspiration
that
many
people
think.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
5.
The
contemporary
emphasis
on
creativity
for
students
is
overblown.
What
students
actually
need
more
of
is
discipline
and
boundaries,
not
using
creativity
as
an
excuse
to
do
their
own
thing.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
6.
Creative
thinking
requires
out
of
the
box
thinking
and
rejecting
previous
guidelines
and
boundaries.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
7.
The
most
creative
thinkers
often
have
delicate
egos,
so
it
is
essential
to
foster
an
environment
that
avoids
negative
feedback
and
requirements
for
redoing
work.
Every
creative
attempt
must
be
valued
and
praised.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
8.
The
best
way
to
improve
creativity
for
students
is
to
have
a
creativity
curriculum
with
a
creative
thinking
class.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
9.
If
students
really
want
to
learn
more
about
creativity,
they
can
take
an
art
class.
When
were
trying
to
prepare
them
for
high-stakes
tests,
we
dont
have
any
extra
time
in
the
core
curriculum.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
10.
Creativity
is
primarily
the
action
of
one
exceptional
individual.
The
person
makes
the
culture,
not
the
other
way
around.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
2.
Rigorous
Decision-
making
Systems
Level 1
Level 2
Level 3
Level 4
The
culture
requires
compliance.
Success
is
equated
with
avoiding
mistakes.
Weve
worked
too
hard
to
get
to
where
we
are
to
mess
it
up
with
any
new
ideas.
Initiatives
are
more
characterized
by
announcements,
labels,
and
speeches
not
substantive
changes
in
professional
practice.
The
culture
declares
victory
and
moves
on
rather
than
expose
new
ideas
to
systematic
evaluation.
We
listen
to
presentations
from
competing
vendors
and
come
to
a
consensus
about
what
to
decide.
Learning
mistakes
errors
that
test
hypotheses
and
found
them
to
be
wrong
are
visibly
celebrated.
We
have
the
bone-
deep
belief
that
a
zero
mistake
zone
is
a
zero
learning
zone.
We
consider
at
least
two
alternatives
and
use
the
best
available
evidence
from
a
variety
of
sources
and
methods.
We
always
consider
at
least
two
mutually
exclusive
hypotheses
and
test
them
with
data.
We
know
what
works
and
doesnt
work
because
we
test
alternatives.
The
leader
decides
and
the
team
implements.
Creativity
Essential:
Level 1
Level 2
Level 3
When
we
make
changes,
we
do
so
around
the
edges.
Our
fundamental
mission,
vision,
and
values
are
untouchables
whatever
changes
we
make
must
be
made
without
violating
our
sacred
traditions.
We
can
identify
a
significant
change
which
was
studied,
debated,
implemented,
tested,
and
that
stood
the
test
of
time
through
constant
rigorous
assessment.
4.
Leadership
Models
and
Supports
Creativity
Leaders
are
masters
of
the
rhetoric
of
change.
They
have
posters
on
the
virtues
of
innovation
and
creativity
in
their
offices
and
return
from
conferences
with
lots
of
futuristic
thinking,
typically
framed
in
vague
phrases
and
evidence-free
predictions.
Leaders
know
that
creative
ideas
will
lack
credibility
without
visible
leadership
support.
There
are
at
least
a
couple
of
examples
in
the
past
year
when
the
leader
personally
modeled
a
change
before
it
was
implemented
throughout
the
organization.
We
might
try
some
initiatives,
such
as
new
technology
implementation,
but
thats
for
the
Geek
Squad,
not
busy
leaders.
When
its
all
working
perfectly,
the
leaders
will
take
a
look
but
not
until
there
is
no
risk
of
public
embarrassment.
Level
4
We
have
many
case
studies,
modeled
on
well-recognized
creative
successes
in
music,
art,
engineering,
teaching,
learning,
and
leadership.
Our
students
and
staff
have
the
discipline
to
start
with
repetition
and
the
courage
to
experiment
creatively
with
new
ideas.
Leaders
are
actively
engaged
in
experimentation,
including
flipping
agendas
for
board
meetings
and
personally
engaging
in
alternative
learning
and
teaching
strategies.
Leaders
openly
talk
about
their
biggest
mistakes
and
what
they
learned
from
them.
Identify
a
specific
challenge
in
leadership,
teaching,
or
learning
that
you
face
right
now.
This
should
be
something
that
is
critically
important
for
you
and
your
colleagues.
A
significant
number
of
our
students
appear
to
be
disengaged
in
class.
This
observation
is
corroborated
by
observations
of
teachers
and
administrators
and
surveys
from
students
and
parents.
Disengagement
is
strongly
related
to
lower
performance
by
students
and
lower
satisfaction
by
parents.
Identify
the
assumptions
that
now
prevail
and
consider
an
alternative
assumption.
Present
Assumptions
Alternative
Assumptions
1.
Its
not
our
job
to
entertain
students
1.
Students
can
be
engaged
by
being
sometimes
they
need
to
just
work
at
it,
competent,
and
that
requires
practice
even
if
its
boring
thats
good
that
is
frequently
boring.
