Professional Documents
Culture Documents
com/divest
Global
Corporate
Divestment Study
Closing the deal: strategies
to increase speed and value
:mll`]kh]]\'nYdm]]imYlagfak[gehda[Yl]\&L`]j]akYf
ghhgjlmfalq[gklafngdn]\affgl[geeallaf_km^[a]fl[YhalYd
gjj]kgmj[]klgl`]kYd]$Yf\k`gjl[mlkl`YleYqYhh]Yjlg
kYn]lae]Yf\egf]qg^l]f`Yn]l`]ghhgkal]]^^][l&Gmj
klm\q\ak[mkk]kl`akZYdYf[]Yf\gl`]jc]qkljYl]_a]k^gj
km[[]kk^md\an]kle]flkl`Ylghlaear]Zgl`kh]]\Yf\nYdm]&
Afl`akklm\q$o]Y\\j]kk^gmjim]klagfkl`Yl
Yj]^gj]egklgfgmj[da]flkeaf\k2
<go]`Yn]l`]ja_`laf^gjeYlagflg
eYc]_gg\hgjl^gdag\][akagfk7
O`YlnYdm][j]Ylagfd]kkgfk[Yfo]
d]Yjf^jgehjanYl]]imalq7
@go[Yfo]aehjgn]\an]kle]fl]p][mlagf7
@go[Yfo]kljac]YZYdYf[]Z]lo]]fkh]]\Yf\nYdm]7
O]km__]kld]Y\af_hjY[la[]klgYfko]jl`gk]im]klagfk
Yf\hjgna\]gZk]jnYlagfkYZgml`go[gehYfa]kna]o
l`]ajgofhgjl^gdagkljYl]_qYf\\an]kle]flhjY[la[]k&
;gehYfa]kl`Yle]la[mdgmkdqYf\j]d]fld]kkdq]pYeaf]l`]aj
hgjl^gdagkim]klagfaf_o`]l`]jl`][gehYfqakj]Yddql`]Z]kl
gof]jg^]Y[`Ykk]lYj]l`]gf]kl`YlY[`a]n]lgh%daf]_jgol`
Yf\Yj]j]oYj\]\$Zgl`ZqklYc]`gd\]jkYf\Zql`]eYjc]l&
C]qf\af_k
Companies often struggle to get the right information to make good portfolio decisions and
to balance speed with value when selling assets. Here are the highlights of our 2015 Global
Corporate Divestment Study:
74%
g^jekYj]mkaf_
divestments to
fund growth
66%
saw an increased
valuation multiple in the
remaining business after
their last divestment
55%
say they need better
analytics tools to improve
portfolio reviews
value creation
lessons from
private equity
Preparation shortcuts
elongate diligence and
50%
of executives completed
their deal on time by starting
preparations earlier
<]faf_km[[]kk
9km[[]kk^md\an]kle]fle]]lkl`j]][jal]jaY2
@YkYhgkalan]aehY[lgfl`]nYdmYlagf
emdlahd]g^l`]j]eYafaf_[gehYfq
Three success
criteria met
19%
?]f]jYl]kYkYd]hja[]YZgn]]ph][lYlagfk
;dgk]kY`]Y\g^laeaf_]ph][lYlagfk
@a_`h]j^gje]jklYc]l`]lae]lghj]hYj]o]dd
afY\nYf[]g^Y\an]kle]fl$mf\]jklYf\l`]
hgl]flaYdhggdg^Zmq]jkYf\l`]ajf]]\k$Yf\
[geemfa[Yl]l`]nYdm]g^l`]ljYfkY[lagflg
k`Yj]`gd\]jk&E]\ameh]j^gje]jk\go]ddgf
kge]$ZmlfglYdd$g^l`]k][gehgf]flk&
One success
criteria met
No success
criteria met
19%
of sellers are high performers who meet
three key success criteria
34%
Two success
criteria met
34%
13%
9j]qgm[gfka\]jaf_\an]klaf_Ykk]lk7
A^fgl$qgmk`gmd\Z]&
L`]\]YdeYjc]lakjYehaf_mhYf\Y[lanaklk`Yj]`gd\]jkYj]Z][geaf_Zgd\]j&;gehYfa]kemkl
gmlh]j^gjel`]aj[geh]lalgjkZq[gflafmgmkdqf]%lmfaf_l`]ajhgjl^gdagkg^Zmkaf]kk]kYf\
j]Ydaraf_eYpaemenYdm]^jgeljYfkY[lagfk&
<an]kle]flhdYfkYj]af[j]Ykaf_Yk[gehYfa]kj]Ydar]l`Yl
\an]kle]flkYj]Yc]qoYqlg^mf\Zmkaf]kk_jgol`&L`]nYdm]
g^_dgZYd\an]kle]flk`Ykaf[j]Yk]\Zq0(kaf[]l`]E9dgo
g^*((1 E]j_]jeYjc]l\YlY!&
9egf_gmj=Q?dgZYd;gjhgjYl]<an]kle]flKlm\qj]khgf\]flk$
,-j][]fldq\an]kl]\gjhdY[]\YZmkaf]kkgfYoYl[`dakla^al
oYkflj]Y[`af_h]j^gjeYf[][jal]jaY&O]Z]da]n]l`aklj]f\ak
k]llg[gflafm]$oal`-,g^]p][mlan]k]ph][laf_Yfaf[j]Yk]af
l`]fmeZ]jg^kljYl]_a[k]dd]jkafl`]f]pl)*egfl`k&
<an]kle]flkYj]`Ynaf_Yhgkalan]aehY[lgf[gehYfa]k&
K]n]flq%^gmjh]j[]flg^jekkmjn]q]\mk]\l`]^mf\k^jge
l`]ajegklj][]fl\an]kle]fllg\jan]gj_Yfa[gjafgj_Yfa[
_jgol`&9f\..kYql`Yll`]aj\an]kle]fl`Y\Yhgkalan]
aehY[lgfl`]ajnYdmYlagfemdlahd]k&
57%
46%
16%
;gf[]jfkj]dYl]\lgk`Yj]`gd\]jY[lanake
45%
16%
F]_Ylan]aehY[lgfjakc'j]oYj\ZYdYf[]g^hgjl^gdag
44%
9%
MfYlljY[lan]f]kkg^eYjc]ll`Ylmfalakgh]jYlaf_af
43%
7%
9f]]\lg_]f]jYl][Yk`
40%
15%
@a_`^mlmj][Yk`afn]kle]flj]imaj]e]flk
39%
8%
;gehYfqakfgll`]Z]klgof]j^gjl`]
Ykk]l'dgokqf]j_a]koal`j]klg^Zmkaf]kk
34%
2%
Ghhgjlmfakla[ af[dm\af_mfkgda[al]\YhhjgY[`ZqYZmq]j!
29%
14%
Consideration
How did you use the funds raised from your most
recent divestment?
