Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Welcome to
AERO 2513 (MC225/238)
AERO 2459 (BP078/070)
Airworthiness Management
Frameworks
(57.03.34) by appointment
Contact:
7/16/2015
Groundrules
No smoking, eating or drinking.
Set mobiles to silent.
One person speaks at a time.
Show respect for one another.
If in doubt, ask yourself the question: Would I act
like this in a management board room meeting
with chief executives present?
RMIT University 2015
7/16/2015
Course Content
Lecture 1 ~ Airworthiness: An Introduction.
Concept of airworthiness, understanding of
safety in an aviation context, technical
airworthiness, operational airworthiness.
Lecture 2 ~ Airworthiness Management Frameworks
History and explanation of the overarching legal
systems.
Lecture 3 ~ Airworthiness Management Frameworks
State of registry, the concept of National Aviation
Authorities (NAA), overview of the Australian
NAA (CASA).
Course Content.Cont.
Lecture 4 ~ Initial Airworthiness
Overview of Civil Aircraft. The role of NAAs. Civil
Design Standards.
Lecture 5 ~ Initial Airworthiness
Overview of Military Aircraft. The role of NMAAs.
Military Design Standards.
Lecture 6 ~ Initial Airworthiness
Guest Lecture.
7/16/2015
Course Content.Cont.
Lecture 7 ~
Continuing Airworthiness
Continuing Airworthiness Management
Organisations (CAMO).
Lecture 8 ~ Continuing Airworthiness
Approved Maintenance Organisations
(AMO).
Lecture 9 ~ Continuing Airworthiness
Safety Management Systems (SMS).
Lecture 10 ~ Continuing Airworthiness
Regulatory Compliance.
Lecture 11 ~ Continuing Airworthiness
Related Issues.
Lecture 12 ~ Revision
RMIT University 2015
Initial Airworthiness
(Original Airworthiness)
Reproduced from
sats.aeroengineer.net
Continuing Airworthiness
(Recurrent Airworthiness)
Reproduced from
www.planespotters.net
7/16/2015
10
7/16/2015
12
7/16/2015
13
14
7/16/2015
15
Useful Resources
All relevant publications and web links will be
provided as the need arises during the delivery
of this course.
Some handouts may be provided.
There is a very comprehensive Learning Guide
(~ 95 pages) available which you should
download and read in parallel with the lectures.
16
7/16/2015
17
18
7/16/2015
19
http://www.casa.gov.au/scripts/nc.dll?WCMS:PWA::pc=PC_91072
20
10
7/16/2015
21
22
11
7/16/2015
23
24
12
7/16/2015
10 Minute Break
Are Aeroplanes
Safe ?
26
13
7/16/2015
27
28
14
7/16/2015
29
30
15
7/16/2015
31
32
16
7/16/2015
33
ICAO assigned
regions:
RASG = Regional
Aviation Safety
Group Region
34
17
7/16/2015
2013 Accidents by
Phase of Flight
2013 Accidents by
Type of Service
35
36
The
Evolution of
the
Commercial
Air Transport
World Fleet
Commercial
Aviation Accidents
1958 - 2013
A Statistical Analysis.
AIRBUS S.A.S. 31707 Blagnac
Cedex, France
AIRBUS S.A.S. 2014.
18
7/16/2015
Commercial Aviation Accidents 1958 2013 A Statistical Analysis. AIRBUS S.A.S. 31707 Blagnac Cedex, France AIRBUS S.A.S. 2014.
37
Commercial Aviation Accidents 1958 2013 A Statistical Analysis. AIRBUS S.A.S. 31707 Blagnac Cedex, France AIRBUS S.A.S. 2014.
38
19
7/16/2015
Levels of Safety
A single airliner is designed for 30,000+ flight cycles.
Each take-off and landing is one cycle (G-A-G cycle).
This corresponds to > 50,000+ flight hrs.
The typical economic operational life is 20+ yrs.
A large fleet of one type typically consists of 200 aircraft.
Hence the fleet total = 50,000 x 200 = 10,000,000 hrs
= 1 x 107 hrs or 107 hrs.
39
Levels of Safety
The objective of CS 25.1309 is to ensure an acceptable safety
level for equipment and systems as installed on the aeroplane.
A logical and acceptable inverse relationship must exist
between the Average Probability per Flight Hour and the
severity of Failure Condition effects, such that:
40
20
7/16/2015
Levels of Safety
41
42
21
7/16/2015
Bird strikes are common occurrences and can lead to minor damage.