But
if
the
result
preparation
for
life.
engages
them,
they
put
up
with
a
lot
of
frustration
and
repetition
look
at
them
with
a
new
video
game
or
social
media
application.
2.
The
curriculum
is
crammed
with
2.
Students
dont
learn
content
by
content,
leaving
little
time
for
more
coverage
but
by
self-testing
with
engaging
interactive
activities.
immediate
feedback,
and
then
honing
in
on
the
areas
they
need
to
learn.
3.
The
hyper-connected
lives
of
students
3.
Cognitive
ability
significantly
increase
leaves
them
disengaged
unless
they
have
when
students
are
absorbed
in
nature
and
multiple
activities
going
on.
disconnected
from
technology.
Moreover,
focus
is
a
critical
success
skill.
4.
If
we
tried
to
add
engaging
activities,
4.
We
will
only
know
which
engaging
such
as
self-designed
assessments,
multi-
activities
are
linked
to
student
success
if
media
presentations,
etc.,
then
we
would
we
conduct
a
rigorous
experiment
not
be
criticized
for
not
adequately
covering
by
avoiding
them.
the
curriculum.
If
the
alternative
assumptions
are
true,
what
are
two
new
solutions
that
you
could
consider
in
response
to
your
greatest
challenge?
1.
Two
departments
that
have
identical
pre-assessments
and
end
of
semester
finals
have
agreed
to
an
experiment.
By
flip
of
a
coin,
teachers
will
either
continue
the
coverage
model
from
the
previous
semester
or
participate
in
the
engagement
model.
The
specific
engaging
activities
will
at
least
double
quantity
of
engaging
activities
compared
to
the
coverage
model
and,
as
a
result,
there
may
be
less
coverage
of
curriculum
in
the
class.
At
the
end
of
the
semester,
we
will
compare
the
gains
from
the
pre-assessment
to
the
semester
finals
between
the
two
groups,
and
then
reassess
the
impact
positive
or
negative
of
increasing
engagement
activities.
2.
Two
other
departments
will
experiment
with
a
minimum
of
twenty
minutes
of
fully
focused
time
(that
is,
work
directly
on
the
relevant
curriculum
in
whole-
class,
individual
work,
or
small
group
work,
all
without
technology
assistance).
Administrators
will
make
at
least
20
observations
at
random
intervals
during
the
semester
to
observe
the
percentage
of
students
engaged
during
fully
focused
time
compared
to
traditional
connected
time.
Copyright 2013, The Center for Successful Leadership. Research@NonprofitLeaders.org
Creativity
Tool
Kit
Challenging
Assumptions
Identify
a
specific
challenge
in
leadership,
teaching,
or
learning
that
you
face
right
now.
This
should
be
something
that
is
critically
important
for
you
and
your
colleagues.
Identify
the
assumptions
that
now
prevail
and
consider
an
alternative
assumption.
Present
Assumptions
Alternative
Assumptions
If
the
alternative
assumptions
are
true,
what
are
two
new
solutions
that
you
could
consider
in
response
to
your
greatest
challenge?
1.
2.
Sources:
Aldridge,
R.
L.
(2009)
Parables:
A
symphonic
oratorio.
New
York,
NY:
C.F.
Peters
Corporation.
Buch,
E.
&
Miller,
R.
(2013)
Beethovens
ninth:
A
political
history.
Chicago,
IL:
University
of
Chicago
Press.
Csikszentmihalyi,
M.
(1996)
Creativity:
Flow
and
the
psychology
of
discovery
and
invention.
New
York,
NY:
Harper
Collins.
Govindarajan,
V.,
&
Trimble,
C.
(2010)
The
other
side
of
innovation:
Solving
the
execution
challenge.
Boston,
MA:
Harvard
Business
School
Publishing.
Kandel,
E.
R.
(2012)
The
age
of
insight:
The
quest
to
understand
the
unconscious
in
art,
mind,
and
brain.
New
York,
NY:
Random
House.
Keeley,
L.,
Pikkel,
R.,
Quinn,
B.,
&
Walters,
H.
(2013)
Ten
types
of
innovation:
The
discipline
of
building
breakthroughs.
Hoboken,
NJ
:
John
Wiley
&
Sons.
Kleon,
A.
(2012)
Steal
like
an
artist.
New
York,
NY:
Workman
Publishing.
Kyung
Hee
Kim
(2011)
The
creativity
crisis:
The
decrease
in
creative
thinking
scores
on
the
torrance
tests
of
creative
thinking.
Creativity
Research
Journal,
23:4,
285-295.
Hofstadter,
D.
R.
(1985)
Variations
on
a
theme
as
the
crux
of
creativity:
Metamagical
themas.
New
York,
NY:
Basic
Books.
Mueller,
J.S.,
Melwani,
S.,
&
Goncalo
J.A.
(2011)
The
bias
against
creativity:
Why
people
desire
but
reject
creative
ideas.
[Electronic
version].