HYq\gof\]Zl
74% used
divestments
to drive growth
12%
J]lmjf^mf\klg
k`Yj]`gd\]jk
34%
14%
Afn]klaf[gj]
Zmkaf]kk
17%
EYc]Yf
Y[imakalagf
23%
Afn]klaff]ohjg\m[lk'
eYjc]lk'_]g_jYh`a]k
9nga\Ycfg[cYll`]\ggj
9[lanaklk`Yj]`gd\]jkg^l]fk]]l`]nYdm]g^\an]kle]flk
Z]^gj]l`][gehYfq\g]k&9dgf_oal`YfYkk]lfglZ]af_
hYjlg^l`][gj]Zmkaf]kk$[gf[]jfYZgmlk`Yj]`gd\]j
Y[lanakeoYkl`]egklaehgjlYflj]Ykgf^gj[gehYfa]klg
k]ddYkk]lk). `a_`]klh]j[]flY_]!g^]p][mlan]kkYq
k`Yj]`gd\]jY[lanakeoYkl`]egklaehgjlYfllja__]jg^l`]aj
dYkl\an]kle]fl$Yf\,-kYqaloYkYeYbgj[gfka\]jYlagf&
;gehYfa]k\an]klYdkg^gjghhgjlmfakla[j]Ykgfk&9degkl
Yl`aj\ *1!g^]p][mlan]kkYql`]ajdYkl\an]kle]floYk
ghhgjlmfakla[$Yf\,*]ph][lYfaf[j]Yk]afmfkgda[al]\
Zmq]jYhhjgY[`]k&
Most important
>mjl`]jegj]$,/g^[gehYfa]kkYql`Yl]n]fa^l`]qo]j]fl
dggcaf_lg\an]kl$l`]qogmd\[gfka\]jk]ddaf_YlYhj]eame
afl`]jYf_]g^)(%*( Yf\Yl`aj\g^l`gk]ogmd\_gZ]dgo
)(!&:mll`akjYak]kl`]im]klagfg^o`]l`]j[gehYfa]kj]Yddq
cfgol`]nYdm]g^l`]ajmf\]jdqaf_Zmkaf]kk]k&AfhYjla[mdYj$
a^[gehYfa]k\gfl[gf\m[lj]_mdYjhgjl^gdagj]na]okoal`
Y[[mjYl]\YlY$l`]q[Yflhjgh]jdqYkk]kko`]l`]jYZmq]jak
g^^]jaf_Yhj]eamegjfgl&
Kgo`]l`]jalkYfY[lanaklafn]klgjgjkaehdqYhgl]flaYdkmalgj$
[gehYfa]kf]]\lgcfgo`golgj]Y[l&:]ll]jq]l$l`]qk`gmd\
Z]hjgY[lan]Yf\kljYl]_a[YZgmll`]ajhgjl^gdagYkk]kke]fl&
37%
54%
FmeZ]jg^mfkgda[al]\YhhjgY[`]k
22%
36%
42%
FmeZ]jg^\aklj]kk]\kYd]k
22%
32%
Decrease
46%
Stay the same
Increase
Kh]]\eYll]jkafY\an]j_af_][gfgeq
9jgmf\l`]ogjd\$_jgol`jYl]kYj]\an]j_af_&;gehYfa]kaf
l`]9e]ja[Yk$=mjgh]Yf\]n]f;`afY`Yn]fYddqklYjl]\lg
Y[[]hll`Yll`]ajhgjl^gdagkYj]flafdaf]oal`l`]hgkl%[jakak
dgo%_jgol`]fnajgfe]fll`Ylak`]j]lgklYq&Gfl`]gl`]j
`Yf\$[gehYfa]kafhYjlkg^9kaY%HY[a[$dac]G[]YfaY$
Af\gf]kaYYf\Af\aY$Yj]^g[mkaf_gfYj]Ykg^l`]][gfgeq
oal`kljgf__jgol`hjgkh][lk&
L`akdgf_%l]je][gfgea[[`Yf_]akhmk`af_[gehYfa]klg
j]^g[mkgfl`]aj[gj]klj]f_l`kYf\_jgol`Yj]Yk&Af^Y[l$
YZmkaf]kkZ]af_[gfka\]j]\fgf%[gj]akgf]g^l`]egkl
hj]nYd]flj]Ykgfk^gj\an]klaf_ ,.!&9keYfq[gehYfa]k
j]Ydar]l`]qeYqZ]dYl]afj]ZYdYf[af_l`]ajhgjl^gdagk$
l`]j]akYegmflaf_mj_]f[qlgY[l^Ykl2-(g^]p][mlan]k
kYql`Yl[dgkaf_\]Ydkima[cdqYf\oal`[]jlYaflqakegj]
aehgjlYfll`YfoYalaf_dgf_]jlgk][mj]Y`a_`]jhja[]&
50%
<gqgm`Yn]l`]ja_`laf^gjeYlagf
lgeYc]_gg\hgjl^gdag\][akagfk7
;gehYfa]kYj]af[j]Ykaf_dqj]dqaf_gflgh%daf]_jgol`lgaehjgn]eYj_afk$YkY\][Y\]%dgf_^g[mk
gf[gklj]\m[lagf[ge]klgYf]f\&Afgj\]jlg_jgo$l`]qemkl]pYeaf]l`]ajhgjl^gdag`gdakla[Yddq
Yf\im]klagfo`]l`]jl`][gehYfqakj]Yddql`]Z]klgof]jg^]Y[`Ykk]l$gja^l`]q[gmd\j]\]hdgq
l`Yl[YhalYdegj]]^^][lan]dq]dk]o`]j]$Yddo`ad]c]]haf_afeaf\`gol`][gehgf]flkafl]jY[loal`
Yf\Z]f]l]Y[`gl`]j&
>j]im]flhgjl^gdagj]na]ok`]dh[gehYfa]kj]Yddg[Yl][YhalYd
lgaf[j]Yk]k`Yj]`gd\]jnYdm]Yf\j]Y[lima[cdqlgeYjc]l
[gf\alagfkgjY[lanaklk`Yj]`gd\]jk&9kYj]kmdl$fgf%[gj]
Zmkaf]kk]k[YfZ]kgd\Yll`]ghlaeYdlae]oal`Y\]imYl]
hj]hYjYlagf$dgf_Z]^gj]l`]\][akagfZ][ge]k[jala[Yd&
Q]l-0g^]p][mlan]kY[cfgod]\_]l`Yll`]q\gfl[gf\m[l
kljYl]_a[j]na]ok^j]im]fldq]fgm_`&
=n]f^j]im]flj]na]okYj]gfdqYk_gg\Ykl`]\YlYYf\
YfYdqkakl`Yl_gaflgl`]e&:]dgoo]^g[mkgfl`]egkl
aehgjlYflaf^gjeYlagfYf\af^jYkljm[lmj]l`Yl[gehYfa]k
k`gmd\d]n]jY_]lgaehjgn]hgjl^gdagh]j^gjeYf[]&
58%
14%
Af\mkljqh]j^gjeYf[]Z]f[`eYjck
56%
13%
9[[]kkZ]ll]j\YlY
=p][mlan]kkYql`Ylkh][a[af^gjeYlagfkm[`Ykaf\mkljq
Z]f[`eYjck$[YhalYdafn]kle]flj]imaj]e]flkYf\[gfkakl]fldq
hj]hYj]\hjgl'[Yk`go^gj][YklkZqZmkaf]kkmfalkYj]
nalYdlgaehjgnaf_hgjl^gdagj]na]ok&J]daYZd]\YlYj]imaj]k
afn]kle]flkaflae]$kqkl]ek'lggdkYf\j]h]YlYZd]hjg[]kk]k&
:mkaf]kkYfYdqla[klggdklgeg\]daehY[lg^hgjl^gdag\][akagfk
55%
19%
9ddg[Ylagfkg^k`Yj]\k]jna[][]fl]jkYf\
gl`]jk`Yj]\Ykk]lk$af[dm\af_h]ghd]
Hjgl'[Yk`go^gj][Yklk^gjZmkaf]kkmfalk
Ogjcaf_[YhalYd$af[dm\af_Y[[gmflkj][]anYZd]'hYqYZd]$
[mjj]flYf\Y[[jm]\daYZadala]k$hj]hYa\Ykk]lkYf\]ph]fk]k
52%
11%
?j]Yl]jaehY[lgfkljYl]_a[\][akagfk
51%
12%
;YhalYdafn]kle]flj]imaj]e]flk^gjZmkaf]kkmfalk
12%
50%
?j]Yl]j[gf\]flaYdalq^gjf\af_k
8%
39%
:]ll]j[geemfa[YlagfZ]lo]]fZgYj\'kljYl]_ql]YeYf\E9
25%
11%
Consideration
Most important
@aklgja[Yf\^mlmj][YhalYdafn]kl]\af
Zmkaf]kk [YhalYd]ph]f\almj]k!