RMIT University 2015
43
An emergency landing was made with the nose landing gear turned sideways.
RMIT University 2015
44
22
7/16/2015
45
All one hundred passengers and nine crew members on board the flight died. On the ground, four
people were killed and one critically injured. This was the only fatal Concorde accident during its
27-year operational history.
RMIT University 2015
46
23
7/16/2015
47
10 Minute Break
24
7/16/2015
Airworthiness
Airworthiness as a Process to Ensure Safety Outcomes
at Acceptable Levels.
It is not necessary to explore these issues of passenger
perception or financial trade-off in detail for students to
accept the underlying assertion since all those who work in
aviation have seen these issues played out every day in
every aspect of aviation.
What is worth emphasising, and remembering throughout
this course is that:
Airworthiness processes are all about achieving
acceptable levels of safety.
49
Airworthiness
Airworthiness as a Process to Ensure Safety Outcomes
at Acceptable LevelsCont.
What is an acceptable level of safety is complex and is
driven by customer tolerance and perceptions, regulatory
reflection of what is acceptable to customers, and operator
perception of reputation.
In aviation you get what you pay for. Safety has a cost and
Airworthiness processes are in part in place to assist with
getting this balance correct.
50
25
7/16/2015
Airworthiness Definitions
A wide range of definitions for Airworthiness exists.
The FAA definition is split across a range of individual
regulations. The FAA [implicitly] states that an aircraft is
airworthy:
. as long as the aircraft meets its approved type
design, is in a condition for safe operation and
maintenance, preventative maintenance, and alterations
are performed in accordance with 14 CFR parts 21, 43,
and 91.
This is a limited definition that applies to technical aspects
of airworthiness.
http://www.faa.gov/aircraft/air_cert/airworthiness_certification/std_awcert/
51
Airworthiness Definitions
In Basic Regulation (EC) No 216/2008, Article 5
Airworthiness, Para 2 (c), EASA defines airworthiness:
.each aircraft shall be issued with
an individual certificate of
airworthiness when it is shown that
it conforms with the type design
approved in its type-certificate and
that relevant documentation,
inspections and tests demonstrate
that the aircraft is in condition for
safe operation.
52
26
7/16/2015
Airworthiness Definitions
The JSP 553 Military Airworthiness Regulations
(2006) Edition 1 Change 5 defines airworthiness
as:
.The ability of an aircraft or
other airborne equipment or system
to operate without significant hazard
to aircrew, ground crew, passengers
(where relevant) or to the general
public over which such airborne
systems are flown.
53
Airworthiness Definitions
In summary, two conditions must be met before an aircraft
can be considered airworthy:
The aircraft must conform to its type certificate (TC); that is,
when the aircraft configuration and the components
installed are consistent with the drawing, specifications,
and other data that are part of the TC, and include any
supplemental TC and field-approved alterations
incorporated into the aircraft.
The aircraft must be in condition for safe operation; this
refers to the condition of the aircraft relative to wear and
deterioration.
An aircraft which conforms to its type certificate data sheet
and is in a condition for safe operation, is considered to
be airworthy.
RMIT University 2015
54
27
7/16/2015
Airworthiness Definitions
For the purposes of this course the Australian
Defence Force (ADF) understanding of
airworthiness provides the best holistic
definition of Airworthiness:
Airworthiness is a concept, the application of which
defines the condition of an aircraft and supplies the
basis for judgment of the suitability for flight of that
aircraft, in that it has been designed, constructed,
maintained and operated to approved standards and
limitations, by competent and authorised individuals,
who are acting as members of an approved
organisation and whose work is both certified as
correct and accepted on behalf of Defence.
Australian Government Department of Defence, DI(G) OPS 02-2,
AMDT NO 2, Sept 2014,Section 9.
RMIT University 2015
55
Airworthiness Definitions
Airworthiness is a concept
This is highlighting that the notion of airworthiness does
not define a particular state for a particular attribute but
rather a series of attributes all of which must be
achieved.
56
28
7/16/2015
Airworthiness Definitions
Which defines the condition of an aircraft
57
Airworthiness Definitions
Supplies the basis for judgement of Suitability for
Flight.
