Professional Documents
Culture Documents
printing document
X x- X H-
St'
DUPLICATE,
x- n- K X
Filtered:
PAYMENT WORKSHEET
Botch t I&U/-5
fiplt : 2020005
rtcct-;-
HG2770SCrtOi
CIRCUIT
COUNTY
<***
CLERK ID
bep.?,-r.y
Office: CIVU
DlJPLlCA'rt.
Stti.tVi
*-xw*
Beatriz Perez
d |
CfrPup
@ $2.50=
SUMMONS FEE J.
@ $10.00=
DN 0|
MEDIATION FEE
@ $60.00=
<S> $100.00=
PN
DN
:=
!:!
ii!
ATTORNEY BAR#
REFUND AMT.
TOTAL DUE
I0
1 of 1
EXHIBIT
EXHIBIT 1
1
10/13/2015 4:35 PM
pleadings or other papers as required by law. This form shall be filed by the plaintiff or petitioner for the use of the Clerk
of the Court for the purpose of reporting judicial workload data pursuant to Florida Statues section 25.075.
I.
CASE STYLE
Case No.:.
Judge:
II.
TYPE OF CASE
fl
? Condominium
fl
Professional malpractice
fl Eminent domain
? Auto negligence
fl
Malpractice - business
A Negligence - other
fl
Malpractice - medical
fl
Business governance
Business torts
Environmental/Toxic tort
Business Transaction
Construction defect
fl
fl
Mass tort
Negligent security
Constitutional challenge-statute or
ordinance
fl
A,
Other
fl
fl
Antitrust/TradB Regulation
Constitutional challenge-proposed
amendment
fl
Corporate Trusts
? Products liabilily
Discrimination-employment or other
fl
Insurance claims
fl
Intellectual property
fl
Ubei/Slander
fl
fl
Securities litigation
fl
fl
fl
fl
Trade secrets
Trust litigation
III.
IV.
J3
Monetary;
Non-monetary
Punitive
(Specify)
V.
Yes
M No
VI.
M No
?
I
"!
VII.
Yes - If "yes" list all related cases by name, case number and court:
Yes
? No
I CERTIFY that the information I have provided in this cover sheet Is accurate to the best of my knowledge
and belief.
Mariano R Gonzalez
(Type or print name)
FL Bar No.:
983063
10/29/2014
Date
Plaintiff,
vs.
Plaintiff, J.K. PROJECT GROUP, INC. ("J.K. PROJECT"), a Florida Corporation, by and
through undersigned counsel, hereby sues the Defendant, ACE AMERICAN INSURANCE
COMPANY ("ACE"), a Foreign corporation, and states as follows:
I.
This is an action for breach of contract wherein Plaintiff seeks damages in excess
I
of $15,000.00.
:]
2.
in the State of Florida and operates a gas station in Miami-Dade County, Florida.
3.
Defendant ACE is, upon information- and belief, a corporation duly authorized to
conduct business in the State of Florida, and which does, in fact, issue policies of insurance in Miami
Dade County, Florida.
4.
Defendant issued an insurance policy to Plaintiff bearing Policy No. TSP G2467 1 859
001, which insured the gas station located at 6776 SW 1 17 Avenue, Miami, FL 33183, at all relevant
times herein. Policy number TSP G24671859 001 is hereto attached as Exhibit "A."
1
5.
On or about April 27, 2010, while the subject policy was in full force and effect,
Plaintiff suffered damage lo their business as a result of a release of petroleum from an underground
storage tank which contaminated the property. Upon inspection in August 2010, Plaintiff discovered
the high levels of contamination by way of "free floating product" and notified Defendant of loss on
August 10, 2010.
6.
As such, Plaintiff filed a claim with Defendant and said claim was assigned Ace No.:
JY10J0448470.
7.
Plaintiff complied with and performed all conditions precedent under the subject
policy for the recovery of benefits and/or said conditions were waived by Defendant.
8.
However, Defendant, by word, conduct and deed, has denied coverage and has refused
9.
Defendant, therefore, has breached the terms of the subject contract of insurance by
failing to pay the benefits which became due and owing to Plaintiff as a result of the covered loss.
10.
insurance benefits dne and owing to them under the subject policy.
1 1,
Defendant's conduct has caused Plaintiff to retain the services of the undersigned
attorney to represent them in this action, and Defendant is, therefore, also liable for reasonable
attorney's fees pursuant to Fla.Stat. 627.428 for such services.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff, J.K. PROJECT GROUP, INC., a Florida corporation, demands
judgment against the Defendant, ACE AMERICAN INSURANCE COMPANY, a Foreign
corporation, for (i) damages and interest thereon, (ii) attorney's fees and costs pursuant to Fla.Stat.
627.428, and (iii) such other and farther relief as this couit deems just and proper.
Law Offices of
Gonzalez & Associates, P.A.
Attorney for Plaintiffs
Tel:
954-538-1304
Email 1: mg@gonzalezlegal.com
Email 2: jennifer@gonzalezlegal.com
:!
EXHIBIT "A
Declarations -
POLICY IDENTIFICATION
G 24 671859 001
TSP
MARKETING OFFICE:
Philadelphia
OF
POLICY IS:
: New
NAMED INSURED IS
BUSINESS OF INSURED
POLICY PERIOD
: FROM 10/01/2009
G24671859
TO
10/01/2010
IN RETURN FOR THE PAYMENT OF PREMIUM, WE AGREE WITH YOU TO PROVIDE THE INSURANCE AS STATES
IN THIS POLICY, SUBJECT TO ALL THE TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF THIS POLICY.
IMPORTANT NOTICE
!:
RETROACTIVE DATE:
RETROACTIVE DATE:
UW-5X99 (2/97)
10/01/2009
POLICY IDENTIFICATION
DECLARATIONS - UNDERGROUND STORAGE TANK LIABILITY POLICY
Page 2
CLAIMS-MADE
TSP
G24671859 001
LIMITS OF INSURANCE
$ 1,000.000
AGGREGATE LIMIT
$ 1.000.000
DEFENSE EXPENSE AMOUNT
$ 1.000.000
DEDUCTIBLES
$10,000
DEDUCTIBLE AMOUNT
$ 1,767.00
$ 17.67
;
'
$ 15.90
$ 1,800.57
LOCATION NUMBER AND ADDRESS OF INSURED SITE: As on file with the insurer
I.
4.
2.
5.
3.
6.
UW-5X99 (2/97)
COVERAGE A OF THIS POLICY PROVIDES BODILY INJURY AND PROPERTY DAMAGE LIABILITY
COVERAGE ON A CLAIMS-MADE BASIS. COVERAGE B OF THIS POLICY PROVIDES CORRECTIVE
ACTION COSTS COVERAGE ON AN INCIDENT-REPORTED BASIS.