<]n]dghYfYdqla[Ydlggdk
;gehYfa]ko`gk]dYkl\an]kle]flj]kmdl]\afY`a_`]j
nYdmYlagfemdlahd]gfl`]j]eYafaf_Zmkaf]kko]j]-0
egj]dac]dqlg`Yn]mk]\kljgf_YfYdqla[lggdkl`Yfdgo]j%
h]j^gjeaf_[gehYfa]k&
;gehYfa]kemklYfYdqr]YeqjaY\g^\YlYhgaflklgeYc]Y
hgjl^gdag\][akagflgp$k]dd$kmklYafgj_jgoYZmkaf]kkmfal&
>a^lq%n]h]j[]flg^]p][mlan]kkYqZmkaf]kkYfYdqla[kogmd\
eYc]l`]ajhgjl^gdagj]na]okegj]]^^][lan]$Yf\f]YjdqY^l`
g^]p][mlan]k$l`]`a_`]klh]j[]flY_]$kYqalakl`]kaf_d]egkl
aehgjlYfloYqlgaehjgn]hgjl^gdagj]na]o]^^][lan]f]kk&
L`]egkl[jala[YdYfYdqla[Ydlggdk[Yf\gl`]^gddgoaf_2
Model multiple scenarios. Mf\]jklYf\l`]jYf_]g^
hgl]flaYdhgjl^gdag[`Yf_]kYf\l`]ajj]kh][lan]fYf[aYd
[gfk]im]f[]k&L`akak[gehda[Yl]\Zql`]f]]\lg
mf\]jklYf\l`]j]dYlagfk`ahkYegf_nYjagmkZjYf\k
gjZmkaf]kk]k&>gj]pYehd]$a^qgmZmqZmkaf]kk9$k]dd
Zmkaf]kk:$afn]klafZmkaf]kk;Yf\'gjaehjgn][gkl
kljm[lmj]afZmkaf]kk<$o`Ylogmd\l`Yldggcdac]Y[jgkk
Ydd[gehYfq^mf[lagfkgn]jl`]f]pll`j]]lgn]q]Yjk7
Run regression models based on sales-to-investment.
Mf\]jklYf\`goqgmjZmkaf]kkmfalkj]khgf\lg[`Yf_]k
afhja[af_$Y\n]jlakaf_$hjgeglagf$affgnYlagfYf\
gl`]j^Y[lgjkkgqgmcfgoo`]j]lg^g[mk[YhalYd&
9fYdqr]fgf%fYf[aYde]lja[k&;gehYfa]kemklmk]Za_
\YlYl][`fgdg_qlgj]Y[`fgf%ljY\alagfYd\YlYkgmj[]k&>gj
]pYehd]$kg[aYde]\aYkgmj[]keYqj]n]Ydl`Ylhjg\m[lkYj]
Z]af_j][]an]\\a^^]j]fldqafl`]eYjc]ll`YfYfla[ahYl]\&
L`]k]lggdkYj]]^^][lan]fglgfdq^gjhgjl^gdageYfY_]e]fl
ZmlYdkg^gj[j]Ylaf_Ykljgf_$kmhhgjlYZd]nYdm]klgjql`Yl
]f`Yf[]kkYd]hja[]Yf\]ph]\al]k\ada_]f[]&
55%
of executives say business analytics would
make their portfolio reviews more effective
Af[j]Yk]hgjl^gdagj]na]o^j]im]f[q
Fglgfdq\gj]_mdYjhgjl^gdagj]na]ok`]dh[gehYfa]k
eYc]Z]ll]j%af^gje]\\][akagfkYf\]ph]\a]flhgjl^gdag
k`a^lk$Zmll`]qYdkgaehjgn]afl]jfYd[ggh]jYlagfj]dYl]\
lg\YlY_Yl`]jaf_Yf\[gfk]fkmkZmad\af_Yjgmf\Y[lagfk&
;gf\m[laf_hgjl^gdagj]na]okloa[]Yq]Yjaka\]Yd&
J]_mdYjj]na]okaehjgn]afl]jfYd\qfYea[kaflogc]qoYqk&
>ajkl$l`]qZ]ll]jhj]hYj]l`]E9l]Yelgaehd]e]fl
ZgYj\'kljYl]_ql]Ye\][akagfk&>gj]pYehd]$a^YZmkaf]kkak
hmlgfYoYl[`dakl$l`]E9l]Ye[Yf`Yn]egj]d]Y\lae]
lghj]hYj]l`]Zmkaf]kk^gjkYd]2*-g^]p][mlan]kkYql`Yl
Z]ll]j[geemfa[YlagfZ]lo]]fl`]ZgYj\'kljYl]_qYf\E9
l]Yeogmd\aehjgn]hgjl^gdagj]na]o]^^][lan]f]kk&
K][gf\$^j]im]flhgjl^gdagj]na]okYj]na]o]\Zq]ehdgq]]k
Yf\k`Yj]`gd\]jkYkYfgZb][lan]]p]j[ak]lg[j]Yl]
klYc]`gd\]jnYdm]&:q[gfljYkl$af^j]im]flj]na]ok[Yf
]Y[`Z]k]]fYkYka_fg^Yhgl]flaYd\an]kle]fl$d]Y\af_
lgjmegjk$mf[]jlYaflq$j]\m[]\]ehdgq]]egjYd]Yf\
o]Yc]jkmhhda]jgj[mklge]jj]dYlagfk`ahk&L`]eYbgjalqg^
]p][mlan]kY[cfgod]\_]l`]f]]\^gjegj]^j]im]flj]na]ok$
o`ad]+1kYql`Yl_j]Yl]j[gf\]flaYdalqg^f\af_k$lgg$
ogmd\eYc]j]na]okegj]]^^][lan]&
25%
say that better communication between
the board/strategy and M&A team would
improve portfolio review effectiveness.
39%
kYql`Yl_j]Yl]j[gf\]flaYdalqg^f\af_k
would make reviews more effective.
O`YlnYdm][j]Ylagfd]kkgfk[Yf
qgmd]Yjf^jgehjanYl]]imalq7
HjanYl]]imalq H=![gflafm]klggmlh]j^gje[gehYjYZd]hmZda[[gehYfa]ko`]fal[ge]klg
[j]Ylaf_nYdm]$Y[[gj\af_lg=Qkegklj][]flHjanYl]=imalqNYdm];j]YlagfKlm\q&Fglgfdq\a\
MKH=hgjl^gdag[gehYfa]kY[`a]n]]imalqj]lmjfk,&,pl`gk]g^kaeadYjhmZda[dqdakl]\[gehYfa]k
^gjl`]kYehd][gehd]l]\Z]lo]]f*((.Yf\*()+$ZmlH=kkljYl]_a[Yf\gh]jYlagfYd
aehjgn]e]flk`Yn]Z]]fYc]qh]j^gjeYf[]\jan]j&
Sources of annual EBITDA growth
in the US, 2006131
0.8%
kYd]$[gehYfa]kk`gmd\j]YhhjYak]l`gk]_ma\]daf]klg
\]l]jeaf]a^Y\\alagfYd^g[mk[gmd\lgd]Y\lgaf[j]Yk]\
kYd]nYdm]&
0.2%
4.7%
4.6%
8.6%
Bolt-on acquisitions
18.9%
Disposals
Other
O`ad][gjhgjYl]k]dd]jkeYqgjeYqfgl`Yn]l`]kh][a[lae]
[gfkljYaflkg^H=\]h]f\af_gf`gol`]qeYfY_]l`]aj
hgjl^gdagkl`]q[Yfkladdd]YjfnYdm][j]Ylagfd]kkgfk^jgeH=&
9f\alkogjl`fglaf_l`Yll`]k]d]kkgfk[Yf`]dh[j]Yl]nYdm]
afYZmkaf]kkmfalo`]l`]jgjfglalakZ]af_hj]hYj]\^gjkYd]&
KlYjl]YjdqlgZmad\
kmklYafYZd]_jgol`
H=cfgokl`YlZmq]jk]p`Ymklan]dqk[jmlafar]afn]kle]fl
ghhgjlmfala]k&Kgk`gjl%l]jej]n]fm]afYlagfYf\[gkl
[mllaf_\gfglhYkkl`akl]kl&JYl`]j$H=^g[mk]kgfdgf_%l]je
kmklYafYZd]_jgol`&H=jekg^l]fhdYf^gj$Yf\]p][ml]gf$
gh]jYlagfYdaehjgn]e]flkq]YjkafY\nYf[]g^Yf]pallg
[j]Yl]kmklYafYZd]h]j^gjeYf[]Yf\ege]flmel`Yle]jal
`a_`]jnYdmYlagfk&
10
Enhancing revenue.L`]dYl]kl=QHjanYl]=imalqNYdm]
;j]YlagfKlm\qj]n]Ydkl`Ylf]Yjdq`Yd^g^nYdm]gn]jl`]da^]