For the physical condition of the aircraft the known
condition can be used to determine if the aircraft can
perform designated roles. I have to define what is
needed; the airworthiness process must then prove that
the aircraft matches what is needed. The same concept
applies to all aspects of the operation.
Designed, constructed, and maintained to approved
standards and limitations
This is the basis of technical airworthiness, the physical
condition of the aircraft.
RMIT University 2015
58
29
7/16/2015
Airworthiness Definitions
Operated to approved standards and limitations
This is basis of operational airworthiness, the way that
the aircraft is operated.
59
Airworthiness Definitions
Who are members of an approved organisation
Illustrates that while individuals have defined
responsibilities for airworthiness, that the system
requires individuals to operate within a defined
organisation, where each persons role and scope of
authority is defined.
Whose work is both certified as correct and accepted
on behalf of Defence.
Suggests that process and people are not only approved
once, but the outcomes they produce are formally
approved in an ongoing manner.
RMIT University 2015
60
30
7/16/2015
Airworthiness Definitions
Suitability for flight:
Suitability for flight is an assessment that flight of the
aircraft within designated configuration, role and
environment occurs to an acceptable risk of:
a) loss of life or injury to aircrew and passengers;
b) loss to other personnel or damage to property as a
direct consequence of the flight; and
c) loss of, or damage to the aircraft.
61
Technical Airworthiness
Technical airworthiness is concerned with
ensuring aircraft are designed, constructed and
maintained to approved standards by competent
and authorised individuals, using approved data
and working within approved organisations under
a system of certification and acceptance.
Australian Government Department of Defence, DI(G) OPS 02-2, AMDT NO 2, Sept 2014,Section
10(a).
www.combataircraft.com
62
31
7/16/2015
Technical Airworthiness
An aircraft type is deemed technically airworthy if it is:
Designed to and certified as meeting approved
standards by an approved organisation.
Constructed by an approved organisation in accordance
with approved standards.
Maintained by qualified people in accordance with an
approved instructions, operating within an approved
organisation.
Accepted on behalf of the regulator as meeting the
regulators requirements.
63
Operational Airworthiness
Operational airworthiness. Operational
airworthiness is concerned with ensuring aircraft are
operated in approved roles, with correct mission
equipment, by competent and authorised individuals,
according to approved procedures and instructions,
under a system of supervision and monitoring.
Australian Government Department of Defence, DI(G) OPS 02-2, AMDT NO 2, Sept
2014,Section 10(b).
www.angelfire.com
RMIT University 2015
64
32
7/16/2015
Operational Airworthiness
An aircraft type is deemed operationally airworthy if it is:
Technically airworthy, AND
Operated within approved roles and environmental
parameters,
By qualified, competent and authorised personnel,
According to approved limitations and instructions,
Under a system of checking.
65
Operational Airworthiness
Firstly Technical Airworthiness is a precursor to
Operational Airworthiness. This should be reasonably
intuitive. An aircraft must be technically airworthy before
it is possible to operate it in a safe manner.
For the operation to be safe the aircraft must be
operated within approved roles and environmental
parameters and according to approved limitations and
instructions.
Hence Operational Airworthiness (as well as technical
airworthiness) is not an open-ended concept. It can only
be assured for a pre-defined operational role in a predefined environment.
66
33
7/16/2015
Operational Airworthiness
Further this role and environment must be defined at the
time of design. The technical airworthiness must
therefore be informed by the pre-defined role and
environment and this will flow through to all subsequent
notions of airworthiness for a particular aircraft and
system.
This issue of role and environment definition is
fundamental to the concept of Airworthiness and will be
explored throughout the course.
67
Operational Airworthiness
CASE STUDY: The Vickers-Armstrong
Valiant was a British four-jet bomber,
once part of the Royal Air Force's V
bomber nuclear force in the 1950s and
1960s. The Valiant was designed for
operations as a high-level strategic
bomber during the Cold War era.
When the Soviet Union shot down a US
Lockheed U-2 spyplane in 1960 using
an early SA-2 Guideline missile, the
SAM threat caused the V-force to train
for low-level attack. By late 1964 it was
found that all variants of the Valiant
showed premature fatiguing and intercrystalline corrosion in wing spar
attachments. This resulted in the
premature retirement from service of
the Type in 1965.
RMIT University 2015
ausairpower.net
68
34
7/16/2015
69
70
35
7/16/2015
71
72
36
7/16/2015
73
74
37
7/16/2015
End of Lecture 1
38