Professional Documents
Culture Documents
recovery. The problem was not just a deteriorating trade policy environment, but
some other serious issues. GATT negotiations did not include services and
agricultural trade in its gamut. As the world trade grew in size, the share of
services trade along with that of merchandise started to increase leading to the
insufficiency of the GATT principles to cover the expanding aspects of ever
evolving global trade. As a result, these loopholes were taken as advantage by
many trading countries, resulting in a lopsided development of world trade.
These and other factors convinced GATT members that a new effort to reinforce
and extend the multilateral system should be attempted. That effort resulted in
the Uruguay Round, the Marrakesh Declaration, and the creation of the WTO.
PRINCIPLES OF WTO
The agreements of WTO cover everything from trade in goods, services and
agricultural products, these agreements are quite complex to understand,
however all these agreements are based on some simple principles;
Non-Discrimination
This is a very simple principle which advocates that every member
country must treat all its trading partners equally without any
discrimination, meaning that if it offers any special concession to one
trading partner, such concessions need to be extended to its other trading
partners as well in entirety. This principle effectively gets translated into
"MFN" or the Most Favored Nation. However, this principle is relaxed in
certain exceptional cases, such as if country X has entered into a regional
trade agreement with another country Y, then the concessions extended to
Y country need not be extended to other non-members of the agreement.
Besides these developing countries facing Balance of Payment problems
also get concessions, and if a country can prove unfair trade it can retain
its power to discriminate.
The Non-discrimination principle is also translated as a principle that
would ensure "National Treatment" to all the goods, services or the
intellectual property that enters any other countries national borders.
Reciprocity
This Principle reflects that any concession extended by one country to
another need to be reciprocated with an equal concession such that there
is not a big difference in the countries Payments situation. This was
5
Transparency
The multilateral trading system is an attempt by governments to make the
business environment stable and predictable. Thus this principle ensured
that there is lots of transparency in the domestic trade policies of member
countries. Moreover, the member countries are required to sequentially
phase out the non-tariff barriers and progressively reduce the tariff
barriers through negotiations.
Thus, these principles were primarily to serve the purpose of freer and fair trade
and also to encourage competitive environment in the global market. This was
further supposed to enhance development and Economic reforms in the
developing countries over a period of time in a phased manner.
The goals behind these functions are set out in the preamble to the Marrakech
Agreement. These include:
Ensuring large and steadily growing real incomes and demand; and
These objectives are to be achieved while allowing for the optimal use of the
world's resources in accordance with the objective of sustainable development,
and while seeking to protect and preserve the environment. The preamble also
specifically mentions the need to assist developing countries, especially the
least developed countries, secure a growing share of international trade.
7
INDIAN ECONOMY
The economy of India is the fourth largest in the world, and is the tenth largest
in the world Growth in the Indian economy has steadily increased since 1979,
averaging 5.7% per year in the 23-year growth record.
Indian economy has posted an excellent average GDP growth of 6.8% since
1994. India has emerged the global leader in software and business process
outsourcing services, raking in revenues of US$12.5 billion in the year that
ended
March 2004.
need
to
bring
more
area
under
irrigation.
Export revenues from the sector are expected to grow from $8 billion in 2003
to $46 billion in 2007. Indias foreign exchange reserves are over US$ 102
billion and exceed the foreign reserves of USA, France, Russia and Germany.
This has strengthened the Rupee and boosted investor confidence greatly.
A strong BOP position in recent years has resulted in a steady accumulation of
foreign exchange reserves. The level of foreign exchange reserves crossed the
US $100 billion mark on Dec 19, 2003 and was $142.13 billion on March 18,
2005.
Reserve money growth had doubled to 18.3% in 2003-04 from 9.2 in 2002-03,
driven entirely by the increase in the net foreign exchange assets of the RBI.
Reserve money growth declined to 6.4% in the current year to January 28, 2005.
9
During the current financial year 2004-05, broad money stock (M3) (up to
December 10, 2004) increased by 7.4 per cent Economics experts and various
studies conducted across the globe envisage India and China to rule the world
in the 21st century.
recorded
growths
of
5%,
8.8%
and
7.1%
respectively.
Services
The service sector is the fastest growing sector. It has the largest share in the
GDP accounting for about 48% in 2000. Business services, communication
services, financial services, community services, hotels and restaurants and
trade services are among the fastest growing sectors.
10
OVERVIEW
Yields per unit area of all crops have grown since 1950 due to application of
modern agricultural practices and provision of agricultural credit and subsidies
since Green revolution in India. However, international comparisons reveal that
the average yield in India is generally 30% to 50% of the highest average yield
in the world.