THIS POLICY PROVIDES PAYMENTS FOR DEFENSE EXPENSE WHICH ARE LIMITED UNDER THE
PROVISIONS OF DEFENSE EXPENSE PAYMENTS (PARAGRAPH 2. OF SECTION III).
Various provisions in this policy restrict coverage. Read the entire policy carefully to determine rights, duties and
what Is and is not covered.
Throughout this policy the words "you" and "your" refer to the Named Insured shown in the Declarations, and any
other person or organization qualifying as a Named Insured under this policy. The words "we", "us" and "our"
refer to the company providing this insurance.
The word "insured" means any person or organization qualifying as such under Section II - Who Is An Insured.
The phrase "first Named Insured" means the first person or organization listed as a Named Insured in the Decla
rations.
Other words and phrases that appear in quotation marks have special meaning. Refer to Section Vi - Definitions.
SECTION I - UNDERGROUND STORAGE TANK
COVERAGE
1. Insuring Agreement
a.
Damage Liability
CG 00 42 10 01
Page 1 of 12
sured.
surance.
CG 00 42 10 01
agreement.
Page 2 of 12
e. Damage To Property
"Property damage" to:
action
costs"
or any other ex
penses:
:]
CG 00 42 10 01
g. Corrective Actions
"Corrective
Page 3 of 12
5. Supplementary Payments
2,
policy as:
CG 00 4210 01
Page 4 of 12
b. Any person
1. Limits Of Insurance
ber of:
(1) Insureds;
CG 00 4210 01
a deductible, if applicable.
d. The Defense Expense Amount applies sepa
Page 5 of 12
CG 00 4210 01
Page 6 of 12
:|
c. Method Of Sharing
b. Excess Insurance
5.
Premium Audit
6. Representations
By accepting this policy, you agree:
a. The
7. Separation Of Insureds
Named
to
each
insured
against
whom
CG 00 42 10 01
Page 7 of 12
regulations, codes or
standards.
refund.
11. Nonrenewal
CG 00 42 10 01
Page 8 of 12
15. Premiums
provisions apply:
ended; or
ended,
whichever Is applicable.
(b) Initiate, and cooperate in, the transfer of
control, to any appropriate insured, of
all:
(i) Claims; and
of
defense of such
"suit"
CG 00 4210 01
Page 9 of 12
graph b. above.
not be cancelled.
"suits"; and
CG 00 42 10 01
Page 10 of 12
lectible
after
takes effect,
the endorsement
riod.
Period Endorsement
SECTION VI - DEFINITIONS
1. "Bodily Injury" means bodily injury, sickness or
disease sustained by a person, including death re
CG 00 4210 01
Page 11 of 12
:!
in which
such
resolution
damages are
ing.
CG 00 4210 01
Page 12 of 12
Named Insured
Policy Number
Policy Period
UST
G24671859 001
10/01/2009 to 10/01/2010
10/01/2009
The "insured" and the Insurer, agree that the following storage tank(s) have been added to the policy as listed "covered
underground storage tanks" and/or "covered aboveground storage tanks":
Tank ID No.
and Address
Tank Type
Retroactive Date
(UST or AST)
10000
UST
10/01/2009
10000
UST
09/14/2009
10000
UST
09/30/2009
Florida
33183
33183
J.K. Product Group Inc.
6776 S.W. 117 Ave
Miami
Florida
33183
PF-14104 (04/03)
Page 1 of 2
Authorized Signature
PF-14104 (04/03)
Page 2 of 2
COMMERCIAL
GENERAL LIABILITY
CG 00 64 12 02
WAR
1.
2.
Warlike action by a military force, including action in hindering or defending against an actual or
expected attack, by any government, sovereign or other authority using military personnel or other
agents; or
3.
CG 00 6412 02
Page 1 of 1
POLICY NUMBER:
2301 N.W.
87 Ave,
Miami,
11621 S.W.
FL 33172
101 Ave,
Miami,
FL
33176
Information required to complete this Schedule, if not shown above, will be shown In the Declarations,
Section II -
CG 20 26 07 04
Page 1 of 1
ENDORSEMENT
Named Insured
Endorsement Number
Policy Symbol
Policy Number
Policy Period
TSP
G24671859 001
10/01/2009 to 10/01/2010
10/01/2009
The "insured" and the Insurer agree to the following Policy change(s):
If this Policy is issued to certify your compliance with Federal or State financial responsibility requirements, the
Insurer shall comply with such financial responsibility requirements. However, the "insured" agrees to
reimburse the Insurer for any payment made by the Insurer, on behalf of the "insured" which the Insurer would
not have been obligated to make under the terms of this policy but for the agreement contained in the first
sentence of this condition and/or through the Insurer's issuance of a Certificate evidencing this Policy satisfies
financial assurance requirements..
Authorized Agent
PF-18327 (05/05)
Page 1 of 1
TERRORISM
radioactive contamination; or
CG 21 71 12 02
Page 1 of 2
CG 21 71 12 02
Page 2 of 2
Named Insured
Policy Number
Policy Period
TSP
G24671859 001
10/01/2009 to 10/01/2010
10/01/2009
In consideration of the additional premium indicated above, which is included in the Premium as listed on the
Declarations, the "insured" and the Insurer, hereby agree to the following Policy change(s):
A.
With respect to any "hostile acts" or "terrorism" exclusions contained in this Policy, or attached to this Policy
by endorsement, such exclusions do not apply to a "certified act of terrorism", as defined in Paragraph C
below.
B. With respect to any one or more "certified acts of terrorism", the Insurer will not pay any amounts for which
the Insurer is not responsible under the terms of the federal Terrorism Risk Insurance Act ("TR[A"),due to
the application of any clause which results in a cap on the Insurer's liability for payments for terrorism losses.
C.
"Certified act of terrorism" means an act that is certified by the Secretary of the Treasury, in concurrence with
the Secretary of State and the Attorney General of the United States, to be an act of terrorism pursuant to
TRIA. The criteria contained TRIA for a "certified act of terrorism" includes the following:
1. The act resulted in insured losses in excess of $5 million attributable to all types of insurance subject to
TRIA; and
2. The act is a violent act or an act that is dangerous to human life, properly or infrastructure and is
committed by an Individual or Individuals as part of an effort to coerce the civilian population of the United
States or to influence the policy or affect the conduct of the United States Government by coercion.
D.
Notwithstanding any coverage that may otherwise be afforded for punitive damages under this Policy, if any,
coverage shall not be afforded for damages arising, directly or indirectly, out of a "certified act of terrorism"
that are awarded as punitive damages.
E.
The coverage afforded under this endorsement shall expire at the earlier of the following dates:
1.
F.