Retrieved
September
30,
2013,
from
Cornell
Universiy,
ILR
School
site:
http://digitalcommons.ilr.cornell.edu/articles/450/
MacDonald,
J.
R.
(2010)
Working
beyond
borders:
Insights
from
the
global
chief
human
resource
officer
study.
Somers,
NY:
IBM
Global
Business
Services.
[Electronic
version]
Retrieved
September
30,
2013
http://public.dhe.ibm.com/common/ssi/ecm/en/gbe03353usen/GBE03353USEN.PDF
Nussbaum,
B.
(2013)
Creative
intelligence:
Harnessing
the
power
to
create,
connect,
and
inspire.
New
York,
NY:
Harper
Collins.
Ownes,
D.
A.
(2012)
Creative
people
must
be
stopped:
Six
ways
we
kill
innovation
(without
even
trying).
San
Francisco,
CA:
Jossey-Bass.
Sawyer,
R.
K.
(2013)
Zig
zag:
The
surprising
path
to
greater
creativity.
San
Francisco,
CA:
Jossey-Bass.
Keynote:
How
To
Value,
Nurture,
and
Encourage
Crea8vity
by
Students,
Teachers,
and
Leaders
Douglas
B.
Reeves,
Ph.D.
The
Center
for
Successful
Leadership
www.ChangeLeaders.com
Research@NonprotLeaders.org
Overview
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
Crea+vity is Not. . .
19
20
21
22
The Book
23
They are:
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
Creativity is merely a
Creativity is merely a
plus name for regular
plus name for regular
activity. Any activity
activity. Any activity
becomes creative
becomes creative
when the doer cares
when the doer cares
about doing it right, or
about doing it right, or
better.
better.
- John Updike - John Updike -
31
32
We
must
discourage
.
.
.
33
34
35
36
Step
1
Prepara+on
Innova+on
by
deni+on
has
to
be
compared
with
what
went
before.
You
have
to
have
knowledge
of
the
expected
before
you
create
the
unexpected.
Prevents
people
from
reinven+ng
the
wheel.
Novelty
without
deep
knowledge
is
just
randomness.
37
Step
2
-
Incuba+on
Seung
down
the
crossword
and
taking
a
walk.
The
Importance
of
recess
and
naps
(for
students
and
adults)
According
to
a
2012
Lancaster
study,
subjects
were
beoer
able
to
crea+vely
solve
dicult
problems
aeer
taking
a
break
and
undergoing
the
REM
cycle
of
sleep.
38
Step
3
-
Insight
That
glorious
moment
when
it
all
comes
together.
Archimedes
in
the
bathtub.
A
moment
of
inspira+on
that
is
oeen
accompanied
by
a
state
of
intense
focus,
loss
of
+me,
and
euphoria.
39
Step
4
-
Evalua+on
Wherein
you
take
prior
knowledge
of
the
domain
to
evaluate
whether
an
idea
is
worth
pursuing.
Does
this
have
value?
Has
this
been
done
already?
Is
this
possible?
It
is
vital
in
this
process
that
there
is
a
clear
delinea+on
between
idea
and
person
origina+ng
the
idea.
Copyright 2013, The Center for Successful Leadership. Research@NonprofitLeaders.org
40
Step
5
-
Elabora+on
The
Implementa+on
of
idea:
Wri+ng
the
essay.
Conduc+ng
the
experiment.
Chiseling
the
marble.
Wri+ng
the
code,
etc.
41
42
Flunk him!
Fire her!
-60
Wunderkind
Look
for
Paoerns
become autodidacts.
Fostering
Incuba+on
An
Interdisciplinary
Approach
Using
Math
to
Teach
Art
Elementary
School
Level
Using
ra+os
to
scale
both
two
dimensional
and
three
dimensional
artwork
up
and
down
Middle
School
Level
Finding
Illustra+ons
and
Design
in
Geometric
Proofs
High
School
Using
Trigonometry
and
Physics
to
design
and
construct
three
dimensional
sculpture
Fostering
Incuba+on
An
Interdisciplinary
Approach
Using
Humani+es
to
teach
History
Elementary
School
Level
Collabora+ng
on
a
graphic
novel
to
illustrate
the
founding
of
a
state.
Middle
School
Level
Wri+ng
short
c+on
set
in
the
+me
period
of
study.
High
School
Analyzing
literature
through
the
poli+cal
lens
of
the
+me.
Fostering
Incuba+on
An
Interdisciplinary
Approach
Using
Music
to
teach
Science
and
Math
Elementary
School
Level
Using
the
experimental
method,
allowing
students
to
construct
their
own
instruments,
learning
how
dierent
paoerns
construct
dierent
tones
Middle
School
Level
Learning
basic
harmonic
theory
trough
the
ra+os
of
Pythagoras
High
School
Looking
at
the
science
of
tone,
+mbre
and
harmony
Genera+on
Valua+on
Generate
Solu+ons
to
Missing
Parts.
Edi+ng
Remove
Ideas
or
sec+ons
that
dont
work.
Art
is
Thee
Pablo
Picasso