Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at http://www.jstor.org/page/
info/about/policies/terms.jsp
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content
in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship.
For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Dumbarton Oaks, Trustees for Harvard University is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to
Dumbarton Oaks Papers.
http://www.jstor.org
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
andtheIllustration
Liturgy
oftheNinth-Century
Psalters
Marginal
MARIA EVANGELATOU
*""*issueofliturgicalinfluenceon theillustration
JL of Byzantinemarginalpsaltersis well knownin
In thisarticleI focuson theninthliterature.
scholarly
ofliturand
century
psalters, suggestthattheinfluence
on
their
illustration
was
more
extensive
gicalpractice
and systematic
thanpreviously
recognized.My analysis
offerssome insightinto the creationof thesemanuscripts,and also looks at the roleof theliturgyin the
experienceand expressionof the people who created
and used thepsalters.I concludethattheimportance
of liturgicalsourcesin the illustrationof the ninthcentury
marginalpsalterswascloselyrelatedto theproOrthodoxand specifically
iconophilemessagethatthis
illustration
was designedto promote.
exclurefers
AlthoughtheGreekword
to
the
Eucharist
the
term
will
(theMass),
sively
liturgy
be usedhereto refer
to anyregularchurchservice(while
thetermDivineLiturgywill be used fortheEucharist
likebaptismand exorcism,
alone).1Churchsacraments
db* This articlewas preparedduringmypostdoctoralfellowships
at thePontificalInstituteofMediaeval Studiesin Toronto(20052006) and the RadclifFeInstituteforAdvancedStudyat Harvard
Universityin Cambridge,MA (2006-2007); it was revisedduring myfellowshipat Dumbarton Oaks (2009-2010). I warmly
thankall threeinstitutes
forsupporting
mywork.The articleelaboratesextensively
on materialdrawnfrommyPhD dissertation(n.
9 below),whichwas completedwiththesupportofseveralinstitutionsto whichI am thankful:the Artsand HumanitiesResearch
Board of the BritishAcademy,theAntonisLeventisInstitute,the
BritishFederationofWomenGraduates,theCentralResearchFund
of the University
of London, the Courtauld Instituteof Art,and
theSocietyforthePromotionofByzantineStudies.The illustration
' 9
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
MARI A EVANGELATOU
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
number
ofminiatures,10
haveledByzantinists
toplace haveprominent
notations.12
In addition,
the
liturgical
thecommissioners
in the lastpagesoftheChludovPsalter(folios165to '6jw)
and usersofthesepsalters
circleoftheByzantine
a collection
ofprayers,
almostallofwhichare
patriarchal
capital.Prominent preserve
in
who
have
been
named
as
owners
the
thelastparts
possible
employed liturgy.13
(Unfortunately,
personages
or contributors
to theconception
ofthepsalters
are oftheothertwopsalters
do notsurvive.)
Thisevidence
ofthese
Patriarchs
Methodios
thatthecommissioners
andproducers
(843-847)andPhotios(858-867 suggests
theiruse in
and877-886);thebishopofSyracuse
Asbestas, threepsalterswantedto accommodate
Gregory
to bothpatriarchs
a painter;and theliturgical
also
friend
andhimself
celebration,
they intended
although
thechiefadvisorofMethodios,
MichaelSynkellos.11 themforotherpurposes.As theirrichillustration
werealsodestined
for
Eventhoughit is impossible
to provebeyonddoubt clearly
thesepsalters
indicates,
this
devotion
andmeditation,
anditis exactly
theinvolvement
ofanyofthesepeoplein thecommis- private
theproduction
ofsuchsophisitiscertain purposethatprompted
sionoftheninth-century
psalters,
marginal
thatthesemanuscripts
wereproduced
forhigh-ranking ticatedcorporaofminiatures.
However,sincethese
inter- manuscripts
weremadealsoforliturgical
churchmen:
use,itislikely
peoplewhoseeducation,
theological
also
reflect
and
further
serve
intheaffairs
oftheChurch thattheillustration
ests,anddailyinvolvement
might
ofthefaithwouldenablethemto thispurpose.
and themysteries
between
ofthe
Scholars
havediscussed
therelationship
thenumerous
references
andappreciate
identify
indifthe
illustration
of
these
codices
and
the
illustration
to
literature,
iconophile
psalters'
patristic
liturgy
Tikkanen
I
ferent
More
than
a
The
material
discuss
and
ways.
century
ago,Johan
polemics, liturgical
practice.
torecognize
thatmostoftheChristological
hereoffers
additional
evidence
on therichtheological wasthefirst
marshownintheByzantine
ofthesepsalters,
andtherefore andMariological
andliturgical
references
episodes
verses
that
were
chanted
toa
illustrate
thattheywereaddressed
reinforces
thehypothesis
psalm
ginalpsalters
feastdays.He sawthisas indicating
on therelevant
audience
ofchurchmen.
sophisticated
ofthe
ofthe extensive
influence
on theillustration
Theclearest
indication
thattheproduction
liturgical
to liturgi- codices.He notedthatsomeoftheseverseswerealso
ninth-century
psalters
responded
marginal
inpatristic
comcalpractice
comesfrom
their
text:allthree
and/or
manuscripts quotedintheNewTestament
and
asprophecies
ofthesameChristological
mentaries
fols.
10 ChludovPsalter,fols.23V,35V,51V;Pantokrator
Psalter,
i6r,
his
buthe didnotsystematize
episodes,
Mariological
165.Corrigan,VisualPolemics,
27-34, 110-21,figs.38-39,43-44, in.
liturwhich
of
the
above
to
determine
factors,
findings
11 For an extensivediscussionand further
literatureon thedate
in
wasmoredecisive
orbiblical/patristic
influence,
gical
and historicalcontext,with referenceto the specificpeople menof
illustration.14
the
psalter
shaping marginal
tionedhere,see Corrigan,VisualPolemics,124-34. She convincingly
toanswer
In
Walterattempted
1986,
three
and
the
circle
Christopher
that
a
between
the
relationship
psalters
argues
of
an
exhaustive
thisquestion
of Methodios is moreprobablethan a connectionwith Photios.
inventory
bycomposing
in thesemanuscripts.
miniatures
theChristological
J.Andersonhas suggestedthatMethodioswas theinventor
Recently
he createdwas
oftheGreekillustrated
psalterand thatthearchetype
He examinedeightyChristologicalepisodesand
theParismarginalPsalter.Andersondatesthiscodexto Methodios's
on thebasisofthe
groupedthemintofivecategories
Romanexilein 815-21and proposesthata Western,illustrated
psalto
sources
of
influence
that
he
identified.15
tercouldhavebeenhis sourceofinspiration.He also statesthatthe
According
Chludovand Pantokrator
Psaltersdatemuchlater,in thelate9thor
10th
"The
Creation
oftheMarginalPsalters,"in Ritual
(See
early
and Art:ByzantineEssaysfor Christopher
Walter,ed. P. Armstrong
[London,2006], 44-6$.) In myopinion,none ofAnderson'sargumentsareconvincing.The proposeddatingand chronologicaldistancebetweenthethreepsaltersis problematicforvariousreasons,
and thereis no wayto proveor disprovethattherewas a preexisting
in Byzantium(whichis ratherplautraditionofpsalterillustration
sible,giventheexceptionalimportanceofthisbook in privatedevotionas wellas a numberoficonographiefactorsin thefirstsurviving
examples).In a futurepublicationI will treatthis issue in more
detail.For thepossibleexistenceof illustratedpre-iconoclast
psaltersin Byzantium,
see also n. 21.
above),127-29,140-41,144,146.
13 Ibid.,141-42.
Acta
14 J. Tikkanen,Die Psalterillustration
im Mittelalter,
SocietatisScientiarumFennicae31,no. 5 (Helsinki,1903),49-78.
15 . Walter,"ChristologicalThemesin theByzantineMarginal
PsaltersfromtheNinthto theEleventhCentury,"REB 44 (1986):
269-87. On 272-82 he lists eightyepisodes in fivecategories:
DUMBARTON OAKS PAPERS | 63
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
6l
MARIA EVANGELATOU
In hermonograph
thiscategorization,
counterparts.20
episodes theirninth-century
onlytwelveChristological
of
the
earlier
on
the
illustration
wereinspiredby the use of the corresponding
psalters,Kathleen
psalm
on therelevantfeast Corriganfocuseson visual polemics,and the influversesin theliturgicalcelebration
is
somewhat
This
conclusion
days.16
misleading,how- enceoftheliturgyis nota mainthemeofheranalysis.
of
the
because
ever,
many
forty-nine
Christological Althoughsherecognizesthatthechoiceofsubjectmatterand certainiconographie
detailsofa fewminiatures
episodesthatWalterconsidersto be inspiredby the
in
the
New
were
conditioned
to
some
extent
of
relevant
verses
Testament
by liturgicalpracinterpretation
or in psalm commentariescorrespondto psalm pastice,she contendsthattheprincipalfactordeterminespeciallyin thoseimages
sagesthatwerealso used in theliturgicalcelebration ingthemeand iconography,
feasts(discussedbelow).17 thatwereaddedin theninthcenturyto thesupposedly
oftherelevant
Christological
Thismeansthattheinfluenceofliturgicalpracticeon
preexistingtraditionof psalterillustration,was the
intentionto createa visualstatement
witha particular
theminiatures
have
been
far
more
extensive
than
might
in
In the
Walterconcludes,and closerto Tikkanen'sevaluation. iconophileovertone defenseofOrthodoxy.21
This is in facttheopinionthatis put forwardby
followinganalysisI suggestthatCorrigan'siconophile
in
in
a
article
which
he
Cutler
1980-81
Anthony
suggeststhatthe bulk of the iconographyin Byzantine 20 Ibid.,22-30; L. Maris,"L'irruptiondes saintsdans illustraAB 68 (1950):153-62,esp. 162.See also
originsand associations tiondespsautiersbyzantins,"
marginalpsaltershasliturgical
that"wouldhave been immediatelyevidentand per- C. Barber,"Readingin theTheodorePsalter,"in Barber,Theodore
Psalter(n. 7 above),essay,-2.
to thecontemporary
userofthe
fectlycomprehensible
Cutleridenti- 21 Corrigan, Visual Polemics(. above), 4-5, 41-42, 45-46,
psaltersbuttodayrequiresexplication."18
Forthehypothesis
thattherewas no preexisting
tradition
fiesdifferent
influence
on theillustra- 56-59,123.
levelsofliturgical
in Byzantium,
ofpsalterillustration
seen. 11above.See also themore
tionsofthesecodices,notall equallyevident,and gives cautioustreatmentof theissue Brubaker,"BristolPsalter"(n. 7
by
a fewexamplesthat aim to demonstratethe overall above),esp. 127-28,135-36.AlthoughI agreewithherthattheexisofthemanuscripts.19
However,thenumber tenceof thepsalterillustrationin late antiqueByzantiumremains
complexity
a hypothesis,
I do not understandwhyshe assumeswe haveno "litof scenesexaminedis muchtoo small to supportthe
eral"miniaturesin thesurviving
ofthatperiod(which
manuscripts
applicationofhis thesisto theentirecorpusofminia- in herview underminesthe hypothesisof pre-iconoclasticliteral
turesin theByzantinemarginalpsalters,
as CutlerhimEvenifin thesurivivinglate
psalmillustration).
antiquemanuscripts
selfadmits.Nevertheless,
his observations
theminiaturesdon'talwaysappearin proximity
to therelevanttext
suggestthe
influence
on theillustration
ofthese or at timesincludeelementsnot mentionedin the scriptures,still
extentofliturgical
manyof theirOld and New Testamentscenes illustrateliterally
codicesand open thedoorforfurther
research.
the storiesof the bible (e.g.,the Vienna Genesis,sterreichische
in
ManyofCutler'sexamplesconcernminiatures
Nationalbibliothek,cod. theol. gr. 31,or the Rabbula Gospels,
forwhichliturgical Florence,Laurenziana,cod. Plut.I, 56) in thesamewaytheminiaeleventh-century
marginalpsalters,
influence
hasbeenmoreextensively
Milan Gregoryor Paris Sacra Parallela
recognizedthanfor turesof the ninth-century
(1) twelvedrawnfromNew Testamentpsalmquotations;(2) thirtysevenfrompatristiccommentaries;
(3) six fromlaterpatristicwritforwhichno
ers;(4) twelvefromByzantineworship;and (5) thirteen
liturgicalorpatristicsourceis known.Walteralso discussesfiveepisodesfoundonlyin theeleventh-century
marginalpsalters,284-86.
16 Ibid.,277-79.
17 Ibid.,272-75.
18 A. Cutler,"LiturgicalStratain the MarginalPsalters,"DOP
34-35 (1980-81):17-30.
19 Ibid., 18-30. Accordingto Cutler,the mostobvious level of
ofthemarginalpsaltersconliturgicalinfluenceon theillustration
sistsof representations
of the "authors"of the liturgiesor depictheminiaturesare
tionsoftheEucharist.At a lessevidentstratum,
inspiredbytherolethatthepsalmversestheyillustrate
playedin the
variousoffices.
The deepestand leastobviouslevelconcernsminiatureswhoseiconography
was modifiedbyreference
to theliturgy.
do (bothusedbyBrubakeras examplesofliteralillustration;
Milan,
Ambrosiana,cod. E. 49/50inf.,and Paris,BibliothqueNationale
betweenthoselate antique
de France,cod. gr.923). The difference
miniaturesand the ones usuallytermed"literal"in psaltersis due
not in the natureof the illustrationbut in
to intrinsicdifferences
thatofthetexts:mostbiblicalbooksarenarrative
accountsofevents
of
(like Genesisor theGospels),whilethepsalterconsistsprimarily
to good and evil
invocations,admonitions,and generalreferences
thatrarelymentionspecificeventsand arewrittenin a poeticlanguagefullofvividmetaphorsand similes.So whileminiaturesthat
illustrate
thetextofGenesisortheGospel arenarrative
epiliterally
ofthepsalterusuallyvisualizethepoetic
sodes,literalillustrations
i.e.,thewordsofthetext.Psalterminiaturesthatrepresent
imagery,
Old Testamenteventsinspiredbythefewrelevantdirector indirect
references
foundin thepsalmsareusuallylabeled"Old Testament"
ratherthan "literal"illustrationsin scholarlyliteratureto distinbutoftentheyareas literal
guishthemfromthe"word"miniatures,
ofthepsalms.
as theminaturesthatvisualizethepoeticexpressions
DUMBARTON OAKS PAPERS | 63
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Psalters
oftheNinth-Century
andtheIllustration
Marginal
Liturgy
| 63
emphasissometimesleads herto undervaluetheliturwiththepolemicalaspect
gicalfactorand itsinterplay
The drivingforcein thecreationof
oftheillustration.
thesecodiceswas indeedthedefenseofOrthodoxyand
but
as Corrigansuggests,
especiallyoficonveneration,
in thisdefense,inspirationfromtheliturgyseemsto
havebeeninstrumental.
The followinganalysisis dividedinto two main
examinationofthematerial
parts.First,a comparative
ofthe
and decisivetheinfluence
howextensive
clarifies
of
the
illustration
the
was
on
ninth-century
psalliturgy
withthesameChristological
ters.Groupsofminiatures
subjectsareexaminedto determinewhethertheillustrationoftherelevantpsalmversesdependedmoreon
in
theiruse in the liturgyor on theirinterpretation
fresh
a
offer
The
conclusions
patristiccommentaries.
usedbythemakon thesourcesand criteria
perspective
on theirideology
ersofthepsaltersand,consequently,
and intentions.
Second,casesofliturgicalinfluenceon
particularminiaturesare used to illuminatethecomofninth-century
Byzantine
plexityand sophistication
to
in
relation
illustration
liturgicalsources,
psalter
and iconophilepolemics.
visualexegesis,
beforeproceeding
is necessary
A finalclarification
to themaindiscussion.Despitean emphasison liturgical influence,I do not proposea dichotomybetween
patristicand liturgicalsourcesin the illustrationof
the ninth-century
psalters.Althoughmystudyaims
theimportanceoftheliturgicalfactor
to demonstrate
I do notsee itoperatingin
and explainitssignificance,
butratherin dialogue
to thepatristicfactor,
antithesis
theinteraction
withit.Specificcasesthatdemonstrate
sourcesare discussedbelow.A relebetweendifferent
vantpointto bearin mindat theoutsetis thatto a large
extenttheliturgyitselfmusthaveincorporatedmany
of patristicpsalm exegesis.In other
interpretations
of psalm verseson
the
words,
liturgicalemployment
specificfeastdaysof theByzantineChurchwas probsince
bypatristicpsalmcommentaries,
ablyinfluenced
both theearlyChurchFathersand the authorsof the
in theinterpredevelopingritehad a commoninterest
of the
tationof the Old Testamentas a prfiguration
New. Thisapproachoriginatedin theNew Testament
examined
itself.Indeed,in thecase ofsomeminiatures
seem
sources
and
below,biblical,patristic,
liturgical
linked,and it is impossibleor evenpointinextricably
less to tryand separatethem.In addition,the New
Testament,patristiccommentaries,and the liturgy
thepsalteraccordingto therelevanceof
ofteninterpret
itsvocabulary:in somecasesthewordingofthepsalms
oftheNew Testamenteventstheyare
is so reminiscent
supposedto prophesythattheirChristianexegesisis
successfuland memorable.As thefollowparticularly
the plannersof the ninthing analysisdemonstrates,
centurypsalters'illustrationseem to have considered
relevantvocabularyalong with liturgicalsources.So
even thoughmyanalysissheds morelighton the litofthese
factorfortheillustration
urgyas an influential
psalters,it does not aim to establishrigidmodels of
thatare moreakin to modernscholarly
classification
to Byzantinerealities.In otherwords,
than
mentality
we need to have a nuanced approachto the material
and notlose sightofthelargerpicturewhileexploring
ofreferand sophistication
itsdetails.The multiplicity
ences in the miniaturesof the ninth-century
psalters
is a factthat is promotedratherthan limitedby the
as discussedbelow.
importanceoftheliturgicalfactor,
ComparativeAnalysis
The followinganalysisfocuseson fourChristological
episodes that correspondto major churchfeasts.In
Old Testament
Byzantinemarginalpsalterillustration,
sceneswereusuallyinspireddirectlybytheversesthey
illustrated.The same was true forthose miniatures
of
thatrepresented
literallycertaingenericreferences
the psalms (e.g.,to the conductof virtuousor sinful
was crehowever,
men).22The Christologicalimagery,
ated accordingto a different
pattern.The illustration
of a psalm versewith an episode fromChrist'slifein otherwords,theexegesisof an Old Testamenttext
with a New Testamentepisode- was the resultof a
thatin mostcaseshad already
processofinterpretation
been appliedto thatspecificversebeforethecreation
oftheninth-century
marginalpsalters.Relevantinterpretationshave appeared occasionally in the New
in psalmcommenTestamentitselfand systematically
tariesand otherpatristictextsor in liturgicalpractice
ofpsalmversesin theliturgi(i.e.,in theincorporation
offeastdaysexactlybecausethesepsalm
cal celebration
were
consideredpropheciesof the relevant
passages
22 Corrigan,VisualPolemics,14-20. See below,pp. 4O~45> for
some exceptionsto this rule (cases of liturgicalinfluenceon Old
Testamentorliteralillustrations).
DUMBARTON OAKS PAPERS | 6}
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
64 I MARIA EVANGELATOU
thepiercing
ofhandsortheearthquakeas an allusionto
In thesamecategory
I includekey
Christ'sCrucifixion).
wordsthatwerewidelyusedin patristic
exegesisas allusionsto specificChristological
and
episodes wouldhave
beeneasilyrecognizedas suchbya well-informed
audience (forexample,or ,
or
sign footstool,as keywordsfortheCross).Relevantvocabulary
as specifiedherewas notalwaysa factorat workin the
useofthepsalms,25
but
patristic
exegesisortheliturgical
itseemstohaveplayeda centralrolein theillustration
of
theninth-century
as
a
filter
that
limmarginalpsalters
itedthevisualizationof Christologicalinterpretations
In severalinstances,nothingin theOld Testamenttextofthe
psalms immediatelyrecallsthe New Testamentepisodes theyare
and theconnectionsare illuminatedonlyby
supposedto prophesy,
the exegesesof the commentators.