The premium for "certified acts of terrorism" coverage is calculated based in part on the federal participation
in payment of terrorism losses as set forth in TRIA. The federal program established by TRIA is scheduled to
terminate at the end of December 31 , 2014, unless extended by the federal government.
PF-23726 (01/08)
2008
Page 1 of 2
G. If this "policy period" extends beyond December 31, 2014, please note that the TRIA premium, above, is
premised on the parties' assumption that TRIA will later be extended through the end of the "policy period",
thereby mandating that Insurer make available coverage for "certified acts of terrorism" for the entire "policy
period". In the event that TRIA Is not extended beyond December 31, 2014, or otherwise expires at some
point during the "policy "period", the Insurer will refund the unearned portion of our TRIA premium to the
insured on a pro-rata basis. In the event that new TRIA extension or replacement legislation is enacted
requiring Ihe Insurer to offer coverage for terrorism that is materially different than the coverage
requirements included in the current version of TRIA that expires on December 31, 2014, the Insurer
reserves the right to re-price and prospectively modify terrorism coverage to conform with the statutory
requirements and risks presented by any such new legislation.
Authorized Agent
PF-23728 (01/08)
200B
Page 2 of 2
10. Cancellation
written
receive notice of
reason,
reasons:
11. Nonrenewal
(a) Nonpayment of premium;
(d) A
substantial
change
in
the
risk
CG 30 15 03 98
Page 1 of 1
IL 00 17 11 98
A. Cancellation
'i
and
c. Recommend changes.
tions:
B. Changes
This policy contains all the agreements between
you and us concerning the Insurance afforded.
The first Named Insured shown In the Declara
tions is authorized to make changes in the terms
of this policy with our consent. This policy's terms
can be amended or waived only by endorsement
issued by us and made a part of this policy.
C. Examination Of Your Books And Records
We may examine and audit your books and rec
ords as they relate to this policy at any time during
the policy period and up to three years afterward.
D. Inspections And Surveys
IL 001711 98
Page 1 of 1
IL 00 21 07 02
B. Under any
.]
;J
Medical
Payments coverage,
to
IL 00 21 07 02
Page 1 of 2
IL 00 21 07 02
Page 2 of 2
SIGNATURES
Endorsement Number
Named Insured
Policy Number
Policy Period
TSP
G24671859 001
10/01/2009 to 10/01/2010
10/01/2009
THE ONLY SIGNATURES APPLICABLE TO THIS POLICY ARE THOSE REPRESENTING THE COMPANY
NAMED ON THE FIRST PAGE OF THE DECLARATIONS.
By signing and delivering the policy to you, we state that it is a valid contract.
INDEMNITY INSURANCE COMPANY OF NORTH AMERICA
GEORGE D.
MULLIGAN, Secretary
Authorized Agent
IL P 001 01 04
provisions of your policy. You should read your policy and review your Declarations page for
complete information on the coverages you are provided.
This Notice provides information concerning possible impact on your insurance coverage due to
directives issued by OFAC. Please read this Notice carefully.
The Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) administers and enforces sanctions policy, based on
Presidential declarations of "national emergency". OFAC has identified and listed numerous:
Foreign agents;
Front organizations;
Terrorists;
Terrorist organizations; and
Narcotics traffickers;
as "Specially Designated Nationals and Blocked Persons". This list can be located on the United
States Treasury's web site - http//www.treas,gov/ofac.
In accordance with OFAC regulations, if it is determined that you or any other insured, or any
person or entity claiming the benefits of this insurance has violated U.S. sanctions law or is a
Specially Designated National and Blocked Person, as identified by OFAC, this insurance will be
considered a blocked or frozen contract and all provisions of this insurance are immediately subjecl
to OFAC. When an insurance poficy is considered to be such a blocked or frozen contract, no
payments nor premium refunds may be made without authorization from OFAC. Other limitations
on the premiums and payments also apply.
IL P 001 01 04
>
ALL-20887 (10/06)
Endorsement Number
Policy Symbol
Policy Number
Policy Period
TSP
G24671859 001
10/01/2009 to 10/01/2010
10/01/2009
This insurance does not apply to the extent that trade or economic sanctions or other laws or regulations prohibit
us from providing insurance, including, but not limited to, the payment of claims. /MI other terms and conditions of
policy remain unchanged.
Authorized Agent
Page 1 of 1
Endorsement Number
Policy Symbol
Policy Number
Policy Period
TSP
G24671859 001
10/01/2009 to 10/01/2010
10/01/2009
In accordance with the federal Terrorism Risk Insurance Act, we are required to provide you with a notice
disclosing the portion of your premium, if any, attributable to coverage for terrorist acts certified under the
Terrorism Risk Insurance Act.
The federal share equals 85% of that portion of the amount of such insured losses that
certified under the Terrorism Risk Insurance Act exceed $100 billion in a Program Year (January 1 through
December 31), the Treasury shall not make any payment for any portion of the amount of such losses that
exceeds $100 billion.
Cap On Insurer Participation In Payment Of Terrorism Losses
:!!
if aggregate insured losses attributable to terrorist acts certified under the Terrorism Risk Insurance Act exceed
$100 billion in a Program Year (January 1 through December 31) and we have met our insurer deductible under
the Terrorism Risk Insurance Act, we shall not be liable for the payment of any portion of the amount of such
losses that exceeds $100 billion, and in such case insured Tosses up to that amount are subject to pro rata
allocation in accordance with procedures established by the Secretary of the Treasury.
Authorized Agent
includes copyrighted material of Insurance Services office, inc., with its permission
TRIA11b (1/08)
hllps://www2.miami-dndeclerk.com/ocs/Viewer.aspx?QS=7nu9WLj
Filing A 2 1 X4G376 Olcclrmticitlly Filed 1 2/22/20 14 O&J&JO AM
Plaintiff,
vs.
Defendant.
For its Answer and Affirmative Defenses to the Plaintiffs Complaint, (he Defendant,
ACE American Insurance Company ("ACE"), by and through its undersigned counsel, stales
as
follows:
Paragraph UL' of the Complaint does not state an allegation against ACL' for
which a response is required. To the extent a response js required, ACE denies the truth of tire
allegations as staled.
2.
With respect to (lie allegations in Paragraph "2" of the Complaint, ACE denies
knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of lite assertions staled
therein.
3.
With respect lo the allegations in Paragraph u3" of the Complaint, ACE admits
only that it is authorized to do business in the State of Florida and that it has issued policies of
insurance in Miami-Dade County, Florida.
i of 5
10/13/2015 4:41 PM
printing document
4.
With respect to the allegations in Paragraph "4" ol" the Complaint, ACH admits
only that it issued to J.K. Project Group, Inc. an Underground Storage Tanks Liability Policy,
policy number TSP G2467 1 859 00 1 , on a claims-made and reported basis for the period October
I, 2009 to October 1, 2010 (the "Policy"), the terms and conditions which speak for themselves.
