Professional Documents
Culture Documents
.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Oxford University Press is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to American
Literary History.
http://www.jstor.org
Reading
Politics,
Poe's
Mind:
and
Mathematics,
the
Association of Ideas
in the
"The
Murders
Rue
in
Morgue"
John T. Irwin
188
AmericanLiteraryHistory 189
190
AmericanLiteraryHistory 191
192
AmericanLiteraryHistory 193
194
AmericanLiteraryHistory 195
196
But "Thayerhad no intention of modeling West Point's curriculum after the advanced and highly abstractcurriculumof
the Ecole Polytechniqueof 1815; instead,he looked back to the
curriculumof the years 1795-1804, when the Polytechnique
had been a genuine engineeringschool. Perhaps Thayer was
influencedin this respectby GeneralBernard,an earlygraduate
of the Polytechnique"(Molloy 389). Though mathematicswas
at the core of the curriculumthat Thayerestablished,the emphasis was on its practical applications, with a specific bias
against the theoretical:"The Cadets were not encouragedto
expressthemselvesin abstractterms"(Molloy432-33). Indeed,
one wonderswhetherDupin's quarrelwith "some of the algebraistsof Paris"reflectsa bias againsttheoreticalmathematics
left over from Poe's education at West Point.
Thayer copied not only West Point's curriculumand its
system of examinationsfrom the Polytechniquebut even specific regulations,such as that forbiddingcadets to have any
books in their rooms "beyond prescribedtexts and reference
works" (Molloy 390). In addition, he employed a graduateof
the Polytechnique,ClaudeCrozet,to teach engineering.Crozet,
who had been an artilleryofficerin Napoleon's army, had accompanied Bernardto the US in 1816, servingfirst as an engineer in the US Army and then on the engineeringfaculty at
West Point from 1816 to 1823. Like Charles Dupin, Crozet
had been a student of Monge's at the Polytechnique,and he
introducedinto the US the study of descriptivegeometry,the
field that Monge had invented. In 1821 Crozet published A
Treatise of DescriptiveGeometryfor the Use of Cadets of the
U.S.M.A.,a text that was still "the standardwork for third and
fourthclassmenuntil 1832" (Molloy 444) and would thus have
been availableto Poe.
WhenPoe enteredthe MilitaryAcademyin 1830, Thayer's
Polytechnique-derivedcurriculumhad been in place for thirteen years,and so we can be fairlycertainwhat Poe's course of
studies involved. For the firsttwo years at West Point, a cadet
concentratedon two subjects-mathematics and French.In the
examinationsystem "subjectswere weightedaccordingto their
importance.Thus for freshmen,who studiedonly mathematics
and French, the former subject received a weight of two, the
latter a weight of one" (Molloy 438). Includedin the study of
mathematics was "a little drawing,and a fair amount of descriptive geometry" (Molloy 441). In his first year, a cadet,
"even in the slowestsection, masteredalgebra,plane geometry,
plane analytic geometry, plane trigonometry,and basic techniques of surveying;the advanced section covered advanced
AmericanLiteraryHistory 197
plane and sphericalgeometry in addition to the previous subjects" (Molloy 422). Poe was in the advancedsection in mathematics, as he braggedto John Allan in a letter dated 6 November 1830: "I have an excellentstandingin my class-in the
firstsection in every thing and have greathopes of doing well."
But he adds that "the study requisiteis incessant,and the discipline exceedinglyrigid."He goes on to note, "I am very much
pleasedwith Colonel Thayer,and indeed with everythingat the
institution"(Letters38).
As one of Poe's contemporariesat West Point, A. B. Magruder, recalled, Poe "was an accomplished French scholar,
and had a wonderfulaptitude for mathematics"(Thomas and
Jackson 107). Indeed, Poe's standingin his studies, as he told
Allan, was excellent:after the Januaryexaminationsin 1831,
he was third in French and seventeenth in mathematics in a
classof eighty-seven(Thomasand Jackson 112). And since "the
performanceof each Cadet was chartedon a daily basis," with
the gradesbeingturnedoverto the superintendentweekly(Molloy 428), Poe's rankingin these areasduringhis five months of
classes at West Point is a significantgauge of his ability, particularlyof his mathematicalaptitude, for at the time that Poe
attendedWest Point and for severaldecadesafter,the Military
Academy was "unquestionablythe most influential mathematical school in the United States"(Cajori 121).
Poe's sense of his high academic standingin his class can
be seen in a subsequentletterto the superintendent.Aftergetting
himself court-martialedin February1831 for "grossneglect of
duty" and "disobedienceof orders"and dismissed from West
Point, Poe wrote Thayer on 10 March requestinga letter of
recommendation:"I intend by the firstopportunityto proceed
to Paris with the view of obtaining, thro' the interest of the
Marquis de La Fayette, an appointment (if possible) in the
PolishArmy. In the event of the interferenceof Francein behalf
of Polandthis may be easily effected.... A certificateof'standing' in my class is all that I have any rightto expect. Any thing
farther-a letterto a friendin Paris-or to the Marquis-would
be a kindnesswhich I should neverforget"(Letters44-45). One
wonderswhetherPoe's plan to go to Paristo continuea military
careerafterhis dismissalfrom West Point had been influenced
by the recentreturnto Franceof Bernard.Indeed,one wonders
whetherBernardwas Thayer's"friendin Paris"mentioned in
Poe's letter. French army recordsshow that Bernardhad "returned to active service in the Corps of Engineers"as of 12
February1831 (Carter307), a month before Poe's letter.