For example,see Athanasiosof
Alexandria'sinterpretation
ofPs. 32:10,"TheLordscattersthecounsels of nationsand he frustrates
the reasoningsof peoples and he
frustrates
the counselsof rulers,"whichhe considerspropheticof
Christ'sResurrection
(Expositioin salmos,PG 17:165;table2,no.
to persecution/defeat
and subse16).Or notethegenericreferences
in
68
salvation
Psalm
that
certain
commentators
considered
quent
propheticof Christ'sdeath and Resurrection(table 2, no. 31),but
can be in factappliedto anysituationofdeliverancethroughdivine
help.Bycomparison,thepsalmsmentionedin Table 1referto rising,
awaking,and thedefeatofdeath,all ofwhicheasilybringto mind
theResurrection.
In othercases,thepsalmtexthas verygenericreferencesthatcan be connectedto severalChristologicalepisodesthat
sharecommon elements.In thesecases, the choices made by the
commentators
can be consideredrathersubjectiveand mightdiverge
fromone authorto another.Forexample,theologically
speaking,salvationreferences
can be relatedto Christ'sBaptism,Crucifixion,
or
and the mentionofGod's glorycan be linkedto the
Resurrection,
orAscension.Forexample,compare
Resurrection,
Transfiguration,
theinterpretation
ofPs. 17:47b,". . . blessedbe myGod and let the
God ofmysalvationbe exalted,"as a reference
to theResurrection,
to
theinterpretation
ofPs. 19:6,"We will rejoicein yoursalvation,and
in thenameofour God shallwe be magnified,"
as a reference
to the
Crucifixion(table2, no. 9 and table4, no. 1). In fact,in bothcases
wordsrightbeforeor afterthesepassagescould haveinspiredtheir
connectionto theResurrection
(Ps. 17:47a,"TheLordlives"and Ps.
19:7,"The Lord has savedhis Christ").But whileAthanasiosinterpretedPs. 19:5-7as propheticoftheResurrection,
Origenconnected
Ps. 19:6 to the Crucifixion(tables2, no. 10 and 4, no. 1). Underthe
column"relevantvocabulary"of mytables,I includepsalm verses
accordingto the criteriaI have specifiedabove,and I givespecific
explanationsforthevocabularyofeach Christologicalepisodewhen
I discussthemin themain text.InsidebracketsI reportverseswith
to more
vocabularythatI considerambiguous,becauseitmightrefer
thanone Christological
event.Forexample,comparePs. 77:16,"And
he broughtwaterout oftherock,"as a reference
to theCrucifixion
(table 4, no. 11)to Ps. 113:8,". . . who turnsthe rockinto pools of
water"(table5,no. 4) as a reference
to theBaptism.In patristicliteratureand liturgicaluse thewatermiracleofMoses at Horeb (Exodus
25
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
to follow closelythe practiceof the Stoudios monasteryin Constantinople.27As is well known, the
liturgicalnotations of the PantokratorPsalter follow the cathedralriteemployedin Hagia Sophia at
Constantinople,28while the liturgicalnotationsof
the Chludov Psalterand the Paris marginalPsalter
withboth thecathedraland the
indicatea familiarity
monasticrites.29
the
ninthcentury,the latterwas
By
of the
introducedfromPalestineto somemonasteries
and cencapital (includingthe Stoudios monastery),
turieslater prevailed over the cathedral rite.30The
two ritesfollowa different
divisionof the psalter,31
but theyhave manysimilaritiesin theiruse of spesources
cificpsalmversesforspecificfeasts,whichis themain
Liturgical
concernhere.32In the followinganalysis,anygeneral
I employthe same textsas in previousresearchby
referenceto the cathedralritedependson the inforthe Typikon mationprovidedin the TypikonoftheGreatChurchy
Cutler,Corrigan,and Walter,particularly
in
to themonasticriteis basedon the
the
Great
Church
of
(Hagia Sophia Constantinople) whileanyreference
informationin the TypikonoftheSavior. Although
as preservedin cod. Hagiou Stavrou40, dated to the
mid-tenth
centurybut believedto preservean earlier in the tables accompanyingthis researchI provide
A subsidiarysourceis the Typikonofthe informationfrom both typika, I give precedence
tradition.26
comto the Typikonofthe Great Churchforinformation
GreekMonasteryoftheSavior(a Greek-speaking
in
in
the
town
of
on
the liturgical correspondence between psalm
Messina, Sicily)preserved
munity
cod. Messinensisgr.115,dated to 1131and considered versesand majorfeastdaysfora numberof reasons:
in thesepsalms,
17:1-7,Numbers20:1-13),whichis referenced
was indeedrelatedbothto the Baptismand the Crucifixion
ofChrist(in thelattercase oftenwitha baptismalconnection
as well).See A. Semoglou,"L'icnesinatede la Crucifixion
.
36 et son contenu'mosaque':La dialectiquede la Passion,"
4 (2005): 11-21(hedoesnotfollowtheSeptuagint
Iconographica
ofthePsalmsemployedhere).In mytablesI connumbering
siderthevocabulary
ofthewater-producing
rockmoreapproandambiguous
inthecaseof
priatetoa Baptisminterpretation,
a Crucifixion
sincetheflowing
ofwateris more
interpretation,
characteristic
oftheformer
event(anditisa constant
component
ofpsalmexegesisas prophetic
oftheBaptism),whilethespillthanwateris morecharacteristic
ofthelatter
ingofbloodrather
event.However,
bothliquidsflowedfromChrist'spiercedside;
so thisis indeeda casewherethecomplexities
andsubtleties
of
anditsexegesisremindus thatrigidclassifications
are
Scripture
oftenproblematic.
26 Le typicon
dela Grandeglise:Ms. Sainte-Croixno.40yXesicle,
ed. and trans.J.Mateos, 2 vols. (Rome, 1962-63); forthe date see
i:xviii-xix.
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
66
MARIA EVANGELATOU
theTypikon
and geographically
of
Chronologically
theGreatChurch
ismuchclosertotheninth-century
psaltersthanis theTypikon
oftheSaviorinMessina.
thanthe
thatthecathedralritewas lessimportant
monasticone,atleastforthescribeoftheChludov
In myopinion,however,
thereareindications
Psalter.
ritewasatleastofequalimportance
thatthecathedral
to him,so I discussthisissuein somedetail.
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
rite.42
The
accordswiththecathedral
ritetowhichthey intoantiphons
thatthecathedral
opinionindicates
true
for
the
fixed
for
matins
to
him.
same
is
must
have
been
of
lesser
(prthro)
psalms
importance
correspond
in theuppermargins
of
thisomis- andvespers:
thisisonlyonewayofinterpreting
However,
theyaremarked
to
the
office
of
in
the
the
folios
sion,andother
appropriate according
Hagia
point
opposite
possibilities
might
that
In otherwords,theevidencesuggests
ifthescribewasmorefamiliar Sophia.43
Forexample,
direction.
or
not
the
Psalter
was
he
whether
Chludov
ritethanwiththemonastic
withthecathedral
rite,
producedin
itsmakersand userswerevery
mostly and fora monastery,
relying
mighthaveaddedthehypopsalmata
rite.Thisis notsurprising
withthecathedral
rather
thanon a written
source(iffor familiar
on hismemory
wheretherecently
in
he
used
a
codex
without
cathedral
ninth-century
Constantinople,
liturgical
example,
withthe
notations
tocopythepsalms).In thisway,hemayhave introducedmonasticritewas interacting
and wheremonksand monastic
unfa- cathedraltradition,
somehypopsalmata.
On thecontrary,
forgotten
For
institutions
were
linkedtothepatriarchate.
rite
have
with
the
monastic
would
closely
prompted
miliarity
whohasbeenmentioned
MichaelSynkellos,
himto usea written
thedis- example,
sourceto copyprecisely
in theproinvolved
In
as oneoftheclergymen
tribution
ofthekathismata
anddoxaionebyone.39
possibly
both
abbot
of
the
was
the
codex
duction
that
at
the
end
of
addition
records
ninth-century
psalters,
Corrigan
ofPatriarch
monastic oftheChoraMonastery
andchiefadvisor
textsthatprobably
reflect
thescribe
included
In myopinion,
thislastargument
practice.40
might
sug- Methodios.44
offers
furTheillustration
oftheChludovPsalter
was
and
used
that
the
codex
produced perhaps in
gest
and
between
themonastic
buton thewholethereis no substantial therproofofthisinteraction
a monastery,
it
but
at
the
same
time
ofindifference
toward
orlackoffamiliarity thecathedral
indication
spheres,
givespriofthetext
as muchas thestructure
thereis fur- macytoa patriarch
withthecathedral
rite.On thecontrary,
to thecatheritewascen- anditsliturgical
notations
tosuggest
thatthecathedral
therevidence
giveprimacy
which
that
the
traltothelifeofthepeoplewhoproduced
andusedthe dralrite.Corrigan
miniatures,
suggests
in
a
monk
as
the
Chludov
Psalter
ChludovPsalter.
"martyr,"
represent
in all three a groupofmonksas "therighteous,"
andmonksgivAs already
notedbyvariousscholars,
of
theassociations
alms,reinforce
ninth-century
psalterstheentiretextofthepsalms ingand receiving
with
a
monastic
of
the
cathethis
is written
to
the
verses
However,
manuscript
setting.45
according
long
versesofthePalestinian althoughthe presenceof monksin the Chludov
dralriteandnottheshorter
in comparison
withtheother
in theeleventh- Psalteris conspicuous
or monastic
rite(used,forexample,
where
no monks
two
in
the
Stoudios
Theodore
Psalter
ninth-century
psalters,
century
produced
marginal
in
it
is
not
as
for
in
the
Psalter
the
Chludov
as, example,
Moreover,
nearly emphatic
Monastery).41
appear,
whichwasproTheodore
number
oftheodesandtheirdivision theeleventh-century
andarrangement
Psalter,
ducedin theStoudiosmonastery
foritsabbot.In the
threeofthefive
ChludovPsalter,
onlytwoorperhaps
39 ForCorrigan'sview,see VisualPolemics,128,141,n. 8. She mentionsmissinghypopsalmatafor8 out of a total 68 antiphons(1,4,
7, 9, 12,26, 27,38). In anycase, I do not believethatthisomission
bears muchweightagainstotherargumentsthat clearlyindicate
theimportanceofthecathedralriteforthemakersand usersofthe
ChludovPsalter(seebelow).
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
68
MARI A EVANGELATOU
It is worthyofnoticethatin theChludovPsalter
we see figureswhose monasticidentificationis not
certain,fortheylack signssuch as the hood or the
schema.On thecontrary,
priests(morepreciselybishare
identified.48
This ambiguity
ops)
alwaysclearly
the
monastic
habit sharplycontrastswith
regarding
the preciseand consistentmannerin which monks
arerepresented
in theTheodorePsalter:in mostcases
in
dark
tunicsand mantles,and usually
theyappear
theywear a dark but still clearlyvisibleschemaand
analabos (scapularand harnessstrapsor cords).49
The
tunic and hood. The second is dressedin the same color (without
a hood), so he mightalso be a monk. The thirdman is younger,
with richuntrimmedhair and dressedin red,so clearlyhe is not
a monk.The Chludov miniatureforPsalm 111:9(foln^r) representsa charitableman (ANHP ) offering
alms to an
monk
with
a
brown
hood
and
below
which
is vismantle,
elderly
ible his brownschemaheld by a belt and his ochertunic.Behind
himstandsa groupofundifferentiated
youngmendressedin ocher
tunics(withouthoods, mantles,or schmas).The inscriptionnext
to themreads "poor" (FIENHTEC). Perhapsthe intentionis to
who will distributethealms
presentthemonkas theintermediary
offeredbythe charitableman to thepoor. Alternatively,
he could
be represented
as thefirstamongthepoor,foremphasison his austerewayoflife.It cannotbe excludedthathe is intendedto be the
leaderofa monasticcommunity(sincetheyoungmenbehindhim
are dressedin the same color as he and could be novices),but the
absence of hoods, belts,or otherclear identificationsignson all
thosefiguresat thebackrendersthisreadinguncertain,ifnotdubious. In the TheodorePsalter,in the illustrationof Ps. 36:26 (fol.
43v) all the charitablefiguresare clearlycharacterizedas monks,
but in the case of Ps. 111:9(folJ53V)
onlythe firstone is, making
morepossiblea similarreadingin thecorresponding
Chludovminiature.Der Nersessian,L'illustrationdespsautiersgrecs(n. above),
28 and 52,figs.74 and 247.
48 For example,John Chrysostomand PatriarchNikephoros
phelonion,and omophorionwithcrosseson fols.
wearingsticharion,
23V,47V, and 5iv.
(Der Nersessian,L'illustrationdespsautiers
grecs[n. j above],18,21,
22-24, 2.6,33,35,38-40, 41, 45-46, 5153-5456,figs.5,2.9,39,47,
57-58,109-, 121,125,44>J53>
57~58,6, 183,193>9723>2-42'>
254259-60, 263,281-82).Some ofthesefiguresare nuns,and also
wearschemaand analabos. Euphemia,who was not reallya nun,is
as suchon fol.163V(sinceshewearsschemaand analarepresented
bos abovehertunicand belowhermaphorion),and Theodora,who
led a monasticlifedressedas a monk,is actuallyrepresented
as a nun,
again with schemaand analabos (fol. 157).Der Nersessian,ibid.,
Psalter(n. 7 above),do not comment
53-54, and Barber,Theodore
on thedetailsofmonasticclothingin these(or other)cases. In the
TheodorePsalter,theconsistentdepictionoftheschema(scapular)
DUMBARTON OAKS PAPERS | 63
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
),whichmentionsthateach
brothershouldhave threedifferent
scapulars(a largewoolen one,
and twomore,one forworkand one forSaturdayand Sundaychurch
services).ThemaximumnumberforeachoftheotheritemsofclothingthatStouditemonkswereallowedwas tworatherthanthree.The
termusedin theGreektextpublishedin PG 99:i72oA-B is
("on the shoulders"),which is translatedas "scapular"in BMFD,
38).I takethisto be thesamepieceofclothingthatI term
1:114-15,
schema(seethediscussionin n. 46 above).
50 In the following count I do not include Old and New
Testament saints. I consider only figuresthat are haloed or
inscribedas ("holy")evenwhentheydon'thavea halo. See the
previousnotefora listofmonks(and a fewnuns) in theTheodore
Psalter,mostofwhomareeponymous.To themadd St. Onouphrios
Der Nersessian,L'illustrationdespsautiersgrecs,52,fig.
on fol.152V,
145 (not listedabove because he does notwear the monastichabit
butis naked). Othercategoriesof saints(mostlypriests,especially
bishops,militarysaints,and a fewothers)are depictedon fols.3V,
13V,15,20V,23V,27V,29V,32V,33V,35V,36V,38V,29V,40, 48. 49V,
55r57V, 76V,79V,8ir-v, 85V,89V,90, 95V,107V,109,2,
149V,158,163,165,167,169,ibid.,18,
127,130V,131V,
124V,125V,
21-32,35-39,42.-44 46-48, 5153-54figs6-7 2.4,2736,42.,47
51,55-56,60, 62, 66, 68-69, 82-83, 88-89, 94, 97, 123,127,13031,139,146-47, 155,176,179,185,202, 204-5, 211-12,239,256,262,
26 compositionswithsaintly
265,268,270. Thereareapproximately
bishopsorpriests(comparableto the27 withmonks),and about 10
withmilitarysaints(sometimesdepictedtogetherwithothertypes
ofsaints).
51 Thisis St.SymeontheStylit(on fol.3v).Comparethefivecases
of othereponymoussaintsbesidesPatriarchNikephoroswhom I
mentionbelow:the SevenSleepingYouthsofEphesos,fol.29;St.
fol.47V;ConstantinetheGreat,
George,fol.44;JohnChrysostom,
fol.58V;and Eustathios,fol.97V.Also,in additionto one anonymous
monkdepictedas a martyr(fol.22v),thereis a groupofanonymous
dressedin shorttunics(layworkmen?)beingbeheadedand
martyrs
St. George(militarysaint)beingtorturedon thewheelon fol.44,
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
7O I MARIAEVANGELATOU
58 Forexample,see fols.3V,5V,13V,
i6v,22,36.46,48V,51,56V,
59V,61V,73,7$v,8$r,87V,90V,97V,ioor,103,107V,114V,133,
139V,
uncialscriptis stillpreserved
in the
141V,
144,156.Theoriginal
foliosindicated
inbold.In theothercases,thenotations
areinthe
minuscule
ofthei2th-i3th
Psalterillustration
c, whenthecodexwasrewritten, 59 Tikkanen,
(n.14above),variousexamples,
script
butinmostcaseswecanbesurethattheyappearright
ontopofthe
Themes"
(n.15
e.g.,onpp.49,53,60,62,63;Walter,
"Christological
notations
ofthe9th
above),278-79.
original
DUMBARTON OAKS PAPERS | 63
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Patristic
sources
a
thesetwomanuscripts
includein theircommentaries
number
of
drawn
Christologicalinterpretations
large
one mayassumethatat
frompreexisting
compilations,
leastsomeof thoseearliersourceswerefamiliarto the
producersof the ninth-century
marginalpsalters.The
be used to determine
two catenacodicescan therefore
whetherthe Christologicalillustrationof the ninthcenturypsaltersdependsmoreon psalmcommentaries
oron liturgical
usage.I havealsotakenintoaccountpubcommentaries
lishedpsalm
(underthe namesof individualauthors),not onlybecausetheysometimeshave
absentfromthetwocatinterpretations
Christological
used here,butalso becausetheyshow
ena manuscripts
thebroadrangeofsourcesusedin thecreationofcatenae
on thepsalms:sourcesthatmayalso havebeenusedfor
includedin the
thecreationofthevisualcommentaries
marginalpsalters.
In thefollowinganalysis,theinfluenceofthelitis
comparedto thatofpatristicpsalm
urgy specifically
forthe
as obvioussourcesof references
commentaries
ofthepsalter,and notto patristicinterpreillustration
tationsofthepsalmsfoundin othertexts.Moderntools
like theBblia Patrsticareflectresourcesavailableto
scholarstoday,butnotwhattheplannersoftheninthcenturymarginalpsalterswould havehad at theirdisposal. Not onlyis it impossibleto guess the rangeof
otherpatristicsourcesasidefrompsalmcommentaries
but at
thattheymighthavetakeninto consideration,
timesit is misleadingto label suchsourcesas patristic
ratherthanliturgical.For example,psalm interpretationsfoundin patristichomiliesreadon specificfeast
days should be thoughtof as liturgicalratherthan
patristicsources,becauseitwas theiruse in theliturgy
thatmade themwidelyknown.Such caseswill notbe
discussedhere.
Since we do not have at our disposal the exact
liturgicaland patristicsourcesthatwould have been
availableto themakersof theninth-century
marginal
psalters,it is obvious that the resultsof the following investigationcannot be conclusive;theyare just
indicativeofcertaintendencies.Evenso,theycan conof the subject.Due
tributeto a betterunderstanding
thatthisinvestigation
to thequantityof information
number
of
tables
a
presentall
systematically
requires,
the evidence,and the conclusionsare summarizedin
theninth-century
marginalpsalters,waspurelydue to technicalreasons (legibilityoftherespective
microfilms).
DUMBARTON OAKS PAPERS | 63
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
72 I MARIA EVANGELATOU
Table i. Psalmsillustrated
in theninth-and eleventh-century
withChrist'sResurrection
Byzantinemarginalpsalters
Psalter
No.
Psalm Accompanying
illustration
7:7
9:33
11:6
David at Christ's
-r
L
Tomb
Relevant
vocabulary
'
a/^tjlij
i
Lord ... be exalted... awake
Anse,
Si
-*
s
j
S
jS
^
6r
v
X
v
X
i2V
David, Christ
a-^tji
1 jl
in j
Arise, Lord,letyourhand be lifted
9V
24V
i8v
David, Christ
. T ,
...
.
XT
Now will ITarise, saystheLord
v
X
,
i6v
__
X
nv
20V
77
/7
Ch
'
CO
2iv
._
^
44
44
55V
77
. ,
,
enemies be scattered
63
82V
109
104
A
Anastasis
God . . .
(is)' leadingforthprisoners...