PROBLEMS
The low productivity in India is a result of the following factors:
Overregulation of agriculture has increased costs, price risks and uncertainty.
11
(a) Exemption of export profit from income tax under section 80-HHC of the
Income Tax
(b) Subsidies on cost of freight on export shipments of certain products like
fruits, vegetables and floricultural products.
engineering sector industries like automobiles & forgings & castings, processed
foods industry and the high end outsourcing services.
India must improve legal and administrative infrastructure, improve trade
facilitation through cutting down bureaucracy and delays and further ease its
financial markets.
India has to downsize non-plan expenditure in Subsidies (which are highly
ineffective and wrongly applied) and Government salaries and perquisites like
pensions and administrative expenditures.
Corruption will also have to be checked by bringing in fast remedial public
grievance system, legal system and information dissemination by using egovernance.
The petroleum sector has to be boosted to tap crude oil and gas resources within
Indian boundaries and entering into multinational contracts to source oil
reserves.
It wont be a bad idea if Indian textile and garment Industry go multinational
setting their foot in western Europe, North Africa, Mexico and other such
strategically located areas for large US and European markets.
The performance of India in attracting major FDI has also been poor and
certainly needs boost up, if India has to develop globally competitive
infrastructure and facilities in its sectors of interest for world trade.
India has a large potential to increase its agricultural exports in a liberalized
world provided it can diversify a significant part of its agriculture in to high
value crops and in agro-processing. This would depend first on undertaking
large infrastructure investment in agricultural and agro processing as also in
rural infrastructure and research and development. India has not only to create
14
export surplus but also to become competitive. The potential for exports would
also depend on freeing of agricultural markets by the developed countries.
SUGGESTIONS
1. The Indian economy is predominantly an agrarian economy and its
prosperity depends upon the progress of agriculture. Agriculture sector is
considered as the backbone of our economy and a majority of farmers
depend upon it for sustaining their livelihoods. They should be give
additional incentives and provision of electricity, irrigation facilities and
infrastructural support, improved technologies and provision of inputs at
reasonable cost.
Among the agricultural production incentives, subsidies are considered to be
the most powerful instrument for accelerating the growth of agricultural
production. The subsidies should be equally distributed among the different
regions and groups of our society for achieving the goal of rapid growth in
agricultural development .Provision of input subsidies in agriculture has
been recommended on the ground that it gives incentives to the farmers to
use new technology. It also gives incentives to use these subsidies and hence
increase production. However,
exchequer and reduce investable surplus and consequently the growth rate of
the economy. Besides, they might generate inequalities in the distribution of
income and may lead to distortions and inefficiency in the system.
2. In the Pharma sector there is need for major investments in R &D and
mergers and restructuring of companies to make them world class to take
advantage. India has already an amended patent Act and both product and
Process are now patented in India. However, the large number of patents
15
going off in USA recently, gives the Indian Drug companies windfall
opportunities, if tapped intelligently. Some companies in India have
organized themselves for this.
3. The most important things for India to address are speed up internal reforms
in building up world-class infrastructure like roads, ports and electricity
supply. India should also focus on original knowledge generation in
important fields like Pharmaceutical molecules, textiles, IT high end
products, processed food, installation of cold chain and agricultural logistics
to tap opportunities of globalization under WTO regime.
4. India should expand its exports of agricultural products in which it has
tremendous comparative advantage. The provisions of W.T.O offered ample
opportunities to India to expand its export market. Export prospects are
brighter with soybeans, oilseeds, oil meal and cake, fruits and vegetables,
and fruit preparations. Thus, high export prospects are seen with high value
products, horticultural products, and processed products, marine products
.India need not be extremely defensive and inward looking, as Indian
agriculture has demonstrated strength which needs to be appropriately used
to compete in the global market, otherwise it will become a case of missed
opportunity.
5. The Government should improve the livelihood pattern of small & marginal
farmers by enhancing their access to appropriate and affordable
technologies, market related information and linkages.
6. Sustainability of extension services and expert advice through capacity
building exercises effectively bridging the rural-urban divide.
7. Associate all professionals involved in different aspects of agriculture and
rural development through national and international networks.
8. Promote financial sector inclusion for farmers and small & medium
enterprises in agri-sector through access to market capital and risk
management tools.
9. India would do well to reorganize its Protective Agricultural policy in name
of rural poverty and Food security and try to capitalize on globalization of
16
The result of this agreement as mentioned earlier was limited as, GATT was
only an agreement and there was no enforcing agency to strictly implement the
clauses and punish the country which breaks the clauses. Thus the impact was
partial. However, with WTO coming into effect, the competition from imports
for the domestic firms has increased. WTO had the deadline till 2005, for the
domestic policy was supposed to phase out the QR's; for those countries which
face severe balance of payments problems special concession period was given.