g^Yfafn]kle]flak[j]Yl]\l`jgm_`j]n]fm]]f`Yf[]e]fl&
Af[dm\af_l`]gl`]j`Yd^$o`a[`akZjgc]f\gofZ]lo]]f
afgj_Yfa[_jgol`Yf\[gklkYnaf_k$l`]k]nYdm][j]Ylagf
afalaYlan]k`Yn]j]kmdl]\afYfYffmYd=:AL<9af[j]Yk]g^
f]Yjdq)1&
O`ad]Yf]pl]fkan]hjg\m[l]phYfkagfhjg_jYe[gmd\Z]
mfj]Ydakla[^gjYZmkaf]kkl`Yl`YkZ]]f]YjeYjc]\^gjkYd]$
[gehYfa]k[YfklYjllgghlaear]l`]ajhjg\m[l^gglhjaflY[jgkk
[mklge]jkYf\_]g_jYh`a]k&9Zgd\]jegn][gmd\Z]lgY\\
hjg\m[lkgj]phYf\aflg\a^^]j]fl_]g_jYh`a]kgjeYjc]lk
l`jgm_`Ybgafln]flmj] BN!YjjYf_]e]fl&O`ad]alakaehgjlYfl
lg`Yn]YBN]palkljYl]_q$YBN[Yfhjgna\]Y[j]Ylan]kgdmlagf
Yf\Yhgl]flaYde][`YfakeZqo`a[`qgm[Yfaf[j]Yk]hja[]k
gfj]dYl]\hjg\m[lk&K]dd]jk[gmd\Ydkg[gfka\]jY[imajaf_Yf\
afl]_jYlaf_Yfgl`]j[gehYfq&
?]g_jYh`a[Yd
]phYfkagf
21%
Price
increases
23%
6%
13%
;`Yf_]g^
g^^]jaf_
22%
15%
Aehjgn]\
k]ddaf_
New
hjg\m[lk
;gjhgjYl]]p][mlan]k_an]]imYdo]a_`llgl`]aehgjlYf[]g^
Zggklaf_j]n]fm]Yf\j]\m[af_[gklklg]f`Yf[]nYdm]l`]
logkl]hko]j]mf\]jlYc]f]imYddqg^l]fYf\[al]\Zq,(g^
l`gk]o`gmf\]jlggcl`]eYkl`]ajegklaehgjlYflafalaYlan]&
?an]fH=kkm[[]kkaf[j]Ylaf_kmklYafYZd]nYdm]Zq^g[mkaf_
gfj]n]fm]$h]j`Yhkegj][gjhgjYl]kf]]\lgk`a^ll`]aj^g[mk
lgoYj\l`]lghdaf]&
Extracting working capital. ;gehYfa]kg^l]ff]_d][l
l`akaehgjlYflnYdm][j]Ylagfd]n]jgfdq+- l`]dgo]kl
h]j[]flY_]!g^]p][mlan]k\a\al&@go]n]j$]pljY[laf_
ogjcaf_[YhalYdoYkk]d][l]\egklg^l]f *)!Ykl`]kl]h
l`Yl[gehYfa]k\a\fgllYc]ZmlZ]da]n]l`]qogmd\`Yn]
Z]f]l]\^jgel`]egkl&@]j]alakY\nakYZd]lg^gddgol`]
d]Y\g^H=$o`a[`g^l]f]pljY[lkogjcaf_[YhalYdlgj]afn]klaf
_jgol`Yj]Yk&
L`]hjgZd]eakl`YlZmq]jk_]f]jYddqogflhYq^gj]p[]kk
ogjcaf_[YhalYd&;gehYfa]khdYffaf_lg\an]klYZmkaf]kkf]]\
gfdq]fgm_`ogjcaf_[YhalYdlgjmfl`]Zmkaf]kkgfY\Yq%lg%
\YqZYkak&Egj][Yk`l`Yfl`Ylk`gmd\Z]hmllgogjchjagjlg
kYd]&>g[mkaf_gfl`akg^l]fdgo%`Yf_af_^jmaloaddYdkg[Ymk]
^]o]j\akjmhlagfkl`Yf\a^[mdl[gkl%[mllaf_\][akagfkj]dYl]\lg
h]jkgff]dgjkmhhda]jk&
Cutting costs through procurement.;gehYfa]k[Yf]fl]j
aflg_jgmhhmj[`Ykaf_gj_YfarYlagfk$gj]n]f^gjel`]ajgof
Zmq]j[gfkgjlaY$lgj]\m[][gklkYf\]f`Yf[]eYj_afk&
20%
Ghlaear]\l`]lYpkljm[lmj]
64%
20%
Gh]jYlagfYdaehjgn]e]flklgj]\m[][gklk'aehjgn]eYj_af
40%
63%
=f`Yf[af_j]n]fm] ]&_&$hjg\m[l
aehjgn]e]flgj\akljaZmlagf]phYfkagf!
62%
40%
Gh]jYlagfYddqk]hYjYlaf_l`]Zmkaf]kkhYjlaYddqgj^mddq
57%
25%
=pljY[laf_ogjcaf_[YhalYd
29%
Undertook
35%
11
Kge]afalaYlan]kl`YleYq`Yn]Y_j]Yl]j[`Yf[]g^Y\\af_
nYdm]j]dYlan]dqima[cdqaf[dm\]j]f]_glaYlaf_oal`n]f\gjk$
j]\m[af_\akljaZmlagfYf\K?9[gklk$]pljY[laf_ogjcaf_
[YhalYdYf\k]ddaf_g^^j]Yd]klYl]&
Fgk][j]lkYm[]
L`]H=hdYqZggc\g]kfgl`Yn]mfaim]d]n]jklghmdd&H=
^g[mk]kgfnYdm][j]YlagfZqZ]af_\ak[ahdaf]\oal`hdYffaf_$
e]Ykmjaf_$Y[[gmflYZadalqYf\j]oYj\af_Y[`a]n]e]fl&L`ak
YhhjgY[`[j]Yl]kY_j]Yl]jk]fk]g^mj_]f[qYf\eYfY_]e]fl
^g[mkgfnYdm][j]YlagfafalaYlan]k&
Governance model. H=gof]jklYdclgeYfY_]e]fl
^j]im]fldq&Afl`][gjhgjYl]ogjd\$o]km__]klegj]
^j]im]flYf\Y[lagf%gja]fl]\e]]laf_klgaf[j]Yk]
Yll]flagfgfnYdm][j]Ylagf&;gjhgjYl]gj_YfarYlagfk
Ydkgk`gmd\eYc]gZb][lan]\][akagfkZYk]\gfjgZmkl
af^gjeYlagf$afkl]Y\g^d]llaf_afl]jfYdhgdala[kYf\
[geh]lalagf^gjj]kgmj[]kaeh]\]hjg_j]kk&
Rewards.H=g^l]fg^^]jk]imalq%lqh]j]oYj\klg
[j]Yl]af[]flan]kl`jgm_`gmll`]nYdm][j]Ylagf
hjg[]kk&;gjhgjYl]kaf[]flan]hjg_jYekYj]g^l]f
dafc]\lg_jgmhh]j^gjeYf[]Yf\k`gmd\afkl]Y\dafc
\aj][ldqlgaf\ana\mYdZmkaf]kkmfalh]j^gjeYf[]&
Management accountability.H=l]f\klgeYc]
ima[c]j\][akagfkj]_Yj\af_Y[[gmflYZadalqZ][Ymk]l`]
[geemfa[Ylagfdaf]kYj]k`gjl]j&GmjH=klm\q^gmf\l`Yl
`Ynaf_l`]ja_`leYfY_]e]fll]YeYll`]klYjlg^l`]\]Yd$
jYl`]jl`Yf_gaf_l`jgm_`eYfY_]e]fl[`Yf_]kdYl]j$ak
gf]g^l`]^Y[lgjkegklkljgf_dq[gjj]dYl]\oal`k`gjl]j`gd\
h]jag\k$`a_`]j=:AL<9_jgol`Yf\`a_`]j]imalqemdlahd]k&
L`]c]qlgnYdm][j]Ylagf^gj[gjhgjYl]kak[j]Ylaf_YhdYf]Yjdq
Yf\`gd\af_eYfY_]e]flYf\]ehdgq]]kY[[gmflYZd]&L`ak
oYq$k]dd]jk[Yfk`goYljY[cj][gj\g^km[[]kkl`YleYc]k
^mlmj]hdYfk[j]\aZd]&
PE focuses more on
value creation by being
disciplined with planning,
measuring, accountability
and rewarding achievement
12
@go[Yfqgmaehjgn]
\an]kle]fl]p][mlagf7
<an]kle]fl]p][mlagfaf[dm\]kn][jala[Ydogjcklj]Yek2_gn]jfYf[]$lYp$[Yjn]%gmlfYf[aYd
klYl]e]flk$\]Yd%ZYkakaf^gjeYlagfYf\gh]jYlagfYdk]hYjYlagf&@]j]o]^g[mkgfl`]`a_`]kl%aehY[l
Yj]Ykoal`afl`gk]ogjcklj]Yekl`YlYj][j]Ylaf_l`]egklka_fa[Yfl[`Ydd]f_]k^gj]p][mlan]k&