Y
, b,dwell
,
n in
eventhemthat
tombs
,
63V
n
83
~r
X
83
109V
77:65
David, Christ
1
at -r
Tomb
78V
109
v
X
105V
136V
10
79:3
Holy Women
1
at lomb
Stirup yourdominance,and
il
come to deliver
us
11
81:8
Anastasis
12
101:14
43:24
David, Holy
L
,w
Women at -r
Tomb
43:27
67:2
Anastasis
o
8
67:7
13
106:14-16
'
A
A
Anastasis
Anastasis
When you
shallhavecompassion
for
arise,you
;
]
r
82V
X
..
142V
_.
.
.
c
,
Zion, tor the set time is come
ioov
He brought
themoutofthe
darkness
andshadowofdeath...
hecrushed
thebronzegates
134V
171
a C. Walter,
Themes
intheByzantine
from
theNinthtotheEleventh
REB 44 (1986):278.
"Christological
MarginalPsalters
Century,"
Die Psalterillustration
imMittelalter,
ActaSocietatis
Scientiarum
Fennicae31,no.5 (Helsinki,
J.Tikkanen,
1903),61-62.
(alltables)
Keytoabbreviations
norelevant
illustration
orinterpretation
X relevant
folioismissing
documented
directliturgical
use
documented
indirect
use
liturgical
~ noliturgical
usedocumented
inextanttypika
relevant
tomorethanoneChristological
scene
[ ] ambiguous
vocabulary,
vonLaodiceazu Psalm1bis50,"inPsalmenkommentare
ausderKatenenberlieferung,
3vols.,
Apollinarios "Apollinaris
ed.. Mhlenberg
York,1975-78),
1:3-118.
(Berlin-New
[CPG Supp.3681]
Asterios Asterii
commentariorum
inpsalmos
suntaccedunt
ed.M.
sophistae
quaesuper
aliquothomiliae
anonymae,
Richard(Oslo,1956).[CPG 2815]
ofAlexandria Expositio
Athanasios
inpsalmos,
PG 27:59-590
DUMBARTON OAKS PAPERS | 63
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
andtheIllustration
oftheNinth-Century
MarginalPsalters 73
Liturgy
Liturgicaluse
Psalmcommentators
Basil,236C, Pseudo-Athanasios,
669C-D
M)
*"
33
+^
.d
andsources
Description
Eusebios,i4iB,Didymos, 1.116.78
69r
27V
7or
_ __ .
^
112
Orieen,
Didymos,
I.SSS-4S2.
)))
^
y
' 1428B-C,
Eusebios,681D, Didymos,2.63.681,
Theodoret,1376A
Athanasios,293B-D, Didymos,
2.65.686,CyrilofAlexandria,1145C-D
24
I2V
Pseudo-Athanasios,984C
Asterios,ns:6, Pseudo-Athanasios,
^
1001C
2.7
/IT
I5OV
*
Eusebios,i257C-D,Hesychios,.276A
3i3v
I76r
.
__, ,
Tbeodoret,i74.A
335r
i9or
TOU
TSM 246.,
d.andtrans.M. Arranz(Rome,1969).
gr.us, A.D. 1131,
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
74 I MARIAEVANGELATOU
beforeGospelreadingsof
theyaresungas prokeimena
thematins,whichhaveas theirthemetheResurrection
(tablei, nos. 1-3,6-12). Two moreverseshavean indirectliturgicalaffiliation:
theyarepartofor aresimilar
to Easterhymnsthatat leastin one case weresungin
Hagia Sophia (table1,nos. 4, 13).However,onlytenof
thesethirteenversesarerelatedto theResurrection
in
sources
nos.
1,
1,
3-4,
6-9,
(table
11-13).
mycommentary
Thesenumbersgivea slightprecedenceto theliturgical
rather
thantheexegetical
factoras themotivation
forthe
illustration
oftheninth-century
But
this
small
psalters.
difference
is onlyan indicationof,nota conclusive
proof
oftheliturgical
factor.We shall
for,thepreponderance
havetoexamineall thepsalmversesthatwereinterpreted
quentlyrepresented.
as prophecies
ofChrists Resurrection
in thecommentaras suchin thepsalters,
to reacha
ies,butnotillustrated
Christs
Resurrection
moresolid conclusion.It shouldalso be notedthatall
thirteenversesillustrated
witha Resurrection
miniaChrist'sResurrectionis the most frequently
ture
contain
words
related
to
this
applied
easily
Christological
eventsuchas "rise,"
"standup,""saveus,""hecrushedthe
Christologicalinterpretationof the psalms in the
and themostfrequently
thewordingofthose
commentaries,
surviving
rep- bronzegates,"etc.Consequently,
resentedepisodein the ninth-century
verses
that
were
as propheciesofthe
marginalpsalpsalm
interpreted
ters.It appearsin severalversions:Christrisingfrom Resurrection
butarenotaccordingly
illustrated
mustbe
the Tomb,the Anastasis(JesusdefeatingHades and
takenintoconsideration
in thesearchforreasonsthat
can explaintheabsenceofsuchan illustration.
raisingAdam and Eve), the Myrophores(the Holy
Women at the Tomb), and David standingnext to
Accordingto thepublishedpsalmcommentaries
Christ'sSepulcher.Because the Resurrectionappears and thecatenamanuscripts
I haveconsulted,fifty-five
so frequently
in the textualand visual materialdispsalmsotherthanthosealreadyexamined(and somecussedhere,it is theperfectcase studyfora quantita- timesmorethanone versein eachpsalm,fora totalof
tiveanalysis.It providesdata fortheidentification
ofa
as prophetic
references
eightypassages)wereconsidered
of
which
can
then
to
Christ's
Resurrection
I
would
like
to sugspecificpattern liturgicalinfluence,
(table2).
be testedandverified
throughtheanalysisofother,less
gestthattheprincipalreasontheywerenot chosento
scenes.
be illustrated
witha miniatureofChrist'sResurrection
frequently
represented
Christological
into
account
all
three
maris
that
most
of
themwerenotusedin theliturgical
celeTaking
ninth-century
indications
from
the
Theodore brationofthatevent.Of thefifty-five
ginalpsalters(including
psalms,onlyeight
and BarberiniPsaltersforthemissingfolios),Christ's wereemployedin servicesrelevantto theResurrection
Resurrectionis depictedalongsidethirteendifferent accordingto the Typikon
oftheGreatChurch(table2,
versesin one or anotherof the iconographieversions nos. 2, 24, 30, 43-45, 51-52),and one moreis related
mentionedabove (tablei). One of theseverseshas no
to Eastercelebrations
althoughit is not mentionedin
orpatristicassociations,
butis verysimilarin
theTypikon
liturgical
oftheGreatChurch(table2,no. 13).In only
itswordingto anotherverseofthesamepsalmthathas
threeof thesecases could the wordinghave inspired
both(tablei, nos. $-6). Ten ofthethirteen
verseshave
an illustrationof Christ'sResurrection(table2, nos.
a directliturgicalaffiliation:
to
the
Typikon 2, 13,52).Six morepsalmswerepartof thecelebration
according
ofHoly
of Easteror of the followingweeksaccordingto the
oftheGreatChurch,
theyareusedin theoffices
Easter
or
the
week
after
or
monasticTypikon
Easter,
Saturday,
Sunday,
oftheSavior(table2,nos. 1,11,23,32,
but
in
46, 55), only twocasescan thewordingbe consid62 Seenotes7-8,above,fortherelationship
between
thesemanu- eredrelevant(table2,nos. 11,23).
andtheninth-century
Textcontinues
onpage82.
scripts
psalters.
DUMBARTON OAKS PAPERS | 63
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
andtheIllustration
oftheNinth-Century
Liturgy
MarginalPsaltersI 75
No.
Psalm
2:1
2:10
,
1
T,
I laydown
and, slept;
1aWaked
3:7-9
Lord;
j deliver
j 1 me,
Arise,
my
God
4:4
4:9
T ..... ,
, ,
I will he down in peace and sleep
5:4
6:5-6
'
y.6
Title
5
Psalm
commentators
Relevantvocabulary
J
- .
,
A
Among the hymns
forthe eight
Return, Lord delivermysoul
... who will acknowledgeyou in
Hades?
'
-
8:10
.1
1 11
shallyou
15:8-11 Hades,neither
your
allow
.
uln
HolyOne to seecorruption
16:3
16:13-14
17:8
, r _.
(cf.Matt. 28:2)
Didymos,i.i25.9
5v
27V
Origen,
115-9;
Eusebios,
96-97
"
7r
z9r
Pseudo-Athanasios,
, o ^ ^ .,
7v
659B-C; Cyril,
729-
-
Theodoret,888C)
Iir
^ov
Asterios,74. 11-18
Eusebios, 120A;
Athanasios, 76D;
ASterios,8i-86)z56
Asterios,105,107;
i8v-
Cyril,757A
19
-
Asterios,
34
46
33V
45V
^
Description
,
and sources
Ps. 2 wasthepsalm
fortheEaster
kathismata,
TSM 329.
Ps. 3:6wassungat
matinson Easter
Sunday,TGC :9;
Ps. 3wasthepsalm
fortheEaster
rormcLdsrer
TSM
kathismata,
329.
10
Eusebios,161A-B
. ,
33-
Athanasios, 109C
J
135, 225;
_ ,
1.180.97;
Didymos,
_
,
Theodoret,
961-65
u.
i,v
Origen, 1061B-C
1216A-B;
Origen,
. .
>
Didymos, 1.129.19
Arise, Lord
Theearthshookandbecamefearful
. ^o
.2 ^
S
Asterios,
7:16ff.
Didymos, 1.148.51
L 11not leave
1
1
...
You shall
mysoul in
TT
17:47
TheLordlives. . . andlettheGod of
1.1
11
mysalvationbe exalted
I9:5"7
. . . TheLordsavedhisChrist
(anointed)
Theodoret, 988B
41V
50V
Athanasios,
.i5D-iz8A
44
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
j6 I MARIA EVANGELATOU
TABLE 2. Continued
Liturgicaluse
No.
Psalm
Relevant vocabulary
Psalm
commentators
<j
"
.2 ^M
u.
"
a
js
*i
11
2OIS-O
Title
1249C;
_ Ongen,
,
Didymos, 1.219.167
Eusebios, 201C-D;
Athanasios, 132A;
4sr
^5
S3V
5)
46
54V
Cyril,837B-C
21:2022
_^ ,
Didymos, 1.230.188
48
56
- ,
Title
Ar
psalm ... on the firstday
; of the
,
Cyril,844C; Theo1
*
5OV
57V
13
iy'7~l
week
and sources
1 1 i.r
TT
He
asked lireor you andj you gave
1.1
1 ri
1 1 is
him length
glory
7 ... his 5
7
6 or days
salvation
ereat in your
;
0
Description
.:...29.
Pseudo-Athanasios,
731D
Allnci^ncm
/'11us10ns
to Pcs.
23:7- appearin
forEaster
hymns
andHolyWeek
Divine
"
which is a weekly
celebrationof
the Resurrection
(unspecifiedrite).a
14
27:7
15
29:6
29:9-12
16
32:10
34:2-4
iy
34:17
34:23-25
Athanasios, 149D;
Pseudo-Athanasios,
748D
57V
Eusebios 257D;
Awake, Lord
63V64
Didymos, 1.262.262
.
Eusebios, 261D
r
dance rorme
-
62
64r-v
Athanasios, 165B
70
69
Cyril,896C
'
7r
71V
Cyril,905C-D
8ir
73
Eusebios, 313B-C
82
73V
a S.G.
duPsaume23,7-10etdu
desportesduParadis,
proposdesillustrations
desportesdel'Enferetouverture
Tsuji,"Destruction
Psaume117,19-20,"CahArch31(1983):11.
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
andtheIllustration
oftheNinth-Century
Liturgy
MarginalPsalters 77
5
2
S
98r-v
8ir-v
Origen,1413B;
Athanasios,197D;
^ ,
Didymos,1.322..
o;
23.418;Cyril,996D;
Theodoret,
1165B
103
83
~
103
Psalm
commentators
18
39:2.-4
...
14.32
Apollinarios,
40:9
r
,
, n
. . . Surely,
hewho
sleepsshallnot
riseup?
r
40:11
.
,,
on meand
You,Lord,havemercy
.
.
... J
.
raisemeand I willrepay
r ; them
Athanasios,200A;
.,
A
Cyril,997A-D;
-,
^^
1168A-B
Theodoret,
20
44:9
Basil,403C-408A
21
45:6
23
111111
J L
on
shall
1048D
helphertowardsthemorning
48:16
ButGod shalldelivermysoul
fromthehandofHades,
me
whenhe receives
50:10
,bonesshall
'.
rejoice
54:17
a I .S
.
j
No.
,
L .
Relevant
vocabulary
y
22
^
.2 ^_
S
.
Psalm
19
use
Liturgical
Basil,453C
. .
.
^
Athanasios,241C;
ah
^
36.93
Apollinarios,
Eusebios,484D
b
<j
12
131V
X39r
83
89
96
99V
Ps. 54:17wassung
atvesperson the
first
Wednesday
afterEaster,TGC
2:102, 7^/254.
24
54:18-
20
i5
Description
j sources
and
57:7-9
Evening,
... he shall
and morning
delivermysoulinpeace
Origen, 1469A;
Eusebios,
484D-485A; Hesychios,1220A
Athanasios,
^D-zoA
I53V
IO4V
l68V
IO8V
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
78
MARIAEVANGELATOU
TABLE 2. Continued
Liturgicaluse
No.
Psalm
1
11
Relevant
vocabulary7
_ .
Title
26
27
171
58:17
60:7-8
Theodoret, 1323B-C
Pseudo-Athanasios,
gioryf
62:12
64:14
65:1-3
^^> ^
-2
M
%
896C
Didymos, 2.5455.660a
Cyril,1133A,Didymos, 2.55.661
77
-
:
192V
-
!9^
-2
*:
u I
Description
and, sources
109
""
Eusebios,
549D-552A
62:10
30
n _
1304B-C
'
61:3
29
Theodoret,
""
&>
j
Psalm
commentators
nov
ii5.r
115V
-
ii8r
week,
following
TGC 2:84,94,
249.
31
68:3
Cyril,1161CD
213V
123
68:14-15
a
bios, 744B-745A
Zl6r
I24V
68:21
68:30
Eusebios, 760A;
Pseudo-Athan.,
~
2I
928D
32
69:5
Eusebios,772C
r r
after
TSM
Easter,/
330.
33
70:19-21
Origen, 1520C;
Eusebios, 785C-D;
Athanasios,
321A-B; Theodoret,
1428A
226V
128V
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
andtheIllustration
oftheNinth-Century
Liturgy
MarginalPsaltersI 79
Liturgicaluse
N0.
Psalm
1.1
Relevant
vocabulary
Psalm
commentators
^
^"
.S3
M
Jj
j<
g
Description
and, sources
Pseudo-Athanasios,
960D (aboutthe
guardsat Christ's
Tomb)
35
77:5
Eusebios, 908B-C
265
139V
36
78:11
146
Title
Didymos, 2.140.830
37
80:2
38
83:11
39
y
Theodoret,
. ,
.
rr
j in
For one day
yourcourts is better
.
1
than thousands!
Eusebios,
_
. . .
1013C-1010A; Atha. _,
.
nasios, 36915
.
. . . For yourmercyis greattoward
Athanasios,
.
_. .
^
ret,1560B-C
'
274
152V
n
.
376B-C; Apolhnar- 277V111
ir
85:12-13 me;andyoudelivered
mysoulfrom .i_^,
10s,56.141;Theodo278
, ,
1
87:4-5
. . . MylifehastouchedHades ...
111dead
freeamong the
40
87:1014
42
1540A-B
. . . Will youshowyourwondersto
1 1 i^
t
. . . In the
the dead?
morningmy
willreachyou
prayer
88:13-5
88:4750
...
1.
. savehis
Who is hewho... will
... wrl
ir
,
,
1
1
soulfromthehandorHades?
89:14
in themornWe havebeensatisfied
we rejoiced
and
with
mercy;
your
ing
andweregladin all ourdays
_~~
Athanasios, 380B-
C; Pseudo-Athan.,
^ -J
1020D; Didymos,
2.160.871
,.
Lusebios,
. ^
,
1061C-1064C
Eusebios,1097D;
Athanasios,388D
Eusebios,1120A-B;
_ , . .
Pseudo-Athanasios,
.-.
1036B
-
l8or
X56v
281V
157V
286v,
7
i6iv
163V
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
8 ARIA EVANGELATOU
TABLE 2. Continued
Liturgicaluse
m
No.
1
Psalm
91:2
43
9I:5
li
Relevant
vocabulary
y
bb
j
Psalm
commentators
I
-
Athanasios, 404C
^
.2 ^
<
<-
'
*? ^
Description
r
and sources
J66r
44
92:1-2
95:i-3
Eusebios,
1184B-1185C; Athanasios, 408B
297V
167
3o3r
i7or
,
n
Ps.
95:10 was the
Pseudo-Athanasios,
io6iC,Didymos,
prokeimenon
2;.2.O.;91
45
95:9_IO
Pseudo-Chrysos^
torn,774
feasts,including
days afterEaster,
TSM 328; . was
the prokeimenon
of the baptismal
riteon Holy
Saturday,TGC
2:86, and the verse
of the alleluia on
the Saturdayafter
Easter, TSM Z55.
beforeMark
16:9-20at matins,
TGC 2:170;95:2
wastheprokeimenonon Annun
L on
ciationwhen
EasterSunday;
and 95:10wasthe
on
prokeimenon
the3rdSunday
afterEaster,TSM
142, 263.
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
andtheIllustration
oftheNinth-Century
Liturgy
MarginalPsaltersI 81
Liturgicaluse
^
No.
Psalm
103:15
r
i
li
Relevant
vocabulary
Psalm
commentators
4
103:22
bb
j
s
32-Ov
Pseudo-Athanasios,
1096C-D; Hesy321V
^>
u.
.S3 "fr
j
j
e
u s
107:3
48
108:2s29
49
109:3
50
114:8
51
5
117:24
7 ^
1
1
... I will awake early
-
Hesychios,
1309B-D
Eusebios, 1339A-B;
it
Hesychios, 1320D
Didymos, 2.254.1039
Forhe hasdelivered
mysoulfrom
.,
.
j
death
338r-v
i8ir
Basil, 492C
1584C; .
Origen,
A,
Athanasios, 480A;
*
lheodoret, 1817A
342-V
192
195
psalmon theSundayafterEaster,
TSMtfo.
chios, 1289A-B
47
Description
r
and, sources
344
359V
205
the
Divine Liturgy
,
Easter
of
Sunday,
^^^
-*
TSM
TGC
2:94,
248.
131:8
Arise, Lord
-
131:14
.
*t
Athanasios, 521D
138:16
138:18
_ .
,, A
Origen, 1664A
223V
142:8
.
,
Athanasios, 541C
Resurrection),
TTzC 2:172.
23
~
53
55
--
52
54
148:7
Didymos,
2.260.1280
235
~
Ps. 148 was the
antiphon of matins
'
, -w j
on the
5thWednesr
j
dayarterhaster,
TSM 268.
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
82
MARI A EVANGELATOU
Textcontinued
frompage74.
Of the forty-seven
psalms in table 2 forwhich
no liturgicalusage is reportedin the Typikonofthe
Great Church,the wordingof at least twenty-eight
withthe
wouldbe moreor lesssuitableforillustration
Resurrection.
Thepsalmsreferto salvationfromdeath
orHades,theyasktheLordto rise,standup,orsavehis
whichwas
people,ortheyincludetheword"morning,"
takenbypsalmcommentators
to alludeto
consistently
thehour of the Resurrection.Referenceto the number eightin the psalmswould also have been recognizedbywell-educated
as an allusionto the
clergymen
due to therelevantinterpretation
ofthe
Resurrection,
or
the
"first
of
the
week"
in
day
patristic
"eighthday"
tradition(cf.Table 2, nos. 5, 13).63
Since none of these
withtheResurrection,
itis obvipsalmswas illustrated
ous thata relevantreference
in thecommentaries
and
an appropriate
not
were
sufficient
to
vocabulary
inspire
a Resurrection
miniature.The decisivefactorforillustratinga psalm versewith this Christologicalevent
seemsto havebeenitsuse in theliturgy.
