You are on page 1of 7

CHILLER PLANT CONTROL

This case study demonstrates the control of a three stage chiller plant that
cools water in a primary loop, which feeds into a secondary loop with a
heat load.

MINING INDUSTRY

MINING INDUSTRY
CHALLENGE:
Investigate the operation and effectiveness of a three stage chiller plant that
cools water in a mine primary and secondary loop with a heat load. Develop an
effective control system in a situation where the load changes rapidly.

BENEFITS:

Transient analysis of the System

Control Optimization

Heat loads

SOLUTION:

Page

Flownex was used to simulate the control of a three stage chiller plant using a
step controller in conjunction with a controller on a bleed valve that allows
colder water from the primary circuit into the warmer secondary circuit. The
simulation shows that the control strategy is effective.

Flownex was used to simulate the control of a three stage


chiller plant using a step controller in conjunction with a
controller on a bleed valve that allows colder water from
the primary sales@flownex.com
circuit into the warmer secondary circuit.
www.flownex.com

CONTROL OF A CHILLER PLANT

SYSTEM DESCRIPTION

The lay-out of the system is shown in Figure 1.

Figure 1: Layout of three-step chiller plant.

The water in the primary and secondary loops is circulated at nearly


constant rates by two independent pumps. A varying heat load
heats the water in the secondary loop. Controller C1 senses the
temperature in the primary loop and attempts to keep the
temperature constant by switching chiller stages on or off.
Controller C2 senses the temperature just before the heat load and
opens or closes the control valve in an attempt to keep the
temperature at the inlet to the load constant.
OBJECTIVE OF SIMULATION

Page

The objective of the simulation is to investigate the operation and


effectiveness of the control system in a situation where the load
changes rapidly.

www.flownex.com

sales@flownex.com

The objective of
the simulation is to
investigate the
operation and
effectiveness of the
control system in a
situation where the
load changes
rapidly

FLOWNEX MODEL
The Flownex model of the system is shown in Figure 2. The threestage chiller is modeled by three pipes, each with a negative heat
load of 1100 kW that can individually be switched on or off by
separate PID controllers. The control valve is also controlled with a
PID controller.

Primary loop

Secondary
loop

Load

Valve

Control valve

Three-stage chiller
Pump

Stage 1

Controller
Step
Controller

Figure 2: Flownex model of the three stage chiller plant with control system.

DESCRIPTION OF SIMULATION
A transient simulation is done where the load in the secondary loop
is varied as shown in Figure 3.

3500
3000

Load [kW]

2500
2000
1500
1000
500
0

200

400

600

Page

Time [s]
Figure 3: Variation of load with time.

www.flownex.com

sales@flownex.com

800

1000

Stage 2

Stage 3

The initial condition or the simulation is the steady-state solution


with a fixed temperature of 45 C at node 13.
The settings of the three step controllers for the chiller are as
follows:

Stage Setpoint

Deadband

1
2
3

1 C
1 C
1 C

5 C
6 C
7 C

Minimum
heat
-1.1 MW
-1.1 MW
-1.1 MW

10 MW/C 0
10 MW/C 0
10 MW/C 0

Figure 4 shows how the different stages will be switched on and off
on rising and decreasing temperatures.

Step

Off

On
On

Off

On

Step

Off

Step

Cooling

Combined effect

5
6
7
9
Temperature [C]

Figure 4: Settings of step controller.

RESULTS

Page

Figure 5 shows the variation of temperature at the inlet to the load


for the case where the chiller step controller is on while the control
valve controller is switched off.

www.flownex.com

sales@flownex.com

25.0

Temperature [C]

20.0
15.0
10.0
5.0
0.0

200

400

600

800

1000

Time [s]

Figure 5: Temperature at inlet to the load with the control valve controller switched
off.

Figure 6 shows the variation of temperature at the inlet to the load


with both controllers switched on. Apart from the initial transient
the control valve controller succeeds in keeping the temperature at
the inlet of the load within a narrow range.

18.0

Temperature [C]

16.0
14.0
12.0
10.0
8.0
6.0
4.0
2.0
0.0

200

400

600

800

1000

Time [s]

Page

Figure 6: Temperature at inlet to the load with the control valve controller switched
on.

www.flownex.com

sales@flownex.com

Figure 7 shows the variation of control valve diameter with time.


0.12

Diameter [m]

0.10
0.08
0.06
0.04
0.02
0.00

200

400

600

800

1000

Time [s]

Figure 7: Variation in valve diameter with time.

CONCLUSION

Page

Flownex was used to simulate the control of a three stage chiller


plant using a step controller in conjunction with a controller on a
bleed valve that allows colder water from the primary circuit into
the warmer secondary circuit. The simulation shows that the control
strategy is effective.

www.flownex.com

sales@flownex.com

The objective of
the simulation is to
investigate the
operation and
effectiveness of the
control system in a
situation where the
load changes
rapidly

You might also like