5.
knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the assertions stated
therein, other than that J.K. Project maintains that it discovered "free floating product" while the
Policy was in effect and that J.K. Project gave notice to ACL of this purported discovery on
August 10, 2010.
6.
With respect to the allegations in Paragraph "6" of the Complaint, ACL admits
only that it received notice from J.K. Project of a purported "underground storage lank incident"
while the Policy was in effect and lhat ACH assigned file number JY10J0448470 to this
purported incident, and denies each and every allegation contained in Paragraph "6."
7.
ACli denies the truth of each and every allegation contained in Paragraph "7" of
the Complaint
8.
Willi respect to the allegations in Paragraph "8" of the Complaint, ACL admits
only that it has disclaimed coverage under the Policy lor the costs claimed by J.K, Project for the
purported "underground storage tank incident" reported to ACL on August 10, 2010. By way of
further response, ACK denies that it has any coverage obligations with respect to such costs as
J.K. Project has failed to evidence any "underground storage tank incident" for which coverage
is afforded under the Policy.
9.
ACli denies the truth of each and every allegation contained in Paragraph "9" of
the Complain!.
2 of 5
10/13/2015 4:41PM
printing document
10.
ACE denies the truth of each and every alienation contained in Paragraph "10" of
the Complaint.
II.
ACE denies the truth of each and every allegation contained in Paragraph "1 1" of
the Complaint.
WHEREFORE, the Defendant, ACE American Insurance Company, demands that a
judgment be entered in its favor, that il he awarded its costs expended herein, and that it he
awarded any such further relief in law or in equity to which it is appropriately entitled.
FIRST AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE
The Complaint fails to stale a claim upon which relief may he granted.
SECOND AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE
Coverage is unavailable for any "corrective action costs" associated with the "free
floating product" described in the Complaint as plaintiff has failed to demonstrate that the "free
floating product" resulted from a "storage tank incident" that commenced on or after the Policy's
October 1 , 2009 retroactive date.
THIRD AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE
Coverage is unavailable Ibr any "corrective action costs" associated with the "free
floating product'' described in the Complaint as plaintiff on the basis of the doctrines of known
loss and loss in progress.
FOURTH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE
Coverage is unavailable, for any "corrective notion costs" associated with the "lice
floating product" described in the Complaint to the extent thai the Policy's exclusion tilled
Failure To Comply With Environmental Laws applies.
3 of 5
10/13/2015 4:41PM
printing document
Coverage is unavailable for any "corrective action costs'' associated with the "free
flouting product" described in the Complaint to the extent that the Policy's exclusion tilled
Corrective Actions applies.
To ihc extent that ACE has any obligation to indemnify plaintiff for "corrective action
costs" associated with the "free floating product" described in the Complaint, which is denied,
such obligation is limited only to "corrective action costs" associated with an "storage tank
incident" (hot happened on or after October 1 , 2009, and ACE lias no indemnity obligations with
respect to any "free floating product" thai was released or discharged into the ground prior to this
dale.
SEVENTH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE
The liability of ACE under the Policy, if any, is subject to the applicable limits of liability
and all applicable terms, provisions, conditions and exclusions contained therein,
EIGHTH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE
Coverage is unavailable under the Policy with respect to any costs associated with the
"free floating product" described in the Complaint to the extent (hat ACE was prejudiced as a
result of plaintiffs failure to give timely notice of a "storage lank incident."
ACE fully reserves its lights to assert additional defenses upon further investigation and
discovery, and upon further delineation of plaintiffs specific claims against ACE.
' !
4 of 5
10/13/2015 4:41 PM
printing document
Respectfully submitted,
TRAUB LlEBEUMAN STRAUS & SHREWSBERRY LLP
/')
(if
kf
'\-r:
i (
5 of 5
10/13/2015 4:41 PM
printing document
Plaintiff,
vs.
Defendant.
defense raised by Defendant in its Answer to Plaintiff's Complaint, and demand strict proof thereof.
In addition, Plaintiff states that by its actions Defendant waived Plaintiffs duly to comply
with certain conditions precedent and post -loss conditions of the subject policy of insurance and is
.v
thus estopped from asserting same as a defense, including, hut not limited to, any allegation thaL a
proof of loss wits not provided by Plaintiff or that Plaintiff failed to mitigate damages.
Plaintiff further states thai any allegation concerning the late reporting of the subject claim.
the failure (o furnish proper notice or (he failure to provide a proof of loss is hereby denied as well
since Defendant would not have been prejudiced by such action or lack of action.
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
1 HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing document was sent via
U*.S. Mail on this 4"' day of February, 2015 to: Lauren Curtis. Esq. at Trnub Lieberman Straus &
Shrewsbury LLP
Primary; k'nnisClrnnhliebenrimrcnm
Secondary; !i viHiJiiliaji
1 of 2
10/13/2015 4:42 PM
https://\vww2.miami-dadeclerk.coiii/ocs/Vic\vei,.aspx7QS=7mi9WL...
Law Offices of
Email I: mg@gonzalczIegal.com
Email 2: jcnnitcr@gonzalczlegaI.com
2 of 2
10/13/2015 4:42 PM
printing document
Defendant.
Plaintiff, J.K. PROJECT GROUP, INC.,, by and through undersigned counsel, and pursuant
to Hlii. R. Civ. P, LI 40, hereby file their Motion to Strike Defendant's Seventh Affirmative Defense
in Defendant's Answer and Affirmative Defenses, and in support thereof state as follows:
On December 22, 2014, Defendant filed its Answer and Affirmative Defenses to
Plaintiffs Complaint. Plaintiff is now seeking lo strike Defendant's Seventh Affirmative Defenses.
2,
ACE under the policy, if any, is subject to the applicable limits of liability and all applicable terms.
provisions, conditions and exclusions contained therein. However, Defendant does not specifically
slate (lie policy language, exclusion, condition or limitation that relieves it front liability under lite
policy for Plaintiffs' loss.
3.
An affirmative defense is a defense which admits the cause of action, but avoids
Page - 1 -
1 of 2
10/13/2015 4:48 PM
printing document
liability, in whole or in part, by alleging tin excuse, justification, or other matter negating or limiting
liability. AY. Paul Manny Ins. Co. v. Couchur, 837 So. 2d 483 (F)a. 5 1,1 DCA 2002). Furthermore,
the case law clearly holds that if any insurer is relying on an exclusion in the policy, said exclusion
Honorable Court enter an Order striking Defendant's Seventh Affirmative Defenses and any and all
further relief the Court deems just and proper,
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICK
I HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing document was sent
via U.S. Mail on this 4'" dav of February. 2015 to: Lauren Curtis, Esq. at Traub Lieberinan Straus
& Shrcwsbcrry LLP
Pi'i maty: Icurds ('MrflnhlitHnuman.com
Secondary: l^tklalMn^tnuddiohennM^mi
Law Offices of
:=
Tel:
954-538-1304
Email 1: mg@gonzulczlegal.com
Email 2; jennlfer@gonzalczlegal.com
By: /s/ Mariano R, Gonzalez.