Yet thisalone
is notenough;thevocabularyoftheversemustalso be
For example,psalmsthatwereemployed
appropriate.
in theliturgical
celebration
oftheResurrection
accordto
the
the
Great
Church
ing
Typikon
of
(althoughthey
werenotinterpreted
in thepsalmcommenaccordingly
taries)butdo not containa vocabularythatobviously
refers
to thiseventarenotillustrated
in the
accordingly
ninth-century
marginalpsalters.64
Some specificexampleswill further
indicatethe
ofbothliturgicalaffiliations
and appropriimportance
ate vocabularyas prominentfactorsin the choice of
illustrationsubjectmatterin the ninth-century
marthreecases,psalmverses
ginalpsalters.In thefollowing
arerelatedto morethanone Christological
eventin the
commentaries
their
(and
vocabularysupportsall such
but
the
event
illustratedin the marginal
references),
psaltersis theone withliturgicalaffiliations.
Psalm 40
Accordingto the catena manuscriptsand the published psalm commentariesthat I have consulted,
verses9 and 11of Psalm 40 (table2, no. 19)are related
to Christ'sResurrection:
"Theywerespeakingunlawfullyaboutme.Now thathe sleeps,shallhe notriseup
again?. . . you,Lord,havemercyon meand raisemeand
I willrepaythem."Likewise,verses6 and 7 arerelatedto
theJewsandJudasrespectively:
"Myenemieshavespokenbadlyofme.When willhe die andhisnameperish?
Wheneverhe would come to see me,he would speak
hisheartgathered
slander;thenhewouldgo out
falsely;
and spreaditabroad."65
verse10is relatedto the
Finally,
Last Supperand thebetrayalbythefaithlessdisciple:
"Evenmyclosefriend,
whomI trusted,he who shared
Thewordmybread,hasliftedup hisheelagainstme."66
of
all
these
verses
fits
their
ing
respective
Christological
However,in the Chludov Psalterthe
interpretations.
arethosethathave,in addition
onlythemesrepresented
topatristic
affiliations.
justification,
liturgical
According
to theTypikon
the
Great
verses
and 10-11
Church,
2,
6,
of
werechantedas prokeimena
on MaundyThursday,
with
a similarliturgicalusagerecordedin the Typikon
ofthe
while theversesinterpreted
as propheciesof
Savior,67
the Resurrection
werenot used in the Easterliturgy.
no
miniature
of the Resurrectionappears,but
Thus,
ratherthereis depictedJudastalkingagainsthismaster
to theJewsand theLastSupperwiththetraitor
turning
hisbackto Christalongsideverses6-12.68
65 Origen, Selecta in Psalmos, PG i2:i4i3A-C; Athanasios,
Expositio in psalmos, PG 27:i97B-C; Cyril,Expositio in psalmos, PG 69 :99 6- ; Theodoret,Interpretatioin psalmos, PG
8:4-5.
66 This interpretation
appearsalso inJohn13:18.Cf. Athanasios,
Expositioinpsalmos,PG 27:2ooA; Cyril(ofAlexandria),Expositio
in psalmos,PG 69:997; Theodoret,Interpretatio
in psalmos,PG
80:1165c.
67 Mateos, Grandeglise,2:74. Accordingto the Typikonofthe
Savior,verses2.iob-n aresungat thealleluiaon MaundyThursday
(Arranz,Saint-Sauveur[n.27 above],236).
68
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
andtheIllustration
oftheNinth-Century
MarginalPsaltersI 83
Liturgy
Psalm87
Psalm 88
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
84 I MARI A EVANGELATOU
Psalm 23
Psalm 23:7-10 (table2, no. 13;table 7, no. 2) is interas referring
both to Christ's
pretedin commentaries
Resurrectionand his Ascension,and it is also used
in hymnscomposedforthe liturgicalcelebrationof
both events.In the Chludov Psalter,the eventillustratedis theAscensionratherthan the Resurrection,
nextto theimagemakesreferalthoughtheinscription
enceto both:"Liftthegatesofheavenand ofHades/'76
As Sahoko Tsuji has observed,theologicallythe two
eventsare interrelated,
as thebreakingof thegatesof
Hades and Christstriumphoverdeathlead to theliftarrivalof
ingofthegatesofheavenforthetriumphant
theascendingPantokrator.77
It is worthaskingwhythe
Chludov miniatureemphasizesthe Ascensionrather
thantheResurrection.
Thewordingprovidesa plausible
answer.Psalm 23:7-10 reads:"Liftup yourgates,you
princes;be liftedup,youeternalgates,so thattheKing
ofglorymaycomein. Who is thisKing ofglory?The
Lordstrongand mighty,
theLordmighty
in battle.Lift
up yourgates, princes;be liftedup,youeternalgates,
so thattheKing ofglorymaycomein. Who is he,this
Kingofglory?The Lord ofthepowers- he is theKing
ofglory."
When relatedto theResurrection,
theseverses
be
taken
to
allude
to
the
moment
when
Christ
might
breaksthegatesof theunderworldto liberatethejust
fromthebondsofdeath(and in thiscontext,thereferenceto "theLord mightyin battle"is fitting).78
When
relatedto theAscension,thesameversesmightallude
to theopeningof thegatesofheavenforthearrivalof
ChristPantokrator.
In fact,certaindetailsin thewordof
these
verses
ing
mightbe morecompatiblewiththis
event,ratherthanChristsdescentintotheunderworld.
In Christiancosmology,
thegatesofheavenarecertainly
moreancient,and therefore
morefittingly
describedas
76 Fol. r," TOT OTPANOT KAI
."Therelevant
folios
aremissing
inthePantokrator
andParis
Psalters.
marginal
77 S. G. Tsuji,"Destruction
desportesdel'Enfer
etouverture
des
proposdesillustrations
du Psaume23,7-10et
portesduParadis,
duPsaume117,
tothe
19-10,"CahArch
31(1983):5-33,withreference
illustration
ofPsalm23ina number
ofeastern
andwestern
medieval
manuscripts.
78 Indeed,on folio29Voftheninth-century
Psalter,
Stuttgart
whichissupposed
todependona modelcommon
inByzantium
and
theWest,Psalm23:24isillustrated
withChristbreaking
thegatesof
the underworld. See A. b.2L':tsoms>
Anastasis: TheMaking ofan Image
(Princeton,
1986),85-86,fig.19.
thanthegatesoftheunderworld
"eternal,"
(createdafter
heaven,afterthefallofsomeoftheangels,and afterthe
sin of Adam and Eve,whichled to the subjectionof
humankindto death).Thetriumph
ofChristoverdeath
and thefinalresurrection
ofthejuston theDay ofthe
Last Judgment
also implythatthegatesof Hades are
noteternal.The "princes"and the"powers"overwhom
theKingrulesaremorereminiscent
oftheangelsofthe
realmthanthedemonsofHell,whofollowthe
heavenly
ordersof theDevil. The gatesof theunderworld
were
notwillingly
the
of
but
openedby powers darkness, were
brokenbyJesus,whilethegatesofheavenwere
forcibly
not violatedwhen Christenteredthemaccompanied
Therefore
thepsalmreference
to the
byhis "princess."
eternalgatesthatmustopenfortheroyalarrivalis more
withthestoryoftheAscension.
compatible
It is alsoworthy
ofnoticethatPsalm23:7wasused
intheByzantine
attheconsecration
ofchurches,79
liturgy
and accordingto theTypikon
oftheGreatChurchitwas
also employedin the annual commemoration
of the
consecration
ofimportantchurchesofthecapital.80
In
otherwords,thispsalmwas connectedwiththededicationofa holyspaceto God andhistriumphal
entryinto
it.Suchan occasionis analogousto thereentry
ofChrist
Pantokrator
intoheavenafterhisAscension,especially
sincea Christianchurchwasperceived
as
bythefaithful
heavenon earth.81
Theliturgical
use ofPsalm23forthe
forexample,
79 It ismentioned,
inthe8th-c.Barberini
eucholoandE. Velkovska,
eds.,
gion(cod.Vat.Barberin.
gr.336),S. Parenti
Barberini
Veucologio
156.3).See
gr.336(Rome,1995),172(prayer
alsotheTypikon
inMateos,Grande
oftheGreatChurch
glise(n.
i6 above),1:186.
80 Mateos,Grande
dedication
of
(6 September,
glise,1:16.17-21
thechapeloftheTheotokos
inthechurch
ofSt.Anna);1:138.13-20
dedication
ofthechurch
ofChalkoprateia);
(18December,
1:146.1021(23December,
dedication
ofHagia Sophia;cf.1:144.25-27,
22
Psalm23:7chanted
asthenavegatesofHagiaSophiaare
December,
a celebration
thatseemsconnected
bothwiththefeast
ofthe
opened,
and
with
the
of
day
1:334.7-9,
l9 (9
following
approach Christmas);
dedication
ofthechurch
ofPege);1:344.23-26
dedicaJuly,
(18July,
tionofthechurch
ofTheotokos
1:354.10-15
Kallistratou);
(31July,
dedication
ofthechurch
ofBlachernai).
81 Forexample,
seethereference
I ofConstantinople
byGermanos
in hisEcclesiastical
and
1,"The
History MysticalContemplation
church
isan earthly
heaveninwhichthesupercelestial
Goddwells
andwalksabout."P. Meyendorff,
ed. andtrans.,
St. Germanos
of
On
the
Divine
(NewYork,1984),56-57.
Constantinople:
Liturgy
ofByzantine
orByzantine-inspired
church
Comparethedecoration
doorswiththemes
thatrefer
totheentrance
ofthefaithful
intopar"ChurchDoorsandthe
adise,as discussed
byM. EnglishFrazer,
DUMBARTON OAKS PAPERS | 63
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
andtheIllustration
oftheNinth-Century
Liturgy
MarginalPsaltersI 85
consecration
ofchurches
couldhavebeenanother
source
ofinspiration
forthepositive
visualinterpretation
of
the"lifted
thanthose
gates"as thoseofheaven(rather
ofhell)in therelevant
Chludovminiature.
Although
itisimpossible
toknowifthepeoplewhoplannedthe
illustration
oftheByzantine
rationalpsalters
marginal
izedinsucha way,itisworthconsidering
it,giventhat
sources
andliturgical
couldhave
commentary
practice
either
a
of
the
Anastasis
orofthe
inspired
representation
Ascension.
Whatiscertain
isthatthepeopleresponsiblefortheillustration
ofthesepsalters
wereoften
faced
withmultiple
had
to
choose
options.They
subjects
different
sources
ofinspiration
andvarious
among
possianditisworth
thatmight
bilities,
patterns
investigating
their
decisions
andilluminate
their
criteria.
The
explain
as
well
as
more
evidence
example,
following
presented
indicates
thatappropriate
was
below,further
wording
an important
factor
intheillustration
ofthemarginal
withspecific
psalters
episodes.
Christological
theTypikon
on the
oftheSavioritis theprokeimenon
sameday.83
to
the
sameliturgical
sources,
According
Psalm117is thethirdantiphonon thefeastof the
Epiphany(Christ'sBaptism),and verses26-27a are
on the sameoccasion.84
On theother
prokeimena
ofwhichI am aware
hand,no psalmcommentaries
these
verses
as
ofChrist's
interpret
prophetic
Baptism,
and thetextdoes not includewordsthatcouldbe
considered
obviousallusionsspecifically
to thisevent
(no mentionofwater).In sum,verses24 and 26 of
Psalm117wereliturgically
in thecelebraemployed
tionof theResurrection,
theEntryintoJerusalem,
andtheEpiphany.
Patristic
commentaries
mentioned
thefirsttwoevents;however,
thevocabulary
ofthe
versesthemselves
allowedforan obviousconnection
withonlytheEntryintoJerusalem.
Psalm117:26is
indeedillustrated
withtheEntryintoJerusalem
in
theTheodoreand theBarberiniPsalters,
suggesting
thatoriginally
a similarminiature
mighthavebeen
containedin theChludovand possiblyalso in the
Pantokrator
and theParismarginalPsalters,
which
nowlack therelevantfolios.85
The selectionof the
Psalm117
eventto be illustrated
heremayhave
Christological
tothepublished
commentaries
andcatena beendetermined
aboveall bytheuseofPsalm117:26
According
thatI haveconsulted,
Psalm117:24(table in theGospelnarration
oftheEntryintoJerusalem,
manuscripts
reference
to theResurrection: whichmusthaveinfluenced
the relevantpatristic
2,no.51)is a prophetic
"Thisis the daywhichthe Lord has made;let us interpretation
and liturgical
use ofthisverse.Since
theGospelswererevered
morethananyothersacred
rejoiceandbe gladin it."Thesameverseis usedas a
on
Easter
to
both
their
of psalm
text,
prokeimenon
Sunday,according
interpretations
Christological
theTypikon
the
Great
Church
and
the
verses
would
have
been
well
known
and
of
Typikon
of
particularly
theSavior.However,itswordingdoes notmakean
respected.On theotherhand,thisexamplemight
obviousreference
to Christ'sResurrection,
and it is also indicatethatin theByzantine
psalters
marginal
notillustrated
witha relevant
ofa psalmverseforillustration
withan
imageintheByzantine theselection
Verse26 ofthesamepsalmreads: appropriate
scenedependedlargely
on
psalters.
marginal
Christological
"Blessedis he whocomesin thenameoftheLord. itsliturgical
on therespective
feastday
employment
FromthehouseoftheLordwe blessyou."Thisverse and on theappropriateness
ofitswording.
Theverse
isrelated
toChrist's
bothin the chosenforillustration
EntryintoJerusalem
amongthreepossibleoptionsis
in
and
in
as
well
as
the
one
that
in
to biblicalandpatristic
addition
Gospels
psalmcommentaries,82
only
theliturgical
celebration
ofthecorresponding
feast
associations
alsohasliturgical
affiliations
andrelevant
to
the
this
the
Great
Church
verse
The
will
further
demaccording
Typikon
of
vocabulary. following
analysis
is thekoinonikon
on PalmSunday,
andaccording
to onstrate
theimportance
ofthelattertwofactors.
GatesofParadise:ByzantineBronzeDoors in Italy,"DOP 27 (1973):
145-62.
82 Matthew21:9 and Mark 11:9; mentionedby Walter,
Themes"
(n. 15above),272,no. 12.Origen,Selecta
"Christological
inpsalmos,
PG i2:i584.C-D;Athanasios,
inpsalmos,
PG
Expositio
inpsalmos,
PG 80:1817.
27:480;Theodoret,
Interpretatio
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
86 ARIA EVANGELATOU
Table 3. Psalmsillustrated
withChrist'sCrucifixion,
theCross,orotherrelatedscenesin theninth-and eleventhcentury
Byzantine
marginalpsalters
Psalter
No.
Psalm
Relevant vocabulary
_3
21:8
j>
.2
36
35V
19
ior
19
ior
IIV
v
X
23r
37V
21:17-19
2or
45:7
45V
xr
X
,r
X
r
79vc
68:22
me also gall
and made me drink
They
; gave
6
6 forrmyfood,
,
vinegarrormythirst
,
67
nn
88vb
x_
X
87V
114V
72V
98
96
124V
ft
,^
73:12
85:I7
86r
115
148V
98:5
98v
6v
X3IV
l68r
_
98:9
140
7r
131:7
ILL
place wherehis reetstood
IO1
I72V
223
nor
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
andtheIllustration
oftheNinth-Century
Liturgy
MarginalPsaltersI 87
Liturgicaluse
Psalmcommentators
-a
Origen,1253A;Asterios,134.25
Eusebios,208A-B; Athanasios,133A(Ps. 21:7)
Descriptionand sources
3
S
=
(2
cj
u
Used as thekoinonikonforthefeastofthe
ExaltationoftheCross on 14 September,
TGCi:3i,TSMi5
54V
<3
Origen,1257B;Athanasios,133D-136A;PseudoAthanasios,725B-C; Theodoret,1017A-B
.
A,
s^
Athanasios,216C
-
-la
-d
LireorDionysiostheAreopagite
~ .
_o r ,.
(Jngen,63;husebios,749-B;Athanasios,
a r j al
t^t^-j
321A;Pseudo-Athanasios,92SJJ;Didymos,
oo
r-ix-rLj
2.81-82.717;
Cyril,
1169; Iheodoret,1409
;
^
,.
Eusebios,861B;
ai.,/-.
Athanasios,336C
217V
9IV
i2$r
-, 1
, * n
Theodoret,1561A-B
Pseudo-Athanasios,1072C; Pseudo-Chrysostom,
781;Hesychios,1269A
Hesychios,1269B-C
_^__^^_^^_^
781
Pseudo-Chrysostom,
310
rr.L
o
'
or
Christmasand1Baptism,
24 Dec, 5Jan.),
TSM 330
Prokeimenonon 14 September(Exaltationof
theCross),TSM 25
_,
-
^!i_________^
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
88
MARIA EVANGELATOU
ChristsCrucifixion
The ninth-century
marginalpsaltersinclude miniaturesof the Cross or Christ'sCrucifixionin relation
to ninepsalmpassagesthatall havepertinent
wording
(table3,nos. 1-9):86theyeithermentiondetailscorrespondingto eventsoftheCrucifixion(like themocktherendingofgarments,
thebreaking
ing,thepiercing,
ofbones,thegallandvinegar,
ortheearthquake),
oruse
associated
with
expressions
traditionally
Golgothaand
theCrossin patristicliterature
(like"holymountain,"
"centeroftheearth,""footstool,"
"sign,"and derivative
and ).
In thecommentary
words,i.e.,
sourcesI consulted,eightof thesenine psalm verses
are relatedto the Crucifixion(table3, nos. 2-9), and
a liturgicalaffiliation
can be attestedforsevenofthem
nos.
1-3,5-6, 8-9).
(table3,
86
enth-century
marginalpsalters.
In thesamecommentary
sources,sixteenpsalms
otherthan those alreadymentioned(and sometimes
morethanoneversein eachpsalm)arelinkedto Christ's
Passionon theCross (table4). The wordingof at least
nineoftheseversesmighthaveprompted
an illustration,
sinceitcan be relatedto thecontempttheJewsshowed
towardChristwhenhe was hangingon theCross,the
abandonment
theearthquakethattook
byhisdisciples,
the
theredemption
place during Crucifixion,
brought
to humanity
and so on (table
throughChristssacrifice,
not one of
4, nos. 2-4, 6-9, 12,14, 16). Nevertheless,
themis employedin the liturgicalcelebrationof the
Crucifixion
totheTypikon
according
oftheGreatChurch
noneis illustrated
witha Crucifixion
and,predictably,
miniaturein the ninth-century
marginalpsalters.87
Likewise,ten psalms used in the liturgyof Maundy
87 Accordingto the Typikon
oftheSavior,one of thesepsalmsis
relatedto thecelebrations
forGood Friday(table4, number14).
Table 4. Psalmsthatwereinterpreted
as prophetic
ofChrist'sPassionon theCrossin Byzantine
psalm
but
were
not
illustrated
in
commentaries,
accordingly theninth-and eleventh-century
marginalpsalters
Liturgical use
No.
.2 ^
*c
bbrtMU^^^
Psalm
Relevant vocabulary7
Psalm commentators
19:6
~ .
_,
Or.gpn.n48B
3 .t
g .ti
,
and sources
magnified]
.
30:6
Into your
hands I will
'
. .
commitmyspirit
~ .
Ungen,
1300
30:1214
I becamea reproachamong
.
11mine
all
enemies
,.
, _,
Eusebios,269B
64
65
34:15-16
me
They
Jrejoicedagainst
&,
J sneered
. . . they
at me
Eusebios,308D-309A;
A
1
Athanasios,172C
Sov
72V
34:21
And theyopened
wide
, . mouth
,
their
upon me
. ,
.
.
Athanasios,i7sA
8iv
37:12
My friendsand my
neighbors... stood still;
.
and, mynearestorrikin
stood afaroff
. ...
12.26
Apolhnanos,
r
444
r^. ,
n
[G.rdyoursword]
Hesychios,1196A-B (sword
is theCross)
44:5
[Bendyourbow]
Cf. Paris,gr
^46
(bow is the
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
andtheIllustration
oftheNinth-Century
Liturgy
MarginalPsaltersI 89
TABLE 4. Continued
Liturgicaluse
No.
Psalm
48:8-9
Relevant vocabulary7
. . . Shall a man redeem?He
shall notgiveto God his
Psalm commentators
D .,
.2 *
*c
SbbSMU^^*
3 .a
g .ti
escrip ion
and sources
ii9r-v
Athanasios, 260C
163V
Theodoret, 1380C
Basil, 440B-441C
56:5
67:9
70:1011
,.
n _,
Eusebios, 780B-C
10
75:4
.