To judge, then, from the curriculumat West Point in Poe's
198
AmericanLiteraryHistory 199
guage of the Polytechnic School, signifies that part of stonecutting,on which Frezierand De la Rue have writtenso much."
Indeed, in the curriculumfor the Polytechniquethat Monge
drew up in 1794, half of the time allotted for mathematical
study"wouldbe given overto 'stereotomy,'or civil and military
engineering,"an area of study that "included descriptivegeometry, mechanicaldrawing,theoriesof shadowsand perspective and their applications to stone and wood cutting techniques"(Molloy 104) for use in roadbuilding,bridgeand canal
construction,and harborimprovementsand fortifications.Poe's
use of the word, then, almost certainly reflectshis own Polytechnique-basedschooling at West Point and possibly reflects
as well his sense of the influence that the Polytechnique'sscientificinnovationshad had on daily life in Franceby the 1830s.
And, indeed, I think we can detect here some of the associations at work in Poe's own mind that led him to use this
odd technicalterm connectedwith the Polytechnique.The chain
of associationswould seem to beginwith Poe's choice of a name
for "the little alley" whose pavingremindedthe narratorof the
word stereotomy. He calls the alley "Lamartine."Mabbott is
undoubtedlycorrectin thinkingthat the name is an allusionto
"the voluminous poet" Alphonse de Lamartine(1790-1869).
Accordingto Mabbott,Poe consideredLamartine"a bore, and
slyly gave his name to a little alley" (2: 571nl 8). But there is
clearlymore involved in his use of the name thanjust a passing
slap at a boring poet. Like Andre Dupin, Lamartinewas one
of the figuresdiscussedat lengthin Lomenie'sSketchesof Conspicuous Living Charactersof France, the book that Poe reviewed in the same issue of Graham'sMagazine in which he
published "The Murdersin the Rue Morgue." In the chapter
devoted to him, Lamartineis depicted as a man who has succeeded in a dual career-being both a brilliant poet and an
adept politician. Having held various diplomatic posts under
the restoredmonarchy, Lamartineeventuallybecame a member of the Chamberof Deputies in 1834, servingin that body
at the same period when Andre Dupin was its presidentand
200
AmericanLiteraryHistory 201
202
AmericanLiteraryHistory 203
204
AmericanLiteraryHistory 205
share a common root). The associative link between the constellationof starscalled Orion and the actor Chantillyis, then,
not just that both had had other names at one time but that
Chantillyhas attemptedto rise in society from his formercobblestone-orientedtradeby becoming a starin the theaterin the
tragicrole of a king. The use of "star"to referto the principal
actorin a theatricalproductionhad, as the OED shows,become
commonplace by the 1820s.
From a would-be theatricalstar to the image of stars in
the heavens is an easy mental step, but a stellar translation,
whetherin the theateror in ancientmythology,is more difficult
for a groundlingto effect, particularlywhen the groundlingin
question is built too close to the ground to reach that high.
Dupin says that when the narratorthought of "the poor cobbler's immolation" by the press, he changed his posture: "So
far,you had been stoopingin your gait;but now I saw you draw
yourselfup to your full height.I was then surethat you reflected
upon the diminutive figureof Chantilly.At this point I interrupted your meditations to remark that as, in fact, he was a
very little fellow-that Chantilly-he would do better at the
Theatredes Varietes"(2: 536-37). That the narratorinterprets
the public humiliation of this lowly upstartas having a larger
social significance,a significancethat bears on the narrator's
being jostled in the street by a common laborer, seems clear
from the fact that aftergazingdown at the pavementand stooping in his gait followingthe incident with the laborer,the narrator appearsto recover himself, to rememberwho and what
he is by drawing himself up to his full height. This almost
subliminaldramaof the tensionsbetweenhigh and low in postrevolutionaryFranceis, of course, wholly appropriateto a tale
in which a humanlikeanimal slave firstmimics or, if you will,
apes its master(the shavingepisode)and then breaksloose from
its master'scontrolto spreadterrorthroughthe streetsof Paris.
That the fallen aristocratDupin intervenesin this case of master/slave reversalto help restoreorderbespeaksa political orientation that later becomes explicit in "The PurloinedLetter"
when he intervenesagain, this time on the side of royalty, to
thwart another master/slave reversal-an orientation that no
doubt reflectedto some degree the political sentiments of the
fallen Virginia gentleman who invented Dupin, a gentleman
who, after his wealthy foster father had disowned him, spent
the restof his life tryingto regainhis lost social statusby playing
the role of the mastermind,hopingto risethroughthe uncertain
social ranks of JacksonianAmerica by the power of sheer intelligenceto occupy his rightfulposition in an American aris-
206