Mariano R. Gonzalez, Esq.
Florida Bar No.: 983063
Page -2-
2 of 2
10/13/2015 4:48 PM
hltps:/Av\v\v2.miami-dadeclerk.com/ocs/Vie\ver.aspx?QS-7nu9WL...
Plaintiff,
vs.
a Foreign Corporation.
Defendant.
/
Civil Procedure, requests the Defendant, ACE AMERICAN INSURANCE COMPANY to produce
the following:
All
notes,
correspondence,
documentation
or
other
writings
evidencing
communication between Plaintiff and Defendant concerning the claim at. issue.
3.
AH
notes,
correspondence,
documentation
or
oilier
writings
evidencing
communication between Defendant and any agents or other tliird parlies concerning the
claim at issue.
I
;
I
1 of 3
10/13/2015 4:46 PM
printing document
I.
All notations regarding notice of the incident that is the subject of this legal action,
including assignment of claim, computer print-oitl of notice, first notice of loss report, or report from
agent of loss concerning the claim at issue.
5.
All telephone messages to or from you, or any of your agents on your behalf, regarding
All interoffice memoranda and claim notes regarding receipt of notice of claims and
telephone conversations with anyone about the receipt of notice of claims concerning Plaintiff.
7.
Any and all documents containing any information on what was said by the Plaintiff
at any time during the handling of any claim for the incident (hat is the subject of this legal action,
including adjuster notes, claim reports, interoffice memoranda, tape recordings of any statements
made by the Plaintiff, and any transcript or written statement from the Plaintiff.
8.
Copies of each and every paper submitted by the Plaintiff in support of any claimed
9.
Plaintiff or any third party concerning the claim which is the subject of this action.
10.
A copy of your underwriting manual and manual for your insurance agents and
adjusters regarding the policies and procedures by which your company determines exclusions of
coverage for the .same type of policy, property* and claimed losses, as claimed by the Plaintiff in this
legal action.
II.
12.
All photographs in Defendant's possession, custody, or control taken at any time prior
2 of 3
10/13/2015 4:46 PM
printing document
agents or assigns for the loss(es) being claimed under the subject insurance policy which is the
subject of this complaint.
Id,
Any and all applications for insurance submitted by Plaintiff to Defendant for any
performed by Defendant for purposes of issuing the initial insurance policy to Plaintiff.
Id.
I HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing document was sent
via U.S. Mail on this 4lh day of February. 2015 to: Lauren Curtis, Esq. at Trail b Llcbcnnan Stratus
& Shrewsbury LLP
Primary:
954-538- 1 304
Email I: mg@gonzulez1egal.cont
Email 2: jennifer@grm7a1ezlegal.com
By: /s/ Mariano R. Gonzalez
Mariano R. Gonzalez, Esq.
Florida Bar No.: 983063
3 of 3
10/13/2015 4:46 PM
printing document
I HEREBY CERTIFY thai a true and correct copy of the foregoing document was sent
via U.S. Mail on this 4th day of February. 20(5 to; Lauren Curtis, Esq. at Truub Liebemum Straus
& Shrewsberry LLP
Primary: tcwlLfti:iraLitdiclwiiinuLeurri
Secondary:
Law Offices of
Gonzalez & Associates, P. A.
Attorney for Plaintiffs
954-538-1304
Email I: mg@gonzalezlegal.coni
Email 2: jennifer@gonzalezlegal.com
By; hf Mariano R. Gonzalez
Mariano R. Gonzalez, Esq.
I of 5
10/13/2015 4:50 PM
printing document
Please slate the full name, current huiuc street address, and telephone number of (lie
I.
person or persons answering, or assisting in the answering, of these Interrogatories.
2.
List the names, addresses, and phone numbers of all persons believed or known by
you, your agents or attorneys Lo have any knowledge concerning the investigation of (heclaim which
is the subject of this litigation or which has any knowledge concerning any of your defenses lo the
complaint filed in this action. In addition, please state the subject matter of each person's knowledge
2 of 5
10/13/2015 4:50 PM
printing document
Please slate the name and address of the current custodian of any and all documents
3.
produced pursuant to Plaintiffs First Request for Production.
Have you obtained any of the following, and if so, identify its custodian and from
4.
whom any of the following was obtained: statements from any party to or witnesses) to litis
litigation; statements from any person who may know about any issues in this litigation.
;!
3 of 5
10/13/2015 4:50 PM
https://w\vw2.miaim-dadederk.com/ocs/Vie\ver.aspx?QS=7n\i9WL...
printing document
Are you claiming (hat an exclusion contained in the .subject policy applies' to (lie
5.
subject claim? If so, please provide- all underlying facts which support such claimed exclusion,
including all relevant dates; explain how you became aware or obtained such facts; the name,
address, and telephone number of all persons who have knowledge of such facts; the name of the
person with the most knowledge concerning such facts; and identify all documents which support
such facts (list the date, author, recipient and subject matter of each such document).
6.
interrogatory which relies on information contained in any privileged document, pleuse provide, a
privilege log identifying such documents. Please state the title, subject matter, persons involved,
and/or any other means of identifying said documents, in addition to die privilege claimed, for every
document for which you are claiming a privilege.
4 of 5
10/13/2015 4:50 PM
printing document
Affiant
:
STATE OF
)SS
COUNTY OF
who upon being first duly sworn, says that the foregoing answers to interrogatories are true and
correct to the best of his/her knowledge and belief.
clay of
, 2015.
Notary Public
My Commission Expires:
Took Oath, or
Did Not Take Oath.
Personally known to me, or
Produced Identification
Type of Identification
5 of 5
10/13/2015 4:50 PM
printing document
IN Tl IH CIRCUIT COURT OF TI IE
NOTICE OF HEARING
Plaintiff,
vs.
Defendant.
TO:
Secondary: Bguldaljan^frauldiebermaji.coni
YOU WILL PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that the undersigned will call up for hearing before
the Honorable Peter R. Lopez Circuit Court Judge, in his chambers, at the Miami-Dade County
Courthouse, 73 West Flagler Street, Room DCC (201, Miami, Florida 33130, on Thursday,
March 19, 2015, at 9:00 A.M., or as soon thereafter as same may be heard:
DEFENSE
I HEREBY CERTIFY (hat a true and correct copy of the foregoing was senl via email on
this 5"' day of February, '2015, to the above-named addressee.