Gf]g^l`]egklaehgjlYfl[gfljaZmlgjklgeYpaearaf_Zgl`
kh]]\Yf\nYdm]aklgklYjlhj]hYjaf_gflae]2`a_`%h]j^gjeaf_
[gehYfa]ko]j]-(egj]dac]dqlg`Yn]klYjl]\hj]hYjYlagf
gflae]l`Yfdgo%h]j^gjeaf_[gehYfa]kl`YlklYjl]\l`]
hjg[]kkdYl]Yf\`Y\lglYc]k`gjl[mlk&
EYfY_]qgmjlae]daf]
>gjlq%^gmjh]j[]flg^]p][mlan]kkYql`]qk`gmd\aehjgn]`go
l`]qeYfY_]l`]aj]p][mlagflae]daf]^gjl`]ajf]pl\an]kle]fl&
Leading practices
<]n]dghYkljgf_\an]kle]fl_gn]jfYf[]kljm[lmj]
l`Yl[Yf`]dheYfY_]hjagjala]k$afl]j\]h]f\]f[a]k$
j]kgmj[]kYf\klYc]`gd\]j]ph][lYlagfk$Yk
o]ddYk]fYZd]ima[c\][akagf%eYcaf_
=ehgo]jYf]p][mlan]kl]]jaf_[geeall]]
Yf\^mf[lagfYdk]hYjYlagfd]Y\]jklg[j]Yl]Yf
afl]jfYdYf\]pl]jfYd[geemfa[YlagfkljYl]_q
l`Ylk]lk]ph][lYlagfk$\]f]kjgd]kYf\
j]khgfkaZadala]kYf\^Y[adalYl]k]p][mlagf
EgZadar]l`]\]Ydl]YeYf\\]n]dghlggdkYf\eYl]jaYdk
lgkmhhgjlk]hYjYlagfhdYffaf_Yf\]p][mlagf
:YdYf[]l`]f]]\^gj[gf\]flaYdalqoal`l`]f]]\lg
_]ll`]ja_`lh]ghd]afngdn]\afl`]kYd]hjg[]kkY[jgkk
^mf[lagfYdYj]Yklg[gehd]l]l`]\]Yd]^[a]fldq
<]f]Yf\[geemfa[Yl]l`]\]Ydlae]lYZd]Yf\
c]qead]klgf]kYf\k]lmhj]_mdYjegfalgjaf_
<]n]dghYj]Ydakla[lae]daf]lgYnga\Y[[]hlaf_Y
dgo]jhja[]ZYk]\gfYfYjZaljYjq\]Y\daf]
@a_`%h]j^gjeaf_[gehYfa]ko]j]-(egj]dac]dql`Yf
dgoh]j^gje]jklg`Yn]km[[]kk^mddqeYfY_]\l`]aj
]p][mlagflae]daf]&
45%
;ggj\afYlaf_YddZmkaf]kk^mf[lagfkafngdn]\afl`]k]hYjYlagf
34%
12%
EYfY_af_l`]]p][mlagflae]daf]
12%
32%
KlYjlaf_hj]hYjYlagfgflae]
9%
Some room for improvement
31%
Ka_fa[Yfljgge^gjaehjgn]e]fl
<]f]l`]h]jae]l]j
L`akakY[d]YjhYafhgafl^gjk]dd]jk&@Yd^g^]p][mlan]kkYqthey
k`gmd\Z]ll]j\]f]l`]h]jae]l]jg^l`]Zmkaf]kk^gjkYd]$Ykal
Y^^][lkYddgl`]j[Yjn]%gmlogjcklj]Yek&
Leading practices
9__j]_Yl]fYf[aYd\YlYlgY[[geeg\Yl][`Yf_]kaf
l`]h]jae]l]j ]&_&$dgY\\YlY^gjl`]]flaj]gj_YfarYlagf
gj\anakagfafYoYql`Ylhjgna\]k^gjghlagfYdalq!
Mf\]jklYf\\a^^]j]flhY[cY_af_ghlagfkYf\`go
ghlagfYdalqeYqaehY[lfglgfdql`]Zmkaf]kk^gj
kYd] ]&_&$ljYfkalagfk]jna[]Y_j]]e]flk$kmhhdq
Y_j]]e]flk!$ZmlYdkgl`]j]eYafaf_gj_YfarYlagf
]&_&$kljYf\]\[gklkYf\aehY[lgf_g%^gjoYj\
j]n]fm]k$]Yjfaf_kYf\ogjcaf_[YhalYd!
:]]paZd]oal`j]_Yj\lgZmq]jk\]kaj]kYZgml
the nature g^l`]Zmkaf]kk^gjkYd]YZmq]j
eYqfgloYflYddYkh][lkg^l`]Zmkaf]kk$
^gjnYjagmkj]Ykgfk ]&_&$Yflaljmkl!
@a_`%h]j^gjeaf_[gehYfa]ko]j],,egj]dac]dql`Yf
dgoh]j^gje]jklg`Yn][d]Yjdq\]f]\l`]h]jae]l]jg^
l`]Zmkaf]kk^gjkYd]&
13
Ghlaear]l`]lYpkljm[lmj]
HYqYll]flagflgAL
LYpkljm[lmjaf_Yf\hdYffaf_[YfY^^][ll`]\][akagflg
\an]klgjfglYf\[YfYdkgkljgf_dqafm]f[]l`]^gjeg^l`]
ljYfkY[lagf&=f`Yf[af_YljYfkY[lagfklYpkljm[lmj]j]imaj]k
\]lYad]\cfgod]\_]g^`aklgja[lYpjakckYf\]phgkmj]kYf\
Yfmf\]jklYf\af_g^`golgeala_Yl]l`]lYp[gklkg^l`]
\an]kle]fl&K]dd]jk[YfeYc]l`]\an]kle]flhjg[]kkegj]
]^[a]flYf\ka_fa[Yfldq]f`Yf[]\]YdnYdm]Zq[jala[Yddq
Ykk]kkaf_l`]k]lYpakkm]k&
ALk]hYjYlagfakg^l]fl`]egkl[gehd]p^mf[lagfYdYj]YYf\
f][]kkalYl]kl`]dgf_]kld]Y\lae]$Yf\j]dYl]\akkm]k[Yf
oj]Yc`Yng[gfl`]]flaj]kYd]hjg[]kk&L`]akkm]k[YfZ]
]ph]fkan]Yf\mfk]lldaf_^gjhgl]flaYdZmq]jko`goYfllglYc]
gn]jY^mddq^mf[lagfaf_Zmkaf]kk&KlYjlaf_]Yjdq[Yfhjgna\]Y
em[`[d]Yj]jna]og^l`]c]q\][akagfhgaflkYf\]fYZd]l`]
k]dd]jlgeafaear]\akjmhlagf$j]\m[][gehd]palqYf\[gkl$
eafaear]l`]lae]Z]lo]]fka_fYf\[dgk]Yf\j]\m[]l`]k[gh]
g^ljYfkalagfk]jna[]kY_j]]e]flk LK9k!&@Yd^g^]p][mlan]k
kYql`]qk`gmd\aehjgn]gf\]l]jeafaf_l`]ajALk]hYjYlagf
j]imaj]e]flk$Yf\egklkYql`akgh]jYlagfYdYj]Yf]]\kl`]
egklka_fa[Yflaehjgn]e]fl&
Leading practices
ImYfla^qlYpYlljaZml]k ]&_&$dgkkYf\[j]\al[Yjjq%
^gjoYj\k!Yf\hjgna\]\g[me]flYlagfkmhhgjlaf_
l`]nYdm]g^lYpYlljaZml]klgl`]Zmq]j
9fla[ahYl]ljYfkalagfYdk]jna[]f]]\kYf\hgl]flaYd
_dgZYdlYpkqf]j_a]k$l`]j]Zq]f`Yf[af_l`]nYdm]
g^l`][Yjn]%gmlZmkaf]kklghjgkh][lan]Zmq]jk
J]kgdn]gh]flYp[gfljgn]jka]khjagjlg
[dgkaf_lgaf[j]Yk]]^[a]f[q\mjaf_lYp
\m]\ada_]f[]Yf\hj]k]jn]\]YdnYdm]
<]n]dghYf]^[a]flljYfkY[lagfkljm[lmj]lg
eYpaear]_dgZYdY^l]j%lYpkYd]khjg[]]\k
9fla[ahYl][`Yf_]kafl`]^mlmj]]^^][lan]lYp
jYl]j]kmdlaf_^jgekljm[lmj][`Yf_]k ]&_&$dgkk
g^[geeakkagfYaj]gj]flj]hj]f]mjkljm[lmj]k!$
Yf\[gfka\]jlYphdYffaf_kljYl]_a]klgeala_Yl]
64%
20%
16%
14
Leading practices
=klYZdak`Y[jgkk%^mf[lagfYdALl]Yelgk[gh]$
hdYfYf\h]j^gjel`]dg_a[YdALk]hYjYlagf
9da_fl`]<YqGf]ALgh]jYlaf_eg\]doal`klYf\Ydgf]
gh]jYlaf_eg\]dkljYl]_a]k af[dm\af_o`]l`]jl`]AL
[gkl^gjl`]k]hYjYlaf_Zmkaf]kk[YfZ]j]\m[]\!