18
Thus it is very clear that only those firms that have competitive advantage
would be able to survive in the long run, and those firms which are weak would
fade into history in the process.
2. Trade Related Investment Measures (TRIMS)
The agreement relates to investments originating from one country to another.
The agreement prohibits the host country to discriminate the investment from
abroad with domestic investment, which implies that it favours national
treatment of foreign investment. Besides this, there are several other clauses of
the agreement totaling to 5 in this segment, one agreement requires investment
to be freely allowed within domestic borders without any maximum cap on it.
Another restricts to impose any kind of export obligation or import cap on the
investment. Another requires that there should not be any domestic content
requirement on foreign firms operating and manufacturing in other countries.
These agreements have a direct impact on our Trade, Investment and foreign
exchange policy, domestic annual budgetary proposals and also on the industrial
policy.
Implementation process for the above requires proper preparation by the
industries and policy makers, as sudden change may result in loss of revenue
and decline of foreign exchange for the government and economy, and it may
result in decline of market share and profitability of businesses, decline in
employment opportunities and over all decline in growth.
3. Trade Related Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS)
An intellectual property right refers to any creation of human mind which gets
legal recognition and protection such that the creator of the intangible is
protected from illegal use of his creation. This agreement includes several
19
20
an agreement on the agricultural issues have always been evading and debated
strongly by all the countries involved in trade in agriculture.
The agreement on agreement deals with market access, Export subsidies and
government subsidies. Broadly, as of now the requirement is to open up the
markets in specific products in market access and incase of subsidies, it is to go
for tarrification and phase it out eventually or reduce it to bound limits. The
immediate impact of the agreement would be on the policy makers to scrutinize
all the items under subsidy, QRs and tariffs. However, the calculation of AMS
reveals that the subsidy given to Indian farmers are much below the acceptable
levels and therefore need not be changed. Looking from other perspective, the
reduction of tariffs and subsidy in export and import items would open up
competition and give a better access to Indian products abroad. However, the
concern is on the competitiveness and sustainability that the Indian farmer
would be able to prove in the long run once the markets open up. Thus there is a
requirement to change policy support to meet the changing needs of Indian
agriculture to gear it up for future.
5. Agreement on Sanitary and psyto-sanitary measures (SPM): this
agreement refers to restricting exports of a country if they do not comply with
the international standards of germs/bacteria etc if the country suspects that
allowing of such products inside the country would result in spread of disease
and pest, then there is every right given to the authorities to block the imports.
Indian standards in this area are already mentioned and therefore there is no
need to change the law, but the problem is that of strictly implementing the
laws. There is an urgent need to educate the exporters regarding the changing
scenario and standards at the international arena, and look at the possible
consequence and losses to be incurred if the stipulations are not followed.
Therefore, to meet the standards certain operational changes are required in the
21
industries such as food processing, marine food and other packed food that is
being currently exported from India.
6. Multi-Fiber Agreement (MFA): This agreement is dismantled with effect
from 1 January 2005. The result was removal of QR on the textile imports in
several European countries. As a consequence a huge textile market is opened
up for developing countries textile industry as well as for other countries that
have competitive advantage in this area. The immediate impact is on the
garment and textile manufacturers and exporters. However, it still needs to be
seen whether the industry is able and ready to take advantage of the large
markets. This requires quite an amount of modernization, standardization, cost
efficiency, and customization and frequent up gradation of designs to meet the
changing need of global customers. The dismantling of QR also mean more
competition to Indian textile exporters and therefore, it becomes imperative to
enhance the competitiveness in niche areas.
Certain Other Unresolved Issues:
There are several clauses in each of the above agreements; where there has been
no consensus arrived. Besides that there are several other cases where there is
no consensus on the entire agreement itself, which means that these are still in
their conceptual and drafting stages.
Some of such agreements are on Labour Standards and core social clauses,
which intend to impose a labor standard and certain norm against exploitation of
labour by the organization where they work. Such standards are likely to result
in banning of certain items exports to developed world causing severe damage
to industries such as Carpet manufacturing, crackers, leather, handicrafts and
sports goods.
22
24
BIBLIOGRAPHY
BOOKS:
1. Indian Economy in 21st century M.M. Sury
2. Agriculture and world trade organisation
3. Indian economy and WTO G.K Chadha
4. Indian Economy: Current Development A.N. Agrawal
25