Law Offices of
Gonzalez & Associates, P,A.
Attorney for Plaintiffs
954=538-1304
Email I: mg@gonzaIczleg5d.com
Email 2: jennifer@gonzalezleg5il.com
1 of 1
10/13/2015 4:51 PM
a Florida Corporation.
NOTICE OF CANCELLATION OF
Plaintiff,
HEARING
vs.
a Foreign Corporation.
Defendant.
TO:
> -nr'in'
'i 1 "
ii*~i
rr
Secondary: BguldaIian@traul)liel)crniaii.coni
YOU WILL PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that the undersigned hereby CANCELS the hearing
before the Honorable Peter R. Lopez Circuit Court Judge, in his chambers, at the Miami-Dade
Count)' Courthouse, 73 West Flagler Street. Room DCC 1201, Miami, Florida 33130, on
Thursday, March 19, 20J 5, at 9:00 A.M.. or as soon thereafter as same may be heard:
PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO STRIKE DEFENDANT'S SEVENTH AFFIRMATIVE
DEFENSE
1 HEREBY CERTIFY thai a true and correct copy of the foregoing was sent via email on
954-538-1304
Email I: mg@gonzalczlcgal.com
Email 2: jennifei@goiizalezlcgal.com
Plaintiff,
vs.
MOTION TO WITHDRAW
Counsel for Plaintiff, LAW OFFICES OF GONZALEZ & ASSOCIATES, P. A., hereby
files this Motion to Withdraw as counsel of record for J.K. PROJECT GROUP, INC., and as
2.
3.
GROUP. INC. that they seek the advice and representation of other counsel.
WI 1EREFORE, counsel for Plaintiff. LAW OFFICES OF GONZALEZ & ASSOCIATES,
P.A., respectfully requests this Court enter an Order granting ihis Motion to Withdraw as attorney
for Plaintiff. J.K. PROJECT GROUP, INC.
']
1
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing document was sent via
U.S. Mail and email on this 16"' day of June, 20 (5 to: Lauren Curtis, Esq, aiTraub Liebermaii Straus
& Shrewsbeny LLP; Thomas Pequeno at 0776 SW 1 17"' Ave, Miami, HI.; Kelly Kubtofc at Merlin
Law Group, P.A.
Primary: lcuilis@trnuhlie.hcrnian.com
Secondary: BguldaUan@traubIlebcrman.com
Primal)'; ngenriquez@aol.com
Primary: l4>radle.y@mei1inla\vgroiin.coni
Law Offices of
Email 1; mg@gonzalezlegal.com
Email 2: jennifer@gonzale7.legnl.com
By: A7 Mariano R. Gonzalez
a llorida Corjxiration.
NOTICE OF HEARING
Plaintiff,
vs.
Defendant.
TO:
Thomas Petjueno
Primary: lcurtis@lrauhlicbDrman.com
Primary: Htcnr8tmez@aoLcom
Secondary: ltculdalioTi@lraubHehermnn.com
Kelly Kubidk
1
Primary: FhrariIcv@merlinIawcroun.com
YOU WII .1 . PI .hasp: TA Kp: NOTICE that (ho undersigned will call up for hearing before the
Honorable Pclcr R. Lopez Circuit C?ouri Judge, in his chambers, ai the Miami-Dade County
Coutlliou.se, 73 West Plagler Street, Room IX:C 1201. Miami. Morida 33 1 30. on Tuesday, June 30,
2015, sit 9:00 A.M., or as soon thereafter as same may be heard:
PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO WITHDRAW
I iikrkhy CERTIFY i hat a true and corned copy of the foregoing was .sent via email on this 16'"
.day of June, 2015. to (lie above-named addressee.
Law Offices of
Gonzalez & Associates, P.A.
Attorney for Plaintiffs
36(H) Red Road, Suite (>03
Miramar, Florida 33025
Tel:
954-538-1304
Email I: mg@gon/.alezlegstJ.eoni
I {mail 2: jennifer@goiizalezlcgal.eom
Plaintiff.
vs.
Defendant.
TO;
Thomas Pequeno
6776 SW 117"' Ave
Miami, Fl.
Primary: Hecnrlnucz@aol.coiu
Primary: lairtis@trtuihlicbcrmaii.cQm
,eani
Secondary: Bgnldnlinn@traubl{eberman
Kelly Kubiok
Merlin I^aw Group, P,A.
Primary: Fbradlcv@mcilinhi\veroun.com
YOU WILL PLEASE TAKE NOTICE Ihut live undersigned hereby CANCELS I he bearing before the
Honorable Peter R. Lopez Circuit Court Judge, in bis chambers, at the Miami-Dade County
Courthouse, 73 West Flagler Street, Room DCC 1201. Miami, Florida 33130. on Tuesday, June 30,
2015, at 9:00 A,M., or as soon (hereafter as same may be hoard:
PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO WITHDRAW
I HEREBY CERTIFY thai a true and correct copy of lite foregoing was seal via email on this iff"
day of June, 2015, to (he above-named addressee.
Law Offices of
Con/ale/. & Associates, P.A,
I i m JUD1CIALCIRCU IT IN AND
FOR MIAMI-DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA
a Florida Corporation.
Plaintiff,
vs.
J
NOTICE AND CLAIM OF ATTORNEY'S CHARGING LIEN
Florida Bar No. 983063
ALL PARTIES TO THIS CAUSE AND ALL OTHERS WHOM IT MAY CONCERN
ARE HEREBY CALLED UPON TO TAKE NOTICE THAT:
I.
compensation due to the Law Offices of Gonzalez & Associates, P. A., pursuant to the contract with
Plaintiff, for legal services rendered in the above-styled cause. The Lien is claimed against any
monies or other properties received by Plaintiff in the above-styled cause as security for payment of
the fees and disbursements incurred on the Plaintiffs behalf.
2.
certificate; of service
I HEREBY CERTIFY thai a true and correct copy of the foregoing document was sent
via U.S. Mail and email on this 31*' day of July, 20 1 5 lot Lauren Curtis, Esq. ai Traub
Liebernmn Straus & Shnewsbeiry LIT; Thomas Pequeno at 6776 SW 1 17th Ave, Miami, Fl.;
Kelly Kuhiak ai Merlin Law Group, P.A.
Primary; lcartls@lraublicberinaii.com
Secondary: Bguldalian@traubllcbcrman.com
Primary: I lgcnriqtroz@aol.com
Primary: Ifrradleytfomerlinlawgroup.coro
Law Offices of
Gonzalez & Associates, P.A.
A Florida Corporation,
Plaintiffs,
vs.