A\]fla^qghhgjlmfala]klgj]\m[][gklk^gj<YqGf]Yf\
\]n]dghYfgjeYdar]\]Yjfaf_khj]k]flYlagfY[[gj\af_dq
J]na]ok`Yj]\kg^loYj]da[]fk]gjALk]jna[]
Y_j]]e]flk$Yf\\]l]jeaf]l`]fYf[aYdYf\
k]jna[]%d]n]daehY[lYf\LK9\mjYlagfdaealYlagfk
HdYf`golgeala_Yl]hgl]flaYdjakckYkkg[aYl]\
oal`\YlYafl]_jalqYf\Yhhda[YlagfYnYadYZadalq
50%
of executives say they should improve on
determining their IT separation
requirements
L]ddl`]nYdm]klgjq
K]dd]jkemklYfYdqr]l`]ajZmkaf]kk^jgeYZmq]jkh]jkh][lan]&AfhYjla[mdYj$hjgna\af_lYadgj]\af^gjeYlagfj]_Yj\af_hgl]flaYd
Zmq]jkqf]j_a]k$gf]%lae][gkl]klaeYl]kYf\YnYdm][j]YlagfjgY\eYhYj]l`]egkl]^^][lan]afaf[j]Ykaf_l`]Ykk]lk
YlljY[lan]f]kkYf\aehjgnaf_ljYfkY[lagfkh]]\&
Leading practices
Present the synergy opportunity for each potential
bidder.>gj]pYehd]$k]dd]jkf]]\lglYadgj[geemfa[Ylagfk
\a^^]j]fldqlg[gjhgjYl]n]jkmkhjanYl]]imalqZmq]jk&
L`akkl]hak[al]\Zql`]dYj_]klh]j[]flY_]g^]p][mlan]k
+1!Ykl`]egklaehgjlYflgf]af]f`Yf[af_nYdm]&
K]n]flq%l`j]]h]j[]flg^[gehYfa]kl`Ylhj]k]fl]\
kqf]j_qghhgjlmfala]k]p[]]\]\l`]ajnYdm]]ph][lYlagfk$
Yf\/,]p[]]\]\l`]ajlaeaf_]ph][lYlagfk&
Provide an estimate of one-time costs. Gfdq--
lggcl`akkl]h&@Yd^g^l`gk]o`g\a\flkYql`]q
ogmd\`Yn]Z]f]l]\egkl^jge`Ynaf_\gf]kg&
L`akakaehgjlYfl$Z][Ymk]alklj]f_l`]fkYk]dd]jk
f]_glaYlaf_hgo]jo`]fal[Yf\]egfkljYl]l`Ylal
`Yk[gfka\]j]\l`]Zmkaf]kkk[mjj]flkljm[lmj]Yf\
l`][gklk]kk]flaYdlg\]dan]jaf_o`Ylakf]]\]\lgY
Zmq]j&>mjl`]jegj]$Zmq]jkoYfllgZ][d]Yj]pY[ldq
`gol`][gklk`Yn]Z]]f[Yd[mdYl]\$]kh][aYddqa^l`]q
Yj]Z]af_Ykc]\lghjgna\]hYjlg^l`]^mf\af_&
71%
39%
Hj]hYj]\Ym\al]\fYf[aYdklYl]e]flk^gjl`]\an]kl]\Zmkaf]kk
62%
18%
<]n]dgh]\nYdm][j]YlagfjgY\eYh
59%
37%
;j]Yl]\klYf\Ydgf]gh]jYlaf_eg\]d k!ZYk]\gfZmq]jhggd
58%
17%
Hjgna\]\Yf]klaeYl]g^gf]%lae]k]hYjYlagf[gklk
55%
25%
Hj]hYj]\n]f\gj\m]\ada_]f[]j]hgjl
33%
43%
Undertook
Most important
15
9j]qgmkljacaf_YZYdYf[]
Z]lo]]fkh]]\Yf\nYdm]7
G^[gmjk]$l`]a\]YdkalmYlagfaklg^gddgol`]d]Y\af_hjY[la[]k\ak[mkk]\afl`]hj]nagmkk][lagflg
]p][ml]l`]\]Ydima[cdqYf\eYpaear]kYd]hja[]&:mlg^l]f$[gehYfa]k^g[mkkgd]dqgfeafaearaf_
laeaf_Z][Ymk]\]Ydmf[]jlYaflq[gmd\\YeY_]l`]Zmkaf]kkgjZ][Ymk]l`]qmj_]fldqoYfllgj]afn]kl
[YhalYd]dk]o`]j]&9dl]jfYlan]dq$l`]qoYfllg`gd\g^^^gjY`a_`]jkYd]hja[]&O`]f[gehYfa]k^g[mk
kaf_d]%eaf\]\dqgfkh]]\gjnYdm]_gYdk$l`]q^j]im]fldqgeall`]f][]kkYjqkl]hklgY[`a]n]]al`]jgf]&
Kh]]\j]imaj]klYadgj]\hj]hYjYlagf^gjYfal]_jgmhg^Zmq]jk
O`]f[gehYfa]k^g[mkkgd]dqgflae]$l`]qg^l]flYc]k`gjl[mlkYf\j]d]Yk]af[gehd]l]gjafY[[mjYl]af^gjeYlagf&L`]j]kmdl
akl`YlZmq]jkeYq\jghgmla^l`]qj]fgl[ge^gjlYZd]oal`l`]afn]kle]fl[Yk]&H=Zmq]jk$afhYjla[mdYj$eYqdgk]^Yal`afl`]
eYfY_]e]fll]YeYf\f]_glaYlagfk[YfZ][ge]hjgljY[l]\YkZmq]jkdggc^gjYdl]jfYlan]jgml]klgYfko]jl`]ajim]klagfk&
L`akmf[]jlYaflqakg^l]fj]][l]\afYdgo]jfYdg^^]j$hYjla[mdYjdqa^[geh]lalagf`Yk^Ydd]fg^^\mjaf_l`]Za\hjg[]kk&
L`]c]qlg]ph]\alaf_l`]\]Ydaklgmf\]jklYf\l`]dac]dqZmq]jkYf\`golghj]hYj]^gjl`Ylfal]_jgmh&
LYc]l`]lae]mh^jgfllg\]f]o`Ylqgmj]k]ddaf_ o`YlYf\
o`gak_gaf_oal`l`]Zmkaf]kk!$mf\]jklYf\`go\]h]f\]flal
akgfgl`]jYj]Ykg^qgmj[gehYfq$Yf\[gfka\]jYf\hdYf^gj
hY[cY_af_ghlagfk
;gf^mkagfYegf_Zmq]jk
K]dd]j[j]Yl]knYjagmkk[]fYjagkafj]Y[lan]eg\]Yf\
f]_glaYlagfklYc]dgf_]j
@Yn]Y[d]Yjna]ogfl`]egkldac]dqZmq]jkYf\l`]ajnYdm]
\jan]jk$[geemfa[Yl]l`]nYdm]^jgeYZmq]jh]jkh][lan]$
Yf\hj]hYj]^gjl`]ajj]kh][lan]fYf[aYdj]imaj]e]flk
Yf\im]klagfk
OYkl]lae]YfYdqraf_ajj]d]nYflaf^gjeYlagfgjZja\_af_
lgaf[gjj][l\YlYhj]nagmkdqhjgna\]\
Hgkalagfl`][gehYfqkm[`l`YlZmq]jkYj]Za\\af_gfa\]fla[Yd
h]jae]l]j \]falagfg^f]l\]Zl$ogjcaf_[YhalYdlj]Yle]fl$
ljYfkalagfk]jna[]Y_j]]e]flk$]l[&!