.
, A,
n
Pseudo-Athanasios, 960C
11
77:i6
Pseudo-Athanasios, 972D
,,
in
288V
i6ir
339
"J
192
J
Ps. 108was
thefixed
at the
psalm
. .
9thhour
ofGood
Friday,TSM
sharp dagger
12
13
'
_
107:8
* 11 1
1
And he brought water out
rill
ortherockj
You rejectedyourChrist
Athanasios,392B-C;
(anointed)... he became a
reproachto his neighbors Didymos,II. 176.891a;Cyril,
... you made all his
1210B
enemiesto rejoice
[God has spokenin
his sanctuary;
I will be
. j
, J ... .. ..
Sikima
14
thatflowedfrom
(thewater
.
,
. , .,
4^L
Christs sideon theCross;
_
.
, . ,
^
Pseudo-Athanasios,1133D
J7
o
108:25
I becamealso a reproachto
,
lu
them;when
theysaw me
shook
theirheads
they
109:2-3
w/
L
Zion
With
you is
dominionin thedayof
yourpower]
.
A,
Athanasios,
460D;
H ^ h '
542V
I94V
15
. A TT . .
^ .
Oneen,
b 1569A; Hesychios,
344
The mountainsskipped
like rams
16
[Who turnedthe rockinto
pools ofwater]
Hesychios,1332B-C (cf.
no. 11)
35ov~3$ir i99v-2oor
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
?0 I MARI A EVANGELATOU
Table 5. Psalmsillustrated
withChrist'sBaptismin theninth-and eleventh-century
Byzantinemarginalpsalters
Psalter
No.
Psalm
Relevant vocabulary
28:3
!
-5
-g l
*
!
"2
2
31
47V
44V
2ora
many waters
73:13
72V
98
i2$r
3
7
76:17
75V
/
^ '
(3V,Petr. 265)
xr
X
99
29V
113:3,5
117
164V
26v
154
113:8
L Hint
a
water
the
intospringso
2^v
l97v
in thisrespect.For example,scholarshavenotedthat
the iconographiedetailsof the miniatureillustrating
Psalm45:7 on folio45VoftheChludovPsalter(table3,
thelifeof
no. 4) also relateit to a traditionconcerning
In otherwords,itwas not
DionysiostheAreopagite.89
thatinfluthe
the
and
only liturgy
psalmcommentaries
enced the illustrationof the ninth-century
marginal
psalters,but otherpatristicsourcesas well. Another
case involvesPsalms4:7 and 85:17(table3,nos. 1 and
in theChludovPsalter
7),bothofwhichareillustrated
withtheCrossbearinga circularimageofChrist.The
88
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
andtheIllustration
oftheNinth-Century
Liturgy
MarginalPsaltersI 91
Liturgicaluse forthefeastoftheEpiphany
(Christ'sBaptism,6 Jan.),and theeveof5Jan.
Psalm commentators
i_.
r>.
HeSVChlOS, I241D-I244A
r L ^r> /- a
husebios,896D-C; Astenos,
^ .,
^
133:4-5;
Cyril,
II92D
*J
^
r r^ -1
Basil,289C-D; Didymos,
; .
,
,
I.260.255;Theodoret,1065A
59
y
242
253V
350V
.tS
u.
j3
J
$
.a
u%
I34V
L L
U
L
1
-C L
bybophroniosorjerusalemin his hymnsrorEpiphany
(unspecifiedrite).c
n
138V
words""
(Psalm 4:7) and ""(Psalm
an
association
with the Cross. In the
85:17)promote
case ofPsalm 4:7, thisconnectionappearsonlyin the
of theverseas a koinonikonon
liturgicalemployment
whentheExaltationoftheCross is cel14 September,
ebrated(table3,no. 1). In thecase of Psalm 85:17,it is
of Theodoretthatinteronlythepsalm commentary
pretsthe word ""as a referenceto the Cross
(table3,no. 7). The factthatbothversesareillustrated
in theChludovPsaltercouldindicatethatthedesigner
oftheillustration
eitherwas awareofboththeliturgical
orwas inspiredby
practiceand thepsalmcommentary,
one of thesesourcesin orderto applythe samevisual
to bothverses(becauseof theirsimilar
interpretation
he couldhavebeenawareof
vocabulary).
Alternatively,
theuseoftheword""
as a reference
to theCross
in otherpatristictexts,while ignoringthe liturgical
and psalm-commentary
references
mentionedabove.90
In otherwords,a strictdistinctionbetweenliturgical
and otherpatristic
works
sources,psalmcommentaries,
is not alwayspossible(or meaningful)in theexaminationofmarginalpsalterillustration,
as all threesources
seemto haveplayedan importantrole.Moreover,the
interest
in iconophilepolemicswas thecataoverriding
ofthemesthatmighthave
lystin thefinalpresentation
been
other
sources.Forexample,
inspiredby
originally
in thecase of Psalms4:7 and 85:17,thecircularimage
of Christ that appearshangingfromthe Cross is an
elementwithobviousconnectionsto iconophileargumentsabouttheequal (orevensuperior)venerability
of
to the exegeticaltraditionthat interpretsthe
90 For references
words""
and ""
of Psalms 4:7 and 85:17as referencesto theCross,see Corrigan,VisualPolemics,72,n. 53.
DUMBARTON OAKS PAPERS | 63
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
?2 I MARIA EVANGELATOU
holyiconscomparedwiththesignof theCross.91The
betweenliturgicalinfluences
interaction
sophisticated
and iconophilepolemicsin ninth-century
marginal
in
the
second
is
illustration
further
discussed
psalter
will
be
more
At
evidence
of
this
paper. present,
part
the
of
the
the
for
importance
liturgythrough
given
events.
oftwomoreChristological
examination
Christs
Baptism
Christ'sBaptismis depictedthreetimesin both the
buttheevidence
Chludovand thePantokrator
Psalters,
of the Theodoreand the BarberiniPsalterssuggests
Psalm
theexistenceof a fourthminiatureillustrating
from
the
now
28:3,
ninth-century
manuscripts
missing
sourcesavailableto me,
(table$).92In thecommentary
all fourpsalms are relatedto Christ'sBaptism.The
sinceitdoesnot
wordingofthetextfavorsthisexegesis,
taken
to referto
but
can
also
be
mention
water,
simply
son after
to
be
his
thevoiceofGod proclaiming
Jesus
in theJordan(Matthew3:17,Mark 1:11,
his immersion
Luke 3:22,Psalm 28:3);thedefeatof thedeviland his
demonsin thewatersofBaptism(Psalm 73:13);or the
characterof Christ'sBaptism,evidentin
supernatural
All four
theagitationofthewaters(Psalms76:17,113:5).
of
in
celebration
the
verses
are
also
used
liturgical
psalm
event(table5).
thisChristological
In the commentarysources, six other psalm
to Christ's
versesareconsideredas propheticreferences
of
them
is
None
employedin thecelBaptism(table6).
ebrationof theEpiphanyaccordingto the Typikon
of
in theninththeGreatChurch,and noneis illustrated
centurymarginalpsalters,althoughin mostcases the
wordingofthetextcouldhavemotivatedthedepiction
to agitatedrivers,
of Christ'sBaptism(e.g.,reference
hisSon,or anointingwithoil- analGod proclaiming
ogous to the anointingof Christand the initiatesby
Otherpsalmsusedin thecelebration
theHolySpirit).93
91 Ibid.,73.
Psalter
witha
inthePantokrator
92 Psalm76:17wasillustrated
it:
itdoesnotrepresent
scenethatalludestotheBaptism,
although
oftheJordan
towardthepersonification
Christis shownwalking
and anotherriver(Dufrenne,L'illustrationdespsautiersgrecs[n. %
with
thepsalter
above],28,pl. 13).Thefoliowascutfrom
together
ofSt.Petersburg
thatarenowkeptinthePublicLibrary
three
others
foliois3V.
ascod.165- therelevant
totheTypikon
93 According
oftheSavior,oneofthesepsalmsis
Psalm 113
Accordingto thecatenaeof codicesParis,gr.146 and
Marc. gr.17,verses4 and 7 of Psalm 113(table4, no.
16) arerelatedto theearthquakethatfollowedChrist's
Crucifixion:"The mountainsskippedlike rams,the
hills like lambs. . . the earth trembledat the presenceoftheLord,at thepresenceoftheGod ofJacob."
towater(the
verses3,5,and 8,whichrefer
Consequently,
ofwaterfroma
seaandtheJordanRiver)andtheflowing
in the
rock(allusionto Exodus17:1-7),wereinterpreted
to thewaterand blood that
samesourcesas references
had flowedfromChrist'ssideon theCross and to the
of theevent.In
baptismaland eucharistiesignificance
to Christ's
is
related
verse
cod. Marc.gr.17Z,
3 directly
ofthispassagefully
jusBaptismaswell,andthewording
with
than
a
connection
tifiesthisinterpretation
(more
see table5,no. 4): "Thesea lookedand
theCrucifixion;
fled,Jordanturnedback."In otherwords,thenatural
elementofwaterin whichChristwas immersed
during
contact.
his Baptismwas agitatedbythesupernatural
Thepsalmcommentaries
publishedin Patrologia
graeca
in relationto all these
preserveonlyone interpretation
to the blood and waterflowing
verses:the reference
in relationto
fromChrist'ssideduringhis Crucifixion
is
made
forverses3,
to
the
verse8. No reference
Baptism
5,and 8. The allusionin theabovepsalmpassagesboth
to earthquakesand the agitationof theJordanwould
justifythe depictionof both Christ'sCrucifixionand
literature
bothinterpretaBaptism.Indeed,in patristic
to themiracleofthewatertionsarediscussedin relation
flowingrockbyMoses at Horeb mentionedin Psalm
on5-7January
ofChrist's
tothecelebrations
related
(table
Baptism
6,number
$).
94 Psalms140,66:2-3,4-5,and6-8; 92:1-2;79:4,1,26,and27;
44:2-,,and4~sa; 148:1;31:1,114,and117(Mateos,Grande
glise[n.26above],1:176-86).
DUMBARTON OAKS PAPERS | 63
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Psalters
I%
andtheIllustration
oftheNinth-Century
Liturgy
Marginal
butwere
ofChrist'sBaptismin Byzantinepsalmcommentaries,
as prophetic
Table 6. Psalmsthatwereinterpreted
in
ninththe
and
notillustrated
eleventh-century
marginalpsalters
accordingly
Liturgical use celebrating
Christ's Baptism
<
No.
n
Psalm
2:7
5
J
r,
ii
Relevant
vocabulary
commentators
Psalm
Asterios,133.5-6
(cf.Matt. 3:17,Mk. i:n,
Lk.3:iz)
J2
S M)
. . . ThereforeGod . . .
has anointedyouwith
theoil ofgladness
beyondyourfellows
Cyril,1040B (Christ
anointedbytheHoly
Spiritduringhis
65:6
... Theyshallpass
throughthe river
(Jordan)on foot
Origen,1500A-B;
Eusebios,653B;
Asterios,133.1-2
198V
7i:8
r ,.
o -
Lusebios,804C-D
230
92:3-4
; j
The rivershavelifted
up theirvoices. . . the
, .
the
L sea are
billowsof
wonderful
97:8
The riversshallclap
1.1
1
1
theirhands together
.2 J
S ^
fe &
'
(J
2
*S
5
Description
andj sources
j
on vespersof
6 Jan.,
and
the fixedpsalm on 5Jan.,
TSM 97, 103,330.
Baptism)
~
r ,.
Eusebios,1192C
TT
,.
Hesvchios,
;
. n ^
1263JD-C
129V
,
167
Christs
Ascension
TheAscensionis depictedfourtimesin theChludov
as proPsalter,and all fourpsalmsare interpreted
to theAscensionin thecommenpheticreferences
sources
available
to me.Thewordingis fitting
tary
DUMBARTON OAKS PAPERS | 63
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
94 I MARIAEVANGELATOU
Table 7. Psalmsillustrated
withChrist'sAscensionin theninth-and eleventh-century
Byzantine
marginalpsalters
Psalter
No.
Psalm
17:11
i
J
J2
*o
1
,
he
new on thewingsorrwinds
14
v
X
v
X
i6v
27V
27V
22
2$v
41
voo
X
58v
8ir
77
7ir
95V
mounted
oncherubs
andflew,
i
23:7-10
Liftup yourgates,youprinces;
be liftedup,youeternal
gates,so thattheKing ofglorymay
come in. Who is thisKing ofglory?
The Lord strongand mighty.. . .
.
46:6
God is gone up
witha shout,theLord
?. . .
withthevoiceorra trumpet
4^v
5^:6
55V
107:6
5C
.* j
js
S
Relevantvocabulary
149
.2
189V
a Tikkanen,
Psalterillustration
, 63.
b
Psalterillustration,
63.
9; Tikkanen,
Tsuji,"Destruction,"
cIllustration
butthatwasaddedtonth-c.ones.
thatdidnotexistin9th-c.psalters,
forsuchan exegesis,
sincetheversesmentionflying
on cherubim
and winds,theopeningofeverlasting
ofthekingofglory,
andGod's
gatesfortheentrance
All four
abovetheheavens.
ascentandhisexaltation
verses
arealsousedintherelevant
celebration
liturgical
(table7).95
The samecommentary
sourcesconsiderverses
ofelevenotherpsalmsto be prophetic
references
to
95 Table 7,no. 5concernsa miniaturethatappearsonlyin theeleventh-century
marginalpsalters.
theAscension(table8); in eightofthese,thewordsince
ingcouldeasilyhaveinspiredan illustration,
it mentionsascentor dwellingin highplacesor in
theheavens(table8, numbers
1-4, 7-10). However,
noneof theseverseswas used in theliturgicalcelnoneof
ebrationoftheAscension,and predictably
in
withan Ascensionminiature
themis illustrated
The
theninth-century
psalters. antiphonal
marginal
oftheGreat
psalmsthat,accordingto the Typikon
oftheAscension
aresungin thecelebration
Churchy
in additionto Psalm46 do nothavewordingthat
DUMBARTON OAKS PAPERS | 63
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
andtheIllustration
oftheNinth-Century
Liturgy
MarginalPsaltersI 95
Psalm commentators
<j
**
-d
^
"
Description
and sources
37V
48
A,
^
*
Athanasios, 141C; Pseudo-Athanasios,
51V
58
.
. .
,.
r
r the
,
in various hymns ror
Extensively
J used
.
,
-r j 'h
c
c
,
reastortheAscension
rite).
_. ,
~
733B;Tneodoret,
1033B
Athanasios,
217C;Pseudo-Athanasios,
833D;
1208D
Cyril,1053B-C;Theodoret,
12V
0 2V
(unspecified
r
Ps.56:6isidentical
to 107:6,whichwasused
as theprokeimenon
attheDivineLiturgy
of
thefeast,
TGC 2:128;Ps 56wastheantiphon
TSM 329.
duringmatinsofthefeast,
Eusebios,
260C; Pseudo512A;Athanasios,
Athanasios,
876C
1312A-B
Hesychios,
Ps.46 wasthethirdantiphon;
Ps.46:6
wasusedatthematinsandtheDivine
ofthefeast,
TGC 2:128,184;Ps.
Liturgy
andtheverseat
46:6 wastheprokeimenon
thealleluiaandkoinonikon;
Ps.46 wasthe
ofthefeast,
TSM 271-73.
antiphon
338V
192
can be directly
relatedto thisChristological
event
are
not
in
the
(and
interpreted
psalm
accordingly
commentaries);96
consequently,
theyare not illustratedin the ninth-century
psalters.One specific
will
be
to
used
illustrate
moreclearlythe
example
of
affiliations.
importance liturgical
96 Psalms85,140,41,and45 (Mateos,Grande
glise,2:126-28).
Theantiphonal
intheTypikon
Savior(inaddipsalmsrecorded
ofthe
tionto46) are44 and45(Arranz,
Saint-Sauveur,
328).
inTSM.
Seeno.4. Notmentioned
Psalm8
In thepsalmcommentaries
and thecatenaemanuavailable
tome,Psalm8:2(table8,no.2) isinterscripts
as
toChrist's
Ascension:
Lord,our
preted referring
is yournamein all theearth!For
Lord,howmajestic
has beenexaltedabovetheheavyourmagnificence
ens."In thesamesources,
as wellas inMatthew21:16,
verse3 is relatedto Christ'sEntryintoJerusalem:
"Fromthelipsofchildrenand infantsI willordain
DUMBARTON OAKS PAPERS | 63
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
?6 I MARIA EVANGELATOU
but
ofChrist'sAscensionin Byzantine
Table 8. Psalmsthatwereinterpreted
as prophetic
psalmcommentaries,
in
the
ninthand
werenotillustrated
eleventh-century
marginalpsalters
accordingly
usecelebrating
Liturgical
Christ's
Ascension
No.
Psalm
7:8
8:2
i8:7
ii
Relevant
vocabularyJ
The congregationofnations
shallencircleyou,and forthis
cause you returnon high
.r
,
has
. .. ror yourmagnificence
Psalm
commentators
Athanasios,8oB;
Pseudo-Athanasios,
669D; Cyril,752A
Eusebios,128B;
A
,
111
been exalted above
, ,
the heavens
Astenos, 121.29;
_
^. ,
1.147.48;
Didymos,
L .,
^
Cyril, 757C
^.,
.211-12. iss
Didymos,
J
-g
as
%
2
g
Description
andj sources
34
ior
42-v
207V
122
2"
&&>*
.
<j
<*
15V
"a
end ofheaven
67:19
,,
,. ,
Pseudo-Athanasios,
^
67:34
Eusebios,720A;
Athanasios,303C-D;
Theodoret,1397B
68:30
Didymos,2.84.722a
84:9
Theodoret,1549
88:28
I shall makehim a
first-born,
higherthan
kingsoftheearth
i6or
90:11-12
He shallgivehis angelscharge
concerning
. shall
L 11L
bear
you
They
youupon theirhands
l65r
103:3
. . . He who makesthecloudshis
chariot,he who walks
on thewingsofthewind
Hesychios,1284B
179
112:5-6
thelowly
thingsin heaven,and
on theearth?
,.
Eusebios,1349C-D
11
131:8
223V
211V
317V
123
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
andtheIllustration
oftheNinth-Century
Liturgy
MarginalPsaltersI 97
In psalmos,PG
PG 23:740-41), 273nos. 9 (cf.Pseudo-Chrysostom,
55:761),20, 25; 274 nos. 29, 34, 39, 42, 43, 45, 47; 275 no. 50; 280
no. 73 (cf.Athanasios,Expositioinpsalmos,PG 27:312c). The broad
scopeofsourcesemployedin theselectionofsubjectmatterand even
certainiconographiedetails in the ninth-century
marginalpsalinwhich
culturalenvironment
ters- a clearsignofthesophisticated
thesemanuscriptswereproduced- is a subjectthatI hope to treat
in a futuremonographbasedon myPh.D. dissertamoreextensively
tion(see n. 9, above).
103 For theproblemof textualinterpretation
duringthe iconoclast crisisand its connectionto ninth-century
marginalpsalter
to liturgicalsources),see Corrigan,
illustration(withno reference
VisualPolemics(n. 3 above),113-20.
DUMBARTON OAKS PAPERS | 63
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
?8 I MARIAEVANGELATOU
Incarnation
wasforetold
intheOldTestament,
fulfilled psaltersis anotherexpression
ofthistheology,
also
in theNewTestament,
in the builton manylayersofmeaning.Someexamplesof
andregularly
celebrated
it
in
should
also
be
made
visible
themultiplicity
ofreferences,
withspecialattention
liturgy,
images.104
This argumentis openly emphasizedin a
totheliturgical
areexamined
below.
factor,
fewminiatures
witheucharistie
matter.105
subject
somecompositions
in theChludovPsalter
Moreover,
seemto base theirpolemicalmessagenot onlyon
Case studies
but
also
on
as
shown
iconophile
inspiration,
liturgical
in thesecondpartof thispaper.It appears,there- In thispartoftheinvestigation,
focuses
on
myanalysis
influence
on theillustration thesubjectmatter
andiconography
ofa fewmarginalfore,thattheliturgical
of theninth-century
andaimstohighlight
theirliturgiminiatures,
marginalpsalterscan also be psalter
considered
and
in connection
to thepro-Orthodox
or
polemically
pro-Orthodox specifi- cal references
and system- specifically
of
the
illustration.