Defendant.
as to Case No.:
Gonzalez, Esquire, Gonzalez. & Associates, P. A., .1600 Red Road, Suite 603, Miramar,
FL
33025,
E-mail:
E-mail: kkubiak@merlinlawmoup.com
fuarcia@meriin!awflTPui).com
fbra (lley@merlintowuroup.com
dalvarez@meriinIawuroup.com
!
Tl 1425li7.IXK;l
JenniferffigpnzalezlegaLcom,
for
I he
Plaintiff requests all further Pleadings, Orders, and Notices as lo the abovercfcrcnccd cause of action should be directed to substitute counsel, Kelly L. Kubiak, Esq.
and Francisco 0. Garcia, Esq,, of Merlin Law Group, PA, as provided herein.
Tampa, FL 33602
Facsimile:^ 1 3) 229-3692
Email: kkubiak@tnerHnlawafoup.coin
fGaicia@merliiilawuronp.com
Email: nig@tionzalezleual.com
dalvarcz@mcrliiilawttroup.coni
,rU'l25l>7 IX')C,t
.lcnnifcr@uonzalczlcKal.com
avii, DIVISION
,i,K- PROJECT GROUP. INC..
A Florida Corporation.
PlaiudlTs.
vs.
i
i
:nkl
through
(lit.-
undersigned
Counsel,
hereby
01c
this
Joint
Stipulation
tor
C'ioi'i/nkv. Ixjuiiv. (ion/ale/ & Associates. P.A., .1600 Red Road. Suite 60.1. Miraninr.
1
II.
5.1025.
I (-mail:
nm ii-aon/afcgloual.com:
lhradie\fr/?me.rlinlaw inoup.com
didvmy/VrOierlinlaWK^
I MW7M49II: K ,1
Jennifer rfiion/ak'/lceiri.eom.
for
the
g-15 iv ? 3 z
i
5
X
gis.li-a J SI ?
is. i5 5-r I" !. = ?"-
; ;= 2 r* * ^ i
fe p S.S-2S, v. = - s- V-- r
i?fe=r^SSil^ - 3\
mm
5
2
InII =
= f -' V?\
=* :-.
5.'..
5=
P.
r.
'
5s
f:
rf
r-
r:
-2
-r*
=L
S
5
9;
r
."V
ilf 1 a ac.
&1
yz
57 -'
mg*ti ;i/
g s
sT
5 '-
2 =.
- *
i r a
>
m
&
>
>
S
"5
9*
5*
I?
> s-.
&
>
=r
rz
Si
-?
J
K
f-
P-
7"'
,s.
"
r.
f
s
>
pc
t
-.!S
- N
i s bJ. ir f
g II
2.
=;
7;
cr
t
s*
= *
5
=
r.
vs,
THIS CAUSE came on for consideration on the Joint Stipulation for Substitution
of Counsel for the Plaintiff, and the CouiT being fully advised in (he premises, it. is:
ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that said Stipulation he and the same is hereby
granted thai Kelly L. Kubiak, Esquire and Francisco Garcia, Inquire of Merlin Law
Group, PA shall henceforth be substituted as counsel on behalf otThe Plaintiff in place of
Mariano R, Gonzalez, Esquire, Gonzalez & Associates, P. A and said firm shall be
09/18/15.
'MiO- /
t
/
6
PETER R. LOPEZ
I I UfOso IKK'J
JUDGMENT
The parties served with this Order are indicated in the accompanying 11th Circuit
email confirmation which includes all emails provided by the submitter. The
movant shall IMMEDIATELY serve a true and correct copy of this Order, by mail,
facsimile, email or hand-delivery, to all parties/counsel of record for whom
service is not indicated by the accompanying 11th Circuit confirmation, and file
rM-NtfM.IKX-:!
CIVIL DIVISION
J.K. PROJECT GROUP, INC.,
A Florida Corporation,
Plaintiff,
v.
NOW,
the
Plaintiff,
J.K.
PROJECT
GROUP,
INC.,
Florida
Corporation ("Plaintiff'), by and through its undersigned counsel, and pursuant to Ida. R.
Civ. P. 1.190, hereby files tins, its Motion for Leave to File Amended Complaint, and in
On October 29, 2014, Plaintiff filed a Complaint against its insurer, ACE
inspected and discovered a discharge that was confirmed on or about December 12, 20 1 0.
3.
Plaintiff now seeks leave of this Honorable Court to add the second
i
discharge claim to the Complaint as a separate count and a declaratory action regarding
TihWU.lXX;!-
1
;
coverage for the April of 2010 loss and February II, 2014 loss.
Plaintiffs proposed
Defendant has agreed to Plaintiffs Motion for Leave to OJc its Amended
Complaint.
6.
would be proper for this Honorable Court to grant Plaintiffs' Motion for Leave to file its
Amended Complaint. Dimick v. liay, 774 So. 2d 830, 833 (Fla. 4lh DCA 2000) ("It is
axiomatic that under Florida law, the trial court must liberally allow amendments to a
complaint unless the defendant would be 'prejudiced1 thereby."); srn also, fCAC USA,
INC. v. Ktnra, 805 So. 2d 1, 10 (Fla. 2d DCA 2001) ("Public policy favors the liberal
b.
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing has been
furnished via email generated by the Florida Court's K-Filing Portal Service to: Lauren S.
Curtis, Esq. and Bradley T. Guldalian, Esq. of Trttuh Libenlian Straus & Shrewsberry
TllMffW-IXX ;l
LLP, I'irsl Central Tower, 300 Central Avenue, Suite IOOO, St. Petersburg, PL 33701
T1 UW7.M JXX';I
11 1 KW7.U 1 X K.';l 1 J J 1
X.\ I \
Plaintiff;
14-027709 CA
Vv
Defendant.
AMENDED COMPLAINT
Plaintiff, J,K. PROJECT GROUP, INC. ("Plaintiff*), by and through (he undersigned
counsel, hereby sues Defendant, ACR AMERICAN INSURANCE COMPANY (herein after
referred to as"ACK"), and as grounds therefore would state as follows;
GENERAL ALLEGATIONS
1.
This is an action for damages in excess of fifteen thousand (S 15,000.00) dollars exclusive
of interest and costs
2.
At all limes material hereto Plaintiff was and is the owner of a storage tank and real
property located at 6776 SW 1 1 7'1' Ave, Miami, in Dade County, Florida ("properly.'").
3.
Plaintiff purchased a policy of insurance from ACB, policy number G24671859 002,
policy period from October I, 2009 through October I, 2010. A true and accurate copy of the
policy is attached hereto as Exhibit "A".
EXHIBIT "A"
Tiuwfii ixxru
rni^Thi.ixx'iin'nwtii.otKi-.ijpniiwTfit.ixx^u
d.
Plaintiff has paid all premiums on said policy, and the policy was in lull force and effect
at all relevant times herein,
5.