9\\alagfYdlae]kh]fl]nYdmYlaf_Za\k
@Yn]Y[d]Yjdq\]f]\Yf\]p][mlYZd]k]hYjYlagfhdYfl`Yl
k`gokZa\\]jkYjgY\eYhg^`gol`]qoadd_]ll`]Zmkaf]kk
^jgeo`]j]alaklg\Yqaflgl`]aj`Yf\k af[dm\af_klYf\Ydgf]
[gklYfYdqkak!
:mq]joadd\]n]dghalkgofna]og^klYf\Ydgf]Yf\gf]%
lae][gklk$o`a[`oaddfglZ]^YngjYZd]lgl`]k]dd]j
Hjgna\]kmhhgjlYZd]$j]Ydakla[eYjc]lYfYdqkakYf\^gj][Ykl
FglYZd]lghgkalagfY[gfnaf[af_nYdm]klgjqZmq]j[gmd\
\ak[gmflhja[]gjoYdcYoYq^jgel`]\]Yd
L`afcYZgmlZmq]jfYf[af_j]imaj]e]flkYf\`]dhl`]e_]l
fYf[af_ ]&_&$\]ZlakkmYf[]!
<]dYq]\[dgkaf_\m]lglae]lgfYf[]gj\ak[gmfl]\kYd]
hja[]YkfYf[af_akegj]]ph]fkan]l`YfYfla[ahYl]\
Hjgna\]Ym\al]\fYf[aYdklYl]e]flkgjmf\]jklYf\fYf[aYd
klYl]e]flj]imaj]e]flk
DaealZmq]jhggdYf\l`]j]^gj]^YadlgeYpaear]nYdm]
LYc]lae]Yf\j]kgmj[]klgklYjll`]d]_Yd]flalqk]l%mhhjg[]kk
Egj]lae]lg[dgk]$gjklY__]j]\[dgkaf_\Yl]kZq[gmfljq$
a^k]hYjYl]d]_Yd]flala]kYj]f]]\]\
Mf\]jklYf\l`YlYkeYddZmkaf]kkakfglf][]kkYjadq
]Ykqlgk]hYjYl]
Mf\]j]klaeYl][gehd]palqgjj]imaj]\hj]hYjYlagflae]$
d]Y\af_lg]dgf_Yl]\ka_faf_Yf\[dgkaf_
K]ddlgYZmq]joal`Yf]paklaf_hdYl^gje
Dgk]nYdm]Yf\hgkkaZdqlae]2[gklkZmq]jegj]Yf\lYc]k
dgf_]jlg[j]Yl]Yf]oklYf\Ydgf][gehYfq
l`Yflgafl]_jYl]aflgl`]Zmq]jk_]g_jYh`a[gj
hjg\m[laf^jYkljm[lmj]
10
16
Dgk]nYdm]a^Zmq]jk[j]Yl]l`]ajgofna]o
Dgk][j]\aZadalqo`]fqgm[YflYfko]jZmq]jim]klagfk
A^eYpaearaf_nYdm]akqgmj_gYd
O]km__]kll`Ylqgm^g[mkgfl`]^gddgoaf_[jala[Ydogjc
klj]Yeka^qgmj_gYdaklgeYpaear]nYdm]2
Afn]klafnYdm][j]YlagfafalaYlan]klg
]f`Yf[]j]n]fm]Yf\eYj_afk
9lljY[lY\\alagfYdZmq]jk3kge]lae]kk]dd]jk
[gf\]flaYddqk[gh]gmlafl]j]kl^jge[gehYfa]k
]&_&$Ogmd\qgmZ]afl]j]kl]\a^Y[]jlYafZmkaf]kk
[Ye]lgeYjc]l7O`Ylogmd\Z]afl]j]klaf_lgqgm7!
@gd\af_g^^gfka_faf_Y\]Ydmfladqgm_]lYkh][a[nYdmYlagf
[gmd\e]Yfl`YlqgmoYkl]lae]Yf\]f]j_qYf\]f\mhoal`
fgZmq]j&L`]egj]lae]l`YlhYkk]k$l`]_j]Yl]jl`][`Yf[]
qgmjZmkaf]kk[gmd\_gaflg\][daf]^gjeYjc]lj]YkgfkYf\'gj
dY[cg^afn]kle]flYll`][gjhgjYl]d]n]d&9f\qgm[gmd\]f\
mhZ]af_^gj[]\lgk]ddYlY\ak[gmfl&Kgk]dd]jkf]]\lgl]ddY
kljgf_$[j]\aZd]nYdm]klgjqYf\o]a_`l`]ghhgjlmfalq[gklkg^
oYalaf_lggdgf_^gjl`]ja_`lhja[]&
;gfka\]jl`]Zmq]jkeaf\k]lYf\
[geemfa[Yl]hgl]flaYdZmq]jkqf]j_a]k
;j]Yl]Ykljgf_nYdm]klgjql`Ylqgmcfgo
oaddklYf\mhlgZmq]jk[jmlafq
L`]kh]]\%n]jkmk%nYdm][`Ydd]f_]
The delay in divestment preparation
Yf\l`]af]^[a]fl[ggj\afYlagf
between business functions affected
transaction value as market
conditions were changing drastically.