The
callyiconophile,bothin its extensive
iconophile
message
aticinfluence
and in its conceptualfunction.This general
intention
istodemonstrate
notonlytheextent
accordswiththeviewthattheByzantine
was
but
also
the
of
influence
onthe
liturgy
sophisticationliturgical
in itsdefenseofOrthodoxy
militant
illustration
ofthesepsalters,
andtogivefurther
(althoughin a
proof
rather
than
a
of
the
interaction
between
the
various
sources
manner),
panegyrical
by
contesting
complex
thedogmatic
beliefs
andcon- oftheillustration
anditsoverriding
gradually
incorporating
iconophile
agenda.
cernsoftheChurchuntiltheywereeveryday
I
first
mention
twocaseswhichprovethateven
experiencesofthecongregation
thewords,images, whencertainminiatures
through
appearprogrammatically
the
and
entire
ofthe designed
topromote
an iconophile
movements,
objects,
mystagogy
message
seemingly
rite.106
Theillustration
oftheninth-century
to theliturgical
ofthepsalter,
marginal unrelated
employment
theinspiration
whichledtothechoiceoftheirsubject
matter
have
after
all.
might beenliturgical
104 K. Parry,
theWord:Byzantine
Depicting
Iconophile
Thought
TheMedievalMediterranean
oftheEighthandNinthCenturies,
12(Leiden,1996),125-32;A. Giakalis,ImagesoftheDivine:The
Ecumenical
Studiesinthe
Council,
Theology
ofIconsat theSeventh
of
Christian
54
History
Thought (Leiden,1994),78-81,103-6;L.
ArtintheNinthCentury:
Brubaker,
Practice,
"Byzantine
Theory,
and Culture,"
BMGS 13(1989):40-42; J.Lafontaine-Dosogne,
Visionsauxquelles
lesprophtes
dans
"Thophanies:
participent
l'artbyzantin
la
restauration
des
Art
aprs
images,"
Synthronon: et
de lafinde l'Antiquit
etduMoyenAge(Paris,1968),
Archologie
SeealsoCorrigan,
VisualPolemics,
to
135-48.
49-89,withreference
literature.
on theEucharist,
whichtheiconoprevious
Specifically
clastsperceived
as animageofChristandtheiconophiles
as Christ
seeS. Gero,"TheEucharistie
DoctrineoftheByzantine
himself,
Iconoclasts
anditsSources,"
BZ 68 (1975):4-22.
105 Suchas theCommunion
oftheApostles
Psalms
illustrating
a circular
iconof
33:9and109:4(orDavidandMelchisedek
flanking
ChristinsteadoftheCommunion),
discussed
Visual
byCorrigan,
TheIllustration
theChludov
Psalter
ofPsalmp8in
Theminiatures
Psalm98 on folio98Vof
illustrating
theChludovPsalter
discussed
(fig.1)areinsightfully
by
The
Cross
set
on
the
hill
of
corCorrigan.
Golgotha
toverse5:"ExalttheLordourGod andworresponds
ofhisfeet,
forheisholy."
shipatthefootstool
Corrigan
mentions
thatin psalmcommentaries
and patristic
literature
the"footstool"
wasconsidered
a reference
to theCross,andtherefore
is
the
exegesis
inspiration
forthisillustration.
Belowthisimageverse6,"Moses
andAaronamonghispriests
andSamuelamongthem
thatcalluponhisname,"is illustrated
withthethree
Polemics,55-59.
biblicalfigures
identified
to
byinscriptions.
According
106 Fortheissueofliturgy
as theology
R. Taft,
see,forexample,
MosesandAaron(thelatter
a censer
holding
EastandWest:
Problems
inLiturgical
Beyond
(Rome, Corrigan,
Understanding
and
like
an
dressed
Old
Testament
turn
See
also
Anastasis
for
Kartsonis,
priest) invenl997)>2-33-38.
(n. 78 above),227,
a reference
to thecanonsoftheCouncilin Trullo(691-692AD)
eration
towardthescrollsin Samuel'shandsthatrepthatemphasized
theyearly
andweekly
commemoration resent
liturgical
theholyscriptures
oftheJews.Shesuggests
that
oftheResurrection
in response
to variousheretical
beliefs;and
thejuxtaposition
between
theCrossandthethree
bibliSt.Germanos
Meyendorff,
(n.81above),42 fF.,
ofConstantinople
esp.
cal
the
scrolls
illustrates
an
figures
venerating
argument
theemphasis
onChrist's
inthe
Incarnation
48-52,oninterpreting
insupport
oftheveneration
oftheCrossandtheicons
ontheEucharist
Germanos
asresponse
to
commentary
byPatriarch
andiconoclasm
inparticular.
thatwasoftencitedin iconophile
sources:
as theJews
heresy
DUMBARTON OAKS PAPERS | 63
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
I 99
Psalters
oftheNinth-Century
andtheIllustration
Marginal
Liturgy
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
In theChludov
in theirholyscrip- carriesa circular
honorthewordofGod contained
imageofChrist).110
riteforthe
turesandnottheinkandparchment
withwhichthey Psalter,
onlyverse5 (usedin themonastic
arewritten,
the
honor
Christ
and
Exaltation
of
the
is
illustrated
with
a
Christians
cross;howCross)
similarly
thesaintsthrough
theveneration
oftheCrossandthe ever,thecathedral
riterecorded
in theTypikon
ofthe
iconswithout
the
or
the
wood
Church
offers
us
two
further
clues
for
worshipping
pigments.107Great
possible
This explanationilluminatesthe meaningof liturgical
influence
on theillustration
ofPsalm98 in
to thistypikon,
the
iconographiedetailsin the serviceof iconophile theChludovPsalter.
According
but
it
overlooks
the
affiliations
fourth
chanted
on
seems
to
14 September
polemics,
liturgical
troparion
on whichthechoiceofsubjectmatter
wasprobably refer
toPsalm98:5("ExalttheLordourGod
precisely
based.Cutlerdiscussestheuse ofverses5 and 9 of andworship
athisfootstool").
that"Today
Bydeclaring
Psalm98 in thecelebration
oftheExaltationofthe theprophetic
wordshavebeenfulfilled,
forbeholdwe
Crosson 14September
inthemonastic
andthecathe- bowinproskynesis
attheplacewhereyourfeetstood,
dralritesrespectively,
and makessomeobservations Lord,"thetroparion
seemstoalludetotheprophecy
of
the
influence
of
one
or
the
other
or
in
David
Psalm
that
mentions
the
"footstool"
of
rite,
98:$
regarding
evenofbothrites,on thispsalm'sillustration
in the theLordortheplacewhere
his"feetstood."111
Another
to mypro- sourceofinspiration
fortheillustration
ofbothverses
Byzantine
psalters.108
marginal
According
basisfortherepresentation
ofthe 5 and6 ofPsalm98 intheChludovPsalter
couldhave
posal,theliturgical
Crossin relationto Psalm98 wouldhaveenhanced beena troparion
chantedon thefirst
SundayofLent,
theauthoritative
valueofthisvisualcomment,
and whichwasdedicated
tothememory
ofMoses,Aaron,
wouldhavereinforced
anyiconophilemessagethat andSamuel,whenPsalm98:6wasusedas a stichosat
theentirecomposition
wasintended
topromote.
But thealleluia.Thistroparion
"Theassemannounces,
thereismoretobe saidregarding
influence.
of
the
withMosesandAaron,
liturgical
bly
prophets,
together
As alreadymentioned,
theninth-century
litur- rejoices
which
greatly
todaybecausetheCross,through
ofthePantokrator
Psalterreflect
have
saved
shines
and
their
us,
gicalnotations
only you
brings
prophecies
thecathedralrite,whilethoseof theChludovand totheirfulfillment."112
Thecombined
reference
tothe
ParismarginalPsaltersdemonstrate
interest
in and prophets
andtotheCrosson thedaydedicated
tothe
withboththemonasticand the cathe- three
biblical
in
mentioned
Psalm
familiarity
98:6
figures
mayhave
dralrites.In accordance
withitsliturgical
theircombined
on
notations, inspired
folio
98Vof
representation
thePantokrator
Psalterincludesa miniature
of the theChludovPsalter.
churchofGolgothain connection
to verse9, which
Theemphasis
ofthesetwotroparia
on thefulwasaprokeimenon
forthefeastoftheExaltation
ofthe fillment
ofprophecies
the
Cross
(i.e.,Christ's
through
Crossaccordingto the Typikon
the
Great
Church.109
us
another
Passion)might
of
help comprehend
yet
aspect
Theprophets
Perhapsthemostcharacteristic
exampleofthecom- ofthisChludovillustration.
venerating
binedinfluence
ofbothritesis offered
heldbySamuelcanbetakentohonor
bytheillustra- theholyscriptures
tionofPsalm98 in theParismarginal
where andtherefore
theirownprophecies
Psalter,
aboutthe
sanctify
bothverses5 and 9 areilluminated
of
the
Incarnation
in
contained
the
the
of
scrolls; fulfillment
byimages
Crossat Golgotha(in thesecondcase,thecrossalso theseprophecies
isvisualized
abovethembytheCross,
whichillustrates
theOld Testament
textofthepsalms.
In otherwords,theprophets
validatetheChristian
107 Corrigan,VisualPolemics,41-42.
108 Ibid., 41, note 72, mentionsCutler'sreference
to the use of
Psalm98 in thefeastfortheExaltationoftheCross,butin hermain
textshementionsonlypatristicsourcesand iconophilepolemicsas
thebasisforthecreationofthispsalm'sillustration
in theChludov
Psalter.See Cutler,"LiturgicalStrata"(n. 18above),22-23. For the
see table3,nos. 8 and 9 (Mateos, Grandeglise
liturgicalreferences
[. above],1:32;Arranz,Saint-Sauveur[n.27 above],25).
109 Fol. 140 (Dufrenne,L'illustrationdespsautiersgrecs[n. 5
above],33,pl. 21);Cutler,"LiturgicalStrata,"22,fig.9.
36).
111
,."Cf.Ps. 98:$:"
,."
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
andtheIllustration
oftheNinth-Century
MarginalPsalters
Liturgy
fitsthisexegesis.
Whatisofparticuvisu- passageperfectly
thatisprominently
oftheOld Testament
exegesis
ofverses1-2:"Why
hereistheillustration
withnumerous larconcern
theChludovPsalter
alizedthroughout
nations
the
then
did
the
and
The
illustration
of
Psalm
scenes.
98
conspire
peoplesplotinvain?
Christological
of
took
their
standand therulin
The
the
earth
miniatures
the
Chludov
the
whole
of
cycle
kings
justifies
the
Lord
andagainsthis
ers
the
truth
withimages
thatspecifically
Psalter
together
against
emphasize
gathered
theiconophile
oftheIncarnation,
andtherefore
psalters
argu- AnointedOne (hisChrist)."Mostmarginal
a minthe
text
include
this
of
that
still
foreseen
the
mentthattheevents
preserve part
by prophets
through
the
iature
relevant
to
Christ's
theirminds'eyeandphysically
by high
interrogation
byeyewitexperienced
reflect
notonly
Theseminiatures
andPilate.118
mustalsobevisible priests
nesses
atthetimeoftheIncarnation
also
the
but
icons.
The
fulfillment
the
toallChristians
commentaries,119
liturgicaluse
psalm
through holy
on
as
of
these
verses
validathe
and
ofOld Testament
prokeimena MaundyThursday
resulting
prophecies
and
toboththeTypikon
inByzantine according
faithisa basictheme
tionoftheChristian
oftheGreatChurch
Once more,thewording
andspecifically theTypikon
as wellas in pro-Orthodox
oftheSavior.110
liturgy,113
withsuchan exegesis.
is
of
the
makes
the
This
psalm fullycompatible
liturgical
iconophileexpositions.114
Psalterpreserves
the
Chludov
on
folio
2v
marthe
other
Psalter
on
the
influence
Chludov
However,
(and
theJews
scene:Isaiahreproaching
a totallydifferent
evenmoremeaningful.
ginalpsalters)
in Isaiah
theirLordas described
fornotrecognizing
the
above
is
inscribed
which
1:4,
image(fig.2). As
Psalter
2
in
the
Chludov
Psalm
TheIllustration
the
ChludovPsalter
of
the
reader
of
Corrigannotes,
wouldhaverecalledthatin Isaiah 1:3theprophet
All theByzantinemarginalpsaltersthatstillpre- says,"Theoxknowshisownerandtheasshismaster's
ofChrist's crib,butIsraeldoesnotknowme,"and wouldhave
servePsalm2:7 includea representation
thedecreeof theLord: the relatedthiswiththeox and ass thatappearadoring
Nativity:"Proclaiming
Lordsaidtome,Youaremyson,todayI gavebirthto ChristinthesceneofhisNativity
directly
represented
followIn
other
Isaiah.
of
the
beneath
lead
the
words,
was
This
verse
image
following
interpreted,
you'/'115
illustration
the
Isaiah
of
the
of ing patristic
1,
andHebrews1:5and 5:5,as prophetic
ofActs13:33
exegesis
to
bothin thepsalmcommentar- oftheChludovPsaltercombinestwominiatures
Christ'sIncarnation
Christas the
sinceitwas criticizetheJewsfornotrecognizing
useoftheverse,
andintheliturgical
ies116
of24 December(accord- Messiah,whenevenanimalswereabletoseethetruth
in thecelebration
employed
1 believethatin the
inJesus.121
oftheGreatChurchand the ofGod's Incarnation
ingto boththeTypikon
ofthispsalm eyesofninth-century
Thevocabulary
iconophilesthiscomposition
Typikon
oftheSavior).111
connotations.
wouldhavehadobviousanti-iconoclast
hadspecial
Incarnation
the
of
on
the
reality
Old Testament
113 Manyofthenumerous
incorporated Emphasis
excerpts
wereusedexactly
feasts
ofvarious
inthecelebration
Christological
of theNew Testament
becausetheywereconsidered
prophetic
inTables1,3,5,and7.
thecasesrecorded
events.
See,forexample,
114 Seen.104above.
fol.9V(Dufrenne,
fol.iv. BristolPsalter,
115 ChludovPsalter,
fol.
despsautiers
L'illustration
54,pl. 47). TheodorePsalter,
grecs,
despsautiers
V illustration
2(Der Nersessian,
grecs[. above],
fol.7V(Anderson,
Canart,andWalter,
Psalter,
18,fig.3).Barberini
iniPsalter[n.7 above],57-58).
Barber
PG 23:88A-B;
Commentaria
116 Eusebios,
Athanasios,
inpsalmos,
PG
PG 27:68A; Cyril,Expositio
inpsalmos,
inpsalmos,
Expositio
PG 8o:88oB.
69:721;Theodoret,
inpsalmos,
Interpretatio
117 Psalm2 was one of the threeantiphonalpsalmson 24
verse7,wereprokeimena
andspecific
verses,
December,
including
verses
andmonastic
onthesameday(cathedral
7band8 accomrite);
on thesameday(monastic
rite).See Mateos,
paniedthetroparia
Saint-Sauveur
Grande
Arranz,
r.152;
(n.27above),78,81.
glise,
Herodand
fol.2r:twoofficials,
118 TheodorePsalter,
probably
witha Jewwhopointsdown,towardAnnasand
Pilate,converse
des
L'illustration
Christ(Der Nersessian,
Caiaphasconfronting
of
rulers
the
fol.
Barberini
Psalter,
7:
17-18,fig.3).
psautiers
grecs,
Barberini
Christ(Anderson,
theearthwithout
Canart,andWalter,
fol.9:therulersoftheearthwithout
Psalter,
57).BristolPsalter,
despsautiers
L'illustration
Christ(Dufrenne,
53,pl.47).
grecs,
119 Eusebios, Commentariain psalmos,PG 23:8oD-8iC;
PG 27:64C-D; Cyril,Expositio
Athanasios,
inpsalmos,
Expositio
PG
PG
Theodoret,
69:720c;
inpsalmos,
Interpretatio
inpsalmos,
8:87-87.
120 Mateos,GrandeEglise,2:74;Arranz,
Saint-Sauveur,
235.In
hour
onthefirst
Ps.2:1.2isalsosungwiththetroparion
thistypikon,
matins
the
is
andtheentire
ofGoodFriday,
antiphon
during
psalm
onthesameday(ibid.,238,236).
VisualPolemics
121 Corrigan,
(n.3above),45-46.
DUMBARTON OAKS PAPERS | 63
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
102
MARIA EVANGELATOU
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
andtheIllustration
oftheNinth-Century
MarginalPsaltersI 103
Liturgy
forthe iconophiles,
who justifiedthe
significance
ofhishuman
of
Christ
on
the
basis
representability
ofbeingsiminature.122
Theyaccusedtheiconoclasts
lar to Jews,becausebydenyingChrist'srepresentlike
exactly
abilitytheyalso deniedhisIncarnation,
theJews,
whoopposedbothiconveneration
andthe
In iconophile
Incarnation
oftheMessiahinChrist.123
theiconoclastsare also said to be worse
literature,
thananimals,forunlikethemtheyare notable to
histruths.
This
obeytheirLord'swilland recognize
in
here
the
be
echoed
juxtaposition
comparison
might
iconooftheimpiousJews(alludingto theJew-like
and
the
obedient
animals.124
clasts)
observes
thatthetwoimages
Corrigancorrectly
on folio2voftheChludovPsalter"worktogether
to
makea statement
from
that
made
the
different
very
by
scenealone,"butherassertion
thatthisstateNativity
on theliturgy
or on psalm
ment"is notdependent
true:
the
is
not
entirely
liturgy
mightin fact
exegesis"
fortheillustrahavebeenthesourceof inspiration
theJews.125
tionofPsalm2:1-2withIsaiahreproaching
Isaiah
the
Great
to
the
Church,
Typikon
According
of
andthesecond
1:1-20is thelectionbetweenthefirst
ofversesfromthebeginning
prokeimenon,
consisting
on thefirst
ofPsalms1 and2 respectively,
Mondayof
Theconnection
ofPsalm2:1-2withIsaiah1:4
Lent.126
is therefore
madein theritualofHagia Sophia,and
as oneofseveralfactors
shouldbe considered
leading
hereandguiddiscussed
to thechoiceoftheimagery
sancofitsviewers.
practice
Liturgical
ingtheresponse
1
connection
ofIsaiah andPsalm
tionedtheexegetical
to Isaiah1:4
2:1-2;butthechoicetousethereference
for
the
Psalm
with
2:7 was also
Nativity
juxtaposed
commenother
sources
influenced
by
(e.g.,patristic
motivated
taries)andwasultimately
bythepolemical
to serve,as
Psalter
was
the
Chludov
designed
agenda
stresses.
rightly
Corrigan
of
I turnnowtothediscussion
ofa fewminiatures
hashad
inwhichliturgical
influence
theChludovPsalter
effect
not
andfar-reaching
a muchmoresophisticated
but
also
on
the
the
matter
on
iconography
only
subject
tothem.
viewer
ofthescenesandthepossible
responses
124 For example, in a passage fromthe Seventh Ecumenical
Council iconoclastsare describedas "moreirrationalthantheirrationalbeings,"because,contraryto animalsthatacknowledgetheir
creatorand followhis commandments,
theyare opposed to divine
law: Mansi i3:2i2C-D. For othersimilarexpressionssee,forexamtrsadversusConstantinum
ple,PatriarchNikephoros,Antirrhetici
PG ioo:72iB-C,
PG 100:276,477, Apologeticus,
Copronymum,
et
ed.
Featherstone
eversio,
,
740
(n. 123above), 58
Refutatio
(26:17-18); Theodorethe Stoudite,Epistles,in TheodoiStuditae
Epistulae,ed. G. Fatouros(Berlin,1992),244 (epistle126.6-7), 558
in Georgiimona(epistle402.6-10); GeorgetheMonk, Chronikon,
chiChronicon,
ed. C. de Boor (Leipzig,1904; correctedand re-edited
on fols.23V1978),780:17-18.Theminiatures
byP.Wirth,Stuttgart,
24 ofthe Chludov Psalterseemto referto the sameidea oficonoclastsas beingwilderthananimals.See theanalysisin Evangelatou,
"ByzantineMarginalPsalters"(n. 9 above),51-53.
125
126
Corrigan,VisualPolemics,4.