On or about April of 2010, a fuel truck discharged fuel onlo Plaintiffs subject property
so that the Department of Environmental Resources Management ("DERM") issued a Notice (hat
corrective actions must take place,
6.
The damage to the Plaintiff s property was due to a release and therefore a covered peril
under the policy.
7.
Prior to the loss, DERM was monitoring the property. There were no corrective actions
.1
Plaintiff has made application for insurance benefits under the policy. Plaintiff submitted
to ACE the requested documentation in its possession.
In
December of 2010,
Resources Management
TIKWfU IXSC.I
It is
10.
The damage to the Plaintiff's properly was due to a release and therefore a covered peril
under the policy.
11.
Plaintiff purchased a policy of insurance from ACE. policy number G24671859 002,
policy period from October I, 2010 through October 1, 201 1.
Plaintiff
has
made
application
for
insurance
benefits
under
the
policy,
but
Defendant/Insurer, ACE has failed and refused to pay for any damages.
Plaintiff re-alleges all allegations contained in paragraphs one through seven and further
Sometime in April of 2010, a fuel truck owned by Direct Fuel Transport, Inc. discharged
fuel onto Plaintiffs subject property so that Ihe Department of Environmental Resources
Management ("DERM") issued a Notice that corrective actions must take place.
15.
On or about Fcbmary 26, 2009, the prior owner provided a lank and line lest. The (esl
results were good.
Additionally, on June 27, 2009, J.co I). Adancs, President of Blue Stone
The only
requirement was monitoring the site. DERM did not require the soils to be remediated.
Trtftrtrii IX'iCl
16".
Plaintiff has complied with all conditions precedent to bringing all causes of action
alleged in this complaint or the Defendant, ACE, has waived or is estopped from asserting the
same.
18.
Defendant, ACE, has breached its insurance contract by failing to pay all of the
Plaintiff has suffered damages as a result of not having benefits paid pursuant lo the
insurance policy.
22.
All conditions precedent to obtaining payment of said benefits under the policy from
Plaintiff was forced to retain legal counsel to represent their interests in this cause and is
obligated to pay a reasonable fee for services rendered pursuant to Florida Statute v5627.d28,
ixx\i
O'llMTM 1XX.'.|;;VI
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff, J.K. PROJECT GROUP, INC., demands judgment against the
Defendant, ACE AMERICAN INSURANCE COMPANY, for an amount exceeding FifteenThousand Dollars ($15,000.00), exclusive of costs, interest, pre-judgment interest, attorney's
fees and costs and all other relief deemed just and appropriate by this Court and Plaintiff
respectfully requests a jury trial.
Count II Breach of Contract
(Breach of contract For December 2010 discharge)
24.
Plaintiff re-alleges all allegations contained in paragraphs one, two, seven through twelve
and further alleges the following:
25.
On or about December 12, 2010, DERM performed an inspection which revealed at least
;l
27.
Plaintiff has complied with all conditions precedent to bringing all causes of action
alleged in this complaint or the Defendant, ACE, has waived or is estopped from asserting the
same.
29.
Defendant, ACE, has breached the policy by improperly denying the claim.
rii(W6i ixte.i
30.
Defendant* ACE, has breached its insurance contract by failing to pay all of the
aforementioned benefits due and owing under the policy.
31.
Plaintiff lias suffered damages as a result of not having benefits paid pursuant to the
insurance policy.
32.
Plaintiff was forced to retain legal counsel to represent their interests in this cause and is
obligated to pay a reasonable fee for services rendered pursuant (o Florida Statute 627,428.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff; J.K. PROJECT GROUP, INC., demands judgment against the
Defendant, ACE AMERICAN INSURANCE COMPANY, for an amount exceeding FifteenThousand Dollars (515,000.00), exclusive of costs, interest, pre-judgment interest, attorney's
fees and costs and all other relief deemed just and appropriate by this Court and Plaintiff
33,
Plaintiff re-alleges all allegations contained in paragraphs one through thirty two ant!
further alleges the following:
34.
Plaintiff files this declaratory action concerning its rights under Storage Tank Third Party
Liability Correction Action and Cleanup Costs Policy Number policy number G24G7 1859 002,
policy period from October 1, 2013 through October I, 2014. A true and accurate copy of the
policy is attached hereto as Exhibit "C'\
Tltrty?6l IX1CI
35.
On or about February 1 I, 2014, Cos la Oil Company's fuel truck discharged fuel onto
Plaintiffs subject property so lhat the Department of Environmental Resources Management
("DKRM") issued a Notice that corrective actions must take place.
DERM has acknowledged a discharge and requires thai the property be remediated.
37.
Defendant, ACE, has accepted coverage for this loss, but refuses to withdraw lite
wrongful denials for the April of 2010 loss and the December 12, 2010 loss.
i!
39.
The damages caused by the April of 2010 loss and the February II, 2014 loss exceed the
coverage available for the February 11, 2014 loss.
40.
in order lo repair the property in the area of the April of 20 1 0 loss and the February 1 1 ,
2014 loss, the denial of coverage for the April of 2010 loss must be determined. If the denial of
the April of 201 10 loss was wrongful, then this coverage should be afforded to Plaintiff along
with the coverage for the February 1 1 , 20 14 loss. Both coverages are necessary to repair the area
TMfiWil IX KJ.l
41.
Plaintiff has complied with all conditions precedent to bringing all causes of action
alleged in this complaint or the Defendant, ACE, has waived or is estopped from asserting the
same.
40.
An actual controversy exists between the parties which has let! the parties uncertain with
respect to their legal rights and responsibilities, particularly related to Plaintiff's rights/coverages
obligated to pay a reasonable fee for services rendered pursuant to Florida Statute 627.428.
42.
There exists a bona fide, actual, present and practicable need for a declaration of each
parties' rights and obligations under the Policies marked as Exhibit A and B.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff, J.K. PROJECT GROUP, INC., requests that this Court enter
a)
COMPANY, wrongfully denied coverage for the April of 2010 loss, then
the coverage available for the April of 2010 loss will apply, as well as the
coverage available for the February 1 1, 2014 loss.
b)
That Plaintiff be awarded attorney fees and costs pursuant to Fla. Stat.
627.428.
c)
And any further relief that the Court deems just and proper.
Tl WOM OiiC.1
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I HEREBY CERTIFY lhat a line and correct copy of the foregoing has been furnished
via email generated by the Florida Court's E-Filing Portal Service to: Lauren S. Curtis. Esq. and
Bradley 'J'. Guldalian, Esq. of Traub Libennan Straus <& Shrewsberiy LLP, First Central Towei;
360 Central Avenue,
Suite
1000,
St.
Petersburg, FL 33701
tlcurtis@traubliebenuan.eom:
108952
:!
dalvarez@ineiTmlawaroup.com
rnwjhi ixxm