Executive at a UK-based
technology company
17
Conclusion
Dggcaf_^gjoYj\2Y\\j]kkaf_qgmjlgh\an]kle]fl[`Ydd]f_]k
=Y[`k][lgj`YkalkgofkljYl]_a[aeh]jYlan]^gjeYcaf_hgjl^gdagegn]kfgo&?dgZYdaf\mkljaYd
[gf_dge]jYl]kYj]Z][geaf_klj]Yedaf]\$da^]k[a]f[]k[gehYfa]kYj]koYhhaf_Ykk]lkYf\[gfkme]j
hjg\m[lk[gehYfa]kYj]jYlagfYdaraf_ZjYf\k&;gehYfa]kafl`]l][`fgdg_qk][lgjYj][`Yf_af_l`]aj
Zmkaf]kkeg\]dk$Yf\afl`]gadYf\_Ykaf\mkljq$mhklj]YeYf\\gofklj]YeZmkaf]kk]kYj]Zj]Ycaf_mh&
:mlfgeYll]jl`]af\mkljq$d]Y\af_hjY[la[]klg]^^][l
ljYfk^gjeYlagfYd[`Yf_]Yj]kaeadYjY[jgkkl`]ZgYj\$
Yf\\a^[mdllgaehd]e]fl&A^qgmjdYkl\an]kle]floYk
mfkm[[]kk^md$lYcaf_YdggcYlhYkleaklYc]kgjgeakkagfk
[YfhYn]l`]oYq^gjY\ghlaf_Z]ll]jhjY[la[]kl`]f]pllae]
Yjgmf\&KlYjloal`kljYl]_q2Yj]qgm[gf\m[laf_j]_mdYj
hgjl^gdagj]na]ok79j]qgmYddg[Ylaf_[YhalYdlgaf[j]Yk]
k`Yj]`gd\]jnYdm]7F]pl$^g[mkgfhj]nagmk]p][mlagf
[`Ydd]f_]k&=p][mlan]kfYe]\k]n]jYd_gn]jfYf[]$fYf[aYd
Yf\gh]jYlagfYdkl]hkl`Yll`]q^]dll`]qk`gmd\eYfY_]Z]ll]j
afl`]ajf]pl\an]kle]fl$af[dm\af_\]faf_l`]h]jae]l]jkg^
l`]Zmkaf]kk$[ggj\afYlaf_l`]Zmkaf]kk^mf[lagfkafngdn]\af
l`]\an]kle]fl$[geemfa[Ylaf_afl]jfYddqYf\oal`Zmq]jk$Yf\
\]l]jeafaf_ALk]hYjYlagfj]imaj]e]flk&
FglYZdq$l`]qYdkghgafl]\lghj]%kYd]nYdm][j]Ylagfkl]hkl`Yl
l`]q^]dlogmd\`Yn]Z]f]l]\l`]eZmll`Yll`]q\a\fgllYc]&
EgklaehgjlYflgfl`akdaklgn]jYddo]j]]pljY[laf_ogjcaf_
[YhalYdYf\eYcaf_gh]jYlagfYdaehjgn]e]flklgaf[j]Yk]
eYj_afkl][`faim]kl`YlH=jek`Yn]mk]\oal`_j]Yl
km[[]kk&Af^Y[l$H=`YkeYfqnYdm][j]Ylagfd]kkgfklgg^^]j$
af[dm\af_\ak[ahdaf]\hdYffaf_$e]Ykmj]e]fl$Y[[gmflYZadalq
Yf\j]oYj\af_g^Y[`a]n]e]fl&L`]k]Yj]YddkljYl]_a]kl`Yl
[j]Yl]Yk]fk]g^mj_]f[qYf\^gkl]jeYfY_]e]flYll]flagflg
nYdm][j]Ylagf&
;gehYfa]kl`Yl[gf\m[l^j]im]flhgjl^gdagj]na]okmkaf_l`]
ja_`l\YlYYf\YfYdqla[k$Yf\l`YllYc]l`]lae]lghj]hYj]Y
[j]\aZd]klgjqlYadgj]\lgkh][a[Zmq]jk$klYf\l`]Z]kl[`Yf[]
g^eYpaearaf_Zgl`kh]]\Yf\nYdm]afl`]aj\an]kle]flkYf\
af[j]Ykaf_nYdmYlagfemdlahd]kafl`]ajj]eYafaf_Zmkaf]kk]k&
Gfdq)1g^]p][mlan]ke]lYddl`j]]g^l`]k]km[[]kke]lja[k&
L`]k][gehYfa]kYj]Z]klhgkalagf]\lghjgY[lan]dq_Yaf
eYjc]lk`Yj]Yf\Y\Yhlima[cdqlg^mlmj]eYjc]l[`Yf_]k&
Lgd]Yjfegj]YZgmll`][jala[Ydkl]hklg[Yjn]gmlYZmkaf]kk
afkapegfl`k$Ykcqgmj=Q[gflY[l^gjgmjRoadmap to
carve-out sale success&
O`ad]faf]af\mkljqk][lgjkYj]j]hj]k]fl]\$l`]klm\q
^g[mk]kgf[gfkme]jhjg\m[lk$\an]jka]\af\mkljaYdk$
fYf[aYdk]jna[]k$da^]k[a]f[]k$gadYf\_Yk$Yf\l][`fgdg_q&
Egj]l`Yf`Yd^g^l`]]p][mlan]kj]hj]k]fl[gehYfa]koal`
YffmYdj]n]fm]kl`Yl]p[]]\MK)Z&
Produced in association with
Remark
Research from the Financial Times Group
18
Contacts
Pip McCrostie
EY Global Vice Chair
Transaction Advisory Services
pip.mccrostie@uk.ey.com
+44 20 7980 0500
Steve Krouskos
EY Global Deputy Vice Chair
Transaction Advisory Services
steve.krouskos@uk.ey.com
+1 +44 20 7980 0346
Paul Hammes
EY Global Divestiture
Advisory Services Leader
paul.hammes@ey.com
+1 312 879 3741
Rich Mills
EY Americas Divestiture Advisory
Services Leader
rich.mills@ey.com
+1 404 817 4397
Martin Hurst
EY Europe, Middle East, India and Africa
Divestiture Advisory Services Leader
martin.hurst@de.ey.com
+49 6196 996 27365
Stephen Lomas
=Q9kaY%HY[a[<an]klalmj]
Advisory Services Leader
stephen.lomas@au.ey.com
+61 3 9288 8441
Kenneth G. Smith
Japan Divestiture Advisory
Services Leader
kenneth.smith@jp.ey.com
+81 3 4582 6400
19
EY |9kkmjYf[]tLYptLjYfkY[lagfkt9\nakgjq
About EY
=QakY_dgZYdd]Y\]jafYkkmjYf[]$lYp$
ljYfkY[lagfYf\Y\nakgjqk]jna[]k&L`]
afka_`lkYf\imYdalqk]jna[]ko]\]dan]j`]dh
Zmad\ljmklYf\[gf\]f[]afl`][YhalYd
eYjc]lkYf\af][gfgea]kl`]ogjd\gn]j&
O]\]n]dghgmlklYf\af_d]Y\]jko`gl]Ye
lg\]dan]jgfgmjhjgeak]klgYddg^gmj
klYc]`gd\]jk&Afkg\gaf_$o]hdYqY[jala[Yd
jgd]afZmad\af_YZ]ll]jogjcaf_ogjd\
^gjgmjh]ghd]$^gjgmj[da]flkYf\^gjgmj
[geemfala]k&
=Qj]^]jklgl`]_dgZYdgj_YfarYlagf$Yf\eYq
j]^]jlggf]gjegj]$g^l`]e]eZ]jjekg^
=jfklQgmf_?dgZYdDaeal]\$]Y[`g^o`a[`
akYk]hYjYl]d]_Yd]flalq&=jfklQgmf_
?dgZYdDaeal]\$YMC[gehYfqdaeal]\Zq
_mYjYfl]]$\g]kfglhjgna\]k]jna[]klg
[da]flk&>gjegj]af^gjeYlagfYZgmlgmj
gj_YfarYlagf$hd]Yk]nakal]q&[ge&
About EYs Transaction Advisory Services
@goqgmeYfY_]qgmj[YhalYdY_]f\Y
lg\Yqoadd\]f]qgmj[geh]lalan]hgkalagf
lgegjjgo&O]ogjcoal`[da]flklg[j]Yl]
kg[aYdYf\][gfgea[nYdm]Zq`]dhaf_l`]e
eYc]Z]ll]j$egj]af^gje]\\][akagfk
YZgmlkljYl]_a[YddqeYfY_af_[YhalYdYf\
ljYfkY[lagfkaf^Ykl%[`Yf_af_eYjc]lk&
O`]l`]jqgmj]hj]k]jnaf_$ghlaearaf_$
jYakaf_gjafn]klaf_[YhalYd$=QkLjYfkY[lagf
9\nakgjqK]jna[]k[geZaf]Ymfaim]k]l
g^kcaddk$afka_`lYf\]ph]ja]f[]lg\]dan]j
^g[mk]\Y\na[]&O]`]dhqgm\jan][geh]lalan]
Y\nYflY_]Yf\af[j]Yk]\j]lmjfkl`jgm_`
aehjgn]\\][akagfkY[jgkkYddYkh][lkg^qgmj
[YhalYdY_]f\Y&
*()-=Q?EDaeal]\&
9ddJa_`lkJ]k]jn]\&
),))%)+-/0,)
=Q?fg&;=(0-0
=<(+)/
L`akeYl]jaYd`YkZ]]fhj]hYj]\^gj_]f]jYd
af^gjeYlagfYdhmjhgk]kgfdqYf\akfglafl]f\]\
lgZ]j]da]\mhgfYkY[[gmflaf_$lYpgjgl`]j
hjg^]kkagfYdY\na[]&Hd]Yk]j]^]jlgqgmjY\nakgjk
^gjkh][a[Y\na[]&
L`]na]okg^l`aj\hYjla]kk]lgmlafl`akhmZda[Ylagf
Yj]fglf][]kkYjadql`]na]okg^l`]_dgZYd=Q
gj_YfarYlagfgjalke]eZ]jjek&Egj]gn]j$l`]q
k`gmd\Z]k]]fafl`][gfl]plg^l`]lae]l`]q
o]j]eY\]&
ey.com
20