Mateos,Grandeglise(n. 26 above),1:12.
DUMBARTON OAKS PAPERS | 63
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
104 I MARIAEVANGELATOU
TheIllustration
64and6$
ofPsalms
intheChludov
Psalter
11:"You shallblessthecrownoftheyear(ortheannual
)
becauseofyourgoodcycle:
ness;and yourplainsshallbe filledwithfatness."The
Here I examineone of the mostobviousinstancesof
liturgicalusage of thisverseand of the entirepsalm
miniature mightofferthekeyto thesourceofinspiration
and the
liturgicalinfluencein a marginal-psalter
and attemptto disclosesomeof itsless obviouslayers intendedmessageofthisminiature.
of meaning.At the lateralmarginof folio6zv of the
Accordingto the Typikonofthe Great Church,
ChludovPsalter,twodeaconssoundsemantrato sum- Psalm 64:12 was sungas the stichosat the alleluia of
monthefaithful
to theliturgy,
whilethelowermarginis
theDivine Liturgyon 1 September,
thefirstdayofthe
filledwitha representation
ofPentecost
calendar
when
God's
(fig.3).Corrigan Byzantine
year,
blessingforthe
indicatesthatthedepictionofthedeaconsisa rareexam- nexttwelvemonthswas invoked.129
The entirePsalm
in whichliturgi- 64 was sungas the thirdantiphonon the same occaple of a marginalpsalterillustration
calpracticeis reflected
in thechoiceofsubjectmatter.127 sion.130Betweenthe singingof the entirepsalm and
moreextensive
indicates
thatliturgical verse12as thestichos,thelectionwas fromColossians
However,
analysis
influence
had an evengreater
effect
on thiscomposition. 3:12-16,whichbeginsand endswithphrasesreminisThe two deacons are connectedby means of a
centof thevocabularyand contentof Psalm 64:i4.131
reference
to
Psalm
"The
rams
of
the
flock
As
thepsalmistmentionstheramsclothedwithwool,
64:14:
sign
areclothedwithwool,and thevalleysshallaboundin
so theapostlementionstheflockofChrist,whichmust
be clothedwithChristianvirtues,132
and as thepsalmgrain;theyshallcryaloud,theyshallsinghymns."An
arrowlike
toward
the
deacons
is
attached
ist
mentions
the
of
the
Lord
nature,
signpointing
bythriving
praising
to the initialletterof thisverse.128
The deaconswho
so theapostlementionsthepraisingoftheLord byhis
summonthe faithfulare like ramsin a flock,leaders virtuouschildren.133
The flourishing
of natureand of
of the congregationthatpraiseGod forthe prosper- humansouls in prosperity
and virtueis thesubjectof
ityhe sendsto theplantsand theanimalsoftheearth the liturgyon 1 September,when the congregation
thewholeyear,as describedinverses12-14. wouldinvokeGod's blessingformaterialand spiritual
throughout
The firstofthetwodeaconsappearsrightnextto verse well-being
theyear.Accordingto thecathethroughout
dralrite,Psalm 64 playeda majorrolein theliturgical
127 Corrigan, Visual Polemics, 149, n. 13. The semantron
celebrationof thatday,not onlybecause it provided
is a woodenboardstruckwitha malletto summonthe
()
the thirdantiphonand its twelfthverse("you shall
faithful
to church.It is stillused in Orthodoxmonasteries
today.In
blesstheannual cycle"was thestichosat thealleluia),
theEcclesiastical
disHistorybyPatriarchGermanos,itis specifically
but
also becausethisverseinspiredthecentralpartof
cussedas thecall forthecongregation
to attendtheDivine Liturgy.
See below,p. 106.
thebasic troparionof thedaythatwas chantedthree
128 The initial ofthisverseis coloredwiththesamebluewith
times:at matins,duringtheprocessionthatfollowed
whichthearrowattachedto itwas painted.The arrowand colored
Psalm64 was also very
it,and in theDivine Liturgy.134
."
The
3:12:"
sameversesarecombinedin theTypikon
oftheSavior,Arranz,SaintSauveur(n. 27 above),14
133 Ps. 64:14: ",
."
Colossians
3:16:",
."
134 Mateos, Grandeglise,1:4.13-18,8.14,8.26-10.1.The troparion containedthephrase"blessthe annual cycle"("
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
andtheIllustration
oftheNinth-Century
Liturgy
MarginalPsaltersI 105
fig. 3 Moscow, State Historical Museum. Cod. 129,Chludov Psalter,folio 62V,Psalms 64:12-14
and 65:1-4. Deacons sound semantra;Pentecost.Rectangles highlightthe signs that relatethe
deacons to Ps. 65. Ovals highlightthe signs thatrelatethe apostles to the word "rams" of Ps. 64.
FromM. V. epkina, MiniatiuryKhludovskoi Psaltyri(Moscow, 1977); courtesyof the State
Historical Museum, Moscow.
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
io6 I MARIAEVANGELATOU
135 Arranz,Saint-Sauveur,
13:3-6,12:19.
136 Ibid.,13:11,
14:9,.
137 Likewise,on fol.io6v of the BarberiniPsalter,the two deacons are relatedto both Psalms64:14 and 65:1(Anderson,Canart,
and Walter,BarberiniPsalter[n. 7 above],94). On thecontrary,
on
fol. oftheTheodorePsalterthetwo deaconsare relatedonlyto
Psalm 65:1 (Der Nersessian,L'illustrationdespsautiersgrecs[n. y
above],36,fig.129).
138 Mateos,Grandeglise,2:220. Ps. 65 is also thefirstantiphon
of EasterSundayaccordingto the TypikonoftheSavior,Arranz,
Saint-Sauveur,
249.
199;A. Mantas, T
(843-1204) (Athens,2001),202
10,esp.204, 208,210.
140 Eusebios,Commentariainpsalmos,PG 23:648; Athanasios,
Expositioinpsalmos,PG 27:288; Cyril,Expositioinpsalmos,PG
69:11320.
141 Forexample,accordingto Eusebios,thefollowing
psalmsforetellthecallingofnationsbyChrist:2, 8,21,22,23,46, 56,58,64, 66,
67,71,80, 85,95,97,99, 101,106,107,112,116,and 127;Commentaria
inpsalmos,PG 2:68-72.
142 Mateos, Grandeglise,2:84. The sameuse is recordedin the
249.
Typikon
oftheSavior,Arranz,Saint-Sauveur,
143 See table2,number30.
144
" ."
DUMBARTON OAKS PAPERS |
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
andtheIllustration
oftheNinth-Century
Liturgy
MarginalPsaltersI 107
Resurrection
ofChrist,butinsteadmentionsthepraises
thatthewholeearthaddressesto God, a situationmore
oftheconversion
oftheworldtoChristianity
reminiscent
and the inaugurationof the Churchinitiatedon the
dayof Pentecost.Indeed,accordingto the Typikon
of
in the
Pentecostwas commemorated
theGreatChurch,
firstfourdaysafterEaster,whenPsalm6$ was thefirst
from
Thelectionsforthesedayswereexcerpts
antiphon.
On thefirst
totheeventsofPentecost.145
Acts2 referring
MondayafterEaster,whichwas dedicatedto theapostles,verses$,2, and 3 of Psalm 18werechantedduring
Thispsalmwas also chantedon
theDivine Liturgy.146
all themajorfeastsrelatedto Christ'sdisciples,includIndicativeofthisuse is theillustration
ingPentecost.147
ofPsalm18in theChludovPsalterwitha representation
SincePentecost
oftheApostlesteachingthenations.148
ofthe
celebrations
the
wasofcentralimportance
during
firstfourdaysafterEaster,whenPsalm65 was thefirst
context
thattheliturgical
itcan be suggested
antiphon,
andtheappropriate
wordingofthispsalmledtoitsilluswithPentecost.
tration
However,thisPentecostminiaturehas a peculiar
iconographiefeaturewhichalso relatesit to the ecumenicalcouncils:the throneof the Hetoimasiawith
theGospeland theHoly Ghostis placednotabovethe
apostles,as was thenorm(cf.fig.4), butbetweenthem,
exactlylikethethroneholdingtheGospelin representationsoftheecumenicalcouncils.Thesecouncilswere
trainByzantine
withPentecost
connected
intentionally
were
dition,inordertoproclaimthattheChurchFathers
divine
under
and
tradition
the
acting
following apostolic
betweenPentecostand the
guidance.Thisrelationship
thelectionwastakenfromActs2:14145 On MondayandTuesday,
Acts
from
on
21, Wednesday
2:22-36, and on ThursdayfromActs
Grande
See
Mateos,
2:38-43.
glise,2:98,100,102,104.Accordingto
theTypikon
254),Acts2:22and
oftheSavior,(Arranz,Saint-Sauveur,
38was readon Wednesdayand ThursdayafterEaster,butin thistypikon,Ps. 65was notsungas an antiphonon thosesamedays.
146 Mateos,Grandeglise,2:98.14.
147 See ibid.,2:215,iI9 fran indexofall thefeastscommemoratingthe apostlesin whichPs. 18:5was chanted.See also Tikkanen,
Psalterillustration
(n. 14 above),35-36.
148 Fol. 17. The same scene appears on fols. i9v-2or of the
TheodorePsalter(Der Nersessian,V illustrationdespsautiersgrecs
[. 7 above],22,figs.34-35),and fols.32r-voftheBarberiniPsalter
(Anderson,Canart,and Walter,BarberiniPsalter[n. 7 above],67).
A moreconciseversionof the same sceneappearson fol.31of the
BristolPsalter (Dufrenne,L'illustrationdes psautiersgrecs [n. 5
above],55,pl. 49).
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
MARI A EVANGELATOU
thesemicirsimilarities:
(figs.4-5) revealsthefollowing
on
culardisposition
oftheprotagonists
sitting benches,
otherparticipants
placed at thebottomcornersof the
position
page,and a thronewitha book in a prominent
at thecenter.In thePentecostscene,thethroneabove
theapostlessupportsa closedbook surmounted
bythe
In
Ghost.
the
council
the
throne
in
the
scene,
Holy
middlebetweentheChurchFatherssupportsan open
theusualpracticeatecumeniGospelbook.Thisreflects
cal councils:theenthroned
bookstoodforthepresence
ofChristand oftheHoly Ghostwho had inspiredthe
andwouldalsoinspire
theactsofthecouncil.154
scriptures
Comparisonof thesetwo miniatureswith that
on folio 62Vof the Chludov Psalter(fig.3) makes it
obvious that in the latterthe thronewith the open
book relatesmorecloselyto the iconographyof the
ecumenicalcouncilsthan to Pentecost.The throneis
morea realobjectstandingbetweentheapostlesthan
a symbolfloating
abovetheirheads.Thepositionofthe
throneamongtheapostlescannotbe consideredaccidental,an accommodationmade forthelack of space
abovethefigures,
wherethethronenormallyappears
in standardPentecosticonography.
Thereare numerous examplesofPentecostrepresentations
in Byzantine
and
icons
where
the
throneis
manuscripts portable
omittedaltogetherfromthe compositionbecause of
lackofspace.155
in theChludovPsalter
Consequently,
154 Walter,
desconciles,
147-48,mentions
thatthe
L'iconographie
fig. 4 Paris,Bibliothque
Nationale.Cod. gr.510,folio
enthronement
oftheGospelas a symbol
ofthepresence
ofChrist
Photocourtesy
ofBibliothque
301.Pentecost.
is attested
intheThirdEcumenical
Council(Ephesus,
431),while
nationalede France.
itsdisplay
isalsomentioned
inthreeotherecumenical
councils:
the
Fourth(Chalcedon,
III, 680),and
451),theSixth(Constantinople
theSeventh
of860and
(NiceaII, 787),andalsoatthelocalcouncils
To theseI addthereference
totheGospel
869atConstantinople.
in twoletters
to theactsoftheFifthEcumenical
related
Council
II, 550),Mansi9:188,189AandC. Walternotes theillustrated
(Constantinople
codiceswiththeliturgical
homiliesof Gregory
"unebrveallusion"
tothepresiding
oftheGospelinthe
presence
ofNazianzosexaminedbyG. Galavaris,TheIllustrations
ofthe
oftheSixthEcumenical
theacts
Council,butinreality
proceedings
Nazianzenus(Princeton,
LiturgicalHomiliesofGregory
1969),
ofthiscouncil
tothepresence
oftheGospel: 80-81.In fouroftheseminiatures,
givethemostreferences
lackofspacehasledtotherepMansi11:3240,381A,460C, 521D,553B,585E,605D,616E,629D
resentation
ofthescenenotinitsusualsemicircular
arrangement,
edition
Concilium
(mostrecent
byRiedinger,
Constantinopolitanumbutin a horizontal
similarto thatoftheChludov
arrangement
tertium,
176,166, 408, 522,$76,636,672, 694, 764). Walter, Psalter(figs.48-49). In thesecasesthespaceavailablebetween
desconciles,
147,. 145,mentions
L'iconographie
onlytwopassages, thetwogroupsofapostles
couldhaveallowedthedepiction
ofthe
Mansin:224E,232D(Riedinger,
Concilium
Constantinopolitanumthrone,
whichis,however,
omitted.
Inthetwelfth-century
Pentecost
theGospel mosaicin SantaMariaa Grottaferrata,
Tertium,
40,50).On folioi6rofthePantokrator
Psalter,
an empty
throne(withno
is depictedon a benchamidtheparticipants
in theiconoclastic
ofa horizontal
comGospelorHolyGhost)appearsin thecenter
councilof815,attesting
tothewidespread
ofthe
usageofthedisplay
flanked
ofapostles.
thisisa modHowever,
position
bytwogroups
councils
Vision
andMeaning,
212, ernaddition
(Brubaker,
Gospelinecclesiastical
tothemosaic,
andwedo notknowwhatwasoriginally
withreference
tofurther
literature).
there.See E. Kitzinger,
"TheMosaicsin theCappella
represented
155 For example,in thenineteendepictionsof Pentecostin
Palatinain Palermo,"
ArtB31(1949):278-79n. 55.Kitzinger
sees
DUMBARTON OAKS PAPERS | 63
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
I 109
Psalters
oftheNinth-Century
andtheIllustration
Marginal
Liturgy
Nationale.Cod. gr.510,folio
fig. 5 Paris,Bibliothque
Council.
Ecumenical
Second
Courtesyof
355.
France.
de
nationale
Bibliothque
in themosaic(allusionsto theLast
connotations
eschatological
iftheempty
havebeenemphasized
would
These
allusions
Judgment).
the
wasoriginally
throne
(as a referapostles
among
represented
so thiscouldbe another
enceto thefuture
comingoftheJudge),
scene
ina Pentecost
ofthethrone
theunusual
casewhere
placement
G.
of
an
additional
Matthiae,
toward
layer meaning.
point
might
/ mosaicidell'Abbaziadi Grottaferrata
(Rome,1970),270,sugParousia(presence
a Pneumatos
geststhatthismosaicrepresents
in
I assume,itscontinuous
oftheHolyGhost,meaning,
presence
I wasnotableto conandnotjustduringPentecost.
theChurch,
from
theinformation
I retrieved
sulta copyofthispublication;
ofS. Maria
"TheIconography
ofP. O. Folgern,
thebriefmention
A ReadingofthePictorial
a Grottaferrata:
Cyclesin theLightof
BollGrott
andMariology,"
theByzantine
66-67 [2002-3]:
Liturgy
initssemicircular
ofPentecost
arrange257,n.1).Forrepresentations
theeleventh
iconsdatedfrom
inportable
thethrone
mentwithout
see P. Vokotopoulos,
to thefourteenth
:
century,
l8>36,42-,83,86,107,113,
131.
1995).figs.
(Athens,
in a positionatodds
thedecisiontodepictthethrone
of
withconventional
iconographythesceneindicates
withtheecumenitheintention
toconnectPentecost
cal councils.While thedovebelongsto theiconogof
to thesymbolism
it also refers
raphyofPentecost,
the enthroned
Gospel in the ecumenicalcouncils,
oftheHolyGhost.In fact,
to
the
referring inspiration
in one instancetheimageoftheenthroned
Gospel
related
surmounted
bytheHoly Ghostis definitely
council.On folio107Vofthetenthto an ecumenical
ofecclecod.
Paris,
suppl.gr.108$(collection
century
siasticalcanons),suchan imageappearsat theend
of thecanonsof theSeventhEcumenicalCouncil,
intendedto denotethedivineinspiration
obviously
text.156
of therelevant
Analogousallusionsmaybe
sceneon folio6zvofthe
to thePentecost
attributed
is reminiswherethecomposition
ChludovPsalter,
the
amid
centoftheenthroned
participants
Gospel
councils.Sucha choiceis perfectly
oftheecumenical
wellknownforthe
in a manuscript
understandable
aspectofitsillustration,
pro-Orthodox
polemically
is onlyone
us thatliturgical
andreminds
inspiration
illustraof
this
creation
the
which
on
ofmanyfactors
tionwasbased.
miniaofthisPentecost
Thepolemicalovertone
reinforced
with
and
be
can
ture(fig.3)
by
paralleled
ofthe
ofthesounding
overtone
thepossiblepolemical
semantron
depictedrightabove.In hisEcclesiastical
ofConstantinople
the
History, iconophilepatriarch
the
that
Germanosstates
soundingof the semanofthe
tronis notonlya signalfortheinauguration
fordemonstokeep
butalsoa warning
DivineLiturgy
thepatriarch
awayfromthechurch.Moreprecisely,
of
the
represents trumpets
saysthat"thesemantron
to battleagainst
theangelsandcallsthecontestants
thedeaconsin
theinvisibleenemies."157
Therefore,
as ifwarning
be
Psalter
theChludov
may perceived
tokeepawayfromtheChurchall theyear
evilspirits
twopsalmsbasicto the
round,sincetheyillustrate
the
calendarandtheeccleof
inauguration
liturgical
the
their
siasticalyear.With
semantra,
theyprohibit
fromviolatingnotonlythespacebut
evilintruders
theecumenical
alsothetimeoftheChurch.Likewise,
thepeculiariconography
councilsalludedtothrough
desconciles
156 Walter,
(n.139above),61,fig.28.
L'iconographie
St. Germanos
157 Meyendorff,
(. 8 above),
ofConstantinople
56-59 (2.).
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
I MARIA EVANGELATOU
oftheDivine
and solemncelebration
bytheorderly
bothofwhicharebasedon sacredtraditions
Liturgy,
Theallusionto theperpetual
anddivineinspiration.
of
the
thefigures
of
Church
cycle
through
liturgical
thedeaconsrevealsthecontemporary
and continuous relevance
ofPentecost
forthelifeoftheChurch.
As in theinauguration
of ecumenicalChristianity
in
and
the
reafErmation
ofitsecumenical
(Pentecost)
Orthodoxdoctrines(thecouncils),theHolyGhost
descendsto bestowdivinegraceon God'speoplein
the celebration
of the Divine Liturgy(thecentral
.eventin thelifeoftheChurch).In fact,thebelief
oftheOrthodoxChurchin thedescentoftheHoly
Ghostduring
theDivineLiturgy
isconsidered
a main
reasonfortherepresentation
ofPentecost
or ofthe
Hetoimasiaofthethronein thebemaofByzantine
churches.161
Folio6iyoftheChludovPsalter
presents
a different
visualexpression
ofthesameidea,with
on thepolemicalsignificance
oftheDivine
emphasis
and
the
of
the
Liturgy
inspiration
HolyGhostin the
evil
and
fight
against spirits
(repelled
bythesemantra)
heretics
(condemned
councils).
bytheecumenical
Thisillustration
is characteristic
ofthesophistication
andcomplexity
ofliturgical
influence
andits
158 Such accusationsare in line withthelongtraditionof
use
in
the
service
of
Christian
authors
pro-Orthodox
polemicsin the
namingthedevilandhislegionsas theinstigatorsofdisorder,
sin,andheresy.
See,forexample,
JohnofDamascus, Byzantine
psalters.In thiscase,theinflumarginal
Contraimaginumcalumniatores
orationestrs,in Die Schriften
des
enceoftheliturgy
is notrestricted
to thechoiceof
Johannesvon Damaskos, ed. B. Kotter (Berlin-New York,1975),
matter
on
the
basis
of
the
use
ofpsalmverses
subject
3:69 (2.2, 3.1),71 (2.4, 3.1-2),72-73 (2.6, 3.3),124 (3.13);acts of the
in
butextendsto thevisualization
of
feasts,
specific
SeventhEcumenicalCouncil, Mansi i3:6oD-6iB, 205A-B, 225E;
more
and,
PatriarchNikephoros,Antirrheticus
PG
liturgical
ceremony
(semantron-sounding)
3,
ioo:4ooA, 493B, 513C,
toiconographie
PG :57-, 580B, 601B-604A, 605B, 621A,
choicesthatreflect
liturApologeticus,
importantly,
ed.
629D-632A, 641B,645A, 704B, 716B,74.$A, Refutatio
eteversio,
and
Another
gicalsymbolism,
significance, theology.
Featherstone
(n. 123above),12(6:58-59),13(7:26-27), 20 (10:48oftheinteraction
betweenliturgical
influexample
49), 42 (19:52-55),196 (111:51-70),198(112:21-22).For examples
ence
and
or
pro-Orthodox specifically
iconophile
fromotherChristiantextssee:EpiphaniosofCyprus,Panarion,PG
examined
polemicsis detectedin thelastminiature
41:368, 545D, 673D, 857A,1065C; acts of the ecumenicalcounfor
the
which
makes
reference
tothesacraments
ofbapcils, example sixth,Mansi n:629E, 636A,66oD-E, 697C-D,
here,
728D, 732D-E, 736C. See also C. Mango,Byzantium:TheEmpire
tismandexorcism.
in ordertoprotect
ofPentecost
werealsosummoned
in otherwords
theChurchfromdemonicintruders,
to be agents
theheretics,
whowereoftenconsidered
ofthedevilandpossessedbydemons(an accusation
frequently
expressedin iconophilesourcesagainst
theiconoclasts).158
Thecomplementary
function
of
thetwominiatures
is evenindicated
the
reference
by
themto therelevant
signsconnecting
psalmverses:
on theonehand,signsconnectthedeaconsto both
Psalms64:14and6$:i;159
ontheotherhand,Pentecost
is paintedrightbelowPsalm65:4,whilereference
signsrelatetheapostlesto theword"rams"ofPsalm
In otherwords,
thesameverseisrelated
both
64:i4.160
tothedeaconswholeadthecongregation
intheinauofthecalendarandliturgical
andto
guration
cycles,
theapostles
whoareinspired
toleadthepeopleofthe
earthin theinauguration
oftheecumenical
Church
ofChrist.In combination,
thetwominiatures
onthis
of
the
ChludovPsalter
enhancethesigpage
mutually
nificance
andpolemicalaspectoftheirmessage:the
ChristianChurchinaugurated
at Pentecostis conthe
ecumenical
councilsand
stantly
by
safeguarded
TheIllustration
Psalter
6/intheChludov
ofPsalm
Folio 65oftheChludovPsalteris one ofthemost
in theentirecodex(fig.6). Three
illuminated
densely
different
versesofPsalm67 areillustrated
withthree
an icon of
separate,yetinterrelated
compositions:
161 Mantas,To
(. 139
above),202-15.
DUMBARTON OAKS PAPERS | 63
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
miracleevolv- 31reads:"Rebukethewildbeastsofthereed."Since
exorcism
SaintPaul,Christ'sgreatest
the"wildbeasts"
identify
psalmcommentators
ing aroundit, and below them,the storyof the certain
thatthe
Ethiopianeunuchbaptizedby the apostlePhilip. withdemonsandthedevil,itisnotsurprising
witha sceneofexortheir"rebuking"
arefullyjustified artistillustrated
and thelastcomposition
Thefirst
wereinterHowever,
manymorepsalmverses
psalmverses. cism.167
bypatristic
exegesisof therespective
to thedevilor demonsbutwere
theyoungest,
Verse28,"Thereis Benjamin,
ecstatic," pretedas references
so
in theChludovPsalter,
as a reference notillustrated
inpsalmcommentaries
wasinterpreted
accordingly
confurther
needs
Psalm
to
to SaintPaul becausehe descendedfromthetribe theattention
67:31
given
ofthisexorcism
Thespecific
ofBenjamin(Romans11:1,Philippians3:5),was the sideration.
epiidentity
and sodewillbe ourstarting
oftheApostles("theyoungest"),
lastsummoned
pointin thisinvestigation.
at Christ'scomalludedto bythe Sinceone ofthedemonsdeparting
had intensevisionary
experiences
man
the
from
mand
inscribed
Theiconon folio6$ris
word"ecstatic."162
possessed is inscribed
previously
typeis "Legion"()168and theuncleanspiritsare
(), buttheportrait
"Benjamin"
thatofSaintPaul,withhislongdarkbeardandbald headedtowardtwo pigs,thisminiatureillustrates
an inhabtowhichJesusfreed
on Mark5:1-20,according
miniature
head,holdinga codex.In therelevant
demons
of
multitude
a
from
with itantofGerasos
a medallion
(approfolio85ofthePantokrator
Psalter,
a
namedLegion)thatsubsequently
possessed
a similarfigureis actuallyinscribed"SaintPaul" priately
and
themtofallovera precipice
( ).163Psalm67 no longersur- herdofswine,causing
be
to
considered
was
This
below.
waters
in
the
drown
"and
Verse32,
vivesin theParismarginalPsalter.164
the
since
exorcism
miracle,
expelled
outherhandto God,"wascom- Christ'sgreatest
Ethiopiawillstretch
driven
before
and
were
demons
numerous,
as
away
commentaries
in
the
being
psalm
monlyinterpreted
most
the
of
"Son
as
the
Christ
how
high
Acts8:26-40,whichnarrates Philip theyrecognized
foretelling
connect
commentators
Two
God"
of
Christ.165
name
in
the
eunuch
$:7).169
an
(Mark
psalm
baptized Ethiopian
miraexorcism
Atthelowerleftpartoffolio6$r,theapostlemeetsthe verse2 ofPsalm67 withthisparticular
onfolio
whoplannedtheillustration
Theperson
theprophe- cle.170
eunuchwhoisshownona chariot
reading
been
have
Psalter
Chludov
the
of
to
by
inspired
may
65
ciesofIsaiahon hiswayhomefroma pilgrimage
theinterpretation
related
he
but
these
commentaries,
underto
man
the
has
After
Jerusalem. Philip taught
is evenmore
verse(31),whosewording
ofthetextanditsfulfillment to a different
standtherealmeaning
insteadof"riseandlet
thewildbeasts,"
"rebuke
and PassionofJesus,theeunuch fitting:
in theIncarnation
verse
in
as
2,whichisillustrated
enemies
disperse"
askstobe baptizedinthenameofChrist.Thisis rep- your
the
in theChludovPsalterwith Anastasis.However,
onthelowerright
resented
partofthefolio.166
ofexorcism
tothesacraments
related
sources
on thesamefolio liturgical
miracle
Theexorcism
depicted
inthe
influence
a
had
have
and
Verse
topsalmcommentaries.
greater
related
might
isonlyindirectly
baptism
162 Origen,Selectain psalmos,PG 12:1509;Eusebios, Commentaria in psalmos,PG 23:712;Athanasios,Expositioin psalmos,PG
De titulispsalmorum,PG 27:917
27:3OiB-C; Pseudo-Athanasios,
to Hesychios
is now attributed
work
this
to
CPG
3:6552,
(according
ofJerusalem);Cyril,Expositioin psalmos,PG 69:1156;Theodoret,
inpsalmos,PG 80:1393.
Interpretatio
163 Dufrenne,L'illustrationdespsautiersgrecs(. 5 above),27,pl.
. Likewiseon folioio6v oftheBristolPsalter,ibid.,60, pl. 53.
164 Ibid.,41.
165 Eusebios,Commentariain psalmos,PG 23:717;Athanasios,
PG
Expositioin psalmos,PG 27:303c; Cyril,Expositioin psalmos,
PG
in
80:1393.
Theodoret,
69:1160;
Interpretatio psalmos,
166 The same scenes illustratePs. 67:32 on folio 85V of the
Pantokrator
Psalter;see Dufrenne,L'illustrationdespsautiersgrecs,
27,pl. .
inpsalmos,PG 23:713-16;Athanasios,
167 Eusebios,Commentaria
Pseudo-Athanasios,De titulis
PG
in
27:303;
Expositio psalmos,
inpsalmos,PG 69:1157.
PG
27:920;
Expositio
Cyril,
psalmorum,
as in Sepkina,Miniatiury
168 Mistakenlytranscribed
(n. 4 above).
169 According to Mark 5:12-13,the legion of demons asked
two thouChrist'spermissionto possesstheherdof approximately
in
mentioned
is
detail
This
close
sand swine grazing
probably
by.
orderto indicatethegreatnumberofdemonsexpelledbyChristand
miracleis menemphasizethe magnitudeofhis miracle.A similar
demoniacsof
two
the
of
tionedby Matthew8:28-34 (the healing
Gadara).
170 Eusebios, Commentaria m psalmos, b 23:679-81, ana
De titulispsalmorum,PG 27:912.
Pseudo-Athanasios,
DUMBARTON OAKS PAPERS | 63
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Hl
M ARI A EVANGELATOU
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
andtheIllustration
oftheNinth-Century
Liturgy
MarginalPsaltersI 113
in theByzantine
riteofbaptism.174
Theexorandperception
ofthiscomposition
andits readings
conception
connection
withthebaptism
oftheEthiopian
eunuch. cismofdemonsthatmighthaveheldthesoulofthe
In theritefollowed
catechumen
beforehis or her
the
Greek
Orthodox
undertheirinfluence
todayby
riteofiniwasa basicthemeintheChristian
Churchin casesofexorcism,
Psalm67 is recitedin baptism
to
the
Barberini
to tiation.175
full.171
Thesameriteincludesa prayer
attributed
According
eighth-century
thesecondofthethreeexorcism
in whichtheonlyspecificexor- Euchologion,
JohnChrysostom,
prayers
riteincluded
ofthebaptismal
atthebeginning
is thatoftheGerasene,
as the recited
cismmiracle
mentioned
ofthemultito themiraculous
ofsuchmiracles
mostmemorable
andpowerful
expulsion
per- a reference
in Mark5:1-20.176Specific
Thedifficulty
hereistodetermine tudeofdemonsnarrated
formed
byChrist.172
canbetraced
back mentionis madeofthefactthatthedemonsasked
whether
modern
Orthodox
practice
topossesstheswine(Mark5:12In
the
totheByzantine
published Christ'spermission
period.
euchologion
This
was
considered
proofoftheirpowerlessness
manuscripts 13).
byJacobGoarin1730,basedonByzantine
Psalm67 is indeed and byanalogyimpliedthattheirexpulsionduring
toeleventh
oftheeighth
centuries,
The
ritewouldbe equallysuccessful.177
fora sick thebaptismal
when
those
used
mentioned
praying
among
of
the
that
evidence
above
an
exorIn
that
demons.
edition,
expulsion the
suggests
by
personpossessed
onfolio65oftheChludovPsalter
is similar uncleanspirits
toJohnChrysostom
attributed
cismprayer
may
to theEthiopian's
reference be seenas complementary
a specific
totheoneusedtodayandincludes
baptism
ofdemons
andexpelling
totherebuking
refer- as a reference
Thecombined
oftheGerasene.173
tothemiracle
it
is
In
this
rite
of
in
the
context, particuencetoPsalm67 andMark5:1-20inthesamecontext
baptism.
theswine
narrative
in
the
that
for
a
source
of
have
been
ofexorcism
Gospel
larly
significant
inspiration
may
ina lakeafter
ofverse31on folio65oftheChludov andthedemonsendupdrowned
theillustration
falling
into
the offa precipice(Mark5:13).Theirdisappearance
oftheGerasene.
Psalter
withthemiracle
Moreover,
thisexorcism
choiceto represent
episodeon thesame
folioas thebaptismoftheEthiopianeunuchmight
ofthese 174 Mateos,Grandeglise(n. 26 above),1:186;2:62,138.
mention
havebeeninspired
bythecombined
atthe 175 Cf.JohnChrysostom,Eightbaptismalcatchses,
inthetextsemployed
inHuit catevents
twoNewTestament
chsesbaptismalesindites,d. and trans.A. Wenger,2nd ed., SC
rite.
baptismal
50 (Paris, 1970), 139-40 (2.12); idem, ThreeBaptismal Catchses,
to theTypikon
oftheGreatChurch, in
According
Troiscatchses
baptismales,d. and trans.A. Pidagneland L.
thebaptism
Acts8:26-40 narrating
thepassagefrom
Doutreleau, SC 366 (Paris, 1990), 44-46, 188-94 (2.6-7). The
byPhilipwasone oftheNew Testament expulsionofdemonsis a veryprominentelementin today'sGreek
performed
to
171
(fromnow on referred
,
as Euchologion)
,
'
13thed. (Athens,1998),288-91.
,
172 Ibid.,312.
sivrituleGraecorum
173 J.Goar,Euchologion
(Venice,1730;repr.
Graz,i960), 575,582e.On page 584,anotherexorcismprayermakes
to Mark 5:1-20 (esp.5:8-9, theexpulsion
thesamespecificreference
ofthelegionofdemons),as well as to Mark 9:15-29 (esp. 9:25,the
exorcismand healingofa deaf-mute
boy).Thisprayeris also found
in theBarberiniEuchologionofthe 8th (Parentiand Velkovska,
Barberini[n.79 above],226-27,prayer207). ForthedatL'eucologio
the
of
manuscriptsused byGoar (whichincludethe Barberini
ing
Byzantind'exorcisme(Ms.
Euchologion)see L. Delatte, Un office
de la Lavra du MontAthos,20) (Brussels,1954),10 (themanuscript
publishedbyDelatte is ofthe 18thc). The use of Psalm 67 to repel
demonsis attestedquiteearly,forexample,in thelifeofSt.Anthony
the Great,13.7,G. J.M. Bartelink,ed.,Athanased'Alexandrie:Vie
SC 400 (Paris,2004), 172.
d'Antoine,
Orthodoxbaptismalrite,closelyfollowingtheByzantinetradition
{Euchologion,79F.).For the importanceof exorcismin the early
to primary
Christianbaptismalrite,see also thevariousreferences
sources and secondaryliteratureby A. J. Wharton, "Ritual and
in Ravenna,"ArtB
Reconstructed
Meaning:TheNeonian Baptistery
59 (1987):358-75,esp. 361and nn. 13-18.
as
of
Mark
5:12-13, opposed
Matthew8:31-32).
177 Parentiand Velkovska,L'eucologioBarberini,102: "
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
examples
iconography
(according
theswinearerepresented
belowor nextto Christand theGerasene,
butnotabovethem),see thefollowing:an ivoryplaquewithChrist's
miraclesdated in thefifth
centuryand attributedto a workshopin
Rome [AgeofSpirituality:
Late Antiqueand Early ChristianArt,
Thirdto SeventhCentury,
exhibitioncatalogue,ed. K. Weitzmann
[New York,1979],446-47, cat.no. 407); theminiatureon fol.212V
of cod. Paris,gr. 923 (K. Weitzmann,TheMiniaturesoftheSacra
Parallela, Parisinus Graecus23 [Princeton,1979],fig.447); fols.
i6v and 70Voftheeleventh-century
cod. Laur.
Constantinopolitan
VI. 23, which illustrateMatthew 8:28-34 and Mark 5:6-10 (T.
de la Laurentienne,Florence,Laur. VI.
Velmans,Le Ttravangile
23,Bibliothquedes Cahiers archologiques6 [Paris,1971],23,35,
cod. 5 oftheIviron
figs.26, 140); fol.156ofthethirteenth-century
Monasteryon MountAthos(Pelekanidou,
[. 5 above],2:300,fig.24).
DUMBARTON OAKS PAPERS | 63
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
andtheIllustration
oftheNinth-Century
Psalters
I 115
Liturgy
Marginal
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Ii6
M ARI A EVANGELATOU
Theresulting
messageis thaticonsarenotdemonic
as
the
iconoclasts
claimed,buton theconobjects,
aresoholythattheycandriveawaydemons.On
trary
a secondlevel,thejuxtaposition
oftheiconand the
of
exorcised
demonsprobably
alludesto thevictory
theiconophiles
overthedemoniciconoclasts
andthe
of
the
latter
from
the
of
the
Orthodox
body
expulsion
Church(aneventcompared
toexorcism
intheiconoIn
a
similar
the
vein, baptismand
philesources).184
oftheEthiopianeunuchcouldbeperceived
cleansing
as an allusionto thepurification
oftheChurchfrom
thedarknessofheresy.
Becauseof theirdarkskin,
wereoftenusedas symbols
ofsinandherEthiopians
in
and
otherearly
commentaries,
homilies,
esy psalm
Christian
andByzantine
texts,including
iconophile
literature.185
Thissymbolism
couldhaveprompted
a
184 For a detailedanalysisoftheabovereading,see Evangelatou,
"VirtuousSoul,HealthyBody"(n. 123,above),192-96.
185 It is not uncommonin Byzantineliteratureto speak about
demonsin the formof "Ethiopians,"a wordused to referto blackskinned figuresin general (and not necessarilyinhabitantsof
Ethiopia).See forexampleG. W. H. Lampe,A PatristicGreekLexicon
oficonoclasts
todemonsseen. 158above.)In psalmcommentaries,
the
Ethiopiansmentionedin Psalms71:9,73:14,and 86:4 areinterpreted
as menwithblacksoulsignorantofthedivinelight(Cyril,Expositio
inpsalmos,
inpsalmos,PG 69:1181c,1188A;Theodoret,
Interpretatio
PG 80464, 1565B).TalkingaboutPsalm 67:32in particular(the
verseillustrated
on folio65oftheChludovPsalter),Cyrilconsiders
outherhandto God" to be a reference
to nations
Ethiopia"stretching
thataredarkin sinand askto be savedbytheLord {ExpositioinpsaltheEthiopiansof
mos,PG 69:1166).EpiphaniosofCyprusconsiders
Psalm73:14to be hereticsdarkenedbysin (Panarion,PG 41:357c).
More importantly,
the Letterof the ThreePatriarchsto Emperor
mentions
a visionin whichan Ethiopianwho cutsdown
Theophilos
an olivetreefromthe ambo of Hagia Sophia standsforthe iconoclastPatriarch
Theodotos(815-21),
whosucceededthedeposediconoPatriarch
See
The
LetteroftheThreePatriarchsto
phile
Nikephoros.
and RelatedTexts,ed. and trans.J.A. Munitizet
EmperorTheophilos
al. (Camberley,
1997),73-75 (i2.a-f). Theextenttowhichreferences
likethesereflected
or shapedperceptionsofracein Byzantiumstill
awaitsa systematic
and comprehensive
investigation.
in the
baptism
readingoftheEthiopian's
typological
ofthe
to thecleansing
ChludovPsalteras a reference
in analogyto
oficonoclasm,
Churchfromtheheresy
theexorcism
miracleaboveit,whichmostprobably
hasthismeaning
becauseofitsinteraction
withPaul's
icon.To conclude,thecomplexillustration
offolio
another
65in theChludovPsalterprovides
example
ofmultilayered
in ninth-century
references
marginal
illustration.
Italsodemonstrates
thatliturgical
psalter
influence
maylieatthebasisofa thematic
conception
ofimages,buticonophilepolemicsshapedthefinal
resultanditsperception.
Theconclusion
drawnfromtheaboveanalysis
is that
influence
on
the
illustration
of
the
ninthliturgical
and
century
psalterswas indeedextensive
marginal
wasinextricably
linkedwiththeiconophile
agendaof
thesemanuscripts'
illustration.
Thisprominent
liturgical influence
isjustified
notonlybythepervasive
use
ofthepsalmsin theByzantine
riteandbytheregular
oftheclergymen
whodesigned
andused
participation
in Churchservices.
thesepsalters
It is alsojustified
by
thecentralroleoftheliturgy
in thespiritual
lifeof
theChurch,andespecially
in thecontinuous
proclaandprotection
of
mation,
celebration,
dissemination,
Orthodoxdogma,a mission
whichwasalsoservedby
thetheological
and
ofillusrigor iconophile
emphasis
intheninth-century
tration
Byzantine
psalters.
ofCalifornia,
SantaCruz
University
of
of
DepartmentHistory ArtandVisualCulture
D-201Porter
College
1156HighStreet
SantaCruz,CA 95064
maevang@ucsc.edu
This content downloaded from 157.138.161.232 on Fri, 30 Oct 2015 16:42:16 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions